This article may have been recategorised and is therefore no longer available at this URL.

You can try to find the updated link in the article archive.

Share article:

Reader Comments (27)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Robert Tressell
1 Posted 06/05/2020 at 08:25:52
Totally agree with the point that we need to speculate on players like Onyekuru in order to grow. Whilst him, Lookman and Vlasic may not have done anything much for the first team, they all made a profit for the club. Worth signing a couple each season.

As for the man himself, he seemed to have tremendous potential, albeit a bit raw. I was hopeful he'd be a first teamer. But looks like the injury, World Cup and work permit debacle knocked his confidence and chances at a critical moment and he's destined now to score goals in an inferior league.

Steve Hopkins
2 Posted 06/05/2020 at 08:39:09
Speaking of Lookman, does anyone know what's become of him? Wikipedia lists him as making only 7 appearances for Leipzig this season.
Clive Rogers
3 Posted 06/05/2020 at 09:31:58
Steve, last I read, Leipzig wanted to convert him to a wingback and he has lost his place since then.
Steve Hopkins
4 Posted 06/05/2020 at 09:52:08
That's interesting, thanks Clive.
Dave Abrahams
5 Posted 06/05/2020 at 10:16:22
Did Walsh sign Lewis Gibson from Newcastle Utd? He could turn out to be a gem of a signing. Catch them young is the way to go – as long as you sign the right ones.

Jarrad Branthwaite could be another good signing last season from the North East. He looks okay, very tall and still some growth in him... could be another Jackie Charlton, only better looking!!!

Jim Jennings
6 Posted 06/05/2020 at 11:04:01

Re Lookman, he simply has not been near good enough to get in RB Leipzig's team with the players ahead of him. But it is ironic because he is exactly the profile of player they sign which the author suggests EFC should do. Young, good re-sale value and relatively low risk – even if he did cost big enough money.

Half that RB Leipzig squad is (or was before Covid-19) being linked with moves to cash-rich Premier League teams – fellas like Konate, Upamecano, Sabitzer and of course Werner, who were all signed for relative buttons.

Derek Knox
7 Posted 06/05/2020 at 12:47:11
Hi Dave @5, not entirely sure if Walsh was behind the signing of Lewis Gibson, but if he was, it's probably about the only one he got right. Sorry to correct you but Jarrad Branthwaite was signed from Carlisle United.

Like you say though he could, along with Lewis Gibson prove to be money well spent. It's not very often we can say that with Everton. We have a terrible record when you look back, at some of the astronomical sums (and Contracts) that have been shelled out on poor choices.

Dave Abrahams
8 Posted 06/05/2020 at 13:13:14
Derek (7), nice to hear from you, hope you are getting through this terrible time okay, see you some time this year, hopefully.

Derek, believe it or not I put down from The North East for Branthwaite, because I couldn’t remember which club we signed him from, this word checker is getting worse and worse, I’ve warned Lyndon about him, between you and me, I think he’s a relation of Lyndon’s or maybe Michael’s.

Michael Kenrick
9 Posted 06/05/2020 at 13:13:19
Dave, so sorry... that was poor mistake by me. I feel just like Prof Neil Ferguson now... totally and painfully exposed. Mind you, when you're knocking up a fine-looking young lady like that... well, I forgive him.

Derek, Steve Walsh left us in May 2018, while Gibson was signed the previous summer, so it would be reasonable to expect that Walsh had been heavily involved with his acquisition by the club.

"You win some, you lose some" has to be the aphorism for the youth recruitment game in football. Which seems to have now largely replaced the 'local kid comes good' pathway. Although the number of kids we have that are at least from the British Isles is still pretty robust.

Lyndon has put a positive spin on the Onyekuru saga, which may be justified by the ultimate profit secured. But any wages we paid (especially when he was out injured) should also be factored in. At least Brands had the wisdom to cash in rather than prolong the agony of wondering when he would ever make his Everton debut.

Dave Abrahams
10 Posted 06/05/2020 at 14:19:37
Michael (9), fair enough, we all make mistakes – although I still think you are covering up for that word checker.
Tom Bowers
11 Posted 06/05/2020 at 15:45:11
I have always said that football is a business, like anything else, and it comes down to balancing the books whilst trying to satisfy the shareholders. Many players become investments as a young signing and, if not for the team's success, then later on for monetary gain.

However, some players do not progress for many different reasons and it is not always their fault. Clubs change managers so often these days that your face may fit for a short time... then it doesn't under a new manager.

Some young aspirants have attitude problems and want to be picked every game, even when they have a poor run, so they want out pretty quickly.

Nagging injuries don't help and affect performances and then there are outside transgressions that prevent a player from progressing. Everton have had their fair share of misfits as we all know.

Some things will never change but we long-suffering fans are really hoping the corner is being turned with Ancelotti and the new guys in the boardroom.

Derek Knox
12 Posted 06/05/2020 at 16:30:40
Hi Dave @8, yes it would be great to see you before the year is out, putting an optimistic spin on things, but the way things are going it will be in Temperance House, or a tea-room.

The forecast for Pubs opening again doesn't look likely to be this year, and unfortunately for some, who may have been struggling before, it will be the final nail in their respective coffins.

It has been a devastating blow this, to virtually every country in the World, and it's not even nearing to be under control. There is talk of mutations of the original virus, and second waves etc, there are so many stories and counter stories, you don't know who or what to believe.

Anyway, take care mate and stay safe, as I wish to all on TW.

