Southampton vs Everton

Let’s start having a go at teams and start making it exciting again.

Howard
Galloway, Jagielka, Stones
Oviedo, Cleverley, McCarthy, Coleman
Barkley
Kone, Lukaku

Joking aside, I think you have it right. 3-5-2 is the way to go and play two up front from the start.

It’s simple: play our best players in their right position, play a style and system that they are comfortable with and that’s proven to work in the Premier League, and get the ball forward to our £28M striker in a way that plays to his strengths not his weaknesses... sadly, none of which Martinez will do!!

Howard
Coleman Jagielka Stones Oviedo
Deulofeu McCarthy Cleverley Mirallas
Barkley
Lukaku

Meanwhile... back in the real world, it’ll be the usual 4-5-1, as we all know, where Lukaku has to come so deep to get the ball, he may as well be selling hotdogs outside. It’ll only change if we are one or two down late on in the game.

As you said yourself, they’ve got a makeshift defence, so they can easily be got at... although they are quite dangerous at the other end. They are a very good home side and have dished up a few hidings there so our defence will need to be on its toes.

I’m still on holiday and don’t know if the game is on Sky or BT. I do know we’ve never won on BT so I’m going for a draw. I’d settle for that because it's not a happy hunting ground for us. I’d urge the Spaniard to be positive but, to coin a phrase, I won’t hold my breath.

Lukaku Kone
Barkley Barry McCarthy Cleverley
Galloway Jagielka Stones Coleman
Howard

or push the ’undroppable’ Barry into the LB slot (the role that he played for the last 30 minutes last week) and play an attacking 4-3-3:

Mirallas Lukaku Deulofeu
Barkley McCarthy Cleverley
Barry Jagielka Stones Coleman
Howard

I personally liked Lukaku and Kone playing together up front. I think they complemented each other well and Lukaku appreciated the space that Kone created for him. I think Martinez will go 4-4-2.

Maybe he can’t do it for the full 90 but he’s there to provide competition for the main man, and given he scored last week when Lukaku didn’t, I’d say Kone has earned his start. Martinez won’t play 3-5-2 away at Southampton. I’d expect the usual 4-5-1. I had high hopes that Cleverley was brought in to replace Barry not play alongside! I thought Cleverley was one of our brightest players last week, the only midfielder to actually get past the striker and in to the box. Drop Barry and bring in Osman on the left?

Howard,
Coleman Stones Jagielka Oviedo
McCarthy Cleverley
Mirallas Barkley Osman
Kone

I know Osman is not a natural winger but he did a reasonable job out wide last season, he is disciplined enough to stay out there and bring Oviedo in to the game on the overlap. His short passing is also good and we’re going to need someone with tricky feet who can do a half decent imitation of Pienaar.

Subs would be Lukaku for Kone for when he runs out of puff / reverts to being toilet again. Deulufeu for Osman if we need to chase the game.

Pushing the "undroppable" Barry back in the wake of Baines’ injury might be a revelation, but RM would never go for it.

As much as I’d love:

Howard
Coleman Stones Jagielka Barry
Barkley McCarthy Cleverley
Deulofeu Lukaku Mirallas

We’re likely to see the ol’:

Howard
Coleman Stones Jagielka Galloway
McCarthy Barry
Barkley Cleverley Mirallas (if fit)
Lukaku

It will be:

Howard; Coleman, Stones, Jagielka, Galloway; Barry, McCarthy, Cleverley, Mirallas, Barkley; Lukaku

Tepid, turgid shite until they score. Then we might see some life.

We just seem incapable of keeping a clean sheet and every time we play any team with pace we sit deep, get nervous and invite them to attack. S’ton pass the ball quickly and crisply and have some pacey players looking to get into space. If we start with McCarthy/Barry then I can already read the script.

Only slight hope is that they will have to make the running and we can hit on the counter -- assuming we actually pass the ball forward quickly.

Personally, I don’t have a problem with the formation, but it’s very frustrating to see Cleverley pushed out wide when he could give so much energy and life to Barry’s position.

