Bill Kenwright isn't perfect, but in the scheme of modern football chairmen he is perfection for Everton

, The Mirror , 8 December, 132comments  |  Jump to most recent
In The Mirror, Andy Dunn's write-up on the Everton Chairman, who admits is much maligned by supporters, but makes the case that Bill Kenwright continues to 'overachieve' despite the limitations of the club.

» Read the full article at The Mirror



Reader Comments (132)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Richard Reeves
1 Posted 08/12/2013 at 15:32:23
What?!!! Must make mental note............Andy Dunn = lazy, deluded journalist.
Danny Broderick
2 Posted 08/12/2013 at 16:58:32
What exactly has BK achieved at Everton? We are where we are despite him, not because of him!
Linda Morrison
3 Posted 08/12/2013 at 17:09:54
Danny I would like to ask you where you think the club would be now if BK had not come in when he did and we still had the hamper man.
Jimmy Sørheim
4 Posted 08/12/2013 at 18:06:58
He has chosen okay on managers, but totally failed on stadium after stadium and investor after investor with his over priceing.

For the moment I am okay having him here, but he needs to find a stadium solution like yesterday!!!!

Tom R Owen
5 Posted 08/12/2013 at 19:57:51
Linda
The hamper man was bad news I admit
But how would you like the luvvie failures catalogued - alphabetically or annually?
Matt Traynor
6 Posted 08/12/2013 at 20:02:36
The "Hamper Man" delivered a new stand at least.
Oh and didn't pile debt onto the club.

But he wasn't "one of us". Yeah, what a twat.

Mark Dunford
7 Posted 08/12/2013 at 19:58:23
We have also sold consistently well during his tenure and there are few ex-Everton players who have gone on to better things. The price for Fellaini and Lescott was high. Rooney was an exception. It is difficult to blame him for poor purchases which are largely down to choices made by the coaching staff. I tend to think he did well in rescuing the club from the mess it was in when he took over, made two good managerial appointments and has traded as well as could be expected. The stadium should have been delat with more effectively and Kirkby farce was avoidable. Kings Dock would have been ideal. It isn't a fashionable view and it would have been nice to have attracted some investment to build on potential at some moments in past few years. It isn't a bad record and people should be careful what they wish for and a quick glance at the Championship table will tell you that the grass isn't always greener
Peter Laing
8 Posted 08/12/2013 at 20:06:31
Let's see how good a chairman he is when the chips are down and Roberto requires the funds to replace Lukaku and Del Boy need replacing at the end of their loan spells.
Mick Davies
9 Posted 08/12/2013 at 20:38:44
He's a true blue, but he's made some mistakes ie KD and Kirkby but he's picked the right man and he can redeem himself by backing him before gets pissed off, like he did with Whelanchair. Over to you Bill
Andrew Hawes
10 Posted 08/12/2013 at 20:23:52
Completely true, Mark, people detest kenwright without knowing what the alternative is! He's said all along he's not the man to take Everton forward, but he did stabilise this club and is the reason we are where we are today!

When Everton are producing absolutely brilliant performances at Goodison on Saturday, Old Trafford on Wednesday, and tonight at The Emirates, where would you prefer your Chairman and ultimately the decision maker in the club to be? In India? America? A yacht off Russia? — No, I would prefer him in the ground going through the agonising moments like the rest of us!! Just as Bill Kenwright is — as always!

John Keating
11 Posted 08/12/2013 at 20:58:53
Andy Dunn and the rest of the "freebie" loving media — our own local journos included — have been more than happy to perpetuate this myth of the "small club overachieving with limited resources" for years.

Of course this was more than aided and abetted by Kenwright and Moyes. Whilst this shite was peddled then the media more or less kept off Kenwright's back. Hopefully Martinez puts Kenwright in a position where he can't keep making these excuses. Let's not try and rewrite history here.

Kenwright has put nothing into this Club his lies and deceit have split the support like no other. He is a charlatan and I just pray — as I've been doing for years - that someone now will see that we are a Club that can progress with investment and force Kenwright to go. Moyes can no longer hide behind this "little club" shite he was happy to peddle for years... hopefully Martinez will force Kenwright out in the open!

Colin Glassar
12 Posted 08/12/2013 at 21:08:21
100% in agreement, John Keating. If he doesn't back Martinez in January then even his mates in the media will have nowhere to hide. He has made two great footballing decisions in his time at the helm: Moyes and Martinez; the rest has been a sham.
Steve Guy
13 Posted 08/12/2013 at 21:13:53
Could write but would only be repeating what John Keating said above. I would expect a few more of these pro BK pieces between now and January as the annual attempt to lower expectations ahead of the transfer window.

I'd like to think in wrong and that BK will provide funds to maintain our momentum but his track record says otherwise. For 15 (?) years he has been looking for someone to take the Club forward and we've had nada. Just scaremongering about the alternatives and the compliant media going with it. Well the first myth has been blown out the water with RM showing Moyes what can be done with tactics and sin miedo; plucky little Everton my backside.

Patrick Murphy
14 Posted 08/12/2013 at 21:39:05
Steve you would hope that if there was any interested parties out there they would make an approach right now while the club is making headlines. But I can't see it happening and we will have to accept that BK will be at the helm for a good while yet, which is a shame because it wouldn't take a great amount of money for Everton to make that great leap forward.

The fact that outsiders can even utter that RM might be a viable alternative for Wenger or Moyes or that Barkley and Baines can be purchased says that whatever the good or bad points of BK's tenure the club desperately needs fresh investment - no matter how many points the team accumulates.

Aman Kanji
15 Posted 08/12/2013 at 21:44:54
Can someone PLEASE list the top 10 problems / mistakes made by BK and we can vote on them... I'd love to have a proper discussion and rounded view of his tenure at EFC.

It frustrates the hell out of me when I read 'generic' comments about his 'luvie antics' and how he has held EFC back. How many of use run mutli-million pound businesses paying wages circa £50k a week and dealing in a cut throat environment...

Let's out this to bed once and for all...

Barry Rathbone
16 Posted 08/12/2013 at 21:23:05
I've said to much ridicule on here and other forums money is not everything, a club of our size being 9th ish in the financial table does not justify throwing in the towel, a charge I lay at Moyes door not the boards.

Now before I get ex communicated I understand the Sky years demonstrate otherwise. I recognise Kenwright and co have done dreadful things some are amateurish mistakes but other stuff borders on immoral.

The Kirkby stuff was just a self serving money spinner for a hand full of people that could have killed us as a club, never forgive that.

But unfortunately that is business and I would expect every football board in the country to do the same - IF THE FANS LET THEM!!!

That's really my point football fans don't like boards full stop - they all seem crooks or tight with money or complete head cases like at Cardiff/ Hull/ Blackburn so I'm gonna come out the closet here.

If the team is doing well I don't care who is in charge - I'm as fickle as that - dreadful I know but at the moment "the devil I know" Bill is ok.

(Martinez getting poached within 3 yrs because we still can't match financially will see me marching on Bill's office with a bazooka mind)

Tom R Owen
17 Posted 08/12/2013 at 21:56:17
John 799
You've hit the nail on the head
Eugene Ruane
18 Posted 08/12/2013 at 21:53:03
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=32Y1hmkX7Q8
Patrick Murphy
19 Posted 08/12/2013 at 22:06:39
Eugene let's hope we can say to BK "see you later - Alligator" pretty soon.
Danny Broderick
20 Posted 08/12/2013 at 22:06:17
Linda,

History will prove that the hamper man was not such a bad chairman or us - he's a beacon of shining light compared to Kenwright! Off the top of my head, in the short period he was our chairman, we must have broken our transfer record several times - I'm thinking Samways, Amokachi, Speed, Ferguson, Bilic, Barmby etc. so he invested heavily in the team. That's a positive.

We didn't borrow any extra money, there's another positive. We won a trophy, and while that was more down to the squad and manager at the time, surely he deserves a mention for investing in that squad? So another positive in my book. And we also invested in the stadium, by re-building the Park End. So not a bad track record, in my opinion.

Where would we be now if he was in charge? I would say straightaway we would be much better run. We would probably be in a new stadium – maybe the King's Dock?

I'll give Kenwright his due – he is good at picking managers. After that...... I'm struggling. Maybe, he's a blue, I'll give him that. He's not a very good salesman though, is he?

Danny Broderick
21 Posted 08/12/2013 at 22:23:03
Also, let's see how much money RM has to spend in January and next summer. Bearing in mind we brought in £33 million for Fellaini and Anichebe. We spent around £20 million on McCarthy, Koné, Alcaraz and Barry. Let's see where that other £13 million goes, shall we? Because another thing Bill is good at is the law of diminishing returns, or Other Operating Costs, as it is known on the balance sheet.
Mark Frere
22 Posted 08/12/2013 at 22:06:28
Spot on John Keating, our managers are just left to paper over the cracks and the real problems at boardroom level. Fans will and have tolerated BK and his cronies while ever things don't look that depressing on the footballing side of things. Lets cast our minds back a couple of years ago when Arteta, Yakubu and Beckford were sold, and we didn't see any of the money invested on replacements. We started the season poorly and fans frustration almost reached boiling point with the board.

