FAN ARTICLES
Cannon Fodder Fans
No matter what we say, we're off to Kirkby because that's what the club wants. We fans, well, screw us. It's just our job to pay and turn up every week ? hey, we're the People's Club after all. No plan B, well doesn't that say it all. The club consistently tell us bugger all, and when they do it's that we really don't have a choice! (By the way, I've nothing against Kirkby before anybody gets the hump ? we were the first and biggest club in the city, so why should we move?)
We have a Chairman who is patently incapable of moving the club forward and a Chief Executive who, let's face it, has no real feel for things Everton, it's just his job. You may argue that's not a bad thing because emotion has no place in business, however where football is concerned the whole thing trades on people's emotions. If it didn't then we wouldn't settle for the shite we've had to put up with over the last few years, both on the field and off.
As for the Chairman, well, was it not on his watch that we lost the golden opportunity of the Kings Dock, a new Everton stadium on one of the world's most famous (and photographed) waterfronts?
And as for Rooney and Fortress Sports, well let's not even go there. Great Evertonian, yes, blah blah blah, but then again aren't we all? Delivered us from Agent Johnson, yes thanks, but let's remember that he was also on the board at the time. I've nothing personal against Bill Kenwright but you've got to call his leadership into question, to put it mildly.
You'd think that with Bill's feeling for the club and Keith Wyness' business skills then you'd have a perfect combination running the club. But how wrong you would be. Oh, and Robert Elstone's American savvy too ? nearly forgotten about Rocky's mate and what he's brought to the party!
And now they are telling us that the only deal in town in in Kirkby and that we really have no option but to move out of the city. And we will go, they'll see to that. So give it 10 years ? if that ? down the line and more and more kids in the city will drift towards the red shite because they'll find it easier to identify with them as the 'city' team.
Like most of us, I have to accept that the Old Lady's shelf life is coming to an end, but I don't believe that it's unfeasible to stay within the city boundaries. If the club say it's too expensive then let them tell us why we can't afford it and where the money has gone, because we all know that it ain't going on players.
One of the ironies of this whole situation is that we're told that the new ground won't cost us much so that will leave more money to strenghthen the squad. Really? Well, Goodison costs us fuck all right now so why are we shopping in the bargain basement again?
It's hard to get away from the idea that those running the club cling to the view that once we move for as little cost as possible then we become an attractive proposition for a big bucks investor and they walk away with a big wedge apiece. But the fans who really keep this great club going ? well, what do we matter, we're just cannon fodder. If you want to go down in history as the guys who shut down Goodison Park then you should be 100% certain that you're taking us to a place fit for a club with the greatest tradition in the English game.
Christ, no plan B ? and plan A is just a crock of shit.
Reader Comments (52)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 18/07/2007 at 04:31:35
And after a quick Google search interestingly both named MPs were reportedly vociferous in 2002 when EFC applied for EU money set aside to alleviate poverty to help fund the failed Kings Dock project. All after our media savvy Chairman Mr Kenwright made an undisclosed donation to the Labour party, maybe he?s getting some free ?spin? lessons from Alaister Campbell??????????Agent Kenwright anyone?
3 Posted 18/07/2007 at 08:28:08
To be fair to Wyness though Kevin Latham says goodison costs nothing so why havent we got £10 million each year to spend? EAsy answer is that the new stadium with corporate and non matchday activity will supply the extra revenue.
The info that I need is what will the stadium look like? I dont want FC Kolns stadium, it looks crap. Wyness said that fans dont like the bowl type stadium. What fans and when? it was good enough for the Kingsdock and everyone agreed that was great! I think that the 4 sided stadium is cheaper to build and my suspicion is that it is a meccano build. We are likely to be offered a second best solution which will be dressed up and spun.
If I am wrong and the stadium design is ’world class’ then I will have to think very hard - putting my emotion to one side - as i cant see another alternative coming our way. Remember Everton couldnt come up with the £35m to put a deposit on the Kingsdock let alone fund a stadium on its own!
