The Mail Bag

Fernandes the “luxury player”?

Comments (10)

I still can't understand why Fernandes is being labeled a luxury player. Where I sit in the stadium he looks the full package. He has got a good passing range, skills, strength, pace and he can tackle.

What is a luxury player? If its someone who can change a game then thats what Fernandes is. I see everyone questioning him. He dosen't defend. He dosen't track back. He dosen't dominate. For one he is not there to defend he is there to create. If anyone is going develop his workrate and defensive abilities it is David Moyes. Probably one of the most defensive minded managers in the premiership.

What sort of player is Arteta? He is our best player by about a mile yet he is not someone who is going to take the game by the scruff of the neck. The fact of the matter is Fernandes is going to be a big miss and we will notice next season. Who is going to do a better job than him next season? Phil Jagielka??? Some People have got it into their heads that Jagielka is a midfielder. Ask any Sheffield Utd fan and they will tell you he is a cental defender. He can do a job like Neville but is just as limited.

If Nugent is worth £10 million and Scott Parker worth £7M then Fernandes is a bargain at £12M. We are missing out on a player who could move us up a gear.
Connor Rohrer, Toxteth     Posted 16/06/2007 at 16:04:46

back Return to the Mail Bag

Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Baz Longdon
1   Posted 16/06/2007 at 23:17:11

Report abuse

he played brilliantly tonight against israel u21?s, completly bossed midfield and scored with an absolute bullet from just outside the box. im really pissed off were not even gonna attempt to sign him :( Fernandes, Arteta and Cahill...for the first time ever we would have had a truly world class midfield !!!
Bert Farthingay
2   Posted 16/06/2007 at 23:50:11

Report abuse

I think Connor is spot on. Fernandes was excellent tonight. He made them tick. People need to stop being negative and face reality. The only flaws in his game he has is tracking back. He will make us much better but people are critisising him. Name one bad game he had last season? A luxury player is someon like Van Der Meyde. Ten minutes of class and 80 of anynonity.
Kev Kendall
3   Posted 16/06/2007 at 23:42:05

Report abuse

FFS, why are so many people being so negative?
Fernandes has said he wants to join, but we can't buy him because of the dual ownership, or at least we can't until we sort it out, and with him being away at the moment, as with Nugent, Baines, and whoever else is in the same tournament, nothing will be done until its conclusion.
Jagielka also wants to join, apparently, so it's only a matter of time before the hearing is out of the way and we find out for certain.
Barry Bragg
4   Posted 17/06/2007 at 00:39:52

Report abuse

Well, if Fernandes is that good and £12M a bargai,n why aren?t there a queue of top clubs waiting to take him and why are Benfica soooo keen to get rid. In actual fact there isn?t any other club remotely interested in him at that price and despite his talent I am not surprised. If he is worth £12M then Arteta is worth about £40M and he isn?t ....Arteta is worth about £12M and Fernandes about £3M-£4M. Moyes knows more about his players than any of us and he knows what Fernandes is worth ...and its not £12M.
Jorge meiro Costa
5   Posted 17/06/2007 at 01:32:11

Report abuse

I'm sorry, Barry, but that is just a load of shit. Manuel actually fell out with Benfica. And if Arteta is so good then why aren?t any big clubs coming in for him? To me, if you compare Fernandes and Arteta, they are both very similar players. Both skillful and creative players. But Arteta does not have Fernandes?s strength or pace. Fernandes will be a better player in my opinion and the fact that he is also 4 years younger. How is he worth £3-4 million. Barton is going for £5.8 million. Scott Parker is going for £7 million. So how the fuck is Fernandes that cheap?
Baz Longdon eh ???
6   Posted 17/06/2007 at 06:24:46

Report abuse

lol @ fernandes only being worth 3m-4m !!!!

he will be signed up by a big club soonish and in 2-3 years he will be worth about 20m +.

along with ronaldo, moutinho, and nani he is seen as the future of portugese soccer.

Lue Glover
7   Posted 17/06/2007 at 08:14:16

Report abuse

All this debate about Manny is probably academic because it’s unlikely that he’ll sign for us. I really hope I’m wrong though.
He was excellent last night and as when he lost the ball just outside his penalty area he executed a very skilful tackle about 10 yds in front of the goalkeeper to win it back. He made a mistake and made up for it immediately. Ok, Israel are hardly world class opposition but I’ve watched Portugal in every game and he has certainly got better with each match. He only played for us a handful of times, I’m pretty certain that a consistent run in the team would have produced more lovely football. His passing is deadly accurate and splits defences like a knife.
Manny brought a dimension to our game that no one in the existing set up (except San Mikel) can bring. M & M got the crowd Ole’ing on a couple of occasions, when did we last hear that at GP?
Call me picky but 12 million Euros is a lot less than £12 million quid. Personally, when you look at how the prices for players is going up by the second, I think he’d be worth every penny. Now that Portugal are out of the competition maybe there will be some clarity over his future. I’ll be crossing fingers and toes that they find a way of bringing him to us.
Bernard Beaumont
8   Posted 17/06/2007 at 09:14:44

Report abuse

Too many people have swallowed Moyes?s careful slagging off of the player towards the end of the season. Sure he would be buying ?potential? but that?s what talent spotting is all about. "We?re buying the finished article," he said when he signed Beattie ? and then set about changing everything about his game. Believe NOTHING this or any football manager ever tells you!
John Holmes
9   Posted 17/06/2007 at 17:17:22

Report abuse

What I find slightly odd about all this is Fernandes made this quote about not coming on Wed/Thu or before yet nothing has come out from the club or on the official site.

I know they’re not the best at volunteering information but if negotiations really had been abandoning they’ve generally told us that kind of thing. I’m still warily hopeful that there’s talking going on behind the scenes. Maybe Everton are testing Benfica’s resolve with a period of silence. I dunno, maybe I’m wrong but one report in one newspaper with no backup does sound rather dubious. Especially the Daily Mail.
john foat
10   Posted 18/06/2007 at 10:43:21

Report abuse

yea conner good prospect but needs to get up and down the park a bit more, tends to go missing at times not worth 12 mill

© ToffeeWeb