Howard
Coleman Stones Jagielka Galloway
Barkley McCarthy Cleverley
Deulofeu Lukaku Mirallas

a) He was using the 90 minutes to assess how his players character would react to 90 minutes of adversity and humiliation; or

b) he was so shocked by the lack of committment throughout the team he was genuinely as confused as the supporters and when in doubt do nothing...?

Also, at that time, the Premier League was definitely second priority after the Europa League.

This is not an anti-Roberto rant, just the opposite. He does seem to have a ’long term plan’ and there will continue to be many twists and turns. If he choses to give Oviedo playing time then this will be a big plus for me as he seems a player with real drive. Barry at left back would be interesting but for me most of all I want to see McAleny playing a role.

I can’t understand how after 3 assists, 2 goals and lively throughout 135 minutes of pre-season play he looks like he is being overlooked? Would love to see a positive result so come on you Blues!

I don’t even bother expecting anything from Everton under this manager anymore. I mean how long is it since we beat a top half team away from home? Was it the win at Old Trafford in 2013?

You know it will be the same pathetic formation that yields hardly any decent attempts on goal and no men getting forward in support of the isolated striker. That will continue until we go a goal down late in the first half or early in the second then soft ollies will bring Naismith or Kone on and we will get caught late on with a goal on the break and lose 2-0.

You can almost read the script, it’s just so hard to be anything like positive about Everton at the moment, from performances on the pitch right through to the total ineptitude off it regarding bringing players in or dealing with other topics.

Are people really advocating Barry at left-back?! I have no idea who plays right wing for Southampton but he's going straight into my fantasy football team.

If his lack of pace is shown up in a holding midfield role then it's going to be an absolute horror show at full-back.

Be sensible guy's, this is the 100 mph football of the Premier League not some sort of beach kickabout.

I think it really sums up how low we’ve sunk that each week you just know that it's gonna be another slow, lethargic, turgid display which gives you no incentive or enthusiasm to get excited about. What really amazes me about Martinez is surely, after witnessing and being responsible for complete and utter shite week after week, he must realise that he’s got to drastically change his all approach because his way is painfully not working and if he at least looked like he was trying a new approach and something different, it would give me some optimism to hang on to.

Also completely agree with Phil about the ludicrous calls to play Barry at left back! It's bad enough to have to witness him slumbering round in midfield every week, never mind him being totally exposed to a speedy wide man, or even a not too speedy one!

If it's just a case of doing anything to get rid of him from our midfield, then why don’t we just consider doing the seemingly unthinkable, and just drop him altogether??

Southampton under Ronald Koeman are everything I wish we were. They play fast vibrant attacking football, always with something at the end of it and most importantly they have more than one way of playing.

It also is miraculous, despite all the talent they keep losing, that they manage to compete to a high standard; they and Swansea are commendable footballing models.

I would love to see something different from Everton tomorrow, I truly would... but I know full well that I won’t get anything other than that usual frustrating tippy-tappy nonsense played in triangles around the corner flag at snails pace with zero end product.

As we say, it’s hard to be positive.

Southampton fans will be expecting a comfortable win. We will do well to survive this season. A very badly run club.

Martinez just seems all very casual about our lack of defensive and striking options, again we are one or two injuries up front away from crisis point, it may never happen but given our track record it probably will.

There is still no sign of this elusive creative midfielder either.

It may have been too early back in June to start panicking about our lack of movements in the transfer market but it's getting to the stage now where your looking at four or five signings in a few week's, and that hoping we don't sell on Stones too!!

Is this target now realistic?

I'm not naive enough to expect us to be challenging for the league title at the start of the season. All I want, and I don't think it's asking too much, is that when I get in the car to set off for the game, I at least feel that, irrespective of who we're playing, we give it a good go and play with some passion and enthusiasm and at the end, to have made the opposition know they've been in a game. Instead, its almost a dread of what I'm going to be witnessing again and unfortunately no amount of me being slagged off by Martinez's supporters will change that.

I was sarcastically condemned for having the nerve to criticize our preseason displays, with them arguing that preseason friendlies doesn't matter, it's only when the season starts that we should form an opinion. I asked them to give me just one thing that he was going to change to give me a glimmer of hope that he could turn it around this season but the silence was deafening.

