Skip to Main Content
Members:   Log In  |  Sign Up
The Mail Bag

What goes through their head?

Comments (53)

First of all, thank you, Joey Yobo for your service; you where great when we needed you but now we have grown into a much better side it was best for you to move on!

Surely Yobo going frees up £20k to £30k a week to spend on a loan signings' wages or why not just sell him, pay a loan fee... or again wages! Birmingham sign Hleb on loan who is a quality player, Birmingham's wage structure surely isn't bigger than ours! Ben Arfa signs for Newcastle on loan ? again their new wage structure isn't bigger than ours and both these players would prefer to be at Goodison than a small club and a relegation candidate.

And if we did make a late bid for Donovan or Bentley why not do it a week ago or well before Deadline Day! And Grafite from Wolfsburg, knowing Yobo was going, why not offer him the extra wages he wanted with the spare money! Or if he didn't want Yobo why not offer him to clubs weeks ago and give himself time to use the wages or loan fee instead of having an hour!

To me it seems really simple!
Chris  Hannon, Wirral     Posted 01/09/2010 at 09:49:02

back Return to the Mail Bag


Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Andrew Fair
1   Posted 01/09/2010 at 14:03:18

Report abuse

I think all fans are asking these questions but then look at majority of other teams in prem and it seems they too have a mad rush on last day of transfer window. Spurs and West Ham even trying to stop time to purchase players. I honestly think Moyes is happy with his lot and the things we heard through various sources were just rumours.

Yes we could have done with a goalscorer but is it worth wasting the wages saved on Yobo on Grafite who is a bench warmer at Wolfsburg and is unproven in Prem? We should trust Moyes and welcome Donovan in January to fire us to Europe.

David McKitt
2   Posted 01/09/2010 at 14:05:10

Report abuse

I'm still hoping they will use the wages to offer Pienaar a better contract.
Anthony Hughes
3   Posted 01/09/2010 at 14:03:38

Report abuse

It could be to the outside world that we just aren't viewed as a big club and that the likes of Newcastle, Birmingham and Sunderland are (in a lot of foreign players eyes) our equal. We don't have a high-tech, modern stadium to attract players nor do we usually pay big wages. It's 15 years since our last trophy and, other than a couple of skirmishes with the Europa League, our profile can't be that high in Europe.

I know we've had decent finishes in the Prem in recent years but I think on the whole our club as an overall entity is in a slow decline. I've mentioned before on other threads, other than selling our prized assets, where will the money come from to fund future transfers and wages to suit?

Chris Hannon
4   Posted 01/09/2010 at 14:25:16

Report abuse

David #2, good shout but I think Moyes is too stubborn to budge!
Anthony Hughes
5   Posted 01/09/2010 at 14:48:20

Report abuse

Good point regarding Pienaar, it appears that whatever we've offered isn't enough.
If he was going to sign he would have done so by now. Expect Rednapp to be back for him in the January transfer window with a dirt cheap offer. If Spurs are still in the Champions League he would suit them as he won't be cup tied
Danny Burke
6   Posted 01/09/2010 at 14:38:41

Report abuse

It always seems simple to everyone on the outside looking in, I doubt in reality it is. We are not the only club looking for players on deadline day though, everyone else seems to be at it. A slimeball, sorry I mean agent, was on Sky the other day saying that 90% of deals are initiated before the deadline day and have been going on for maybe a number of weeks. Very few come about just on deadline day.

I would liked to have seen Hleb come in, he's a good player. Hleb went to Birmingham saying "they wanted me more", not sure who "they" were but that obviously swayed him, Ben Arfa I would have liked to see to but he apparently has attitude problems.

Maybe Joey was lined up to go a while ago and his wages are spent on increasing existing players wages (arteta, Baines, Rodwell etc).
Maybe the extra money will go to Pienaar.
Maybe we need to cut costs and save that cash.
Maybe the money will halp fund a loan for Donovan in January.
The bottom line is we just do know so speculation is usless.
Franny Porter
7   Posted 01/09/2010 at 15:09:31

Report abuse

I see Jermaine Pennant went on loan to Wigan I think, would he have been worth a punt at right mid?
Ray Robinson
8   Posted 01/09/2010 at 15:23:59

Report abuse

Franny, Noooooooo!
Mike Gaynes
9   Posted 01/09/2010 at 15:58:28

Report abuse

US media say Everton made strong, repeated bids for Donovan. MLS wouldn't budge.

