The Mail Bag

Creating Giants

Comments (63)

You could tell by watching today's game that the team is full of fear. Got me thinking about some of the things that people used to say about Brian Clough.

The one thing that came to mind was that he made an average player feel like a world beater, he made every player feel like a giant. He filled his players with confidence. He didn't send his players out to stiffle the opposition. He sent them out with belief to express themselves and let the opposition worry about them.

But when I think of David Moyes and his tactics, why would you have confidence? I mean, he is pretty much saying to his players, "You're not good enough, so let's keep it tight and hope that we don't concede. And maybe, just maybe you might nick a goal..."

Reminds me of the David and Goliath story. How the young boy wasn't swayed by fear; and we all know the outcome.
Gordon Crawford, Belfast     Posted 21/11/2009 at 16:26:04

back Return to the Mail Bag

Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Chris Jones
1   Posted 21/11/2009 at 19:19:10

Report abuse

Time to go? Maybe.

Tactics set the tone for this game - we played with fear. At 1-0 we woke up for 10 mins in the second half and it was if the players realised they actually had the ability to get something out of it.

We’ve been done by a quality side, but I’m sick of seeing us rollover against the top teams before the kick off. Ironically we’ve had a lot of chances and s handful of the lads have played really well — the exceptions being the woeful Fellaini and the out of form Cahill.

What struck me most was how heavy footed we’ve looked — especially in midfield.

Anyway the buck stops with the manager. Only two wins from the next two games will do. Belief comes from the gaffer and we’re showing none at the minute.
John Gaulton
2   Posted 21/11/2009 at 19:24:20

Report abuse

The fans will only put up with this rubbish for so long. I love Moyes but I really think he has taken it as far as he can, the other teams have caught up to us and even gone past us.
John Smith
3   Posted 21/11/2009 at 19:26:01

Report abuse

Dire? Boring? Predictable? Any really.

If I do hear the line "we have injuries" one more time I might just throw myself in the Mersey!

We keep using the same frigging line each week, injuries this, injuries that, etc etc, and the most annoying thing is, we don’t have injuries, we have two players out, Jagielka and Arteta, now you can’t tell me that we will suddenly be transformed into a top 5 side when they come back, because the simple fact of the matter is, WE WONT.

It will still be the same boring, predictable shite that we have seen today and since the season kicked off, we have a near enough full strength squad yet we just rolled over today to a Manchester United side who aren’t firing on all cylinders at all, we seemed to be in awe of them each time they got the ball, treating them as if they were the number one side on the planet!

Looking at today and over the past few weeks, Liverpool as bad as they are playing, and lets not forget, Liverpool did beat Manchester United with ease without Steven Gerrard, they will come to Goodison and probably find the net with ease, I’m saying at least three times.

Were pathetic, no fight, no spirit, no determination, a manager who is now I beleive out of his depth and a chairman who hasn’t got the money to run the club, yet wont sell up because he’s a "TRUE BLUE" Bollocks to it!.

15 years without a trophy and now were being overtook in the table by teams like Sunderland / Manchester City and Aston Villa.
Chris Jones
4   Posted 21/11/2009 at 19:35:13

Report abuse

John - totally understand your frustration but we had a few more out than just Mikel and Jags. Neville, Pienaar and Bily would all be starters - that’s half a team.

Still no excuse though.... Oh yeah forgot Davey’s favourite (Osman).
John Smith
5   Posted 21/11/2009 at 19:46:05

Report abuse

Chris, the thing is, what would Neville, Pienaar and Bilyaletdinov contribute even if they were playing?

Neville is a disadvantage to any team, he gets completely caught up in big games like this, his leadership skills (if you can call them that) only seem to be authorised against lower league teams like Hull, Blackburn, etc etc.

Pienaar is frustrating at the best of times, and today, he most probably would of went missing for the entire game and when he would of had a touch he would of either a) ran out of brain or b) shoved off the ball by a smaller player.

As for Bilyaletdinov, the jury is still out on him, he seems to play well and then dissapears, I don’t think Old Trafford would bring the best out of him.

We have two real talents missing, but we have a squad of over 20 "professional" players so we really have to stop using the same old excuse, it's boring me to death just hearing it. Liverpool had a lot more injuries than us, yet they have more points and are higher in the table than us, and also beat United.

They also have players like Lucas, Babel, Kuyt, who I don’t think could get in our starting eleven, yet their higher than us (with injuries)

I’m fed up of it, its predictable and far to one-dimensional. I for one, am not looking forward to playing Liverpool, whilst most teams actually want to play them in the form they are in.

