The Mail Bag
Enough's Enough!
Comments (34)
All summer I've tried to be optimistic about the current transfer predicament at the club, however, when I woke up this morning to find that Moyes has supposedly been 'misled' by agents over the Love deal, it really pissed me off and gave me the urge to write in.
How can a Premier League club consistently struggle to negotiate one transfer deal when every other club in the league seems to manage it with little or no problems?
Alright, maybe Moyes has been 'misled' on this occasion, but the Moutinho deal seems to have gone quiet. What about M'bia, Milito, Smith, Topal? I don't understand why we can't go in for players along the £10m lines of Milner and Wright-Phillips. We've just got over 10 mil for the AJ deal so there is surely some source of finance at the club, although after AJ was seemingly forced out in order to raise funds, it seems to me as though in comparison with a lot of other sides the club are in fact skint.
i know for almost certain that Moyes will bring in players before the window, but why hasn't it been done earlier? Even if anyone comes in before Blackburn, there is no way they will play, leaving us with 10 seniors which for a top 5 premier side is embarassing. Midfield looks especially poor at the moment.
The only way forward long-term has to be investment. My only criticism of Kenwright is that he should have maybe attracted some investment by now. The guy loves the club as much as any one of us does and tries hard but at the end of the day, we are currently in danger of falling backwards again.
Anyway, whatever happens from now until 1st Sept, i know that we'll all still remain loyal and passionate because at the end of the day, we are the best fans in the world.
COYB
Matt Roache, Posted 14/08/2008 at 17:03:55
Comments
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
4th?
5th? Top 10?
Worse?
Or a cup win?
Now that would be the sweetest of endings to a terrble close season. Lets just get behind this team and give them a big cheer! COYB
think its a bright future for Everton with good youth policy and fine manager....the rest will follow and we can win our games till new players come in so no problems...COME ON THE BLUES...
I fail to believe that we will not add to the squad at all in the closed season. Things cannot possibly be that bad. If this were to be the case, Moyes would have walked before now.
Not saying I would be duped into thinking everything is fine and dandy if it did happen but my understanding of the way the PR works at Everton is to try bury over the deep lying facts with some well-timed good news.
I am so frustrated I cannot believe how incompetent this club is and have now given up all hope of any signings. Even as I write this I feel my blood boiling and I now have to delete my computer history so me boss doesn't see all the sites I've visited!! No point in the letter I just wanted to get it off me chest. I shall now go and do some invoicing, aaah that feels better.
WE ALL ARE!!!!
My emotions this pre-season have gone loopy over all the rumours, gossip, including BULLSHIT rumours spread by those people on this very site!
I?m sure most do it in good faith but the "so-and-so is arriving soon" or "my cousins dog said" crap only adds to the MISERY
.
Not one new signing (and, no, I don?t count Pienaar!) .... it is embarrassing to be an EFC supporter right now.
Here?s one example why: Villa make a bid for Cuellar of Rangers, within a mater of days, if that!!, he?s a Villa player.
Now, I?m not saying we needed him but FFS I wouldn?t say no to him...but my point is is that the whole deal (at least based on what we know admittedly) was so quick it was downright amazing!
So, why, do we have to put up with a whole pre-season of utter garbage in terms of lack of signings, promises, "the money is there", " the money isn?t there", "it?s not linked to DK", "will DM sign", "DM will sign soon".......it?s garbage and so effing frustrating.............I can?t wait for Saturday if only that signals the end of pre-season!!
The only saving grace is that The RS couldn?t beat Standard Liege last night...that was quite funny (Did anybody see Jamie Carraghers? quote? Laughable!)
Okay, I?ve calmed down now.............3 points in the bag on Saturday, live on the tele here, in Moyes we trust, COYB!!!
Final comment, even with all the youngsters (I actually find that exciting) I still think we have a cracking team if we can bring in some decent players SOON I will actually be dead excited for this season..........when Pienaar, Cahill, even Hibbert, Anichebe and AVM......FINALS HERE COME!!!!
Remember how it was the end of the world when we Divering Dave didn’t pursue David Nugent?