I look forward to Wyness and Kenwright presenting their stadium plans as that is the crux of this deal for me, as well as whether there really will be ’state of the art’ transport links as this will be crucial to long term sustainability. Over to you Bully.
4 Posted 18/07/2007 at 09:18:06
There’s no plan B says Mr. Chief Executive. Just like that. No plan B. It’s not our fault, there simply isn’t one.
Well, why aren’t there any other plans, ffs? Because you agreed to a stupid exclusivity deal, that’s why. And Mr. Chief Executive keeps blabbering away on the official site without mentioning this small yet important detail, that he himself was the one who had set fire to the bridges.
Sadly I’m not in a position to vote so this isn’t about should we go or not. But I hate being treated like an idiot.
5 Posted 18/07/2007 at 09:19:00
6 Posted 18/07/2007 at 09:24:44
7 Posted 18/07/2007 at 10:05:11
What do you think Goodison Park will become when we’re in Kirkby?
8 Posted 18/07/2007 at 10:33:44
everton is forever, not a stadium.
9 Posted 18/07/2007 at 10:40:18
Get real guys the vote is only being held to appease the fans and won?t be taken note of at all and whose to say what the for and against figures will be when the vote does take place. Again these probably will be issued by the Club and can be changed to their advantage.
I really am getting very disillusioned with everything and I am usually one of the ones who say "Oh ye of little faith".
10 Posted 18/07/2007 at 10:45:35
"Deal of the century"??? - a stadium in a cheap area with a long-held dodgy reputation that is miles away from the city centre, causing travel headaches for all. I happen to shop in Tesco but the purist in me says a supermarket should not be part of our stadium.
The Kings Dock miss makes me so frustrated it makes me feel sick
"Nil satis nisi optimum" - never has our motto looked so hollow. Thank you Bill and keith
11 Posted 18/07/2007 at 10:30:20
Emotionally I do not want to move from our family home at Goodison or re-locate outside our city boundaries. I sense we will forever miss the history, the emotion and personal attachment we all have for that part of Walton that is Goodison Park; but we can not survive in this new football era without dramatic change.
My brain tells me that to stay at Goodison will eventually destroy the club as our failure to compete both on the pitch and financially will generate an inevitable spiralling decline on a par with clubs such as Sheffield Wednesday and Nottingham Forest.
The chance of a move to a 55,000 new stadium for a relatively small financial outlay may well be our saviour. Let?s remember that our current financial plight meant that we could not afford our contribution of £35m to Kings Dock so the prospect of a new stadium for an initial outlay of £10m plus refurbishment costs is very attractive.
I am encouraged by the potential ground design on offer; hopefully not for us the boring Lego bowl shaped stadiums like the Riverside or Reebok but more a proper traditional 4-sided football stadium with character and a resonance based on Everton history. We should appoint a fan-based co-ordination committee to oversee the refurbishment to ensure that our Everton history is embedded in the new stadium.
Finally, I like so many will forever miss the terraced-housed streets, smells and banter of yester-year around Goodison Park but the future for Evertonians will not be for just me and you in 2007 but for our children and grandchildren who are the Evertonians of the future. Remember as residents in the city of Liverpool we have moved-on from our docklands heritage and seen it replaced by a vibrant city who?s economic stability is not based on one industry locked in history but the new economy of the 21st century. We as Evertonians now need to face the future full-on as well.
So, please let?s look to that exciting future, get involved in defining the external stadium design, the internal facilities and refurbishment and ambiance of our potential new ground and move-on. Everton have successfully moved once before, if my history serves me correctly, and we made a success of that so let?s do it again.
12 Posted 18/07/2007 at 11:35:55
13 Posted 18/07/2007 at 12:09:10
I have spent 35 years watching my beloved team at Goodison park and I am still not 40 so nearly my whole life. But I have watched the ground decay for years now. I love my walk through the terraced streets on my way to the ground but come on its not that nice !! I know I would hate making that same walk in 3 years time with the monstrosity of a stadium that will grow in the park. We will be a laughing stock.