That January, we brought Pienaar and Donavon in on loan and bought Jelavic with money from selling Billy. There was no real investment from the board but these players came in and turned round our fortunes on the pitch. The early discontent from our fans were nullified, BK has made managerial appointments that have saved his skin.

The guy is a real charlatan like John correctly says.

Ste Traverse
23 Posted 08/12/2013 at 22:27:55
Can Andy Dunn take his tongue out of Kenwright's backside?

We usually get these pro-Kenwright articles in the media whenever we go on a good run.

I wonder what Mr Dunn thinks of the many fiasco's BK has on his watch during the last 14 years?

Kevin Tully
24 Posted 08/12/2013 at 22:28:27
Why would anyone want to ruin the good vibe we all have right now?

Mentioning his name at this juncture is like goosing a supermodel knowing you have to pay for the brat to wear Gucci undies for the next 20 years.

Let's just enjoy the hear an now please, without hearing the screams of labour.

Peter Warren
25 Posted 08/12/2013 at 22:32:07
Andy Dunn sums it up perfectly we will always play in blue, be called Everton and have a chairman who is an Evertonian. That's it. Ridiculous
Iain Johnston
26 Posted 08/12/2013 at 22:22:41
Danny, he sold Ferguson behind Walter's back to fund Park Hampers.

He lied to Walter about finance, hence the reason Dacourt, Matterazzi and Collins where sold on rapidly. Smith said at the time if he'd known Johnsons financial state he wouldn't have spent the money.

He also refused to relinquish his assets in Tranmere which was unlawful. If he was such a beacon of shining light, why didn't he invest in Tranmere Rovers when they were on the verge of promotion?

He made a quick buck at our expense then fucked off to Jersey. Just another Robert Maxwell...

If Kenwright hadn't got his mates to stump up the cash, we were gone.

Iain Johnston
27 Posted 08/12/2013 at 23:23:25
But yes, Kenwright was supposed to be short term, to steady the ship. He hasn't got a clue about business and his mates haven't got a clue about Everton...

If he does finance RM in January, it begs the question, why not OFM?

Maybe the plug was pulled on Fer because he knew £8.5m was robbery, the Bily and Yakubu deals where so loss-making, he got wind he was off up the East Lancs and OFM never got in the way of players leaving to further their careers away from "little Everton".

In short, he was sick to death of the other guy's misery.

Harold Matthews
28 Posted 09/12/2013 at 01:26:22
I always thought Mr Dunn was a keen Koppite.

As for BK. Well he can certainly pick a manager, that's for sure, but I don't trust guys who fake tears. The Kings Dock and Kirkby fiascos were way over my head. I tried to read up on them only last week but got lost in the jungle of back-stabbing committees and forums. If BK was at fault he definitely wasn't on his own.

He suits Martinez because he keeps his nose out of the football side of things and that's a big plus. We're on a great run and, quite frankly, I'm loving it.

As for the future. What will be, will be. I'm too old to give it a seconds thought.

James Flynn
29 Posted 09/12/2013 at 02:39:38
I clicked on the Mirror link to make sure. Same headline.

"Perfection for Everton", Kenwright is?

The earth has tilted on its axis.

Roberto has the same challenge as Moyes. How to do well with (as nice as I’ll put it) "indifferent" ownership.

If Roberto gets us into the CL or keeps challenging for it this season and the two following, don’t expect him to stay if Mr Perfection et al still control the Club.

Gareth Fieldstead
30 Posted 09/12/2013 at 05:47:08
I am also going to rehash what has been said. Three weeks before the window reopens and Bill's mates are coming out with supportive pieces, questioning the sanity of those fans who dare to question his tenure. The proof will be the available funds, especially when Roberto had a profit of over £10 million and it has been suggested that the McCarthy transfer was not dependent on a player being sold. I look forward to him explaining why Martinez had no funds and the overdraft remained at £50 million.

As for comparing him to Johnson, I think in general we have had garbage chairmen since Carter was in charge. Johnson openly lied about the club's financial affairs, undermined all his managers and nearly took us down twice.

Marsh was more interested in the golf course, responsible for the club being broke and lagging behind when the EPL took off and obviously Kenwright, well we could be here all day listing his mistakes. Fingers crossed there is genuine money to spend and Martinez continues with the great start he has made , COYB!

John Keating
31 Posted 09/12/2013 at 09:19:51
Andrew 783 Mark 749
your comments seem to ring a bell from the last couple of seasons.
Where you mention Kenwright past comments from many could have the name Moyes !
It's a "be careful what you wish for" piece.
How many of those did we see over the last few years regarding Moyes and I would suggest to you that those fears have been blown completely out of the water !
I appreciate you have your opinions guys but when someone lies consistently over years, to have any trust or belief in him is complete naivety.
Martinez has proved that a bit of positivity, a bit of change of attitude and more important, accepting that we are not a "little club punching above our weight" can work wonders.
Imagine what might be if we could get a board of directors that formulated a long term business plan and put anything more than nothing in investment in the Club would achieve!
But then again its trying to convince the "be careful what you wish for" brigade
Thomas Lennon
32 Posted 09/12/2013 at 09:18:21
Name me an Everton board who were interested in building the business other than via football? After the 60's up until Johnson we invested little and certainly didn't act aggressively when the Premier League started up. Carter seems to have presided over one or two excellent (but short) periods but little seemed to be done about building on those, pushing our finances up to and beyond our competitors. We seemed to rely on a rich owner rather too much - once he was gone so was the money.

Johnson did his bit for the business side but wasn't a football man - the opposite pole. If KD has happened we would still be in his charge and he would at least part own the ground, though argueably we would have had a buyer if that were the case.

Kenwright & friends inherited a wreckage which we edged around with Moyes rebuilding.

Since True Blue was dissolved (and Kenwright has become Chairman)we have consistently improved - to the point we now play Arsenal off their own ground 4 days after winning at OT. Business side is still nowhere near our big competitors but is improving. Just are we can see the benefit of moving on from 'rebuild' mentality on the park, we hope that moving on from a football chairman will had a similar effect on the business side of things. The snag is we would have to accept change too - right now we could be playing in front of 55000 (think we could fill it now?? At least £500 000 a game more than last season when we only had 30 - 35 000 a game) but travelling a little longer, changing some traditions, paying a little more etc etc.

I know I know - disaster/lining pockets/single train line...but also the financial foundation for the Martinez revolution. We will always be limited by the size of our pockets.

Matt Traynor
33 Posted 09/12/2013 at 09:59:05
The Mirror and The Echo are owned by the same group. The Echo (and the Mirror) ran piece after piece when Stadtler and Waldorf were taking the RS to the brink of relegation. Our Chairman is looking to make a financial killing off the club having put no money in and seen our debt position spiral (£40m to spend on transfers or 5 years interest payments?) yet they continue to tell us how lucky we are to have him.

I don't even believe the date on that rag anymore.

Brin Williams
34 Posted 09/12/2013 at 10:31:20
Bill's an 'Impressario' but fails to impress!!
Ciarán McGlone
35 Posted 09/12/2013 at 10:31:07
Anybody who doesn't know the history of Kenwright - Pre- and Post Johnson.. should really hang their heads in shame.

There is no need to rehash the arguments. Those people who bother to find out about their club know that he a complete and utter fool.

Eugene Ruane
36 Posted 09/12/2013 at 11:04:29
Andy 'He tells it like it isn't!' Dunn is basically just another mouthpiece for the status quo.

One more lazy-arsed hack churning out two-bob 'opinion' that does nothing but fill blank spaces by looking at the LITTLE picture.

Recently he was whining about the 'unfairness' of loaning players which imo misses the point completely (and probably deliberately).

Smoke-and-mirrors, muddy-the-waters, alehouse lawyer shite.

But I'll tell you what, just to show this is not just reactionary intransigence on my part, I'd be prepared to change my opinion and give the feller fulsome praise should I ever read anything by him along the lines...

"THE FINANCIAL DISPARITY OF PL CLUBS AMOUNTS TO CHEATING AND MUST END!" - "Imagine watching a 100m Olympic sprint final and noticing that 5 of the runners have been forced to wear diving boots. There would be such an outcry about unfairness that it would simply never happen. Yet every season, because four or five clubs can outspend the rest by, in some cases, hundreds of millions, the rest are to all intents and purposes, wearing diving boots when the season kicks of and..."

I won't hold my breath.

As for his opinion on BK, like saying "Ok I accept that Dracula has those two big pointy teeth, but what about all his many OTHER teeth that are perfectly fine?"

