Everton v Liverpool: Player Ratings

Michael Kenrick
19/04/2026
(Photo by Molly Darlington/Getty Images)

Well, after failing to beat the Red Bastards, I’ve marked them all down a point from what I was going to give them. No Man of the Match because that was a glorious opportunity to beat them spurned yet again.

Jordan Pickford – 6

Stupidly booked early on but made some key saves, yet marked down for letting them score twice. 

Jake O’Brien – 7

Solid defending and did well a couple of times getting forward. 

James Tarkowski – 6

Key clearance off the line but marked down for not stopping Van Dijk’s header.

Jarrad Branthwaite – 7

Brilliant positioning but it could be a massive hit with his hamstring after clearly being fouled by Graebberch — not given.

Vitalii Mykolenko – 6

Well involved but his crossing is just not accurate enough.

Idrissa Gana Gueye – 7 

His interventions are just brilliant — and he didn’t do any of his daft shots

James Garner – 7

Well involved: Garner was Garner

Dwight McNeil – 5

Clever touches but he’s just not strong enough, and failed to shoot on target 

Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall – 7

Showed great desire and anticipation but the ball doesn’t quite stick to him as it should.

Iliman Ndiaye – 7

Such great feet, and a good goal, but otherwise, he did not deliver enough end-product, and that’s my biggest beef with him.

Beto – 8

He scored and he worked very hard… but his miss when clean through was horrific. 

Substitutes:

Thierno Barry – 3

Ran about after he came on but did not affect the play.

Tyrique George – 3 

Given 10 minutes plus stoppage time to make an impact. Did nothing bar trap the ball nicely with his first touch.

Michael Keane – 5

Late sub, perhaps should have done more at that last corner?


© ToffeeWeb