Skip to Main Content
Members:   Log In  |  Sign Up
The Mail Bag

No Tim: no Teeth; no Spirit

Comments (19)

It seems there has been a growing opinion amongst some fans that Tim Cahill is no longer an automatic selection in the squad and at best is an impact bench player. Over the past few seasons he has proven time after time to be our most vital player for many reasons not just goal scoring and yet still some people doubt his value to the team.

It is no surprise when Tim is out that we lack efficiency in front of goal and seem to be playing without spirit. I have lost count how many times Tim has saved our bacon in situations exactly that we found ourselves against Newcastle and Brentford. well at least these doubters have got what they wanted and are reaping the joys of not having him in the squad.

I'm not suggesting his absence is is the reason we are playing shite at the moment and we are not a one man team, but clearly he has been the victim of some unfair critique in recent times. The arguement that he played poorly early last season just isn't accurate given the circumstances.

The fact is that Tim has either scored or played a part in nearly all our goals this season and it seems that without him we are Toothless Toffees.
Peter Bourke, Sydney, Australia     Posted 22/09/2010 at 00:04:36

back Return to the Mail Bag


Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Gary Hegarty
1   Posted 22/09/2010 at 07:37:40

Report abuse

Tend to agree and it was certainly my opinion on Saturday and again this morning.
I accept that he is not the best player in the world but his heart, spirit and overall his fight are greatly absent when he doesn''t feature.
For all the guile of Arteta and Pienaar, the leadership of Neville and work effort of Baines - Cahill is the heartbeat who time and time again puts his body on the line for Everton.....not himself....Everton.
I for one appreciate what he offers even if others don't.
Jalil Noor
2   Posted 22/09/2010 at 07:58:34

Report abuse

Just to play devil's advocate.. maybe because Tim play this role so well, jut behind the striker, that DM persists in 4-5-1 formation? So even when Tim is not around he thinks he should stick to it and put another fella, who is Fella, in that role ...

I got nothing against Tim, I seriously don't but why oh why can't we just play 2 upfront FFS even when Tim is available or not? Can't any of the other strikers do a similar job? Or are they all trained to wait upfront and wait to be fed?
Thomas Christensen
3   Posted 22/09/2010 at 08:54:50

Report abuse

Can't argue with that Peter, Moyes has over the years set his team up to get the best out of Tim and he has done that.

The only come back from your point that Tim is great - what does Moyes do when Tim isn't in the team - Lose to Newcastle and Brentford??

Other managers adapt and get the best out of their remaining squad.
Lynn Thorne
4   Posted 22/09/2010 at 09:34:42

Report abuse

I have been thinking almost the exact same things.
Tim makes a nuisance of himself and keeps defenders occupied. We have no-one else who can/will do that.
BUT - we should play 2 up front when he's not available. Or playing 'lesser' opposition.
I thought Yak did ok last night - but age/pace/weight is getting to him and a striker alongside would help.
Beckford is still learning and is not a lone striker - Yak would be able to find him and he could learn a lot
Chris Rudd
5   Posted 22/09/2010 at 09:43:41

Report abuse

Peter - I wrote similar (see below) in a different thread yesterday...

"And perhaps all those who've recently been calling for Cahill's head should watch Saturday's game again. No Tim = no drive, energy or fighting spirit."

But as Lynn says, if Tim is unavailable we should be playing two up front as no-one can play that role like him - certainly not Fellaini who is presently being shoved here there and everywhere by Moyes. And one up front at Brentford is laughable.

But to get back to your original point, Cahill is an Everton legend in my eyes and stands for everything that's good about this club. Let's pray he's back giving defenders "behaviour" (thanks Mark O'Brien) at Fulham at the weekend.
Chris Fisher
6   Posted 22/09/2010 at 09:59:38

Report abuse

There's one thing I disagree with on your comments, Peter, and that is when you say you are not suggesting that his absence is the reason we are playing shite ? because his absence is the reason we are playing shite!

He may not be the most skillful player at our club but, when our backs are to the wall and we need someone to stand up and fight, Tim is the man we look to. He would've loved it last night and would've driven us on.

Guess how many points we would have if it wasn't for Tim Cahill? 0. Work it out and you'll see I'm right. Unfortunately he can't do it all on his own although he seems to be trying at the moment! Literally, apart from him and Baines, there is no one who has played well this season.

