Season 2014-15
Opinion
Talking Points
Leaving it Late?
| 04/07/2014We're into July now and we've made new no signings. That lot across the park have already signed three players. Anyone else getting slightly concerned?
Also, we've not even announced our pre-season fixtures yet apart from Ossie's testimonial and the game against Tranmere Rovers. Getting a bit late now isn't it?
Is this all as a result of the World Cup? Surely pre-season fixtures should have been scheduled by now?
Return to Talking Points index : Add your Comments
Reader Comments (105)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 04/07/2014 at 14:32:17
I have to say IÂm beginning to get edgy as I see quite a few clubs already making significant signings and we are left with jack (and I donÂt mean Rodwell).
The RS already have 3 – and soon will have an additional 㿲 – 80 million off Barça for Tetanus Teeth. No matter who they sign though, if Ratboy goes, theyÂll be half the threat they were last season. He was their talisman, always chomping at the bit (or doing a bit of chomping).
We need a world-class striker (the injury-proof kind hopefully) – and (to me) we should pay whatever it takes. Break the bank... break into a bank – just get us a goal scorer!
Bobby looks like he is willing to bring some of the youngsters through, and given our quest for European glory, weÂll need them if weÂre to maintain top four aspirations and have decent cup runs.
The Coleman extension is great news; now get McCarthy, Barkley and Stones tied down also. I think Barry should be offered 2 years at max as (in a different way to Suarez) heÂs a bit long in the tooth. IÂm pleased that Hibbo got an extension – Everton through and through, and whatever his limitations they are not loyalty, application or hard work.
Throw in 4, 5 or 6 sensibly priced reinforcements / free transfers on top of what we have – and IÂll be cautiously optimistic for a trophy this coming year. The core is already in place, we just need some Bobby transfer magic.
But please letÂs start soon ... I donÂt want this to go down to the final minutes, of the final hour, of the final day.... yet again.
"Dear Santa,
I know itÂs a bit early but..."Â
3 Posted 04/07/2014 at 14:25:07
If we start on the 16th of August with what we have, I may then throw the toys out of the pram. Ideally we would want the big signings in for the start of August, but no need to panic yet.
As for pre-season, I canÂt imagine many look forward to those long tours abroad, so a few light warm up games will see us starting the season fresh and raring to go.
Paste this link on your desktop if you want to get really wound up! It lists every new signing team by team in the Premier League:
4 Posted 04/07/2014 at 14:46:44
5 Posted 04/07/2014 at 14:34:43
Ray.
This is Everton, so seriously you are going to have to chill.
Top – and I mean top of the list – is the fact that we need a striker, a 20-goal-a-season striker, a striker similar to the one that put Belgium 2-0 up against the USA. That for me is the man RM wants and I would say that Everton are very close to getting him.
Obviously Everton's transfer plan will be totally fucked up if he manages to hit the winner against Argentina and then play another blinder in the semis – but, as it stands, I would say we are in with a serious shout of getting Lukaku.
If the above doesn't happen, then I've a feeling we will hit Swansea for Bony; if that fails, then fuck knows... but I'm sure one of the above transfers will come true.
6 Posted 04/07/2014 at 14:59:32
I'm more relaxed this season than before and putting the delay down to the World Cup.
A striker and a midfielder, both of high quality, will come in soon. I can feel it.
7 Posted 04/07/2014 at 15:07:07
I suppose watching nothing happening can get scary but donÂt fret too much because, as a football club, we are consistent at it with the phrase ÂWe go with what we have got being heard after most windows.
UP THE BLUES
8 Posted 04/07/2014 at 15:18:46
9 Posted 04/07/2014 at 15:22:13
But, not announcing any serious pre-season fixtures yet – even allowing for the World Cup – what the hell is all that about?
10 Posted 04/07/2014 at 15:23:42
I also expect a few surprises and hopefully a big One.
COYB Boys
11 Posted 04/07/2014 at 15:39:39
12 Posted 04/07/2014 at 15:40:24
13 Posted 04/07/2014 at 15:36:04
Jay #1, it doesnÂt matter who weÂve been linked with, as 90-95% of it is nonsense, but some of them do seem quite decent as it happens.
We need six new players, four of them direct replacements for the four we had on loan last season, along with a central midfielder (or possibly two) and a Âright-sided Oviedo if you get my drift – Seamus will either have to play every minute or weÂll be weakening every time we rotate the squad as it stands now.
