A false dawn?

by   |   28/04/2016  36 Comments  [Jump to last]

I know I'm being a bit previous but am I the only Evertonian who is a bit disappointed that there has been a deafening silence from Farhad Mashiri since he invested in 49.9% of our club's stock?

Many of us saw his arrival as a sure sign that things were changing and the control of all things Everton was no longer vested in Bill Kenwright. For several weeks after "the deal" was announced — and in spite of disappointing results on the field, there seemed to be a feeling of new hope for a bright future for the club in the comments and messages of the fanbase, both old and young.

It wasn't so much that there was, at last, real hope for a new ground and significant investment in new players but more a feeling that new life was being blown into the creaking structure that is Everton FC. Of course, it's early days, but for me the alarm bells started to sound when we learned that, far from aspiring to be our new leader, the investor didn't even desire a direct place on the Board.

On enquiring about this development via local and national sports writers, I was told that it was not Moshiri's style to grab the headlines nor seek hands-on involvement. His style, it seems, is to put up the money in support of a sound business plan and rely on others to make that money work for him. Sharing this message with ToffeeWebbers, resulted in much scorn being placed on me by fellow contributors who saw the new man very much as the New Leader and inspirational figure.

Kenwright was consigned to history, we were told — from now on "the new money" would call all the shots as Farhad and his proxy got their feet under the table. "Moshiri will see to it that Martinez is toast," they affirmed, and once the now apparently mythical Board Meeting took place, we would be looking towards Europe for a new manager. Of course, it's only Thursday evening and such an announcement may be being drafted as I write — although I think not.

So tonight, I reiterate my view that Moshiri is not overly interested in such details and is happy to leave football matters in Kenwright's hands. I can only say that such trust in our resident procrastinator is utterly frustrating to us mere "punters"... but, to the major Investor, it may prove ruinously expensive!

back Return to Talking Points index  :  Add your Comments »


Reader Comments (36)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Lyndon Lloyd
2 Posted 28/04/2016 at 22:01:27
Phil, I think you hit on it at the outset there – it's simply too early from outside appearances to make any determination over Moshiri's role and intentions. He has only been at the club a couple of months after all.

Certainly, were his feet further under the table, you could expect a bit more decisive action but there's no outward evidence that he isn't getting things order behind the scenes. And the fact that he doesn't have a seat on the Board is probably just semantics – Sasha Rayazantsev is his proxy and will no doubt act accordingly and Moshiri will be present at any high-level meeting of real consequence.

Tony Hill
3 Posted 28/04/2016 at 22:10:29
I was suspicious from the outset about Kenwright's residual influence and so it is proving. I still haven't recovered from that fucking awful interview after the Chelsea game and the bollocks Moshiri was spouting at the same time about joining the Blue family or some such.

I share your scepticism but live with some hope that Moshiri may yet turn against BK. The worry, as others have noted, is that our saviour will be happy to take the tv money profit and need not exert himself unduly.

Brent Stephens
4 Posted 28/04/2016 at 22:13:11
Phil, I think your take on Moshiri is one possibility, especially as you've discussed with sports writers with some knowledge of him.

On the other hand, weren't we told that he'd had enough at Arsenal because he couldn't get on the board and more actively involved in the running of the club? I might have that wrong, so stand to be corrected. But if that was the case at Arsenal, presumably he bought into Everton for more than a financial return?

It's early days - I've seen new CEOs, University Vice Chancellors come in and try to make an immediate impact (new broom) and others who have been a year before producing a new, all-embracing strategic plan. Perhaps our man is happy to play the long game, as long as Roberto doesn't sink the ship in the meantime? Nothing more than a guess.

Dave Abrahams
5 Posted 28/04/2016 at 22:13:16
Phil, local and national sports writers know as much as you and me,
Dan Davies
7 Posted 28/04/2016 at 23:02:29
Phil every post you make your dragging me down man! It's bad enough as it is without you continually posting stuff like this. I'm trying to stay as positive as I can.

But the longer this drags on, slowly but surely, your posts are coming back to haunt me. I really really hope your wrong and I would be delighted if you were.

Your like that horrible neighbour we had when I was kid who wouldn't give the ball back when it went over his hedge!

