Season › 2011-12 › News
Bily not prepared to sit on the bench
The Russian has struggled to hold down a first-term berth since his £9m from Lokomotiv Moscow and now, in his third season at Goodison, he is finding appearances fewer and further between.
A move to Wolfsburg has been mooted in recent days, with rumours suggesting it's likely he will be making a switch to the Bundesliga if a deal can be done between the clubs, as the midfielder looks towards Euro2012 in the summer.
"If the winter transfer window closes and I still find myself sitting on the Everton bench, I could not justify it," Bily told The Sun.
Quotes or other material sourced from The Sun via Sky Sports
Reader Comments (23)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
3 Posted 24/12/2011 at 05:59:26
Could we not start e-mailing petitions in to the club hq demanding answers to the 'MAIN' questions,that SO MANY fans in unison have ,???? IE; board descisions/transfers and Moyes key team/selections
ETC.??
4 Posted 24/12/2011 at 06:52:14
Moyes team selections have fuckin irked me for ages. Neville as defensive mid!!!!! I rest my case.
6 Posted 24/12/2011 at 10:23:32
7 Posted 24/12/2011 at 11:47:35
8 Posted 24/12/2011 at 12:35:20
What does that have anything to do with the fact that the guy is bone idle, can't head a ball, can't tackle, has no pace, can't make a pass etc etc etc.
He's been shite, has been given loads of chances and not performed.
The odd goal every now and again does not justify him being in the squad.
An extremely poor buy given our limited money.
Get rid for whatever we can get - if anything - and off the wage bill.
9 Posted 24/12/2011 at 12:45:55
Isn't FIT to sit on the bench... maybe not his fault, whose door does it lie by...Davy
10 Posted 24/12/2011 at 12:50:39
It seemed that once Moyes bought Bilyaletdinov he didn't know what to do with him and just shunted him out onto the wing since, 'Oh, he's got a decent left foot on him.' He should have been played in hisnatural position from the start, but of course when we signed him we had Cahill playing well there... which makes the signing of Bilyaletdinov even stranger, to my mind.
11 Posted 24/12/2011 at 14:00:32
12 Posted 24/12/2011 at 14:43:57
That's all he needs to know; his chances are gone. Bye-bye, Bily.
13 Posted 24/12/2011 at 14:44:27
If he is as good as some people make out then why has he never shone, even when not "out of position"? They guy has had about 3 or 4 good games since signing for us. If he really wanted to impress then why hasn't he?
Surely his "talent" would have enabled him to play well even when playing out wide? Osman often has to play out wide, which isn't his position either but has played more than a handful of good games doing so. Yet he ges slaughted on this site.
Get rid and buy put the Dixie Dean statue in his place; after all, they have the same amount of movement.
14 Posted 24/12/2011 at 15:05:29
15 Posted 24/12/2011 at 15:25:45
Bily shines when played in an advanced position behind a striker. He has quick feet, is intelligent and can pick out a pass and a good cross. Its not his fault if Moyes useless fucking tactics mean that bily is left trying to cross/pass the ball to 1 blue shirt in a sea of the opposition, or he's shoved out on the wing and expected to beat his man for pace.
If the guy is good enough to play for Russia - a country with 141 million people - then he should be good enough to play for us.
Moyes is tactically inept and he plays his 4-5-1 system regardless of the players he has available, rather than changing his system to suit what he has. Consequentially we often play with a right back in centre midfield, central midfielders on the wing, midfielders in the striker's role.....and we wonder why the team can't score a goal and plays some of the worst football in any league.
16 Posted 24/12/2011 at 15:39:50
Everton 3 - 0 Liverpool
Carsley and Neville CM. I rest my case!!!
17 Posted 24/12/2011 at 17:59:39
Because I can list a lot of embarrassing defeats where he has played there.
18 Posted 24/12/2011 at 18:59:14
China, India, USA and Pakistan all head Russia in the population stakes so can't see that being justification for his inclusion in our squad as those countries don't produce top footballers.
The guy is just not ATHLETIC enough...he may have the technical ability and a bit of class on the ball but he does not have what the Premier League requires...simples!
After Per Kroldrup, I think this is Moyes 2nd worst signing...(I think!)
19 Posted 24/12/2011 at 20:05:20
I'm not saying Neville should always play there but to say he cant do a job as a defensive midfielder and use it as proof that Moyes doesnt know what he is doing is rediculous.
I dont think we have ever replaced Lee Carsley who i believe was very underated, but Neville is as close to him as we have and i think we wont realise his value until he has gone.
20 Posted 24/12/2011 at 21:31:48
Anyway I digress, back to Bily....I think you're wrong when you say that he doesn't have what it takes for the Premier League. He is good enough and he does have a good set of attributes. They're just not a good set of attributes for where Moyes wants to play him.
You could go grab Lionel Messi, give him a handful of starts at centre half and then come up with some bollocks about how the guy is shit at defending set-pieces, can't out-muscle a centre-forward and can't tackle to save his life, then use that to suggest he isn't good enough for our squad or the league. Personally I'd blame the idiot who put him at centre half, not the player who has never had the ability to play there.
21 Posted 24/12/2011 at 23:39:01
Or longer, It's a Derby game ffs, a bit of mongrel in the middle never goes far wrong there... or, who else was in the team that day, the meastros for want of a better word, but the meastros can't play unless the workers push the piano on to the stage. Or even just how good were the opposition that day, what was their team.
If Carsley and Neville were stone that day did the opposition try to us the scissors aproach instead of the paper.
Carsley on his own yes, maybe. Neville on his own maybe but 99 time out of 100? Nah.
And that without even getting into the..are 2 defensive mids really needed..imo NO.
22 Posted 25/12/2011 at 01:35:47
This tells us all that we will ever need to know about Ian Tunstead and the quality of his footie nous. An absurd statement brimming with high-minded arrogance: yeah, 'I rest my case', indeed.
Shall we add up the number of poor performances by Phil Neville in centre-mid and the number of glowing match-winning performances in centre-mid by pipsqueak (oh, and by the way, like me you'll all remember the match in question and PN was very far from being our best player that day). We know the answer don't we?
Anyone who is prepared to put out 10 words, 2 numerals, and a hyphen to make the case for PN in centre-mid is utterly delusional.
24 Posted 25/12/2011 at 19:00:10
"An absurd statement brimming with high-minded arrogance: yeah, 'I rest my case', indeed. "
"Anyone who is prepared to put out 10 words, 2 numerals, and a hyphen to make the case for PN in centre-mid is utterly delusional. "
Please read post 3 by steven who i was responding to. Hopefully you will understand where that "high minded arrigance" came from. I was repeating Stevens own words.
25 Posted 25/12/2011 at 19:09:20
I think it was, so something was done right, so why not try to repeat it? As I say I don't always agree that Neville should play defensive mid but to say he can't play there is rediculous. Do you want to go and argue with SAF about it as well who also used to play him there? No, I thought not, but Moyes is fair game.
27 Posted 26/12/2011 at 04:08:19
Moyes made a mistake hoping Bily would work out. Fair enough. Even that hope isn't really a mistake.
Bily has to go because he can't cut it in the league. Moyes, or any EPL manager, has nothing to do with it.
So goodbye Bily. I started to write good riddance too, but have to say I have no reason to express meanness. I accept absolutely that every time Bily played, he did his best. We all saw how good his best was.
The MOP blames Moyes for Bily's shortcomings. What's new? Bily's like most players taking a crack in a top league. He's not good enough. Happens every day all the time.
We have younger players on the roster better than him. Goodbye and good luck Bily. Just go for God's sake.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
2 Posted 24/12/2011 at 02:22:32