Skip to Main Content
Members:   Log In  |  Sign Up
The Mail Bag

The Fellaini Enigma

Comments (26)

This guy can do so much for Everton if he is coached correctly. He still has old habits but has improved somewhat. Unfortunately, he is tall and awkward which means he stands out in his aerial challenges and referees find it easy to penalize him rather than the opponent around the penalty area, similar to what happens to Crouch and also happened a lot with Big Dunc (although Big Dunc could dish it out far to obviously).

I believe too many referees cop out when these players are competing strongly and give the decisions the wrong way. Unfortunately, football has to live with a percentage of inept referees, just as it has to live with dirty defenders.

In the Newcastle game, Fellaini got some poor decisions against him. One thing he has to learn in the Premier League is not to antagonize referees after he is penalized fairly or unfairly by remonstrating too much which will only make him more of a target for referees.
Tom Bowers, Canada     Posted 28/09/2010 at 17:36:34

back Return to the Mail Bag


Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Gaute Lie
1   Posted 28/09/2010 at 20:07:51

Report abuse

Fellaini will always be on the ref's checklist, because of his size and style of playing.

However, he's more in control when playing DM, and seems to get fewer cards when playing DM rather than AM.

And, one has to remember he's still a very young player. It's easy to forget this because of his size, transfer fee and hairdo (he he).

He's not a agressive player a la Duncan, who mostly scared the shit out of the opponents before smashing them to the ground ( or tried to strangle them ( Freund)). I miss Duncan.. Lots of fun watching him.
Jamie Tulacz
2   Posted 28/09/2010 at 20:16:14

Report abuse

Agree completely your point Tom. The problem is he does get quite wound-up as well, which only means that other teams go out to antagonise him even more.

To be fair to him though he does seem to have cleaned up his act somewhat, and seems to be getting a few less cards nowadays.
Charles King
3   Posted 28/09/2010 at 20:36:50

Report abuse

The Fellaini enigma really needs the Bletchley Park treatment.

I'm here all week.
Gaute Lie
4   Posted 28/09/2010 at 21:00:02

Report abuse

By the way, Why call him an enigma?

I don't see him as a big?? Just a player that has yet to be all that he can be.
Steve Cotton
5   Posted 28/09/2010 at 21:57:53

Report abuse

Has anyone ever seen him smile??? Or laugh??? That might help with the refs...
Eugene Ruane
6   Posted 28/09/2010 at 22:05:07

Report abuse

Charles, that made me smile.

It also made me wonder if at some stage there'll be a Hollywood version of The Fellaini Enigma, but in the Hollywood version he'll be playing for LA Galaxy.

(and played by John Turturro)
Ian Kearney
7   Posted 28/09/2010 at 23:08:32

Report abuse

To be honest, if I was a top class holding midfielder (no laughing!), I'd probably show signs of frustration if I got played upfront while a centre-half was in my position.
Gavin Ramejkis
8   Posted 29/09/2010 at 00:04:41

Report abuse

Dont agree Tom, you need to remonstrate with these bastards in black if they get it wrong otherwise they'll think they got it right penalising you and carry on doing it, the top sides get right into the ref, sod this respect bollocks when the top sides dont bother why should we?
James Stewart
9   Posted 29/09/2010 at 00:18:37

Report abuse

Ian Kearney spot on!
Peter Bourke
10   Posted 29/09/2010 at 00:43:43

Report abuse

Tom, I'm pretty sure I get your point but what different type of coaching would you suggest that will stop him being a target by referrees? I think he is victimised somewhat by certain ref's but what do you mean by coached correctly?
Rog Benn
11   Posted 29/09/2010 at 03:19:27

Report abuse

When he turned Bellamy last season, the lad laughed wholeheartedly. He is a magic lad who is terrific to watch ? intense, skillful, tactical. Too many of us have been down on him. I fear he will be playing in another strip by the time he can be truly appreciated.
Anthony Hughes
12   Posted 29/09/2010 at 07:55:32

Report abuse

Ian@7, spot on, Fellaini is our best defensive midfielder and should be playing there.
How many other managers play their defensive midfielder up front?...Mascherano, Essien, Palacios, Fletcher, Barry, Song. None of their managers at any time have played them out of position, put Fellaini where he belongs and see him blossom into the player he can be.
Anthony Millington
13   Posted 29/09/2010 at 11:41:52

Report abuse

Anthony, I agree with you, but Fellani is a liability and may get found out playing there because unlike the players you have mentioned Fellaini doesn't mark up all the time and doesn't track runners enough.
Joseph Strumm
14   Posted 29/09/2010 at 12:16:43

Report abuse

The only enigma is why Moyes plays him out of position. His name should be first on the teamsheet; his recent frustrations are understandable given the shape and tactics we've recently employed. Also, it must be disheartening to play in a team with no ambition or desire.