(with pieces like this, I'm guessing Bill must be free vol-au-venting Dunn to within an inch of his life when he goes to Goodison)

Eric Myles
37 Posted 09/12/2013 at 12:05:49
Aman #822, a bedtime read for you
http://www.toffeeweb.com/season/10-11/comment/fan/16215.html

http://www.toffeeweb.com/season/10-11/comment/fan/16228.html

Matt Traynor
38 Posted 09/12/2013 at 12:55:14
Thomas #967

"After the 60's up until Johnson we invested little" - the Main stand was rebuilt from 69-70, finally opening in full in 1971

"We seemed to rely on a rich owner rather too much" - Under John Moores EFC were financially sustainable. He underwrote a lot of the transfers, but ensured the club traded profitably to afford them
-
"Johnson did his bit for the business side but wasn't a football man - the opposite pole. If KD has happened we would still be in his charge and he would at least part own the ground," - Kings Waterfront happened under Kenwright's watch. Not Johnson.

"Kenwright & friends inherited a wreckage which we edged around with Moyes rebuilding" - The inherited a club with a healthy balance sheet and many assets. Compare that to what we have now.

"The snag is we would have to accept change too - right now we could be playing in front of 55000 (think we could fill it now?? At least £500 000 a game more than last season when we only had 30 - 35 000 a game) but travelling a little longer, changing some traditions, paying a little more etc etc" - I am assuming you are referring to Destination Kirkby. Putting aside the fact that it was never going to get Planning Permission, or BK was never going to raise the £82m to build it, the accessibility reports prepared by the consultants showed huge numbers of the fanbase would see travel times extended from around 45 minutes to 120 minutes. One can only speculate what would have happened to them, as EFC chose not to consult with them as to whether this would affect their attendance. The idea that DK would generate an additional £6m p.a. was tenuous at best, and, assuming the £82m was borrowd, it's likely it wouldn't have met the increase in finance costs.

But apart from that, great post. You just work at The Mirror with Andy Dunn.

Paul English
39 Posted 09/12/2013 at 13:13:22
Andy Dunn, watch him on Sunday Supplement... He is a bitter kopite, who can't stand our club...!!!
Scott Robinson
40 Posted 09/12/2013 at 13:26:58
In my opinion, Kenwright sums up Everton. Integrity, passion and decency. Someone on BBC said we are going to be the second most loved team in the league! We play with our hearts and love the game.

Most of the owners in the PL are overseas, not particularly interested in the team, but rather the power and glory it brings. It's time that we acknowledge that, despite all the faults and limitations of BK, he represents everything that is Everton. I am proud to have him as our Chairman!

Scott Robinson
41 Posted 09/12/2013 at 13:31:03
sorry, I meant Chairman!
Alex Bonnar
42 Posted 09/12/2013 at 13:19:59
Bill Kenwright / Everton have no money and at present nobody with money to waste wants to buy us. However much you want that to be different will not change it, so either name the buyers with money or a specific source of money that we can have in addition to the current situation.

Instead of moaning about what you dream should be, why not just organise 30,000 supporter to put in £1,000 each, without any payback guarantee, and give the £30,000,000 to the club, easy to say – if you don't have any money to spare, then join the club with Bill Kenwright and stop complaining.

Alternatively, you could just support and enjoy the superb footie and players we have at present. Happy Christmas – can't wait for the next game myself.

Phil Bellis
43 Posted 09/12/2013 at 13:24:49
Few get a chance at redemption but Kenwright has one in January
He can start beginning to make up for his myopia, losing Kings Dock (whatever the conspiracy theories, he was the chairman) by telling the money men to piss off, discovering ambition, taking a chance and helping Martinez to the Champions (sic) League

Under Roberto the ethos of "just get plucky little Everton 40 points" won't wash

Winston Williamson
44 Posted 09/12/2013 at 13:44:37
Scott Robinson 026

Integrity and decency?

I personally have no response to that.

Unbelievable...

Denis Richardson
45 Posted 09/12/2013 at 13:21:48
A few good results and a smiling manager and suddenly people have very very short memories.

Am not going to begin to list the lies and cock ups this chairman/board have delivered in the last decade or so. Good performances on the pitch are what the masses want and care about, few actually give a shit about what happens behind the scenes. Hence when the results are good, all of a sudden our Chairman is the dogs bollocks again - utter garbage.

BK in my view is an Everton fan but don't for one minute think he doesn't have his own financial interests at heart first. The man has not put anything into the club other than the price he paid for his shares (how he funded that price is still to this day a mystery, the 'I remortgaged my house' bullshit is a non-starter) - this in itself is not necesarily a negative as no owner is obligated to put their own cash in, over and beyond what they paid for their stake. However, what has been clear over the last decade is that this board has no plan at all in relation to the long term future of the club.

They have relied managers keeping the club just about on life support via decentish league finishes and decentish transfer dealings, dodgy loans and lastly the massively HUGE god send of the Sky TV money. Without the TV money every year, we would have gone under a long long time ago. Ambition at board level has never been more than simple survival in the league, hence why Moyes had it so easy for a decade.

A decade ago the stadium was an issue, a decade on the stadium is STILL an issue. There has been no viable plan to sort this out since the KD and Kirkby fiascos. I have not heard anything whatsoever in the recent past as to what plans the board have to sort out the elephant in the room. Please don't start on the 24/7 search for a buyer nonesense again either. Simple things like our commercial income are also a joke and the deal for the training ground but those other topics.

The sad ironic situation we find ourselves in, is that the more successful Roberto is on the pitch, the less the pressure on the board becomes to do anything meaningful as the majority of Everton fans are only interested in what happens on the pitch in the near future and not where the club will be in 5 or 10 years time. The only hope I can see at the moment is that Roberto somehow miraculously gets us into the CL and the extra money generated will allow us to progress or persuade an investor with a decent business plan to cash BK out - for whatever ridiculous sum he's after.

Am curious to see if we still continue to make a loss despite now getting an extra 20m odd a year in TV money, or will 'other' operating costs suddenly balloon from 23m to 40m+!

Eric Myles
46 Posted 09/12/2013 at 14:01:01
Denis #035 "Am curious to see if we still continue to make a loss despite now getting an extra 20m odd a year in TV money"

You'll have to wait more than a year to find that out, the next set of accounts due out, sometime in January maybe, will be last years.

Ciarán McGlone
47 Posted 09/12/2013 at 14:10:15
"In my opinion, Kenwright sums up Everton. Integrity, passion and decency."

----------------------------

Christ on a bike.

Eugene Ruane
48 Posted 09/12/2013 at 14:49:09
Scott Robinson - "In my opinion, Kenwright sums up Everton. Integrity, passion and decency."

I imagine your opinion is much sought after.

P T Barnum believed 'There's a sucker born every minute' and views like this show he was spot on.

I'm actually reminded of Tony Hancock's version of 12 Angry Men.

Despite 11 jurors against him, he won't entertain the idea that the defendent is guilty, so (at 17mins 50 secs) he is forced to give his reasons why.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejHKA2HI4TY

John Keating
49 Posted 09/12/2013 at 16:42:39
Scott
where have you been the last 14 years ?
Obviously not on planet Earth !
Integrity, decency ? Unbelievable
Another one trying to rewrite history.
Harold Matthews
50 Posted 09/12/2013 at 16:52:21
Fantastic thread. The life and works of BK provide more entertainment on Toffee Web than all other topics added together. A man for all seasons. A sunny smile and a shady wallet.
Danny Broderick
51 Posted 09/12/2013 at 18:30:52
Kenwright has sold off all the silver. We don't even own our training ground now. The finances are terrible. And yet they are looking for £130 million to sell us! Incredible. We'll have no money again in January - that's obvious, because Bill's mates in the media are painting the rosy picture again, buttering him up so the fans lap it all up. Let's see where the £13 million profit we made in the last window goes...
Jim Lloyd
52 Posted 09/12/2013 at 22:36:35
Linda, Scott.

For the life of me I cannot understand how you come to the conclusion that Kenwright is a good Chairman.

He has sold every asset we had. He has farmed out the catering and the merchandising, so we get nothing in the way of profits going into the club.

That might be construed as a good man, doing his best to keep the club afloat. Personally, I think that is total bollocks. How any Evertonian can forgive him for his part in the loss of the Kings Dock, I just cannot fathom.

Then there is Kirkby. Too much to go into here but the lies that we were told, the division of the fans and the total lack of looking for an option b, should the plans for Kirkby not materialise, makes me think he has been a disaster for our club.

Iain Johnston
53 Posted 10/12/2013 at 02:32:26
I’m sure there are many individuals who would love to invest in Everton.

Maybe BKs money mad mates who really control the club keep blocking this so they keep control of their golden goose?
Until they decide to release their grubby limpet like hold I don’t think anything will change.

