Recent Reader Comments

• Utter shite from S C. What\'s he want to be, the new Leon Osman? Say something controversial Seamus. Swings and roundabouts. If this happens we will be relegated, if we hadn\'t have signed him we would go down. If Tarks hadn\'t have done that we would be in Europe. Praise the club that gave you a luxury living, also. If you had done your job of defending properly we wouldn\'t have been in that position....
  Paul Kossoff in Coleman says Everton 'would be in the Championship' without Jordan Pickford's performances in recent seasons
• Caution. You aren't buying the 25-year-old Icardi, you are buying a player that didn\'t score in Europe last season from 10 games, and where most goals came against Turkish league fodder.rnrnFor me, a firm No. ...
  Ian Bennett in Mauro Icardi — Striker Solution or Toxic Distraction?
• There are so many negatives around Icardi, it would be a No for me.rnrnAs others have said, we already have options for emergency cover in Alcaraz, Dibling, Johnson and George not to mention youth players like Braiden Graham who are all better suited to the demands of the Premier League than an egotistical prima donna who hasn't trained for months and has never played in the Premier League.Keep your powder dry, Everton, and spend time and money lining up a quality replacement for Barry in January....
  Jay Harris in Mauro Icardi — Striker Solution or Toxic Distraction?
• Steve Round covered that he tipped Moyes off 2 years ago, and reckons the player will have been seen 30 times by Moyes and his staff.rnrnIf it was me, I'd start Garner right-back tomorrow, Rohl right wing, and a midfield two of Armstrong and Hackney. We've been a soft touch away at Spurs for too long down the decades.rnrnSpurs will be targeting Tarkowski and Rohl, so I'd turn it on its head. Rohl has the pace to be quicker than Robertson, leaving a fresh Grealish and Johnson to win the game from the bench.rnrnI don't think Maitland-Niles is ready to start a game away from home. And I'd like to get Hackney, Armstrong and Garner into the team without losing Dewsbury-Hall.rnrnA nice point on the George goal last week, was Armstrong took Shaw out by being that far forward. Shaw had a difficult choice, in that whoever he didn\'t pick up could score....
  Ian Bennett in Holding Hayden Hackney back could be a masterstroke for Everton
• The most successful striker Moyes signed first time round wasn\'t known for his defensive contributions. ...
  Geoff Cadman in Mauro Icardi — Striker Solution or Toxic Distraction?
• The lad has talent and could be a real jewel in the crown for Everton this season. He seems like a leader in the Alan Ball mould and his short stint against Man Utd showed so much to admire.Only time will tell, so let\'s hope there are big rewards for the team this season and beyond with his inclusion....
  Tom Bowers in Holding Hayden Hackney back could be a masterstroke for Everton