I'd say him and Cahill are the only two winners in the team, the rest are happy to become rich aspiring to mediocrity, as are the majority of players in this "con" we call the Premier League, predictable premiere bore!

Brian Waring
15   Posted 29/09/2010 at 13:40:15

Report abuse

Refs may pick on him because of his size, but at the end of the day, the lad is no angel, he is far too handy with that elbow of his.
Tom Bowers
16   Posted 29/09/2010 at 14:20:07

Report abuse

The use of elbows has become a disease these days, whether jumping for a high ball or challenging for a through ball. Arms are coming across people's faces and what is happening in the box from free kicks and corners is nobody's business. All players need protection and referees who are inept are encouraging defenders to continue their dirty work.

Yes, I appreciate there is great pressure which says defend at all costs but referees also have responsibilties to clean up the game a little. Williamson against Fellaini was a prime example of desperate defending by a limited defender which constantly went unpunished by an inept referee.

I believe Fellaini was bought because of his height but he should only be a deep midfielder and not go forward except on set pieces. When forward he is generally static. He needs to learn about timing and making a run for the high ball at the right time.

Helikaon Bow
17   Posted 29/09/2010 at 16:45:10

Report abuse

"The use of elbows has become a disease these days wether jumping for a high balL"

Lifting your elbows when jumping is a human instinct we've developed over thousands of years. Live with it clown. It won't change.
Jon Cox
18   Posted 29/09/2010 at 18:26:15

Report abuse

"Live with it CLOWN" Whats all that about. No need for it mate.

I hear you've a book comming out called "How to make friends and influence people"

We all know about elbows being used to elevate. "Live with it clown" will not endear you for very long on this website.

As a fellow Evertonian, I'm gutted to read that.
Gerry Quinn
19   Posted 29/09/2010 at 18:59:44

Report abuse

Helikaon - where you, perchance, the Entertainments Officer on the Marie Celeste?

I disagree with your statement - I believe that It depends on how high and how "bent and pointed" your elbow becomes! Yes, modern day footballers do have to lift their arms to jump - but not to the extent some of them take it to. Thugs, purely out to hurt others.

Similar comments remind me of that RS thug - who absolved himself by trying to convince everyone that he "pulled out " of the tackle on Naismith - and the RS goalie who brought the art of lifting one leg to jump (considered normal) to a fine art of thuggery.

There are far too many people accepting these types of things as "normal" - they would make perfect candidates to join the FA steering commitee!
Jon Cox
20   Posted 29/09/2010 at 19:12:21

Report abuse

Gerry, no, I see it more like the swimming instructor on the Titanic
Derek Thomas
21   Posted 30/09/2010 at 07:55:45

Report abuse

Fellaini DOES NOT NEED COACHING ? especially by the muppets we have.

On the one hand, you have a God given talent, co-ordination and reflexes. You can't make a silk purse out of a sows ear.

But at this Club and others plenty have been the other way.

You teach the basics to them as kids the 3 G's, pass and move, support the guy with the ball, give him an option, more than one if poss.

They will, if the have half a football brain, learn by doing. The half-time and full-time debrief aka bollocking will put them right... along the lines of and no doubt prettied up in PC nice were you thinking of doing (or not doing) whatever.

Too much coaching ruins the game and some of the players.

It's a simple game.

Oi teacher, leave those kids alone...cue guitar lick.
Ian Kearney
22   Posted 30/09/2010 at 11:00:40

Report abuse

The very best coaches, and I'm talking about the elite, will realise that at some point preparation will take you only so far, you will reach a point once you've got the players you wanted, coached and drilled them into a team, that you will have to take a leap of faith and give them their heads.
Chris Fisher
23   Posted 30/09/2010 at 11:25:04

Report abuse

I think most of the time and this was evident in the Newcastle game and I've seen it happen in a few other games as well, he gets constantly fouled and nothing is given for him. He then makes a few fair challenges that he gets punished for, he gets wound up and then starts throwing his weight around and throwing some elbows. In short, refs are dickheads.
James McGlone
24   Posted 30/09/2010 at 15:09:15

Report abuse

I'm not sure if he isn't being 'coached properly' or have you heard something?

The Big Fella playing out of position is something we've all had to do when there are injuries ? I'm sure he'll get over it.

I can't think of anyone who has had a decent start to the season, but I've great belief that it will be turned around.
Helikaon Bow
25   Posted 30/09/2010 at 16:55:44

Report abuse

"Fellaini is our best defensive midfielder and should be playing there"

Have to agree with you there. Last season he was immense in that position.

What we need is a striker! :-)
Tim Kells
26   Posted 30/09/2010 at 19:37:07

Report abuse

He certainly played well on Saturday at Fulham.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.

© ToffeeWeb

Latest News

Subscribe to The Athletic, Get 40% off

Online Football Betting with Betway

Bet on Everton and get a deposit bonus with bet365 at

Recent Articles

Talking Points & General Forum

Pinned Links


We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.