Skip to Main Content
Members:   Log In Sign Up
Text:  A  A  A

Confessions of serial cheaters!

By Santosh  Benjamin :  25/10/2008 :  Comments (29) :
I'm sorry about the negative title but that's my most striking memory of this game. Yes, we played a brilliant 2nd half and nearly got an unlikely win against a star-studded Utd team but that's not what I remember about the game. I will come to my review of the game itself a little later.

The referee for the game, Alan Wily (yes, I spelt it like that on purpose!) spent the entire game doing his best to help Utd get the upper hand. From invisible fouls on Utd players to blowing the whistle everytime we got possession.. he was terrible. He conveniently forgot to book Giggs after his foul but booked Neville after the diving twat rolled round like his balls had finally descended.

The other thing that left me fuming was the Utd players whining when they were up against it.. from Giggs to Drug-evader Rio to the the badge kissing bald shit to the biggest cheat of the modern game.. Wrongaldo.. they just were pathetic in their whining.

Ok enough of that... it's been a long time since I have written on here. I have been watching all the games on TV here in India and wondering where we would get our season on track. The team sheet showed that we were being positive for once and Hibbo's injury allowing Neville to stay at RB.. was sad that Castillo was not starting but was happy to have Yobo back.

We started brightly with the Utd superstars slowly getting into the flow of things. Soon enough though they started to show their class with their passing and defending. And in the 22nd minute Fletcher of all people ran onto a Giggs ball with Fellaini lazily watching... he scored with composure to start Utd on their way.

After that the crowd and the players seemed to sense the inevitable a ? Utd steamrolling ? so we sauntered through the half with Howard the most active player in blue, making a few smart saves. 1 minute of added time was what we were promised and although we were attacking, the whistle was promptly blown by Wily.

The second half started and the same side came out hopefully after a rollicking from the gaffer. They started much better and were closing down Utd and attacking with purpose. Still my negative nature wondered when the 2nd Utd goal would come to crash our hopes... it didn't.

What did come was Phil Neville making a crunching tackle on the Ole Diver, who rolled around clutching his tummy. The reaction of Giggs and Rio, almost willing the ref into sending Neville off, was bloody irritating. It was only a yellow luckily and the game went on. A few more good moves and then came the equaliser... Neville's cross from the right headed in wih power by Fellaini.

We were buoyed by that and wave after wave of attack followed and mistakes started creeping into the usually composed Utd back-line, Yakubu latching onto one of those and nearly scoring, Van Der Sar and the post saving Utd from going behind. Rooney was his usual bully self and a hard tackle on Mikel got him a card which prompted him to kiss his Utd badge... and the response from SAF was even more prompt, took the fat, bald twit off.

I hoped Moyes would bring on Vaughan and Big Vic to try and get the win but he kept it late to hold onto the draw. We withstood the usual late barrage from the Utd players and the officials who gave them 4+ mins of added time to earn a great draw.

I hope this spurs us on to better things in the coming weeks. We are capable of more and we need to start showing it. My MotM was Neville and I'd have never thought of him before for it but his commitment and passion (plus the pass for the goal!) showed he was proud to wear our badge.

Pienaar came close to being my MotM ? good passing and tackling too. Arteta started slowly but was great at the end. The defense did just enough but could do better with composure. Vaughan needs more time on the pitch, Those who doubted Moyes's passion for the club would have no doubt seen his constant ranting on the touchline especially when things went against us.

I hope we can use this to press on to better things... COYB

Reader Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Michael Hunt
1   Posted 25/10/2008 at 15:35:17

Report abuse

Good review Santosh, pleasing to see some backbone and fight from the lads again (though Howard?s saves after we went one down were probably key to sustaining belief and fragile morale).

The childish and cheating conduct of Rooney and Ronaldo is an embarrassment to the game... and the respect campaign becoming a bit of a joke. Still, if the blue boys start playing to their potential now then that is will be very welcome, however overdue. Only letting one goal in is a 50% improvement on this season average, so maybe even a clean sheet is not far away at last!