David Edwards
8 Posted 28/04/2016 at 23:13:25
Phil – too early to judge, as you suggest – but no harm in expressing the first inklings of concern that a new page might be getting turned as quickly as we hoped. At least, if these concerns are realised in the next few weeks or months, you've definitely got 'bragging rights' to say – I told you all!

If he had the power and drive I hoped he had when he bought in to the club, Roberto would not be in a job now. The fact that he still us, and likely to be there on Saturday / at the end of the season / next season (delete as applicable) – it does not bode well. Maybe, he's waiting to have final confirmation of our views against Bournemouth? Let's give him something to think about!

Patrick Murphy
9 Posted 28/04/2016 at 23:25:20
Whatever the reasons for Mr Moshiri not taking full control and seemingly allowing the old guard to look after footballing matters, you can bet your life there will be a financial aspect to it – even if it's not clear to us as fans.

Bill will want to be associated with the delivery of a new stadium/ modernisation of Goodison and it probably suits the new biggest shareholder to keep Bill onside, the two-year period would seem to suggest that's how long it will take to put all the ducks in a row regarding the stadium issue.

Of course, if the playing side doesn't deliver, that will be addressed but I get the feeling that Mr Moshiri has bigger fish to fry at the moment but only time will tell and like everybody else I find myself only guessing as to what may happen.

James Flynn
10 Posted 29/04/2016 at 00:33:40
"We were told", "they affirmed". I missed all that. Thanks.

The guy who paid out around £85 million for his shares "is not overly interested in such details and is happy to leave football matters in Kenwright's hands"?

Appreciate your sense of humor. Bit dry, but funny.

However, a natural path of that thinking would lead to a public vote of confidence from the Club regarding Roberto's future (And no, Bill's "What a manager" comment doesn't count). Where is this positive pronouncement from the Club? Nowhere.

I'm of the opinion we need to take this deafening silence from the Club as a positive. Certainly not as an indication of Roberto's continued employment as manager of Everton Football Club.

Jay Wood
11 Posted 29/04/2016 at 03:35:29
Still pedalling you 'nudge-nudge, wink-wink, in the know' line I see Phil.

As others mention, I don't see anything abnormal in Mr Moshiri not being more vocal as you desire. Rather, I find it reassuring he isn't playing the big 'I AM' and making populist grandiose statements to garner popular support, but rather being more circumspect and getting a feel of the club before declaring his vision and ambitions for the club.

He arrived at a time outside the transfer window and when the club needed no distractions of boardroom shenanigans as we still retained a genuine hope of landing a trophy.

As I've oft repeated here, none of us have the first idea of the distribution of shares or whether individual major shareholders have been designated areas of responsibility.

You however, Phil, have on more than one occasion (and you repeat the claim here in your closing paragraph) tried to convince others that your 'informed guess' (your words) is that Kenwright retains control over footballing matters at the club, whereas Moshiri is either largely passive, or solely concerned with commercial matters, or even both! (Not quite sure how the latter scenario is plausible).

You even started trying to pass off your 'informed guess' as confirmed fact.

Here, you are again scaremongering, casting suspicions because he has appointed a proxy in his stead on the board. Given his other business interests (which have generated the wealth by which he bought into Everton), I don't see the phantoms in this as you wish to spook others with.

You even say as much in your OP: "I was told that it was not Moshiri's style to grab the headlines nor seek hands-on involvement. His style, it seems, is to put up the money in support of a sound business plan and rely on others to make that money work for him."

You were NOT 'scorned' on TW for stating the above as you claim. You were challenged on the earlier 'informed guess' you made, which at the time you admitted you had no evidence to back up. You were challenged again when you attempted to pass off your speculation as hard fact.

My own view has remained unchanged since Mr Moshiri arrived: I don't expect a mission statement from him before the final ball of the season has been coughed up to the opposition... I mean... kicked in anger!

Since he came on board, the issue of whether to retain the services of Martinez has become pressing. I consider how and when the board's decision on the manager is determined will inform us just what sort of custodian of the club Mr Moshiri will be and just how ambitious he is.

I'll repeat to you again something I said to you on another post: stop pretending you have insider information, or attempting to pass off as fact your highly fanciful speculation.

Jay Harris
12 Posted 29/04/2016 at 04:35:08
My take on it is that Jon Woods has had enough and Moshiri is very concerned with Martinez (even before the Chelsea game).