Two or three of those replacements may well be the same people, Barry, Traoré and maybe Lukaku, so those deals donÂt need to be hurried, and in LukakuÂs, canÂt be. Martinez has even joked about wanting certain players to have a bad World Cup so the price goes down. If it was Ham-ez Rodriguez he was after, then no chance.
IÂd say three in by the end of July, not the start, will be okay. I certainly wonÂt be panicking. Deadline day seems to be inevitable for the way weÂre going to be doing business, as any bid we make now for sought after players will just be stalled in the hope that someone else bids against us.
The pre-season was delayed so that we could work out how to arrange it in relation to the Europa League, but that doesnÂt seem to matter now. Does anyone know what other clubs have arranged so far?
14 Posted 04/07/2014 at 15:49:16
15 Posted 04/07/2014 at 15:56:13
16 Posted 04/07/2014 at 16:02:18
We just need a striker who can score 20+ goals.
17 Posted 04/07/2014 at 16:11:28
18 Posted 04/07/2014 at 16:14:33
We are panicking a little early.
19 Posted 04/07/2014 at 16:18:59
20 Posted 04/07/2014 at 16:24:07
Lukaku is the key as, until Roberto knows what is going to happen to him, nothing else will fall into place. I know he is expensive, and I know he will probably go elsewhere... but I think he would make a great addition to our young team.
Strikers are always difficult to source whatever the club unless you can sign a blank cheque. Once we have the striker, others will follow. I fully expect most of EvertonÂs main signings to be completed by the end of July.
As for Barry, if he wanted to stay at the club, I am sure he would have let the manager know.
21 Posted 04/07/2014 at 16:25:41
22 Posted 04/07/2014 at 16:35:04
Unfortunately there is nothing amusing about the blatant lies our chairman repeatedly loads onto the fans.
What is amusing, however, is the few fans who continue to believe him.
23 Posted 04/07/2014 at 16:35:45
93-94 Cole - 34 Shearer - 31 Le Tissier - 25 Sutton - 25 Wright - 23
Beardsley - 21
94-95 Shearer - 34 Fowler - 25 Ferdinand - 24 Collymore - 22 Cole - 21 Klinsmann - 21
95-96 Shearer - 31.Fowler - 28.Ferdinand - 25
96-97 Shearer - 25. Wright - 23
97-98 Top scorer 18
98-99 Top Scorer 18
99-00 Philips - 30, Shearer - 23, Yorke - 22
00-01 Hasselbaink - 23
01-02 Henry - 24, Hasselbaink - 23, Van Nistelrooy - 23, Shearer - 23
02-03 Van Nistelrooy - 25, Henry - 24, Beattie - 23, Viduka - 20
03-04 Henry - 30, Shearer - 20, Saha - 20 , Nistelrooy - 20
04-05 Henry - 25, Johnson -21
05-06 Henry - 27, Nistlerooy - 21
06-07 Drogba - 20
07-08 Ronaldo - 31, Torres - 24, Adebayor - 24
08-09 Top Scorer - 19
09-10 Drogba - 29, Rooney - 27, Bent - 24, Tevez - 23, Lampard - 22
10-11 Berbatov - 20, Tevez - 20
11-12 Van Persie - 30, Rooney - 27, Aguero - 23
12-13 Van Persie - 26, Suarez - 23, Bale - 21
13-14 Suarez - 31, Sturridge - 21, Toure - 20
I'm afraid these 20+ goal strikers are probably out of Everton FC's price range! Although we have had some of those on our books – Beattie, Johnson, Beardsley and Saha – unfortunately not when they were at their most prolific.
24 Posted 04/07/2014 at 16:58:34
25 Posted 04/07/2014 at 17:37:20
26 Posted 04/07/2014 at 17:49:50
Until the World Cup finishes then I don't see any major money moves, which personally worries me as all and sundry will be chasing around for the players who want to move. If Belgium get to the final, then Lukaku's future won't be resolved until about July 20-25 by which time we will be travelling around in pre-season with only a limited number of players in pre-season. Didn't this happen a few years ago with Moyes in USA?
27 Posted 04/07/2014 at 18:02:11
28 Posted 04/07/2014 at 18:18:20
I'm not too worried but I don't think we'll get Lukaku unless no Champions League team goes for him.