Then it was terrible when Keiran Richardson got away, followed by Jason Koumas and even Johan Voegel slipped through our fingers.
Everyone was predicting doom and gloom but Moyes quietly went about his business unearthing a couple of gems in Jagielka and Pienaar, signing one the countries top young defenders in Baines and then late on added a 20-goal a season goalscorer (Yakubu actually signed on August 29th).
Moyes decided to hold fire and not pursue Nugent, Richardson and Koumas, it caused many fans to panic but in hindsight would you swap Jagielka, Baines, Pienaar or Yakubu for any of them?
I’m not trying to underplay the seriousness of the situation. Its undeniable that Everton need quality players to add numbers to the squad. I’m just saying dont panic.
Moyes is on the case and panic buying is not something he does and frankly nor should he.
Let him take his take and hopefully deliver another group like Jagielka, Baines, Pienaar and Yakubu.
All that doom and gloom sparked by ’missing out’ on Nugent, Koumas and Richardson was soon forgotten when Jagielka, Baines, Pienaar and Yakubu helped Everton have a solid UEFA Cup run and finish 5th in the Premiership.
We have evry little money (I suspect we spent too much this time last year - Baines, Yak, Jags = 20 million)
This means we can only offer modest wages and low transfer fees. Players and clubs know they can get better deals elsewhere - and the greed of them means that they’s rather play for Newcastle reserves on 60 grand a week than play in Europe for us on 35 or 40... fair enough.
Our manager and chairmen are not so much ditherers as cautious. When you look at the money spent on Kroldrup, Beattie and Van der Meyde... fair enough too.
Despite this, we do need midfielders. We seemed to be well in the hunt for mid range fee (4 - 5 million) players like Kallstrom, Bradley, M Johnson and M’Bia a few weeks back. Two of these would do nicely... funded by the AJ money. So what happened?
Something is rotten at EFC ... either the debts are uncontrollable of someone is on the take.
NO CLUB has EVER been this awful in the pre-season Premiership transfer market... especially after shipping out so many players recently...McFadden, Wessels, Carsley, Johnson, even Fernandes, Gardner and Gravesen...7 out, none in! And then there’s the injuries ... Cahill, Pienaar, VdM, Hibbert and Vic in China... we are down TWELVE players.
Just not good enough.
Enough of the COYB rubbish... BSFP... buy some F*$@ING players!!
Acting Chief Executive Robert Elstone told evertonfc.com: ?The first game at Goodison has historically proved to be popular amongst Evertonians and Saturday?s fixture is proving to be just the same.
?Everybody I have spoken to is looking forward to what will hopefully be another memorable campaign on the pitch and the increased media coverage following the official Premier League season launch over the past few days has only added to all the anticipation.
"We have spent a large part of the summer getting ready for the new campaign and now it is down to us all to make sure Goodison is full to the rafters every second week so we can give David and the players the support they deserve."
IT MAKES ME SICK TO THE STOMACH, LIE AFTER LIE AFTER LIE.
What have we done to be ready?? fuck all, shit pre season, shit results and no players. THANKS EVERTON YOU GANG OF TWATS!!!
"As the season goes on, we are going to have to use these boys as we don?t really have big numbers," said Moyes.
No shit Davey, so does that mean as the season goes on you knew we would not be buying players to bulk up the squad??
WTF!
very small story and sounds like somethin they have just made up?!
Say’s it all for me....
Maybe the Dithering Dave tag is unwarranted and he is held up by the club....
swift chairman - my arse....
The Mail are the only people carrying this story, though there are scant reports from Italy about Tiago fancying Everton - that and the odd mention of him & Nuno knowing each other......oh but then they go & spoil it by mentioning Moutinho!
This club is a fucking joke.
In relation to David Moyes, I think it’s about time that Evertonians, whilst recognising his efforts in improving our position on the table, should at the same time also recognise his weaknesses and the problems he has created for himself and EFC in the recruitment of players to this Club with his posturing.