Bill is Bill but cannot ignore the pressure from his colleagues and fans.

The picture that seems to be being painted is Bill asking for a turnaround in the last 4 games to be considered a sign but Moshiri and Woods are already considering alternatives with a poor result against Bournemouth bringing the axeman forward.

None of us really know what is going to happen but I would be shocked if Martinez is still here at the start of next season despite Bullshit Billy's thoughts.

Darryl Ritchie
13 Posted 29/04/2016 at 05:55:51
Phil's makes a point. So far, the silence from the board, the entire board, has been deafening. We had the "What a manager" bit after the Chelsea game, then nothing. Kenwright and Moshiri have been at a couple of games, but haven't offered any more sound bites.

Until somebody, anybody, says something about the clubs future, re: hierarchy, new ground, manager status, it's all going to be speculation.

They may indeed have a plan, but as of now, they're not saying what it is. Perhaps it's still being worked out. It's still early days, and there's an awful lot to do. It's the, not knowing that's the worst. I hope they get it right, but as we all know, "It's the hope that kills you!".

On a side note: With some fans planning a protest on Saturday, it will be interesting to see if anybody from the board shows up.

Phil Walling
14 Posted 29/04/2016 at 06:54:12
Almost bludgeoned into submission by the length if not strength of Jay Wood's response, I do so hope that all is well in the corridors of power as he continues to imply.

However, even IF that is so and Martinez is removed from office forthwith, I have little faith that a Board guided by Kenwright is any more likely to get it right this time than they did last. Moshiri or no no Moshiri.

Robin Cannon
15 Posted 29/04/2016 at 07:00:10
"His style, it seems, is to put up the money in support of a sound business plan and rely on others to make that money work for him. Sharing this message with ToffeeWebbers, resulted in much scorn being placed on me by fellow contributors who saw the new man very much as the New Leader and inspirational figure."

You imply that that style, and mentioning that style, is something to be criticized. That's pretty much exactly the kind of owner I would like to see.

I would imagine (and, it's all imagination and speculation at this stage) that he likely wouldn't want to make major changes during the season, or at least when we had some hope of achieving something. In general, I'd hope any takeover would involve some subsequent assessment of the internal workings of the club before any action to make radical change.

Phil Walling
16 Posted 29/04/2016 at 07:27:04
Fair enough, John, but surely not an ideal situation whilst that Leader continues to be Kenwright ?
Ian Brandes
17 Posted 29/04/2016 at 09:47:16
I reckon that BK thinks he still exerts the major influence even though we now have a major investor in Mr.M.

I also think that BK will soon receive a rude awakening.

It is the only logical thing to happen.

Alan J Thompson
18 Posted 29/04/2016 at 11:57:33
Robin Cannon(#15), Couldn't have put it better. Settle in, see how things work, at the right time suggest changes then, if necessary, exert power.
Dominic Tonge
19 Posted 29/04/2016 at 12:51:51
Whilst at Arsenal, Mr Moshiri and business partner/associate penned a letter to the club's board . I think personally if we are trying to find insight into what Moshiri wants, and what he stands for this might provide a little bit. It also may allay some fears around player retention, and also new signings.

Here is the link.
Link

I would say this might indicate he is quite keen to take a hand in football matters, but will sit back when able to use the 'If it ain't broke, don't fix it ' mantra. I think that in the case of EFC, it's broke though.

Jay Wood
20 Posted 29/04/2016 at 15:56:01
Phil @ 14 "I do so hope that all is well in the corridors of power as (Jay Wood) continues to imply."

Therein lies the rub, Phil. I don't 'imply' anything as if it is an indisputable fact. That has been the domain you have operated in on this matter.

I simply offer an alternative opinion to your own, with no pretence that I have 'insider knowledge' on the subject as is your tendency.

You offer a further unfounded presumption that should Martinez be removed from office that you "have little faith that a Board guided by Kenwright is any more likely to get it right this time than they did last. Moshiri or no Moshiri."

You have absolutely no grounds for elevating BK to the position of deal breaker, either on the dismissal of RM or in the selection of his replacement as you imply.

In your opening post you stated "On enquiring about this development via local and national sports writers", possibly to give 'legitimacy' to your argument.

On another thread you mentioned one of those sources was your Godson.

