Skip to Main Content
Members:   Log In  |  Sign Up
The Mail Bag

Should David Moyes depart ? who next?

Comments (131)

I have posted elsewhere an idea that I would like to float through the fan Article facility. Who knows whether David Moyes will continue to see his immediate and longer term future at Everton? It depends on so many factors that one could debate them forever.

Without doubt he has done a remarkable job at Everton in many aspects of management etc. There is much debate now as to whether or not he has reached a crossroads both in terms of his own managerial aspirations and the current complex financial uncertainty at the club etc.

Much debate revolves around who would replace him if he left. Obviously, who that person might be is determined by the ability of the club to resolve the many factors that may contribute to David Moyes leaving in the first place! Much talk then tends to focus on current managers and who Everton might try and entice to the club.

One post on the site raises the issue of Moyes going to Man Utd ? which I think would be highly unlikely as there would appear to be nothing in his career so far to suggest that he is ready to take over the most successful club in the last 20 years in England and perhaps one of the biggest brands in European and world football.

But I would like to suggest that the managerial link with Man Utd may not rest exclusively with Ferguson and Moyes. If Everton could get their house in order and put together a package both financial, and regarding the longer-term stability of the club, then I would suggest that they could do worse than take a chance on trying to entice Ryan Giggs to undertake his managerial and coaching aspirations with Everton.

Here is a young man with unparalleled credibility within the game; enormously successful over many years; winner of every honour in the game; the recipient of whatever insights Ferguson's managerial career may have given him and desirous of continuing his football career in coaching and management. If he could be enticed to enter that new phase at Everton, it could well be that he would bring a stature to the role that would perhaps bring a creative approach to the requirements of the first team that Evertonians of all ages have long craved - some of us longer than most!

Not only would that stature perhaps not tolerate some of the appalling levels of inability anbd lack of application evident in some elements of the current squad but it would also perhaps be such that it would attract aspirational players ? and the more established ? to consider a future at a newly invigorated Everton.

All this assumes that Everton get their commercial and ethical acts together. While in no way wanting Everton to "sell their soul" to the nearest "billionaire devil" in order to bring about a more optimistic future, nevertheless, if they could but bring about more stable conditions in an ethical manner, then I do think that a venture such as this could help breath new life into what at times appears to be a somewhat moribund enterprise. Just an idea.
Anthony Lamb, Burscough     Posted 29/04/2011 at 20:55:17

back Return to the Mail Bag

Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ged Simpson
1   Posted 30/04/2011 at 07:46:25

Report abuse

2 points :

1. I think Moyes will stay and I would welcome that.

2. Agree that Giggs is one of the best players ever but I have grave doubts about his ability to manage. Wrong character traits. To quiet.
Jim Potter
2   Posted 30/04/2011 at 08:11:19

Report abuse

I'm with Ged - I want Moyes to stay.

Giggs - nice idea, but coming from a great career to a club with no money and he with no management experience smacks of Bobby Charlton failking at Preston.

If Moyes left - then I hope it's O'Neill.
Chris Bannantyne
3   Posted 30/04/2011 at 07:58:53

Report abuse

Word is that should Barcelona win the champions league, then Pep Guardiola will move on. He says he wants the job at Everton, because it represents a bit of a challenge.

Or maybe that was just a dream I had....
Paul Knox
4   Posted 30/04/2011 at 07:54:04

Report abuse

Only positive I can say about moyes is he has built up a good squad,even go as far as saying one of the best midfields in the prem ( when all fit). Otherwise he has been a big failure.hiding in the dug out when things go wrong on the pitch, formation and tatics same old.cost us in major games. I personally seen through him in the engrossing result against dinamo Bucharest away and since then only strenghtend my belief( even though I have started each season since giving him another chance,only to let me down again and again.
When talking to other supporters they say who else then,my answer is anyone( although I do have my own favourites ,coyle Being one growning on me,what would he do with a squad like ours). Its not just moyes( dithering Dave) kenwright and his backers too must go.the pair are holding us back no ambition,no money and no idea.
But like most, I will be there next season expecting us to be back up there fighting for the title.
Ps managers who have managed us for over 100 games who has worst record?
John O'Mara
5   Posted 30/04/2011 at 08:20:41

Report abuse

I think the majority of realistic fans would want Moyes to stay. The problem for Moyes is that he has become a victim of his own success. He has raised the bar at Everton and expectations have gone the same way. Everton are now consistently the best of the rest and this has been achieved with limited funds.

If Moyes stays then the club needs to support him. I do not think this means we need to go out and spend mega-millions but we must be prepared to pay wages comparable to other big clubs or we will continue to lose our best players. We may still need someone with financial clout to achieve this. As regards Moyes successor why not groom Phil Neville over the next couple of seasons.

Mike Bates
6   Posted 30/04/2011 at 07:51:35

Report abuse

I interpret your title a little deeper than who would replace *him* - rather, I saw it as 'Should Moyes depart - Who next (for chairman)?'

With Bill's greatest asset in keeping his 'train set' gone, the pressure on him would be enormous. Now I don't like Bill, and IF Moyes was to go I reckon you will see the likes of your Doddys et al buying an amber and blue scarf, or whatever, and voicing their concerns about the running of the club, and joining the inevitable protests.

I don't have a massive problem with Moyes, I just think he's reached the end of his time with us - its all a bit stale. But lets be honest, Moyes isn't the greatest manager in the world. He's not the best in England. He's not even the best in Liverpool!!! If he left it wouldn't be the end of the world...it could just be the start of a new one.
Steve Sweeney
7   Posted 30/04/2011 at 08:57:02

Report abuse

Mike #7, spot on,
I too think MOyes has done all he can at Everton.
The club is stale, its like a marriage gone wrong with both parties knowing that its over but staying together for the sake of the kids.
Moyes grow some balls and do one of two things,
1 Insist on Billy Bullshit coming clean and acknowledging that he has no intention of selling the club and tell to get investment to back you or you walk.
2. Walk because Billy Bullshit has no intention of doing the above.
As for who would take over I don't think any decent manager after speaking with Bullshit Billy would take the job.
We could end up with with another Yes Man but can you see any experienced Premier League Manager agreeing to work with the constraints put on him by this joke of a board.
We could end up with the likes of McClaren or Southgate who will most likely do anything to get back onto the premiership gravy train.
Richard Dodd
8   Posted 30/04/2011 at 09:37:20

Report abuse

If Everton resolve their alleged financial difficulties, Moyes will be in a job for life. If ever he did move on, then you're right about a Man Utd replacement. Captain Pip is a shoe-in!
Phil Bellis
9   Posted 30/04/2011 at 10:19:22

Report abuse

Richard,
Explain "alleged" please
Micky Norman
10   Posted 30/04/2011 at 10:27:12

Report abuse

Giggs? I seem to remember similar things being said about Roy Keane. Can't see Moyes leaving unless the financial worries were to get really bad, a la Portsmouth. In which case a promotion from inside would be the only affordable option. If by some miracle the financial worries were resolved eg by an oil strike when they're digging up the Park End car park,then I think Moyes would first be given the chance to spend it.
Luke O'Farrell
11   Posted 30/04/2011 at 11:08:57

Report abuse

#2

O'Neill? It would be a grave day if he ever got the job; in the event of Moyes going.

Although I can't really see Moyes leaving at all.
Mark Pierpoint
12   Posted 30/04/2011 at 11:34:20

Report abuse

Wouldn't want Moyes to go either. If he did go to Villa, (and i think he may if he was offered a decent transfer kitty there) then i would want us to go for Paul Lambert. Two successive promotions, Champions League winner at Dourtmund i think. The next big thing for me
Neil McKinney
13   Posted 30/04/2011 at 10:55:53

Report abuse

Mike #7 Good point about Kenwright's position becoming very precarious if Moyes went. Moyes is the one thing making life a little more comfortable for BK than his actions sholuld have afforded him.

Not so sure about this statement though "lets be honest, Moyes isn't the greatest manager in the world. He's not the best in England. He's not even the best in Liverpool!!! If he left it wouldn't be the end of the world...it could just be the start of a new one."

True, can't argue against most of that, he's not the best in the world or in England, but woulod any of the managers considered better come to Everton if he left. Reallistically? No, they wouldn't, and personally I see Coyle as another Moyes, just like many of the others who would be candidates for the job.

I guess some fans are more prepared to take the gamble than others.
Ian McDowell
14   Posted 30/04/2011 at 11:41:21

Report abuse

Mark Hughes hopefully he would bring Zamora, Dempsey and Dembele.
Eric Myles
15   Posted 30/04/2011 at 11:44:16

Report abuse

Does April Fools come to your part of the world a bit later than the rest of us Anthony???

Ryan Giggs FFS.

It's so ridiculous I find myself having to agree with Doddy!!
Guy Hastings
16   Posted 30/04/2011 at 11:54:01

Report abuse

PNev would get it before Giggs. As for O'Neill, if that overhyped, long-ball, 'everyone's fault but mine', self-aggrandising egomaniac ever takes the reins at Goodison then Tony Marsh's vitriol towards Moyes would be milquetoast compared to the righteous wrath that would descend upon the swollen head of MO'N from Day 1. I'm just saying, like...
Ryan Holroyd
17   Posted 30/04/2011 at 12:29:24

Report abuse

I hate all this 'Moyes should grow some balls and get Kenwright to spend some money' or walk shite.

