Skip to Main Content
Members:   Log In Sign Up
The Mail Bag

Can we win the FA Cup and would we want to?

Comments (34)

This has to be the moest negative I've seen Evertonians for while, understandably; this season is far from a positive one and our accounts are not encouraging. I'm pretty good at understatement I think you'll agree.

Having not submitted more than a few comments in the past, I wanted to offer a distraction from accounts, selling players, and who should get the sack, even though these are all important things!

1) Are we good enough to win the FA Cup this year?

2) Would we want to, given our current league position and the distraction that would offer?

3) Would it offer some consolation to the dismal overall Premier League performance and probable sale of good players in the summer?

Hmmm, not much of a distraction hey!?


1) Without an in-form and fit Saha and some heroics from Fellaini, I doubt Baines can win the competition by himself! So probably not.

2) Yes, although no team is 'too good to go down' I think even the worst David Moyes team has spirit. Aside from maybe the one that played at the Reebok on Sunday. (No, Victor, banging the ground when you fall over doesn't count as spirit, it's immaturity!)

3) Obviously it might, but it would be bitter sweet and last for days I expect before all the papers start crowing about how the team that won the FA Cup is disintegrating.

So go ahead, tell me how stupid I am for even considering such a stupid thing...

If you know your history.

Lewis Barclay, London     Posted 15/02/2011 at 14:04:17

back Return to the Mail Bag


Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Mike Rourke
1   Posted 15/02/2011 at 14:56:31

Report abuse

Do I want us to win the FA Cup?

I'm going to have to align myself with those that say 'YES, YES, YES'!
Brian Waring
2   Posted 15/02/2011 at 15:05:19

Report abuse

1 No
2 Yes
Kunal Desai
3   Posted 15/02/2011 at 15:19:03

Report abuse

No. Chelsea will beat us.

Lets look at the bigger picture and get to around 45 points to preserve our PL status.
Mike Bates
4   Posted 15/02/2011 at 15:22:58

Report abuse

In all honesty I think if we were to win the FA Cup (we won't) - it will paper over the many many cracks. So no, with the heaviest heart, I wouldnt like us to win it.

I couldn't bear Bill being able to hang on for another few years on the back of it... and as for Moyes. Words can't describe how I feel about him right now.
Erik Dols
5   Posted 15/02/2011 at 15:42:58

Report abuse

What is the point of playing in a competition if we actually don't want to win it - because it " is a distraction" or "will paper over the cracks"? This is the same insanity that has people wanting to qualify for Europe - and then want to get out of European competition as soon as possible as it is not important enough and players get tired!

1. Dunno, so far this season we're really not good enough, but who knows?

2. YES YES YES are you crazy?? Why do you even ask this question? The day that I don't want my team to win a competition is the day I'll stop caring about football.

3. Of course it would. It's silverware. It's the FA Cup. It's winning a competition. That's what football about.
Mike Gwyer
6   Posted 15/02/2011 at 15:41:02

Report abuse

I could never say that I would want Everton to lose. Ever. Chelsea away is probably the hardest game you could play but they have a CL game the following Tuesday (away) which IMO will affect the team picked to play us.

It's all we've got left this season hence I'm not travelling to Stamford Bridge hoping to lose. Hopefully we will have a good sing song and I'm sure some verbal words will be aimed at BK.

Tom Bowers
7   Posted 15/02/2011 at 16:15:35

Report abuse

Forget the F.A.Cup. Chelsea may rest players anyway ahead of the Champions League but still we cannot afford any injuries ahead of our fight to stay in the Prem.and should also play some youngsters for experience.
Chris Matheson
8   Posted 15/02/2011 at 16:15:37

Report abuse

Mike Bates makes a very persuasive argument (let me say again - KENWRIGHT OUT!!"). And you can be sure that if we did win, his smug face would be all over the TV.

However, Erik is right, we are here to win things. I would love us to win the Cup.

We're not going to, though: Chelsea will probably beat us on Saturday.
David Price
9   Posted 15/02/2011 at 16:32:57

Report abuse

In answer to Lewis's strange dilemma.
To quote Meg Ryan in " When Harry met Sally"
Yes, Yes Yes !!!!
John Brennan
10   Posted 15/02/2011 at 16:53:10