Phil, if any of your journalist sources has headline making knowledge of the nuts and bolts of the Moshri buy-in, or possible 'secret deals and arrangements' between him and BK which you have tried to pass off as fact, then ... why haven't we read an EXCLUSIVE in the media from your sources exposing the same?

Journalism is an extremely cut-throat business. Any journalist worthy of the name would not hesitate in sharing such revelations with his editor and their audience. He would risk getting a rocket up his arse if the editor ever found out he hadn't filed a report on the same.

Everton and Martinez is a big running story across the media at the moment. Any media outlet would definitely run a story of the insider knowledge you claim on the arrangement that exists between Moshri and BK.

That no one has rather suggests ... no proof of such an arrangement exists.

It continues to be what it is ... an invention of your imagination.

Tony Waring
21 Posted 29/04/2016 at 17:40:52
New stadium ? At the club's present rate of progress all we'll need is a few quid for each game to rent a pitch at Buckley Hill.........assuming it's still operating as footy pitches........I've been away from Merseyside a long time but one of my sons used to play there and on reflection it was a lot more fun watching the kids than it is watching the Blues these days !
Paul Thompson
22 Posted 29/04/2016 at 17:42:18
Another gloomy missive from TW's own Private Frazer - we're doomed I tell you. Yes, I know we have had a fair bit to be gloomy about, but like others I prefer to wait and see what Moshiri comes up with. I suspect we'll know soon enough and I'm cautiously optimistic.
Sid Logan
23 Posted 29/04/2016 at 21:35:41
Phil,

don't see it the way you at all. Moshiri is clearly a clever businessman. However I'm sure he appreciates the difference between a normal business enterprise and a football club, namely they don't just have customers - they have supporters.

He will not want to charge in and kick Bill in to touch this early in the proceedings. At the same time I'm sure he won't stand by and see things start to go completely pear shaped because of Kenwright's traditional overly romantic and unprofessional take on everything Everton.

I'm certain Moshiri will not walk all over Bill - not too early anyway - but I'll guarantee he won't allow him to continue to big up Martinez when he can plainly see that view is as unconvincing as it is naive. He also knows a that the supporters have turned against Martinez and that will strengthen his arm. It's probably the reason the meeting was called anyway and it may be his biggest concern at least according to Matt Law in today's Telegraph.

I think if he begins today's discussion by taking an anti- Martinez line it looks like he'll have John Woods on his side as well as his own man Alexander Ryazantsev. Without knowing where Robert Elstone's support lies - at a guess I'd say pro-Martinez along with Bill. That would still be a 3 against 2 debate.

All speculation, of course, but it counter balances your pessimistic view that Kenwright will win the day! At this late stage in the day I doubt we'll get an announcement until after tomorrow's game when a show of anti-Martinez feeling could well consolidate the anti-Martinez views of those on the board.

If your view that Kenwright's love affair with Martinez wins the day then we're all well and truly fucked but I don't believe that's going to happen!

Ian Robert
24 Posted 29/04/2016 at 21:41:13
Here we go again... he knows exactly what is happening between members of the board. Excellent.
Peter Barry
25 Posted 30/04/2016 at 08:49:29
Moshiri should be judged by HIS actions and not by the foolish projections supporters put on him. So far, he has done and said diddly squat that Billy Liar would not want him to say.

If we are still being Managed by Martinez next season, even the most deluded supporter will have to realize that we have been sold another 'Kings Dock' type dream by a master conman, Boys Pen Billy.

David Pearl
26 Posted 01/05/2016 at 02:55:45
I'd suggest Phil, that Moshiri would be pretty foolish to throw his weight around so soon – I'm sure he'll let Martinez and Kenwright carry the flak for now. When the season closes though I doubt he will just hand over his cheque book. He will want to know what we all want to know. Do we have a plan, a direction, a style... a manager to take us forward? Who's that new kid at right back? WTF is in these pies?

He didn't make his money by luck. So let's see what the next few weeks bring and then see if he can take us by the short and curlies. Can he persuade Stones and Lukaku to stay and build a team around them? Its going to be some summer, so hold on tight.