29 Posted 04/07/2014 at 18:59:11
30 Posted 04/07/2014 at 19:05:43
With only one player from the Everton squad left in the World Cup, I think the manager should be back at Finch Farm starting to negotiate for players he wants plus checking on the condition of the returning players. I am not surprised at the lack of any incoming players at this time as, being a realist, I do not trust our chairman and his merry band to back up the manager until they feel it is right to release funds.
32 Posted 04/07/2014 at 19:39:44
33 Posted 04/07/2014 at 19:45:25
34 Posted 04/07/2014 at 20:04:19
Unfortunately, I also think this article is about 7 weeks premature. We do our business late, partly to see if there is any seriously big offer for one of our marquee players, but most importantly, and listen up those with short memories, because it allows Kenwright the space to say, oh, we tried to get some big deals, but ran out of time, but Roberto will have all the money we've raised in the next window.
By now, I could get to the moon, by walking along Kenwright's nose...
35 Posted 04/07/2014 at 20:05:49
I imagine the club will probably go to a training camp somewhere and play a local side before coming back to take on Tranmere. ThereÂs a free weekend in between OssieÂs testimonial and the start of the season so the club might fit in one or two games there. But it is a bit unusual because normally everything is announced by now.
To be honest, I did think we would have Barry signed by now, but I think why he hasnÂt is down to the payments that we have to make to Manchester City. I imagine that Roberto would like to think Barry and Traore will be signed before pre-season starts. We can only wait and see.
The future of Lukaku will probably rumble on for a while. ItÂs clear that itÂs RobertoÂs number one target, hence why he hasnÂt moved for any other striker. Chelsea wonÂt want to let him go for 25 million less, so Everton will have to do a lot of negotiating to get the price down I imagine. If I can remember correctly, Roberto did say that he was prepared to wait to get his desired his targets. So I am not too worried on that one. If we donÂt manage to get Lukaku, IÂm sure Roberto will have other targets in mind, and weÂll trust him on his judgement.
It is annoying not seeing the club bring in players early, especially when others are, but thereÂs a lot of factors to take in and I think we are going to have to be patient. But all being well, things will start rolling now that World Cup is coming to an end.
Me personally, I hope we can bring in Lukaku and I like the look of Perisic from Croatia too. Hopefully Barcelona could lend us one of their up and coming stars again, or you never know, they might give us Deulofeu back for another year with the transfer of Luiz Suarez.
36 Posted 04/07/2014 at 21:00:38
So just to recap thatÂs four new players required just to get back to square one. Then you need new players on top of those four to strengthen.
37 Posted 04/07/2014 at 21:04:38
Roberto out! Kenwright out! Elstone out! If they don't appreciate that only two games are important to the fans and that we cannot afford for another debacle like we have endured for the last 50 years, then they shouldn't be at the club – Find a buyer BK!!
[TIC, obviously...]
38 Posted 04/07/2014 at 21:09:01
39 Posted 04/07/2014 at 20:38:55
As per usual, we won't have fortunes to throw around, so it will be difficult to tempt any star players to play for us. Also, it must be a nightmare trying to negotiate with agents etc and be able to nail them down in good time.
Realistically it will be a case of make do and mend as usual I fear, but I don't think we will be scratching about too much though, because him and the team created a really good impression last season, which is bound to be a plus when it comes to signing up players on loan or permanent.
40 Posted 04/07/2014 at 21:49:49
Re, the friendlies, can you imagine Roberto arriving back next a week on Sunday ringing, for example, Wolfsburg or Porto on the Monday asking, "Fancy a game a week on Wednesday?" Surely the friendlies have been arranged but not announced? If so, why not?
Re signings, surely there must be some in the pipeline? As a previous poster stated, we're about 4 down on last year's personnel with loanees leaving. That means we have about 8 - 10 players to sign yet. Somehow, I don't think even Roberto could surpass last year's deadline day harvest?
I know that 1 July was a significant date in terms of players' contracts, there's a World Cup on and the draw for the Europa League hasn't been made yet, but something doesn't smell right!
41 Posted 04/07/2014 at 22:41:49
What doesn,t smell right is the mold from Bullshit Bills wallet .
43 Posted 04/07/2014 at 23:45:33
44 Posted 05/07/2014 at 00:33:45
Step 1 (July): Look for free agents and search the relegated teams & lower league teams for potential signings.
Step 2 (until the day before the window closes): Wait until the big clubs finish their signings.