Report abuse

Im afraid the FA Cup doesnt mean much these days, but teams like ours have to try to win it as well as the League Cup. I am with Eric. It amazes me that clubs (Oneill did it with Villa) dont seem to place too much emphasis on winning cups anymore and we all know the reaso why.
There are a few ideas being kicked around about revitalising the FA Cup.
1. Have FA Cup "weeks" with matches played Tuesday-Thursday leaving the week end free for Premier League games.
2. No replays. There is a guaranteed winner on the day.
3.Semi finals to be played as in the past, at neutral grounds and not at Wembley ( i know Wembley needs the money).
4. Seeding of teams so the "big" clubs dont meet each other too soon.
5.Whoever wins the FA Cup gets a place in the Champions League. Doubt if that could happen because other European clubs would understandably kick up a fuss!
6. Get the League Cup out of the way by December so the FA Cup can then have more exposure.
I dont agree with all of the above, but at least it shows that the powers that be are aware of the fading glamour of the Cup, poor attendances and clubs not playing full strength sides until the later rounds.
Mammon has a lot to answer for!!!
James Stewart
11   Posted 15/02/2011 at 17:48:56

Report abuse

1. No we are not good enough to win the FA Cup.

2. No we are not too good to go down either. Did you not watch the Bolton game? Teams have played a lot better than that and gone down!

We need another 10 points and at the moment that looks a hell of a task.
Mick Gallagher
12   Posted 15/02/2011 at 17:58:53

Report abuse

Win the cup and stay up
6000 thousand toffs cant be wrong fingers crossed
Gavin Ramejkis
13   Posted 15/02/2011 at 18:16:39

Report abuse

1. Not a hope
2. The fans deserve something to celebrate as they've had fuck all to enjoy this season besides false dawns
3. same response as 2
James Hollister
14   Posted 15/02/2011 at 18:16:48

Report abuse

I think we need to be concentrating on the league..whats the good of winning a cup and getting relegated?

Sorry but with the deep serious trouble we are in this season, the FA cup can take a back seat.

Then there is going to the Bridge where under Moyse we have never won. Then being beaten by a poor Bolton side..with due respect this cup tie could be over by half time if we play like we did against Bolton.

The league will always be more important than a cup run.
We get past a poorly performing Chelsea we still have to worry about Arsenal and ManU. The distraction could easily make things worse in the league.

The only thing I want this season (sadly) is our premiership things stand we will be lucky to stay up I mean 3 points of the bottom, with no sign of improvement from us, and it only takes the teams in the bottom 3 to put a run of 2 or 3 wins together and we'll be right into the bottom 3.
James Hollister
15   Posted 15/02/2011 at 18:22:08

Report abuse

William Hill slashed the odds of us going down from 42/1 to 16/1 thats a hell of a drop.

25/1 to win the FA Cup, while at 22/1 Birmingham and Fulham. Not surprisingly ManU are clear favourites.

Ryan Holroyd
16   Posted 15/02/2011 at 18:14:25

Report abuse

Try telling the 6,000 fans that have bought tickets for the Chelsea game that you don't want to win the FA Cup.
Mike Bates
17   Posted 15/02/2011 at 18:36:45

Report abuse

...I dont want to win the FA Cup.

There's bigger things at stake.
Stephen Kenny
18   Posted 15/02/2011 at 18:53:26

Report abuse

It would be my best day as an Evertonian if we won the cup.

All those who have said no obviously never went to Wembley, because there's no way you could say no and mean it if you did.

I don't buy into the cup being a distraction from the league anyway. A good result saturday, and a home game against Reading means all of a sudden players are putting a shift in in the hope of geting to Wembley and playing.

That can only be beneficial to us in the run-in.
Chris Hannon
19   Posted 15/02/2011 at 19:25:45

Report abuse

Going down are we fuck well stay up and win the cup... Everton
James Flynn
20   Posted 15/02/2011 at 20:02:26

Report abuse

I don't know. I'm chalking this up as a transition season. The old team went as far as it could and here we are. But we remain a team with lots of talent.

Obviously, we need ownership with pockets deep enough to make a move or two.

For all their supposed genius, SAF and Wenger win at the rate they do because they have elite predators, not because they are some kind of tactical wizards. Wenger stuck to his finance plan and sold Henry for a fortune to La Liga. By the economic wisdom (which I agree with in general), Henry was 28-29 years old and at the peak of his value. Except Arsenal's EPL Trophy Guns grew suddenly silent without Thierry (and have remained so).

EFC hasn't had the luxury of a Henry-level attacking talent since when? That's what we're missing. With that, let me repeat what you all might get sick of hearing, "Please Steinbrenners, buy this team".

We're on the verge, however disappointing this season has become. We don't need deep pockets. We need pockets just deep enough.
Karl Masters
21   Posted 15/02/2011 at 22:35:00

Report abuse

Why would you not want to win a trophy????? Isn't that what it's all about?

With the initial 3,000 tickets sold in days and another 3,000 snapped up I am glad to see not all Evertonians are as negative as some of the stuff posted on here.
Matt Traynor
22   Posted 15/02/2011 at 23:19:15

Report abuse

I was lucky enough to be still in England when we won the FA Cup in 95, unlucky enough to watch our league games that season. Despite Joe Royle's "Dogs of War", we were terrible in the league, and the FA Cup was a massive distraction ? conceding only one goal in the competition (dodgy pen in the semi), riding our luck (Brizzle City away) and beating much-fancied teams in the semi and final.

Those who say the FA Cup has lost its importance, let's see what kind of 2nd string Chelsea put out in what is realistically their last chance of silverware this season ? and given they've won it last 2 seasons.
Jamie Sweet
23   Posted 15/02/2011 at 23:12:19

Report abuse

Mike Bates... I can assure you, if we score a 90th minute winner against Arsenal or whoever, in the Cup Final, at Wembley this year - you, and every Evertonian on the planet will be jumping around and celebrating like a lunatic.

If for one moment you think that you would shout "bollocks" and throw your cat at the tele or whatever, then surely you are mad.

I agree whole heartedly that the knock-on effect of seeing Billy Bullshit climbing out of the woodwork with a big beaming grin on his face will be hard to take, but I can dream about punching him in the face another day... I would be concentrating on the fact that we actually fucking won something ? which, at the end of the day, is the ultimate goal of any football club.
Dick Fearon
24   Posted 16/02/2011 at 00:03:53

Report abuse

Much depends on Moyes's team selection and tactics. He could 'go for it' with Jags at the back and twin strikers plus Cahill coming from deep.

Past experience tells me to expect him to aim for a low-scoring game with one striker. Pray god it is not Anichebe.

Jason Lam
25   Posted 16/02/2011 at 01:41:08

Report abuse

As an Evertonian of course we want to see us win. But it'll only further paper the cracks of a crap manager and potless board. Chelsea will beat us so we needn't worry too much about this one.
Adam Fenlon
26   Posted 16/02/2011 at 05:45:01

Report abuse

I know how gutted we all felt when we lost the 2009 final so would absolutely love us to win the thing.

The reality is we're not even close though, even if Chelsea are vulnerable.
Howard Don
27   Posted 16/02/2011 at 07:46:03

Report abuse

I'm an Evertonian so YES to all three, of course.
Chris Perry
28   Posted 16/02/2011 at 08:15:00

Report abuse

No, we are not good: Chelsea will win, 2 or 3 goals will be enough

No, we need to concentrate on the leauge, no point in winning the FA Cup and being relegated!
Andy Callan
29   Posted 16/02/2011 at 08:34:23

Report abuse

Football is about winning things....

If you're not prepared to put all your effort in winning competitions then what is the fuckin' point in existing purely for the sake of it.

I can't fuckin' believe for one second that people wouldn't take a FA Cup win, even if it meant us going down.... I'd snap their hand off.

After all we've won fuck all now since '95 - that's 16 years; half my fuckin' life.
Chris Fisher
30   Posted 16/02/2011 at 10:34:57

Report abuse

Would I want Everton, the club I love and support, to win the FA Cup..... erm, YES.
Ernie Baywood
31   Posted 16/02/2011 at 10:59:54

Report abuse

Of course I want us to win it.

Do I think we can? Yes. We've competed well against the better sides and our performances at Stamford Bridge have been good in the last few years.

I think we're an ideal Cup side. Capable of knocking off the top sides. Whether we can beat someone like Bolton is up for debate.
Tom Bowers
32   Posted 16/02/2011 at 13:59:57

Report abuse

Winning the Cup would overshadow where we finish in the league and at this stage it would not be a good position. It would also overshadow the fact that it has been an awful season and give more credence to Moyes being the manager to continue next season which will provide just more of the same ideas.

Anyway... why worry, we will not get past Chelsea unless we get lucky like the Redshite and hope Chelski don't turn up.

Robert Johnson
33   Posted 16/02/2011 at 14:13:18

Report abuse

For those whose answer to Question 2 is "no", then maybe you should have a think about whether this being a football fan lark is for you.

Christ what's the point in following any sport at all if you don't want to see your club win stuff?
Scott Goin
34   Posted 16/02/2011 at 14:14:51

Report abuse

From a purely financial aspect, winning the FA Cup and playing in Europe will really help the bottom line. Maybe then Everton won't have to sell off their best young players.

This team isn't as bad as they showed at Bolton but they aren't near as good as people thought they were at the beginning of the season. They're certainly capable of winning the FA Cup but they'll need to avoid injuries and have some luck on their side. Saha is key. We may be able to win one match without him but there's little chance of long-term success with Anichebe and Beckford as our strikers.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.

© ToffeeWeb
Subscribe to The Athletic, Get 40% off

Bet on Everton and get a deposit bonus with bet365 at


We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.