BBC Bias... Again!

 Comments (45) jump to end

Just a very quick point from something that really annoyed me this morning.

I'm not sure how many TW readers are also 5 Live listeners, but I usually wake up for work to their breakfast show.

At just before 8 am today they had a short segment on the derby. The studio guests, announced in order - Liverpool obviously first - were Dietmaar Hamann and... Nick Barmby. Could the biased old beeb not have found one single former player with Everton-only connections to represent our side in this little debate?!

The discussion itself was short and banal and mostly seemed to focus on Merseyside unity and Hillsborough, plus of course some talk of whether Rodgers is now making an impact after they beat the Ruskis last night. Nothing whatsoever about Everton.

The final insult was when each was asked what the result would be. Hamaan went for a draw. Barmby said he therefore felt pressured to pick a winner. After a beat, he said he thought Liverpool would win. I'd forgotten how little respect I had for the treacherous fool, but all the feelings of betrayal swiftly came flooding back!

None of this is news of course — BBC coverage of LFC always borders on the sycophantic. But this morning was particularly galling. To borrow Keegan's famous phrase, I will love it, love it, if we beat them on Sunday...

Mark Boulle, London     Posted 26/10/2012 at 10:46:43

back Return to Talking Points index  :  Add your Comments back

Reader Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Dave Lynch
369 Posted 26/10/2012 at 13:32:41
What the fuck are you worried/annoyed about what the BBC think, say or do for?

Coming from an organisation that were shit-scared of outing Jimmy Saville shows they are a bunch of tossers. It's what happens on the pitch that matters.

Nick Entwistle
374 Posted 26/10/2012 at 13:49:24
Why is the level of importance you give the media far and away above the quality it produces?
Tony I'Anson
376 Posted 26/10/2012 at 14:20:20
Mark, let's hope we do our talking on the pitch on Sunday. I can understand the frustration though, with 2 more sleeps to go.
Eugene Ruane
377 Posted 26/10/2012 at 14:30:35
BBC bias against Everton to Jimmy Saville in 'a oner'.

Love TW.

Ray Roche
393 Posted 26/10/2012 at 16:03:38
Dave, I can understand peoples frustration and annoyance with the BBC. It is particularly galling to see the BBC, a supposedly impartial commentator on all matters, including sport, consistently ignore or refer to Everton in the most negative of tones. Are we not worthy of positive reporting? Can the BBC not find anyone who can fight our corner?

If you've never listened to that odious twat Alan Green reporting on an Everton match, especially a derby, then I urge you to tune in to Five bloody Live, or whatever programme the cretin happens to be on just now, and try to say that there is little to get annoyed about. Me? I was apoplectic.....

[A sudden, usually marked loss of bodily function due to rupture or occlusion of a blood vessel.]

Ciarán McGlone
397 Posted 26/10/2012 at 16:32:54
Ahhh..not this crap again.

This particular hyper-senstivity is becoming an embarrassment.

Michael Brien
398 Posted 26/10/2012 at 16:33:49
Whilst I normally enjoy most of the BBC sports offerings - the 6 Nations coverage is excellent - I have to admit to being rather tired of their apparent bias towards Liverpool. I would totally agree with Ray about Alan Green - but mind you he is just plain annoying whoever he is reporting on - after all he speaks with such arrogance about a sport that to my knowledge he hasn't played professionally.

Hopefully we will do our talking on the pitch.

Mike Hughes
403 Posted 26/10/2012 at 16:54:22
I see on the BBC website that they're highlighting Brendan Rogers' "plight" at poor refereeing decisions affecting his results this season. Very convenient ahead of the derby, the cheeky get.

It's wrong to stereotype but It wouldn't surprise me if the paedo-protecting Beeb position Rogers' "plight" ahead of starving African children and destruction to the rain forest soon.

They must have a gobshite template for recruitment at that club.
It's a perfect match every time.
Whining bastards.

Come on lads. Let's stuff them on Sunday. Two or three nil and a Naismith Special on Suarez in injury time.
You owe us after last season.
Give them something to whine about.

Rant over.
For now.

Mike Allison
405 Posted 26/10/2012 at 17:14:00
The other Mike beat me to it, but OMG WTF and all that.

Check this and have your head exploded:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/20102766

I don't know where to start...

Nick Entwistle
407 Posted 26/10/2012 at 17:23:29
Thanks for that Mike.

Didn't take long to become 'one of them' did he.

Tony J Williams
408 Posted 26/10/2012 at 17:20:03
Mike, just discussing that article with a Chelsea fan......lots of swearwords were forthcoming
Barry Rathbone
409 Posted 26/10/2012 at 17:12:23
Journos are lazy twats, you only have to listen to the Sky prog on a sunday, witless buffoons re-iterating cliches and stereotypes about clubs and players ad infinitum.

