Season › 2013-14 › News
Hodgson at odds with excitement over Barkley
England boss qualifies his comments amid criticism

Hodgson drew criticism for his ham-fisted attempt at dampening enthusiasm over the player's performance against Ecuador in Miami on Tuesday afternoon after Barkley showed off his prodigious abilities in the 2-2 draw with the South Americans. He set up England's second goal for Ricky Lambert with a scintillating run and showed plenty of other flourishes normally so lacking in the English game but Hodgson initially chose to dwell on the negative aspects of the youngster's display in his comments after the match.
The 66 year-old expanded on his comments in his press conference yesterday, acknowledging Barkley's precocious talents but left few doubts that he sees him as an impact player in Brazil rather than a starter when the Three Lions' World Cup campaign kicks off in eight days' time.
“I'm sure he'll be happy with his performance, as a first one for 90 minutes," Hodgson said, "and I think he justified the fact I've taken him with us on this adventure we're embarking on, because a player of his type, with the confidence and who is prepared to take an awful lot of risks with the ball, there will be times in the game when we need him."
“He's a talented boy. I'm not criticising him. I'm just making certain that people don't get too carried away. Because unfortunately we know also it's too easy to concentrate on the good things. You would need to watch the game again for 90 minutes through my eyes and see the performance as a whole and not just the cameo moments where he did brilliantly. That's the point I'm making."
In trying to deflect what he termed as the media's "obsession" with Barkley, Hodgson had sought to praise Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain, Phil Jones and Jack Wilshere for their displays but reserved little for Barkley who has less international experience.
"He's not here ‘to learn," Hodgson explained. "He's here to be a part of our team and he's here to play. But I think it's a bit unfair on Oxlade-Chamberlain, who really did have an outstanding 60 minutes, and harsh on the two centre-backs, Jones in particular, who in his first game back did ever so well for us, and I think it's harsh on Wilshere and Lampard too. What I'm trying to do is deflect the newspapers from just being about Ross Barkley.
"He's got drive, he's got energy, but he's got to learn when to release the ball. For every good turn there was a time when he lost the ball and put us on the back foot defensively," Hodgson continued, ignoring the fact that it was Oxlade-Chamberlain (who was otherwise impressive) who gave the ball away for Ecuador's first goal and who was injured trying to atone for another giveaway in the second half.
Typically, Martinez elected to use more positive language in support of his rough diamond.
“He is a special player, a unique player and this is so rare," the Spaniard said. "He is the biggest talent for his age I have seen in European football. He has power, pace and technical ability — elements you rarely find in a player. He would look at home in the Spanish, German or Dutch models, no doubt about it.
“We have a responsibility to develop his talent and to protect him and nurture him. The back-heel to Rooney, the pass for Lambert's goal and the shot Ross had give you an indication of the player that he will become. We have to allow him room to develop and let's not put too much pressure on him.
“At the moment he is perfectly suited to playing in the No 10 role, but in time he will develop into the complete midfielder. Nothing fazes him, but the World Cup is a massive event and Ross needs protection. We just need to calm things down a bit and don't expect too much from him. I've seen what Roy had to say after the game but I think he was just trying to protect him a little bit.”
Also flying in the face of Hodgson's cold water were comments from veteran midfielder Frank Lampard, who compared Barkley to Wayne Rooney.
"It's the fearlessness of youth," Lampard remarked. "He has great ability on the ball, running at people and taking them out — and that's what you want to see.
"It's brilliant for him, brilliant for the team and individually to see him come through. It's great for the team to have players in those attacking areas who can make things happen.
"I'm sure he will have learnt a lot from the game in terms of positions to pick up, times to turn, times not to. But when you've got players like that in a team, players who can run away from people and make things happen, then you're very happy."
Quotes sourced from The Telegraph
Reader Comments (73)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 06/06/2014 at 06:37:12
His other problem is that he adores RS players, probably because of his brief association with the club and will do all he can to include them, hence the inclusion of Henderson in the squad, a very ordinary player who will be exposed in this tournament. If he moves Rooney out wide there would also be no starting place for Sterling and that would upset Hodgson too.