WE DO NOT HAVE ANY MONEY. WE DO NOT MAKE ENOUGH MONEY. YOU CAN'T SPEND MONEY YOU HAVE NOT GOT.

All this bullish, macho crap that Moyes should walk if BK doesn't give him any money is stupid crap.

Why the hell would you want to walk out on a top Premier League job like Everton if you have nowhere else to go?

Not many teams have money to spend bar 4 or 5 clubs.

Moyes is not going anywhere soon.
Phil Bellis
18   Posted 30/04/2011 at 13:02:30

Report abuse

Calm down, Ryan...save it for 3 o'clock
Chris Regan
19   Posted 30/04/2011 at 13:07:28

Report abuse

GUTLESS! Absolutely GUTLESS. Instead of fighting for your club and getting Kenwright out you are discusing the demise of the club.
Mark Stone
20   Posted 30/04/2011 at 13:14:40

Report abuse

Ian (15) I assume thats a joke .. given that Mark Hughes consistenty finishes in a lower league position that Moyes every year despite a similar or greater transfer budget? Or not?
Gavin Ramejkis
21   Posted 30/04/2011 at 13:33:21

Report abuse

Imogen Thomas reputedly doesn't think Giggs is quiet.

I agree with a few posters that say Moyes has gone stale and I agree I think he has taken Everton as far as he can and with BK not spending a penny on the club he won't go any further. I'd go further and say if he does leave I hope he blows the whistle on BK and his board on his way out.

Doddy, WTF are you on about "alleged", as Phil asked please explain and whilst you are at it explain where the KD ringfenced money went, where the Desperation Kirkby money went, how much BK pissed away on DK, where the Pienaar money went, how we couldn't even afford a loan in January, why another mortgage was taken out in December to pay the interest off another mortgage and if we aren't in the shit financially why Keane lookalike Elstone admitted at the fans forum there wouldn't be any money for players in the summer and Moyes would have to buy to sell.

0 out of 10, must try a whole lot harder.
Gavin Ramejkis
22   Posted 30/04/2011 at 13:40:45

Report abuse

On the article itself:

Dream ticket: Boas ? never going to happen.

I'd like to see Lambert from Norwich.
Colin Potter
23   Posted 30/04/2011 at 13:53:02

Report abuse

Paul Lambert
Kevin Sparke
24   Posted 30/04/2011 at 13:53:08

Report abuse

Wow - Giggs... genius

KENWRIGHT: Hello Ryan - fancy a job?

GIGGS: Yeah brill - what is it?

KENWRIGHT: Manage Everton - I'll give you no money for team building, you'll be selling your best player every other season, and every transfer deadline you'll be rumoured to be on the brink of a major signing only for it to not happen... Oh and to not go backwards as a club you'll need to win manager of the year three times and achieve consistent top half of the table finishes with a transfer budget less than an eighths of Liverpool's and less than West Brom, Wigan and Wolves... and Europe would be good

GIGGS - You're pulling my pisser Bill... that's fuckin impossible!

KENWRIGHT - Well David Moyes manages it...
Jay Harris
25   Posted 30/04/2011 at 14:30:17

Report abuse

Well said Kevin.

The only thing that's gone stale at Goodison is the air around Kenwright's seat.

Moyes should audition for a leading part in the next Mission Impossible movie.
Roman Sidey
26   Posted 30/04/2011 at 14:56:39

Report abuse

On current performance, I'd take the unknown in place of Moyes. However, if he could somehow, overnight, change from being a cautious, defensive tactitian, I would support him to the hilt - although he is not worth 65k a week no matter how well we do.

Had he done this 12 months ago, we'd possibly be in a top four position, and our money troubles would be slightly lessened, thus giving him the opportunity to maybe spend a bit.

As I said, on current performance, have no time for him.
Lee Courtliff
27   Posted 30/04/2011 at 15:53:27

Report abuse

I'd take a chance on Paul Lambert.

He has got Norwich in with a great chance of promotion, he has European experience, he has won a major competition in his playing career and he is young and hungry!

I don't remember much about him as a player but he seems to be the most highly regarded young manager in the game.

Bit like Moyes was.
Andrew Heaton
28   Posted 30/04/2011 at 17:10:47

Report abuse

He wouldn't last 6 months at Man U! He is a "good" manager! Alex Ferguson is arguably "the best manager ever" do you think a manager of Moyes calibre could replace him?? no way!!
Ian McDowell
29   Posted 30/04/2011 at 17:56:17

Report abuse

Mark Stone @21 I suggest you read the title it says should Moyes depart who next. I'm not saying Moyes is better or worse than Hughes but he would be my choice should Moyes depart. It might not be everyone's choice but everyone is entitled to their opinion. I also notice you gave no opionon on your choice.
Ian Kearney
30   Posted 30/04/2011 at 18:27:00

Report abuse

As others have said Lambert is the best up and coming manager, Lee, he was an intelligent player who could organise and knew what he had to do to be a good player for his team.
Fran Mitchell
31   Posted 30/04/2011 at 18:23:27

Report abuse

2 viable and realistic options:

First the obvious:
Paul Lambert. He is the flavour of the month, the next big thing, the best young manager in England etc. Obviously very successful where he has been, and play's (relatively) good football with it. However, would he go? Would he want to give up on the Premiership with Norwih and be the villain, or do an Owen Coyle? Also, he has had 2 years of never ending success, which is good, but how will he adapt to inconsistency? Will he sink when a club hits a run of bad form, or will it make him stronger. Some managers never recover after having a period of excellent results change to a period of poor results. He will always be a gamble for this reason, but a worthwhile one.

Second, another big risk.
Steve McClaren:
Yes, that's right. The worst manager in Englands recent history. But, look at Boro after he left, a rather average job with them was made to look like a very good job done with hindsight. Capello, one of the 'worlds best' has hardly made the same England team much better, ok, he qualified for the WC when McClaren failed, but McClaren was up against a very good Croatia while Capello was up against a very poor Croatia with 10 men. He faired very very well in Holland (won the league), and had a tough time in Germany (with a tam struggling to live up to their league title victory 2 seasns previously, and a board and squad of players reminiscent of previous Newcastle teams). He has been worked in Europe for 2 years, thus he will have lots of contacts, knowledge of the young players in those leagues, plus the experience that none of our current staff have i.e. European style football (what many fans seem to crave). He is also available, so no compo to pay, and would probably jump at the chance to join us. For me, he is the man.

Other Wildcards:
O'Neill, unattached; Pellegrini, Malaga; Villas Boas, Porto; Scolari, Palmerias; Coyle, Bolton; Grayson, Leeds; Holloway, Blackpool.
Andy Crooks
32   Posted 30/04/2011 at 18:44:26

Report abuse

Here's a prediction. If Moyes should go Kenwright will want to look good on the cheap. So.I reckon it will be an old Evertonian for a fraction of the cost of Moyes. Step forward ... David Jones. I'd take Lambert or Poyet.
Ian Kearney
33   Posted 30/04/2011 at 18:51:08

Report abuse

I think Boas may go somewhwer bigger than us, Pellegrini might be a good shout, as is Poyet.
Trevor Mackie
34   Posted 30/04/2011 at 19:19:27

Report abuse

Martinez.
Richard Dodd
35   Posted 30/04/2011 at 19:54:25

Report abuse

OK,Gavram, lets assume we`re absolutely skint. If that IS so then to finish seventh or eighth in these circumstances makes Moyes an absolute fecking genius,doesn`t it? You can`t have it both ways!
David Hallwood
36   Posted 30/04/2011 at 20:03:19

Report abuse

Knowing Kenwright, he'll probably advertise it at the local job centre on a dutch auction wages wage structure
Richard Harris
37   Posted 30/04/2011 at 23:13:31

Report abuse

Moyes was appointed as a manager with potential. Time for him to go and as we probably can't afford a proven manager who has won trophies then a new manager with potential cannot be any worse. Being honest, how many games under Moyes have we dominated when playing against lesser teams? Look back at narrow wins when it was the poor finishing from the opposition that helped our victory. How many times have we played good passing football, had pace up front, creativity in midfield and more than just a Plan A ? There have been too many times when the play has been dire, like today.
Gavin Ramejkis
38   Posted 30/04/2011 at 23:22:18

Report abuse

Doddy you tiptoed around the questions and just asked another, the questions aren't how Moyes finishes where he does. You implied the club isn't broke and Phil Bellis and I are still awaiting your explanation as to why not, your inside line, whatever reason you think we aren't. I asked a lot more questions than Phil and you haven't answered one of them. What exactly is it I can't have both ways?
Dick Fearon
39   Posted 30/04/2011 at 23:42:40

Report abuse

Going by the responses it would appear that most of you are quite happy to have even more years of the mindless brain numbing mediocre second rate rubbish served up by the maestro of stultifying defensive tactics with a liberal dose of spin.
When you take into consideration that 99 per cent of football managers have to survive on far less of the kind of back up assistance that Moyes recieves the question should have been,
who would do a worse job.
Moyes can indulge his coaching fantasies at Finch Farm, a state of the art training facility with its first class medical and coaching staff.
Other managers can only dream of having nine years total control and guaranteed for as long as he wants.
Then he would enjoy the support, indeed, the worship of easily satisfied fans.
Then of course there is the no small matter of a fantastic salary.
IAll that means I am at a total loss as to why Moyes gets so much praise and adulation.
When so many of his peers are working on a smaller shoestring and with far less bac up methinks a reality check is called for..
Phil Bellis
40   Posted 01/05/2011 at 00:36:48

Report abuse

Richard, back from the match and thoroughly bemused by the team selection and ashamed of the subsequent performance
You must have missed my previous reply to you, which I will reproduce here and await your kind response...