I want to see us build a new home , build a future that will see my one year old son love to embrace as his own and provide a club that his children will want to follow. we cant do that at Goodison. And to be fair, Liverpool City Council have left it very late in the day to work with us positively in locating suitable sites in our fair city. They have had 8 years to do that and even now they are not coming up with a deal any where near as favourable. So lets vote and go with a heavy heart but with optimism for our future a ’New Dawn’ for the Club we love..
14 Posted 18/07/2007 at 12:05:23
I don’t believe that by changing the stadium and it’s infrastructure the Everton Board will suddenly work out how to treat it’s ’customers’ (God I hate calling myself a customer.. but bare with me, I have to use their terminology to make this point) and maximise their matchday revenue. I, like most Evertonians I know try to spend every penny on a matchday at Everton so that they can maximise the amount of money they get from me, but I have lost count of the number of times I’ve queued up at half time for 15 minutes and seen 3 people in front of me get served. It’s so bad that I now don’t even bother going to queue up. For God’s sake we have the guy who runs Tesco assisting the board and yet we can’t serve more than one customer every 5 minutes during the peak half time window! Give me a break. Why will this change if we move to another stadium? Will the staff suddenly become competant? Will they suddenly be trained and managed properly? Will they suddenly become helpful? If so, why can’t you do this at Goodison now?
I think the above example clearly shows that the Everton board have not done anything to Maximise the revenue that can be generated at Goodison on a matchday, if every fan spent just £5 in Goodison buying food and drink this would generate £200,000 per match! or around £4,000,000 a season! I desperately want to spend my money at Goodison and if I could buy descent food and drink there I would and if I knew I could get served at half time I’d by more drinks (Especially as my son is always asking for drinks at half time and I have to say ... wait till were on the way home son, I’ll never get served here!).
The Toffee Shop is the same, if you get there after 2:30 you can’t get in. So why don’t they create some satellite shops around the ground and increase turnover? I simply do not trust this board because of the all too many examples of how they actually can’t run a company profitably. Didn’t we outsource the Toffee Shop because we actually lost money running it? How is this possible?
If we move to a new Stadium I’m not expecting anything to change because the board have already shown me over the last 5 years that they can’t run a business profitably and efficiently, despite having a captive and dedicated customer base for 2 or 3 hours every second week totalling around 40,000 each time.
15 Posted 18/07/2007 at 12:40:39
The old lady has served us well but the ground is very poor in comparison with many other smaller clubs.
The sad message at the moment is that Bill K or Wyness do not have the ability (or desire?) to attract any investment to enable a new ground to be built in the city.
There is no point in having the ballot - The deal is done and we will be going to Tesco Stadium in Kirby from August 2010!!!
16 Posted 18/07/2007 at 13:11:43
17 Posted 18/07/2007 at 12:37:16
I can?t remember a start to a season when I was so dispirited; the reason why we have not spent any money on players is that money is being saved up for the new stadium?
(Thought there was no cost!) The UEFA cup campaign looms and we have no new arrivals to bolster an already thin squad. Somehow it is assumed that all those that vote against the move (and the tens/hundreds of thousands that are not allowed to) will simply turn up at the Tescodrome with the same enthusiasm to follow Everton. (will we have a name change? After all does the name matter anymore if we play in Knowsley?) Although many will turn up, I fear many will not. The people who say there is no option will probably say this does not matter, as a shiny corporate supporter will emerge along with new supporters who are handy for the M57 and fancy coming to watch a premiership match. I?m sorry but Everton, as we have known it will cease to be and that?s something I don?t want to witness. The People?s club moniker sounds like a hollow, sick joke, as does the club motto. It?s time for some open, vocal and forceful dissent from the fans. If we want to make a difference we need to let the players and management know what we think, not via a nice quiet vote, that wont be listened to but by a bit of raucous rebellion at the start and end of matches. I am not advocating barracking the players in any way, but what other forum do we have to make our voices heard?