Jamie Morgan
10   Posted 01/09/2010 at 16:33:38

Report abuse

i agree with a lot of the questions your asking but i think we only have a little bit of info fed, probably lots more goes on and how much is pure speculation we will never know.

I would have preferred Joey to have been sold to free up funds but this way at least he is off wage bill and we may have £4mil next summer from a permanent deal.
I honestly think Donovan will be back in Jan. I just hope its full time.
Late deals on deadline day always reek of desperation to me, Sunderland lost frazier campbell for 6 months so break out a major chequebook! Stoke.....wel they are just shit and need anyboday!
Neil Steele
11   Posted 01/09/2010 at 16:36:44

Report abuse

Moyes is slow in the market, we have always known this. To go into a season without a right sided player, but with 8 players who can play central midfield is frankly ludicrous.

The squad is grossly imbalanced and the manager should have used player trading to allow us to address those issues.

Unfortunately he is outdated in his approach and his stubbornness will undoubtedly cost us big this season.

I have said it 100 times and i'll say it a 100 more until people understand; Everton FC is not in a position to carry £30m of talent on it's bench when it still doesn't have a suitable first XI.

Joke management that will completely undermine our entire season.
Jamie Morgan
12   Posted 01/09/2010 at 16:42:55

Report abuse

I blame Hibbert and Osman for not putting in transfer requests!!
Keith Slinger
13   Posted 01/09/2010 at 16:43:34

Report abuse

Grafite would not have qualified for a work permit.
David Parks
14   Posted 01/09/2010 at 16:48:43

Report abuse

The Echo state that the Yobo going will free up wages/funds for January.

Most will assume Donovan, but maybe Davey has something else up his sleeve?
Neil Steele
15   Posted 01/09/2010 at 17:07:39

Report abuse

Excellent David, what great planning...half a season without a wide right player...we will be playing catch up again by then.

Moyes never learns, same mistakes again and again and again.

Re-signing Rodwell was the most pointless thing ever. We are going absolutely nowhere now and he will be away in a couple of years anyway.

We'd have been far better served cashing in and buying the players we needed to actually make something of the here and the hope that our other top players may then be retained LONG TERM.

Under David Moyes, as well as he has done at times, we are always just "2 or 3 players away".

If he had more ability in the market and could player trade like Harry Redknapp for example, then those problems could have been addressed long ago.

In fact...the only time he has excelled in the market is when his hand has been forced by players departing against his wishes.

Food for thought.

Rodwell or Fellaini should have been sold for big money in order to allow us to address the other problem areas.

We have 8 central midfield players and not one wide right player, that is an absolutely ludicrous scenario.
Mike Elbey
16   Posted 01/09/2010 at 17:08:50

Report abuse


You have perfectly summed up our problem and the massive mistake made by Moyes this summer.

His stubbourness has cost us a massive opportunity as by selling from a position that we have a surplus could have enabled us to buy Donavan and a striker. It infuriates me to see the likes of Rodwell and Fellaini sitting on our bench when inferior players always get their shirt and we have no right sided midfielder at the club.

Someone needs to tell Moyes that selling someone to free funds to purchase someone that benefits the team and balances the squad does not make you a selling club....
Brendan O'Doherty
17   Posted 01/09/2010 at 19:25:55

Report abuse


Nonsense. The board have failed to provide the funds to Moyes for team strengthening yet again this summer. It is they you should be directing your frustrations at. If the funds had been provided for at least a loan signing, you would not even have contemplated selling one of our best players.

If we'd sold Rodwell or Fellaini to fund new signings there would have been outrage directed at the manager. Do you really think that selling 1 of our best talents would appease supporters? I think not.

We are trying to build a squad, not dismantle it.
Jay Harris
18   Posted 01/09/2010 at 20:15:52

Report abuse

totally agree.

Point well made.

The amount of flack Moyes takes on behalf of this totally inept board is beyond comprehension.

He got his winger (Gueye) but could only buy a 1 million one not the 15 million one we really need.