Stefan Tosev
2   Posted 25/10/2008 at 15:54:03

Report abuse

Wiley was a joke and what about Brown getting only yellow when Yakubu would have been through one on one with VdS, it really makes me mad week-in, week-out watching the preferential treatment of the Sky 4 and Ferguson complaining that United werent given enough protection WTF?
Anthony Keating
3   Posted 25/10/2008 at 16:00:30

Report abuse

Best half of the season so far I reckon, let's hope we can push on. Thought Fellaini was much improved in the 2nd half and again, hope this sparks the fella into life.

The boy Rooney though, one dog him.

Keith Glazzard
4   Posted 25/10/2008 at 16:28:36

Report abuse

Brown was the ?last man? between Yak and the goalkeeper, no doubt about the intention of the player deliberately committing the foul, so the yellow that the ref gave should have been red. Just as identical tackles outside the box within minutes of each other resulted in a free kick for them, and nothing for us.

On the bright side, good football and attitude - perhaps some self belief, and a few wins in the coming fixtures.
Edwin Cole
5   Posted 25/10/2008 at 16:58:42

Report abuse

Phil Neville had one of the best games in the blue shirt. Captain led by example today and it was impressive. Osman should have long been taken off and been replaced by Castillo to sit deep and anchor. That would have relieved Fellaini?s defensive duties and freed him to play further upfront in support of our twin strikers. Pienaar and Arteta served as useful outlets in the attacking 3rd.

With Cahill back for Wednesday?s Bolton game, drop Osman put in Castillo, drop Lescott put in Baines. The team is slowly coming together. Another central midfielder who can link the passes come the January transfer window and we can be in the top 6, realistically speaking.

George McKane
6   Posted 25/10/2008 at 17:07:23

Report abuse

It was certainly a game of 2 halves. First half I thought they may have run riot. Half-time chat was about how bad we were and what may happen second half.

What happened second half makes it interesting ? nothing whatsoever to do with Moyes?s tactics, no ? Neviille put a challenge in; Man Utd panicked and surrounded referee and somehow the crowd and the players woke up.

We cannot beat then by class and football, we have to compete, challenge, battle ? it worked. The referee certainly seemed to give them everything; there is no doubt in my opinion that the whole system is set up to really ensure that the Top Four is maintained. The referees give the top 4 everything ? you could see it today.

But it was not Moyes; again they had players booked, bring on Vaughan to run at them? No, only bring him on with a minute or so to go...

So a point was fantastic. I thought certain players were great but you mentioned Arteta, for me he was the poorest Everton player on the pitch today and has been consistently poor for around 12 months. I cannot understand what he is doing. Yes, he is a gifted player but what does he do? He actually delivers nothing at the end.

I thought Fellaini won lots of headers; Pienaar was good. Let?s see what happens now with the so-called easier games coming up. For me, nothing except a good win with some football being played next week will do. Moyes has a lot to prove to me.

Wayne Smyth
7   Posted 25/10/2008 at 17:28:25

Report abuse

I thought Fellaini was very good today, seems to be improving with every game and could turn out to be a top drawer box-to-box midfielder (especially given that he?s still only 20).

He was one of the few players who generally looked composed, passed to feet and didn?t give it away. He was all over the pitch in the 2nd half, getting stuck in which was good. The only negative was him not picking up Fletcher's run, but I don't recall the centre halves marking anyone and they seemed to let him run straight through unopposed too.

Neville had a good game too (at least no own goals this time eh? :) . Thought lescott looked very nervy at left back. Sooner we get Baines back there the better.

Was a pity Moyes left it so late for the subs. I thought Saha looked knackered and I was hoping with 20-30 mins left we might see Vaughan with his energy and pace really worry the Utd back 4 who looked as gittery as ours after the goal.