18 Posted 18/07/2007 at 12:31:08
The failer by the board to find any other investment (apart from the tesco offer of ’we’re building a supermarket in Kirkby if you wanna join us’) has left us in this position.
So what do we do? The Kirkby ’choice’ makes good financial sense but i can’t help but feel this will only help in the short term, as to anyone around the world we will eventually be seen as another Tranmere. On the other hand we simply can’t afford what we really want, an innovative 21st century stadium close to stanley park.
My ideal senario would be a state of the art Stadium accross the raod to Goodison in Stanley park, totally different to LFC stadium but just as impressive( if slightly smaller). we could share parking and transport links (as we do now, they can even build a bloody tescos on Goodison if they want! sorry, back to earth now, anyway that would be a ’plan B’, now that is stupid.
When all this is dragged out for the next year or so we’ll still be rail roaded in Kirkby whatever your feelings.
To me it’s gonna be like buying a half price suit from Tesco’s for a tenner. Yeah i got the ’bargain of life time’ but i’m gonna feel like a dick next to me mates.
i think its time we took our motto of our badge.
19 Posted 18/07/2007 at 13:13:20
Let us look at what has been going on.
A deal of exclusivity, this is formed to keep other interested parties at bay. In buisness this would normally cost a substantial sum of money.
Kenwright has also said he does not want to be the chairman who moves Everton out of Goodison Park.
Do they have buyers lined up ?
Look at the near past for some clues.
North West Devolopment Agency pushing for ground share. Was this a clue to say only one stadium in the city was to have grants. We missed the boat, remember the Kings Dock.
If a buisness worth £90 to £100 million pounds had no other plans the cheif executive should resign.
Look at the figures being bandied about. £75 million for a stadium with a further £10 million set aside to fubish it. On that basis both L/Pool and Arsenal are being ripped off to the tune of £115 million.
Wyness quotes, a worthless piece of land in Kirkby would cost us £50 million pounds to buy elsewere.
Too me, the pair leading our club are being very un-economic with the truth. I urge all voting Evertonians not to be taken in by this consortium and lt us see what lays in wait.
20 Posted 18/07/2007 at 13:13:43
I’ll agree that this ballot is simply to appease the fans, in an ideal world I wouldent have held one at all. There is one clear option in moving to Kirkby and I hope that even if the voters deide against that BK and KW will do whats right anyway. These are the people qualified to make such decisions.
Dont get me wrong, I love Goodison. What you need to remeber is that the younger generation do not have the great memories of European and domestic glory that some do of Goodison, just a few decent derby’s and the odd Man U match to savour.
21 Posted 18/07/2007 at 13:27:25
22 Posted 18/07/2007 at 14:24:18
23 Posted 18/07/2007 at 14:52:48
24 Posted 18/07/2007 at 15:46:27
25 Posted 18/07/2007 at 15:33:08
Goodison Park has been a grand stage for some great football matches and has seen great team and players, but sadly we have to move on. Goodison Park is looking a bit tired, very tired in fact.
It will be a wrench, but after a few games, or seasons, we will all wonder why we took so long over the decsion.Lets make the move, and do it quickly.
26 Posted 18/07/2007 at 16:20:47
27 Posted 18/07/2007 at 16:39:47
28 Posted 18/07/2007 at 16:45:39
Someone else just stated, ?no matter where we play, we will always be Everton?, and I have to disagree.. if we lose even half of the scouse hardcore of fans to Liverpool over the years, then that will have a big effect on the atmosphere which is (generally) generated by the true fans, not a load of prawn-butty corporate sightseers, and then what we are heading for is a half-empty supermarket stadium in the middle of nowhere. Oh yeah, why on earth would these corporations take customers to a Kirkby supermarket when there is a nice (world famous!) anfield closer to town?? Why would anyone in their right mind want to stage gigs or events there when there is a larger capacity stadium (world famous!) CLOSER TO TOWN. Do us a favour and don?t repeat the hype bullshit Wyness is spouting please.