Presumably thats where the rumours about Rodwell started because Bill's response to needing a 15 million winger is "who can we sell to buy?".

How easy it is for Kenwright to sit back and say I'm just a supporter like you.
Joe McMahon
19   Posted 01/09/2010 at 21:11:17

Report abuse

Seeing as though Moyes paid more than any of the players, why doesn't he free up his own wages and just Piss Off. I've had it with him now, i'm sick to fucking death of the one up from since the Marcus Bent days. How on earth has he never addressed the right side of mideield problem over the last few years, and he is paid £65k a week FFS.

Before anyone says what about the days of Walter blah blah, well what about teh decades of winning throphies before Walter. 8 years and still waiting for a trophy David.
Roy Coyne
20   Posted 01/09/2010 at 22:47:58

Report abuse

Type or paste your comment here. No txt-speak, please try to use proper grammar, all-lowercase posts are likely to be deleted
Roy Coyne
21   Posted 01/09/2010 at 22:54:23

Report abuse

Sorry about that it should have said that I agree with both Jay and Brenden,why have we never got the funds for transfers? the reason is Bill is still looking 24/7 while lesser clubs seem to find investment
Afzan Yusuf
22   Posted 02/09/2010 at 01:14:15

Report abuse

I don't think DM that stupid not to realise our right side problem. I believe the situation is much more complicated that what we 'informed' fans suggesting.
However, he still need to sort it up and ASAP...
Neil Steele
23   Posted 02/09/2010 at 01:29:31

Report abuse

Brendan, simple questions for you; Have we had a surplus of something in the region of £30m+ of players on the bench or in the stands for every league game thus far this season, yes or no?

Next, does Everton have a first XI strong enough to justify this position? I'll help you...the answer to both is NO.

So, the rest is just piss and wind. I know Kenwright is a waste of oxygen, I'm not stupid. That DOES NOT exonerate David Moyes of all blame though. His attitude, stubbornness and inability to work the market have left us high and dry this season.

We have a massive surplus of central midfield players, and not one wide right player. I am sorry if it offends, but that is MORE down to piss poor management than it is to Bill Kenwright, as much of a cretin as he is. Get yourself out of Moyes's arse and you might be able to see the woods for the trees.

Jamie Sweet
24   Posted 02/09/2010 at 01:51:45

Report abuse

1. If it is true that we "made strong, repeated bids for Donovan" then surely this would suggest we had some money to bid with.

2. This would also suggest that Moyes realises that we do need another quality wide player.

3. We have known for ages that it was unlikely that MLS would let Donovan go.

If the above three assumptions are correct, why the hell haven't we lined up options other than Donovan?

I would have been happy with Hleb or Ben Arfa. Obinna who is now at West Ham is another who springs to mind. Moyes has tried to sign him before. Why not now? Is Donovan so incredible and unique that it is him or nothing? That seems rather short sighted to me.
Brendan O'Doherty
25   Posted 02/09/2010 at 01:49:36

Report abuse

"Have we had a surplus of something in the region of £30m+ of players on the bench or in the stands for every league game thus far this season"

'the answer is NO'

Your point being ?

"Get yourself out of Moyes's arse and you might be able to see the woods for the trees."

Me and the vast majority of Everton supporters are wrong then Neil, are we ?

Your view is a minority one. Maybe you should get off Moyes' back and start supporting the team.
Eric Myles
26   Posted 02/09/2010 at 02:22:18

Report abuse

The bottom line is that this year the TV money is not being doled out in 1 big lump sum at the end of August but spread over the season. So DM is not able to get in that last minute surprise player that nobody has heard of on deadline day when we receive the money.
Neil Steele
27   Posted 02/09/2010 at 08:04:11

Report abuse

Brendan, would you 'boo' David Moyes substitutions? Would you 'boo' his team off the pitch at the end of the game? I would suggest no, not ever. Well...that has been exactly the reaction of many fans at 2 of the 3 games I have been to this season. People don't do that to a man they believe in as much as you believe in Moyes.

My view is a minority view... on internet message boards, populated by lots of people who know everything but don't go to the games. And that's not a jibe... it's a fact.

