Last summer represented serious squad surgery for Everton, as a wealth of senior names headed for the exit door and nine new faces arrived to replace them. Even given that substantial amount of change, this summer is expected to be another busy period for the club’s deal-makers.
The finances available, and which market Everton are potentially shopping in, may still be determined by this season’s run-in. With six games to go, the Blues are nestled nicely in the European chase, a point behind Chelsea in the Europa League berth, and five from Champions League qualification.
Though there’s plenty of uncertainty, the hope will be that transfer plans are already accelerating. I’ve attempted to rank the summer’s transfer wish-list by priority.
1. Centre-forward
Top of the list should be a goalscorer who can elevate this team up a level. Few teams challenge the status quo without a reliable source of goals, and neither Thierno Barry nor Beto has proven to be that.
Only five teams have scored fewer goals than Everton this season, with four players, including Barry and Beto, tied as the club’s top scorer on six Premier League goals.
The latter’s recent purple patch has been welcomed, but a return of 18 league goals over three seasons paints its own picture. Barry’s promise has been demonstrated only fleetingly, and if the club receives substantial offers for either, there will be a temptation to cash in.
The problem, of course, is unearthing consistent goalscorers. Last summer, 10 centre-forwards were purchased by Premier League clubs for fees of £30M and above. Just three, Joao Pedro, Hugo Ekitike, and Viktor Gyokeres, have reached double figures for Premier League goals, and none have scored more than 14.
2. Right-back
A situation that has become a saga. Right-back has been a problem position that the club has repeatedly failed to address, with a long-term successor to Seamus Coleman still to be found. Nathan Patterson’s future appears to be away from Everton, while Jake O’Brien has been the more common fix.
David Moyes may argue the trade-off between O’Brien’s defensive work and attacking limitations is worthwhile, but there’s no doubt the Blues need a more recognised right-back.
The continuation of the O’Brien experiment could also stunt the Irishman’s development centrally, where he should be viewed as the long-term partner to Jarrad Branthwaite.
3. Right-wing
Regardless of whether Jack Grealish or Tyrique George return permanently, a wide option with a preference for the right should be targeted.
Grealish, George, and Iliman Ndiaye all favour the left, while Tyler Dibling’s debut season has been difficult, with only 343 minutes of Premier League football to his name. The 20-year-old is by no means a write-off, but a failure to earn the manager’s trust means regular football may be found elsewhere before he makes a first-team impression.
A clear upgrade from the right, and an injection of goal-threat and creativity, could take his team up a level. Fulham free agent Harry Wilson has been a name mentioned regularly on these channels in recent months and he would fit the bill.
4. Defensive midfield
This summer appears to be the time to replace Idrissa Gana Gueye. The veteran has continued to perform to a good level, but will turn 37 in September and no longer has the capacity to be an ever-present.
Everton have high hopes for Merlin Rōhl and Harrison Armstrong, though neither is in the Gueye mould.
An out-and-out ball-winner to support James Garner and Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall would give Everton one of the most tenacious engine rooms in the Premier League.
5. Left-back
A transfer focus that could shift in priority once clarity is provided on Vitalli Mykolenko’s future. The Ukrainian’s deal is up in the summer with no public announcement on an extension.
Mykolenko has polarised opinion in the fanbase, but his honest defensive work has earned favour with Moyes, who often prefers a safety-first approach. Rarely seen this season, Adam Aznou could benefit from a loan, so a signing at left-back should be sought, regardless of Mykolenko’s future.
Reader Comments (17)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()
Editorial Team
2 Posted 15/04/2026 at 15:27:08
I like Hackney, but I think a more naturally defensive-minded midfielder should be the priority.
Joao Gomes of Wolves could be a good bet. He's been linked with some big spenders but none seem to be prioritising him. Most tackles won in the Premier League last season, and top again this season. He was second in 2023-24 too. Might be worth an article...
3 Posted 15/04/2026 at 15:36:50
Of course many players will be up for grabs and, as is usua,l the moneybags will get first pick.