It's a very similar situation to Italia 90 (though for different reasons) when Bobby Robson's preconceived plans were just not working and the more the media and results pointed this out the more stubborn he became until events took charge (or by some accounts the players!) and the whole ethos of the team changed and in the end England could have won the tournament with a bit of luck they were denied. Robson's defence of his own mindset, if left unchecked, would have ensured a much earlier return to Blighty. Hodgson is making the same mistake.
I have to say I cannot stand the England set-up and the damage it could do to Ross Barkley. A lad who for most of the media, and certainly for me, was easily the man of the match despite Oxlade-Chamberlain's claims, to be criticised by his own manager for his mistakes while ignoring the fact that he saved England from defeat is tantamount to a scandal. The manager should look around and at the performances of the likes of Wilshire, Lampard, Lambert (even though he scored thanks to being set up by Ross) and Milner (ok he's not a full-back but that doesn't mean you have to be totally inept) before attempting to build a wall around himself in order to fend off the claims of Barkley for a starting place.
It was his involvement with England (directly and indirectly) that prevented Rooney from developing into the player that could have been up there with Messi and Ronaldo. Directly because all the weight fell on his shoulders to win games for the team which was usually poor and gave him little service, and indirectly because it led to his head being turned and his move to United where he eventually became almost a utility player at the most crucial period of his development. I would hate anything like that to happen to Barkley.
3 Posted 06/06/2014 at 07:57:51
Having said that I think I probably would have given the man of the match award to Oxlade Chamberlain. His runs just seemed to work slightly more often for me, although Barkley linked up play in the middle of the park better.
4 Posted 06/06/2014 at 08:09:18
Personally, I wouldn't start Barkley against Italy or Uruguay as I think people will be looking for him to make things happen out of nothing, and if it goes wrong then I can see England fans getting frustrated with him, which isn't fair.
5 Posted 06/06/2014 at 08:19:22
A bit Football Manager thinking, I admit, but if that team doesn't have a Defensive Mid because it's looking to play possession football a la Barca, then it's going to be a short World Cup.
6 Posted 06/06/2014 at 08:32:45
Ha, funny, by using his "experienced" management tactics, he is getting more people talking about Ross, not less.
7 Posted 06/06/2014 at 08:45:15
8 Posted 06/06/2014 at 08:55:17
9 Posted 06/06/2014 at 08:47:42
This completely defeats the object of having a wild card type player who can turn defences with one run. Woy's comments should be directed at Wilshere, Shaw, Milner and Smalling who were atrocious.
He has laid his cards on the table now and don't expect Ross to get much game time unless all other options fail and he will get 7 minutes in the last time to try and save us.
10 Posted 06/06/2014 at 08:58:08
The only other thing I would say about Ross is I never see him wanting to make a tackle; he manages just to get close to a player after he has got rid of the ball this is something he has done all season. Now, whether he still has a worry over his triple leg break, I don't know but it is something he has to conquer.
Just to be absolutely clear, I think Ross is a brilliant young player but to ignore his deficiencies will not help him improve as a player.
11 Posted 06/06/2014 at 09:12:10
12 Posted 06/06/2014 at 08:31:57
Whenever England get a burgeoning young talent who offers something new and fresh, the same old criticisms get rolled out ... "they give the ball away", "they aren't safe enough" - implying "I can see something wrong that you can't and that makes me better at watching football than you are." It's always the same. Roll out the coaching staff to put that right.
Next what happens is all of that flair and courageousness gets coached out of them as they have safety first drilled into their heads.
Finally there comes the clamor (as they get older) that we just don't have what it takes to unlock defense, "they aren't the star we thought they could have been."
Thank goodness Martinez isn't of that mindset.
13 Posted 06/06/2014 at 09:42:29
http://www.bbc.com/sport/0/football/27708966
14 Posted 06/06/2014 at 09:36:24
I don't buy the idea that there's no problem with RB losing the ball if you have a good defensive mid to save the day. Sure, a team has to have balance, but the lad's decision making is plainly an area that needs improvement. Martinez knows that, Hodgson knows that. We all know that.