Its bleak.
David Hallwood
6   Posted 21/11/2009 at 20:06:59

Report abuse

I confess Chris. One of the lads had tickets and I could’ve had one, and as I posted, I didn’t even watch it on TV I know it sounds weird but I knew it would be a typical 10 men behind the ball, that just doesn’t work and it just invites a team like Man U to attack and they’ve got too much quality in the final 3rd. So there’s no point in watching it, it’s just like getting tickets to watch your brother get the shit kicked out of him
Stew Marsland
7   Posted 21/11/2009 at 20:02:44

Report abuse

Okay, well there it is — our usual 'rollover and play dead for the Red Mancs. Well I don't know about the rest of you but I am fucking sick of this damage limitation every time we play them. Why can't we have a bash and at least try? There seems no point in playing this fixture any more just give them the points.

But then you have to ask why?Why after how many years in the Premier League we have only beaten them... twice? It is because we are also-rans, and cannot compete any more for trophies and as a consequence have been reduced to minor competition?

We have absolutely no ambition and the players can see this. They will be off after this season no doubt. I cannot blame them.

Billy bullshit has a lot to answer for as he has ruined any progress we have made. What is the point of playing videos of our past successes every match, eg Dixie etc? It is ancient history and means nothing to any supporter today. Kenwright is stuck in a time warp of 80 years ago and needs to be relieved of his position now and somebody has to take this club on because at the moment the only way is down.

Ray Kelly
8   Posted 21/11/2009 at 20:05:22

Report abuse

Is there another team in the Prem’ that goes into these games against the "big 4" with a "We’re beaten before we start" attitude like we do? In fact, I’m being kind there, we go into every game away from Goodison now with an attitude that’s resigned to defeat before a ball is a kicked and I honestly don’t think that any other manager in the Premier League sends his team out without any intention of trying to win these games like Moyes obviously does.

Don’t get me wrong, these other teams may be deluded, but at least they go onto the park with the intention of winning; Moyes's tactics, which are going to be dictated by who he plays and where, are an abject failure, he can’t even be called a reactionary manager because he doesn’t know how to react!

I don’t want to hear the fuckin’ tired injury, stretched squad excuse — it's worn thin when the players who are on the field can’t get the basics right and look totally demoralised. If he plays that fuckin’ 4-5-1 formation again he should be fuckin’ sacked. We’re slipping to the bottom Davey, show some fuckin’ leadership and coaching ability and try something different before we end up in the fuckin’ Championship!

John Smith
9   Posted 21/11/2009 at 20:34:49

Report abuse

Well said Ray, I’m myself just waiting for the "Moyes brigade" to come on.

I’m sick to fucking death of people defending him. So we finish 5th a couple of times? big fucking deal, what do we have to show for it? a nice big shiny FA Cup or UEFA Cup in our cabinet, even a League Cup? No, fuck all, just an over-stretched, tired squad that start the following season in abysmal fashion.

During Moyes reign, whilst agreed it has been much better than any of the shite under Walter Smith, I’m beginning to think Everton fans have gone soft, we still haven’t had any trophy success. Fuck getting to the FA Cup Final last season, we have runners-up medals to show for that, Moyes played a negative game and we paid the price.

We go into every game against teams like Man Utd with a fucking stupid negative attitude and a damage limitation set-up, and its pissing me right off, why not just give the points to United beforehand, it saves me and many people like me 90 minutes of our lives.

We want trophies, not fucking back-breaking league finishes, even if we do happen to break into the Champions League, like 2005, we will just get shown the exit door, were not good enough, not by a million miles.

I’m sorry but we will never ever stop being negative and defeatist under David Moyes.
Ray Robinson
10   Posted 21/11/2009 at 20:57:24

Report abuse

Well, I’m just back from the game and I thought we had a decent go at them. I thought we played better this year than last season when we only lost on a penalty. So it’s not doom and gloom from me. I don’t think the score was a fair reflection.

Plus points, Heitinga and Saha. Also Neil looked more comfortable on the ball at right back than ever Hibbert does.

That was no way near as bad as some of the comments above suggest, in my opinion.
Aiden Jones
11   Posted 21/11/2009 at 21:25:21

Report abuse

Very worrying. After always thinking Tony Marsh talked rubbish .... I now think he might just have been right (or at least talking more sense than I gave him credit for) all along.
Ray Kelly
12   Posted 21/11/2009 at 21:17:50

Report abuse

I think the players just looked resigned to defeat from the kick-off,they’ve obviously got no confidence in the shape of the team they are playing in or the baffling, negative tactics Moyes is directing them to apply.

As the Man U goals went in I clocked the looks on our players' faces, it wasn’t a look of pain — it was one of pathetic acceptance. It has become clear that Moyes's objectives at the start of a season are to maintain the status quo and keep his bank balance and everybody who’s on the payroll at the club ticking over nicely thank you.