Step 3 (the last hours of the transfer window): wait until late in the transfer window to approach those same clubs to see who is surplus to their requirements and sign/loan accordingly.
Nothing to worry about, it’s a well thought-out strategy where nothing can possibly go wrong, especially with the geniuses running the club.
45 Posted 05/07/2014 at 02:20:30
46 Posted 05/07/2014 at 06:41:00
Now I know some fools (me) may think his time and undoubted charm, would be better spent here, trying to persuade the talented and the undecided that their future lies with Everton Football Club... He"ll have earned a fortune and will probably be wearing some boss new clothes for us to talk about.
47 Posted 05/07/2014 at 08:39:27
48 Posted 05/07/2014 at 08:45:16
Which players have signed for other clubs that we would like and that we have a reasonable chance of attracting? Gauld perhaps? I can't think of many. Most of the signings have been marquee buys by the rich clubs.
I'd like to see us compete for the likes of Tom Ince, cheap young english talent with potential to improve, but he hasn't joined Hull yet. Banega would also give us a bit more craft. I'd be shocked if we didn't end up with two permanent transfers in that mould.
I reckon that many of the players we've been linked with, Roberto is not actually interested in signing. The ones that have signed for other clubs that we "missed out on" he could also not be interested in.
Our manager is intelligent, creative and meticulous and importantly he has not shown any indication that he is unhappy with the way things are at the club (ie, issues with BK/money etc). Best to watch him do his job and I suspect we'll be surprised at the outcome.
50 Posted 05/07/2014 at 11:03:35
1 striker
2 central midfielders
1 winger
LetÂs say:
Remy
Barry
Banega
Perisic
Get that lot in the next few weeks and then another 3 or 4 on deadline day. Easy right!
51 Posted 05/07/2014 at 12:08:10
It has been repeatedly stated that we'll be doing business after the World Cup – I believe it's still going on. So what's the problem?
Liverpool have 'splashed the cash' on an over-rated, over-priced Lallana, an older squad back up striker (Lambert) and someone I'm unfamiliar with (Can).
I'm sure that our manager has some of this new-fangled technology and is able to speak to players/agents/clubs, without needing to be sitting in an office in Finch Farm.
If we'd bought players 'similar to Alcaraz, Kone and Robles', the usual suspects would be on here venting their spleen.
If we're running around for players once the season's started, I'll be hopping mad.
Looks to me like some people are desperate for another Martinez gush/slag-off- fest and don't have any ammunition.
I can't wait till we start buying players – it'll all go off on here again!
52 Posted 05/07/2014 at 12:17:02
53 Posted 05/07/2014 at 13:33:37
54 Posted 05/07/2014 at 13:54:29
It seems the excuse factory is already running to full capacity – even though our manager clearly isn't.
Nobody is asking for Martinez to be working miracles, but we are entitled to expect him to be working for Everton. The suggestion that he is giving our club his undivided attention because he is still able to communicate with other parts of the world is laughable.
Our board either can't or won't pay the going rate for talent. Martinez is going to have to rely heavily on his charm and powers of persuasion. How can he do that to the best of his ability, if he's giving so much of his time to a TV company?
There are no 'if''s ... This transfer window is narrow enough for the less wealthy clubs and by taking his eye off the ball for a couple of weeks, Martinez narrows it still further.
Everton running around, trying to sign players once the 2014-15 season has started. isn't something that might happen. It's something that will most definitely happen.
It's not about "growing a pair"... well, actually, it is. Rather than offer meek excuses, shouldn't we be demanding that our manager prioritises the job for which our club is paying him north of ٠M a year to do?
Call me old fashioned, but isn't that the very least we should expect?
55 Posted 05/07/2014 at 15:31:02
Spot on, I could not agree more with your points.
Pour yourself a cold one.
56 Posted 05/07/2014 at 15:59:42
Nobody, as far as I have read on this thread, is really overly panicking or complaining – a few are just querying the wisdom of leaving business until the latter stages of the window. Yes, the majority of the business may well be conducted after the World Cup but IÂll bet weÂre not going to just purchase players who have featured in the World Cup.
If Martinez can conjure up another few gems on deadline day like last year – and thatÂs a big "if", great, but we will again be starting the season 2 or 3 games in without all the required players being available. The lack of Lukaku, Barry and Deulofeu at the start of last season probably cost us 4 to 6 points in the opening three games – and think how that might have changed our season at the death.
