Everton handed home draw against Swansea

, 26 January, 131comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton were drawn to play Swansea at Goodison Park in the draw for the Fifth Round of the FA Cup, one of four all-Premier League ties.

The Blues were the penultimate ball drawn after Manchester City had been paired with Chelsea and Arsenal with Liverpool.

The full draw was as follows:

Manchester City v Chelsea
Sheffield United or Fulham v Nottingham Forest or Preston North End
Arsenal v Liverpool
Brighton & Hove Albion v Hull City
Cardiff City v Wigan Athletic
Sheffield Wednesday v Charlton Athletic
Sunderland v Southampton
Everton v Swansea City

Quotes or other material sourced from BBC Sport



Reader Comments (131)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


John Francis
1 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:38:43
Swansea home!
Chris James
2 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:39:03
Cracking draw: Man City vs Chelsea, Liverpool vs Arsenal... and we get home to Swansea!!!
Colin Glassar
3 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:39:35
I'll take Swansea at home.
Kevin Naylor
4 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:40:01
Great draw, especially with respect to the other ties.
Paul Ferry
6 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:40:50
Could that have been a better draw for us or what, lads and lasses?

"Tell me ma, me ma..."

Mike Gaynes
7 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:41:08
Excellent... a welcome home draw!
Colin Glassar
8 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:40:40
Swansea at home is a good one for us. Either Chelsea, Man City, the RS or Arsenal are going out.
Matthew Salem
10 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:41:26
And it gets even better with Man City vs Chelsea and Arsenal vs redshite....this draw could not have been better
Matthew Salem
12 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:41:26
And it gets even better with Man City vs Chelsea and Arsenal vs redshite....this draw could not have been better
Vinny Garstrokes
14 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:40:49
Could have been worse - I thought we were heading for Southampton away when there were only 4 balls left!
Bill Gall
15 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:41:28
Last 2 balls in the hat just thankful we got the home draw.
Jermaine Jennings
17 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:43:20
Great draw at home! Come on, Toffees — that was for Oviedo!!!
Geoff Freeman
18 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:43:34
Home draw — all we could ask for.
James Marshall
19 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:43:14
Arsenal v Liverpool.

Swansea at home isn't the best or the worst draw for us.

Paul Mackie
21 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:43:49
Excellent draw all round. Shame City and Chelsea can't both get knocked out as we have loanees from both clubs.
Mike Gaynes
22 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:44:14
And the remaining minnows got matched with each other, so they'll still be swimming around when we get past Swansea.

Warren Barton on Fox: "Everton should now be looking at Wembley."

Paul Ferry
23 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:43:31
Could that draw have worked out any better for us! Don't get me wrong, respect to Swansea and all that, but what a draw for us with all that lot in the 'top-4' playing each other. All I wanted was a home draw and we got it and it's written in the sky that we get a home draw in the quarters - yes, sorry, tempting fate, but we will take care of the swans - against a championship team. So, we will play at Wembleythis year.
Craig Fletcher
24 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:44:52
Only two of the "big boy" clubs will be lying in wait in the quarter-finals, and we are playing at home. As Matthew said, this draw could not have gone better for us.
Patrick Murphy
25 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:45:45
Not an easy draw that one as they have beaten United and were losing 1-0 before scoring twice yesterday. But you always hope for a home draw but they are a decent cup side - it depends who we have available.
Ajay Gopal
26 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:45:29
Decent draw - Swansea seem to have gone off the boil, and surely they will be preoccupied by trying to stay out of the relegation dog-fight. Plus, of course the home advantage.
Paul Ferry
27 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:48:09
Wigan at home in the quarters and we this time have the better gaffer.
Mark Frere
28 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:46:39
Excellent draw for us, get past Swans and avoid one of the big SKY 4 teams away from home in the quarter finals and we have a great chance to end our trophy drought.
David Denby
29 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:54:28
Great draw and looking at the other fixtures we are probably in with a good shout of being on tv again. Hopefully not too long before those games are chosen.
Colin Ryan
30 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:55:31
18 previous #EFC meetings with Swansea in all competitions. W13 D5 L0 F42 A13. LOST NONE
Colin Glassar
31 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:56:29
Thanks for that stat, Colin.
Matthew Salem
32 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:54:45
We will take care of the Swans, Paul, just as we did Wigan last year?
Kane Dennison
33 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:54:49
The fact that they have to play Napoli after might play in favour for us too, and the fact we have Crystal Palace at home before hand, I'm looking forward to this one. COYB!!!
James Martin
34 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:52:58
Strange thing the draw isn’t it. Everyone rejoices when we get a lesser side at home but as long as one big team remains in it you have to play them at some point and when is best to play them? At home in the fourth round when they might not be fully up for it, or play a reserve team, or is it best playing their full side at Wembley?

All this draw has done is guarantee that if the two big boys left don’t get drawn against each other they will make up two of the semi-final spots along with us (hopefully) and one other. I suppose that you’re hoping that the one magical performance you need comes in the final, but for me I would feel more confident getting Man City at home rather than in the final. If we want to win it, we will have to play a big team at some point.

