The visitors led through Shayon Harrison and Luke Amos but goals from Nathan Holland and Michael Donohue rescued a point for the Blues.
The result leaves Everton in a strong position as they look to secure back-to-back league titles.
Everton U18s: Hewelt, Birch, Yates, Graham, Thorniley, Walsh, Donohue, Bainbridge, Brewster, Charsley, Holland.
Subs: O'Loughlin, Broadhead, Myers, Evans, Bramall.
Read the full match report: Everton FC.com