His continued inability to effectively manage recruitment activities is a prime example of his major weakness. For instance, year after year we go through the bulk of the transfer window with no apparent effort being made to sign players until the last moment, when, because of the shrinking numbers of players we have available (the size of our squad has shrunk every year for the past three years) we desperately need additions. This last minute frenzy makes us vulnerable to the twin problems of paying over the odds or picking up players who are not up to scratch (eg Bosnar) or clearly unsuitable (Kroldrup). Before the IMWT brigade rush to remind me of the quality players he has secured, what about the quality players he has wanted but are not interested or we have lost because of the ?Everton way? of negotiating or Mr Moyes? reputation for stubbornness? And, whilst he is not be solely responsible for this nonsensical situation, he is complicit and his continued catch-cry of ?we need more players in our squad? especially towards the end of every long, hard season, make his current inactivity and seeming ineptitude hard to swallow.
I also question the effectiveness of his man management skills, a prime example being despite his unacceptably poor performance in this transfer window, he had the audacity to recently publicly criticise Mikel Arteta and demand that he ?recover his goal scoring touch? because he let us down in that respect last year. This would have come as something of a slap in the face for Arteta and would, I think, also affect others in the team who may see Mr Moyes? comments, especially in view of his monumental failure in the transfer market, as hypocritical and certainly not helpful. Add to that his inflexibility in developing a playing system that capitalises on the strengths of the team, and you have the potential for this club to go backwards. I simply cannot see any quality player with any flair or creativity (a la Mouthino) wanting to play for Mr Moyes in his restrictive 4-5-1 system.
Some years ago at a management function, I attended a dinner where the keynote speaker was an FA accredited coach with a well earned reputation as a developer of quality footballers. He was asked what was the hallmark of a good coach/manager and he said ?someone who can recognise the strengths of his players and develop an effective system around those collective strengths while at the same time working on their weaknesses. He is also someone whom players feel they can approach with confidence when they have problems. Equally, a poor coach is one who ignores these principles and bullies players into fitting into his system which, in my experience, is usually restrictive and is also regarded with fear and trepidation by his players. These are the coaches and managers who will eventually have difficulty in recruiting and retaining quality players because of their reputation?.
This is the best explanation I?ve heard and it is the main reason that I have not shared the widely held view amongst Evertonians that David Moyes is some sort of messiah. Add to this, his ?over the top? stubbornness and growing reputation in British and European football for being difficult to deal with, and I have real concerns that, even if we had the money, that any quality players would risk their careers by joining a club where this limiting management style prevailed.
Why would anyone want to wear our number 9 under Moyes?
But as I've just stated, it's all just gone to cover up the fact that our squad has been decimated.. and blame the board as much as you want, and I DO, there seems to be one person who seems to escaping his share of the blame and that's David "Moyesiah" Moyes.
Why? You may ask. Well I'll tell you... our squad has been paper thin since may and regardless of how much he did or didn't have cash wise ,why in the hell hasn't ..
A) Brought in any loan signings?
B) Brought in any bosmans?
C) Signed the £60k a week 5 year deal?
No one but no one else is going to offer him that type of dough. Blame Billyboy all you want but he can only move in the transfer market when Moyes tells him who he wants.Where's this magical/mythical list that he's meant to have given BK in May? I personally don't think he's got any intention of signing the new contract. Why? because Man Utd are looking for a new No. 2 and whoever gets that job will replace Ferguson and that's what I really think he wants.
He's prick-teased us with so-called bids for Moutinho and Love but surprise surprise neither club remember receiving any bids from Everton. Now, all of a sudden, he's trying to hijack the Tiago transfer ? who the fuck are you trying to kid, Moyesey lad? Not me, that's for sure! And as for Smith, FFS he can't even hold a regular place down at the barcodes!!
Kenwright has taken a lot of flack, rightly so for the most part, but we the fans have played our part to cover up Moyes's shocking ineptitude in the transfer market. Now there's nowhere to hide son, you cut the squad to the bone and YOU have failed us and yes lied to us all summer about your contract and transfers. So Davey lad... WHO'S KIDDING WHO ? We the people are waiting....
There is someone or some people leading us up a horrible path which beggars belief. For folk that in both the board and Moyes's words, "Care so much about this club", I can't but help get the feeling at this late stage that we are being led by not only a board, but also by an apparent honest manager, into a dark, untrusting future of disastrous consequences.
I always had hoped that someone (Moyes) would deliver the fans some form of truth, and be looking out for our best interests of sorts. Now on a Friday morning, I somehow have my doubts.
See you on Saturday....
We are at least 5 men short from last years squad with injuries to add on top of that. No signed contract from the Manager that has been promised to be signed. WHAT ON EARTH IS GOING ON?
Sorry, that quote doesn’t describe Moyes in a positive light...how exactly?
Players like Carsley, Osman, Marcus Bent, Kevin Kilbane...these are very limited players, and Moyes found a system that allows them to use their strengths while hiding their weaknesses. That’s PRECISELY what a 4-5-1 did in Everton’s squad..
Further, to say that Moyes’ tactics haven’t changed isn’t true either. Only if you were completely lazy and basing your analysis entirely on the numbers would you say that the 4-5-1 being played in 04/05 is the same as the 4-5-1 (really 4-1-3-1-1) being played last season. The latter allowed for a midfield of Cahill, Osman and Arteta and Pienaar to play attacking football - I don’t know if you saw the West Ham away game in the cup, but it was the most complete controlling Everton performance I’ve seen in years.
But then, Moyes really wants to play 4-5-1, doesn’t he? It’s HIS system. Except when he first arrived, and played 4-4-2. Oh, and except in his first full season, when he started with 3 up front. And at the start of 04/05, when he played 4-4-2 until it became clear it didn’t work. And three seasons ago, when McFadden was being played as a deep second striker (as well as Cahill) alongside Beattie. And two season’s ago, when he first tried Beattie and Johnson until it didn’t work. And last season, when he played Johnson and Yakubu until it stopped working.
Apart from those times, Moyes never changed from 4-5-1, right? Which is presumably why Moyes has problems "retaining quality players because of their reputation". Players are queueing up to leave Everton....right?
Everton’s transfers - you are using Eddie ****ing Bosnar as an anti Moyes example? He came on a free. It was a speculative transfer, that didn’t come off. Wenger makes LOADS of those every year - you just don’t hear about them.
Kroldrup was "obviously" not suited? Did anybody think that at the time? He’s obviously got quality, having led two smaller Italian clubs into the Champions League. But then, we obviously rushed the transfer in at the last minute because of the impending deadline...on June 22.
Don’t let the facts bother you like.
A restrictive 4-5-1 sytem, I’m sorry Laurie but that’s bollocks. The 4-5-1 system is interchangable, players can swap positions and there are many ways to accomadate certain types of players. We retain possession better as we have the extra man in midfield and when we attack all four midfielders are able to support Yakubu.
4-5-1 is the way forward for me, I’m glad Moyes had adopted the formation.
442 for me every time with a partner for Yak and we’ll be in business. The problem I’m having though is that I’m amazed that we thought we could get Love on loan ?? Would we let Yak go out on loan ?? Why don’t we just pay the 12mill and sign him?? He’s miles better than AJ so just go like for like and then try and bring in M’Bia and Manny on loan.
Still a shambles thanks to Blue Bill !!!
Why would we be playing less long balls with a 4-4-2? With less midfielders you win the ball less often, and have to defend slightly deeper to account for the man less. Hence - more long balls.
The key in either formation is to have central midfielders who are comfortable and quick on the ball. If we have Carsley and Nevile (or this season’s equivalent) in midfield, having a partner for Yak won’t make a jot of difference - you are still going to see the long ball whenever we get put under a bit of pressure.
http://www.mailonsunday.co.uk/sport/football/article-1045785/Ive-let-players-strengthening-squad-admits-Everton-boss-Moyes.html?ITO=1490


1 Posted 14/08/2008 at 11:52:07
Report abuse
My take on this situation is based on the complete lack of information forthcoming from the club itself. They know for sure that there are 50,000 Evertonians out there praying for good news or any constructive news either way, but the lack of any solid information has only perpetuated the current mood.
Saturday will come and go, as will our lenghtening patience/impatience.