Dennis Ng
27 Posted 01/05/2016 at 03:26:48
David 26, I agree with you in the caution he should take. Whoever the next manager is, we can't buy success, so hopefully we will get a man that either take us for the long haul or (if Pellegrini or managers of his age group) set the foundation for the next guy to succeed.
Alex Doyle
28 Posted 01/05/2016 at 09:07:29
To echo other comments, I'm not surprised by Moshiri. Outside these forums, from people who understand business, it's generally viewed that Everton is a well run club with a decent management structure in place. Yes, I mean Kenwright and Elstone. Moshiri has decided to back that view with his funds, but probably has many other interests.

Patience is a virtue.

Peter Gorman
29 Posted 01/05/2016 at 10:14:59
False dawn? That bright light in the sky is an asteroid big enough to wipe out the dinosaurs heading directly for Goodison Park.
Tony McNulty
30 Posted 01/05/2016 at 10:37:29
Ian Doyle's piece in the Echo is worth a read:

http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/ian-doyle-change-now-inevitable-11266766?

Quite a good summary of my own views.

I think RM is a dead man walking. It's just a matter of time.

Jim Lloyd
31 Posted 01/05/2016 at 10:59:26
If I remember aright, in the programme where Mr Moshiri introduced himself (quite well, I thought) he let it be known that he wanted to back the manager with funds and would, in time lay HIS plans for EFC before the board. I can't rememeber for certain but I think he also wanted to do the same in a meeting of the shareholders of EFC.

I don't think HIS means anything other than he will take control. I'd have thought that his rep on the Board is there to a represent Mr Moshiri's views but also to see what Billy and Wally (sorry, R Elstone) get up to.

Phil Walling
32 Posted 01/05/2016 at 11:09:30
David @26. I hope you and others are correct in your assessment of how the new investor will act. I'm just a tad less confident that he will see off BK's negative involvement anytime soon.

I guess if he does ask those questions of Martinez, the manager will offer up his philosophy which 'our saviour' may or may not buy into. We can but hope he sees through the bullshit.

Gordon Crawford
33 Posted 01/05/2016 at 11:35:02
The word ulcer comes to mind. As that's what's going to happen if some people don't chill. We have got to be patient and give this guy a chance. All will turn out well.

You have got to ask yourself one question. Can I do anything to change what's happening at Everton Football Club?

Phil Walling
34 Posted 01/05/2016 at 11:40:03
Gordon, as a non-shareholder who now lives so far away, I can't attend games anymore, the answer is definitely NO – I can't change a bloody thing. But that doesn't mean I can't express my fears on ToffeeWeb, does it?
Gordon Crawford
35 Posted 01/05/2016 at 12:07:29
I understand your predicament Phil. And of course you should be able to express your fears pal. I too get fearful about Everton. But then I have to pinch myself and say everything is going to be fine. If we haven't got hope in life, then what do we have?

Good times will roll again Phil. :)

Martin Mason
37 Posted 03/05/2016 at 18:49:49
Some above are making very good points. The best advice I was ever given was when sailing in the Philippines when there were terrible storms hitting the North. I was really down and could hardly function but the skipper said, Martin, only worry about things you can influence no matter how bad things look. Just getting worked up when you can do nothing is pointless. This is the position we are in as Evertonians, we can see the faults and we can see no future unless they are solved immediately yet we are powerless to do anything. Moshiri and the board want exactly the same as us, BK is in the process of handing over, we have the potential to get a ground and strong playing staff because of the investment that Moshiri brings. What shall we do? run around like headless chickens like we are now demanding short term fixes when good businessmen are looking a little further ahead. RM is gone longer term, he is beneath the quality demanded by a club like ours so why can we not just be patient and let the new board resolve all of the problems that they, like it or not, are far more aware of than us. Our duty is to support the team and the club, that we are having a negative effect on the players at Goodison is beyond dispute. I know Everton fans don't do chill out but now is when chill out is needed.
Johnny Rainford
38 Posted 04/05/2016 at 20:40:50
So this is what we have been reduced to. Come on, boys... Taken in real terms, Mr Moshiri has only been at the club 8 weeks so to expect any seismic shift at Everton within this period is probably a bit previous, as you say, Phil.

Give the fella time. He needs to identify who to trust with the 𧶀m he is reportedly bankrolling. I know I would!

Martin Nicholls
39 Posted 14/06/2016 at 10:04:37
Phil - do you still maintain the views expressed in your article?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads



© ToffeeWeb