Let's hope this is the confidence boost the lads needed for us to push on this season.
Antony Matthews
8   Posted 25/10/2008 at 17:39:00

Report abuse

Lescott won't be dropped for Bolton's match, Edwin cos we need some height cos of the way Bolton play. The question is will he fetch Timmy back and if so who does he drop?
Santosh Benjamin
9   Posted 25/10/2008 at 18:11:08

Report abuse

I forgot about the Wes Brown incident... I was furious when he only got a yellow too as I thought he was the last defender. I thought that Saha looked knackered from around the 70th minute... was hoping to see Vaughan from at least that point. Moyes needs to be more aggressive with the subs but I think we are headed in the right direction. It's been a while since I shouted so much while watching the game on TV... it was mainly directed at Wiley but Rio, Ronny and Rooney also got their fair share of abuse from me. Terrible how the big teams get treated so well by the refs. I was also mad coz the commentators were so biased towards Utd.
Terry Smith
10   Posted 25/10/2008 at 18:19:01

Report abuse

It has been the first time this season after a cracking crunching tackle got the rest of the lads up for it. Let's hope that we continue this and get 6 points in the bag against Bolton & Fulham.
Rob Nunn
11   Posted 25/10/2008 at 18:38:59

Report abuse

That was Everton! Drove 100 km to watch them and they did not dissapoint. Fantastic!!!
Tony Williams
12   Posted 25/10/2008 at 19:26:24

Report abuse

Ronaldo and Berbatov should be up for Oscars, George you rightly pointed out that it was Pip’s crunching challenge on the Riverdance King that got us in the crowd up for it but you sound like Tony Marsh when you say it wasn’t due to Moyes.... (I expect Marshy to be invisible this week)

I too believed that Vaughan should have come on 5/10 minutes earlier as their back four looked shot and the youth and pace of Vaughan would have terrified them.

We say it most weeks but the ref was useless again and was simply waiting for them to score.
Anthony Dyer
13   Posted 25/10/2008 at 21:05:10

Report abuse

Why can’t we adopt that attitude in every match we play?

I thought peanuts was exceptional today with his desire to get and use the ball. In fact the 3 players who didn’t perform were Lescott, Yak and Arterta.

This Refereeing situation is getting ridiculous , week after week they ensure the chosen ones are protected and given every decision.

Are the refs just frightened by all the Red teams living in various parts of the country or is there really something more sinister?

From my vantage point I didn’t believe that Neville caught Ronaldo, but the report on sky sports webpage said he recklessley lunged at Ronanldo’s knee.

I also watched BBC final score program foolishly believing that Man U would feature heavily in a 3 game prem round-up. But oh no apart from the patronising hour long special on how great Hull are doing (the new media darlings of the moment) and an inquest in to how Spurs are going to get out of the mess they find themselves in. You would have thought the match at Goodison had no importance whatsoever!

Anyway come on Blues carry on with that attitude and application and the supporters will get right behind you.
Imagine what we could do if the 3 players I mentioned started playing to their capabilities.
Alex Burrell
14   Posted 25/10/2008 at 21:50:07

Report abuse

All this talk about Wes Brown’s tackle. Yes, it was bad... but unfortunately you’re all falling for the MOTD line of "last man therefore he should have got sent off."

Much as it would have been wonderful if he had been sent off, I’m afraid the words "last man" don’t appear in the laws of football. You can only get sent off for "denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity". Cynically scything someone down around about the centre circle doesn’t count as one of those, more’s the pity. But it will get you a yellow for unsporting behaviour.

So Wiley got it right. Perhaps the only thing he did get right today, though. The Neville yellow card, for example, was outrageous.
Keith Glazzard
15   Posted 25/10/2008 at 23:34:15

Report abuse

Alex - you’re talking about the laws of football as if they are administered by a computer, assisted by Hawkeye. This is not the case. Referees make decisions about the intent of a player’s action.

Ronaldo intended to make a fair tackle look like a booking foul by rolling over several times, and succeeded. Brown intended to deny Yakubu a goal scoring opportunity (as there was no other covering player behind him) and got away with a yellow. Wiley interprered his action as a deliberate (some call it professional) foul, but bottled out of deciding that advancing player had only the keeper between him and the goal. He’s obviously never seen anyone score from the half way line - unless of course they were very talented and therefore played for the likes of a Sky4 team.
Andy Crooks
16   Posted 26/10/2008 at 01:09:38

Report abuse

Santosh, I agree with you about the subs. Re the referee, never blame the referee, no matter how crap he is. Keith Glazzard has demonstrated clearly that the cheats are spotted and held in contempt. Ronaldo should remember Rivaldo. A great career blighted by the most degrading act ever seen on a football pitch.
Alex Burrell
17   Posted 26/10/2008 at 08:49:56

Report abuse

I’m sorry, Keith, but can you tell me the last time a player was sent off for denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity at the centre circle?