Questioning the established order of Liverpool, Utd and the FA denies them access and affects their jobs and their equally overblown salaries.

Fuck 'em.

Nick Entwistle
410 Posted 26/10/2012 at 17:26:01
Where would one complain about a manager making comments about the ref before a match? Isn't this banned?
Patrick Murphy
412 Posted 26/10/2012 at 17:19:03
A great many of the programmes made by the BBC are outsourced and therefore they probably have an agenda, rather than the BBC as an organisation.

BBC News Business segments now go to people for comments on the economy or whatever are by pure coincidence the same bank that sponsors our loveable neighbours.

It is very annoying to me personally and most people who are not of the red persuasion that many of the News 24 main news reporters are self-confessed lovers of LFC. Even when viewing a children's programme with my nephew in March, the Scottish presenter, with some puppet in tow, said he was really hoping that the RS would win away to Blackburn as he was an avid Red supporter.

With so many supporters of so many other clubs I have yet to hear someone confess to supporting any of those other clubs

I think the more likely explanation for bias is that those people that do support them, never miss an opportunity to promote their club or complain in large numbers to Offwatch or whoever about the plight – good or bad – of their club.

As I and no-one I know has ever been asked about my viewing preferences I assume that those who voice their opinion or partake in phone-in's are seen as the target audience and as such programme makers will pander to their preferences and prejudices. I could of course be wrong, but that would make more sense to me than believing that 50-75% of the British public support the dark side.

Whatever the reason, you do have to question why we are forced to pay good money to an organisation that is far from impartial and worse still has sucked up to our neighbours for nigh on 40 years.

Patrick Murphy
415 Posted 26/10/2012 at 17:45:52
I didn't realise that Brendan Rodgers had been professionally involved in a Merseyside derby, but obviously he must have been – albeit in a parallel universe – where the Blues have triumphed regularly, due to dubious calls from the match officials. How else could you explain this quote on the BBC website:

"But it is also important to stay calm. I think the referee has a big part to play in that. The history of it shows there has been a lot of red cards but I hope that this weekend we might start to get a decision that goes our way for once."

I would like to see Everton get ONE decision given in our favour... I have waited over 40 years, so I won't hold my breath. Maybe all the negative vibes by Blues fans can be encapsulated by this breathtaking claim by a Reds manager who hasn't even got his shoes fully under the table before proclaiming that the match officials are spoiling his plans and it is so unfair that a team like Everton are above his in the table; obviously something must be fundamentally wrong with the match officials.

I wonder how you can get to that alternative reality, as it seems that the Evertonians there are having a far better time on derby day than us in the real world have endured.

Alan Williams
416 Posted 26/10/2012 at 17:48:46
This was at 7:55 am this morning, I heard it and I shouted at the Radio too, twats! Hamann was the only one that was nice about us, other than that, it was the usual crap of "all families go and sit together at the game, then go the pub together — this hasn’t happened for years and it winds me up.

We don’t sit together and for the 90 mins I hate them more than anything that lives or doesn’t. Thereafter, I tolerate them, but only by biting my lip. Other than sharing a city, we have nothing in common with the club or what is stands for. The quicker they piss off to Scandinavia, Ireland or Cornwall, the better.
Dennis Stevens
417 Posted 26/10/2012 at 17:37:11
Time was when the ref would have been Mr Marriner rather than Andre!
Ged Simpson
420 Posted 26/10/2012 at 18:10:50
Let the BBC know

https://faq.external.bbc.co.uk/templates/bbcfaqs/emailstatic/emailPage

Tony McNulty
422 Posted 26/10/2012 at 18:28:19
Moyes seems to have hit back by his comments on Sky – strong referee; people throwing themselves to the ground when they haven't been touched. These comments are not dissimilar to something I and others said on TW earlier this week.

I am beginning to wonder whether some of the senior people in the club aren't avid readers of ToffeeWeb... Does anyone know for a fact if this is actually the case?

Peter Thistle
423 Posted 26/10/2012 at 18:26:24
The BBC are a joke. Match of the Day is unwatchable these days with those two twats Hansen and Lawrenson. Add to that Lineker's refusal to acknowledge he ever played for us. Thank fuck Sky exists so I don't have to listen to that bunch of muppets anymore.
Barry Rathbone
425 Posted 26/10/2012 at 18:39:59
Tony 422, I've long suspected someone at the club peruses the forums and TW being by far the most serious debating arena must figure highly.

I've lost track of the times Moyes has said something which seems a direct result of comments I've read here.