We also know that he has it in him to be, quite literally – at least in footballing terms – a world-beater. In fact, some of us knew that a couple of years ago, and said so on TW. (Sorry, I couldn't resist that.)
The bottom line is: most people on TW either dislike or are wholly indifferent to the England team. Me? I'm a fan of Everton and England. Come on you whites!
15 Posted 06/06/2014 at 09:56:29
Well, he's now got three or four weeks to teach 'our kid' how to play the safe pass – square or backwards – not to take any chances and to cut out those mazey runs.
In other words to become Cleverley Mk 2. Thank you, Roy!
16 Posted 06/06/2014 at 10:26:54
Roy; "As I said, we didn't want to give the ball away cheaply in this heat." — Fuck off!
Watch Gerard hoof 40-yard passes that trickle out of play, is that not giving the ball away? Glen Johnson's passes going off his right boot like a two-bob rocket everywhere, but maybe you didn't notice that? Wilshere got the ball taken off him like a child, at least Ross can go past 3 or 4 players if he gets the chance.
Ross will be brought on if we are chasing a result – typical tactics from a dinosaur manager. Doesn't this shit make you glad we have someone progressive like Bobby in charge? He will play Stones, Barkley and any other teenager if they are good enough. He will let them make mistakes in big games, because he realises it will eventually pay off.
17 Posted 06/06/2014 at 10:32:30
Alan Ball....never made a tackle in his life...he didn't need to. Hardly ever got his shorts dirty!
Bobby Charlton....ditto.
Paul Scholes....now this lad decided he would lay in with a few tackles but most of them were fouls and some of them were positively dangerous.
Gazza....like Scholes he would tackle but also like Scholes he was dangerous but mainly to himself. His own career began drawing to a close after one of his tackles did his own knee in.
Zidane....not a tackler....didn't have to be.
All that these players did, whether they didn't tackle at all or when they decided not to, was to fulfill their defensive responsibilities by marking players or filling space, making it difficult for the opposition which is exactly what Barkley did and does when he or anybody else lost the ball. Tackling is a skill that is best left to defenders generally speaking although I have to say that the best left-back in the world (Baines) doesn't tackle very often either! Tony Hibbert on the other hand is one of the best tacklers I have ever seen....but unfortunately the rest of his skills are severely limited.
This is why Oxlade-Chamberlain would never be my Man of the Match on Wednesday. Fair enough some of his runs were eye-catching for the easily pleased but when they broke down he stopped dead and left gaps in the middle that Ecuador exploited. He gave the ball away for their equalizer but more importantly he did nothing to try to rectify his error. On the one occasion he did chase a ball he had lost his 'tackle' cost him an injury which might put him out of the World Cup. So, so much for tackling!
Just like Bally and Charlton, Barkley is not a 'ball winning' midfielder. Barkley is a creative midfielder who the ball-winner gives the ball to so he can do his stuff. This doesn't mean he doesn't have to defend but you don't have to tackle to defend. You just have to work hard and cover the gaps which Oxlade-Chamberlain didn't do.
18 Posted 06/06/2014 at 10:50:45
On reflection, there were other members of the team that lost possession in dangerous areas so Barkley wasn't the only person and he didn't do it as often as perceived.
19 Posted 06/06/2014 at 11:03:40
You can add Kevin Sheedy to that list of non tacklers
20 Posted 06/06/2014 at 11:08:48
22 Posted 06/06/2014 at 11:26:44
I don't think you must have seen Alan Ball to claim he didn't tackle I suggest you have a look at his games for us. Sheedy wasn't a great one for tackles but he did make tackles, Ross avoids any chance of making a tackle which is quite different from not being good at making tackles. Just watch next time Ross plays and count how many tackles he makes, I am not saying it should be a strength of his game but he could at least try and make a tackle.
23 Posted 06/06/2014 at 11:17:28
We should go with up-and-coming talent; whatever mistakes they make is another step on the learning curve. Have the past up-and-coming English players fared any better? No. Have they even been close to winning anything? No.