Pre-season starts soon and weÂre still about 4-6 players down on where we should be. ThatÂs not necessarily panicking - just stating an obvious fact. It doesnÂt make sense to me that we havenÂt brought in at least a few squad players.
57 Posted 05/07/2014 at 16:06:54
No major signings (if any) will happen before the end of the World Cup so a bit of perspective and patience is needed.... if we havenÂt signed any new players by the start of August, then the moaning can start!
Personally, if we only get the Barry deal done in July, thatÂll do me (assuming more players will arrive in August).
On another note, anyone have any news on the Kone, Gibson or Oviedo injuries? Would have thought they should all be recovered by now. (Like three new signings.... literally.)
58 Posted 05/07/2014 at 16:12:18
59 Posted 05/07/2014 at 16:14:20
Maybe we just look at thing in different ways.
Myself I think that Martinez is not going to want to "bomb" after a better first season than even the most optimistic of Evertonians would have hoped for. I also think that he very much appears to know what he's doing. With that in mind, I'm prepared to wait and see what he has planned.
Don't get me wrong; the fact that I'm not concerned or showing a certain restlessness doesn't mean I care any less than the supporter who is up in arms already. I just trust Roberto to know what he's doing.
60 Posted 05/07/2014 at 16:20:27
There is not a lot of panicking or even that much moaning on this thread just a well placed concern that we may not be able to afford to wait till the last minute and start the first few games short of numbers like last season.
61 Posted 05/07/2014 at 16:29:00
There is also the World Cup to consider...
62 Posted 05/07/2014 at 16:30:18
63 Posted 05/07/2014 at 16:36:39
Lallana and Lambert have come home from the World Cup. The other signing wasn't at the World Cu.p
64 Posted 05/07/2014 at 16:37:45
The other beauty is "man up"
65 Posted 05/07/2014 at 17:04:53
I'd love to think we're holding out exclusively for a few Brazilians, Germans, Argentinians, Dutch and Belgians!
66 Posted 05/07/2014 at 17:50:25
I would like to think Roberto will have a list of players he wants. One signing could have a bearing on who another signing is, and where they will play in our system.
We have just got shut of a manager who made signings with no idea of how they would fit in.
67 Posted 05/07/2014 at 19:14:57
Signing the likes of Baines, Coleman, Stones, Mirallas, Distin, Jagielka, Naismith and Gibson for around 㿅M is pretty good work.
68 Posted 05/07/2014 at 19:47:38
Hopefully Barry will sign as soon as Roberto gets back from Brazil and then expect lots of last-minute activity plus loan deals.
I canÂt see our board giving us that much to spend regardless of more TV money than ever, kit deal, Chang deal, record season ticket sales and any incoming transfer fees we have left over!
69 Posted 05/07/2014 at 19:51:32
IÂm concerned as I think losing him may set us back a bit. Suggesting Pienaar and Gibson step in is unrealistic in my opinion. Pienaar is a different type of player, and although Gibson is more suited to the centre, I would have thought he would benefit to playing in the centre with Barry and McCarthy putting in the hard work. As it is, I wouldnÂt want my mortgage to be on Gibson being fully fit half way through the season.
As for getting signings in early, well it would be nice but does anyone think it would happen, no matter who the manager was? Some people think it was MoyesÂs policy but letÂs be honest, itÂs finance. Everyone knows weÂre next to skint and thereÂll nearly always be other wealthier clubs looking at the same players weÂre interested in. ItÂs not in their interests to sell to us early and cheap. TheyÂll be hanging on for more cash and weÂll be nipping in at the last minute when the timeÂs right. If not then weÂll be left grumbling on here at the end of the transfer window. Who knows a few people might even blame RM despite the evidence of the last 15 years.
70 Posted 06/07/2014 at 03:29:03
71 Posted 06/07/2014 at 07:18:04
72 Posted 06/07/2014 at 07:27:00
73 Posted 06/07/2014 at 08:05:26
The four squad players would be another Centre Midfielder probably either Cleverly or Rodwell. A backup Striker and two Wingers. Defense is pretty much covered: two Right Backs, two Left Backs, four Centre Backs and Duffy, Garbutt and Browning.
I would use pre-season to assess Junior – if heÂs good enough, we donÂt need the other Centre Midfielder; if he isnÂt, he should follow Vellios and Gueye out the door.