When I speak to people at matches, it keeps me sane, because there is a far more balanced outlook and far less love for David Moyes. Of course, we who don't really rate him probably are still in a minority... I'll tell you what though, it's a far greater 'minority' than you find on these messageboards.

Mike Gwyer
28   Posted 02/09/2010 at 09:57:43

Report abuse


Fair comment and one that I would agree with. When in attendance you will have a full view of how shite our right side is and you will hear all and sundry complain how Moyes still sticks with players who cannot play there. After Wolves equalised I can tell you Moyes was taking a shed load of abuse.

Personally, I would love to know what Moyes thinks post match, because at Blackburn and the 2nd half against Wolves we were dire down the right. This position is now actually assisting the opposition and causing us to lose games - Moyes needs to sort it out as he seems to be going through the entire squad trying to identify who fits the bill, well it ain't Osman or Rodwell.

For me, till we can buy an out and out winger, I would get Arteta back to the right, stick big fella and Rodwell in the middle and Pienaar on the left - with Cahill and Saha up front. Sure everyone wants Arteta lording it in the middle but FFS the opposition, and I mean all the opposition know thats what we do and they compensate by putting at least 1 or 2 markers on Arteta. Then what the fuck is plan B because basically we don't have one. Additionally, at Villa park Arteta was taking abuse from the EFC fans concerning his continuous shite corners and/or free kicks. Hey I know he has off days, and for 75K per week believe me I would have a few, but is anyone allowed to touch a dead ball other than him?

Danny Burke
29   Posted 02/09/2010 at 10:57:11

Report abuse

"If he had more ability in the market and could player trade like Harry Redknapp"

This is such a myth it's untrue, Redknapp has stated over again how he has nothing to do with negotiations but gives the chairman a list of targets. Most clubs do the same.

Moyes has little to do with putting together funds or a package for another player. He identifies them and maybe has an input to the board as to their worth. It is the board who have been woeful in being able to support the manger. To blame David Moyes for the lack of transfer activity is naive at best.

Ask yourself, if you had a team that was only behind Utd and Chelsea since Christmas last year, why would you want to sell any of that squad?
Stephen Kenny
30   Posted 02/09/2010 at 11:11:25

Report abuse


When Fellaini, Arteta etc. get injured,which they undoubtedly will at some point, who steps in? Phil Neville? I'm happy that we keep hold of most of our better players.

If you were talking about clearing some of the deadwood like Vaughan, Yobo etc. then i would fully agree with you point.
Neil Steele
31   Posted 02/09/2010 at 12:32:14

Report abuse

Great responses, gents. I am glad things are finally taking off and we are getting some proper debate going at last!

Mike, thanks for that post, it is great to know that there are other people out there who can at least be balanced, if not in full agreement with me.

Danny, naive you say... that is you, not me. "Harry said" did he? Look at his record of transfer dealings, it speaks for itself. To suggest every club he has been at has coincidentally had the best negotiators in the business on their boards would be some coincidence, wouldn't you say? Also, he said about 5 hours before the deadline the other day "we are done"...then signed Rafael van der Vaart for a song! What he says and what he does are two very different things.

Further to that, there is concrete proof that Redknapp gets directly invloved, in the form of BBC footage from the documentary he was involved in with regards 'bungs'. He was clearly seen negotiating directly with agent Peter Harrison about the possible transfer of the Blackburn defender, Andy Todd... so I'm certainly not 'naive'... overly informed if anything!

Stephen Kenny, I take your point totally, and in an ideal world I would want to keep everyone. This isn't an ideal world though. It's great to have a monster squad and strength in depth... but only when you have a first XI. Everton are not in a position to have £30-40m worth of players on the bench or in the stands when we don't have a solitary right-sided player and our strikeforce looks so powderpuff. Needs must.

Including utility players, we have EIGHT central midfield players of senior standing, it's overkill. Moyes is not to blame for having no funds, but he has let us down big time with his lack of creativity IMO.

The glaring weaknesses in our side will undermine the entire campaign and, sadly, contracts or not, I think the likes of Rodwell and Arteta would be fully in their rights to look at moving on next summer should things pan out as woefully as they are looking like doing. He has let everyone down IMO, the fans and the players.