Richard,
Explain "alleged" please
James Flynn
41   Posted 01/05/2011 at 02:56:20

Report abuse

Not a thing wrong with Moyes. What's wrong is no money for a genuine predator (or two). He's a manager who's at the point where there's nothing more he can get out of a squad without THAT guy (or two) to scare the shit out of his opposing manager.

Strange to think this must be said over and over. We're missing the guy(s) at the top. Nothing else.
Karl Meighan
42   Posted 01/05/2011 at 04:59:42

Report abuse

One thing I do know: it's always going to be a struggle to beat shite like Wigan whilst Moyes is in charge.

The other thing is that, no matter how poor the redshite are, they will almost always finish above a Moyes Everton team.

The only thing Moyes could improve at Everton is the defence as attack-wise the man is clueless.

A reputation as a good manager built on finishing anywhere from sixth to tenth and that's without cup runs apart from the obvious.

Apart from four or five, most of Moyes's 20-man squad could be replaced with better quality for little money.

No manager will have success without taking risks or a gamble from time to time; Moyes plays it safe and we're stuck with him.
Derek Thomas
43   Posted 01/05/2011 at 05:55:07

Report abuse

Who will / could succeed Moyes... after Wigan (and others) the answer has to be...

Almost fucking anybody... up to and including me and or Ryan Giggs.

And no doubt Giggs is a model professional, won shit loads, skillful player, etc etc. So was Bobby Charlton, but big yard dog brother Jack did more as a manager. So where does that leave us?

Paisley and SAF were both rip shit and bust, no frills, solid brick outhouse, winghalf and forward respectively.

From that, ideal candidates from the past player ranks would be David Unsworth, add a Man U connection and we get Pip who, for all we know, might be a Billy Elliot diamond in the rough.

On a lighter note, I would work for a lot cheaper than any of them. Put it into perspective, £65k per WEEK!.... I would love £65k per YEAR.
John Audsley
44   Posted 01/05/2011 at 07:16:46

Report abuse

Phil n Gav

Come on chaps, you should know by and now (and I'm sure you do) that Doddy only ever makes statements on TW or bizarre soundbites

He NEVER answers questions.

I think I've asked him 3 or 4 times this year to explain a few points in "a little" more detail with Zippo response.

Alleged!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Jesus Wept...
Richard Dodd
45   Posted 01/05/2011 at 08:29:41

Report abuse

There is absolutely NO evidence that Everton cannot meet their commitments. Only the clubs with sugar daddies operate without incurring debt ? we are just one of them and judicious management of the kind applied by Kenwright and Elstone will see us through any temporary difficulty with cash flow which may arrive.
Craig Taylor
46   Posted 01/05/2011 at 09:42:26

Report abuse

Warnock! Ticks all the boxes for a club with no money. Wheeled and sealed all his career. Likes attacking football.

People will say he is a cock, but he the type of bloke you hate when against you but will love if he was yours.
Glen Anderson
47   Posted 01/05/2011 at 09:58:09

Report abuse

Kevin Sparke #25 - Well said. Couldn't have written it better myself. All those moaning about Moyes and when he should leave would do well to consider your points.
Karl Meighan
48   Posted 01/05/2011 at 10:08:15

Report abuse

Glen @48 then why even bother playing? Just give the title and cups to the clubs with the most money to spend on players.

Although finance can make a difference, in the right managers hands it is no guarantee. It's doubtful if Moyes had a unlimited budget for players that his teams would play any different.

The only players Moyes has had to sell are Rooney who, young or not, was not even a regular starter under Moyes, and Lescott who he received top dollar for.

If Moyes had a team full of the world's best players, he would probably still send his team out to get a 1-0 lead and defend it.

I don't doubt Moyes has done a decent job but if the aim is to finish top ten and is accepted by the club and fans as success then it's difficult to see how we will ever challenge again.

The team badly lacks pace in the forward areas and we have very few players who can go past a man without even thinking which should be second nature for any attacking midfielders or strikers regardless of cost.
Lee Courtliff
49   Posted 01/05/2011 at 11:26:52

Report abuse

Ian Kierney * 31- Thanks mate. Who did he play for besides Dortmund? I know the name but i just can't picture him on the pitch during his playing days!
Dennis Stevens
50   Posted 01/05/2011 at 12:03:16

Report abuse

If & when Moyes leaves, & somewhere like Aston Villa is more likely than Manchester United, then his replacement will be somebody who is available for free at the time, such as an established "name" between jobs, or available for a very low compensation fee, such as a promising young manager from the lower divisions. I doubt they'll start on £65k a week either!
Tony J Williams
51   Posted 01/05/2011 at 12:23:11

Report abuse

Karl, you are blaming Moyes for our shitty position and then go on and explain that we don't have the staff to sweep all asunder.

It lacks pace because the good fast player are worth a fortune and we can't affofd them, players who stroll past the opposition are worth a fortune and we can't affofd them. You see where I am going.

Moyes is a limited manager is tactics/skill but more importantly in finances.

I return to my normal standpoint, in that we moan as how shit our players are but then act all aggrieved when Moyes can't make this shite team beat all those before us. It just doesn't make any kind of sense.
Danny James
52   Posted 01/05/2011 at 13:27:03

Report abuse

I think Paul Lambert would be a good choice. However, unless our financial situation improves, he will fare no better than Davey.

Even if he were to sell our big name players i.e Mikey, Fellaini, Bainesey, Rodwell etc to pay off the debt, replace them with bargain buys from lower leagues and misfits from abroad who develop into Premier League stars, we would still face the same problems again a few years down the line.

It's all very well buying unknowns for a cheap price and tuning them into stars. Once the time comes for them to sign their second contract with us, their stock has risen and, instead of being paid £15k to £20k a week, all of a sudden they are worth £60k to £80k a week. The club cant afford to pay wages at this level and then we face the situation of having to sell or letting them go for a Bosman free and we are back to where we started again.

Unless we get investment, top 8 is the limit to what we can achieve consistently regardless of whoever runs the team.
Daniel A Johnson
53   Posted 01/05/2011 at 13:54:00

Report abuse

Yes, if Moyes left we would be left with P Neville.

Moyes would suggest him also, he has all his coaching badges and he is according to Moyes a "Winner".

But the thought of P Neville managing us makes me shit bricks, I shudder at the prospect...

I would like Neil Warnock: top bloke, plays good attacking football, and deserves a shot at a big club. I also think that Steve McClaren, with his Man Utd, international, Dutch League, and Bundesliga experience, would do a good job for us.
Ian Edwards
54   Posted 01/05/2011 at 14:00:13

Report abuse

Anyyone that pays hundreds of pounds on a season ticket to watch the dreary negative shite served up by Moyes seriously need their heads looking at.

No one can honestly say moyes has done a decent job this season.
Stephen Leary
55   Posted 01/05/2011 at 14:07:32

Report abuse

He has to go. Again yesterday, watching us knock the ball about slowly, with no idea where to go with it... it's the same old boring shite. How anyone can justify giving that clown upfront Anichebe a new contract is beyond me.

I'm sick of "well, who could do better?" Who knows... but something has to change and fast. As my mate said to me yesterday (who is a Norwich fan), "God, you lot are grim to watch" and I couldn't agree more. I used to defend Moyes but I can't now.

Dick Fearon
56   Posted 01/05/2011 at 13:34:30

Report abuse

At the time of writing, the mob across the park are whupping the Barcodes 3 - 0 and that is before Carroll comes on. Some of you are probably screaming, "What the fuck has that got to do with Everton?" and I say, "Look no further than the attacking style of Dalglish and compare it with that of Moyes." We have been conditioned to accept without question the utter shite that Moyes puts on show.

I expect the usual pathetic moans about Blue Bill etc, etc no money etc etc but that does not disguise the fact that Moyes was given money enough to buy a trio of the best goalscorers in English football. A short time under Moyes was enough to send their careers plummeting.

I reckon He has a bloody nerve to foist the likes of Beckford and Anichebe on fans who pay good money to watch proper footballers.

Robert Pullan
57   Posted 01/05/2011 at 14:32:10

Report abuse

With another disappointing result I suspect there will be the usual clamour calling for David Moyes to go. I'm not sure I want to get into that particular point.

However I have started considering for some time whether Phil Neville will be the next manager. Neville has clearly been getting his Uefa coaching badges. I remember seeing him photographed in the papers last year speaking to Mourinho when Inter visited Man Utd in the Champions League. He was believed to be networking within the game and researching the role.

