Talking Points Archive – Season 24-25

Creative Accounting?

01/07/2025

I have just read that Aston Villa are the next club to sell their women’s team to a sister company for £60M to avoid PSR limits. Why are we not doing the same thing with our women’s team? Or better still, with Goodson Park?  Do the Friedkin group have a sister company? When are Everton […]

The summer barometer

28/06/2025

The unusual summer of matches — including internationals, the much maligned Club World Cup — has arguably delayed activity in the transfer market although one cannot help but notice our darling neighbours and Manchester United have been busy, making some very bright moves. Usually, you’d hope we’d have tuned up the squad for the season […]

Up the flipping workers!

22/06/2025

Over and above any liking or disliking of particular players or management staff, I’m an Everton fan. That said, I’m feeling a little bit torn right now.  The BBC ran this article a day or two ago: £200m written off ~ lessons the Toffees must learn in pivotal summer for David Moyes & Friedkin Group […]

How close Ancelotti came to signing Gabriel for Everton

13/06/2025

Speaking to Podpah, Arsenal’s Gabriel Magalhaes has claimed that he very nearly became an Everton player, and he even had a medical with the Toffees at one point. “I went to Arsenal it was right in the year of Covid, 2020. A little before that my agent said ‘Oh you have an offer from Everton.’ […]

My Greatest Everton, by Alex Young

08/06/2025

For those who follow the Everton Heritage Society on social media, there is an interesting old article with Alex Young. My Greatest Everton, by Alex Young Some obvious, but also interesting choices from the Golden Vision: Gordon WestGary StevensBrian LaboneKevin RatcliffeRay WilsonTrevor StevenTony KayAlan BallKevin SheedyRoy VernonJoe Royle He gives mention to many others, but […]

Farewell to Goodison – an opposition fan’s view

30/05/2025

You say goodbye, I say hello Wow! My first visit to Goodison Park, in fact my first visit to the city of Liverpool. What an incredible experience the weekend proved to be. I’m an artist so I took my oil painting kit to the home of Everton to record the final game at ‘The Grand […]

Here’s To You, Dad…

18/05/2025

The day has arrived… the day we thought we’d never get to… The day to say a fond farewell to our 2nd home,  where we’ve sat for 50 years, through brilliant times, bad times, and traumatic times, in all weathers, to be where we belonged, amongst our fellow Blues. Thanks to Dad, we were all […]

Becky reads your posts to Tony Kay

10/05/2025

Becky Tallentire, who has befriended the past stars for Everton FC and written up their recollections in a trilogy of excellent books, took time out the other day to read the various comments posted about Tony Kay by ToffeeWebbers on the recent Final Day at Goodison thread.

What Money Can’t Buy

07/05/2025

There has been a bit of speculation on the site about what our transfer budget will be this summer and how limited it might be. I believe that, even if the amount is way above our expectations, progress up the table will be limited if it is based entirely on that. We are simply not […]

The Leaving of Goodison

02/05/2025

I’ve written new words to the old sea shanty The Leaving Of Liverpool. It was supposedly first heard around 1870. Feel free to add your ideas, and remember, it’s the tune of The Leaving Of Liverpool – not Lilly the Pink! 😀 Farewell to my seat in Bullens Road and the pillars say that I can’t seeI […]

End-of-term review

28/04/2025

As we get towards the end of the season, I thought it might be useful to debate and take some views of fellow Evertonians on where we are at and what we need to do for next season and the future. I know some articles during the season have been similar but I wanted to […]

The 1878 group have given The Old Lady a great send off

24/04/2025

I would like to say a massive thank you to the 1878 group who have been responsible for the flags on display at matches as well as other fan engagement activities. Their last display I hear is against Ipswich when they plan to have most parts of the ground adorned with flags, and they also […]

My idea for the first senior game at the new stadium

11/04/2025

I just had a brilliant idea! <br><br>Why not have the first game at the new stadium be a testimonial for Seamus Coleman? He thoroughly deserves this as we all know. <br><br>He could be the captain for one last time and especially in the new stadium. He would love it! <br><br>What do you think everyone?