Guy Rogers
32   Posted 02/09/2010 at 13:04:12

Report abuse

Neil, you are spot on. I don't know how any Evertonian with an oodle of sense can disagree with you....

Sell a CM (for £10M) + Buy a RW (for £10M) = Parity + add Balance to the team = Improved team!
Guy Rogers
33   Posted 02/09/2010 at 13:06:33

Report abuse

Stephen when any of our shit right sided players get injured what even shiiter right sided players will we play instead???

Injuries happen its about having balance, we are in more need of cover on the right than in the middle?
Neil Steele
34   Posted 02/09/2010 at 13:12:35

Report abuse

Totally Guy. The problem we now have is that if a side can shut off Pienaar and Baines, then we are basically done as an attacking force. It wouldn't be so bad if we at least had someone better than Cahill in the hole, who could at least dribble a bit or smash one in from 25 potentially...but we don't. To pose so little attacking threat after 8 years of Moyes is, to say the least - and to use a Walter Smithism that Davey seems to have taken to recently - .....DISAPPOINTING!!!
Danny Burke
35   Posted 02/09/2010 at 15:17:56

Report abuse

I said, "To blame David Moyes for the lack of transfer activity is naive at best"

Which it is!

Never said Redknapp had the best team of negaotiators at every club, look at the mess left in his wake though, Bournmouth, Pompey, Southampton, West Ham, all been either in administration or certainly dire straights. He does love to get players in I will give you that. I have never seen this footage so will take your word for it Neil, maybe he was negotiating his own cut of the deal(insert joking smiley here).

I stand by my point that it is the board who have let Moyes and the rest of us down with lack of backing. Id rather we waited and spent our limited funds on a top player rather than waste money on some kind of stop gap like say Pennent. The problem is we should only be signing top class players now and they are harder to come by, especially with our budget.
Neil Steele
36   Posted 02/09/2010 at 16:35:03

Report abuse

Danny, the point that the board haven't provided Moyes funds isn't one anyone will disagree with. Other managers have faced these situations though. My point is simple, we have a powderpuff strikeforce and no right sided midfield player. But we have 8 players who can play central midfield.

That is a ridiculous imbalance and not one the manager should have needed fresh funds to address.

Generally, when he does move, he has signed good players. The problem is though, he is way, way too slow and seems to lack any imagination when it comes to player trading. The only time we have had any kind of serious blast in the market is when player sales have been FORCED.

You can sell a top player without it automatically making you a "selling club" you can do it for the right reasons...when it is the best solution and the right thing to do.

Conceivably we could have let either of Rodwell or Fellaini go without it weakening the team in any way shape or form.

I know Evertonians have a mental issue with this, I think it is some small minded mentality or fear of being belittled by Liverpudlians.

The fact is though, it would have been the right thing to do at this point in time and would have benefited the club.

To go into the season so piss poor offensively as we are is really criminal mismanagement on Moyes' part.
Brendan O'Doherty
37   Posted 02/09/2010 at 18:34:39

Report abuse


"Conceivably we could have let either of Rodwell or Fellaini go without it weakening the team in any way shape or form."

In theory, yes.

But do you really think either the manager OR SUPPORTERS would have tolerated losing either of those two? One who last season began to show us what he is really capable of before he got injured, and the other who in many people's opinion is one of the emerging top talents in England ? Moyes would have been on very dangerous territory if he had done that, and it would have sent out all the wrong signals.

Yes, we are imbalanced with more central midfielders than wide players. If Bilyaletdinov had turned out to anyway decent when played wide, we wouldn't be having this discussion. But he hasn't, and no funds have been provided for even a loan signing, so we are going to have to make do. Probably with Anichebe, or Coleman, or moving Arteta, or whatever. I suspect funds would have been made available for Donovan at the right price, but ONLY him, and possibly because the money could have been recouped in merchandising, etc. That one could still happen.

On your other point, as a match-going supporter you have every right to boo if you are not happy about substitutions, etc. But it is the likes of you who the players need supporting them when they are out on the pitch. You probably know this, which would explain your need to blame someone else when things don't go well. And the manager is always the easiest target.