Kenwright looks miserable, why?. I thought he’d be smiling like a Cheshire cat offering the odd sound bite regarding his masterstroke in employing RM and the rapturous football skills we are displaying, not a bit of it.
I wonder if it’s because he knows his "mates" have already pocketed this summers money and he has to tell his manager the cupboard is bare?

Phil Yates
54 Posted 10/12/2013 at 04:46:41
Am I the only one wondering where Uncle Bill is of late? In the not too distant past, any sniff of success would have him all over TV and Radio, lauding how wise and erudite he was for picking Moyes all those years ago and how they had a special relationship. However, despite us playing the best brand of football seen at Goodison Park for 25 years and winning at Old Trafford, all the result of a wonderful managerial selection, there is no sign of him! No credit stealing or that daft grin, recounting shit stories from the past.

Now, why is that? Maybe he too is really pissed off at the antics of Moyes pre- & post-leaving and he doesn't want to come out for fear of saying what he really thinks. Or that he'd have to admit how shit the football really was under Moyes.

Maybe Roberto Martinez has told him to back off. God only knows, he is used to chairmen who are mouthy after dealing with Whelan, so maybe he's asked Kenwright to let him get on with his job.

Maybe he really is searching 24/7 for a buyer. Although we still look as grim an investment on paper, there is no doubt 'Brand Martinez' would make us more appealing to a genuine football investor.

Whatever the reason, long may it continue. I for one think it's the classiest thing he's done in a long time.

John Zapa
55 Posted 09/12/2013 at 20:32:36
The stadium debate should not have even taken place. The reasons for moving were never justified, neither was their a logical financial benefit to move. I don't think a new stadium is a priority. What's the point of a new 550000 seater stadium when you can only fill it for 2-3 games a season?
The first league cup game of the season, the stadium was barely half full. It may have been lower league opposition but our neighbours had the same situation the next day with Notts County and they had a full house. That summed it up for me. Better the focus is on expanding the commercial revenues, expanding the overseas fan base, and doing well on the field.
Paul Andrews
56 Posted 10/12/2013 at 06:22:10
Scott Robinson 026,

There is a guy in an African state that has a small problem.
He has been left an inheritance of £100 million but has a clause that prevents him accessing it.
He needs a European citizen with a current bank account to take receipt of the funds on his behalf.
All he asks is that the recipient sends him ££££££s to cover his legal fees.

Get in there Scott sharpish before you miss the boat

Jim Potter
57 Posted 10/12/2013 at 07:21:41
Good to see everyone agrees ... as normal.

What is the alternative? Where is the alternative? Er........

The fact is we have Blue Bill .... am I happy - not particularly ... but I can't get away from the fear of a foreign businessman taking over and all that is potentially incumbent with that scenario. That mortifies me ... whereas Bill just worries me.

The one thing that I hope is that he never sells to the archetypal megalomaniac or a business conglomerate. Some people actively crave this - I personally dread it. We will be selling our soul.

What is the solution ... erm .... join me in a prayer anyone?

(Andy Dunn is an Evertonian).

Jim Potter
58 Posted 10/12/2013 at 07:36:57
Paul 252 - the gentleman you refer to is called Mr Umbumba and he has suffered some dreadful misfortunes in Nigeria. I am sure all Evertonians will give generously.
Ciarán McGlone
59 Posted 10/12/2013 at 09:01:03
Jim Potter,

I hear there's a cure now for fear of foreigners.

Jim Potter
60 Posted 10/12/2013 at 09:44:01
CM 280

I should have phrased it "any egotistical businessman". They just tend to be from abroad and have no connection with any English club they buy.

Ciarán McGlone
61 Posted 10/12/2013 at 09:52:01
If you're looking for an egotist Jim..I suggest you look no further than Goodison for that 'tendency'.

I would further suggest that our chairman's 'connection' with the club has played a big part in his misrule - not only has it given him a greater leverage with the fans - he is also quite obviously unwilling to 'let go'.

Peter Foy
62 Posted 10/12/2013 at 09:54:16
We'll all see how decent he is when he's selling Ross Barkley after the world cup for a couple of million and a few add ons while struggling to keep hold of Roberto.
Will Alex Ferguson be in the background while Bill's on the phone crying to his mum?
Aman Kanji
63 Posted 10/12/2013 at 11:47:38
Cheers Eric (#012) — I will get onto it on the train commute...

12 Points from next 4 games....C O Y B

Karl Masters
64 Posted 10/12/2013 at 17:55:43
I’m sure Dunn is a Kopite. I wonder if they would have accepted Kenwright’s performance at Anfield? Not likely!!!!

Its only the over performing Managers of the last eleven or twelve years that have stopped him being exposed.

Financially, the future of our Club is none too clever. We could have had worse, but we certainly should have had much, much better!

Aman Kanji
66 Posted 10/12/2013 at 19:24:34
John #250 Great shout... All you have to do is check StubHub or such like for home games for any of the current top 5 clubs. We always have loads up for sale at face value... Nothing for the others.

Focus on players, league and cup comps. If we carry on playing as we gave last four games, it will snowball...

Robin Cannon
67 Posted 10/12/2013 at 22:02:24
"Commercially, Everton has been pretty much stagnating. The last accounts showed a loss for 2011-12 of just over £9million. Overall debt was up to £46m. Turnover was down to £80.5m and 75 per cent of that figure then went on wages. Throw in the lack of progress on a stadium for the future either and the club is hardly the most attractive financial proposition."

I love how he just suggests that this commercial failure is an unalterable fact that Kenwright has had to overcome, rather than a demonstration of his inability (or unwillingness) to manage Everton effectively as a business concern.

I actually still don't want a billionaire to use the club as a vanity project. Arsenal are still the UK model that I think we should be trying to emulate; who think long term, remained competitive while paying off the debt of a new and excellent stadium, and are now starting to reap the benefits financially to the benefit of the team. In the absence of any hope of a German style ownership model, that's the kind of way we should be run.

Eric Myles
68 Posted 11/12/2013 at 05:17:41
Jim #260, some fans had the same fear over Moyes leaving.
Jim Potter
69 Posted 11/12/2013 at 12:00:24
Eric - I was one of them, but ultimately (to me) whoever we got in (and I was a Martinez fan - although isn't everyone saying that now!) - I don't believe a manager can change the essence of a club in the same way a new "owner" can. Sure, a manager can have a style of play, bring players in, kick them out, etc, - all huge influences - but an "owner" can dictate everyhing. And that really makes my spine shiver given some of the examples out there. I'm no Blue Bill advocate - but under him at least we still feel it's the Everton Football Club we've always known (albeit with huge debts, dodgy "investors", et al).

Patrick Murphy
70 Posted 11/12/2013 at 12:11:15
Jim but to some of us older fans BK's tenure has not seen the Everton FC that we've always known, we were always a force to be reckoned with even if we weren't the top spenders for long periods. If BK's predecessors hadn't have had the foresight to develop the stadium at various points in time god knows where we would have been.

BK's time at the club has coincided with the riches of the PL TV deals and still we are in debt and with a stadium which needs updating – his only plan has been to live hand to mouth and that's a plan any one of us could have come up with but it is not a plan which can take the club forward in the long-term.

Raymond Fox
71 Posted 11/12/2013 at 12:18:22
Right now is a big opportunity for BK and the board to attract outside investment, especially if can sustain our form.

Gate receipts should be up, and would imagine we should attract plenty of neutral fans because of the Martinez factor + the club being seen to fight the battle without the fortunes being spent on players by the big 4-6 clubs.

Brian Dagnall
72 Posted 11/12/2013 at 12:22:26
Interesting reading the very varied opinions of this man.

I've never met Mr Kenwright, don't want to, don't feel I need to.

But I can't help but smile when I read you guys think he tells lies. What, the Chairman of a private UK company tells Porkies .... oh my god, hold the front page. Guys, sorry to break this to you, but in UK Corporate life, it is routine. How does a Chairman of RBS push through a share issue just months before the Bank folds. Are there ANY company fat cats who become broke when a company folds? In your dreams.

Maybe some of you are right that the Chairman made errors. This is also routine, so get over it. The Liverpool FC owner has spent a fortune to achieve what exactly? Company people make errors, spend badly ...... but it's not your money, it belongs to them. Some have said Kenwright's board "sold the silver". But it was their silver, not yours. Everton is not a "Supporter's co-operative", it is a private company owned by a group of individuals.

Frankly I am loving this team we have under RM, it is an absolute pleasure to watch. My eyes fill up with pride as I watch. Criticism and opinions of the Chairman, the Board, and employees from people who are like me, broke and could never own a football team, is just a little tiresome and honestly, utterly pointless.

