Which striker could be a January transfer window solution for Everton?

Patric Ridge
19/11/2026
Richarlison

When the transfer window came to a shuddering close in August, and Everton were left with only Thierno Barry as a recognised senior striker option, then we all feared the worse.

It wasn’t a gamble by Everton; it wasn’t a calculated risk. It was simply inadequate planning and a failure to get an (admittedly expensive) Folarin Balogun deal over the line.

The irony is, it has so far worked out, with Barry thriving as of late. He has taken on the mantle of being Everton’s first (only) choice forward, and run with it.

But, let’s not make believe that it’s all okay. Everton still need a forward, and it needs to be a top priority heading into the winter transfer window. 

However, whereas Balogun would have come in as one of the club’s most expensive signings, and probably as David Moyes’ primary option, Barry has made it clear: Everton now have to look primarily for a back-up; an experienced rotation option to help ease the burden, but also lend Barry a lesson or two.

And given the uncertainty over The Friedkin Group’s commitment, it could even be that Everton must look at a loan or a low-budget permanent move.

The below list might seem uninspiring, but let’s stress, this is based on Everton having a limited budget, with limited choices available in a winter window, when it is generally considered more difficult to do business.

I’d love to be shocked, but for now, here’s a few potential options.

Richarlison

Had matters gone differently late in the transfer window, of course, Richarlison might well have been an Everton player.

It would have been ludicrous had Everton splashed out £30M+ to sign the 29-year-old, but Tottenham need him off the books, and with just a few months left on his contract, perhaps the opportunity would be there again to strike a deal.

The issue would be Richarlison’s wages, combined with the fact he has not featured at all this season for the first team. If he is unfit, there’d be little point in signing him for an instant impact.

Tammy Abraham

Everton made a late loan move for Abraham on deadline day, as they began to waver on signing Balogun. Aston Villa were open to allowing the 29-year-old to leave, but Abraham did not want to join Everton.

However, he is still finding gametime hard to come by; Abraham has featured 11 times, but made only 1 start. He has scored 3 goals in 227 minutes of action, and could bring the experience required but also offer some genuine competition.

If Everton do some legwork with Abraham before the window opens, and Villa are still open to a temporary switch, then this could make perfect sense.

Chris Wood

Hardly the most glamorous of names, but again, these aren’t glamorous times. 

Nottingham Forest have several strikers to call upon, and Oliver Glasner has preferred to go with Liam Delap and Igor Jesus over veteran campaigner Wood, who has made just 1 start.

We all know what Wood offers, and what he doesn’t. He’s getting on, but as an experienced option, who can act as a target man if Everton need an outball.

Would only be an option on loan, though.

Jean-Philippe Mateta

Out of contract at the end of the season, Mateta probably has the most quality of any striker on this list.

But the big question mark is his fitness, with the Frenchman having seen a move to Milan collapse last January due to an underlying knee issue.

However, if he is available at a cut-price deal, given his contract situation, then this could just be the pick of the bunch. A proven goalscorer in the Premier League, and one who would not have to be expected to push himself too hard, risking that knee problem any further.

Danny Welbeck

Welbeck’s summer move for Chelsea came as a surprise to many, but in a lot of ways, it made perfect sense. Xabi Alonso wanted an experienced alternative to Joao Pedro and Emmanuel Emegha.

Welbeck was superb for Brighton, making 201 appearances for the Seagulls, scoring 51 goals and laying on 13 assists. The work he got through up top was fantastic, and provided the stage for Fabian Hurzeler’s young team to build off.

And it’s not as though Welbeck has been a flop at Chelsea. In a lot of ways, he has done what has been asked of him. He has played the role of back-up, featuring 11 times, making 4 starts and scoring 3 goals.

But there has been talk that Chelsea may wish to move him on this winter, and if that is the case, Everton would be daft not to be open to doing business.

Again, we are talking a short-term deal, here, perhaps until the end of the season or for 18 months, but there would definitely be some merit to it.

See – Can you top the ToffeeWeb table? Join Dixie60, ToffeeWeb’s free prediction game

Read more – Jack’s back: Grealish has apologised to Everton, now it’s time to move forward


© ToffeeWeb