If fans like D say they would go to a lot more games if there was ?better facilities? they are just bullshitting ?TV watching? fans who like the idea of supporting everton, and maybe buy a shirt now and again, but I will bet you will be no more willing to turn up every week and support the team vocally.
What is so wrong with Goodison for a few more years anyway, jeesus we only have to spend an hour a week there - anyone would think we have to live there the way some people go on...bring your kid a bottle of coke in with you if you cant be arsed queueing, and like someone else said if the toilets and bar are not run properly at GP, what makes you think it will be so much better in Kirkby?
I think the whole thing is a fucking disgrace, we are being pushed into this and I will never forgive those who spell out the sad ruin of OUR GREAT CLUB. However, we still have a chance to protest, lets make some noise against this at the Wigan game.
COYB!
29 Posted 18/07/2007 at 17:21:48
30 Posted 18/07/2007 at 17:09:36
31 Posted 18/07/2007 at 17:20:12
32 Posted 18/07/2007 at 17:23:58
"If the club say it’s too expensive then let them tell us why we can’t afford it and where the money has gone, because we all know that it ain’t going on players"
Remember when we sold Rooney? Turned out we were in debt to the tune of £40m. We can’t afford it because land and the surrounding infrastructure alone costs shitloads of cash and neither we nor the city council can pay for it. The money has gone to pay off the debt and the accumulated interest on the debt. I’m not sure it’s true to say we haven’t spent it on players. We have broke our transfer record twice which is remarkable for a club as skint as ours.
As for the move, I think deal of the century isn’t far off IF what we read and hear is true. I always presumed part of the deal would be that the Goodison Park site would be sold to Tesco in time for the new Anfield opening. That is something I’d like to see cleared up by Mr Wyness. However, I don’t think we should just say no just because our stadium is on the other side of the road or for any reason connected to Liverpool FC (a la surrendering the city). We need to get over this tribal bullshit. They are playing on a world level and we mean very little to them. It’s about time we at least got onto the European level. Scouse pies and Chang on tap ain’t going to get us there for a while, nice as they may be.
33 Posted 18/07/2007 at 18:49:31
34 Posted 18/07/2007 at 18:59:51
35 Posted 18/07/2007 at 19:19:03
36 Posted 18/07/2007 at 19:19:03
37 Posted 18/07/2007 at 21:23:43
38 Posted 19/07/2007 at 09:08:56
Railroaded by Billy Bullshitter and Dick Turpin Wyness and the gullible swallow it up like its all truth.
39 Posted 19/07/2007 at 09:42:29
Oh and to clarify one thing Kirkby is closer for me to get to but I still don’t fancy it.
40 Posted 19/07/2007 at 10:22:38
A cost of a little over a £1,000 per seat is ludicrously low when you compare it with the £3,000 per seat at the Emirates or even what the reds are talking about paying.
I also don’t buy the "we’ll get our builders to build a £75 million project for £50 million" What kind of contractor has that amount of money to throw away in a business where margins are so tight?
If things pan out the way they’re being talked about we’ll have a sub-Reebok box with every corner being cut and the club will become a laughing stock.
Makes me so mad!
41 Posted 19/07/2007 at 10:14:15
42 Posted 19/07/2007 at 10:56:17
At the time, I lived in Little Sutton on the Wirral, most football fans in those days who lived on the Wirral supported Everton. All this ’hoo ha’ about ’Keeping Everton in the City’ is clap trap. Real followers support the club, not the ground.
Today, Goodison is a relic of a once great stadium. We must move on. For Pete’s sake, Kirkby is not the end of the world. Its only 4 miles from Goodison. In this day and age, 4 miles is absolutely a skip and a jump. For so many Evertonians, Kirkby might well be rather more accessible than is it is today.