Tom R Owen
73 Posted 11/12/2013 at 12:57:21
Brian 648
We go on about the luvvie because WE CARE!
With other companies the shareholders often vote off the CEO when the company is underperforming or in our case the board is enept.
We have a "poacher and Game keeper " scenario here.
Who holds the most shares in OUR CLUB?
Phil Bellis
74 Posted 11/12/2013 at 13:02:52
Brian
"Criticism and opinions of the Chairman...is just a little tiresome and honestly, utterly pointless"
Bet Mssrs Swales and Johnson are relieved at your saying that
Patrick Murphy
75 Posted 11/12/2013 at 12:59:41
Brian you are of course correct in your assertion about private companies and the way they act, but does that mean that everybody should just accept that behaviour as the norm and allow them to carry on regardless - in those other businesses everybody who uses their services has a choice to spend their money or not. Football is a very different animal - most fans cannot just choose another club and spend their money elsewhere and Everton FC in particular is an institution which has many thousands of fans who are emotionally attached to it. How can it be wrong for people to question the abilities and motives of the custodian, even if as you say it is futile to do so. I worry that in another 50 years people will happily accept serfdom and I'm glad I won't be around to witness it.
Phil Bellis
76 Posted 11/12/2013 at 13:09:04
Murphy - none of that, young man!...know your place
Andrew Ellams
77 Posted 11/12/2013 at 13:11:57
Brian, if you want to do the corporate comparison then you could argue that the actions or lack of them of our Chairman and board could have a detremental effect on the quality of the product that we the customers purchase whenever we buy a match ticket. ie. The state things are in off the pitch could easily send the club to shit and leave us watching lower division football every week. Find a Portsmouth or Leeds fan and ask them all about it.
Alan Williams
78 Posted 11/12/2013 at 12:48:25
Brian, don't waste your time trying to be reasonable on this debate, the vast majority of his dissenters always come back with great sound bites and great business ideas with the use of hindsight, very easy in their world.

BK has never had the money to bankroll EFC that's why we have had to go cap in hand for KD and DK, all his major failures come back to the simple fact that the only real wealth is held within his share certificate so don't be surprised we have failed on major projects that involve major investment.

Slagging him off is a waste of time — he is just a patsy to the situation and this constant allegation of selling off the silver is totally misleading for the simple reason he has done it to keep the business afloat. And when you point your finger at him, don't forget the overpaid playing staff that year on year drain the club of its cash.

Other than the value of shares which can go up or down he hasn't taken a wage; if he sells the business for a massive profit on that share price, well good luck to him... but I can tell you factually that he could have easily sold up to any serious offer and made himself a nice earner but he is frightened this legacy will kill EFC. Unless the new owner offers a great deal for the club, he will not sell. Take this as you like but his love for the club is also his big weakness and he is weak when it comes to making decisions; in business at that level he is flawed.

If I ever had a billion, the last place on earth would be to invest in EFC, better to have the money in the bank and enjoy it rather than some player spending it on a gold Bentley like Kevin Mirallas. Some of the comments and allegations raised against him on this site are disgraceful yet they all shout and love the players who spend the cash every week... but hey, the Chairman is a twat!

Tom Hughes
79 Posted 11/12/2013 at 12:55:13
Brian..... I find the "it's not yours so shut up" attitude far more tiresome and irrelevant to be honest. People can and have listed whole series of mishaps, missed opportunities and deception during his tenure...... yet this is all ok to you. Where do you draw the line I wonder?

The club is nothing if the fans don't turn up........ so his shares (and mine) are worthless without them..... yet you find them an irrelevance who can be lied to and deceived repeatedly. Are you serious?

Our club has been run into the ground.... only competing because of the ability of this and the last manager to fashion a good side out of very little........ and by selling to buy or even to survive. How can this be sustainable long term?

Yes, we're doing great on the pitch at present and long may it last..... but it shouldn't detract from the fact that we have underachieved in almost every other respect in the last decade or more. You ask what LFC have achieved in the same time. ...... I've lost count of the trophies won for starters. The board's job is to manage the club to support the manager financially, and to provide the facilities and infrastructure to maximise matchday and commercial incomes.

During their tenure we've been outspent in real and net terms by well over 20 other clubs (including clubs in the lower leagues), and even now are below mid-table in terms of wages. On top of that we are comfortably bottom of the league in terms of stadium development...... There are clubs in the Conference League who have more exec boxes than us.... and the list of other stadium developments is endless. So let's not kid ourselves.

Kevin Tully
80 Posted 11/12/2013 at 13:28:54
Alan - Surely the £35m in interest the club has forked out over the last 7 years, and the sale of players to pay the banks (Arteta) means he should consider selling to the first company who could make us debt free?

You are well informed, so you definitely know there have been two serious proposals to buy the club in those 7 years. Don't you?

Kevin Tully
81 Posted 11/12/2013 at 13:37:47
* Sorry - Make that £35m interest in the past 5 years!!
Tom Hughes
82 Posted 11/12/2013 at 13:36:44
Alan.... don't all clubs have expensively acquired and paid players? Haven't we spent the least of nearly all other clubs and we're way down the wage list table too..... so we can hardly blame those factors for the poor off-pitch investment. In fact most other clubs have invested far more than us in both and off-pitch development. ....... so Kevin Mirallas' car choice is a complete irrelevance.
Winston Williamson
83 Posted 11/12/2013 at 14:00:51
I bought a car last week. A new shiny one! Not gold, I must admit!

If my boss ran the business into the ground, through poor infrastructure and lack of investment would that would be my fault as I bought a new car?

Brian Dagnall
84 Posted 11/12/2013 at 13:47:18
Thanks guys, your counter-points are well made, and I do accept that everyone has a right to object to the way our Club is run.. I did make the point about LFC but someone says they had won trophies in the last 5 years. True, but this current owner has spent loadsamoney and has achieved what? Everton are a better team than Liverpool are. A fatcat owner like the American can spend badly, just like a skint one like Mr Kenwright can. You see we can all be brilliant in hindsight.

Someone earlier said if he had a fortune there is no way he would buy a footy club. Well, you would if the cash invested didn't really matter to you, and you were in love with the Club. They are the only circumstances I would put money in myself. If you apply any standard investment criteria to buying a footy club, you wouldn't touch it with a bargepole.

Some companies in UK are well run, very many more are not. Everton may be well run, but maybe it is not. Man City make an enormous loss every year. Is it well run? I have no idea, but some Sheikh wotsit is spending what he considers small dosh on a little passion he has. So is the Chelski boss, Abramovich.

But where does all that get us in relation to our Club? If our club was magnificently run by an owner who always got it right (Kings Dock et al), I for one am unsure our team would be better than it is now. Maybe it would, who knows? Speculation our Board's fitness to manage is fine, but does it really "dig any coal"?

Noel Early
85 Posted 11/12/2013 at 14:38:08
I have said it on here before and I will say it again, the man has been blessed with a team that has overachieved consistently. Until we go trough a bad period, Kenwright will get a free pass in the media and with the vast majority of supporters.

We all know the catalogue of errors and lack of funding during his tenure. The biggest mistake without question has to be Kings Dock.

How he can't find an investor is beyond me... well, it isn't really, come to think of it. He wants some fool to purchase a new stadium, wipe all debt off, and have enough money for himself and the rest of the clowns he is associated with.

Tony J Williams
86 Posted 11/12/2013 at 15:07:13
I read Scott at 026 and a little piece of me died inside.......
Ciaràn McGlone
87 Posted 11/12/2013 at 15:11:07
"BK has never had the money to bankroll EFC "
--------------------------

.....and yet he did...the actions of a self-centred egotist.

Nick Entwistle
88 Posted 11/12/2013 at 15:07:56
This line about Kenwright being a pauper chairman with rich members of the board not investing does my head in. You don't become a massive player in the West End without making a penny or two.

When the average ticket is about £80, with more seats being sold by the week than Goodison, he'd be raking in about 50% of the profit... those small tubs of ice cream are about three gold sovereigns apiece!

When we were crying out for a midfielder or striker in Januaries past, he spoke in bluffs again and again and didn't invest when we needed that little bit extra.

But if I were him I'd be sitting on the club too. He can talk about 24/7 and all these potential buyers who pull out at the last moment (fnar) but waiting on the chance for CL would encourage a long game. But he's had to sell off a lot of the club along the way on that hope. If its not that, I don't know what the hell he's up to.

Tony J Williams
89 Posted 11/12/2013 at 15:41:57
We'll get the interested investors story come the January window......then it will go quiet again after we have sold Baines and brought in a loan deal.
Brian Harrison
90 Posted 11/12/2013 at 15:39:48
As I understand it we spend virtually everything that we make, so unless a billionaire takes over nothing will change. I know people always ask "Where has all the money gone?" — well, not into BKs pocket I don't think.