Liverpool Senior Cup Final at Goodison

07/04/2025

For many Evertonians, the time is either running out or has now passed when it comes to visiting Goodison Park. With that in mind, an opportunity has arisen with our Under-21s reaching the final of the Liverpool Senior Cup for Evertonians who are struggling to get Premier League tickets to say one last goodbye. I […]

An Alternative Reality

13/03/2025

Aston Villa winning a tie 6-1 on aggregate in the Last 16 of the Champions League — that should have been us!

Duncan Ferguson in Conversation

24/02/2025

Two independent bookshops are bringing Duncan Ferguson to St George’s Hall in Liverpool on 7 May 2025 at 7:30 pm. The event is being organised by  Linghams, based on the Wirral, and Books, based in Oswestry. Special Meet and Greet tickets have sold out, but there is still general admission available and the ticket includes […]

Doucouré can be a bit of a problem

23/02/2025

I like Doucouré but he gets too excited and loses focus, then misses sitters, and finally he then costs us goals. Let me give you some examples: He missed unopposed sitters from almost the penalty spot against Leicester, Crystal Palace and Liverpool. Every shot was skyed over the bar – all three. Good positioning but […]

Everyone’s a critic?

16/02/2025

Anjishnu, Charles and Conor (apologies to any I’ve missed out) have all put their head upon the block of reporting / previewing and there been plenty of volunteers to take a swing with the axe. So how about ‘You’ having a go? I’ll start you off with some basics; Sat. 22nd Feb, Everton Vs Manchester […]

Broke-ing News?

13/01/2025

Sky’s dramatic ‘Breaking News’ report:  The Premier League will issue disciplinary charges tomorrow against any clubs who have broken financial rules for the 2021-24 reporting period, some obvious questions arise: 1. How will they explain Chelsea and Man Utd skirting the rules… again? 2. What new excuse will there be for not announcing sanctions against Man […]

End This Nonsense, Now!!!

04/01/2025

History tells us that the most bizarre comments are normally made towards the very end of a manager’s tenure at football clubs. If that is the case, then “We’ve had so many draws, it’s not a bad run if you add wins to it” is right up there with the very best of them. For […]

Last ever Merseyside derby at the Grand Old Lady

07/12/2024

There’s a site called Billy’s Liverpool to commemorate all the past sights and sounds of Liverpool. Today, a poster I think called John Peat, posted this, written before the match postponement, it deserves a view even though he is from the other side of the fence…  A ‘Red’ Perspective  Assuming we don’t subsequently meet in […]

My First Derby

05/12/2024

There was great excitement in our house in the week before the 112th Merseyside derby, 6 December 1969. Two tickets for the Gwladys Street stand rested on the sideboard. Everton hadn’t dropped a point at home; Liverpool hadn’t won at Goodison since their return to the top division under Shankly and the promise of the […]

Dying for Success?

02/12/2024

I saw today Bove of Fiorentina collapsed mid-game and is in intensive care.   This seems to be becoming a familiar thing. Nowadays, we have better medical support pitch side than 50 years ago so people like Christian Eriksen don’t join the list of five professional onfield fatalities (excluding lightning strikes and rocket attacks) already […]

The Transgressions of Mr Coote

27/11/2024

Just a quick comment. Given David Coote’s recent transgressions, things get worse with him. Apparently, it is being very strongly rumoured that back in 2019 he was overheard in a discussion about the giving of a yellow card before a game. If this is proved, then surely the can of worms would be so large […]

Transfer Rumours and Promising Youngsters

17/11/2024

Seemingly every few days on the various Rumour Mills (including ToffeeWeb and BBC), Everton are being linked with players who I have never heard of, playing for some mid-ranking foreign team or for clubs such as Brighton, Southampton, Leicester etc, who, if we are honest, is like scratching around a car boot sale for players […]