Joe Grundy
7   Posted 22/09/2010 at 12:10:52

Report abuse

Cahill has been great for the club and does his job well but Moyes doesn't play the right people in the position to replace him when he's not there. Why doesn't he give Bily a go in the position that he does well for his country and also did well for Moscow before we signed him.
Steve O'Malley
8   Posted 22/09/2010 at 12:09:23

Report abuse

Its quite simple really Aussies don't like losing no matter what the sport or what is at stake. Tim gives 200% in every game and there is not a player who marks him that doesn't know that they have been in a game when its over, ask Vidic !!
Never ceases to amaze me on this site how many people suggest that Cahill should start on the bench. If we had a few more that had his competitive streak we would be better for it.
Cahill is no Arteta on a skill level but he's not alone and there is more to his game than effort , just go over the tape of the Man.Utd game where he had a hand in all 3 goals
Chris Jones
9   Posted 22/09/2010 at 12:27:16

Report abuse

With Tim in th side we would have secured three points on Saturday and won last night. Simple as. Check out our record when he's injured it's shite.
David Booth
10   Posted 22/09/2010 at 12:22:59

Report abuse

I've never been able to understand the frequent criticism of Tim Cahill on these pages.

He may not be the most 'gifted' or technically admirable players, but boy does he give us an edge.

He's a matchwinner (or matchsaver in our current plight), and clearly frightens other teams.

He's brave, very difficult to legislate for and a real thorn in the side of any opposition.

And he scores a few, doesn't he?

No-one enjoys playing against him, because he's such an unpredictable nuisance? He takes no prisoners either and has a self-belief that many of his teammates need to learn to adopt very quickly if this current team is ever going to do anything.

Tim's one of the most underrated Evertonians - and I use that word very specifically - of the last 20/30 years.
Anthony Hughes
11   Posted 22/09/2010 at 12:31:38

Report abuse

I agree, I can't understand the criticism of Cahill either, he's been our best goal scorer option for most of his time here at our club and his commitment to the cause can never be questioned.
John Keating
12   Posted 22/09/2010 at 12:41:52

Report abuse

Find it quite incredible that people put down loses to the fact that one or two so called regulars are missing !! FFS we should be beating the likes of Blackburn, Wolves, Newcastle and Brentford with our present squad whoever plays or is missing !!
One or two players do not make a team. The RS were still winning last season when Torres and Gerrard were out. Surely we can beat Brentford etc with a few missing
Brett Bradshaw
13   Posted 22/09/2010 at 12:56:38

Report abuse

Agreed, Cahill should be the first name on the team sheet... followed by Baines. This is where our goals come from. Arteta, and Coleman would be my next starters...

Defensively, Howard Jags, Heitinga and Fellaini would get my vote.

The rest can do one!
John O'Brian
14   Posted 22/09/2010 at 15:04:46

Report abuse

I think one man has been at the route of our problems this season... Sylvan Distin! The lad is a liability as far as im concerned, the amount of miscued clearences, over-hit long balls and poor defensive headers is ridiculous. Also playing Distan is causing other players to be played out of position like Heitinga and Fellaini.

Heitinga played in the World Cup Final and Distin can't get in the French squad even with about half the team suspended for Christ's sake. Moyes judgement with defenders over the years has been ptretty good, hes got this one wrong though. Jagielka and Heitinga are the best two centre backs at the club. So play them!!

Another thing I'm not enjoying at the moment is the stick Leon Osman takes, the lad's another one who is being played out of position. Going back to the games with Chelsea and Man Utd at home last year, Osman was one of the best players on the pitch, playing centrally however. He hasn't got the pace or strength to play out there.

Moyes needs to change things quickly or it's going to be another wasted season!!

Ciarán McGlone
15   Posted 22/09/2010 at 19:55:57

Report abuse

What a load of clap trap...

Cahill is a good player....but he also has deficiencies. Sometimes it's right to play him, sometimes it's not.

Using these defeats as a big stick to beat those who don't wet themselves over Cahill is ridiculous.
Richard Harris
16   Posted 22/09/2010 at 21:28:19

Report abuse

Hopefully Tim Cahill will go into coaching when he stops playing - he would work his players hard and accept no excuses...
Peter Bourke
17   Posted 23/09/2010 at 00:37:17

Report abuse

@14 Ciaran.
What a gross distortion of my post your comment is. Its not about people "not wetting themselves over Cahill". I simply pointed out that i believe he has been unfairly criticised in recent times and when he is out we are missing our goal scoring threat. I don't expect people to WET themselves over Cahill at all and thats not what i indicated.
Tim Brashar
18   Posted 23/09/2010 at 05:40:31

Report abuse

Whenever opposing managers, players, fans are asked to name who they fear the most in their upcoming Everton clash, it seems almost invariably that they name Cahill. That says a lot for me.
David Thomas
19   Posted 23/09/2010 at 18:49:04

Report abuse

Cahill is without doubt one of the most important players at the club. We have missed him massively in these last two games and it is no surprise that our two worst performances of the season thus far are from games he was not available for.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.

© ToffeeWeb

Latest News

Subscribe to The Athletic, Get 40% off

Online Football Betting with Betway

Bet on Everton and get a deposit bonus with bet365 at

Recent Articles

Talking Points & General Forum

Pinned Links


We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.