Patrick Murphy
35 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:58:33
Let's hope it's not played at ridiculous o'clock even better let's hope the TV ignore it completely and it's left for a Saturday at 3 o'clock and that plenty of Blues get off their backsides and support the team – finances permitting of course – and let's help to show Bobby what playing in the FA Cup at Goodison can be like in comparison to his previous club, Wigan.
Matthew Salem
36 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:58:47
You are right, James, but on the flip side with every round a team progresses, even if may have been against lowly opposition, increases the desire and hunger for the trophy and that in turn gives each player that extra 10%-15% of drive and passion.
Tazul Islam
37 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:59:03
Quite happy with that... could have been worse. I've got a good feeling about the cup this year, I think we can go all the way.
Paul Ferry
38 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:01:09
Silly, so silly, Matt. I think my post had quite requisite qualifications and, yes, we will beat them because, guess what, we are not the team this year that we were this time last year... and, guess what, we have someone else in charge. My post was not gung ho gusto – 'take care' – and yours was quite frankly unnecessary.
John Audsley
39 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:01:24
Superb draw.

Very happy with it and sure we can get past the Swans.

Alex Trevalyn
40 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:04:08
Very happy it's at home... COYB
Ray Atherton
41 Posted 26/01/2014 at 17:54:43
Ajay

Wigan supposed to be preoccupied about relegation last season. That did not stop them for outclassing us at our home.

Although I am happy with the draw.

Jonny Flynn
42 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:05:05
We are 11/2 joint third favouriites with Chelsea behind Man City and Arsenal. Sums up our chance fairly. We should get through to the business end and it’s anybody’s from there.
Paul Ferry
43 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:08:21
And was this you speaking Matt - 023 - 'And it gets even better with Man City vs Chelsea and Arsenal vs redshite....this draw could not have been better' ... 'could not have been better ... ' - you want it all ways Mr Salem.
Andrew Ellams
44 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:07:39
Some potential plum 6th Round draws too. A little bit of luck and who knows.
David Graves
45 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:10:45
Matthew, within 5 minutes of the draw being made, you make a pessimistic reference to Wigan last year then post some inane drivel about "10 - 15% drive and passion"!
I'm with Paul Ferry. We will take care of the Swans.
David Israel
46 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:14:06
Good draw, and I'm sure Arsenal and Man City will meet in the 6th round, when we will be playing at Hillsborough!
David Israel
47 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:25:49
There's some drama unfolding at the Vetch Field (all right, I know it's not the Vetch Field anymore, but I don't like naming these sponsered football grounds)) with Michael Laudrup apparently on the brink of quitting after some disagreements with Mr Huw Jenkins, the chairman.
Raymond Fox
48 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:23:50
It's not the easiest draw we could have had, but that's being greedy!

It could have been very much worse, I think we should have enough to see them off.

I'll bet there is plenty of shaking of heads and tutting in Swansea.

Mike Gaynes
49 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:34:30
Colin, I've said it before and I'll say it again... you are the guru of statistics. The Kahuna of Kool numbers.
Colin Glassar
50 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:40:18
Yes David, there's trouble down pit as they say in that part of the world.
Harold Matthews
51 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:33:54
It won't be easy but a good performance should see us through.
Mike Gaynes
52 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:37:55
Good shout, David Israel... I saw that item from the Express last night.

Interesting that according to the report, the dispute centers on Tom Ince, whom the owner wants and Laudrup doesn't. Ince was mentioned so prominently for us a few weeks ago that I believe Roberto even commented on him.

Barry Rathbone
53 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:43:38
I remember a radio report pre season stating Laudrup was being chased for several million quid Ajax (they took a wanted ad in one of the papers asking for his address!).

Wonder if he coughed.

Ged Simpson
54 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:50:53
Nice draw and takes 2 big sides out.

Could we... ?

This season keeps butterflies in my tum busy!

David Hallwood
55 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:53:01
OK gents, which would you prefer; Cup Winners or Champions League?
James Stewart
56 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:52:11
Great draw! City will most likely beat Chelsea though so they are still the one to avoid for me.
Barry Rathbone
57 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:55:03
David, a trophy every time for me.
Mike Gaynes
58 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:56:08
David, Cups are special. Cups are forever.
Kevin Tully
59 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:56:43
Absolutely a trophy David. Twenty long years next year mate.
Alex Trevalyn
60 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:55:32
Cup for me David, Champions League work in progress...
Trevor Lynes
61 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:56:17
It is not an easy draw and stats go out of the window in cup games... remember Wigan last season.

Don't let's be counting any chickens now!!!

Ged Simpson
64 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:01:10
The Cup, mate – which we are now 5-1 third favourites. RS 7-1!!

I love filling in time waiting for next match (called work) which will be our win at Anfield. Not long to wait for that one...

Darryl Ritchie
66 Posted 26/01/2014 at 18:46:23
There are four categories when it comes to the draw......

Nearly impossible... Man City, Arsenal, Chelsea, away, with us fielding the under 21's

Possible... RS, anytime, anywhere

Probable... Swansea at Goodison

Get your ticket for Wembley... History shows us, it doesn't exist. Don't count your chickens....

Ged Simpson
67 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:11:31
Be happy - her is RS forum view

"Pretty sure that it was fixed. The miserable 4th round draw obviously lit a fire under the FA’s arses.

I’m not arsed anyways. 4th consecutive home draw for them mind."

Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha

Ged Simpson
68 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:13:36
See ya Tuesday - adios
Sam Hoare
69 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:09:41
A pretty awesome draw for us!

Unlike those above I would probably take CL football over the Cup, which would be great but have less (in my opinion) effect on the short and long term prospects of this club. If we got CL then potentially we could attract even better players to the club and with more money into the coffers would be less likely to have to sell the likes of Barkley et al. The thought of watching us midweek with that music playing as we walk out to face the likes of Barcelona and Bayern Munich give me goosebumps... I think sadly though given our horrific luck with injuries it could be just out of reach.

Jim Bennings
70 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:08:19
Trophy every time.

You cannot celebrate league standings unless you finish 1st.

Our fans need the buzz of winning a trophy again, its been way too long since this great club last tasted that kind of success.

Nothing gave me greater pleasure than seeing my team go up to collect that trophy after the win against Man Utd in 1995 and the trophies I saw us win when I was a young lad in the 80s. Makes me sad that a generation has grown up without seeing Everton win silverware.

On the draw... It's a tricky one but, like most fans I will take it, It's one of those draws that could have been better and could have been worse. When we saw the list of teams left and possible opponents, I am hoping for a Sheff Weds or Charlton at home but if it had to be Swansea then I was relieved it's at Goodison.

The Swans are a bit of a schizophrenic team who can either win at United or lose at home to Norwich so we wont know until the day what we face.

I am a tad concerned that maybe they are due one against us, and I would certainly want us to be getting the job done first time of asking and not have to go to the Liberty and win AGAIN.

All-in-all though could have been worse but until it comes around we have some bigger fish to fry in the meantime, starting Tuesday at 8pm.

Patrick Murphy
71 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:19:25
The FA Cup would my first choice as the game is about winning trophies – however, if we could get a near fully fit squad available soon, why not both the FA Cup and the CL – perhaps a dream but who knows?
Andy Meighan
72 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:13:53
James (#049), as ever, pal, another cracking and sensible post... but Swansea really won't want to be playing us given their record against us. But I'm not getting too smug because they've drawn at Goodison as recently as last season, albeit they parked the proverbial.

And I remember the FA CUpp Quaterfinal draw last season. Most of us on here were booking our coaches and hotel rooms and look how that turned out! Yes, you can't ask for more than a home draw but let's not get ahead of ourselves; there's games to play before that.

Tough games.... Starting on Tuesday, and I can't believe I'm as calm as I am before a derby. I'm starting to think there's something not right with me — why, I don't know... are my instincts telling me something?

Mark Taylor
73 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:20:09
To answer David H, Champions League by a very wide margin. As I said on another thread, the Cup is a lovely day out, but CL offers the chance for breaking into the big time once and for all, not just for the direct revenue from CL, but also the bigger global awareness which should be the basis for a much needed overhaul of our pitiful commercial/sponsorship activity, and a consequent sharp increase in revenue from that source.

Plus you have a much better chance of attracting the very best players and keeping guys like Barkley who, frankly, is not going to be greatly enticed by the relative squalor of the Europa League.

In other words, I'd sooner be Arsenal than Wigan!!!

Jim Bennings
74 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:17:48
Finishing in the Champions League only really means something to a club if they consistently reach the group stages such as Arsenal, Chelsea, United.

For us it would just be like Spurs, it would be a one off and knowing the Everton board, they would still be prudent with the money we got. To have any real impact, we would have to get there at least three years on the spin.

Just look at the last time we finished 4th in 2005. Instead of speculating to accumulate and signing top class proven players, I mean some of the players we spoke with that summer like Bellamy, Parker etc... what did we do?? We signed Simon Davies, Per Krøldrup, a pissed up Van der Meyde and just for a good cause, we re-signed Pistone 6 weeks after we fucked him off because his contract expired.

The Champions League may be the promised land and in your dreams you may play some massive clubs, in a once in a lifetime experience, but there is also the chance, and knowing our luck it would happen, that the first time we got there we would get in a shite group with no big hitters like Barca or Madrid, yet we'd fuck it up finish 3rd in the group and fall into the Europa League.

For me, 4th would be a fantastic surprise this season but if I had to choose one, it would be hearing that final whistle go at Wembley and seeing my team, Everton, celebrate triumphantly after finally winning a trophy and a reward for long term servants like Jags, Osman, finally get a winners medal.

That was my one real sad feeling when the likes of Tim Cahill and Arteta left, two of my favourite players during that 7 year spell at the Blues and they came close to winning a medal to look back on but never did.

Brian Wilkinson
75 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:33:39
Who cares if it means two of the big teams will still be left in. This draw gives Everton time to get back to near full strength so by the time the quarters come round I'm pretty sure Martinez will field his strongest side so who cares who we get, as long as we can put this game to bed we should be back to full strength for the quarters.
Joe Bibb
76 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:38:09
It's the FA Cup every fan wants a home draw. After that, a team that you feel confident of beating and then hope that the other clubs all have harder games.

Why are so many confused by that?

Raymond Fox
77 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:29:23
Well I would sooner finish in the top 4, BUT
the cup would be nice and in my opinion a much easier target, depending on the draw I suppose.

There's no guarantee of either obviously, but the top 4 a very big ask with our injuries and a run of tough games coming up in the near future.

