Part 2 – Beto: The Beautiful Chaos Everton Never Knew They Needed

Ian Jones
02/06/2025

Beto: Profile Overview

Beto is raw, unpredictable, and built for mayhem – more of a wrecking-ball forward than a refined striker. He’s hard to stop when running at defenders, thanks to a blend of pace, power, and physical chaos.

He thrives on instinct, in transition, and when attacking space. But he struggles when asked to link play, hold the ball up, or function in tight, technical systems.

He’s system-dependent: most effective in counter-attacking setups that provide direct service and ask little of him back-to-goal. When tasked with leading the line in a possession-heavy or low-chance team (like Everton often is), his inconsistent touch, shaky decision-making, and lack of a clinical edge become apparent.

Right now, he’s best as an impact sub or Plan B – a late-game disruptor who can stretch the pitch, press aggressively, and cause panic when defenders tire. He has the tools to become more, but needs confidence, simplified coaching, and a consistent role.

In short: not elite, not reliable — but fun, frustrating, and occasionally devastating. A weapon in the right system, but not yet a week-in, week-out starter to build around.

Strengths

Explosive Physicality & Direct Running

  • Remarkably quick for his height – both in straight lines and explosive bursts past defenders.
  • Combines raw strength with chaotic but effective dribbling, can muscle through contact.
  • Constantly attacks channels; thrives on balls over the top and providing a reliable outlet in transition.

Goal Threat

  • Streaky scorer with sharp instincts in the box, particularly on diagonal runs.
  • Not as dominant in the air as Calvert-Lewin despite his frame, but still a threat due to smart positioning and physical presence.
  • Prefers low, driven finishes and instinctive first-time strikes when confident.

Pressing & Effort

  • Works tirelessly off the ball: presses, chases down defenders, rarely gives them time to settle and forces errors.
  • Relentless energy can unnerve structured defences even when not directly leading to goals.

Key Strengths Summary

  • Physical Attributes: Fast, strong, and aggressive – creates space for others by dragging defenders out of position.
  • Direct Running: A transitional threat using long strides to attack space quickly.
  • Work Rate: A tireless presser who adds value even when not scoring.
  • Aerial Presence: Not elite in the air like DCL, but still useful – especially in chaotic or second-ball scenarios.

Weaknesses & Limitations

Raw Technique

  • First touch is unreliable, especially under pressure or at pace.
  • Passing and link-up play are inconsistent; often below Premier League quality.
  • Back-to-goal play is underdeveloped – struggles to hold up the ball cleanly or bring teammates into play effectively.

Decision-Making

  • Prone to poor choices and overthinking – shoots when a pass is needed, hesitates when simplicity would serve him better.
  • Functions best on instinct; struggles when asked to process quickly or think tactically.

Lack of Subtlety

  • Heavily reliant on physicality; when defenders match him physically, he can disappear or fade from matches.
  • Offers little finesse — doesn’t naturally drop into pockets or create space with clever movement.

He’s More System-Dependent Than He Should Be

Beto needs a team that plays to his strengths:

  • Fast transitions
  • Space to run into
  • Simple service – not intricate passing moves or 40-yard hold-up duels

But all his technical and tactical limitations make him difficult to trust as a starting striker in a Premier League team with top-half aspirations. He’s not yet reliable enough to be a focal point, and not clinical enough to thrive in a team that creates few chances.

Areas for Improvement

  1. First Touch & Control
    Needs to improve ball control under pressure to prevent attacking moves from breaking down.
  2. Link-Up Play
    Struggles with hold-up play especially when playing with his back to goal and connecting with teammates. Better decisions and improved passing would round out his game.
  3. Decision-Making
    Often shoots when he should pass. Needs sharper awareness and simpler choices in the final third.
  4. Finishing Consistency
    Can score spectacular goals but lacks composure on easier chances. Needs to become more dependable.
  5. Tactical Intelligence
    Mistimes runs or fails to read the game flow. Improving awareness and off-ball movement would elevate his threat level, especially learning to better anticipate play and stay onside.
  6. Subtlety & Variation
    Heavily reliant on brute force. Adding more nuance – dropping into space, varying runs, linking deeper, or moving between lines. – would make him less predictable.

