The Mail Bag

Negativity

Comments (2)

Sometimes I don't understand all the criticism the website comes in for. It's a fans' website, open to all fans and all their opinions. Unless you are an idiot or just a nasty piece of work you get to voice your opinion. These opinions range from Tony Marsh to Richard Dodd and everyone, myself included, in between. It's the job of the editorial team to run the site and keep the idiots and nasties out. Nothing more. I don't see them as having an agenda as a result.

Here's the opinion of fans out there. Have a read and see what you think. Fair enough in my view. And yes, as fans, they are as entitled as anyone else to throw their tuppence worth in, either in responses or in their own pieces. So let them at it. When you think about it, neither your local boozer or your workmates are as egalitarian about your football loyalties.

When I think of it too, the crap I've posted when tired, sulking in work or just plain frustrated with the club that I have cringed over afterwards, I am amazed that I still get to have my say. As a result I cannot really afford to take the moral high ground with anyone. (I've done it once or twice and felt a muppet afterwards so apologies to all concerned.) As a result I don't understand why people feel the need to complain about posts.You know what you're getting, like it or don't log on.

In fairness too, none of us have the definitive opinion on any subject related to the club yet we all get our say. What more do you want? There's always the official club site I suppose.
Kieran Fitzgerald, Dublin     Posted 12/06/2007 at 18:07:38

back Return to the Mail Bag

Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Lyndon
It shouldn't need saying but thanks for articulating that, Kieran. Unfortunately, despite the relatively high standard of contributions that we try to attract and foster, some people can only seize upon the negatives. Over on the Bluekipper forum, some members have an irrational hatred of ToffeeWeb because of some perceived agenda on our part to destroy anyone currently connected with the club. A post ripping us to shreds is roundly cheered but any praise of an article posted on these pages gets barely a ripple as people are afraid to be seen as consorting with the enemy to agree.

We're all Blues, we just have different expectations and ways of conveying them. A guy like Tony Marsh — I keep bringing him up because his post this past weekend attracted such a violent reaction by some — can't be faulted for his passion even if you don't like the way he makes his points. That's what this is site is about — if you've got something to say, we'll provide you a forum for your views. It enriches the debate and expands the content we can offer our readers. Seems like a good deal to me...

Gareth
1   Posted 13/06/2007 at 02:59:40

Report abuse

Just a quick thought, has the number of criticisms of the editorial policy dropped since the new format has been introduced?

I felt that there was a time where every anti Moyes, Kenwright, Wyness etc etc comment was greeted with a huge welcome from you guys and every positive comment was roundly scorned as "IMWT" or the "Moyessiah" jibes.

With the new format I think a more balanced view is available and the whole site ’feels’ more accessible.

I think you’ve done a sterling job and even though I don’t always (often) agree with your opinions I thoroughly enjoy reading them.

Cheers Guys
Matt Traynor
2   Posted 13/06/2007 at 05:43:49

Report abuse

The one thing you can guarantee with football is it will polarise opinions.

I agree with Lyndon - I think the diversity of contributions here is great, and whilst Michael, Colm and others may make comments that people don’t agree with - it is just their opinion.

I think BlueKipper does toe the ’party line’ - backed up by the interviews with Wyness and the fans events they arrange with the support of the club. That said, they do a good job - I don’t think ’do I log on to TW or the BK site’ - I read both. They’re very different, but for exiles like me, vital for keeping up to date with what’s happening.

© ToffeeWeb