Lyndon Lloyd
14 Posted 06/05/2020 at 18:57:01
Michael (9): Lyndon has put a positive spin on the Onyekuru saga, which may be justified by the ultimate profit secured. But any wages we paid (especially when he was out injured) should also be factored in

By that logic, we wouldn't sign anyone of this ilk for fear of losing money in the long run. Even if we paid him £4m in wages during his time with us (which we obviously won't have done), we still broke even on a speculative signing which would still be fine.

Again, I'd rather we tried these things with low risk and come out even or in profit than not try them at all.

Robert Tressell
15 Posted 06/05/2020 at 19:36:01
Since Vlasic, Lookman and Onyekuru were on loan much of the time I expect we were not paying their (relatively modest) wages. I was disappointed to see Vlasic go as he's certainly no worse than Iwobi and was much cheaper.

These are absolutely the sorts of signings we need. You only need a couple to ignite and it changes the whole club.

Harry Williams
16 Posted 06/05/2020 at 22:34:11
Steve Walsh bought some duds, but also bought some good ones as well: Pickford, Calvert-Lewin, Gana, Michael Keane.

Walsh gets a lot of criticism and yes I see that. But who is better Walsh or Brands? Everybody knows Silva brought Richarlison to the club.

In Walsh's first two seasons with Everton, we came 7th and 8th in the league... then he gets sacked. Brands 8th and.....? Will Brands go!? The architect is not the answer in my opinion!!!!

Gavin Johnson
17 Posted 07/05/2020 at 02:05:38
The lad can't be seen as a failure. We made £4M and also money on the fees from his 2 years out loan.

I would say the club failed by not cancelling the loan once Anderlecht started acting like dickheads. He could have still made that World Cup squad.

I still think we should have insisted on a buy-back clause when we sold him to Monaco. He's only 22.

Steve Brown
18 Posted 07/05/2020 at 03:28:18
Chelsea have built this approach into their business model, with 28 players on loan this season. Many won't play a game for them but will provide profit when they are resold.

I thought signing Onyekuru and Lookman was smart business in a period where Walsh squandered countless millions.

Tony Everan
19 Posted 07/05/2020 at 12:36:50
Steve, yes I was thinking we have been copying Chelsea’s approach a little bit. Ironically our top scorer in the last 30 years was a Chelsea loanee. I think it is a good and viable approach, if we can get the scouting right in the first place. It’s only a matter of time until we find a diamond.
Ray Said
20 Posted 07/05/2020 at 19:14:28
I think it's a bit unbalanced to just compare Brands and Walsh on transfer work alone. I think Brands has more genuine Director of Football type involvement in wider aspects of the development of the footy side of the business than Walsh did.
Derek Taylor
21 Posted 08/05/2020 at 19:03:47
Given that most on here see Tom Davies as falling well short of Premier League standard, it's beginning to look likely that Unsy's Wonders are a bunch of flops. Of the truly homegrown talent, only Rodwell and Barkley are still with top-level sides and then the former is only at Sheffield on a loan!

Perhaps it would be better to stop signing kids at 6 and 7 to concentrate on the brightest talent in the lower leagues?

Kevin Prytherch
22 Posted 08/05/2020 at 19:52:19
Derek – John Lundstram??

Considering we've had Hibbert, Osman, Rooney, Jeffers, Ball, and Dunne who have also gone on to have distinguished careers (albeit some a while ago)... Would it not be sensible to concentrate on both? We have also had Duffy, Mustafi, Stones and Dier on our books as well.

I'm eager to see how Gibson and Branthwaite progress and hope that Brands starts investing in young talent like these two. They might not always come off, but a million or two gambled here and there is a far smaller risk than £28 million on an Italian youth prospect.

Derek Taylor
23 Posted 08/05/2020 at 20:22:45
How silly of me, overlooking all that local talent. Having said that, though, at least three of them came through in the last century whist Stones came from Barnsley!
Kevin Prytherch
24 Posted 08/05/2020 at 20:51:26
Duffy, Mustafi, Stones and Dier all came from elsewhere, which goes along with your premise of buying young talent. I was just saying that it should go hand in hand with producing local talent.

You could include Lookman, Vlasic and Coleman in with them as well, as they've all been bought as relative youngsters not for the first team (with the possible exception of Vlasic) and either made us money, or became very good players for us. This is an area in which I expected more from Brands.

Andy Crooks
25 Posted 08/05/2020 at 21:07:06
Derek, some on here, perhaps many on here, may well see what they regard as Tom Davies's shortcomings. What evidence do you have that it is "most"?


Derek Taylor
26 Posted 08/05/2020 at 22:39:09
Many correspondents criticise his inclusion whenever he is selected. Personally, he'll do for me but not too many would agree.
Harry Wallace
27 Posted 09/05/2020 at 09:23:34
I love this series. Always a great read 👍🏻
Chad Schofield
28 Posted 17/05/2020 at 09:29:14
Chelsea often get pointed at as good, but while they profited, they must be slightly envious of letting the likes of De Bruyne and Lukaku go. Yet they clearly "bought their titles".

I think the Luke Garbutt article shows even more the sliding doors-style side of a professional football career (they're really good Lyndon).

At 22 Onyekuru could go either way. We have made a 50% profit (less wages)... that's not bad. That doesn't make you a selling club if he comes good, or a financial genius if he does nothing - it was just prudent to sell him for that price at the time.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.

About these ads

© ToffeeWeb