Recent Reader Comments

• Too right Conor, UTFT! I am still buzzing about that result. Glad KDH impressed you in a deeper role. It was easily his most complete game in an Everton shirt. That said, I think the manager will play Garner and Tim Iro in the central midfield against Newcastle. James Garner was brilliant and we cannot afford to switch him to cover right back, despite how well he played there. Pickford is the best keeper in the Premier League, bar none....
  Steve Brown in Red mist for Gana but Dewsbury-Hall gives Everton something to defend
• I’ve wanted to slap Keane a few times myself over the years, but not for a while in fairness. He’s having a stellar season thus far. Gana, stupid, why the slap… but a common sense yellow should have been the outcome. This will test our midfield over the next few months. A great team performance, lots of pluses and unfair really to single anybody out, but a special mention to the much maligned Barry, who worked tirelessly, won lots of duels, had some nice touches. Room for improvement, absolutely, but step in the right direction, you bet. ...
  Ian Wilkins in Red mist for Gana but Dewsbury-Hall gives Everton something to defend
• Jimmy I think it says a lot about yourself that after every victory you seek out somebody to have a pop at. Long may they continue to be aimed at me because if they are we are going to do some damage in the league this season. Indeed you would think that Steve who I was debating with would have the chip but I'd say he's more delighted just to enjoy the victory. Yes you are right Jimmy that was the first time he stood up and be counted in a tough game and doing so in a number eight position. What impressed me was his game intelligence, that he kept trying to make sure we didn't get exposed in that second half by helping Mykolenko when possible. I also liked how disciplined he was, that he had fire in his belly and that he produced a constant performance and didn't go missing at any stage. Where I can't agree with you he was anywhere near man of the match however being the match winner often predetermines this. I thought he was clearly motm against Fulham where he had a better...
  Conor McCourt in Red mist for Gana but Dewsbury-Hall gives Everton something to defend
• Keane had a blinder after the slap so maybe it could be a regular thing!...
  Tony Hughes in The aftermath of the Idrissa Gana Gueye-Michael Keane incident
• Watched the game on holiday with no sound as the bar kept playing music...great performance from the 10 men and what a goal not just the shot but the build up, we even stretched them with 10 men and looked like we could have scored another, as for united they huffed and puffed with their possession it pans out that way sometimes. I know Pickford made saves but the real save was superb from Zeeksees header. The sending off was a joke...a common sense approach is needed...again we are the guinea pigs where ever discretion is required...
  Merle Urquart in Red mist for Gana but Dewsbury-Hall gives Everton something to defend
• Gary (5) Maybe Tarkowski would have given Keane more than a slap if he had got there first!...
  Dave Abrahams in The aftermath of the Idrissa Gana Gueye-Michael Keane incident