Phil has been employed in the media working for BBC Radio 5live and also on Sky. I believe Phil is leaving no stone unturned in his pursuit to be a manager and I think he will get that opportunity at Everton.

Whether Moyes will go in the summer is clearly being debated. Even supporters of Moyes (incidentally, I am) should admit this season has seen massive underachievement. Ironically we may finish higher in the league this season than last, yet I have never been more pessimistic about Everton's future.

If and when Moyes goes, like Walter Smith, he will be asked for his views on his successor. I think he will point towards Neville. Kenwright may be sold on the idea as he will be cheap and won't have to negotiate with anyone outside the club.

Now whether Neville would make a good Everton manager is a different interesting argument but don't be surprised to see him appointed player coach or similar role in the next 18 months as he is groomed as successor.

Tony J Williams
58   Posted 01/05/2011 at 17:09:05

Report abuse

Dick, what the feck has that got to do with Everton? Different players, better side etc

Every time he has bought a forward for decent money, he has performed well in their fist season then not been able to carry on with that form. Is that the manager's fault or the player's? I think it's both but obviously with your views on Moyes, I know where you will solely lay the blame.
Gavin Ramejkis
59   Posted 01/05/2011 at 17:24:22

Report abuse

Tony one small problem with your pacy players cost money argument, Moses at Wigan was turned down by Moyes and signed for them for the massive fee of £2.5m, how much did Moyes piss away on Bily again?
Chris Butler
60   Posted 01/05/2011 at 17:43:02

Report abuse

The vast majority of people who are apologists simply can't answer many questions about why they think he's a great manager. I think he's the best manager for our team but not our club.
Sam Hoare
61   Posted 01/05/2011 at 17:59:44

Report abuse

Villa Boas ? fantasy, never going to happen but would love it.

Paul Lambert ? good young manager but a serious risk.

Owen Coyle ? plays good football, probably loathe to leave Bolton.

Martin O'Neill ? left Villa because hands were tied in transfer market, can't see that changing with us.

Neil Warnock ? not leaving QPR and a journeyman manager at best.

All-in-all, I can't see someone who would definitely make a positive change. And with our resources, I honestly don't believe many people could do better than Moyes has done.

One interesting candidate might be Mourinho...he has always spoken of taking a 'legacy' club. A team that is not at the top but that needs building up over a long period.... why not us, Jose? Though no doubt the ToffeeWeb cynics will be complaining about you defensive mentality before too long!!
Martin Handley
62   Posted 01/05/2011 at 18:33:21

Report abuse

If Moyes goes/resigns etc, then I would go with a McClaren as has been posted previously; worst England manager in a generation but, at club level, he ticks all the right boxes. He now has a decent name in Europe as well so could possibly attract a few decent freebies.

After the last couple of games, if Man Utd still want to offer us £25 mill for Rodwell, snap their bloody hands off!

I'd rather keep Fellaini who has started making noises that he wants to stay. As a word of warning to those wantaways, the grass is vary rarely greener... Does anybody remember that little African midfielder we had called Stevie something or other? Went to Spurs... I think he works at the drive through MacD's on Queens Drive now!

Andrew Gilbert
63   Posted 01/05/2011 at 19:14:24

Report abuse

No Lambert for me...too many bad memories of a manager doing well at Norwich who came to Everton.

Poyet is doing a great job at Brighton.
Eddie Howe could be worth a look.
Dave Jones has been consistent at Cardiff and was doing well at Southampton before they fucked him over.

Phil Neville would be the easy choice for the board and his leadership skills are certainly not in question.

If none of them would come then I would do it for a not to inconsiderable sum. Then there is always the milkman!.
Andrew Gilbert
64   Posted 01/05/2011 at 19:19:46

Report abuse

Oh and Ian Holloway would be fun if nothing else!
Dave Wilson
65   Posted 01/05/2011 at 19:30:58

Report abuse

Paul Lambert ? ? ? . . . Fuck me, I cringe when I read this stuff season after season every time somebody gets promoted - or even near it, he`s portrayed as the new messiah . .then he gets relegated or sacked and everyone pretends people like, Mowbrey, Holloway, De Matteo and Martinez were ever mentioned.

You guys astound me, you say you "WILL NOT" settle for mediocrity then call for a manager who has never even achieved that . . .Neil Warnock ? ? ? . . Mr relegation ?

Given how desperate some of you are to get rid of Moyes, you`d think that between the lot of you, somebody would have come up with a manager who has actually managed to finish above him.

Dave Wilson
66   Posted 01/05/2011 at 19:59:17

Report abuse

You guys call for change and berate the people who say we should stick with Moyes.

But look at the names you put forward ffs ?
Is it any wonder most people dont want to trust your judgement ?
Tony J Williams
67   Posted 01/05/2011 at 20:08:04

Report abuse

Moses? How well is he doing this season then? How many teams are apparently interested in him? I said a good fast player. He hasn't really set the Premier League alight... in fact I personally can't even remember him being mentioned on this site until after our game yesterday.
John Daley
68   Posted 01/05/2011 at 20:13:12

Report abuse

Who do I think we would end up with if Moyes left? Someone uninspiring and unadventurous like Shteve Mclaren probably.

Who would I love to take over if Moyes left? That mad German genius Jurgen Klopp. He's just led an unheralded and unfancied Dortmund to the Bundesliga title, with a team made up of young academy products and bargain buys. I think he may actually be clinically insane the way he charges up and down the touchline, regularly getting into rucks with the fourth official and winding up the opposition but he is hugely entertaining. More importantly, his team always plays adventurous, attacking football and he's tactically light years ahead of Moyes, Hughes, O'Neil, Bruce and their boring safety first ilk. It'll never fucking happen like...
Joe McMahon
69   Posted 01/05/2011 at 21:13:00

Report abuse

Dick Fearon (57) I got slated a couple of weeks ago for saying there is no way we will catch Liverpool, I thougth I was just being a realist. But of course you like me (and others) just get abuse for slagging Moyes. Even the actual facts of the situation don't change some peoples minds. Next season they (Liverpool) will be streets ahead of us again, out of reach unless at least one of Moyes or Kenwright have gone. Let's face it they will both still be here.
Stephen Leary
70   Posted 01/05/2011 at 21:34:05

Report abuse

Ermm... Coyle will finish ahead of Moyes as I think Bolton will catch us.

What about Pulis? He has done a great job there and they don't just hoof the ball, that's lazy journalism.

Trevor Mackie
71   Posted 01/05/2011 at 21:28:17

Report abuse

John Daley @ 69

For goodness sake don't be telling people on here success is possible by force of character and ability you'll get hung.

Young unknowns playing great football???

Winning the Title in Germany - not Bayern wtf???

Doesn't this crazy german guy know it's not possible???

Doesn't he know the game has changed???

It's bloody heresy, that's what it is - he should be burned at the stake.
Jay Harris
72   Posted 01/05/2011 at 22:06:57

Report abuse

FFS guys, let's get real.

Liverpool now has a decent board and went out and spent £50 million on Suarez and Carroll.

Who has Moyes got? ? Anichebe and Beckford.

Let's see how Paul Lambert does in the Premier League next season but IMO nobody can touch Moyes pedigree for what he has had to spend.

Yes this season has been utter shite and next season will be even worse unless Kenwright does one.

The Premier League is now all about money, commercialism and power and we dont have anyone with a clue how to run a club.

Tony J Williams
73   Posted 01/05/2011 at 22:51:27

Report abuse

All the names mentioned here and could realistically be tempted to manage us, what have they done to get themselves such an honour? I mean Moyes has finished above them every year so far.
Dermot Ryan
74   Posted 01/05/2011 at 23:16:02

Report abuse

Re-signing and continuing to play Anichebe has seriously undermined Moyes's credibility in my book. The world can see Victor is the worst forward in the Premier League. Why can't he? What has this carthorse done to earn Moyes's continuous support?
Dennis Stevens
75   Posted 01/05/2011 at 23:18:29

Report abuse

I thought the original post was about the possible replacement for Moyes if he should leave Everton. How odd then, that some seem to think it's necessary to defend Moyes's record in comparison to some of the suggestions made.

Especially comical is the idea that not having finished above Moyes in the league might preclude somebody from the job. After all, I don't recall Howard Kendall finishing above Gordon Lee prior to being appointed, or indeed Moyes ever finishing above Walter Smith. Perhaps there's only one thing for it ? if Moyes ever leaves we'll just have to replace him with ...... David Moyes!

Mike Allison
76   Posted 01/05/2011 at 23:45:38

Report abuse

Karl (51): "Glen @48 then why even bother playing? Just give the title and cups to the clubs with the most money to spend on players.

Although finance can make a difference, in the right managers hands it is no guarantee. It's doubtful if Moyes had a unlimited budget for players that his teams would play any different"

Karl, exactly. Your first paragraph is what makes Moyes such a good manager, your second resorts to making up counter-factual hypotheticals.