Yes, he may have borrowed money from Green — but only because the banks wouldn't lend Everton any more money. So maybe Green makes a fair chunk of interest out of his loan but, seeing the banks thought we were a bad risk, then I don't know where else he could have borrowed the money. Even Alan Sugar said the worst job in the world is being chairman of a football club; he says, no matter how much you spend, the fans still think you are a tight arse.

Kenwright personally cant compete with the wealth of the top 10 chairmen in the prem, and neither do we make enough as a club to challenge the top 6. So I would love to hear what BK should be doing to make us more profitable.

Jim Potter
91 Posted 11/12/2013 at 15:51:53
Winston 662.

I note that you wrote this at 14.00 on a weekday - it's not your boss running the company into the ground ....... it's you!

Colin Wainwright
92 Posted 11/12/2013 at 15:54:13
Well Brian. A starter for ten would be to have not flogged the merchandise rights to Kitbag for 20 B&H and a couple of mojos.
Raymond Fox
93 Posted 11/12/2013 at 15:46:32
What ever the ins and outs of BK and the board as business people, we all know the Prem. as a fair competition is a joke.

When you have mega rich owners on ego trips the other clubs are starting each season with a weight around their necks which effectively puts them out of the running.

Is there not an attempt to solve this problem going on at the moment, I did read something about it but I hav'nt had time to
digest it?

Nick Entwistle
94 Posted 11/12/2013 at 15:54:26
Brian, one thing he could have done was not let Walter Smith spend £19m of NTL money before it was in the bank.

Hasn't that underpinned the lost money for over a decade?

http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/deal-away---two-hours-3561125

Kevin Tully
95 Posted 11/12/2013 at 16:04:50
There you go Raymond ;

http://www.financialfairplay.co.uk/financial-fair-play-explained.php

Brian Harrison
96 Posted 11/12/2013 at 16:02:16
Colin 678

Absolutely agree, he should have kept the merchandising in house. But I don't think even if we had not outsourced to Kitbag we still wouldn't have a great deal more to spend than we do in most transfer windows.

Peter Foy
97 Posted 11/12/2013 at 16:15:16
If Bill Kenwright was willing to sell his shares for what they cost him, or even with a reasonable profit, he would have his pick of investors. They would be queueing up.
He could insist on investment in infrastructure.
He could insist on investment in players.
He could insist that the new owner is a blue.

But he won't.

He wants 150m quid.

There lies the problem.

Dan Brierley
98 Posted 11/12/2013 at 15:28:22
Its always been an interesting debate, and one where some people get bent out of shape when anybody dares offer an alternative view that the Chairman isn't as bad as made out. I won't try to justify his fuck ups, but my view is not becuase he is the devil incarnate, its because with Everton he seems to be very naive when making business decisions. Nor do I question why it has taken so long for us to be sold, when I think to myself what kind of investment we would need to be able to spend 30 million a season without acruing debt.

The point that sticks out in all this though, is that around 3 or 4 years ago everyone was adamant we were staring into a 'financial abyss', or 'on the brink of administration', or saying 'this buy to sell strategy doesn't work'. There were angry protests, leaflets distributed, advertisements, websites etc telling us fans that we have to unite because the end was nigh.

And now, here we are years later, flying high in the league, and still going while countless other clubs seem to have gone into administration. All the predictions have evaporated, and when you ask those involved why the protests have stopped, the answer recieved is the equivalent of when someone only looks at the floor trying to scratch a piece of chewing gum off with their foot. If anything, its actually gone the other way. People that previously heavily criticised the 'buy to sell' strategy, have recently been saying how selling Fellaini was and buying McCarthy was an 'excellent piece of business'.

There will always be those fans that believe all the stories they read on ToffeeWeb about things Kenwright has supposedly done, but in reality the average fan couldnt give a shite about how a football team is run, as long as it is doing well in the league. If Abramovich stopped putting his dosh in and Chelsea suddenly started getting into relegation battles I am sure their fans would also make up stories that people would believe and start protests to get him out, even after the guy has probably put the best part of a billion quid into his team.

An interesting way to consider it, is asking who is the best chairman? The one that has to bankroll his business to compete, or the one who gets it to compete without putting anything in? But even though I like the moral logic of that idea,as an Evertonian, I would choose a Sheik over Kenwright in a heartbeat. Even though I would know it was morally wrong that my club became a toy of the mega rich, I would welcome it just to see us become the FIRST merseyside team to win the Premier League trophy. That would be priceless.

Raymond Fox
99 Posted 11/12/2013 at 16:29:20
Thanks Kevin I'll have a look at it.
Brian Harrison
100 Posted 11/12/2013 at 16:40:49
They say opposites attract the 2 subjects that get most people posting is BK and Blue Union.
Alan Williams
101 Posted 11/12/2013 at 18:16:23
Kevin (659), they have had offers that have fallen short of the valuation plus the people making those offers are not individually wealthy enough to put in without a return hence him holding back. He could have easily sold for a reasonable profit and walked away. Tom (661), I'm sorry but it's extremely relevant how much modern day footballers take out of the club because it means the business has to raise more capital year on year just to compete in the transfer market so the business model needs to expand with this market force if we want to stay in the EPL. The simple economic fact is EFC is suffocated as a business by its low revenue streams like Goodison Park, low ticket prices and low amount of corporate hospitality add to this the cash poor Chairman who hasn't sufficient wealth to make a difference then player expenditure is totally relevant to our predicament. EFC board have made mistakes that is normal for a business with very low if any EBITA the mistakes were short term gambles like finch farm was to release funds for the manager in the hope it will drive more revenue through the old lady. The business of football is mad and attacking BK for all his errors is counterproductive to our predicament unless we have a plan B, we don't but you must give them credit because we still have a chance to compete at the top table for probably the smallest investment of all the top 7 teams in the EPL. We all want to go the next level but that level needs a massive investment of many hundreds of millions of pounds with very little chance of them being paid back within at least 8/12 years depending on future TV deals. BK can't do this he openly admits it, by all means challenge his decisions but be respectful of the predicament before your stab him in the back.
Aman Kanji
102 Posted 11/12/2013 at 18:19:45
Great thread... (is this what's known as a thread!) Loving it... We'll structured debate, exactly what I've been looking for...

Agree with so much, including Dan#685 and Ala. #698.

Ideal scenario as I see it in my little knowledge of managing a club would be if we could expand the current ground to add more seating... 10k extra capacity... Improve steady and slow, building up global fan base and season ticket sales.

(there's a slight problem of the availability of space, I know, especially with a primary school [opposite team!])

Expanding suddenly via cash rich investors is a scenario we don't want to get into... EFF will be a plaything with the owner possibly choosing players in/out, choosing the New strip, appointing totally inexperienced senior staff (Chelski, Cardiff)

We'd loose the heart and soul.

Steady she goes...Build slowly, let them get on with it, keep an eye on them and have your say, BUT keep it coherent and not a rant... No one listens to a rant, not even my misses!

Winston #662 which car did u buy, I live the smell of a new car...

Barry Rathbone
103 Posted 11/12/2013 at 18:25:21
Alan, may I ask how you know?

This and previous posts suggest you have the inside track most of us aren't privy to and forgive me if it looks like I'm doubting it's just that the vast majority of us are forever putting 2 and 2 together re Kenwright and coming up with any number you care to think of.

Fair enough if you can't but it would be interesting to find out first hand some answers:

is Bill actually just a figure head?

if so who really holds the reins?

Did Mansoor come in for us?

any names you can mention who looked but didn't buy?

is one of Bill's terms he must stay on?

what is Bill's asking price?

I'm sure others have further questions but if you have the "gen" it would be of great service to the rest of us evertonians to put a bit more meat on the Kenwright bone.

Thanks.

Aman Kanji
104 Posted 11/12/2013 at 18:43:11
Case in point re. moneybags investors who squeeze every ounce of their new clubs...

Come on Tigers!!!!!
http://m.skysports.com/article/sports//9068460

Mark Taylor
105 Posted 11/12/2013 at 19:32:15
Am a bit late to this but BK is the perfect chairman if your goal in life is to finish 6th to 8th in the PL.

Winston Williamson
106 Posted 11/12/2013 at 19:52:35
Jim 676
Was on my dinner then and just leaving the office now! With my boss there's no chance of the ship going under...talk about a scrooge at Christmas!

Aman 708
I'd love to say something very flashy, but it's an Audi A4.

I have one question...

If you don't have the money to invest in the team as a modern day Chairman/Board why bother? Kenwright is a 1980's Chairman in a modern game.