We leave it late to save wages so, although itÂs not ideal getting players in on Deadline Day, if they are only squad players, it does make financial sense. If we are announcing the signings of Barry and Lukaku before 1 August, I will be happy.
74 Posted 06/07/2014 at 09:27:01
Which of course doesn't take account of the players we're losing.
75 Posted 06/07/2014 at 10:03:32
I donÂt think the World Cup has made any difference to our chances of signing any potential players or to the prices that we might have to pay. Indeed, LukakuÂs value may have slightly fallen; if we are purchasing him, then Roberto has some work to do to make him the finished article!
76 Posted 06/07/2014 at 10:25:45
77 Posted 06/07/2014 at 10:29:30
That means we have to wait for some deals... possibly until right up against deadline day when clubs are suddenly motivated differently as they look at missing out on their targets through a potential non-sale of a lucrative asset.
IÂd like to see movement on some of the cheaper targets... Brahimi from Granada was touted at the ١M mark originally and was looking for a move. Barry obviously... but, for the most part, IÂm expecting much of what weÂll do will be late on in the window. IÂm happy with that if it means we get the players the manager wants.
78 Posted 06/07/2014 at 10:39:06
That being the case, I think some people have accept the the best loans become available late in the day because clubs are willing to accept no-one is gonna meet their valuation of a player and agree to loans to reduce the wage bill. However, I still think we have a 㾻M to 㿀M budget with which I expect to make one or two signings maximum before pre-season. The other three or four loans will inevitably come really late in the day, I think one or two on here need to understand that before they give themselves an ulcer!
79 Posted 06/07/2014 at 11:20:15
Yes, but no amount of signings will make up for the loss that is Luis Suarez, so how exactly have the Red Shite strengthened?
Relax, Roberto's got it.
80 Posted 06/07/2014 at 13:41:33
Apart from that, I'm sure Roberto has people lined up; he didn't do badly last year, especially with the loan signings.
Granted most of the World Cup games have been played and I'm certain Roberto saw a few hidden gems there too.
81 Posted 06/07/2014 at 14:49:51
He has now finished his gig in Brazil and is on his way home. I'd be very surprised if he hasn't made some close observations on, inquired about or made contact while over there with certain players on his shopping list, so we'll see what he has to say once he's back.
Hopefully in the next week or so we'll be hearing some good news... just have a little faith!
82 Posted 06/07/2014 at 16:31:32
I can understand your certainty that we'll be running around for players once the season's started. I'm expecting it, but I'd rather wait till that happens before starting the criticism. slagging off Martinez. It's your choice to get your criticism in early.
Putting aside your views on Martinez, where would you expect us to be regarding transfers right now?
84 Posted 06/07/2014 at 17:13:17
I hope that Martinez, faced with our financial restraints, has got his purchasing strategy right. Only time will tell.
85 Posted 06/07/2014 at 17:30:48
Martinez has been a breath of fresh air and reinvigorated the club and I have no issue with what he may be planning but the bottom line is he is hamstrung by our lack of finances; as others have said, we are four players down with the addition of the Europa league to compete in.
We all know how it works by now surely? IÂll be ecstatic if IÂm proved wrong but suspect we wonÂt see any of last JanuaryÂs or last summerÂs net gains from player sales versus players bought invested so it will be a case of waiting for the Sky money to come in or selling to buy.
To all those saying the window has only been open a few days IÂve posted this numerous times on various Everton related sites but here goes again:
http://m.bbc.co.uk/sport/27667106
The key points being the 1st 2 paragraphs:
"The transfer window re-opened on the final day of the domestic season and will close at 23:00 BST on Monday, 1 September.
Clubs could buy domestic players again once they had played their final game of the season. International deals can go through from 10 June."
Most contracts run until the end of June which seems to have confused the matter but, the minute the last ball was kicked, clubs could buy players from the UK and international deals have been open for nearly a month.
ItÂs the inevitability of it all that gets me; we know we wonÂt build on last season or progress.
86 Posted 06/07/2014 at 19:04:24
First let me apologise, I get a little frustrated at the "Roberto can do no wrong" attitude which seems to be sweeping Evertonia at the moment. I have read your post and I know you always try to offer a balanced view.
I don't have an answer to your question. I don't have a definite view of where I would expect us to be regarding transfers right now... but I feel that when small windows of opportunity present themselves – and we can't know that what they are – it has to be in the best interest of EFC that our manager is around to capitalise.