Open message to Daily Mail reporter, Ian Herbert, about Graeme Sharp

08/11/2024

For context, this post is in response to Ian Herbert’s follow-up aside from his earlier, much bigger article about the supposed “alienation” of Graeme Sharp that has already been reported and discussed in depth on this site: Graeme Sharp says he’s been hurt and won’t come back to Goodison Park Unfortunately, it’s behind a paywall […]

Stability at the top

07/11/2024

The advice I was given at the start of my career about the need to create stability at the top was to think of a pyramid.  When the top stone goes on, there are cheers and celebrations; but in reality, the congratulations should go to the architects who designed the base that provided the top […]

It was 65 years ago today…

31/10/2024

31 October 1959 — the date of my first ever trip to Goodison Park. Growing up in Ellesmere Port in the 1950s, the name on every kid’s lips was Dave Hickson, who lived in the town. My dad said we’d go and see him play and arranged to go to the game against Leicester City. […]

Our goalies

30/10/2024

It’s an admittedly well trodden path for many of us on TW but I’ve always been fascinated by the uniqueness of our goalies (and goalies in general) when it comes to scrutiny and accountability.  I’m therefore inviting any memories of our ‘keepers who delivered man-of-the-match performances regardless of their standing now being well less regarded […]

I hope Friedkin appoints Thomas Frank as our new manager

29/10/2024

Seeing as it looks like Man Utd are about to appoint the Sporting Lisbon manager, I hope Friedkin comes in soon and appoints Thomas Frank as our new manager. The question many will ask is why would Frank come here rather than stay at Brentford? There are two reasons: he will be paid considerably more […]

The Not-So Special One

25/10/2024

Apparently, Jose Mourinho has put himself on the job market for when he leaves Fenerbahce and wants to manage a team at the bottom of the Premier League.  Mourinho claimed he would take on a struggling Premier League team once his time in Turkey is over and said: “The best thing I have to do, […]

Will Armando Broja be a better striker than Calvert-Lewin?

21/10/2024

I think most of us agree that Dominic Calvert-Lewin had a really good game against Ipswich if you forget about his failure to convert at least two one one-on-ones with Muric. If he had scored one, it would have given him an enormous confidence boost and Everton an even more comfortable win. This was not […]

The International Return of Gylfi Sigurdsson

12/10/2024

I noted with interest last night, the 84th min substitution of one Gylfi Sigurdsson, making a brief appearance for Iceland on the international stage. Despite almost 2 years left hanging by Greater Manchester Police and the Criminal Prosecution Service after being suspended by Everton — prematurely in hindsight, rather than waiting to actually see what […]

Looking Ahead at the Everton Squad in 2025-26

01/10/2024

With the current season barely 2 months old and the ownership situation yet to be fully resolved, it might be a bit early to be thinking about next season.  However, with some time on my hands, I was curious to see what our full first-team squad looks like and was surprised – and I was […]

Mike Walker: Victim?

21/09/2024

Funny how the old memory cheats you but I was comparing this season with Mike Walker’s short spell as Everton manager back in 1994, thinking we’d started that with more consecutive losses. But no – we started with a draw then drew with mighty Arsenal then Norwich before Walker was sacked. He famously claimed he’d […]

Bring me Roberto Martinez!

20/09/2024

Let me start by saying I despise Sean Dyche as a manager. I said it before he arrived — he isn’t good enough for this club and he has achieved nothing to suggest he deserves to manage Everton. He has no credit in any bank with me.  I have a little more respect for David […]

Footie in Yesteryear

18/09/2024

Just to get away from the nightmare that is supporting Everton these days, I came across an online article re Villa winning the European Cup in 1982. It stated that, in that complete season, they used 14 players: 42 league games (it didn’t say how many League Cup and FA Cup matches), plus however many […]