Tactical Fit & Role

Best Role: Direct Centre-Forward / Vertical Threat

Beto is built for transition football – a striker who thrives when there’s space to attack. Despite his size, he’s not a traditional target man – he’s a powerful, wrecking-ball forward, an unpredictable and powerful force, hard to stop when running beyond defenders.

Beto Under Sean Dyche

System & Style

Dyche’s Everton typically played in a 4-4-1-1 or 4-5-1 with tactical emphasis on:

  • Defensive shape and compactness
  • Direct transitions – long balls, set-pieces, and second-ball battles
  • Physical wide play
  • Hard-working forwards who press, battle and run channels

Beto, by nature, suited this vertical football style – where the ball went forward early and often – especially in games where Everton sat deep and went direct. He was mostly used as a rotational option or impact sub behind Calvert-Lewin.

Beto Under David Moyes

Moyesball in Summary

Moyes’ teams (from peak Everton to modern-day West Ham) prioritise:

  • A solid organised defensive shape (4-2-3-1 or 4-4-2)
  • Counter-attacking wide play
  • Heavy reliance on direct play, set-piece and high work-rate forwards
  • Big strikers who hold the ball, win headers, occupy centre-backs and cause problems

Examples: Ferguson, Fellaini, Jelavić, Stracqualursi, Arnautović, Antonio – all chaotic but effective.

Beto’s Role in a Moyes System: Chaos-Creator Forward

Beto fits into the classic Moyes striker role mould:

  • Not necessarily refined, but big, aggressive, and dangerous
  • Excellent at running channels and using pace/strength – Johnson
  • Could thrive with coaching that simplifies his game (e.g. hold the ball, pin defenders, attack crosses and shoot on sight)

Moyes loves a forward who ‘makes life miserable’ for defenders. Beto can do that

Why He Fits Moyes’ Blueprint

Physical Presence

·         Moyes builds around strong centre forwards who can lead the line, win duels, and create a reference point for the attack

·         Beto’s raw power, strength in contact, and ability to muscle defenders wide fits perfectly.

Vertical Threat

·         Moyes wants fast transitions – win it deep, send it long.

·         Beto runs into space well, especially down the channels, and is a natural target for quick balls over the top.

Pressing & Graft

·         Moyes demands forwards who press and scrap. Beto presses aggressively, often forcing hurried clearances.

·         In a Moyes setup, he’d be tasked with harrying centre-backs and setting the physical tone from the front.

 

Wide Service

·         Moyes often uses hard-working wide players who cross frequently (e.g., Bowen at West Ham).

·         Beto’s aerial ability – while not elite – makes him a dangerous box presence, especially from second balls or knockdowns.

Beto’s Tactical Challenges & Limitations

·         Hold-Up Play Still Developing: Moyes strikers often need to bring others into play. Beto can be sloppy with his touch and passing.

·         Link-Up With Midfield: Moyes values structured play and intelligent combinations. Beto isn’t naturally tidy or creative.

·         Decision-Making: Moyes sides rely on ruthless execution when chances come. Beto can rush or misread moments.

Moyesian Development Track

Moyes has a history of developing raw forwards. With the right guidance, Beto could:

  • Simplify decisions
  • Improve back-to-goal play
  • Learn when to press vs. when to drop

He could grow from chaos merchant to trusted starter – much like Michail Antonio did over time.