Any platitudes about putting the Club back where it belongs and attempting to win trophies are mere red-herrings. He made his bed with Kenwright and will not utter a word about poor closed season or lack of progressive investment. We are stuck with Moyes like it or not — and I fucking don’t!

Richard Dodd
13   Posted 21/11/2009 at 21:25:36

Report abuse

Let’s face it — with six of our top players still missing we were never likely to trouble the Mancs today. In our present state we are good enough to stuff the bottom end teams and hold our own against the middle tier but until we have all our stars back — and I include Ossie in that number — we cannot expect much joy against the ’millionairos’.

Thank god we shall almost certainly be hearing some great news about our ground move in just a few days time. At least that will lighten the gloom!

Ed Staunton
14   Posted 21/11/2009 at 18:03:40

Report abuse

Let me say from the start I am a Moyes supporter, or should I say I have always been in the past. I am now looking for change, to save the club from building all over again.

Moyes has done a good job. I don’t think anyone can dispute that. Taken over an old poorly performing squad & changing it to a much younger better squad, but now we need someone who can take it on.

A positive manger, who can say let’s have a go, that’s the only way we will learn how good we are. For a moment today we had a go, no it didn’t work, but that was because it was a too little too late & having a go isn’t just about attacking, as much as that is what we want, it’s about defending, like you mean it, not standing off rooney, get into him & the rest.

So in the end we need someone to give not only the forwards belief but all the team. Stand up & have a go.

Guy Hastings
15   Posted 21/11/2009 at 21:22:01

Report abuse

I’ve spent the past 90 minutes trying to put my anger and frustration about the performance against Utd into a cogent post. Every time, I’ve wiped it clean and started again. I’ve now given up. At least I spent 90 minutes of effort... 89 more than those in a blue shirt spent at OT tonight. Pathetic.
Billy Buckingham
16   Posted 21/11/2009 at 16:49:08

Report abuse

Well that's fuckin it. Am I the only one who's sick and tired of the shit negative football played by this redheaded shitehawk?

Man Utd get their easiest 6 points every year cos this dummy is shit scared to have a go at them. MOYES OUT FUCK OFF TO SCOTLAND; take Cahill, Gosling, Jo, Heitinga and fucking Rodwell with yer. Before the idiots who continue to sing the red thick bastards name start, you can all fuck off — this negative bastard is making EFC a laughing stock.

Peter Fearon
17   Posted 21/11/2009 at 18:19:34

Report abuse

One word sums up our performance against Manchester United: impotence.

I was irked when we started with the usual lone striker and longed for Yakubu to come on... but really, if there's no creativity or imagination from midfield, it doesn't matter who is up front. It's not that they are second-rate players so much as players turning in too many second-rate performances.

The one serious chance Yakubu got he took a half-hearted stab at and then grimaced in pain. Not one member of the side looked like they felt for a second that they could have an impact on the result and only one or two looked like they cared either way. That's not the attitude that's needed against any Premier League club, let alone Man. United. If they take that attitude into the derby game it will be a long afternoon.

Incidentally, if anyone wants to give us over 20 mill for Rodwell I would say take it and be careful not to bite their hand off. I haven't seen a single match where he has seriously impacted the outcome. I realize he has potential, but right now, take the money and look for someone who can actually produce a win.

Ray Kelly
18   Posted 21/11/2009 at 21:35:04

Report abuse

Let's face it — even if we had our full compliment of players we were never likely to trouble the Mancs today. Moyes would still play 4-5-1 and would still wait till we conceded a goal before having a knee-jerk. For me, this Football Club of ours should never send a team out that is resigned to defeat and we as fans should always expect as much as possible from our team. We are Everton FC not fucking Wigan or Hull, so don’t listen to the mugs who try to dumb down our Club; always demand the best for that is what this club was built on! God how we have fallen under Kenwright!
Michael Evans
19   Posted 21/11/2009 at 21:46:44

Report abuse

Clough was a "Goliath" when it came to man management of footballers - a genius who could inspire players.I know this because I am old enough to have witnessed what he did at Forrest.

In Moyes we have a man who has stablilised the ship blah blah blah. However, can our "David" take on the Goliaths of Ferguson, Wenger etc — No. Why? Well, because our "David" has an inferiority complex when playing against the SKY 4 and his fear then transmits to the team.

There was a time when I truly believed that our "David" could become the "Goliath" we all want him to be.

I now know that I was wrong.