You know as well as I do, that if Moyes does not continue to receive the backing of the majority of match-going supporters he will walk, If he does, the squad will break up and we will have to start from scratch again. With the same board and a new manager who is happy to work with no money whatsoever. It doesn't bear thinking about.
Brendan O'Doherty
38   Posted 02/09/2010 at 18:58:03

Report abuse

Mick Gwyer (#28)

"After Wolves equalised I can tell you Moyes was taking a shed load of abuse."

Proves my point about managers being an easy target for the fans' frustration.

Should not the 'shed load of abuse' have been directed at Saha who bottled out of the tackle, or the referee who didn't blow up for the foul?

Neil Steele
39   Posted 02/09/2010 at 19:17:12

Report abuse

Brendan, I don't understand your 'logic' whatsoever. I couldn't care less what Moyes or 'the supporters' would have thought about selling Fellaini or Rodwell... I only care what is best for the TEAM, the CLUB, and to ensure that Everton FC wins as many football matches as possible.

Have a read of a very long post I have made in response to Alan Clarke's fan article about Moyes on the homepage, because I don't want to repeat myself. If you can answer those points then I will better understand the justification for not selling one of these players, or Tim Cahill for example. I have gone into great detail.

And, in relation to your response to Mick Gwyer, i'd say it's more 'apologist' excuses I'm afraid. Yes is the answer to your question; you could have said both or either of those things and had a point. But that would be to hide from the fact that, irrelevant of Saha's mistake or the referee, Wolves fully deserved their equaliser on the balance of play. They came out 2nd half and penned us in... on our own ground. The Everton performance was completely unacceptable and that, I am afraid to say, is down to one man... David Moyes.

There is always an excuse to hand if you want to reach for them... it's not my way though. I want the best for the club and the best for the team. David Moyes is not that.

Brendan O'Doherty
40   Posted 02/09/2010 at 19:46:40

Report abuse

OK Neil, I can see that I'm not going to be able to persuade you to get off Moyes's back, or that we should not sell our best young players for the purposes of team strengthening.

I will be reminding you of this when we end up with Gary Megson as our next manager.

Stephen Kenny
41   Posted 02/09/2010 at 19:47:40

Report abuse


Why sell the most promising player of his generation when you could sell player's who havent had a look in for month's and are seemingly surplus to requirements?

Clearly Osman cant get in our side anywere other than the right hand side? If he's not good enough, which IMO he clearly isn't then sell him, sell Victor, throw Vaughan in and get a fee for Yobo and bob is most likely your uncle!

Sell the best player of his generation and regret it for the next decade as he smashes yet another goal past us and kisses another team's badge. We have a big enough squad to not have to do things like this anymore.
Chris Sillett
42   Posted 02/09/2010 at 19:57:03

Report abuse

Neil, *11

I agree with everything you said.
Neil Steele
43   Posted 02/09/2010 at 21:42:52

Report abuse

Brendan, another response typical of an 'apologist' I'm afraid. Once faced with irrefutable sense, revert to stupid extremes.

Gary Megson? Why... on what basis?

Is that the logic then is it... "we have to keep Moyes because... Gary Megson".

Sorry, I don't get it.

For the salary we are paying Moyes ? transfer budget or no transfer budget ? we could get a top level coach, make no mistake. I'm down to earth, my personal choice would be Mark Hughes. He is only on a 2-year deal at Fulham and we could take him out of that no problem.

Each to their own. One thing I know for sure... we have no need to be thinking we can do no better than Gary Megson. If that is where you set your expectations then it's no wonder you wildy overrate Moyes.

Brendan O'Doherty
44   Posted 02/09/2010 at 21:51:23

Report abuse

"Once faced with irrefutable sense, revert to stupid extremes."

Opinions aren't 'irrefutable sense', Neil, they are merely opinions. Yours or mine. They may make sense, but they certainly aren't irrefutable.

You seem to assume a new manager would be offered the same salary that Moyes is now on. I suspect they would have to prove that they could work miracles with no money first, before they would be offered a comparable salary. Which of course would rule out most of the best coaches, leaving us with little choice.

Whether you like it or not, most of the players seem to respect and like him. Even Yobo said as much after leaving yesterday. Sorry, I've just remembered you don't like him either after lambasting him yesterday, and having now read your post on the other thread, there doesn't seem to be many players left that you do like. So maybe then you won't be bothered when the squad breaks up after he's gone.