Potential Roles Under Moyes

1. Lone Striker in 4-2-3-1

  • The Antonio role: Run hard, occupy defenders, chase lost causes, get on the end of crosses.
  • Less about finesse – more about pure disruption and giving the midfield time to push up.
  • Needs a No. 10 who can operate in tight places, wide players who can recycle possession and cover for high pressing.
  • Ideal players to support: central attacking midfielders (Josh Brownhill, Maddison, Eze), inverted wingers (McNeil, Diaby), overlapping fullbacks (Patterson, Myles Lewis-Skelly)  

Why it works: Beto pins defenders, a smart 10 exploits space, and the chaos creates second chances.

2. Strike Partner in 4-4-2 or 3-5-2

  • Moyes has used two up front when chasing games. Beto + Calvert-Lewin could be a physical, aerial pairing.
  • Could also pair with a more mobile second striker like Danjuma (if he returns), Kudus, Ryan Christie, Jesé Lingard, Maddison or McNeil, João Pedro, Bryan Mbeumo allowing Beto to stay central.
  • Works with direct wingers such as Richarlison (Everton version), Harvey Barnes, Cody Gakpo,

Other players ideal for this system Jonathan David, Che Adams, Troy Parrott or Gift Orban at Lyon (could be loaned)

3. 4-3-3 or 3-4-3 with space ahead of him

  • 4-3-3 system is less ideal unless Beto is used situationally because he’s not great at linking play with wide forwards and he may become isolated
  • 3-4-2 Needs:
    • Wingers who stretch play and deliver early crosses or cutbacks (Moussa Diaby, Leon Bailey, Anthony Gordon, Karamoko Dembélé, Tahith Chong, Dario Osorio, Patson Daka, Youssef En-Nesyri and Keinan Davis).
    • A midfield that can launch fast transitions.
    • Avoid slow, possession-heavy systems where he’s expected to break down low blocks alone.

4. Impact Super Sub

Right now, Beto could be a really effective Plan B – a chaos agent who comes on when defenders are tired or when you’re playing on the break. He can stretch the pitch, cause panic, and scrap for goals that more polished strikers might not even contest.

Could he become more than that? Possibly. But he’d need:

  • Coaching that simplifies his role.
  • Regular minutes in a consistent tactical setup.
  • Confidence – he’s streaky, and you can see when his head drops.
  • Pairing with a poacher (Dominic Calvert-Lewin) to feed off chaos
  • A late-running 10 (like Doucoure)
  • A wide player switching central (McNeil or Harrison drifting inside)

Best Team Style for Beto:

  • Counter-attacking or direct systems.
  • Situations where the ball is turned over quickly and he’s facing goal.

Summary

Beto: The Beautiful Chaos Everton Never Knew They Needed

If you asked Evertonians what they wanted in a striker last summer, most would’ve said: Someone who can actually stay fit, ruffle a few defenders, and knows where the goal is. What Everton got was Beto — a whirlwind of limbs, pace, and unpredictability. And honestly? He’s not been boring for a second.

At his best, Beto offers something the team have sorely lacked when DCL isn’t at full tilt: an outlet. He charges channels, stretches backlines, and gives Tarkowski and Pickford a reason to aim long without feeling guilty. He doesn’t hold the ball up like DCL, but what he does do is rattle defenders. There’s a rawness to him — a battering ram with a turbo button.

His finishing? Let’s say it’s… inconsistent. One minute he’s burying a low drive like he’s prime Drogba, the next he’s booting it into Row Z from six yards. But what fans can’t deny is the effort. Beto works, he presses, and he runs defenders into the ground. And sometimes, that’s all you need to shift the momentum.

He’s not a finesse player. He’s not going to knit play together like Firmino (and let’s face it, Everton don’t need him to). But as a second striker in a 4-4-2 or an impact sub when the game turns frantic, Beto brings chaos — and that chaos can be a weapon.

Under Moyes, there’s real potential. If Everton go classic: two strikers, one big, one mad – Calvert-Lewin and Beto might just become the most battering forward duo this side of Stoke 2011.

For fans, Beto is hope. Not polished. Not perfect. But very Everton: scrappy, determined, and capable of the odd Jagielka or Tarkowski thunderbolt when it matters most.


© ToffeeWeb