We do have some talent but those key positions, striker, right-back and another strong midfielder are the priorities to bring in.
Money is always the key issue and Everton are down the pecking order so it could come down to bargains and loans.
4 Posted 15/04/2026 at 17:43:06
These two positions have been a problem going on three years now. They must be addressed first. We need two wingbacks that can not only defend, but can attack and keep opposing teams on the back foot.
Once those are covered, then we can address the other positions. But I'm firmly in the be position of right back (so O'Brien can move to CB with Branthwaite) and left back with Mikky as a dependable backup.
5 Posted 15/04/2026 at 18:56:06
And a striker and a right back. We'll see what we get in the summer!
6 Posted 15/04/2026 at 20:02:02
I never really got the point of bringing in Beto's thinner twin when you have Dewsbury-Hall and Ndiaye which puts them both to shame on their versatility.
Whoever Moyes brings in, I hope it's someone willing to shoot from anywhere and has that sixth sense to get on the end of crosses. Mykolenko and McNeil have their moments but both are so limited by ability that it's hard to see them staying on. Not fast enough and neither can use both feet.
Stones makes no sense to me. But I would be enquiring about a loan for Foden having secured a lower fee for Grealish.
7 Posted 15/04/2026 at 21:19:41
Harrison Armstrong has come back as a proven squad player with the potential to be a big part of the squad next season.
Do we have any others ripping it up away from the club who are likely to be pressing for a place before we fork out the big bucks?
I am assuming that the Number 6 role cover for Gana Gueye is already here in the form of Rohl, Iroegbunam or Dewsbury-Hall.
Whether Ndiyaye or Grealish can be converted to a Number 10 role to accommodate another speedy winger, I don't know. But these questions will all be being looked at by the management before they spend our still limited budget.
The only certainty is that, whether they are on the books already, or we need to bring in fresh faces, the squad next season will need to look a little different if we are to compete both domestically and in Europe.
8 Posted 16/04/2026 at 01:37:00
Pickford
Kyle Walker O'Brien Branthwaite Mykolenko
Garner Dewsbury-Hall
Ndiaye Foden Grealish
Beto
9 Posted 16/04/2026 at 09:38:53
Having seen the likes of PSG rip Liverpool apart -- not to mention the highlights from Bayern, Atletico and the rest -- we will do well to consolidate our position towards the top of the Premier League.
10 Posted 16/04/2026 at 13:49:09
A new centre forward, yes, it could be good if Beto is willing to be a back-up, and loaning out Barry.
Gana has been underrated at times, we need someone in that mould -- I've been having high hopes for Iroegbunam, as long as he steps up his quick decision-making.
We don't have proper cover for the left-back position -- if we get a good one, and we tie Mykolenko down, is he willing to play as a back-up?
It's hard to fix everything at once, so big job ahead!
11 Posted 16/04/2026 at 16:57:52
Tyler Onyango and Roman Dixon have had disasters on loan at Stockport. Onyango suffered a season-ending injury in February, and Dixon has barely appeared, although in a hopeful sign, he started and went the full 90 yesterday for the first time in a huge win at Wimbledon.
And Martin Sherif has 3 goals in 18 combined appearances in League 1 (Rotherham and Port Vale, both facing relegation).
No likely contributors unless one of the young keepers makes the roster as a backup.
12 Posted 17/04/2026 at 13:11:32
That said, a striker who knows where the net is and is unafraid to put the ball in the back of the net HAS to the the uttermost priority. Without that we're a sitting duck.
Right back is absolutely 2nd priority. Players have been used out of position for too long and they need to be played to their strengths.
Aside from those two positions and league placings dependent, I'm not overly concerned. Mykolenko has done ok. He's not a world beater but he does the job. If he stays the available budget can be used elsewhere. Replacing Gueye has to be a consideration either this window or next summer.
13 Posted 17/04/2026 at 18:13:19
I don't see him going to utd, lpool, Chelsea or arsenal.
