Nigel Martyn sees 2005 similarities as Everton chase European return

Harry Diamond
21/11/2026
Everton

Nigel Martyn has said he sees similarities between the current Everton side and the one that secured Champions League qualification in 2005.

Everton sit sixth in the Premier League table as the Blues return from the international break, just two points outside the Champions League places. The Toffees have not featured in European competition since 2017/18, having stumbled from a promising position during last season’s run-in.

Moyes has been open in his target of securing European football, despite issues around Everton’s squad depth. Martyn, who formed part of the side that secured a fourth-place finish in 2004/05, said he can see similarities between how Moyes built that side and the current team.

Nigel Martyn sees similarities between David Moyes’ Everton and 2005 side

Speaking to ToffeeWeb as part of the Once a Blue podcast, the former Everton goalkeeper said: “Yeah, I do [see similarities]. The lone striker, and trying to get midfielders around him. Dewsbury-Hall you could say is quite similar to Tim Cahill because he does get goals and controls the midfield quite a lot. There’s a slight similarity there.

“Everton are based around a very solid defence. The Everton side today are defensively very, very strong. The back four is really strong and the goalkeeper is obviously really, really strong.

“I think David, the way he likes to get things done is to make sure we’re solid at the back and then solid in midfield so we don’t get overrun. And then, you know, you see what you can achieve.

“You’ve got to have two, three, maybe even four luxury players that are capable of winning you the game. It’s what he brings in, so he will give them the freedom and, the rest of you, you’ve got the responsibility of making sure you keep everything nice and tidy at the back.”

Martyn reflected on Everton’s Champions League qualification, the club’s highest league finish across the last 37 years. He said that, although there was an element of overachievement, Everton’s solid spine of Premier League know-how built belief.

“I think we believed that we deserve to be there based on our performances but, if you look at it from the outside, there is an overachievement there. That goes down to firstly the manager and the way he drove us on and the levels he expected from us at all times. And then the players on the pitch carried out his instruction. We finished above the eventual Champions League winners that year across the park.

“We had that little bit of enjoyment that we’d finished above them in the league and enjoyed that, but they spoiled the party by winning the Champions League. There were probably teams that should have been finishing above us. But what we had was, first and foremost, a very solid base, some good, honest, hardworking pros that know what that league is, what is needed in that league.

“You look at Stubbs, Weir, Carsley, Kilbane, Cahill and Arteta, we kind of had the players there who knew what to do in that league to finish as high as we could. I think that was an incredible achievement given the other sides that were around us and for us to finish above them was great.”

See – Can you top the ToffeeWeb table? Join Dixie60, ToffeeWeb’s free prediction game

Read more – Jack’s back: Grealish has apologised to Everton, now it’s time to move forward


© ToffeeWeb