I always maintain that if he proves me wrong and does turn it on its head, I will happily enjoy eating a huge slice of humble pie and give him all the praise he'll deserve, but sadly I just can't see it happening.

The surprising thing about last week's performance was that people were surprised by it! I certainly wasn't!

We've just drawn Barnsley away in the League Cup; can anybody, hand on heart, be completely confident that we're going to come away with a convincing victory?

Robles
Browning Stones Jags
Colemen Oviedo
Besic McCarthy Barkley
Lukaku Kone.

It gives balance and pace at the back.

And options off the bench.

Nail head Completely

You then get the 5-yard pass that is belted back to the passer. No thoughts of turning the man, just twat it back to whence it came. Shite of the highest order.

I was almost glad that the dopes serving the ale at half-time were so slow, as it meant I had less time to go and watch the crap ion the pitch.

Here's a little tip for the catering staff... roughly around 30 mins into the game, people will probably start milling down for a bevy and, come around 5 mins to go, a lot will be filing down. Now, I'm no rocket scientist, but even I know that a few thousand fans will want a bevy so it may be a good idea to get a few on the go before the rush instead of having your staff standing there scratching their bollocks waiting for the one lad on the one pump to serve several hundred impatient fans... just a thought like!

If we come away with nothing tomorrow, then with City, Spurs away and Chelsea to follow next, the natives are going to get very restless. It could all go Pete Tong very quicky, chuck in Stones leaving as well (if you were him would you stay if the wheels start falling off?)

I just hope we don't get a bunch of panic buys in 2 weeks' time. Stranger things have happened - we could blast out of the blocks and stuff'em 3-0 - Kone hattrick!

I will be watching this at work, have left the diary clear from 12:30 - 2:30. Can’t wait. It won’t happen but please lads just get up and at ’em from the off. They won’t be expecting that you can be damn sure!

Howard, Coleman, Stones, Jagielka, Oviedo, Besic, Barkley, McCarthy, Cleverley, Mirallas, Lukaku.

Deulofeu and Kone on at 60 mins.... Ross to score again.

Cleverley and Kone tried one or two variations but their team-mates stuck to the same old script. Martinez told Carragher that our formation and tactics were designed to make us different, thereby enabling us to confuse the oppsition. Unfortunately, the only confused people are the fans and the team.

Not sure about the Saints game. We certainlt can't give away corners and freekicks with Ward-Prowse on the ball. The lad can put it on a sixpence. He can also put it onto Pelle's head.

Can't see us getting anything here.

Clearly any manager has a duty to ensure players are fit and totally aware of the style and tactics to employ. On the latter, I suspect some players are more willing and able to absorb and act on instructions than others. Perhaps basic intelligence, will, desire and motivation are the key factors but I guess that's where the 'right fit' aspect comes in and will determine an outcome of success or failure. Do they all listen to their manager, anyway?

Colin @27 has the dream of players 'playing the game in the way they grew up playing it' and whilst I sympathise with that idea to some degree, it's highly unlikely to happen at this level. 'My way or the highway' seems to be the mantra adopted by all Premier managers and I think 'free spirit' went out with the romantics like Joe Mercer and Kevin Keegan.

Having said that, I suspect that for about half a dozen games towards the end of last season, that 'free spirit 'approach did prevail and after a string of abysmal performances and something of a crowd revolt, IT APPEARED that the players took charge of affairs... and to great effect!
During this period, I remember Baines being asked if that is what happened. He sidestepped the question by saying 'the manager will always want us to play in his preferred style.'

In the last couple of games, it was clear he had done so... and with the inevitable result! But this is a new season so we can only hope both players and manager have struck a new accord and all will right with Everton's world!

I think there is very little genuine support for the man and as many of you have said I am expecting "Groundhog Day" but COYB......

The only change I would be tempted with is Browning to start as mentioned above; I think he looks ready and at least looks up for a battle.

This would also allow McCarthy & Cleverly to take the central role.

Could be interesting, but I'm not looking forward to it.........

I fear we will be in serious trouble by the time we play Sunderland on 1st November - I predict we will have amassed a total of 3 or 4 points from 10 games - and been knocked out of the League Cup.