The key word is "obvious". It is not obvious that someone at the half way line is going to score. They could be outpaced by a defender on the way to the goal. Indeed, there was another Man U player not far from the incident. This is something that referees are explicitly taught.

No conspiracy this time, I’m afraid.
Tom Edwards
18   Posted 26/10/2008 at 10:19:52

Report abuse

I don?t usually bother to comment on any aspect of Shrek?s immature and petulant behaviour. I would not have enough time! However, I think yesterday?s bout of badge kissing and gesticulating warranted a yellow card, irrespective of the fact that he had been booked seconds earlier. In reality, he should have been off. Ditto, Wes Brown. I thought the rules stated that the ref had no choice but to send off a player for a deliberate foul if he was the last man? Looks like a large slice of "Sky 4 leniency" was being employed by the ref. Even so, SAF still had to comment that the ref gave his players no protection!
Eric Myles
19   Posted 26/10/2008 at 11:10:03

Report abuse

I thought Arteta showed no interest in the game at all yesterday. It was as if he didn?t want to be on the pitch, which is a pity ?cos for the last few seasons he?s been our best player.

Of that tackle on Ronaldo, IF Neville made contact it was on Ronaldo?s knee, and only a slight touch, so there was no way he needed to be rolling around clutching his stomach. I hope the ref watches the replays of the game and sees the cheating that wqent on by the United players, especially Park.

And the biased commentators were saying what a bad tackle it was by Neville on Ronaldo (when minimal contact was made) but when Saha was scythed down they said it was fair tackle by the United player (forget who)
What bloody hypocrites!!!
Tony Williams
20   Posted 26/10/2008 at 11:59:19

Report abuse

I have had a chance to watch the Pip challenge on Football First and it is Pip?s trailing leg that clips the Ladyboy?s thigh/knee which sent him into his Oscar performance.

Berbatov was the same as well with his theatrics to a slight knock.
Alex Burrell
21   Posted 26/10/2008 at 14:01:37

Report abuse

Tom - you’re not the first to think that the rules say if you’re the "last man" you should be sent off. You won’t be the last, either. Like I said, the laws of football don’t include the words "last man". It’s a useful rule of thumb, but a common oversimplification of the real law.

Tony - as for the Neville yellow card, I couldn’t believe that one. Especially how little comment it got on MOTD. The commentator thought it was a "disgraceful" tackle (without justifying his statement), but they didn’t even consider it in the analysis afterwards. I thought it was a good challenge, and therefore a yellow card for Ronaldo for the theatrics. But that takes balls.

I think the time has come for referees to be allowed to watch the game afterwards and submit any further disciplinary matters to the FA that they notice on the videotape. That seems really simple and straightforward to me. Referees are human, make mistakes, and can’t see all angles, so they should be allowed to reflect in hindsight on the things they might have missed.
Keith Glazzard
22   Posted 26/10/2008 at 17:02:30

Report abuse

Alex - the problem lies in the fact that the refs don’t apply the laws, they first of all interpret them and then apply them to particular situations. Its any easy crowd pleaser on this site to raise the ghost of Clattenburg, but that terrible day he conducted himself as a ’friend of the famous’, treating RS players like old mates (as they smirked all the way to a win) and so made many woeful decisions.

This isn’t a conspiracy theory - just an observation of the way that most refs work. Chopping a man down in the centre circle doesn’t count as preventing an "obvious" goal scoring opportunity to a referee that thinks that the attacking player "could be outpaced by a defender". There’s a lot of room for disagreement in the word "could".

I don’t think the laws say anything about how fast defenders can run - refs make that kind of judgment, and some of us, based on experience, think that they usually give the benefit of the doubt to the defender - if he plays for a Sky4 team.
Tony Hart
23   Posted 26/10/2008 at 17:48:03

Report abuse

It’s a shame Neville doesn’t do a few more of these cruching tackles, although these days it is hard to tackle at all without a yellow card. When he played for Man U you could guarantee that Ferguson would bring him on against ball playing teams like Arsenal to play a purely destrucive role. To my disgust at the time he was very effective at this particulalry aginst Reyes a few years ago. It’s a shame he and the rest of the team can’t deliver a few more reducer tackles like this.
Dennis Garlden
24   Posted 26/10/2008 at 00:39:05

Report abuse

Watching the game on the telly, it looked like Ossie was in the holding role, and building craftily from the back, with Fellaini in front of him. I thought that really worked well once he found his feet in the 2nd half; could Ossie be a more creative "Carsley"??

Good to see Arteta have a good game, and gee that Pienaar is good for us ain't he..... good signs from Saha, he'll come good I reckon!!!

Mick Gallagher
25   Posted 26/10/2008 at 21:24:38

Report abuse

Stuck offshore on a oil-rig and watched the game on Sky later on. Was pleased with the second half and everyone on here that watched it said we deserved at least a point. Most were surprised how much the Mancs got away with and that Wiley was shite and biased, so nothing new there, is there?
Keith Glazzard
26   Posted 26/10/2008 at 22:09:47

Report abuse

Dennis - interesting observation about Ossie playing deeper. One to keep an eye on.

Mick - if you were where you say you were at least we know that your judgment wasn’t fuddled by the drink. I’ve found it very instructive over the years to watch matches on TV with people who supported all sorts of other teams (it isn’t an EFC oil rig is it?). They usually know their football and know what’s right and what’s wrong - there is a strong sense of justice in the honest supporter. I’m sure this particular jury got it right last Saturday.
Paul McGough
27   Posted 27/10/2008 at 05:38:34

Report abuse

Actually looking forward to going to Bolton on Wednesday. I couldn't agree more, that was the best 45 minutes I have seen this season. Why can't we go out there and play with heart and soul for 90 minutes? Come on boys, you have just set a benchmark for performances ? we can only get better.
Brian Donnelly
28   Posted 28/10/2008 at 11:20:49

Report abuse

Osman was playing defensive midfield and very ineffective he was in the first half ? mind you, he wasn?t alone in his feebleness. My abiding memory of him is when he was running after Giggs, who had control of the ball, for about 30 yds and not gaining an inch on him. He looked like a schoolboy completely out of is depth. He is certainly not the answer to our need for a defensive midfield player, but then again, is there anyone at the club who is the answer?

Fortunately that tackle from Neville changed the whole outlook & the whole team looked great, but midfield has been and will continue to be the major problem for EFC.
EJ Ruane
29   Posted 29/10/2008 at 09:57:07

Report abuse

The word ’cheat’ to me suggests a deliberate attempt to subvert.

Certainly in the case of the thick-but-talented Ronaldo, it applies.

His rolling around as though Ricky ’third-person’ Hatton had given him a dig in the guts, should imo, have seen him sent off (then violently assaulted in the tunnel).

In the case of refs, I feel a little different.

I don’t believe the majority are ’cheats’ but I do believe that they are subconsciously nervous of the ’big four’.

And why are they nervous?

Simple - I believe many of them (like the FA/Premier League) are shit-scared of Sir Alex Red-grid, Wenger etc, so on many occasions simply take the shithouse way out.

The worst example of cowardice this seasaon however has not been from a ref.

This was instead from the FA/Premier League over the John Terry sending-off.

Is there ANYONE who believes if this had been a Stoke/Everton/Hull etc player, the red card would have been res...resc....changed?

In the words of Rudyard Kipling, ’as fucking if!’

Therefore is it any wonder refs are cacking themselves to send off/book/bollock ’big four’ players.

And is it really fair that refs get the blame for basically exhibiting completely human traits?

NB: Obviously none of this applies to Clattenberg who IS a morally (and actually?) bankrupt cheating twat!

If you’re in any doubt, just remember the Shearer-Lennon case.

The worst case of football authorities..erm.. ’shithousery’ I have seen?

Alan Shearer practically decapitates of Neil Lennon with his boot.

He was snarling as he did it.

Lennie Peters, Stevie Wonder and Ray Charles could have told you it was a deliberate and angry attack.

Yet when Mary Poppins threatened (THREATENED!) the FA with non-participation in England games if they ’did him’ closed.

Refs get on my tits, but It starts at the top.

© ToffeeWeb

We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.