No matter how the excuse factory want to dress this up, Robbie can not get these few weeks back.
TW reporting that Robbie is back this week and that makes me happier – it doesn't take much
87 Posted 06/07/2014 at 19:44:45
Some people might be surprised, but I share your views on the Roberto gush-fest, which is eerily similar to that given to his predecessor. I genuinely don't think we're missing out by Martinez being in Brazil – he may be closer to the ground regarding players, agents and coaches.
On a wider level, many of us don't have to be chained to the office to be productive. My view is that it's the same for football managers, especially before pre-season. The problem with this debate is that we don't know the budget, or the timeline for the budget. I'd like us to sign two strikers, a canny, streetwise midfielder and a central defender familiar with a football,
As I've said previously, I like and wanted Martinez, so I'm more likely to take a positive view of what he does, but I won't let the facts get in the way. If the squad isn't genuinely stronger at the start of the season, I'll be criticising him, but not before.
88 Posted 06/07/2014 at 20:43:53
Is this 1927?
89 Posted 06/07/2014 at 20:52:02
90 Posted 06/07/2014 at 21:09:04
91 Posted 06/07/2014 at 21:12:03
I wasn't claiming that Martinez being in Brazil restricted our opportunities of recruiting new players.
I state quite clearly that it was the time he devoted to his "other interest" which troubles me. He could have been anywhere.
The four managers who finished above him last season could have spent their summer Moonlighting ... wonder why they didn't?
92 Posted 06/07/2014 at 22:08:59
All the best footballers, coaches, agents and every other footballing person who is anyone would have been in Brazil. Much of a manager's job is to make personal contacts and build-up relationships with those people which may help to get us players on loan or to buy in the near future. I don't ever remember any previous Everton manager getting stick for not being on the job 24/7 in the close season, but I stand to be corrected as always.
93 Posted 06/07/2014 at 22:12:54
I'll accept that while he's on air, he's unable to man the phone and negotiate, but that probably leaves 20 hours of the day for EFC work.
I'll be waiting for the quote from a missed transfer target, 'I wanted to sign for Everton, but Martinez was on ESPN, so I signed for Burnley instead.'
I think it's healthy to criticise the manager, there wasn't enough of that for his predecessor, but this is taking the piss a bit.
94 Posted 06/07/2014 at 22:28:26
I like a good moan so I won't be too harsh on Darren.
95 Posted 06/07/2014 at 22:51:31
I doubt they deal with the agents, the manager may try and sell his vision to the player, where they will play them / whether they will be first choice etc. but after identifying said player, they may put a max price they are willing to pay, then Elstone would take over from there? There are probably pay scales already in place for certain players, they obviously set a maximum wage at the club.
Maybe Matt Traynor can answer this one? He seems well informed on these type of deals.
96 Posted 07/07/2014 at 00:15:29
97 Posted 07/07/2014 at 00:47:05
98 Posted 07/07/2014 at 02:00:05
Based on last season, probably at the moment, but I think there is more work needed to solidify the midfield and defence. Not a coincidence to say I also believe ready-made 20-goal machines are outside our financial abilities.
Perhaps we should focus on the simpler options, like actually signing Barry or whoever was the second option behind him? ItÂs unsettling to hear West Ham trying to pip us to the deal, weird to actually WANT the World Cup to end NOW.
99 Posted 07/07/2014 at 04:55:32
Comparing the lengthy hours / days Martinez put in working for ESPN to Jose's "ambassadors" role is really clutching at straws. especially as Jose has already bagged two players.
Martinez did not just get offered a job when he was out there. He told us weeks ago that we would not be signing anybody until AFTER the World Cup. He narrowed our transfer window in advance because he knew he was going to be tied up.
"20 hours a day for EFC work"? You are deluding yourself Paul, unless Roberto can function without sleep (as well as walk on water). There were days when he barely had time to log on to check if Kenwright's cheque had cleared.
When (not 'if') we kick off what threatens to be a gruelling season, desperately scrambling around to find out who is still available. Perhaps you'll take a bit of time out from being "hopping mad" and reflect on a couple of weeks when anything would have been better than nothing.
100 Posted 07/07/2014 at 07:39:42
I'm sure you'll secretly acknowledge that Wenger is out there derelicting his duty as well.
I don't think anyone out there on TV has a gruelling role and I don't think Martinez being in Brazil is stopping us from acquiring players.