Rob Jones
20   Posted 21/11/2009 at 21:51:23

Report abuse

To be honest I think I’m more pissed off with some of the comments above rather than the team. You can blame Moyes for having an unbalanced squad but ffs. Go back to May and read all the national press - laughing stock - not at all. Total admiration for Everton and the way they coped with the loss of Yak, then Arteta, then Jags. Now lost Neville - misssing against big 4? ask Ronaldo you tit! Piennar? In my world has been one injury too far. Anyway look forward to seeing none of you miserable bastards at Goodison next week.
Charles King
21   Posted 21/11/2009 at 22:03:24

Report abuse

Glad to see some people still understand what EFC should be about, some contributors worry me with their acceptance of the mediocrity of this present manager. I thought Moyes had got it when he first arrived his declaration of the People's Club hit exactly the right note. Unfortunately his utterances since have been less memorable and his actions dreadfully predictable. We need a lot more for £3 million a year.
Ray Kelly
22   Posted 21/11/2009 at 22:07:48

Report abuse

Personally I don’t get my opinions on EFC from reading the press, I get them from what I see on the pitch and frankly I find the media view of "poor little Everton, aren’t they doing well with no money" etc fucking patronising and insulting in the extreme. We are not punching above our weight as the gobshites in the papers or on Sky would have some believe, we are punching way below our heavyweight status!

Don’t believe any of this big four shit, it just lets Kenwright off the hook. It's not what we have on the park, we all know we’ve been deprived of our best players, but its the way the players who we do have available are representing this Club at the moment and it’s not fucking good enough.

Kevin Sparke
23   Posted 21/11/2009 at 22:22:45

Report abuse

Job description for Moyes’s replacement:

You are an up-and-coming manager who will be expected to break the top four and do so playing good football; to ensure you achieve this you will be expected to operate on a minus level transfer budget; find players from the lower leagues and turn them into Premier League players within three months; have a youth system capable of producing a Rooney or Rodwell every three years in line with the club’s financial policy based upon survival and satisfy a delusional section of supporters who expect you to compete with teams with 6 times your transfer budget on an equal footing, play good football every week and disregard any injury problems you may have...

This is what Moyes’s replacement will have to deal with.

Good fucking luck to him I say... because three weeks after he arrives the same dickheads who are shouting for Moyes’s head will be equally as loud shouting for the new manager’s bollocks on a platter.
Chris Halliday
24   Posted 21/11/2009 at 22:34:35

Report abuse

Fuck the injuries, how long are we going to go on about them when talking about a 90 min game of football? There were enough decent players on the pitch today to put in a performance and guess what — only 1 or 2 turned up: Saha and Heitinga. The rest look scared shitless. As much as Moyes is doing my head in, what’s the excuse for Fella, Cahill, Jobo, etc?

Anyone who has ever played football has played when you're second best but you still want to come off the pitch with your own performance intact. Too many of them are hiding behind excuses or simply not good enough.

That said what a negative approach to the game, I lost count of the "punts" up field to no-one, unfortunately we have seen this so many times under Moyes, but it’s ok cos he got us 4th place in 2005 so of course he can do no wrong.

Ray Kelly
25   Posted 21/11/2009 at 22:52:37

Report abuse

Don’t accept the excuses, there’s an apathy that's crept into our support over recent years, we’re encouraged by the media to accept second best and our spineless, ineffectual board are happy to go along with it. It gets them and superfan Kenwright off the hook, it allows Moyes to shrug his shoulders and say, "We can’t compete," instead of saying, "I want my board to help me compete."

Until us, the fans, start to demand more, we will get at best mediocrity and that's not good enough for a top team like us.

Paul Conatzer
26   Posted 21/11/2009 at 23:00:26

Report abuse

I didn’t see the match, so what I’m basing this on is media reports. But, there’s a line in BBC match-report that is something along the line of Everton laid back and invited United to attack. Almost every time, I watch Everton play that happens along with too much mind-numbing hoof ball.

I grew up with the Everton of Ball, Harvey and Kendall and maybe it’s too much to expect that, but surely more can be expected than sopping up pressure and hoping for a break.

Ste Traverse
27   Posted 21/11/2009 at 22:59:28

Report abuse

Charles King. Its not the ’peoples club’, it never has been and never will be, its Bill Kenwright's Club, and Bill’s alone, and every Evertonian in the world should know this.
Paul Henshaw
28   Posted 21/11/2009 at 23:03:16

Report abuse

There was a time when Nil Satis Nisi Optimum meant something.

Frankly, under Moyes, we have turned into a slow, long-ball, negative and frankly horrible team to watch. From playing one up front to having eleven men back at corners, I’m pissed off at the "keep it tight, don’t concede and we’ll nick a goal" mentality that the manager is instilling.

Yep,we’ve had injuries to our most creative players. Yep, some players are out of form. And even yep, some players are playing out of position... but what I’m watching every week is a long ball from the back to a lone striker who flicks it on into space for nobody. It’s painful to watch, it really is.

