Goodison’s Greatest Games: Everton 6-3 Bournemouth
Everton came out firing from the first whistle in this nine-goal thriller against Bournemouth back in 2017.

Saturday, 4 February 2017
Everton came out firing from the first whistle in this nine-goal thriller against Bournemouth back in 2017. Games against the Cherries have so often produced plenty of goalmouth action during their two spells in England’s top-flight, but this one was perhaps the most entertaining of the lot.
Everton were pushing for European qualification at this point in the season, and needed a result at home to Eddie Howe’s side. Inside the opening minute, Romelu Lukaku set the tone of the afternoon when he played a quick one-two before cutting inside to curl an effort into the left-hand side of the goal, leaving the Bournemouth keeper with no chance. 1-0 to Everton.
From the sublime to the ridiculous for Everton’s second goal in the 23rd minute. Lukaku worked his magic on the right-hand side of the box before cutting the ball back to James McCarthy, whose first effort bounced back to him off a Bournemouth defender and, before he could react, the ball then bounced off the Everton midfielder and somehow made its way into the back of the net. 2-0 Everton.
Bournemouth were architects of their own downfall for Everton’s third goal of the game just six minutes later. A terrible pass into their own penalty area landed straight at the feet of Lukaku, who coolly placed the ball over the onrushing Artur Boruc to hand the Toffees a 3-0 lead at the interval.
In typical Everton style, Bournemouth were allowed to get back into the match, a match that had looked done and dusted at the halfway point. The Cherries scored twice through Josh King, a future Everton loanee, making the scoreline 3-2 and making Goodison a very nervous place.
However, up stepped Lukaku. Coleman’s cross from the right-hand side was volleyed in left-footed by the big Belgian striker to complete his hat-trick and put the Toffees 4-3 in front with seven minutes of the 90 remaining. But still the action was not over. Less than a minute later, Lukaku was at it again, getting on the end of a sublime back-heeled through ball from Ross Barkley to score his fourth goal of the game and end any faint chances of a Cherries comeback.
However, Bournemouth did manage to pull another goal back through Harry Arter in the 90th minute, one that was even scrappier than McCarthy’s in the first half. 5-3 to Everton but still time for the Blues to have the last laugh.
In stoppage time, a long ball forward found its way to Barkley, whose performance deserved a goal. The attacking midfielder dodged Boruc and, before even putting the ball into the back of the empty net, celebrated Everton’s sixth and the game’s ninth goal. A celebration that caused some controversy within the footballing world, but one that most Evertonians absolutely loved.
The match went down in history as Everton’s joint-highest scoring game at Goodison Park during the Premier League era, and one that the fans will never forget.
Starting Lineups
Everton: Joel (GK), Coleman, Williams, Funes Mori, Baines, McCarthy, Barry, Schneiderlin, Barkley, Lukaku, Lookman.
Bournemouth: Boruc (GK), Francis, Cook, Mings, Fraser, Arter, Surman, Gosling, Pugh, Wilshere, King.
Scorers:
Everton: Lukaku (1’,29’,83’,84’), McCarthy (23’), Barkley (90+4’);
Bournemouth: King (59’, 70’), Arter (90’).
Attendance: 39,026
Reader Comments (3)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()
2 Posted 10/12/2025 at 15:41:18
Through my bleary eyes, it looked as though we had been beaten 3 - 0. Was I relieved next day when I read the score correctly.
3 Posted 10/12/2025 at 16:34:09
It's a goal I will never forget because I'd put a tenner on Everton to win 5-2, at odds of 100/1, and I was absolutely fuming because I could see from my seat on the back row of the Upper Glawdys Street Stand that the ball had clearly gone out of play.
Everyone was smiling when Barkley scored our sixth except for probably me, who was walking out the ground shaking my head thinking, that would have ended up five - fucking - two, only for those shite officials.
If only they'd had VAR, in those days eh…. Not really, I can't stand it!
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
How to get rid of these ads and support TW


1 Posted 10/12/2025 at 15:13:28
It would be nice if there was a link to the highlights in the article so we could live it again.