Do you really think Wenger and Martinez have gone to their employers and said, "Look lads, I'm going to the World Cup and I'll won't be watching any players, speaking to any coaches, clubs or agents. My phone's off, speak to you on 14th July"?
You don't have to be a blind devotee of Martinez to think that's stretching the imagination a tiny bit, do you?
The truth is that none of us actually know or can quantify how much 'work' is being done. The only thing that matters is the squad at the start of the season. That's when I'll give my opinion on his 'work'.
101 Posted 07/07/2014 at 09:06:58
1) Clubs agree a fee via written offers, which may be after a prolonged period of negotiation. Some clubs may instruct agents at this point if they want to move a player on to go out and find another club, based on an indicative price. An agent should not tout a player without the written permission of the playerÂs club.
Who in the club agrees fees? Could be CEO. A COO. Director of Football. Company Secretary back in the day. The manager shouldnÂt have much input over and above whether heÂs okay with signing or selling the player.
2) Fee agreed, negotiate personal terms with playerÂs agent. Lots of clauses, contracts in the 80s were 2-3 pages and these days are huge, for top players. It can include details of the playerÂs role in the team, and if all is agreed then a medical will be arranged. (This still doesnÂt mean the transfer is done – Willian was having a medical at Tottenham when Chelsea stepped in).
3) AgentÂs Commission is normally paid by the buying club. An agent can only be paid by one party – if a club is desperate to get rid, theyÂll normally pay it. Players at the top level almost never pay it – and I think they should in 100% of cases. Clubs now have to report each payment to agent to the FA, who publish aggregate amounts by club / division. (A transfer can still go wrong here – like it did for Tim Cahill to Crystal Palace in 2004 – thanks Simon Jordan!)
4) Once allÂs done the transfer is lodged with the FA, and either the Premier League or Football League. This will include all the financials, installments etc. and the respective league takes a percentage cut of the fee, and also takes the VAT for the full amount of the transfer fee for future payment to HMRC (I believe this was introduced after the rake of tax defaults from clubs). These are the documents that I think need to be received by the FA by the transfer deadline. I think copies of player agreements can be delayed if there are logistical problems, but if the agreement between clubs is not lodged in time, no deal.
So thatÂs the rough process, and none of it specifically includes a manager. Some clubs operate with a Director of Football / Recruitment etc. I think it really depends on the individual. Every club operates to a budget, so the fees for players and wages/bonuses may be the remit of senior execs at the club, in consultation with the manager.
IÂd expect a manager to be more involved when it comes to discussing terms with the player from a perspective of his role in the team. Remember, according to the rules, a club should not even speak to a player unless a transfer has been agreed between the clubs. (Like that never happens!)
102 Posted 07/07/2014 at 10:07:32
I know for certain Green is the main player for any large outgoing transfers. Bill just cries at his desk!
103 Posted 07/07/2014 at 19:15:04
In defence of Robbie's moonlighting, You dream up a truly bizarre conversation supposedly held between Wenger and Martinez with their employers... and then ask "You don't have to be a blind devotee of Martinez to think that's stretching the imagination a tiny bit do you?" ...
Fair enough, Paul. in the face of such a powerful and persuasive argument, I'm forced to concede that Robbie was absolutely right to turn his attentions elsewhere during an absolutely crucial transfer window.
So what if he has been on the telly more than Sue Barker recently. A man's entitled to earn a shilling, right?
104 Posted 07/07/2014 at 19:53:02
105 Posted 07/07/2014 at 21:43:43
I'm not 'defending' Martinez's 'moonlighting', just like I wasn't 'getting my excuses in early'.
Neither am I 'dreaming a bizarre conversation', I'm hitting your hypothesis with one of my own.
If you shout an argument loud and long enough, it doesn't become a fact. You think he's derelicting his duty and holding us back from signing players. I don't.
You don't like the Martinez gush-fest, and I'm with you on that one. Matching it with equally ridiculous arguments and calling them 'facts' doesn't help anyone.
I think we'll have to agree to disagree and roll on the interesting conversations about the squad once the season starts.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 04/07/2014 at 14:25:46
We have lost Lukaku, Barry and Deulofeu from last seasonÂs squad and have the challenge of the Europa League coming up next season and havenÂt been seriously linked with anyone decent so far.
The "Everton" way is not very good on the nerves and is certainly not conducive to attracting top quality players.