So its a tough call, we could go all out for the cup and give up our outside chance of CL.
But next season with that crap euro comp. you play as cup holders, your effectively giving up your chance of top 4 for that season as well.

In other words I've no idea!!

Patrick Murphy
78 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:46:16
But as we know from bitter experience that the CL is not a straight forward competition - if we do qualify it is likely to be in fourth place and then the possibility of playing another VIllareal type side with what may be a depleted first team if the loanees have returned to their parent clubs and we will not see the competition proper and still end up in the accursed Europa league so no the FA Cup it is for me.
Jim Bennings
79 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:45:14
Raymond Fox

That is true mate but you let next season in the Europa League take care of itself, you don't have to go all out with a full team in it.

Its also where the club themselves has a whole summer to prepare for what they are facing in the forthcoming season and in 2005 we fucked it up big style when we had the carrot of Champions League football to intice some serious top drawer players, but instead we tackled Villarreal with Marcus Bent up front..No disrespect meant to him but you wouldnt see Arsenal or Spurs doing that.

What we need is to leave the season in May having actually achieved something, whether that is winning the Cup or finishing 4th, we need to do something, and then in the summer we need to build and prepare, its ok blowing our own trumpet but we did that in 2005 and then forgot that to be a success in the Champions League we would actually need better players, but we had Beattie, Bent, Kilbane, Simon Davies, Davie Weir, Gary Naysmith, what the hell were we thinking??

For the record, I don't think we will get 4th, we don't win enough games, the games we should like last Monday.
If we are serious the we will need to win either at Liverpool, Spurs, or Chelsea, maybe even two of those three...We play all of them in the next month, so you could say now is another big big test coming up.

David Finney
81 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:52:08
Heart says cup head says champions league.
Karl Graham
82 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:53:45
Why can't we finish 4th and win cup. As long as we don't get replays its only 4 extra games. We should enter every game with winning intentions and see where it takes us.
Paul Gladwell
83 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:58:25
Winning the Cup in 84 was my greatest Everton moment, you take them to your grave, finishing fourth won't.
I bet if you asked Leeds or more so Newcastle fans would they swap those Champs league days for an FA Cup win I'm sure most would prefer the Cup dream.
Robert Jones
84 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:00:46
I'm with Jim 115. I've been going to Goodison since 1966 (I know... I'm getting on) but I will never ever forget winning the cup that year and in 1984 & 1995. 1984 took us on to a special time. rarely does anything beat lifting the cup and that little moment where the captain holds it up. Say what you like, that's such a special time. Cup first for me.
Raymond Fox
85 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:00:36
Your probably right about the Europa League Jim, we could use it as a under 21 comp. I suppose.
I think logically that we will prob. fall short of the top 4, because of the perennial lack of the old spondulicks limiting our strength in depth.

So yes the FA Cup it is!

Peter Mills
86 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:07:38
I have been lucky enough to see us pick up the FA Cup at Wembley 3 times. They are days I will take to the grave.
Dennis Stevens
87 Posted 26/01/2014 at 19:29:31
Be nice to be playing CL next season as Cup-holders rather than League also-rans.
Ste Traverse
88 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:01:21
Signing utter shite like Simon Davies,who was so poor he ended up a huge whipping boy with fans, just about summed up our 'ambition' last time with broke into the top four.

We need to attract better signings if we get into the CL. That said,we do still have the same clown 'running' this club as we did back then.

I would still take the Cup over the top four though. But hey,why can't we go for both??

Karl Graham
90 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:16:26
Just as a side point Europa is worth taking seriously next year as winning it next year would get us in CL.
Michael Evans
91 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:13:12
Most surreal and funniest memory of 84 cup final

Parking up at Wembley and white van, more rust than metal, draws up. Exhaust belching fumes and 'tyres' as bald as you'll see.

Driver and passenger get out and open back doors.

Cocktail of assorted alcohol and other more dubious contents waterfalls out bringing with it an assortment of cans and bottles.

Can't remember exactly how many lads in the back but the first two fell out. The alcohol clearly dulled the pain of their fall.

My Dad and I just sat there laughing our heads off - great memories.

Kieran Fitzgerald
92 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:14:20
Jim, you're right about games like Monday night. Grinding out those results is what get's you the top four. None of the players seemed to see that on Monday night. None of them seemed prepared to grab the team by the scruff of the neck and drive it forward in the second half. Until these players learn that, we will be a top six team, not a top four one.

We can talk all we want about not having Barkley available on the night, or a Roy Keane or a Steavie G, but of the players out on the pitch don't step forward, then forget about it.

A top six finish wouldn't be a disaster. We will be no worse off and will have played better football overall. With the Europa league, I would view it as an extension of having loaned out so many under 21s this season. They will be getting game time for us in the senior team, in a proper competition. It isn't that hard to get out of the group stages and will give them something to aim for. We will only benefit in the league when we have more of these players playing games.

Dave Finney @127, totally agree.

Steve Durham
93 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:22:12
I was at Wembley in '95 and that day will live with me forever...but why does it have to be a choice?

Let's keep a lid on the optimism though, I remember last year, after drawing Wigan at home, telling all and sundry we were going to win the Cup.

Gordon Burns putting the weathergirl in a headlock.