And although the word 'apologist' doesn't really bother me that much, your repeated use of it is becoming quite tiresome.
Ged Alexander
45   Posted 02/09/2010 at 22:13:30

Report abuse

Chaps, the top post is rubbish. Arteta is now getting £4mn a year...where does the extra money come from? A budget is a budget and our wage bill is over by a mile. So, Yobo goes adwe save £2mn a year...that wont cover Arteta's rise AND Tim's rise and Rodwell's rise.

As for Bham and Newcastle having smaller wage budgets...they both get the same TV money, Newcastle get more fans through the gate, Birmingham have a smaller debt.

Turning to Moyes...I agree with Brendan, Moyes is slow, but he probably does not want to make a mistake. The board cannot provide funds, Bill K. is not wealthy and Robert Earl has had some hard times. Jon Woods is a wealthy scouser, but he's not football-wealthy. Cash will come from sales and Moyes wont sell his best players - he has the imagination of a brick.
Anthony Hughes
46   Posted 03/09/2010 at 07:57:00

Report abuse

Money was wasted on Bily last season in trying to buy a player to play wide. I think the idea was too play Bily on the left and move Pienaar to the right but i don't think Moyes and our scouts did a good job checking Bily out as it obvious now he just wont cut it as a wide player.....£9 million pound wasted, which if spent wisely we wouldn't be having discuss selling our better players. now.

It's been mentioned by myself and others before though....where is the money going to come from in the next couple of transfer windows? It can only come from selling off players.
Les Green
47   Posted 03/09/2010 at 09:34:54

Report abuse

Something interesting in the Echo regarding Yobo's exit. The suggestion is that Yobo refused to play the away leg at Benfica. This a quote from the piece...

"But the writing has been on the wall since last autumn, ever since Yobo decided a head injury sustained before a match at Stoke meant he couldn?t board the plane for the trip to Benfica"

Tony J Williams
48   Posted 03/09/2010 at 10:46:40

Report abuse

Anthony, maybe money was wasted but he still scored more and created more goals than Pienaar, who was our "Player of the Seasom"
Anthony Hughes
49   Posted 03/09/2010 at 10:54:34

Report abuse

That's true Tony, i actually think Bily is a good player but he wasn't the type of player we needed and with a bit more homework by the coaching staff and manager then we could have spent that £9 million on a player who would have been more comfortable playing wide right. Bily's best postion may be central or just off a front man but as it been pointed we're overloaded in the central areas of midfield and i don't see him getting a start in these areas.
Tony J Williams
50   Posted 03/09/2010 at 11:07:16

Report abuse

I think that Bily will eventually take over from Cahill and will be a more skillful version, but will he score as many important goals.

It is frustrating that for years we have known we need a good right winger, we tried to get one in Simon Davies but he then decided we wanted tocome in all the time to the middle and was quickly ejected after his one goal in a season.

The problem is, is that there aren't that many, affordable, options for us, Even the England team has problems there, in that Lennon and Phillips are fast but are also shite with the final ball.

We need a good right winger, Moyes knows this but when he has actually had money to spend, has there been one for sale?
Guy Rogers
51   Posted 03/09/2010 at 12:55:24

Report abuse

Wheel and deal like 'Arry. Let that be the last word on the matter .
Neil Steele
52   Posted 03/09/2010 at 20:17:12

Report abuse

Brendan; "You seem to assume a new manager would be offered the same salary that Moyes is now on. I suspect they would have to prove that they could work miracles with no money first, before they would be offered a comparable salary."

Dear God man...what planet at are you on?

You win, I can't argue that. It's utterly fucking stupid, but I've got no answer for it.
Brendan O'Doherty
53   Posted 06/09/2010 at 02:45:44

Report abuse

This is Major Tom to Ground Control:

Here am I sitting in a tin can
Far from the world
Planet Earth is BLUE
And there's nothing I can do.....

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.

© ToffeeWeb

Latest News

Subscribe to The Athletic, Get 40% off

Online Football Betting with Betway

Bet on Everton and get a deposit bonus with bet365 at

Recent Articles

Talking Points & General Forum

Pinned Links


We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.