Nick Entwistle
426 Posted 26/10/2012 at 18:39:20
Anyone catch the horrendous Football Focus last Saturday which had a big ol' Liverpool love-in live from Anfield? All to mark the occasion of playing Reading at home.
Robert Patterson
427 Posted 26/10/2012 at 18:54:44
Suarez last night, DIVE, STRONG REFEREE?
Andy Crooks
429 Posted 26/10/2012 at 19:12:21
Talk about bitter Blues. Who cares what the BBC say? Walter Smith and subsequently David Moyes have been praised to high heaven by the BBC. For fuck's sake, let's stop looking for every imagined slight.

If David Moyes puts out a side on Sunday that, from the very first second, sets out with the intent to destroy that odious team, then the BBC will report it like it is.
Kevin Tully
430 Posted 26/10/2012 at 19:21:11
Those fuckers have not won 2 league games on the bounce since Dec. 2011.

Let's steamroll these cheating " we deserve to win the league " bastards.

They have got David Brent for a manager FFS !

We will win 2-0. Believe.

James Martin
432 Posted 26/10/2012 at 19:26:51
Andy, if the ref gives Suarez a pen every time he is touched in the box or sends off one of our players for nothing or disallows a shed load of legitimate goals for no reason, then there is every excuse to go on at the BBC. Rodgers, like every single other Liverpool manager has done, is pressuring the referee before the derby match.

I remember reading some expose on how the top clubs treat referees at their home games, United used to give them a club watch and get their kids free shirts, some other clubs like to take them on tour with them. Unfortunately, the referee has a greater say than anyone in these games....

If it's Everton v Swansea, then football is allowed to commence and we duly win. If it's Everton v Liverpool, then the ref will undoubtedly intervene in some form or other.

People can blame Moyes all they want for his derby record (which is bad) but some games have just been beyond anyone's control: the Clattenburg derby, the Atkinson derby, the game at Goodison when Mascherano got a deflection with the one shot they had all game and Reina made save after save in one of the most one-sided Goodison derbies in recent history.

You only have to look through any derby compilation to see the number of horrendous tackles from that lot that have gone unpunished. Unfortunately the ref is king in these games and any influence that can be exerted on him should be, Liverpool are masters at any form of the dark arts and the BBC have long been their weapon for this.

Their piece the other week on MotD on why Suarez deserved a pen when they blatantly ignored the images in front of their eyes to make his claim was embarrassing. To contrast that immediately with the one dive Jelavic has probably made all season was just enraging.
Shane Corcoran
435 Posted 26/10/2012 at 19:44:34
Is anyone else noticing the irony of calling Rodgers a moaning bastard when half of the TW audience's opinion ranges from us being hard done by this season to an anti-blue agenda by the Premier League.

I couldn't give too shites about what Rodgers says. Maybe they have been hard done by, Moyes moaned after the QPR so I guess he's a moaning bastard too.

I hope no non-blues are on reading this.
Sam Morrison
436 Posted 26/10/2012 at 19:38:13
Are we getting our excuses in early or what?

We know Match of the Day has long been complacent. Personally I think Lawrensen and Hansen give Everton a lot of credit, but even if they don't... big deal. The producer decides what game to show and they're dictated to by what teams 'draw the biggest audience', which, by popular perception, doesn't include us.

But so what? Rodgers is doing exactly what Moyes has done this week, angling as much as he can to get a bias in his favour from the ref. If we can see it you can be damn sure the ref can too (except Clattenberg).

If your team wins you forget the ref. If we lose then we naturally look for reasons - or scapegoats - our own players shortcomings, other players cheating, or the ref being shit/biased. Not always the case (except Clattenberg).

If we win on Sunday I don't care if they project the footage on Hansen's arse as the credits toll at five past midnight. And if we lose, unless there is a real glaring bias, I hope I won't blame the BBC, Brendan Rodgers pre-match talk, Tony Hibbert not really being a right-back, or the fact that referees are "biased" or "easily influenced by men in red shirts" etc etc

(except Clattenberg)

Richard Farrington
438 Posted 26/10/2012 at 20:00:02
I heard it this morning and couldn't beleive what I was hearing. Just watched BBC 6 o'clock news and in the sports preview its all about them. To quote Morrissey: 'PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE LET ME GET WHAT I WANT – THIS TIME'
FUCKING COYB.
Patrick Murphy
443 Posted 26/10/2012 at 20:14:04
I think some posters are missing the point, most Evertonians accept defeats gracefully even when there has been a mistake by the officials.

There have been games where we haven't deserved to take something, regardless of referees decisions against us, but there have been many games where we have been treated harshly, even when playing better than our opponents.

But as I stated earlier, I honestly cannot recall a Merseyside Derby which has been won by Everton on the back of a mistake by the officials. However, I can remember a great many that we haven't won due to errors made by the officials.

If people think that we have just been plain unlucky with decisions, then fair enough, but I would argue that the odds of one team always being on the wrong end of those errors in their local derby is tantamount to picking the winning lottery numbers 3 weeks on the trot.