Paul Gladwell
94 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:33:08
Michael, that sounds like one of our away vans in the 90s although we never got smiles "no wonder Birkenhead is such a shithole" was one comment from one posh pensioner in some country village we happened to stop at as he noticed the van hire sign, great days in the back of those things when but how uncomfortable.
Chris Wilson
95 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:21:26
We were chasing some good players prior to our brief CL campaign, but we had no track record in the competition and players balked at coming to us. This allowed other teams like Newcastle to come in and snipe us because they would throw massive wages at our targets. We started to panic buy, much like Moyes did this Summer, and that hardly ever ends well.

I think if we truly want to see this club be where we feel we should be, we need more than the cups. And for that, we would need Roberto to be pulling miracle moves, limit our wounded, and have some of our youth develop into first team challengers for 3-4 seasons. A big ask.

Sean Roberts
96 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:39:30
Let's be honest here, we have been given a home draw against a decent team but one that we all know we should be good enough to get past. I would think that this year the majority of the other teams in the draw were desperate not to be drawn against us!!!

Why? Because we are playing extremely well and seem to fear no-one. That speaks volumes to me as to how far Roberto has taken us towards the next level. Come on you blues, let's win this cup for Bryan Oviedo!!!

Karl Graham
97 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:41:24
We are Everton. As Roberto says we are 9 time Champions of the league only the 3 media darling football clubs have won more. Nothing should be beyond us our youth team looks likes its gonna produce not sure which yet as they haven't all developed, now we just need a little bit of finished article quality added.

I strongly believe we have to aim for as high a finish as possible plus FA cup. I thought exactlt the same this time last season but didn't truly believe this time however I feel like we will at least give it a go. The quarter final against Wigan showed that under the previous regime we were always gonna be too cautious resting Gibson was not the way to win.

The only trophy I remember us winning is 95 FA cup we played 3 favourites on the way went for it in every match and lifted the cup.

Jim Bennings
98 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:49:15
Of course football like life is all about opinions.

Some of us say the FA Cup, some say the Champions League or why not even both?

We are now in January with a monumental derby match on Tuesday night given the circumstances and league positions of both clubs who are chasing 4th.. We are all making our predictions and suggested targets but we still have a long season to see out yet.

Tuesday night will be a major test of our resources but it's a game that really we dare not lose because losing a derby is bad enough but we will then be even further behind them.

Whatever line-up that sets foot on to that pitch at Anfield needs to be turbo-charged into a near perfect performance because while we all though the Redshite were lucky to get that draw at Goodison, we were scratching our heads at how they scored three times, it was down to our concentration defending set-pieces not being perfect.

I just want to finish here by saying if we did get into the group stage of the Champions League, my ideal group would be something like this.

Everton
Barcelona or Real Madrid
AC Milan or Bayern Munich
Celtic

We would be joined by one of the two Spanish giants, a visit to the Nou Camp or Bernabeu would be a dream, likewise going to the San Siro.
I include Celtic there because we would have two matches there where the atmosphere would be absolutely rocking at Goodison and Celtic Park under the floodlights.

Paul Ferry
99 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:44:27
Having watched us win the cup two times - '84 and '95 - those memories are a treasured aspect of who I am and I feel sorry for anyone who has not had the night before in London and the match-day sky-high feelings in their life. 1984 in particular was so special in The Punch and Judy in Covent Garden the night before blues just everywhere.

Maybe coz I have that under my belt I definitely lean towards the Champions League and building something special if at all possible. Cups are wonderful one-offs - er excuse me where are Portsmouth today!? I want my great team back and today that means becoming a Champs League regular and, needless to say, we like others are in the Catch-22 quandary in which - like co-opting governing bodies - with the rewards year-in-and-year-out being in the champs league reinforces existing top-4s and a top-4 finish is needed for the champs league.

So, it has to be the top four for me with this manager and our current potential with the possibility of becoming sharers of the pot for more than one season so necessary to cementing the sort of status that might - might - make us a lip-licking prospect for investment human and financial.

I want a trophy for sure but I want our greatness back even more. A trophy does not equate with greatness does it Pompey? I get a shiver up and down the old spine thinking of winning at Wembley but I'm greedy for our greatness and know deep down that to for that we need to be in the top-4.

COYB

Si Cooper
100 Posted 26/01/2014 at 20:18:29
Only team I really 'fear' this year is Citeh (in any competition!). Not saying they are infallible, but when they are on song they seem pretty irresistible and Pelligrini seems to have set his sights on a clean sweep.

Home draw against Swansea is certainly do-able if not exactly a gimme and, as others have said, we should be in better shape numbers wise for the next round if we make it through.

Not sure I fully understand Jim and Raymond's logic in sending the youngsters out as sacrificial lamb's to the far-flung corners of Europe. Won't that just cost the club the same in travel costs whilst seriously lessening our chances of getting to the later stages (where there are potentially some good money making and profile raising opportunities)? Personally, I would be happy, if we won the FA Cup this season, for the domestic cup competitions to be treated less seriously than our league and European aspirations next season.

If we are ever going to re-emerge as a major force in this country we need to acquire some sort of European pedigree to have any chance of the status and monetary rewards associated with such.

Ernie Baywood
101 Posted 26/01/2014 at 21:12:46
Very good draw.