Get the ball down on the deck and fucking pass it to one of your own players. Have a go at teams, get on the front foot and don’t sit back and hope you nick one.

Moyes, wake up and smell the coffee. Admit one up front is a negative tactic, admit Fellaini will never be a player and admit your negativity....
Paul Henshaw
29   Posted 21/11/2009 at 23:17:08

Report abuse

Or is that me being negative?!
Jay Woods
30   Posted 21/11/2009 at 23:18:05

Report abuse

It’s the total gutlessness of the approach to playing Man Utd every time that blows me away. Talk about being beaten in their own minds before a ball is even kicked! It’s disgusting, spineless, supine surrenderism at its yellow worst. We should actually wear an all-yellow kit, home and away against Utd, just to highlight this point. Or a white one to represent our total willingness to capitulate.

And yes, I blame the manager first and foremost for this. It’s his job to motivate these loser millionaires into first giving a toss and then into giving it a bloody go.
Nick Entwistle
31   Posted 22/11/2009 at 00:19:35

Report abuse

I saw Man Utd better than Everton, but score three deflected goals... shit happens.
Gareth Hughes
32   Posted 22/11/2009 at 00:39:22

Report abuse

Nick; Yes, I saw that as well. Fletcher’s goal deflected off the the post and Carrick’s the corner of the net. Mate, don’t comment if your facts are wrong. And yes, shit happens... every time Everton take the field we get shit football and tactics. I wish I could be as laid back about it as you!
John Andrews
33   Posted 22/11/2009 at 00:46:16

Report abuse

Taxi for Moyes!!!!
Gareth Hughes
34   Posted 22/11/2009 at 00:48:09

Report abuse

I’m paying!
Joe Cavanagh
35   Posted 22/11/2009 at 00:48:44

Report abuse

This was the 4th time I’ve been able to see Everton live on ESPN Brasil. The previous games were Arsenal (1-6), Benfica (0-5 and 0-2). So maybe I shouldn’t have expected much. But today’s performance, especially the first half, was dire.

The problem seemed to me to be midfield — absent when defending, and slow and unoriginal when attacking. We gave the ball away cheaply so many times, and made the game much harder for ourselves. Gosling looked completely out of his depth — too slow and lighweight; Cahill sweated but ran into defenders every time; Rodwell was slick but unproductive. But I’ll stick my neck out to defend Fellaini — he at least was trying to carry the ball forward and look for openings, even if he didn’t have much around him to aim for. We were much better connected in the opening of the second half, when there were more options up front.

I agree then with the gist of the comments above — negative tactics put us on the back foot from the start. And we desparately need the return of some midfielders of pace and quality that can read the game.

Looks to me like we’re in for a long winter (or summer, where I am)....

So it’s 4 games and a 1-16 aggregate score - much as I want to see EFC on the telly here, I think I’d prefer it if we never appeared again. At least that way we’d et some goals and points.

Ciarán McGlone
36   Posted 22/11/2009 at 01:29:46

Report abuse

What about those sand people...ripped poor CP30 to bits while poor R2 looked on from a cave...

’This is not the everton you are looking for’ [fingers waved in front of face]...
Nick Xenos
37   Posted 22/11/2009 at 02:21:11

Report abuse

The first half mind set and performance was the reason why we have a very poor record against the SKY 4. What’s the use of playing 4-5-1 when you know the ball will be coming straight back at you. The best form of defence is attack and Moyes should've played 2 up front to start off with.

Why is it that Steve Bruce can send his Sunderland team out with two strikers up top and get a result at Trafford while Moyes sits on his hands and hopes for the best???? Does Sunderland have a better squad than ours?

Speaking of our squad... Gosling may have potential but at the moment, is nowhere near good enough to be playing at this level. Get him out of the fray Moyes and gives someone else a go. I felt sorry for Saha in the first 45 as he was so isolated, he was almost in another post code. Moyes, wake up to yourself!

Derek Thomas
38   Posted 22/11/2009 at 02:43:39

Report abuse

Today I did something I’ve never done before...fades to flashback.

The game was shown (in NZ) delayed at 6:30am and as a back-up for any heavy Sat Night I recorded it as well. Wise decision.

So at 8:45 with toast and coffee in hand off I went. 20 mins highlights of all the other games. RS devils own luck once more and Hunt and Bullard looked good in another game.

Fast forward ads and promo’s and away we go.

Straight from the KO, back to Howard and...HOOF!... encouraging.

Now to my moment of shame.

So crap, boring and predictable it was watching a, for them, average Untd play 90% in our half, that I, mumbles...speak up.

I FAST FORWARDED IT AND JUST WATCHED THE GOALS.

Step one, Hi my name’s Derek Thomas and I’ve been an Evertonian for 48yrs.

Stephen Graham
39   Posted 22/11/2009 at 04:38:44

Report abuse

’Tis but a scratch!

Oh, had enough, eh?
Tony Hyland
40   Posted 22/11/2009 at 04:40:33

Report abuse

Having watched the game (it was never a match) overnight here in Sydney I just thought back to one of my previous posts about our lack of passion.

I noticed a few incidents in the game namely Ref Bennett giving Fellaini his yellow and then lecturing him about one or two other incidents. It's a pity the ref did not show the same attention to detail when Vidic smashed Heitinga in the head.

In another bit of vision you saw Neill roaring for his defence to push up but to no avail. Then, blow me down, Distin sets off on one of the Blues best runs at Utd but nobody seemed to catch on apart from the short spell after half time. In that spell we did knock it around quite well and perhaps did have no luck but as soon as the second one went in that was it.

What cheeses me off is apart from the teams apparent resignation to it all is the way Moysie seems to go into a bit of a sulk alongside the assistant coach.

One final point about the injury situation is that seemingly straight forward injuries seem to morph into month long and over spells out and I’m not talking Jags or Arteta. Our team need to have a good hard look at themselves or they could be in the mire before it dawns on them.

Rob Lyons
41   Posted 22/11/2009 at 09:21:23

Report abuse

These are the problems I think we face having sat through that rubbish yesterday.

1. We clearly have 5 players out that would improve our current starting 11.

2. Saha is the only class player currently in our team and as soon as he touched the ball 4 Man Utd defenders were on him.

3. This is because we only play 1 up top and invite the defeat on us.

4. The media and commentary is so one sided it's untrue. (Felli elbow, they say definite foul, nasty. Johnny gets smacked, Vidic didn't mean it, it was an accident. What a load of bullocks!)

5. when we got the ball not one player moved off the ball to want a pass, they did it all the time. (That's because we are scared to be in control without Peanuts and Arteta.)
6. Off to my first ever Mersey derby Sunday... should be excited, but I'm scared.

John Sreet
42   Posted 22/11/2009 at 09:30:54

Report abuse

It was obvious to us all that the team was set up in the slim hope that we could drudge it out for a draw. It was embarrassing. Too many passengers and the bus seems driver-less.

I think David Moyes has done really well, but he needs to ask himself a few questions this morning, because no matter how well he has run his race, the only thing we remember is the last lap.

Keith Skidmore
43   Posted 22/11/2009 at 10:17:32

Report abuse

The thing that frustrates me is the lack of tackling in our midfield.  I’d expect a five-man midfield to get in the face of 4, I know we have players left, right and centre (quite literally) playing out of position, but to just shadow men and pass them on across the park is not good enough. 

Far too many times I’ve seen opposition players (not just yesterday) given far too much time and space to run, shoot or look for that killer pass, no other team allows us that luxury... why are we so fecking generous?  At least when playing a 4-4-2 each player knows who his man is and what is expected of him.   

I’ve no doubt that, when the first-choice players come back, a fluidity in our play will "return", confidence levels will rise, but the guys that have been taking to the field of late should not just be "filling-in", they should be playing their socks off to make sure their names are first on that teamsheet and if they don’t feel that they are any better than the next guy, they should still put the effort in. 

Getting back to the original post, a mate of mine, a Forest fan, told me a story about a young Ian Woan growing a beard   and being told by Brian Clough to shave it off and that only men can grow beards. After a MotM performance in Europe, Cloughie pulls Woan to one side and says something like "Son, you can grow a beard now... you’re a man!" — TRUE legend. 

The same mate told me how the last time Forest were in the Prem, the Man Utd away fans started chanting "you’ve never been in Europe!"  I suppose they can be forgiven, as SKY only invented football in the 90s. If you know your history, eh!  

Richard Jones
44   Posted 22/11/2009 at 10:44:29

Report abuse

Still on a different planet from the rest of us I see, Richard, come and join us sometime.
Peter Griffin
45   Posted 22/11/2009 at 11:01:03

Report abuse

"Thank god we shall almost certainly be hearing some great news about our ground move in just a few days time. At least that will lighten the gloom!" - Richard Dodd.

Hopefully it’s a big fat NO! Which will definitely "lighten the gloom"... Yet somehow I doubt that’s what you had in mind.

John Andrews
46   Posted 22/11/2009 at 11:28:35

Report abuse

Dan Gosling. Why ? Yes I know he scored THAT goal against the shite but..........
Amit Vithlani
47   Posted 22/11/2009 at 11:36:46

Report abuse

On tactics today, besides the appalling mess made of the line-up and our approach in the first half, I think Moyes deserves criticism for his second half tactics.

Whilst Gosling was hopeless in the first half, switching to 4-4-2 requires width, so taking him off and leaving 4 defensive midfielders on was a nonsense. Gosling has the engine to get up and down the flanks whereas Fellaini obviously does not.

Putting Fellaini on the left against Rafael worked for about 15 minutes — we had the disallowed goal during this period — but Fergie clocked the plan and subbed Rafael and put Fletcher in that position. Moyes failed to change the plan and we were stung for the 3rd goal down that flank as the big Fella did not have the lungs to get back and help out a totally exposed Leighton Baines.
Brian Waring
48   Posted 22/11/2009 at 14:32:46

Report abuse

Or Kevin, wanted manager, with a pair of balls!!!
Charles King
49   Posted 22/11/2009 at 13:55:09

Report abuse

Saw Moyes's brief comments on TV after the whipping at Merchandiser Utd.

All things considered, he seemed surprisingly chipper. Maybe it was the suit and tie, looked like he was trying to impress, like at a job interview or something... Strange, cos he’s devoted to Everton... isn’t he?

Bernie Boltendorf
50   Posted 22/11/2009 at 15:17:37

Report abuse

Moyes and Kenwright out! I said 6 years ago we would never taste success under Moyes, the man is out of his depth, he has taken this club as far as he can.

He couldn't get promotion for Preston, he won't give us what we want either. If, he had a policy of positive ’attractive’ football (as The Cat used to call it) I could accept we will never attain top four status, but we play negative boring stuff, players playing full of fear and not able to express themselves. To me, the sign of Cahill being well below his best says it all, there is something drastically wrong... Taxi!!!

Ste Boyle
51   Posted 22/11/2009 at 16:45:03

Report abuse

Pathetic... Undefendable... SHITE.

Why did he even bother taking the team to Old Trafford, he had no belief they could win.

I'm so fed up with the dire, dour dross that he’s churning out... Why did he bring Hibbert on with 10 minutes to go??? Why not give one of the kids a run?

Useless, absolutely useless. I don't care who comes in to replace him, they cant possibly be as bad as he is... Turd!

Richard Jones
52   Posted 22/11/2009 at 20:25:43

Report abuse

Sadly I think if Moyes still keeps backing Kenwright and not pointing the figure at where the real blame lies, he’ll fall on his own sword.
Adam McCulloch
53   Posted 22/11/2009 at 09:34:55

Report abuse

Yesterday's game actually saw the odd decent performance from some of the lads (I think Heitinga got stuck in pretty well, though whether he's a midfielder or not is anyone's guess). As has already been said by many posters however, the attitude was defeatist and it has been all season.

I've got to say I'm a big fan of Moyes and what he's done for the club, but I think another summer of strain has done him in and it's creeping into our play. Ok, we've never played our best football under him but there used to be some sense of confidence in the players. Not anymore. The injury situation is obviously a bitter one, but (apparently) good players seem well below-par.

All I'm trying to work out now is what WE can do. I mean, it's all starting to look worrying. We have no money, we have a squad that gets smaller every year, we have an inpotent mentality and a coaching and playing staff that looks like they've all had a dog just die. As for the hapless board and a stadium move that would a) take more money away from aforesaid depleted squad and b) divide a restless fan base - well it's all a bit grim isn't it?

I don't think a Barcode-shite "Sack the Board" protest would get us anywhere, but unless the results start picking up then something's got to give. How much can you change though when there's (supposedly!) no-one interested in investment, no money to bring new players in and probably no better manager to come in.

Oh well, least the RS are cocking up on a similar level, though taking that as a positive I guess shows a sign of the times.

Mac Lloyd
54   Posted 23/11/2009 at 09:41:34

Report abuse

I skimmed the match thread and found this little nugget:

"Yeah the Wigan manager would be a great move and he wouldn't cost much"

I got some stick the other week for saying be careful what you wish for with reference to supposed "die-hards" calling for Moyesy’s head. I think Mr Martinez will be even cheaper now, yeah let’s get him in!!!
Mark Hill
55   Posted 23/11/2009 at 10:33:30

Report abuse

Oh this is ridiculous, Kevin Sparke I think has it just about right. I cannot believe this drivvle that is being written here, talk of knee jerk reactions??! We are missing our three best players (and more), and have been for the best part of probably a season, our main goalscoring threat is coming back from a potential career threatening injury and is still finding his feet.

It has been well documented we have no money and for that it’s Kenwright's fault (he hasn’t got billions to throw at the team, if you want that piss of to Man Citeh and see how great they are!).....we have no proof anywhere that anybody has bid for the club, and no proof of what Bill is actually looking for.

