On Monday, Romelu Lukaku bowed out from international football.
Lukaku made his Belgium debut in 2010. He went on to score 94 goals in 135 games for the Red Devils. He retires as his nation’s record goalscorer. He is the third-most capped player in Belgium’s history.
It has been almost 10 years since Lukaku left Everton, and there’s an argument to suggest that, of all the pitfalls of the Farhad Moshiri era, allowing the striker to walk out of Finch Farm on that strange day back in early 2017, without having signed the new contract that all parties thought they had agreed on, was the biggest error of them all.
On that decisive contract non-signing, Lukaku made his own decision, but had Everton really done all they could to make it sure that he would not go back on his commitment to sign? Lukaku would have been worth breaking the bank for — £250,000 a week would have been doable at the time, and worth every penny.
Because goals win you games; they buy you time. Would Mauricio Pochettino be quite as highly thought of as a coach had he not had the goals of Harry Kane to lean back on during his time at Tottenham, for example?
Speaking of Kane, he is perhaps a fitting comparison to Lukaku.
Kane is two months younger than Lukaku, but when the latter did leave Everton for Man Utd in 2017, there was little to separate them in terms of quality.
Lukaku plundered 68 Premier League goals in 141 games, making him the club’s record scorer in the competition. Kane, in comparison, had scored 78 top-flight goals for Spurs by the end of the 2016-17 season; hardly a huge difference.
When Lukaku left Everton, he had netted 87 goals in all competitions and laid on 26 assists. He was superb, and probably one of the only truly world class players the Toffees have had during their prime in the Premier League era.
Yet he was divisive character at the time, and he has been a divisive character since. Some Evertonians simply never seemed to take to him, and Lukaku definitely didn’t help when he often spouted off about his desire to play in the Champions League while he was off on international duty.
Lukaku perhaps learned that the grass isn’t always greener when he went off to Manchester United. He netted 42 goals in 96 games, but he moved on to inter in 2019. It was in Milan that he had his most successful stint when it came to trophies, as he became a Serie A champion. He moved back to England with Chelsea in 2021, but that move did not go according to plan.
From there, Lukaku became something of a nomadic striker flitting between some of Italy’s biggest clubs. Back to Inter, then to Roma, and then two seasons at Napoli, the first of which came with a Serie A crown, the second of which was blighted by injury.
Now, Lukaku is largely out of sight and out of mind at Fenerbahce. Kane, on the other hand, has just won the Ballon d’Or.
So, as Lukaku looks back on his international career, will he, perhaps, also reflect on his club journey, and will he think back to his time at Everton and regret that he did not stay on? Could things have been different, for both he and the club, had he signed that deal in 2017?
And would he get more credit? His tally of international goals is bettered by only 4 men: Cristiano Ronaldo, Lionel Messi, Ali Daei and Sunil Chhetri. Kane (93) is hot on Lukaku’s heel.
But will he ever really be thought of as one of the great goalscorers? It’s unlikely. Instead, he’ll be seen as a bit of a journeyman. And I can’t help but think that, had he just stuck around in 2017, had Everton really pushed the boat out to keep him, then things could have been so different.
See – Can you top the ToffeeWeb table? Join Dixie60, ToffeeWeb’s free prediction game
Read more – Jack’s back: Grealish has apologised to Everton, now it’s time to move forward