Take care of the Swans then hope City play Arsenal in the 6th rd or that we get one of them at home.

COYB!

Brian Wilkinson
102 Posted 26/01/2014 at 21:03:28
Michael not sure about 84 but we travelled up in a white transit van, was about 7 of us in the back complete with sleeping bags, beer and an eld twanky portable battery tv with about a 4 inch screen and a radio combined

Sure it was the same day morning tv started and watching Freddie Star outside the Everton hotel on tv.

We parked up the top of the road about half a mile from Wembley, doubt it was us though you saw that day but I agree, hard to beat that day, singing Elton John songs which were a little bit x rated about the guy, then going into Kensington Saturday night on the lash, parking up in an indoor car park, then sleeping it off before setting back off Sunday morning, happy days indeed.

Kieran Fitzgerald
103 Posted 26/01/2014 at 21:10:44
Jim, you're right about Tuesday night, it will have to be a near perfect performance on Tueday. Regardless of the fact that it's an ordinary RS team with defensive worries, they are still liable to score at least a couple against anyone. If our back four, plus Barry and McCarthy aren't fully up to scratch, we could well need to score three or four to win. Our midfield will need to put serious work into making sure that Lukaku gets proper service.
Jim Bennings
105 Posted 26/01/2014 at 21:18:29
Paul Ferry

True a trophy does not equate to greatness always but Pompey would rather have won the Cup and be in the position than won NOTHING and still be in this position.

At least they, like Wigan will always be able to say they managed to defy the big boys and win the FA Cup.
What are clubs like Portsmouth and Wigan ever likely to achieve anyway?
They are both small clubs that had no divine right to be in the Premier League and were certainly never ever going to be successful in terms of the league anyway.

You ask any Portsmouth or Wigan fan what their greatest ever day has been and they will tell you the same thing..Winning the Cup.

Wigan were always going to get relegated anyway so why not at least take a great memory down with them? Would they have rather just said 'oh sod the cup we can stay up and all jump over the pitch on the last day when we survive by one point'. No..They went down, which at some point was always going to happen but at least their name will forever be etched on the greatest domestic cup competition there is.

As for Portsmouth, the situation they found themselves in was again always going to happen, but they too would have been relegated one day, they are not big enough to survive just finishing 17th in the Premier League every year.
Portsmouth won the FA Cup then the following season they hosted they might AC Milan and the little old rickety Fratton Park, something their loyal fans could never in their wildest dream imagined..Or would they have rather not had those famous days to look back on, and still been in this current plight?

There is no bad ever to come from winning a trophy and that is a fact, what happens after that is down to something completely different.

Paul Ferry
106 Posted 26/01/2014 at 21:34:09
I agree 'there is no bad to come from winning a trophy' Jim - and that is implicit in what I say about the cup, but we were asked to make a choice. And we are neither Wigan or Portsmouth and so this is not good enough or even relevant for Everton - 'You ask any Portsmouth or Wigan fan what their greatest ever day has been and they will tell you the same thing..Winning the Cup'.

'Winning the cup' was not in fact my greatest experience supporting Everton - and I have seen us win a few - and once again we were asked to make a choice - a trophy or another chance at greatness, the second please, all the time.

Raymond Fox
107 Posted 26/01/2014 at 21:59:30
Si, our thinking was if I can speak for Jim, that if we were to play our first team in the Europa Comp. that would bugger us up for the Top 4 finish in the PL again for that year as well, due to the size of our
squad.

That was my thinking anyway.

Jamie Carroll
108 Posted 26/01/2014 at 22:23:25
Whatever European competition it is, just by playing these teams gives Everton an advantage over other teams in the Premier League for seasons to come.

Look at Newcastle, who after finding last season tough with the extra games are now showing the benefit of playing in Europe by being better equipped to beat the top teams.

Geoff Freeman
109 Posted 26/01/2014 at 22:53:53
I don't think we have a choice over top four or the cup as I'm sure Roberto will send the team out to win every game. So I think we'll just have to hope we get both, top 4 and the cup.
Gerry Quinn
110 Posted 27/01/2014 at 00:00:29
Atta boy, Geoff, go for it all - we ARE Everton
Adolf Ng
111 Posted 27/01/2014 at 00:04:12
I can't complain at all, and also have NO EXCUSE not to get into the quarter-finals to the very least...
Joe OBrien
113 Posted 27/01/2014 at 00:14:26
Great draw. You want to avoid the bigger teams till you have to. I'd prefer the RS to beat Arsenal because Arsenal are by far a stronger team. We'll take that one-man team from across the way if we get drawn against them, no bother.

I just saw that Martinez confirmed Coleman won't make Tuesday nite!! That true? I saw it on the Echo site... Disaster if it's true.

Harold Matthews
114 Posted 27/01/2014 at 00:26:12
I'm with Goeff. Preference doesn't come into it. Martinez will go for a win in every game and what will be will be.
Ian Campbell
115 Posted 27/01/2014 at 00:49:26
James (049) don't really understand your post. You seem to suggest that its better for us to play one of these top sides earlier but if that happens it just means that we will have more of them to beat.

Arsenal knocking out Spurs in Round 3 hasn't given them an easy draw in Round 5, has it? If they beat Liverpool, they will likely still have to take care of either Man City or Chelsea in order to win it too.