We are a team low on confidence, because of the results, a manager who when he first turned up was considered the Messiah, for the fact that he has saved us from relegation, totally transformed a team that was full of has beens and no marks. A team that had lost it’s soul and lost its way.

A lot of that was due to the way the club was mismanaged by the previous administration, and yes I am fully aware that BK was part of that administration, but stepped in when we were about to go tits up, again he was declared a savoiur practically.

I just think we need to look at the bigger picture here, it seems what ever they (DM / BK) do they can’t win, they have made glaring errors, but show me a club that hasn’t. We just have not got the money to compete at the level the fans crave. It’s ridiculous that we have this I understand peoples need for success, I think we need to look at the ’degree’ of success we have had under Moyes.

He has done a good job in getting the club to where it is, HE is responsible for that, and all us fans are great at criticising when we are playing badly, and not getting points, make no mistakes I am as disappointed as anyone at what is happening, but who would you have Martinez, was one quoted some time ago.... what are peoples opinion now...? There isn’t anyone better able at this time to manage our club.

Mark Hill
56   Posted 23/11/2009 at 11:09:38

Report abuse

And let's not forget another model similar to ours not in the too distant past, Charlton Athletic. They had little money and a manager who would pick up players from the lower leagues establish them as premier league players, some even played for England and they finished high up the league on many occasions. Then the fans spoke, decided they could do better, they appointed someone called Les... and now look where they are: League One... Be careful what you wish for...
Anthony Newell
57   Posted 23/11/2009 at 11:26:09

Report abuse

Sorry, but I couldn’t let this one pass from Dodd: "In our present state we are good enough to stuff the bottom end teams"

What an utter crock of shit, we couldn’t stuff a fucking xmas turkey, never mind beating Wolves & Stoke by a solitary goal.
Phil Bellis
58   Posted 23/11/2009 at 11:48:53

Report abuse

Dodd... you shouldn’t be allowed near a keyboard.
Stupid boy.
Gerard Carey
59   Posted 23/11/2009 at 11:53:08

Report abuse

All we are looking for is a decent 90 mins effort from our team, is it so hard to pass the ball to a team mate? I have followed this team for 42 years. Moyes definitely has to take a lot of the blame.

Wonder what his tactics will be against Hull, Has he the guts to set the team up to play for an away win, and I mean with a bit of style??!! Who am I kidding??!!

Chris Green
60   Posted 23/11/2009 at 15:29:15

Report abuse

I wasnt at the game, but wasn;t surprised by the result. I agree the tactics do baffle.. especially when we start playing 4-5-1 at home... but the one question I would ask is this...

For all of those wanting Moyes out? Who would we get in? No money, no prospect of any money, a new ground proposal no one seems to want and a team struggling for form.... And please, no answer such as "thats the boards job" etc.... who could/would you have in?! Just a question.....
Chris Green
61   Posted 23/11/2009 at 15:29:15

Report abuse

I wasn't at the game, but wasn't surprised by the result. I agree the tactics do baffle... especially when we start playing 4-5-1 at home... but the one question I would ask is this:

For all of those wanting Moyes out? Who would we get in? No money, no prospect of any money, a new ground proposal no one seems to want and a team struggling for form.... And please, no answer such as "That's the Board's job" etc.... who could/would you have in?! Just a question.....
Andy Codling
62   Posted 23/11/2009 at 16:08:51

Report abuse

How about the Benfica manager?
Bryan Douglas
63   Posted 23/11/2009 at 22:44:15

Report abuse

Richard Dodd again affirms he is part of the problem not the solution for Everton FC. I know his mum only lets him use the computer for 30 minutes a day and, as usual, he abuses it!

The problem at Goodison are deep-seated and not easily resolved by changing attitudes and approaches to games. Yes, the Dogs of War approach has some validity but against the totally uncertain backcloth it will not have sustaining impact.

The shake up has to be from the top down because that’s where the major problems are situated. Moyes has always, for 7-8 years, played the same percentages game. He is dour and defensive. His tactics are dour and defensive. His approach appears to be similar to an eight year olds — hope for the best. We do not have a prime tactical analyst in our midst. Moyes has always been a one trick pony. He is now being found out big time. In any other club he would have been sacked by now.

Therein lies the problem. There appears little chance of that happening. Why is that you have to ask? Look at Kenwright and the Board for your answers. They won’t tell you, you have to look for yourselves.

And there’s the potential move to Kirkby. Who stands to gain from all of this? In what way is this in the interests of the Club? To get good things on the field you have to find answers to the overidding problems within the Club. I only want the best for this Club and at the moment no one is stopping the haemorrhaging.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.



© ToffeeWeb