We have the chance this year to at the very least show the world that we're building an English future; the Germans have done it, Spain have too... Belgium may be the surprise team. Brazil have been doing it for years – would any of those teams be in fear of "Roy's" England? By that, I mean the same defensive set-up, scared of having a go, or playing for penalties? No.
Roy was a stop-gap choice the FA needed at the time to sort the mess out; we now need a manager in charge who can take our current batch of young talent to the next level. Most of the current English squad have been selected from teams playing good attractive attacking football... so why should it be any different for England?
Over to you, Woy...
24 Posted 06/06/2014 at 11:39:44
I dare say that if we scour the archives we may find an example of a tackle somewhere that I didn't see or don't remember...but this would be no more than the exception that proved the rule.
Alan Ball was not a tackler. Neither is Ross Barkley and any attempt to turn him into one would be a mistake as it would strangle his view of how he should play his game.
25 Posted 06/06/2014 at 11:47:17
Sheedy knew how to tackle when required. That elegant a player.. they were rare. I remember a beauty on, I think it was McMahon The game was getting a bit naughty and Sheeds left one on Macca, high up on the thigh.
27 Posted 06/06/2014 at 11:50:24
28 Posted 06/06/2014 at 11:56:42
Problem in this country is if you don't run around like a headless chicken putting in sliding tackles you're not appreciated. Ask Glenn Hoddle, Matt le Tiss.
Messi can't tackle, Ronaldo can't tackle, Iniesta can't tackle. These are not bad players are they.
Leave the tackling to players like Milner, Parker, and the flair to your Barkley's.
29 Posted 06/06/2014 at 12:13:52
30 Posted 06/06/2014 at 12:24:40
If the stupid old bastard had any bollocks, he'd start with Barkley, Sterling, Wilshere and Oxlade-Chamberlain (if fit), and Sturridge up front with one other and not Rooney because he looks like an old man playing a young boy's game.
But we all know he won't; it'll be the usual boring bollocks. Losing then throwing one of the above on to chase a result. Then the usual shite of: "That's why I left them on the bench in case we needed fresh legs but you have to remember, Steven Frank and James were magnificent for 70 minutes." Yes, Roy, sure... play the kids; let's face it, it's not as if they could do any worse, is it?
32 Posted 06/06/2014 at 12:35:58
There's a lot of Scousers in the squad who will all look after each other...
Ross will be fine... And a match winner...
33 Posted 06/06/2014 at 12:26:15
Only time will tell if Ross Barkley can fulfil his obvious talent to 'superstar' status; right now I believe that his own ambition is to succeed at Goodison Park, with England only a secondary concern, I think most Blues fans would prefer the former.
34 Posted 06/06/2014 at 12:47:46
The ball is rarely won back by an out-and-out 'tackle' these days, usually a team works together to put pressure on the ball holder and reduce his passing options by closing down potential receivers. Otherwise possession is recovered when the opposition tries a high-risk high-reward strategy in order to create a chance.
35 Posted 06/06/2014 at 12:48:15
36 Posted 06/06/2014 at 13:34:06
Why should he tackle? 90 per cent of forwards are rubbish at it and either get booked or injured like Oxlade-Chamberlain. If England had proper defensive midfielders like Barry and McCarthy, they would not need him to tackle.
The boy is a genius and I wish he was at home being looked after by Roberto. Woy Hodgson is a twat for what he said.
37 Posted 06/06/2014 at 13:48:33
38 Posted 06/06/2014 at 13:52:24
39 Posted 06/06/2014 at 14:19:26
His 'criticism' was not of Barkley, but of the media, who, others have rightly pointed out, revel in the big build up and sometimes big drop of the next young superstar. If in the course of trying to unlock the opposition, Ross loses the ball and we concede, the same media will crucify him, and Hodgson, for picking one so naïve and lacking big game experience.
I don't trust the media at all. If Ross excels, the clamour will start to get him to Old Trafford, mark my words. For me, I agree with others who suggest he should be used offensively, as an impact sub, when the heat is getting at our own ability to score, and the opposition defenders' ability to defend. Shorn of any major defensive responsibilities (an area I think he needs major development work on), he can be our talisman.
40 Posted 06/06/2014 at 14:35:55
I remember that game and Barkley played great ... surely to be dropped again for the next game!
41 Posted 06/06/2014 at 15:11:49
Then we had Lampard, caught in possession, short passes going astray, then Wiltshire given a poor version of Osman, losing possession, getting pushed off the ball time and again and spending most of the game flat on his stomach.
42 Posted 06/06/2014 at 15:57:23
43 Posted 06/06/2014 at 16:19:40
44 Posted 06/06/2014 at 16:48:03
Ross has many gaps in his game and he needs to curb this headless chicken running about nonsense he gets involved in. A bit of time watching old videos of Butch Wilkins wouldn't go amiss. Why dash forward to try and beat a man, possibly losing the ball, when you could safely pass sideways thereby keeping possession.
Jack Wilshere can show him the way. Jack controlled midfield against Ecuador. He showed how to do it (fall over, sit on your arse and complain).
And as for taking shots from distance. Good grief. Doesn't Ross understand that this sort of behaviour is limited to the older more revered members of the team , specifically Gerard and Lampard (peace be upon them, may their beards never grow shorter).
Being young is no excuse. He needs to learn to be a boring git like the rest of them.
45 Posted 06/06/2014 at 17:09:20
46 Posted 06/06/2014 at 17:16:28
No wonder English football is so far behind the rest of the world – 4-4-2, jumpers for goalposts, can you run until your legs fall off? What a gobshite.
47 Posted 06/06/2014 at 17:20:10
Just a thought on the World Cup: eleven players, as far as I can gather, who have either played or are playing for Everton can be made from the following World Cup squads:- Howard, Yobo, Jags, Senderos, Baines; Barkley, Fellaini, Cahill, Mirallas; Lukaku, Jelavic. Sub (Stones). Just enough to make a team. I don't think I have missed any but I'm sure somebody will post if I have.
48 Posted 06/06/2014 at 18:18:10
49 Posted 06/06/2014 at 18:33:32
Yes he has a role to play in Brazil, but getting to this stage has taken 2 years, a good 90 minutes doesn't make him the answer to all England's questions yet.
I don't understand why Hodgson didn't just say " Yep, Ross had a good game, great to have options like that in the squad" then moved on. The press and fans will speculate whatever happens. He has created the storm by being a arse.
50 Posted 06/06/2014 at 19:18:39
Exactly. That's been my question all along. If you listen to his expanded comments to the fans forum here he actually makes a reasoned case that acknowledges Ross' inexperience while also highlighting his talents.
His curmudgeonly comments immediately after the game where he singled out everything Barkley did wrong just came off all wrong and did nothing for the player's confidence. It was that – in combination with the dubious praise for the likes of Jack Wilshere and Phil Jones on the other side of the coin – that got my goat.
52 Posted 06/06/2014 at 20:30:33
You can add Jo (Brazil) and Segundo Castillo (Ecuador) to that subs bench.
I also think that we had someone who once played for us called Wayne Rooney (England). I know some people prefer to forget though...
53 Posted 06/06/2014 at 20:44:24
Castillo – well, I have a bit of an excuse with him as I'd clean forgot that he appeared for Everton, but now I'll have to bench Jelavic and give Rooney his rightful place in the team.
54 Posted 06/06/2014 at 21:19:03
55 Posted 06/06/2014 at 21:58:45
Why does Ross puff out his cheeks like that? He's always doing it. It looks like he's got a gobstopper in each cheek. Peculiar, most peculiar.
56 Posted 06/06/2014 at 22:16:11
Barkley gave a performance more exciting than any other player in an England shirt and, aside from OxCham, his was probably the best English performance overall.
This will probably be a non-story by the time England lose on penalties and Barkley has only played 15-minute cameos.
Roy is lucky that the media aren't talking about what a cock-end Sterling is, in my opinion, and should be grateful of the distraction.
57 Posted 07/06/2014 at 01:47:50
The problem I have is the timing, and that it even got said at all! You don't "protect" a young star by slamming him a week before the biggest tournament of his life. What the hell is he thinking!!!
58 Posted 07/06/2014 at 02:09:30
59 Posted 07/06/2014 at 03:53:44
Hodgson described Sterling's performance in training on Friday as "breathtaking" and "unstoppable."
Ok, so it's in a training session, but you really have to hope he is saying something different to Ross in private. All just seems a bit ham-fisted to me.
60 Posted 07/06/2014 at 06:42:47
Do a Martinez and keep it positive.
61 Posted 07/06/2014 at 07:07:01
If Hodgson had a brain, he'd be putting this halfwit on a plane home before he crocks anyone else.
62 Posted 07/06/2014 at 09:51:08
63 Posted 07/06/2014 at 10:19:45
64 Posted 07/06/2014 at 10:23:07
"Anticipation, good positioning and speed over ten metres." — I have never see anyone better than Colin Todd for that.
Or, as Cloughie said in the Damned United: "The mighty Colin Todd".
65 Posted 07/06/2014 at 10:42:47
"Alan Ball very rarely made a tackle, He left that to Howard and myself."
From one of the Holy Trinity this morning while out walking his dog.
67 Posted 07/06/2014 at 11:23:06
English managers in general and the England manager in particular have always been suspicious of "Fancy Dans", as a journalist wrote this week that you can reel off a list of players from Duncan McKenzie, Matt Le Tiss, Alan Hudson, Stan Bowles – all of whom have less caps combined than Phil Neville.
I hope and pray the Roberto protects Ross from the "2-yard side pass, Ross, then get into position" merchants, because to be honest I wouldn't give a flying fuck if he never put an England shirt on again – just keep doing it for us Ross.
68 Posted 07/06/2014 at 11:26:18
Between them they managed West Ham, Watford, Villa, Boro, Fulham and West Brom. When Roy was given a bigger job he was inevitably sacked in short order. What else can we expect when we keep putting talent in the hands of such mediocrity?
69 Posted 07/06/2014 at 11:40:31
70 Posted 07/06/2014 at 11:40:14
Roy Hodgson shown a picture of Ross Barkley wearing Chelsea or Man Utd or Arsenal shirt: "The lad is a genius, the future of England, unplayable."
71 Posted 07/06/2014 at 11:45:55
These comments really seem to have come out of left field though. As many have pointed out, he could so easily have said that Ross played well and he can become even better if we don't put too much pressure on him. Instead he has almost attacked the lad for being young and inexperienced.
Totally crazy from a man who I always thought chose his words very carefully.
72 Posted 07/06/2014 at 13:35:20
73 Posted 07/06/2014 at 14:19:30
Hodgson compounded his crass behaviour by lauding two other young players, one of whom failed to simply close down a player facing him in the action of shooting, resulting in a goal conceded, the other has drastically reduced the likelihood of his participating as a result of a clumsy challenge he made.
I hope Ross took note of this deep insight as part of his development.
Finally, Rickie Lambert scored a FANTASTIC goal.... really interesting how much credit Ross has been given for his exciting and opportunistic build up play.
74 Posted 07/06/2014 at 15:09:20
75 Posted 07/06/2014 at 17:32:44
You get Jack Rodwell!!!
76 Posted 07/06/2014 at 17:58:16
77 Posted 10/06/2014 at 16:08:04
78 Posted 11/06/2014 at 13:31:45
Lampard has become a back number like Johnston and the same can be said about several others who have become very predictable such as Milner. Some of the younger players may add spark as substitutes ala Chamberlain, Barkley and Wilshire especially in the heat of Manaus.
I see the Italian game as being very slow and methodical with neither team taking too many chances offensively but nonetheless England could sneak it as the Italian squad is as poor as it's ever been.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 06/06/2014 at 06:30:54
He had a pass completion of 91% the other night,10% more than Rooney whom he praised and the only time he lost the ball is when he tried to unlock their defence, sometimes it failed other times it worked and England scored.
Quite honestly bollocks to him, I don't want the lad having thousands of clowns in pubs around the country either on his case or telling us he needs to move to a 'bigger club' anyway.