I'm very happy with the draw; it's true that in order to win it you'll have to beat some of the top 4-6 teams on the way but I'd rather only have to knock 1-2 of them out and not all of them.

Mick Davies
116 Posted 27/01/2014 at 00:51:35
What is the highest position we could reasonably achieve now, with all the injuries and a few bad blips? I suggest all agree it would be 4th. So with a squad that isn't totally our managers and the palaver of waving off the loanees and trying to recruit as many top notch players as we can afford - then bedding them in without a break, as the qualifiers start early - we will not be prepared. Then,, if we come up against a half-decent club and they do a Villareal, we will be on a downer before the season starts, ala 2005.

Winning the cup on the other hand would give the whole club a lift, the buzz would carry on through summer and the first home game would be a fantastic lift to the new recruits and present squad alike. No one will remember 2005 but even 1966 is feted by fans today. As for the Europa league, it would be a great recruiting vehicle for young players who could be given a lot of the places while most seniors are rested. The money from the gates and -paltry though it is - UEFA's contribution would cover travel costs. And who knows, we could go far and we can enjoy more nights like Nuremberg etc.

No, I don't think the club is ready for the CL just now, and although that will be Roberto's long term aim - along with the title - to dive in too early could do more harm than good

Matthew Salem
117 Posted 27/01/2014 at 02:59:20
Paul (59) and David (65), my post was not intended to be negative, but more cautionary as in Trevor (95). We got an amazing draw and with the "big clubs" paired against each other, I am very content. I feel very optimistic about beating Swansea. We have a very good chance. But that does not mean we merely need to show up. We have a history of fuck ups and sometimes things happen (like on Boxing Day). I'm not sure how any of that is negative...
Matt Traynor
118 Posted 27/01/2014 at 03:13:17
Paul #034 "Shame City and Chelsea can't both get knocked out as we have loanees from both clubs."

Not really sure what you mean, as both are on season long loans and therefore eligible for FA Cup. I know Lukaku hasn't played yet, but he was on the bench Saturday.

Matthew Salem, I get where you're coming from. We've seen unbridled optimism unleashed on these pages a few times this season, usually right before a let down. It's so un-Evertonian, particularly in recent years! No doubt there'll be some predicting cricket scores again, but as long as we're in the draw for the quarters with no replay, I'll be happy.

Paul Ferry
119 Posted 27/01/2014 at 03:33:14
All fair Matthew - 239 - nice post, not a word to disagree with there.
Darryl Ritchie
120 Posted 27/01/2014 at 03:26:49
A way to make the Europa League more relevant and important (and therefore the FA Cup), would be to guarantee the two finalists a spot in the next seasons CL. That any club would work its ass off to get to Europe, and once there, find it in its best interest not to field the best squad possible, is mind numbing!
Matthew Salem
121 Posted 27/01/2014 at 03:31:25
I agree. Matt (240) and I appreciate your balanced view. Shrewsbury, Oldham, Brentford, Reading and Wigan were all mere formalities and we all know what happened. But I have faith in Roberto and our squad and I hope this is finally our year. COYB! FTRS!
Matthew Salem
122 Posted 27/01/2014 at 03:41:31
I am happy you understand where I am coming from , Paul (241). Having said that, let's smash Swansea....COYB!
Ernie Baywood
123 Posted 27/01/2014 at 05:19:22
Matt Traynor. Lukaku is obviously eligible for the Cup but can he play against Chelsea in the Cup? He can't play against them in the league... I'll admit I don't know the rules here. Presume it's an FA rule and he wouldn't play?

Same for Barry and City?

Ernie Baywood
124 Posted 27/01/2014 at 05:26:17
And on the 4th place or Cup debate... it's just 4 more games - one of those after the season. There's no real choice needed.

Our league form improved in 95?

Matt Traynor
125 Posted 27/01/2014 at 05:28:30
Ernie #253 - I see the point now. That's odd though, I don't know what the rule is. The Premier League have their own league competition which is sanctioned by the FA, and I think it is Premier League rules in the case of loans. The FA Cup is under FA rules, and I don't know whether the same rules would apply. I would imagine there has to be recent instances of it though? Anyone recall?
Denis Richardson
126 Posted 27/01/2014 at 06:21:47
Nice draw but one round at a time. Get past the swans and then worry about who's next.

We have half our first team injured at the minute so let's get them patches up ASAP first.

Chris James
127 Posted 27/01/2014 at 06:39:58
Can't see that we should be arguing cup or league.

As has been said above, it's only 3 games in the domestic season (plus 1 outside) and will be on familiar turf (likely Premier League clubs from hereon in).

European competition with double the games, unfamiliar teams/styles and all that travel is far more disruptive and wearing.

Personally I'm praying our season has 20 games left in it.

Ernie Baywood
128 Posted 27/01/2014 at 07:18:21
I'm drawing a blank on finding a loanee drawn against his parent club.

Bamford was loaned to Derby but Chelsea started the loan from after the 3rd Round.

Ernie Baywood
129 Posted 27/01/2014 at 07:42:38
Sanchez Watt (no, me neither) played for Leeds against Arsenal in 2011.

So. Hope. I guess.

Ernie Baywood
130 Posted 27/01/2014 at 08:40:29
Or not...