As I've said before, thank God money isn't the only deciding factor in football, because if it was, we'd be in the bottom half of the table every year. As it is we've got an excellent manager who consistently over-achieves to the point where he's raised your expectations so much you don't even appreciate how well he has to do just to stand still while the likes of Stoke, Sunderland, Fulham and Bolton outspend him in the transfer market.
Mike Allison
77   Posted 01/05/2011 at 23:54:43

Report abuse

Dennis I've just read your post. Kendall had never managed in the same league as Lee and Moyes has never managed in the same league as Smith, so what's your point? Hughes and O'Neill have finished below Moyes in all, maybe most and certainly many of the seasons since he took charge of us.

Different names come up all the time, in about November it was Holloway and Di Matteo, right now its Lambert and even Martinez. Moyes consistently outperforms all other managers except some of those with much bigger budgets than him. Moyes finishes best of the rest pretty much every season, and that's the best Everton can reasonably expect at the moment. There's no evidence to suggest that any other manager could bridge the gap that Moyes has failed to bridge, and plenty of reason to believe that any given manager would fail to match what Moyes has done and end up dropping us back into 'the pack' alongside all the others.
Dennis Stevens
78   Posted 02/05/2011 at 00:14:05

Report abuse

Mike, are you sure you read it - there's not much of an indication in your response? I'm not the one setting the ridiculous criteria - does it only apply if any potential successor has managed in the same division? Does a lower division not count as being "below"? What about a candidiate from overseas - does a foreign top division equate to the premier league? The point is that it's irrelevant as a pointer to whether the next manager will be a success or not. In football there are no guarantees. I haven't mentioned Hughes or O'Neill, so thanks for the rather sketchy info about them but I'm not really interested in their managerial record.

I have to ask - what is your point? Your second paragraph is a marvellous commendation of Moyes performance as manager, but it's rather irrelevant to the debate as to who might be appointed if he leaves. Unless you really are suggesting that Moyes should somehow be his own replacement when he leaves ??!
Tony J Williams
79   Posted 02/05/2011 at 01:03:17

Report abuse

Dennis, if the names being mentioned are not from the premiership then fair enough, but we have heard the Holloway's, the Martinez's etc because at the start of the season they were doing alright but as usual, the status quo has kicked in and the names mentioned, once again finish below Moyes and Everton.

I don't have a problem if another manager comes in and magically takes us up into the higher echelons of the league but it's the usual names getting bandied about when we have our bad run but they always finish below us. How is that proving they can do a better job than Moyes?

For fecks sake we even have a poster saying he would rather have Giggs, as manager.....because...ermm...ermm...his record is fecken brilliant as a manager isn't it?
Dennis Stevens
80   Posted 02/05/2011 at 01:16:24

Report abuse

So, Tony - do you suggest that if/when Moyes leaves, we don't bother to replace him on the assumption that there's nobody better? You may not be impressed by some, or even all, of the suggestions made - but we would have to appoint somebody. There would be no point in just wringing our hands in despair - even if you consider any possible appointment as no more than trying to choose the best of a poor selection of candidates. After all, it's not inconceivable that the club won't be in a position financially to appoint a manager you may consider has proven they can do a better job than Moyes - although one could also argue that success at one club is no guarantee of success at another. Unless there are some dramatic changes at Board level in the meantime, the only thing we can be sure of is that the club won't be splashing the cash!
Tony J Williams
81   Posted 02/05/2011 at 01:32:03

Report abuse

Not at all Dennis, not too sure where you are getting that idea from. I am talking about the names being thrown about on here by some posters suggesting that they will be better managers than Moyes, but the ones in the same league as him they have constantly shown that they are not.

I am more than open to a better manager taking over but it's the preferred weapon of choice for posters who don't like Moyes to offer names that are simply just laughable. Hollaway, yeah get him on board, he's a bit of a laugh and plays all out attacking footy, it doesn't matter that they could still be relegated. Martinez, fantastic, nothing says "I am a winner" than getting your side relegated.
Richard Harris
82   Posted 02/05/2011 at 01:27:16

Report abuse

If we are not in with a shout for a trophy or now not even qualifying for Europe then I'd rather have mid-table and at least some decent football than the dire fare that is being served up. Can anyone honestly say that we have been good to watch this season apart from a few games (or often just one half)?

There have been too many negatives to outweigh the postives. 11 wins so far from 35 league games ? that may be fine for less prestigious clubs but not Everton. Bolton are two points below us, Fulham three, Stoke five (and they are in the FA Cup final). Liverpool (who were meant to be having a nightmare season) are 7 points above us with a 10 goal advantage.

We are 14 points from 4th place which is the same difference between us in 7th and Wolves in 19th. So if Moyes is doing such a great job, raising our expectations, with little or no money, with a small squad and injuries and with the clubs ahead of us better financed then why do the tactics and general play have to be so dull and predictable?

So few of our players can pick out a pass at normal pace and even when they have time on the ball often can't control the ball properly and don't move intelligently off the ball. These should be fundamentals at this level. Just watch most average European teams and they can control a ball, pass to a team mate and move into space.

We lack creativity in most areas and as Moyes has signed most of the players either his team are at fault or his tactics. A great coach can make average players better ? we just seem to have too many average players who are stagnating...

Dennis Stevens
83   Posted 02/05/2011 at 01:41:12

Report abuse

I suspect that for any potential successor suggested it's quite possible to draw up a list of pros & cons; however, it's all really hypothetical & highly subjective ? you either like the look of somebody or you don't.

We can only hope the Board would make the right choice, but who can honestly say that Moyes's previous record had them hoping he would be selected as Smith's successor? Back then he was just a promising young manager that the Board took a bit of a gamble on ? I doubt they envisioned he would have us finishing as high as 4th in only his third full season in charge.

Personally, I've always been biased towards the appointment of former Everton players to the manager's post, but there aren't too many doing a decent managerial job at the moment. Mind you, that may change by the time Moyes does eventually leave, as I can't see him departing anytime soon.

Eric Myles
84   Posted 02/05/2011 at 02:13:42

Report abuse

I'm surprised nobody's mentioned Benitez as Moyes replacement?

He's unemployed and lives local so BK should be able to throw in a Merseyrail pass as part of the deal?
Ste Blundell
85   Posted 02/05/2011 at 02:22:55

Report abuse

Zzzzzzzzzzzz... What a boring and pointless article.
Richard Harris
86   Posted 02/05/2011 at 02:45:21

Report abuse

Boring and pointless? That reminds me of Moyes tactics... :0)
Ray Roche
87   Posted 02/05/2011 at 07:24:19

Report abuse

Dick Fearon,@57
You say,
"Look no further than the attacking style of Dalglish and compare it with that of Moyes."
An attacking style using attacking players that cost £50+ for two of them.
TWO of them.
Gavin Ramejkis
88   Posted 02/05/2011 at 08:13:35

Report abuse

Tony #68

Ok, I'll bite lets do a straight compare this season on Victor Moses and Diniyar Bilyetdinov]

Victor Moses
Played 18 games
Scored 1 goal
Provided 2 Assists
Took 19 shots on Goal
Cost £2.5m
Diniyar Bilyetdinov
Played 25 games
Scored 2 goals
Provided 2 Assists
Took 28 shots on Goal
Cost Approx £10m (various reports have it from £8.9m upwards

Pound for pound Tony, Victor Moses is cheaper, despite injuries has done virtually the same in less matches this season and in the game against Everton had more shots than most Everton players did.

Moses isn't the only example of cheaper players ripping our slow squad a new one this season, he's just a very easy example fresh in the mind from the weekend and one Moyes didn't fancy yet took Bily on and has stuck him on the wing since despite him not being a winger.

Dave #66 cringe as you may, given BK's endless streams of bullshitisms and general lack of cash do you honestly expect Everton to go and poach Guardiola or Mourinho? Realistically would a manager with a trophy cabinet full of domestic and European trophies entertain Everton these days? You have to look the same direction as BK did for DM and thats a hungry lower league manager showing potential.
Dave Wilson
89   Posted 02/05/2011 at 07:43:43

Report abuse

"Moyes was given enough to buy a trio of the best scorers in English football"


I assume Dick, you are talking about the two championship goalscorers and the guy who's career has been savaged by injury ?

I truly believe this sort of argument does Moyes more far more good than harm ? people will always look at statements like that and any confidence they may have had in his attackers judgement will instantly disappear
Dave Wilson
90   Posted 02/05/2011 at 09:32:24

Report abuse

Gavin

This is not a new debate, it happens every season and if we had taken any notice of you guys we may have ended up with one of the guys on my list.
The only thing all these names have in common is within a couple of years they are either sacked or relegated . .Owen Coyle will be shitting himslef if he reads TW.

You seem also to be suffering from what me arl fella used to call the Bernie the Bolt syndrom. Anyone who has a half decent game against us . . .

Victor Moses ? dear me. Try making a like for like comparrison, put him up against Beckford.
Mike Allison
91   Posted 02/05/2011 at 09:59:30

Report abuse

Hi Dennis, Tony has pretty much summed up how I feel. Fair enough if you didn't mention Hughes and O'Neill personally but they are names I've read from people quite a lot so felt it was relevant to the overall debate.