Patrick Murphy
107 Posted 11/12/2013 at 20:09:31
Don't you mean 1880s Winston?
Tom Hughes
108 Posted 11/12/2013 at 22:51:32
Alan..... it's only relevant if we're the only club with a high wage bill..... the fact is we are not. We are nowhere near the biggest spenders on wages nor transfers we are not even average.... therefore it is no more a hinderance in relative or real terms than it is to the rest. As far as being suffocated by Goodison and poor income streams then surely that is their responsibility. .... they have had over a decade to resolve these issues and have failed miserably when all around have transformed their facilities and in most cases still outspent us. Even minnows have been able to maximise the potential to fully harness and grow their fanbases by building ambitiously. Tiny clubs who have spent most of their histories in the lower divisions are planning expansions and new stadia that will see them boast equal or grester capacity than us. Even FC Utd are building a new stadium. We were even offered the greatest get out of jail card of all time..... and we let it go due to internal politics and/or remarkable incompetence. The list of mishaps is almost endless..... the failure to deliver even when handed a solution giftwrapped sums up the performance of this regime. It has been shown that stadium development can be achieved in parallel to team development. .... but our club has demonstrated a complete inability to juggle these issues the way that so many others have. Moyes and now Martinez have papered over these failings.... what happens if we lose Martinez too?
Jim Potter
109 Posted 12/12/2013 at 10:34:24
Winston - 19.52pm! - you deserve a bonus mate. Give Tiny Tim a pat on the head for me.
Jim Potter
110 Posted 12/12/2013 at 10:34:24
Winston - 19.52pm! - you deserve a bonus mate. Give Tiny Tim a pat on the head for me.
Tom R Owen
111 Posted 12/12/2013 at 11:17:05
Tom 786
Well said!
Why do people still think Kenwright is managing our club well?
Alan Williams
112 Posted 12/12/2013 at 12:05:34
Barry, I don't have any inside information from L4 the people I know work in the City and are heavily involved in Football Finance along with other things, one is a customer too so when I meet up for work and socially they know I'm an Evertionian so after some drinks my low level interrogation starts. Football finance fascinates me as it's so different than real business its untrue. These people are ruthless and only care about the deal as opposed to the club but in my world that's normal as a fan it worries me a lot that's why in an odd way BK isn't as bad as you all make out, his intentions are honourable but his passion for the club is totally lost in this world and his willingness to appease everybody means he is a weak Manager. Tom, you need to take the emotion out of your analysis of EFC and look at us as a business based on the P&L, you also need to compare apples with apples and your example of FC United is unrealistic. Businesses run on cash flow it's the single most important part of the engine and its EFC Achilles heel, has been for 20 years. The business of EFC squeeze this every day and it takes a monopoly on all free pennies, we run hand to mouth so a stadium upgrade or relocation take a long term plans EFC don't have any for the simple reason the current custodians have never had the intention to be there as long as they have been they are now stuck with this scenario. The EFC board have made the simple decision to invest in the team first and infrastructure second this will eventfully change but the worry is it will be forced. KD was lost because Gregg wanted control of future income via SFX , EFC Board at the time felt this was too much in hindsight this was wrong but EFC were relegation fodder every year at the time and the new sky deal was years away and wasn't known, The Granchester's had the wealth to bridge this gap but chose to be anonymous, that's far worse in my mind. DK was a great opportunity for the business (not the fan) it was a partnership that made sense but the location was its handicap and I said on TW at the time if that deal was put into Walton Park it would have gone through, was the stadium the best….no, can we afford the best certainly a no so it was a compromise but from a business point (emotion aside) it made sense and it would have increased the value to the shareholders which is what boards do, as a fan your analysis will probably be totally different I'm not interested in dissecting this its gone. The only way EFC can organically grow its assets now is by sacrificing the money from player sales into the business, firstly clear the debt and save on interest, then look at a long term loan for a new build or look at a phased upgrade policy at GP but this policy must be transparent and I'm afraid us fans will have to pay more too it goes both ways if you don't accept this then the only option is to stay as we are and hope we get kids through that add value to the bottom line or get a new owner willing to cross guarantee the investment. These problems supersede the BK debate, it's an unwelcome side line that must stop and all sides must come together for the common goal of improving EFC, the major shareholders like it or not at some point will make a profit on their purchase live with it and move on.
Brian Harrison
113 Posted 12/12/2013 at 12:16:20
Alan Williams

A lot of valid points, and I posted earlier and probably more simplistic in that the club spend virtually every penny that comes into the club. That means there is very little scope to improve the stadium, and as you rightly point out this board have decided to pump the money into players rather than improving the ground. I would also concur that we have some of the lowest ticket prices in the Premiership, I can remember when both Everton and Liverpool season tickets were virtually the same, now I think there is about £300 difference.

So if we don't get a rich owner how do we improve our finances, well we could increase ticket prices considerably but you can imagine the response that would get. Yes we could see how we can improve our merchandising and there is a lot of scope in that area. I would probably think that trying to get out of the Kitbag deal would be too expensive, so we may not have an option there. But I would suggest that we don't renew when the contract finishes I assume it does have a timescale.

So if we cant do much about our merchandising and are reluctant to rise ticket prices significantly, then our only other avenue is the sale of some of the assets ie players. Another avenue that understandably fans don't like. So I like many are saddened that every time we produce a talented footballer the next question is always how long can we keep him before one of the richer clubs come to buy him. This is not just a problem for us but for most Premiership teams, but as fans we don't much care about other clubs and why should we. I just wish there was an easy solution.

Tom Hughes
115 Posted 12/12/2013 at 13:08:31
The point is we haven't just arrived in our precarious financial position. ... and those operating constraints are not confined to Everton only. Saying that we have decided to invest in players instead of infrastructure isn't borne out by the fact that we have been outspent by over 20 other clubs..... several with lower turnovers than us and with expensive new stands or whole new stadia paid for..... and very few have sugar daddy backing too.

As far as I can see our board could be a cardboard cut out for what they have brought to the show and what they have delivered. They most certainly didn't act in our best interests as regards KD or DK but in their own. The arsenal chairman at the time of KD said he would have given his right arm for the same deal...... yet we allowed it to slip...... only a season later we sold Rooney for the outstanding amount that we would have needed (an amount offered by a serving board member at the time).

The whole point of the Kirkby deal was supposed to be centred around the enabling package from the retail element. .... and as predicted this was all a complete red herring. Time, opportunity and resources all wasted. How this is running the club well is beyond me...... and that's not stabbing anyone in the back nor emotional reaction. Emotional based argument is supporting him simply because he's a blue despite the endless evidence. Put it this way, if it was Johnson would the support be so blind?

Patrick Murphy
116 Posted 12/12/2013 at 13:57:36
Television money mostly pays the players wages; merchandise and ticket sales help to pay to run the club; as I have said before any one of us could have operated Everton FC that way if we could have borrowed the anti to purchase it in the first place.

BIll may well be the greatest Evertonian that ever walked the earth but he has done nothing to add value to the club, there is nothing tangible to show for his time in charge and the longer he remains as the owner the greater chance of more and more clubs overtaking us on all fronts.

It is for this very reason that many supporters feel it is vastly unreasonable for Bill Kenwright and his cohorts to make a substantial profit on his original investment.

Eventually as those clubs do catch up off the pitch they will also catch us up on the pitch - a couple of bad seasons on the field or a barren time where we don't have a youngster to sell and we may never ever recover and will become an also ran club when we should have been one of the elite.

Nero fiddled while Rome burned - our Emperor has no clothes.

Eric Myles
117 Posted 12/12/2013 at 13:58:26
Alan #654 "this constant allegation of selling off the silver is totally misleading for the simple reason he has done it to keep the business afloat" If the business is being kept afloat then how come we are reporting ever increasing losses each year?

Dan #685 "There will always be those fans that believe all the stories they read on ToffeeWeb about things Kenwright has supposedly done" Can you enlighten us to the things that you consider BK has "supposedly done" that he is being falsely accused of?

Alan #698 "The simple economic fact is EFC is suffocated as a business by its low revenue streams like Goodison Park, low ticket prices and low amount of corporate hospitality" Isn't it the board's job to resolve these problems and what action have they taken?

"The business of football is mad and attacking BK for all his errors is counterproductive to our predicament unless we have a plan B, we don't" and isn't it the board's job to have a Plan B?

Aman#708" That's what a lot of people have been saying but the board have no interest in gradual improvement they are looking to sell at a great profit without putting any invstment in to achieve it.

Alan#850""Businesses run on cash flow" I'd say it's more like businesses surviveon cash flow. You can have a heavily indebted business continue trading successfully as long as the cash flow is there to prevent the plug being pulled by creditors, that's how Ponzi schemes work.

"DK was a great opportunity for the business... from a business point (emotion aside) it made sense and it would have increased the value to the shareholders which is what boards do" But the board were told from the get go that it was a none starter, that it broke planning and development regulations and would be called in and rejected but they refused to listen. Is that how boards are supposed to operate to increase shareholder values? If it were a true shareholding company the board would have been sacked over that stunt, not to mention the results of the inquiry.

James Flynn
120 Posted 12/12/2013 at 13:37:21
Tom (858) - Thank you.