Luckily Everton improved hugely and most of us were happy with Martinez's first season, but since then things have gone downhill and so quite a lot of us are waiting for style to change and to see what happens in this transfer window. It is now up to Roberto, September is going to be very interesting.

Really? He said that? Like with his own mouth? Staggeringly brilliant!

Compare to Moyes who used to yell just one- or two-word simple phrases at them if they needed telling. Even the most dim player could grasp what to do if being told ’go tight’ or ’press him’, for example.

If he goes completely mad and puts Barry at Left Back I can see a massacre. He'd get destroyed.

http://www.footballorgin.net/2015/08/premier-league-2015-2016-skysports.html

'until they change the rules and laws of the game, I will never change'.

We do not close the opposition down instead we give them loads of space.

We do not practice defending free kicks or corners.

He has MF players dropping to the edge of our penalty area looking to pass to ? another MF player 5 yards to the side of him.

There is very little movement off the ball further forward.

Because we play and pass so deep we don't get many players in the opposition box and the opposition defenders can reorganise time and again because our build up is so laboured.

WE don't have goalscoring capability in MF.

Worst of all Moyes used to make a difference by getting the players superfit and creating a siege mentality unfortunately with every passing game this seems to be eroded.

However I have a feeling (call it madness) that the players may take things into their own hands and get something from this game.

Christ, the whole thing with putting Barry in the fullback position in an attempt to 'find other lines' to break down 2 banks of 4 made me want to slam his face into the giant TV screen thing.

Talk about over-complicating the game and confusing players. What a tool.

I know how simple football is. I've played it all my life at a decent standard. Touch and composure are the first things I look for in a player regardless of position. All of the best teams in the Prem and throughout Europe for that matter play in a similar style. RM tries to be different!?!?

The definition of idiocy is to expect a different outcome when doing the same thing over and over again. Martinez thinks his approach will work even though the evidence is categorical that it doesn't.

Barkley could be a great player but I fear for a player of his ilk playing for a 'scholar of the game, such as Martinez. I couldn't give a shite if RM watches every game of footy there is, on however many screens he has set up at his mansion, it doesn't mean this studious approach will bear fruit in his 'philosophy'. His philosophy is just as likely to ruin players.

I've watched every episode of Thomas the Tank engine with my lad but that's not to say I'll be dropping into Network Rail and offering my services as an expert.

I'm sick of hearing from So-called experts (including RM) about how different footy in the PL is. It's bollocks! It's all down to fitness. Today's players are both skilled footballers and athletes. The speed of the game is what sets the PL apart from the other European leagues. So get the players fit!

Like I said in my earlier post, if a player has a bad game then drop him to the bench and then have him show in training that he can turn it around. If he can't sell him. This loyalty thing works both ways.

I'm certain that Lukaku doesn't spend hardly any time working on his first touch during training. If I was in charge that is ALL he would be working on until he got it right more often than not. It amazes me how bad his first touch is. It amazes me that it is not spoken about more by the pundits.

Speed, Skill and fitness make a difference.

The rest is simple.

That's it exactly. Barry has to go.

Anticipation
Frustration
Disappointment, win, lose or draw.

I think we will be fortunate to come away with a draw.

Swansea, bloody Swansea, I ask you?

But then I read Steve's piece about how they've gone about it and I did some follow-up research via the net. 'We could do that,' I thought. 'Build a new ground as well!' Of course it would take up the rest of this decade to develop a new infrastructure and get rid of all the BVI loans -- and the league position might suffer as a result. But heck, it would be worth it.

Then, I realised their fabulous Chairman and Board had once appointed a certain Spaniard as manager...... and thought they can't be that bright, after all!

I have been reading the site for a good few years and never read such widespread condemnation of a manager- fully justified given the shite continually being served up.

I believe Saturday was the beginning of the end for Bobby, and another listless display on the South coast tomorrow will edge him closer towards the trap door which could open as early as October.

What it would mean is that McCarthy and Cleverly could be the central midfield duo. I think Cleverly should be given more responsibility and thought he came into the game well last week. If not Barry at left-back I would keep Galloway. We can't do any worse than the last 2 seasons at St Mary's can we? Hope the players are more confident than I am.

hTTp://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/transfers/Roberto-Martinezs-season-as-predictable-as-his-tactics-unless-he-unleashes-romelu-lukaku-writes-danny-higginbotham-10456146.html

Tons of pace if we pass the ball a bit faster. Fantasy stuff !!