Put it this way if a referee gives us something we don't deserve, you can bet that he won't be allowed to forget it, as the media especially Auntie Beeb will ensure that it is highlighted over and over again.

I hope he gives them every decision and we still come out on top, that would be really sweet.

Rupert Sullivan
444 Posted 26/10/2012 at 20:36:23
And so it starts... a full 36 hours before the derby match kicks off and Brendan is out casting doubts on referees and saying that poor old Liverpool haven't had the rub of the green this season.

Well, correct me if I'm wrong, but EFC have been denied 4 solid points (from 3 goals) by piss poor refereeing decisions this season, but is there any article anywhere this week showing Davey Moyes crying over lost points, and just wishing for a bit of luck?

This sort of shit non-story just plays into the mind-games managers, with journos so lazy they're happy to print any old crap coming from a footballer's or football manager's mouth.

I'd put money on a decision going the way of Liverpool on Sunday just to make up for it.

To be honest, it makes me glad that Moyes doesn't do it — one of the few...

Lee Courtliff
446 Posted 26/10/2012 at 20:25:24
I don't just want to see us beat them. I've seen that a few times. I've actually been there when we've beat them. I want us to DESTROY them!! That I have never seen.
Dave Lynch
449 Posted 26/10/2012 at 20:42:26
Lee.
The AJ derby, that was a destruction.
Mike Hughes
453 Posted 26/10/2012 at 20:38:23
Lee #446

You are almost right on the money. But to be absolutely correct: we need to hurt, humiliate and then destroy them (all in the football sense of course).

Colin Wainwright
456 Posted 26/10/2012 at 21:25:37
For a destruction, only 6-0 will do. Stop the bellends singing that fuckin' song.
Derek Thomas
471 Posted 27/10/2012 at 01:38:14
RS — you get exactly what it says on the tin. (When was it ever any different?)

No need to invoke the Trades Description Act.

Why are you all STILL surprised?

Matt Traynor
480 Posted 27/10/2012 at 07:21:44
I'm with Andy Crooks on this. Rodgers is only doing what is expected of him, and what we should expect of him. Moyes has already slagged off Suarez in advance of Sunday, though I doubt Marriner needed reminding what he's all about.

On Sunday we start with 11 v 11. Moyes picks that team, sets the tactics.

Let's see what determines the result in the end.

Keith Glazzard
495 Posted 27/10/2012 at 09:38:04
Eugene - there is a connection. The RS have always 'groomed' the media, BBC included. What Jimmy Savile was doing might be in the same league?
Keith Glazzard
496 Posted 27/10/2012 at 09:43:47
ps: To add, there is no way the seriousness of the consequences for the victims is 'in the same league'; it's the intention to exploit I was referring to.
Graham Mockford
502 Posted 27/10/2012 at 09:56:16
Maybe I've been watching different derby games for the last ten years, but — other than two games where we got poor decisions and the game with the deflected Mascherano goal when we were the better side — we have been the poorer side in most of these matches and have got what we deserved.

It's a bit strange really that in a period we have had a competitive team we have not been able, other than on three occasions, to raise our game — especially considering the good record we had in the 90s when quite frankly we were shit.

We can moan all we like about refs, bad luck, BBC bias or el fucking niño for that matter but let's be honest with ourselves: we have not been good enough in these matches and that's I hope what Davey is telling the players tomorrow — they owe us a performance.
Lee Courtliff
519 Posted 27/10/2012 at 13:05:23
Sorry, Dave, but I don't think 3-0 counts as 'destruction'.

I was thinking more along the lines of 5/6 nil.

That's what I want to see before I die.

Rory Slingo
539 Posted 27/10/2012 at 14:55:53
In the Echo, Barmby is telling David Prentice that Everton are favourites going into the derby bigs us up the entire article. Does he have bipolar disorder?
Nick Entwistle
549 Posted 27/10/2012 at 16:32:02
Watched the Moyes profile on Football Focus this lunch time. They went back to the studio and accused his desire for Suarez to stay on his feet and manipulating the ref and not a word on Rodgers' strong ref comments. Grrrr... anyway, only so much concern you can have when Robbie Savage opens his mouth.
Colin Wainwright
634 Posted 28/10/2012 at 00:54:06
Graham, we may have been shit, at times (many) during the 90's, but we had spirit and fight during certain periods. Generally, we twatted the Shite, when we possesed those qualities.

Very rarely, IMO, is a derby about the football played.

Steve Cotton
677 Posted 28/10/2012 at 08:48:20
This will now come down to the team he picks: if Fellaini is fit, he should play further forward. Recently when dropped back he has looked woeful, so play to our strengths.

Mirallas on the right and Coleman on bench please...

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.



© ToffeeWeb