Reading the posts prior to yours "explaining" our predicament, I was beginning to think our owners were innocent bystanders.
Alan Williams
121 Posted 12/12/2013 at 17:19:15
Tom, Pat, Eric: at some point we need to move on from what's happened as the major shareholders own this business that we all love.

Unless we have a rich benefactor we have to deal with what's on the table and that includes organic growth through reducing our expenditure so we can increase investment it's the only way we can advance but we as fans need to understand that simple principle because we will have to be part of the commitment be that through attending the game or increased prices anything else is a pipe dream at the moment.

I'm off up North tomorrow to spend a weekend in our great City so fingers crossed I will see you all in the pubs celebrating the win on Saturday.

Gavin Ramejkis
122 Posted 12/12/2013 at 18:08:14
Apparently if you google Andy Dunn all you get back is images of a knob, utter shite article by an utter gobshite and a RS to boot
Phil Bellis
123 Posted 12/12/2013 at 18:09:57
Alan
You should be in a Goodison bar giving Everton your cash to generate...oh, hang on, erm...outsourcing?
Gavin Ramejkis
124 Posted 12/12/2013 at 18:39:02
Alan #916 I personally find your "let's move on" statement ignoring whats gone on before as deluded as the thought process being discussed at the moment with former IRA terrorists and cleaning that slate. Ok, its not as extreme as the heinous crimes perpetrated there but BK has been at the club for a very long time, including on Peter Johnson's board so fully aware of what was going on before True Blue and wiped from any transgressions that happened on that clock.

Moving forward and the debts began, his blase statement of not having the funds to take the club forward yet over a decade later and far too many royal fuck ups and lies to name - we all know them well and he's still here like a stinking carcass hanging on for a massive free handout, a handout which isn't coming because on his clock the business has stagnated and is worth nowhere near what he and his shady unseen friends of the club are asking for it.

I get the distinct feeling even given some head the ball with enough money to buy him out his self interested ego would demand he still stayed on with some role on the board so we'll only be shut of him when his toes curl up. I find BK's presence at Everton an abhorration and will continue to do so, I've heard all the bluff and nonsense from him, the lies and the countless excuses made by the clapping seals on his behalf. I've heard the careful what you wish for, the xenophobic Daily Bigot style angles of foreign ownership and not one has swayed what I've seen with my own eyes; BK is not a fit chairman for this football club if its ever going to progress beyond its current old boy network amateurish present business model.

Barry Rathbone
125 Posted 12/12/2013 at 18:05:55
Alan Williams

Thanks for the reply, bar Utd and possibly Arsenal, owning football clubs to make money is a complete non starter it has to be a "loss leader" (Man City) or vanity project (Chelsea).

Villa, Liverpool and soon to be exposed Utd with american "business types" can't compete with the above, even Real Madrid are financed with no regard to P&L, spanish banks via royal connections are their benefactors.

We need to be schmoozing multi billionaire tyrants and gangsters with dancing girls and depravity (cv ready in case job advertised in the echo) not simply promoting ourselves as "a going concern" via city types with a sales brochure.

Si Cooper
126 Posted 12/12/2013 at 20:01:14
Barry - sounds like you are pimping yourself out! An aberration I'm sure.
Gary Reeves
127 Posted 12/12/2013 at 19:41:11
Gavin. You’d prefer "any head the ball" than BK? That’s a tad unconstructive, if you don’t mind me saying. Especially following on from some decent posts on this thread.

I don’t usually get involved in these arguments because as other people have said — we are where we are. You can’t magic-up investment from nowhere, and I’ve never been convinced that BK has ever turned down offers that would be beneficial to EFC as a whole.

Personally I’m not sure I’d like us to go down the Man City route, with a team of foreign mercenaries. I just get bored when I hear about Chelsea and Spurs fighting over the likes of Will.I.am for £30m, and it turns out he’s shit anyway. Could have picked up Tom Jones for a fraction of that!

Rather have Roberto’s vision and know-how than foreign "head the balls."

Si Cooper
128 Posted 12/12/2013 at 21:03:42
Gary, I think Gavin meant you'd have to be a 'head the ball' to match what BK is asking for the club.
Gavin Ramejkis
130 Posted 12/12/2013 at 21:20:36
Gary, my statement was as Si says if someone is daft enough to pay over the odds for the club given its true fiscal value. I've said plenty of times on these pages before I don't think it would take a billionaire to make Everton a far better business model.

I'm not clamouring for that mythical bottomless pit of cash to throw around, the paucity of the way the business has been ran is negligent beyond belief, the current incumbents have missed boat after boat and clung on for dear life with detrimental methods to keep the business going rather than taking a steer with the right people employed in the right roles to turn our losses into profits, BK isn't that man and neither are his fellow board members.

I've also said I have no problem with new investors looking to turn coin from their investment, that's the way the world works - they invest in infrastructure and take a slice with profit back out. Unfortunately you have board members putting not a single penny in and yet each holding this inane sense of entitlement that those shares they bought years ago which just meant money swapping hands with their previous owners suddenly entitle them to a massive carpet bagging profit.

Gary Reeves
131 Posted 12/12/2013 at 21:51:33
Well Gavin,I’m afraid I can’t get too excited about profits from shirt sales or sausage rolls. Ultimately it all translates to the team,out on the pitch.

I was lucky enough to have been at the games against West Brom, QPR and Norwich, when we WON the League, and I’ve watched on impassively as Chelsea/City BOUGHT the League.

I’ve always maintained that times would return when players were less mercenary and ownership was less important. Let’s see where good coaching, good scouting and a bit of passion can get us.

Gavin Ramejkis
132 Posted 12/12/2013 at 22:25:38
Gary thats the root cause of monoculture businesses, they become reliant on single income streams, the team plays well you get bums on seats and yes you are turning coin but not exploiting the supporter pound, the team play shite and go in decline and you have no ancillary income streams.

Very simplistic way to describe it, you have a vineyard in Europe, for years they have a good harvest and a good season of wine production but thats all they do, suddenly you have a few years on the bounce of bad weather or blight in your crops and you are royally humped your blinkered reliance on the weather and everything being rosy year in year out with nothing to fall back on and when the worst happens, and it always will, you've nothing to act as a crutch.

Sausage rolls and shirt sales might not float your boat but if you aren't squeezing the pound you aren't worth a balloon as a successful business, a football stadium is empty far more than its occupied, you need to come up with options to earn money all year round and exploit what you have in terms of international players and marketing, corporate match and non match day offerings, symbiotic business partnerships for advertising and promotion.

Investment in infrastructure and additional revenue streams gives you the coin to invest on the pitch and QED build something to attract more and more to the flock.

Harold Matthews
135 Posted 12/12/2013 at 22:48:45
Gavin. Booker Prize stuff. Wish I could write like that. Most of it was over my head but who cares. It was wonderful. Thanks mate.
Peter Lee
136 Posted 13/12/2013 at 00:33:31
I am a regular reader but I was astonished to see the date this thread started and its length.

It is in parts the supreme example of:

Never let the facts get in the way of a good story/moan

I don’t know whether it did any good for XXX but at least I felt better (about myself?).

I suspect that there are few with the facts and the business acumen, although what that has do with football is a moot point, to answer the question but ..........

What is EFC worth?

None of us are interested in what it might have been worth if ............ etc.

We are one of two teams in a medium sized English city, distant from London. Our rivals have a world-wide recognition that eclipses ours.

We don’t have a money-spinning ground.

The unique selling points we have are commercial disasters.

We care about and support the community and former players. And the fans, through limiting the one thing that might make a difference, ticket prices.

We are right to be proud of these things.

That is who we are. Chosen and burdened with the responsibility of tradition.

What is it all worth as business? I genuinely want someone to tell us all. I am not remotely interested on what someone claims Bill Kenwright is asking.

Eric Myles
137 Posted 13/12/2013 at 04:38:16
Alan #916, it's all very well telling fans to 'move on' but the problem is we have the same board with the same blinkers on making the same mistakes day after day.

Surely it's time for the board to 'move on' and look for solutions to problems they have caused instead of waiting for the big pay day as they have been doing for the last 10 years.

Paul Andrews
138 Posted 13/12/2013 at 06:39:08
Eric,

That is the frustrating aspect of our improvement.
If we had a decent Chairman and board who could back Roberto with a reasonable transfer budget the sky really would be the limit.

Gary Reeves
139 Posted 13/12/2013 at 09:08:07
Money trees? Youth Hostelling with Chris Eubank? Monkey tennis?

It’s a Premier League football club — not a fookin’ Village Fete! What sort of extra income streams are you kicking BK about? Shitty souvenirs? Prostituting ourselves to the Chinese? A 4th, 5th and 6th strip? Same-sex marriages on the pitch at half-time?

Christ O’reilly — get real! We have matchday revenue, TV income, some (small scale) corporate stuff, and souvenirs. After that, I’m struggling... but I await some suggestions.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads