Soccernet
 

Everton succeed[pl] against all the odds
Jen Chang ESPN, 27 December 2004

 

[A lesson in American corruption of the English language, especially collective nouns.
Bold highlights inconsistent number (singular[sl] or plural[pl]) in the same sentence!]

It must be something in the water, Penta mineral water in fact.  What else could explain Everton's surprising run this season.  Apparently the unfashionable English Premiership team is[sl] taking a page out of Hollywood's books and drinking the trendy designer water.  The water from the Colorodo River is apparently absorbed quicker by the body than other fluids.  In theory it allows athletes to hydrate more effectively without feeling bloated.  Well, at least that's what Penta say[pl].  In lieu of other more plausible reasons for the Everton's stunning rise, it might well be the secret source of the team's inspiration.

Despite a rather uninspiring draw last weekend against a mediocre Blackburn team, Everton continue[pl] to be the surprise of the season in England.  The Merseyside team is[sl] comprised of essentially what is[sl] a no-name squad[sl], yet have[pl] maintained a top three position for most of the year.

The most shocking thing about Everton's success is the fact that it comes after the forced sale of want-away teenage talisman striker Wayne Rooney to Manchester United.  Usually when a "lower-tier" Premiership team[sl] sells its most potent forward, the end result is that the team can expect to battle relegation for the foreseeable future.

In this case, however, Everton has[sl] shocked all observers and is probably the neutrals' choice for the Premiership.  What's even more amazing is that the club has[sl] yet to spend any of the $35 million they[pl] received in the Rooney windfall.

A glance at the Everton lineup will leave most fans wondering just how this team is[sl] keeping pace with the likes of Chelsea and Arsenal.  The only immediately recognizable names are the goalkeeper Nigel Martyn and the midfield lynchpin Thomas Gravesen.  The forwards[pl] often consist of a converted midfielder, Tim Cahill, and journeyman Marcus Bent, and probably represents[sl] one of the least threatening strikeforces in the EPL.

In addition, Everton[sl] only has one youngster that might be coveted by other Premiership teams, James McFadden, whom ex-Scotland manager Berti Vogts called a better player than Rooney (a stretch to say the least).  As for playing style, Everton is[sl] memorable only for being superbly organized in defense.  On offense, the team's approach play is not the most attractive that fans could hope to see.

So what's the reason for Everton's success?  One key has been its[sl] remarkable defensive improvement.  The team plays[sl] a rigid and conservative 4-5-1 alignment which stifles opposition creativity.  The other reason is the resurgence of supposedly has-been goalkeeper Nigel Martyn, at one time considered among the best goalkeepers in England.  Martyn had been languishing on the Leeds bench the past couple of seasons but was rescued from purgatory by Everton.  The team has[sl] benefited from his return to form and replacement of the often error-prone Richard Wright.

Of greater significance, however, is Everton's team ethic which boils down to three things: commitment, energy and tenacity.  These are three simple qualities that are actually rarely found in today's game.  Everton is[sl] proving that a group[sl] of workmanlike players[pl] committed to a team ethic can overcome more technically gifted skill and flair teams.  In this respect, the team is[sl] following in the footsteps of Greece in the 2004 European Championships and Korea in the 2002 World Cup.  Both those teams showed that superior fitness and a willingess to chase and harass their more gifted opponents could compensate and even triumph over any deficit in skill.

It also helps that Everton are[pl] playing way above expectations and isn't[sl] hindered by the pressure heaped onto other title contenders.  As manager David Moyes noted recently to reporters, "We are playing with a lot of freedom, there is very little pressure on us and I am going to try to keep the players as relaxed as I can."

It's doubtful that the team can continue such a run over the long haul without Moyes bringing in a top-notch striker from the transfer market.  Rumor has it that Moyes has targeted Southampton's James Beattie for his cause.  However, for this season at least, a finish in the top four and Champions League qualification is certainly a possibility.  That in itself would be a remarkable turnaround for a team that, only last season, was wallowing in the depths of the Premiership.

The tally:

  • Everton: Singular 2; Plural 3

  • Team: Singular 7; Plural 0

  • Forwards: Singular: 1 Plural 1 (in the same sentence!)

It is a source of continuing amazement to me how the Yanks persistently fail to even notice how badly wrong they get this.  Is basic English really that difficult?  They will always say "Everton is..." rather than (as we Brits say "Everton are..." and yet, as this example shows, they are grossly inconsistent beyond that.

Perhaps you can argue that Everton: the Club is indeed a singular entity, whereas Everton: the players are clearly plural.  However, the main difference is that British usage considers a corporate group as plural,mwhereas the Yanks think it is singular.