You have a point when you steer the argument specifically to 'who will replace Moyes when/if he goes?' but lots of other posters very much give the impression that they want him to go and be replaced by some of these other guys. That's the attitude/argument I'm really concerned with arguing against, so apologies if I've conflated your real point with another common one on this thread. As far as I'm concerned, Moyes departure is not imminent, so discussion of his replacement is premature, unnecessary and has a dangerous current of misplaced wishful thinking behind it.
Mike Allison
92   Posted 02/05/2011 at 10:06:32

Report abuse

Gavin Victor Moses didn't rip our players a new one yesterday, he didn't even win the game.

Incidentally, I agree that I'd rather have signed him than Bilyaletdinov, although I didn't know that at the time. I'd also rather have signed Pennant and Etherington, and any one of a number of other wide players picked up by other clubs, and with those two, I think I did know that at the time, but you can't look at anything good done by another club and then lambast Moyes for not doing it. That's holding the guy to some pretty high standards (such as omniscience and omnipotence). If we expect Him to have those qualities no wonder people put so much trust in Him.

If we were thinking seriously about a replacement there should be no consideration given whatsoever for whether they were a former Everton player or not, but whether they are a thoughtful and innovative manager or not. The old boys network is the scourge of English football, and the reason we don't produce great coaches.
Karl Meighan
93   Posted 02/05/2011 at 09:06:18

Report abuse

Mike@78 Moyes has not raised my expectations one little bit, i have always expected Everton to compete with the best and always will.

Tony@52 I dont think it would cost a fortune to improve upon Anichebe or Hibbert (who has played ok recently).

Also the impact of Donovan who had pace to burn should have gave Moyes a big clue of what the team needed to have a chance of getting in amongst it at the top.

Some of these players especially the tried and tested do cost big money but there are others who are foreign to the league and those who have a badboy reputation that imo Moyes would never take a slight gamble with.

Its far from easy to improve your team from season to season but good managers find a way and get the job done.
James McGrady
94   Posted 02/05/2011 at 10:06:11

Report abuse

Paul Lambert - did well with Colchester. Took over Norwich City after their relegation and a 7-1 tonking by Lambert's Colchester on the opening day. Got promoted that season and now going to finish 2nd or 3rd in the Championship. Experience it all a Club level winning Champions League with Dortmund.

Owen Coyle - Done good with Burnley and Bolton but most importantly has got two sides known for playing hoof ball for decades playing good football.

Martin O'Neil - Proven track record but I can't see him coming to Everton with 0 money if he left Villa when they had more.

Alan Ivine - Knows the club, studied under Moyes so less of a transition. Got unjustly sacked by PNE after getting to the playoffs - they collapsed after he left. Got unjustly sacked by Sheff Wed after taking over and not be able to keep them up. Where mid to the next season when they sacked him and then the dropped like a stone. Personally I dont think he has what it takes to be PL manager.
Trevor Mackie
95   Posted 02/05/2011 at 10:28:35

Report abuse

The cowardly fear that permeates these pro - moyes posts really piss me off - just because you can't proffer a replacement name agreed by all is no reason to back the shite we endure now.

The manager chooses the style and it defies rational thought that there aren't attacking players in the football world who could come and do a job akin to the good job Jags, Baines, Distin, Lescott do/did in defence. This notion that no-one else could do what DM has done, better it, or most ridiculous of all - take the job on is just pathetic.

He's not unique in having to deal with the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune - The chairman, the money, agents, MOTD, Ferguson's watch, Saha's knee - every manager has them.

IT IS THE REAL BATTLEGROUND.

Picking 11 for saturday, deciding whether to play one or none up front is light relief - look how many do it on here.

After 10 years his efforts have resulted in this squad - manufactured and spray painted in DM colours.
Every result, every performance, every nuance of style, every ounce of preparation, every transfer in and out is down to him.

Unfair? No chance - this is the sole reason he and his lucky bretheren need a wheelbarrow for their wages, and why the applicant line will be a mile long when the job comes up.

But fundamentally it comes down to this - he is at the very top of his industries food chain and as such subject to the unwritten clause of which all his ilk are judged: -

"TURN WATER INTO WINE OR CARRY THE CAN".

There are no excuses.
David Mathieson
96   Posted 02/05/2011 at 10:58:44

Report abuse

Graeme Sharp, & Peter Reid is the way forward for me, no-one knows Everton better than Sharp; both are proven winners. I am sure Reid is the assistant at Stoke, far better than Steve Round. Everton have always done well with promoting from within our own ranks, former players to managers seems to have done us well: Catterick, Kendall, Harvey & Royle.

I would take anyone over Moyes look at the Teams around us, Fulham, Bolton etc we should be finishing above these, we have not only outspent them over the years but are a bigger club. Moyes gets far too much praise for what he should be achieving, minimum.

It should be a top ten finish every year for all Everton mangers. I am sure the main reason why Smith went out the door was because he did not achieve this, Smith was not all bad; he left us with Gravesen & Carsley, undoubtedly the best midfielders we have seen under Moyes imo.
Matthew Williams
97   Posted 02/05/2011 at 11:26:53

Report abuse

It doesnt really matter who we get as manager ? as long as we have no money to spend, we will not progress. I can't see any manager doing a better job than Moyes while he has to sell to build.

If Moyes goes then we will end up with Sam Allardyce, mark my words... so all those people wanting Moyes out, think about it long and hard before you wish for things.
Matthew Williams
98   Posted 02/05/2011 at 11:30:09

Report abuse

@David Mathieson are you serious Sharpe who failed at Oldham years ago and hasn`t had a job since?... Reid who has done an average job everywhere he has been.....

I don't give a flying fook if they know Everton or not ? that should not be a major consideration.

Why not get Kendall back for a 4th time? He has been our most successful and knows the club better than anyone... dear me, deluded, some people!

Nick Taylor
99   Posted 02/05/2011 at 11:23:26

Report abuse

One commodity Everton don?t have much of is luck which constantly acts as a head wind against any momentum we have going. So when fans lament the style of football we are currently playing they should consider the following:

Because our resources are finite we just don?t recover as a team when a key individual is injured or sold. Think how influential the following would have been on team affairs in the past 3 years before fate cruelly intervened;

Yakubu, just getting back to his 1st season level then out for 14 months comes back minus a yard of pace, bang goes 11 m.

Lescott, a very good commanding attacking defender we where bullied into selling (ie wages) side never as strong since

Arteta,on the verge of big things before his knee went up at NUFC not the same player in terms of twisting and turning

Fellaini, formidable before his ankle injury at Anfield in 2010.

Throw in Jagielka (FA Cup final 2009), Saha, Pienaar, Rodwell, Vaughan and even the young lad Ross Barkley who I have no doubt would have featured at some stage this season before his double leg fracture. Align all that with a stadium which does not generate enough revenue and which we rarely fill to capacity.

Can anyone honestly say if all the above went in our favour we wouldn?t be playing a progressive brand of football competing for a CL spot? It?s difficult to disagree with a lot that has been said about BK and the way the clubs run, but I think Moyes deserves better than the mean spirited appraisal of his tenure made by some contributors.
Dick Fearon
100   Posted 02/05/2011 at 11:25:13

Report abuse

Jay # 74, You are correct in pointing out that Dalglish has Carroll and Suarez while Moyes only has Beckford and Anichebe. Would you gave Moyes any credit for Victor's development from 9 years of age?

After watching Beckford umpteen times before signing him, was Moyes blind to the fact that the lad cannot trap a bag of cement?

Had the RS not signed Carroll or Suarez, I doubt if our two would get within a mile of their first team.

Gavin Ramejkis
101   Posted 02/05/2011 at 11:44:11

Report abuse

Dave, are you kidding, Moses is a Midfielder Beckford is a striker, try again son, only this time a little harder
David Mathieson
102   Posted 02/05/2011 at 12:08:39

Report abuse

Matthew Williams
??.It doesnt really matter who we get as manager as long as we have no money to spend we wll not progress?.? The £25 million from Lescott was money we had & did not progress with in anyway shape or form. What makes you think another £25 million to Moyes will make us progress? The 26 million on Yakubu and Fellaini was hardly money well spent either was it? Deluded you must be.


Heard people claim this ?Sharpe who failed at Oldham years ago? ? Oldham this, Oldham that... yawn? not Everton is it? Reid?s managerial career has more achievement than Moyes?s. Sharp & Reid could be a formidable combination for Everton. What has Moyes ever achieved or won? Nothing ? if you mention LMA award for finishing 7th etc I will laugh my arse off.
Karl Meighan
103   Posted 02/05/2011 at 11:52:23

Report abuse

Moses and Nzogbia are the kind of players i could never see Moyes signing.

This type of player can end up as a a total misfit if not settled at a club but the flip side to that is if they feel confortable settled and enjoying there football they could become big important players.

Matthew Williams
104   Posted 02/05/2011 at 12:41:30

Report abuse

@David Mathieson Sharpe has not done anything in management for years and years and he wasnt very good when he did give it a go. Reid didn`t do bad for Sunderland in the early 90s but since then not much and he plays a style of football which I do not really like...so you think bringing these two management failures will bring success just because they know Everton?
Dave Wilson
105   Posted 02/05/2011 at 12:23:26

Report abuse

Gavin

Moses was a striker with Palace and played for England under 17 +19`s as a striker, he has been mainly employed on the wing for Wigan - something you would no doubt whine about if Moyes did it.

Fact is. like Beckford he made the step up but has failed to get a place even in a struggling team.

And by the way on Saturday you were telling us you "heard" Moyes was offered him, now your suddenly proclaiming it as fact.

The fact is, that anybody with 2.5 million could have had him and that made us one probably the ONLY prem club who couldnt have him.

Try harder ? dont need to when you keep raising these nonsensical arguments up, it takes no effort at all to dismiss them for what they are.

Maybe you should consider trying harder ? if Moyes is so bad, it should be easy to put him away. but the best you can offer is another weak arsed point you`ve just made up.
Tony J Williams
106   Posted 02/05/2011 at 12:39:22

Report abuse

"but there are others who are foreign to the league and those who have a badboy reputation that imo Moyes would never take a slight gamble with"

Shandy Andy anyone?

Gavin, bite what? I was suggesting that apart from you singing his praise, Moses has never been, to my knowledge, mentioned on this site. His one goal every half season would have us shooting up the league though wouldn't it? And you do realise that you have compared him to a player many on here think is the worst player ever for Everton and yet his record is only slightly better but only due to playing 7 less games (Are he minutes on the pitch similar to Bily's though)

It's not "cowardly fear" Trevor, it is debate and a valid question. Yes it matters not a jot on web site but it's so much easier to spout "Moyes is shite" but when countered with the "who realistically obtainable do you think could do better?" The answers are usually "shite" or the manager unobtainable..
James Cadwaladr
107   Posted 02/05/2011 at 13:40:38

Report abuse

I think Moyes will stay and for now Im happy with that. What happens to the club, transfers, players, management ovver the summer will show us where we are at and for the time being I dont think getting rid of Moyes is the answer.

If however he was to go, Villa for example and you are asking who I would like in his place the answer is without doubt Jose Mourinho. Who would I like and think we would get.............Gus Poyet.
Dennis Stevens
108   Posted 02/05/2011 at 16:19:10

Report abuse

Mike, you say that we shouldn't give any consideration as to whether any potential successor to Moyes has previously played for Everton. I certainly wouldn't see at as any kind of pre-requisite, but it's worth noting that the only managers to have brought any silverware to the club since the war were all former players. Mind you, they were all also English ? but you'd be sued if you put that requirement in the job specification!
Tony J Williams
109   Posted 02/05/2011 at 18:07:28

Report abuse

Good point, Dennis.
Alex Quigley
110   Posted 02/05/2011 at 18:18:39

Report abuse

Whilst the main move needed is clearly Kenwright doing one, I do get a sense that Moyes has become stale at Everton. His tactics are predictable for other teams and we appear to make the same mistakes each year (slow start; tentative at home against weak teams; too deep and negative formation inviting pressure away). If he is holding out for Man Utd he is seriously deluded, whatever Ferguson might intimate. Fergie just keeps his pals sweet so they can roll over annually at Old Trafford!

I think we do have a few realistic options:

Davey Jones deserves a crack.
Martinez still has an attacking style that would work a treat with better players than his current Wigan squad.
Lambert certainly has his teams playing good passing football, despite the quality of player at his two clubs being inferior to Premier League standard.

What is clear is that all three of the above options play an attacking brand of football that involves passing and creativity ? remember the School of Science?! The likes of O'Neill, Pulis, Warnock play old style hoofball, no better than what we play now. I watch a fair bit of Conference football being up in York and our pattern of play isn't much above that level if I am brutally honest ? it is often effective but it will always be limited ? hence no trophies.

While I don't hate Moyes like some, I am tired of his brand of football, and I honestly think he knows he is out of ideas, out of money and is just pocketing his hefty wages waiting for an approach from Utd that will never come.

Tony J Williams
111   Posted 02/05/2011 at 18:52:08

Report abuse

Alex, we are predictable because we have a good first XI but it pretty much goes to cack after that.

Moyes has to play his best players, when fit, and the team picks itself unfortunately.

Davey Jones, I like him but he hasn't managed to get Cardiff up in 5/6 attempts, hopefully he will this season but e could be a nearly man like Moyes.

Martinez......why do people want him? Posters have a go at some of the defeats Moyes has had but this man has been twatted in so many games, it's unreal. So what he get his team to look pretty, he is probably going to get them relegated this year. At present, he has a 25% win rate...bring him on, halleluah
Gavin Ramejkis
112   Posted 02/05/2011 at 18:54:09

Report abuse

Tony, you asked for a comparison on Moses v Bily.

Dave, you really do take the bullet. Palace played Moses up front but he is listed as a midfielder and at Wigan until injury was playing a reasonable winger or is that something your myopic views deny?

Man City had a £2m bid for Moses turned down, his former manager Neil Warnock was quoted as saying a number of Premier League managers took a look.

Stick to defending Anichebe another lost cause.
Dave Wilson
113   Posted 02/05/2011 at 19:08:20

Report abuse

Gavin

It won't wash lad, I clearly state anybody with ¦£2.5M could have had him, this was proved to be fact.

Just admit it, you made up another cock-and-bull story about Moyes being offered him it and you've been rumbled... You must think we were all born yesterday.

I`d like to say nice try... but it wasn't.
Tony J Williams
114   Posted 02/05/2011 at 19:39:13

Report abuse

No I didn't Gavin, I asked how well he was doing this season and then YOU compared him to Bily, who some posters think is the worst player for Everton ever...... and then his stats didn't really beat Bily's.

What does that show you? That he doesn't even compare to our worst player. (Anichebe is obviously our worst player but he is a forward... I suppose.)

So a "number of Premier League managers" is your proof that Moyes watched him, could afford him, and decided he didn't want him. Tenuous at best methinks. Did he name him specifically? I honestly don't know, as I personally haven't heard him mentioned on here before.
Trevor Mackie
115   Posted 02/05/2011 at 20:38:32

Report abuse

T J Williams,

You disagreed with a point I made and I was going to respond ? but I read some of your earlier posts on this thread and you're just not wired up properly are you?
Tony J Williams
116   Posted 02/05/2011 at 21:13:31

Report abuse

Trevor, you're just not up to any debate are you? Personal insults doesn't equate to a response/disagreement of a point, it's just a fool's game.

The again, two can play at that game so, never argue with an idiot, people passing by won't be able to distinguish between the two.

For that reason, I am out.
Karl Meighan
117   Posted 02/05/2011 at 20:34:57

Report abuse

That's a valid point, Tony, concerning Van der Meyde who was a failure but that's one player. Clubs buy players who fail it happens but they dont stop buying players.

Moyes himself said he was happy with his squad? Man Utd won the title ? were they happy? It didn't look like as they went out and bought a striker who cost less than Moyes spent on Bily.

Moyes's instincts in getting in attacking players are shite, imo; if a player doesn't run down blind alleys chasing lost causes, he wo'nt be a favourite with Moyes, even if they have the ability to go past players and create.

I've not seen much of Tarabat of QPR so don't know if he has what it takes but I doubt Moyes would ever be in for him even if the reports of his talent are true. Bellamy another, a little shit but the type who could shine but its the baggage not wages or Man City why he won't be joining us imo.
Anthony Lamb
118   Posted 02/05/2011 at 20:30:18

Report abuse

Tony Williams (80) - I am not sure you have read my initial post correctly. I think you will see that I was certainly not saying that I wish David Moyes would leave, nor that I would "rather" have Giggs as manager. I was simply referring to the situation if he did in fact do so and I think we all agree that Mr Moyes will leave "sometime"!

I mention the rather "outlandish" idea of someone like Ryan Giggs simply to perhaps raise the possibility of "thinking outside the box". As you well know, Giggs is continuing to defy the ravages of age and performing well at the top level and I have no idea as to when he might decide to undertake his stated hopes of taking up a role in coaching and management.

I simply suggested him as I sometimes think we worship too readily at the altar of experience and continue to perpetuate the managerial roundabout bemoaned years ago by Neville Southall who referred to an insane football industry where managerial failures were often readily rewarded with further opportunities and further lucrative contracts etc on the grounds that they "have experience".

I may be mistaken but I also feel that the managerial reach of the old Catterick and the Shankly days seems to have gone. Except in very rare and prestigious circumstances, contracts, finances, and even the purchasing and selling of players etc are often the domain of others and not simply the manager. It appears to me then that the managerial task should be much more focussed on the nurturing of talented footballers through a professional approach to youth policies, top coaching regimes, genuine skills development etc. Through his experience of over 20 years at the top level at Man Utd, I feel that someone of the stature of Ryan Giggs may just possibly have that "experience".

Everton have had their share of "experienced" managers over many years. In the last quarter of a century, it has resulted in one FA Cup victory! (I hasten to add that this is obviously NOT the sole responsibility of the manager but many HAVE played a part in much of that underachievement!)

As I stated initially, however, whatever happens post-Moyes, whenever that may be, much depends on Everton getting their house in order. SHOULD Mr Moyes leave I was simply suggesting that instead of trawling through the "band of the usual suspects" we could perhaps think a bit more creatively and courageously for it might just be that this "experience" element, although an important element, may at times be just a little over-hyped.

Tony J Williams
119   Posted 02/05/2011 at 21:53:55

Report abuse

Fair enough Anthony. I apologise for that error.
Eric Myles
120   Posted 03/05/2011 at 03:32:26

Report abuse

David #96, Reidy is manager at newly relegated Plymouth.
Damien McKay
121   Posted 03/05/2011 at 10:53:06

Report abuse

Money is not the only thing needed to win in Football. You need a positive thinking tactian, who is willing to take risks on and off the pitch. We need top coaches to get the best out of current players and we need a superb scouting Network to spot good young players who will not cost the Earth.

Standard Liege for example have a better team and play good attacking football. How much have they spent on signings?? Could their coach do a similar job at Everton??

How much did Barcelona pay for Messi? Was it a £100m?? Must've been because you cannot build a great team without a mega rich owners, correct??

We're doomed without Moyes, what are we going to do? Yeah right... give me a break, there are and will always be other managers out there who can do a better job, we just need to take a gamble like we did when we appointed Moyes, and who knows ? it could payoff?
Tony J Williams
122   Posted 03/05/2011 at 12:56:11

Report abuse

"Money is not the only thing needed to win in Football" - I agree but by feck it helps.

There is no coincidence that Man City, who have spent millions upon millions, are now looking to be the team this year to take the 4th qualifying spot for the Champions League.

Look at Chelski, they were floundering, what did they do? Spend over £70m on two new players... and look, they are now 3 points behind the leaders.

A great coach/manager can get you so far but if the players are from Primark, you won't win things. It really is that simple. Portsmouth won a FA Cup by throwing money at the team they didn't have, now they are in a lower division and unable to get a full subs bench anymore.

Man City will probably win the FA Cup...... and it's all down to money, money money. £225k a week for a Barcelona reject.

Barcelona have been lucky, all their youth players have come through at the same time. I doubt we will ever see a team like this again, certainly not in my life time.
James Hollister
123   Posted 03/05/2011 at 17:09:48

Report abuse

Micky Norman ? you say you can't see Moyes leaving unless the financial problem was too great... the fact is, we are beyond it being 'just' a problem ? we are a club in crisis! We have no money at all and we can't even bring in players on loan... I mean seriously, if that's not considered crisis levels, then I don't know what is.

It's sad but I no longer remotely believe we'll ever win any kind of trophy with our current manager and I honestly don't think we'll ever make the Champions League with him again.

And let's be honest, it would be frightening to see us humiliated by the big boys early on; the current team is stale, it's where it is in the league because of how poor the Premier League has become... Best in the World? ? only in the money that's generated; certainly not the footie that's played!

If we are to progress (not necessarily winning things), we do need better management of our players, and what I see, week-in and week-out, is complete mismanagement of the highest order.

Anichebe should never be allowed anywhere near the first team. Further, throwing on your favourite players to disrupt a team that was running on form is another bad move... but he keeps on doing it.

Moyes struggles big time with critical decisions. We should have won a lot more games this season, and we all know that, but, at the end of the day, it's down to the manager ? he picks the sides... and he has failed in the job to do that.

If it was just an isolated season I could probably find a way to forgive him; but, for me, this is not isolated, it's the exact same mistakes made week-in and week-out... It's not about the money; it's about the ability of the manager to do his job properly.

He simply has to go now; he has been too negligent over the years... and has allowed his preferences to over rule what could have been a great squad playing great football.

It's been said to death, that he is a dour and absolutely negative manager, and we'll never win a thing under him. The last straw for me was how absolutely stinking we where against United at Old Trafford... that was just utterly embarrassing ? what was it? Two shots on goal? And that against a second string side... appalling! And the worst part is, that's too much of a kind word for the state of that performance.

Once Moyes goes, BIll Kenwright will be vulnerable... and he will have no choice but to sell... coz no-one in their right mind would want the job with the current custodians. It's sad that it's not only the board who have no ambition ? it's the manager too, despite the crock of shite he and the players spout each week.
James Hollister
124   Posted 03/05/2011 at 17:35:07

Report abuse

Guy Hastings - I honestly do not think Martin O'Neill would want to come to us. For a start, we have absolutely no ambition at board level.

As for fans not putting up with his excuses, we've been doing that for the past 9 years with Moyes... so I think maybe thats a moot point.

I think each of us wants us to play fast-paced attacking football ? not the 'defend and try and nick it' tactic that fails so often when teams just set up shop at the back... when we become absolutely clueless on how to break them down.

I believe MON would be very good for us, but for the life of me, I just couldn't see him wanting to come to us.

I remember back at the start of the decade, we where looking for a new manager, and I understand we approached MON, but he turned us down and did he not then go to Celtic? Some how Smith managed to keep his job until he was sacked and Moyes moved in.

MON wouldn't want to come to us, he is ambitious... which is something we are most definitely not.
Mike Allison
125   Posted 03/05/2011 at 19:02:02

Report abuse

Dennis (108) I don't think the fact that our previous successful managers were Evertonians is particularly relevant to anything. In the past, most managers were appointed on an 'old boy' basis but that doesn't mean that should continue into the future.

Most former blues on the management scene are average at best, and some (such as Peter Reid) still get jobs in the face of all possible logic. Brian Robson continued to get jobs in the lower leagues for years before people finally realised he didn't have a clue. Managers like Mourinho, Wenger, (ahem...) Benitez, Houllier and even Sir Alex Ferguson are good managers without ever having been impressive players (also true of up-and-comer Ralf Rangnick). Also, many of these succesful managers have had their biggest successes at clubs they never played for or had no connection with.

Of course there are many managers who were good players, and many, like Guardiola, who remain at the club where they have strong connections, but I'm arguing that a previous connection isn't a legitimate reason to favour one candidate over another; their intelligence and ability to think innovatively and analytically about the game are more important than anything else.

I'll also repeat the point that English football doesn't seem to value this at all, and instead just wants to appoint famous ex-players regardless of their actual abilities as a manager.

Dennis Stevens
126   Posted 03/05/2011 at 23:24:12

Report abuse

Mike, I'm not touting any former Everton players as Moyes's replacement ? especially as he's still in post! However, the observation I made should certainly indicate that there's no reason not to appoint a former player if they are a viable candidate for the post.

If you recall, one of our most successful managers, Harry Catterick, although a former Everton player, did not have an impressive playing career. The only former Everton player to become manager without showing promise elsewhere was Harvey who came through the internal coaching set-up at the club. I would argue that a previous connection is a legitimate reason to favour one candidate over another ? provided they are otherwise fairly evenly matched.

The only instance I can recall of Everton being tempted by the celebrity former player route was the time Andy Gray was linked to the job. I'm not too sure of the merits of your "old boy" network theory either; I suspect a lot of what happens in the running of club football has far more to cock-up than conspiracy.
James Flynn
127   Posted 04/05/2011 at 02:50:11

Report abuse

Nothing wrong with Moyes. We're missing the fellows who put it in the net.
Dennis Stevens
128   Posted 04/05/2011 at 09:27:40

Report abuse

So if Moyes leaves you'd just replace him with a new striker, James?
Daniel A Johnson
129   Posted 04/05/2011 at 12:23:16

Report abuse

I would like someone like Peter Reid to be part of the backroom/coaching staff constantly reinforcing to these prima donnas what a god given privelige it is to wear that fucking shirt and play on the hallowed turf of Goodison.

Maybe the likes of Bily and Anichebe would run that bit faster if they had Reidy growling at them 24/7...
Mike Allison
130   Posted 05/05/2011 at 12:52:34

Report abuse

Dennis I don't see a difference between cock-up and conspiracy. I don't see the 'old boy network' as a conspiracy in the intelligent, thought out sense, just a laziness of thought among chairmen and the football world at large.

The "he was a good player, and he wants the job, let's give it him..." is far easier for them than understanding the complexities of a modern coaching position and working out which young, and possibly unheard of, coaches might have real potential.

And Daniel (129) I simply don't think that would work with today's millionaire players. An average Premier League squad player earns more than Reid & Co ever did so they take a particular kind of motivation. In particular, that they are part of something progressive or special, or that they can see the intelligence in what they are being asked to do. I can easily envisage that simply growling at them would be treated with derisory laughter, its out of touch, old fashioned and would reinforce the current players attitude that they know more and are worth more than the players of 25 years ago.
Dennis Stevens
131   Posted 05/05/2011 at 16:49:11

Report abuse

I see, Mike ? when you say 'old boy network' you really mean crap Chairmen/Boards who feel more comfortable going for a name they know, be it an established manager with a long & mediocre career or a star player who fancies a go at being manager when he retires. In that sense, you're quite right. If these people really knew how to run a football club then the world of football management would be a much more dynamic environment as coaches of promise would more readily get a crack at managing in the top flight than is the case currently.

However, despite the long-standing inadequacies of successive Everton Boards, I don't really see these criticisms being applicable to Everton's history of recruitment of managers. We haven't tended to employ managers just because they were star players or because established mediocrity is deemed preferable to a promising manager who's proved elsewhere that he has potential.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.



© ToffeeWeb


Latest News

Subscribe to The Athletic, Get 40% off

Online Football Betting with Betway

Bet on Everton and get a deposit bonus with bet365 at TheFreeBetGuide.com



Recent Articles





Talking Points & General Forum

Pinned Links

OK

We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.