(iv) The Association will not give permission for players on loan or work experience to play against the lending Club.
http://www.thefa.com/thefacup/more/rules

Oh well...

Mike Green
131 Posted 27/01/2014 at 08:28:19
James Martin #049

'All this draw has done is guarantee that if the two big boys left don't get drawn against each other they will make up two of the semi-final spots along with us (hopefully) and one other.'

Eh? I've read and re-read this and I'm still trying to work that one out.

Does that mean if we draw one of them it's guaranteed we can't make the semi's.....? Don't understand. I thought this was a knockout competition.....?

I thought the only guarantee that either could be in the semi's was if they did draw each other in the quarters, not the other way around, or have I got that wrong?

Actually, thinking about it you're right, sod it, scrap all the other fixtures, lets put the winners of the Man City, Chelsea, Arsenal and Liverpool fixtures in the final now and save the bother.

David Ellis
132 Posted 27/01/2014 at 08:38:03
Cup every time - JIm Bennings got this spot on. CL is great but to get us to "another level" would require 3 seasons in the group stages. FA Cup is an end in itself.

Its a great draw. Its always better to avoid the big guns as much as possible. Sometimes clubs win it without having to play any at all. I'd rather play City at Wembly in the final than at Goodison in the 5th Round. After all it would be our....er..... cup final.

Kieran Fitzgerald
133 Posted 27/01/2014 at 09:06:49
This is an open draw, names are just picked out of the hat at random. This means that the big clubs could be paired or avoid each other in the next round. We could end up at home to whatever lower league side is next, we could end up away to City. Just leave it alone and lets see what happens on the weekend of the 15th/16th.
Steve Wyness
135 Posted 27/01/2014 at 09:22:11
Del boy back at the weekend too.
Ron Sear
136 Posted 27/01/2014 at 09:20:32
Kieran - Open draw my foot! It took paying off a whole coven of Lark Lane witches and at least two sacrificed virgins to get this draw.
Kieran Fitzgerald
137 Posted 27/01/2014 at 09:25:35
I thought as much Ron. Too good a draw just to be pot luck. Think about it, what will we need to do to win the game and get a decent QF draw? I can't sell the young fella to some Count in Transylvania via the internet, I just can't. The wife would cut me in half, and the silent treatment, just wouldn't be worth it. I'd rather have City away.

Paul Hughes
138 Posted 27/01/2014 at 10:13:41
You can't ask for more that a home draw aginat a side we should beat. But you know Everton!

I remember a home QF against Sheffield Wednesday, with Bolton waiting in the semis – and Benito Fucking Carbone.

Mark Stone
139 Posted 27/01/2014 at 12:23:18
Never mind Wigan LAST season, don't forget Fulham THIS season. Swansea have some good players and this game won't be easy.
Peter Bell
140 Posted 27/01/2014 at 12:35:36
Paul Hughes that QF was against Villa not Sheff Wed.
Paul Hughes
141 Posted 27/01/2014 at 13:17:00
Quite right, Peter. Memory playing tricks again.
Liam Reilly
142 Posted 27/01/2014 at 13:58:18
5 days left in the Transfer Window; would be a good bit of business for the club to make Barry's move permanent now, so he can turn out against Man City in the League and in the Cup should we draw them in the later rounds.

Norman Merrill
143 Posted 27/01/2014 at 15:37:27
The fact that we are playing a talented Premier side, regardless of position in table, should be enough for Roberto to keep the lads in focus?
There is NO easy cup games, Wigan last season proved that.
And I'm sure management will remind, us of that?
Paul Ferry
144 Posted 27/01/2014 at 17:22:29
David Ellis - 284 - 'Cup every time - JIm Bennings got this spot on. CL is great but to get us to "another level" would require 3 seasons in the group stages. FA Cup is an end in itself.'

So, when would you propose we begin this three-year plan - 2014 - 2015 -2016 - 2022? It's not rocket science. We need to begin as soon as possible and keep fingers tightly crossed that we can make it the next year too because if that were to happen we would be in a truly improved situation with the add-ons in terms of attractiveness that that would bring in its wake.

Sorry, can't find the post(er) in question on this thread - did thumb through it a couple of times though! - but it said FA Cup all the time it is 'a great day'! Jesus wept, 'a great day'! We exist this minute for 'a great day'! Get down to London handy, get hammered, we might win, we might lose, but it will be 'a great day'! I've done that day a few times and sure it is 'great' - we won - but it was one in a string of 'great days' at a time when we were 'great'.

Sure a cup win as Mick - 224 - says is a huge 'buzz' and can start balls rolling as in '84. But these times are changed beyond all shape from then, and sorry winning a trophy is no guarantee at all -why would it be - of getting the sort of financial/human investment needed to become well 'great'.

We were asked to make a choice so 'both' seems to me to be a rather limp back seat. Let's win the cup ad wait a year but it will not be a year it will be two, perhaps more. We need to start now, 2014, because if we were to finish top-4 we would be a stronger outfit for it in terms of incoming next season than a 'great day' out at Wembley would bring. Quite frankly, I have a hunch that we would do better than in 2004 with this gaffer in the hot seat.

Gary Cross
145 Posted 27/01/2014 at 18:53:11
Never a truer word said Paul .....I'm with you on that post 460.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb