The Mail Bag
Deja vous vu 1958-59
Comments (13)
I wasn't there today, but I was there early on in 1958-59, when we lost 1-6 at home to Arsenal. On the previous Saturday, I'd seen us lose 1-4 at home to Tom Finney and ten other Preston players. I thought it couldn't get any worse. I was wrong, the next home fixture was against Arsenal, then a very mediocre outfit. We lost 1-6.
Three positives emerged from that game. Derek Temple scored the Everton goal and it was his first in the league for the club. A week later, Bobby Collins was signed and no player in my 50+ years of watching Everton has ever had a bigger impact on the club than that wee man. He was an absolute genius, who almost single handedly transformed an awful ageing team into a credible top outfit. Then, thirdly, the incompetent Buchan was sacked and Carey was brought in to begin a great period in Everton's history.
Do I think that today's result will have similar positive outcome? No!
Every recent season sees Everton dreadfully under-prepared for the start of the season. Every recent season sees us refusing to sign players until the last week in August. And every recent season sees us making a great run between October and March.
Without Arteta, there is not a creative player on the books. Since Carsley went, we have struggled to hold the midfield defensively... and last season we used a 4-6-0 formation which was pragmatic, but lacking in ambition or fluency.
Some may trust in Moyes; I think he's a good manager with little resources and a man who distrusts talent.
We could well struggle. I hope this result was an aberration, but it may not be.
Rick Tarleton, Posted 15/08/2009 at 17:09:06
Comments
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 15/08/2009 at 20:55:23
3 Posted 15/08/2009 at 20:59:27
4 Posted 15/08/2009 at 20:55:21
2 positives for me hopefully. That is the last of Hibbert and Osman. Between both of them, no pace, no basic football brain. A simple pass to a team mate is beyond Hibbert. I know it’s easy to blame them but you can’t doubt the evidence your own eyes see.
It’s only one game albeit a bad one, but I won’t panic till nearer Xmas. We are never going to play like Arsenal but you can still dream we can.
5 Posted 15/08/2009 at 22:08:41
I watched the game in a North London pub packed with gooners and the most humiliating experience of all was when we scored they actually cheered it more loudly than any of their own scores. The truth is I rather thought they might and was hoping we wouldn’t score.
I’ve just been reading Neville’s comments on the OS I don’t know whether to laugh or cry. It seems we don’t know how to defend. We’ll Phil let me tell you and this may come as a surprise but since we lost Carsley we can’t seem to win a tackle in the middle of the park either. How many times did Neville pass the ball backwards? I lost count, only for it to be hoofed back up the park.
I thought I’d never have to witness the Hibbert - Osman combination ever again following the FA Cup Final debacle but I was wrong. Please no more excuses these two aren’t even squad material an absolute disgrace the pair of them. I’d now like to add Neville to that, he should never play in the middle again. He can’t pass, can’t tackle, he just seems to confuse everyone around him and serves no meaningful purpose.
We desperately need a holding midfielder. What really galled me was Neville’s attitude you’d expect a team captain to be balling the players out but then he could hardly do that as he was bloody awful himself.
6 Posted 15/08/2009 at 23:09:51
Does that mean that if we lose a 2nd game, a la 1984, we will win the Title?
That sort of thinking is why casinos keep making a profit... The dice/cards/football fixtures have no memory, heads or odds or black or 2004 doesn’t mean next time it will be tails or evens or red or 2009.
The writing that was on the wall, and has been for years, was covered over along with the cracks by the paper that was SAF taking a chance with his B-team in the semi-final.
Too many seem to have the memory/attention span of Bob the Goldfish.
Cue Topol: Lord, who made the Lion and the Lamb, would it spoil some VAST eternal plan, if Bill was a wealthy man?
7 Posted 15/08/2009 at 22:39:43
Perhaps all of us in some way are responsible for this catastrophe, ce sacre foutoire — this fucking shambles. There seemed to be a sentiment of uncertainty. Nobody was sure whether to cheer or jeer, laugh or cry, go or stay. So, Fabregas said to himself, fuck it, I think I’ll take a stroll through the park and deposit the ball in the net on my way out.
The alternative is, of course, deja vu, with the vu being the passe compose form of voir the French verb to see. Literally "already seen". This phrase summons up Nietzsche’s idea of eternal return. He wrote: "Must not whatever can walk have walked on this lane before? Must not whatever can happen have happened, have been done, have passed by before? And if everything has been there before — what do you think, dwarf, of this moment?"
Such a notion has been challenged many times, most notably, I fancy, by Milos Kundera in his novel, The Unbearable Lightness of Being. I have to say I side with Kundera. Surely, nothing ever really repeats itself totally.
You can be beaten 4-1 twice but the two matches will have been played in different ways. So I suppose what I am trying to say is, fuck it, it was a one-off. Everton will recover and do quite well. This game will fade into memory and there will be others to savour against lesser opposition. But we have to be realistic. The team we were hoping to overtake this season just beat us 6-1. And that’s a bit heavy.
Editorial Team
8 Posted 16/08/2009 at 02:00:44
9 Posted 15/08/2009 at 22:58:56
Individually and collectively it stunk with only Pienaar able to claim any credits. On the other hand, Arsenal were good with quick pass-and-move all over the park and not hoofing it all day. It's easy to slag Hibbert or Osman who are both Championship players and say Lescott shouldn't play but who do we have in reserve? Shane Duffy??? With all due respect, I wouldnt know if I fell over him yet he was on the bench today!!
Others were just as bad. Jo is as bad as any striker we've had in 20 years and there are some puddings in that list!! Fellaini is slower than my mother and she's 77!! He isn't a Premier League player let alone €15 million.
So how do we change it??? Without influx of cash, we don't. Simples. We just try to get as many points as we can off those around us to ensure safety and don't waste our time dreaming of Champions League as we are light years away from there. Sell Lescott as it's the only way we can strengthen the SIDE not just the squad and use the money to get some quality because, without Arteta, we have none. Rodwell looks like he could do it but are we going to rely on an 18-year-old kid to lead us through a long hard season?
It's time to get real. Forget about whether we can push for 4th spot or not as tonight gave us that answer loud and clear. Without investment, last season will be as good as it gets. And all the KEIOC romantics need to wake up as, without Kirkby, there'll be no investment.
Editorial Team
10 Posted 16/08/2009 at 03:59:23
I was actually quite surprised when he chose to take them off. Of course by them it was far too late to change the game. But rest assured: we shall be seeing plenty more of them before this season is over. I don’t usually make predictions but I feel very confident about that.
11 Posted 16/08/2009 at 08:31:17
Well I did say ’hopefully’, and no doubt we will still be seeing them two players on the pitch. A good game against say Wolves, and we will see even more of them. Maybe the man who picks them might need to answer questions in what he really sees in them.
12 Posted 16/08/2009 at 08:53:05
13 Posted 16/08/2009 at 10:58:15
"Do you remember when we lost 6-1 at home to Arsenal? Oh yeah, opening day of the season wasn’t it? Yeah, I remember it well because after going to Wembley in the cup final the season before, I was expecting Everton to finally push on and challenge those CL places. Fuck me, I couldn’t have been more wrong. We signed no-one that summer and ended up in a relegation battle."
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.


1 Posted 15/08/2009 at 20:48:24