Villa could be an option, but think if he stays there another year, posts similar numbers he'll be out our reach.
60m ???
Wilson I'd love but think with him being free he's going to have his pick of any team he fancies.
Kayode for right back would be my pick.
Add a Couple of bargains from spurs when they go down and we could be transformed for 100m
We added a few young developing players last year, we need ready to go starters now !
14 Posted 17/04/2026 at 19:25:34
Despite nasty half-witted racial slurs and clownish lies. I have been championing JOB for weeks on this very website. "The best right back at the club" I called him on last weeks live forum. 2-3 agreed.
Not a natural rightback. He has become more and more accomplished as the season has gone on. If there is a better, affordable, right back out there. I havent seen him. I don't think Moyes has either.
The right back slot may be the favourite hobby horse, but credit to the lad. he has ensured our needs are greater in other areas.
I think JOB will be our right back as long as Moyes is here.
15 Posted 17/04/2026 at 19:34:45
16 Posted 17/04/2026 at 20:37:24
He's done a great job at right-back. However, on the ball, going foward, he lacks ability. Just because he's the best man for the job at the moment doesn't mean he's good enough if we want to progress.
I honestly think upgrades at both left-back and right-back would offer us a different dimension. Both our wide front players are what I'd call inside wide men (right foot on the left, left foot on right). With fullbacks that could get to the byline overlapping to cross the ball, we could be so much better.
17 Posted 17/04/2026 at 21:36:58
Nico O'reilly is a midfield player.
Mattheus Nunes was a central midfielder
Calafori a centre half.
Ben White is a centre half.
Garner & Szoboszlai have been played right back
Obrien is a centre half
Nobody wants to be a Gary Neville. And that is leaving a dearth of full backs & centre forwards for that matter. Kids are all trained as midfielders these days, with the weakest moved to full back. Barton has that right.
Traditional right backs like Patterson and Calvin Ramsey have failed to make there way. Perhaps that's been the case for an age, ivanovic and Carragher being centre halves that performed at full back.
I do think we need two different options at full back. The problem isn't that Mykolenko and Obrien cant do a job, they can. The problem is they only can play one way. And if youre chasing the game, needing to be on the front foot, theyre like tits on a bull.
Ive seen bits of Bueno at Wolves, and I've liked him, he's proved me wrong. I remember him at Goodison as a light weight foreigner when they had Aït-Nour. He looked like a cheap journey man. But he isn't. He looks more of a footballer than Mykolenko.
At right back I agree the options look limited.
I like Munoz, James and Liveramento, but it is clear they'd never come. Josh Acheampong, Rico Lewis, Doue Strasbourg and Norton Cuffy are more likely options but they all present risk.
There are several Premier league clubs looking for decent right backs, and we are unfortunately not the first option. But we do need to sign a replacement for Coleman, and someone that will ensure that the left back slot is the best we can fill.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
How to get rid of these ads and support TW
-sm.jpg)
-sm.jpg)
1 Posted 15/04/2026 at 15:17:46
Beto should definitely be kept for his physicality, work ethic and the fact he can score even not being presented with a glut of chances. I am sure we have scouted many potential candidates, it's a matter of if there is another Thiago out there... perhaps we should follow Brentford scouts about as they always seem to scout well in this area.
The right-back saga will be interesting as of links with Rico Lewis, a right-back who can play holding midfield and replace Gueye there... ?
Harry Wilson could be a good fit on the right, also the type of deal Moyes would like being a free and releasing funds to but spent elsewhere on the like of keeping Grealish and George.
Defensive midfield, if we bring a player in then who will get shipped out? Tim Iroegbunam? Rohl has only just been brought in. There is no doubt Moyes likes a big unit in there as a strong presence.
I think the Manager may dip into the Championship for Hackney "if" Boro are willing to sell, and if they get promotion, which would make things a lot harder.
Left-back, I think Moyes will keep Mykolenko, he is a good full-back, solid if unspectacular.