Now this continual moaning about Bill Kenwright and the CEO, Mr Wyness. Some of the mud slinging really sticks in my craw. Who are these people who write such twaddle. They may not be perfect, few of us are but how are you moaners so much better. You simply pay your dosh at the gate or have a season ticket and for that, want to own the place. You don’t. You own as much as the cinema goer who pays for his ticket at the desk to watch the film. Get wise to yourselves, you supply, in bulk, the means whereby the club can continue to exist but all the work is carried out by friend Wyness and his team. Personally, I think he’s doing a great job, certainly not helped by the moaning gits who criticise everything yet offer absolutley zilch in the way of constructive criticism.
Wake up, the Blues are on the move. In the past I used to twist and turn in revulsion at similar criticisms of David Moyes. Nowadays, those cretins seem largely to have crawled under the flat stones from which they emerged.
Everton are just so much more exhilarating than say 6 years and so ago. We have quite a fair side and David is building a team of youngsters, no fancy £20M players from distant lands, who have managed to secure 6th place and European football next seasion.
Recent rumours suggest we might be signing Vogel, the Swiss Captain and a European experienced player in a position we badly need strenthening. Pienaar?? Who knows, sounds a likely lad but who knows whether we get him. We are moving slowly but steadily upwards. Its not going to take 2 or 3 years but you youngsters will hopefully enjoy the Everton I have known over so many years, then maybe you’ll be positive and stop this non stop whining with which you afflict all the message boards.
43 Posted 19/07/2007 at 11:31:31
44 Posted 19/07/2007 at 13:17:55
45 Posted 19/07/2007 at 14:02:52
I have the misfortune to sit next to a Red at work & he’s shoving their new stadium design down my throat:
http://theredcauldron.blogspot.com/2007/06/is-this-really-new-anfield.html
Looks like they’re getting Fortnam & Mason and we’re getting Tesco value.........
46 Posted 19/07/2007 at 14:40:41
I would like to propose that those Evertonians against the move from Goodison who feel that they are not being heard by the Everton board stand together and make a VISUAL PROTEST by throwing toilet roles onto the pitch from the stands at every home game this season when Everton walk out to Z-Cars. This would give all match going Evertonians, whether they have a vote on the new stadium or not, the opportunity to create a visual protest to the Board without causing any ill feeling to the team or other supporters. In fact I believe the throwing of toilet roles onto the pitch is very spectacular and uplifting for the players and fans alike. Together we can put pressure on the Board to listen to us and realistically look at a plan B. It will also demonstrate very graphically why Goodison is too special to be left for a £50 million Meccano set with no soul and no connection to Everton FC. The time to move to a new stadium is AFTER we have got investors on board with the cash to deliver a state of the art stadium within the City (Preferably beside the Royal Blue Mersey) not BEFORE. Just like the shower across the park! Ask yourself this question, Why will Everton Football Club need new investors in the future when we are in Kirkby in a free stadium? The answer is we wouldn’t, the only people who would want this investment then is the current board who would be able to pocket the millions by selling the club on with little debt and a new Meccano set chucked in. At this point we would have missed the opportunity for new investment to build a super stadium and be stuck FOREVER in our new home, like it or loathe it!
47 Posted 19/07/2007 at 14:00:21
48 Posted 19/07/2007 at 17:53:10
And how to fill the tin shed? Are thousands extra going to be beating down the gates? Or will it just be a case of lousy atmosphere for the match so that Wyness can pimp it out to concert promoters.
Leave Goodison if it makes economic sense and the proposal is for a good ground that can be filled. This smells of a Tesco & concert promoter’s party.
49 Posted 19/07/2007 at 22:47:18
50 Posted 20/07/2007 at 10:47:27
Bill stop this musical farce before it is to late.
Sack Wyness and bring in your close freind David Dein. I am sure he is missing the premeirshhip.
Before long we would have the investment and players to take us bask to the giddy heights of the mid eighties.
Kirkby is so so wrong. Please act before the club becomes a laughing stock.
51 Posted 21/07/2007 at 13:27:00
52 Posted 09/04/2008 at 09:28:53
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 18/07/2007 at 02:40:13