Let me just start this post by stating my bona fides. I was a student in 1983. I saw every game for 4 years so I was very lucky.
I was at Spurs in 1985 when Neville Southall made that save against Falco. I was at Hillsborough when he literally won the game on his own. The save from Varadi was the best save I’ve ever seen.
But then, in 2017, we signed Jordan Lee Pickford. It’s fair to say it took him a while to settle down, the goal he conceded at Anfield was definitely the low point but, in the last 5 years, he’s been nothing short of exceptional.
His stats are great but they don’t really don’t do him justice. We would not be a Premier League club without him.
So it may be an unpopular opinion… but Jordan is the better keeper for me. He’s just played in a poorer side.