He was far from the worst player against Watford and for me outshone McCarthy.

At least he has some long range passing in his locker.

Our problem is not individual players it is the managers insane obsession with his "textbook" tactics.

I've always wondered how many goals Barkley would score, if he had someone up front that can control the ball and lay it back to him, like Kone on Saturday, or, hold it up, let Barkley run into the box from midfield and play Barkley in.

Home... Away from home.. Lukaku up front on his own just does not work; I'd go with two upfront.

I, like many others on here, fear the worst from this fixture. We shall miss Alcaraz at the back! Martinez surely won’t be positive and start with 2 up, instead we will see changes once we go behind.

Our defence will be opened-up and we will concede goals... I just hope Martinez switches things round quickly when things go wrong, unlike in previous visits to the Scummers.

Hope I'm wrong 'cos still just put a tenner on us at 3/1.

I see the pundits have us going down by at least 2 goals tomorrow which given our recent performances (preseason and last week) it’s not hard to see why; however, as it's early days, I've still got a bit of optimism... I think we can get something out of this game: 2-2 for me!!

I probably will though.

And wonder why I did.

But you never know - COYB!

Everton have to come out attacking and get to them early but any semblance of the first half of last Saturday will prove fatal.

Most fans have little confidence in the Everton setup these days and rightly so with the team showing so little confidence or initiative that we all know every game will be tough to win.

The Mirror piece sums up what most of us have been in denial of for years as well.

The following are pre-match quotes by Koeman and Martinez re the Southampton match;

Koeman; "We know the qualities of Everton. We know the way they play........"

Martinez; "The last two visits to Southampton have been really tough games for different reasons. Things that could go wrong did go wrong - two years ago we had two own goals very early and if you look at our history it’s 22 years and we’ve only had two wins. Historically it is a very tough place for us - it becomes an extra challenge and we want to embrace that."

So tomorrow’s defeat will be nowt to do with his appalling tactics folks, it’s written in the stars! Presumably if only he’d been the manager for the past 22 years we’d now have a hope of getting a result, but after such a lengthy time what’s Martinez to do?

This is how to shut me up Martinez; play a team with a plan that’s unknown to the opposing manager; stop talking shite, period; get every player fit enough to physically and mentally compete for the entire match against anyone at all, regardless of the score.

That, amigo, is the definition of "professional" football manager. You should try it.

One reason for this seasons ties of the Kenwright Out group on social media is Roberto. Ok there are lots of other reasons as well but it's the appalling lack of faith in a discredited mgr that is in part fuelling the discontent.

I'm hoping the protests inside the ground do not unsettle the team on the pitch. It's why I hate this form of protest at the match as I can't stand watching it add to the negative atmosphere but fans are just so fed up that you sense a real change from the Blue Union protests of the last few years.

We should and can win tomorrow but it will feel,like a miracle if we to and somehow wanting a miracle away at Douthampton sums up why so many are utterley at the end of their patience with the Board.

But actually the early start on the road with such a far trip... never EVER ends well. I'd say we’re fooked. Maybe DelBoy can save our ass. Or Kone!

If you look at adjectives Martinez uses to describe us, it's quite clear that the man is actually out of his mind.

'Different'
'Flexible'
'Unpredictable'

This is how he sees us. Literally the opposite of every other person watching the game.

The man buys wingers but refuses to play with width. He has two of the best attacking full backs in Europe and yet we don't get a single cross in. We have a £28M striker who has scored more goals at his age than Messi, Ronaldo...his main weakness is his hold up play...and we force him to play with his back to goal. We have players who are undroppable, regardless of form. We have players like McAleny who are unselectable, regardless of form. We have no passion. We are always less fit than the opposition. The manager is a laughing stock who cannot explain himself in plain English.

Is that enough to sack him? Apparently not.

Looks like we'll have to lose some games then.

I actually admire the quest to be different. Such a hard thing to achieve.

I'm up way too early, because my 15 year old, has woke me up, getting himself ready to go the match. I wish it was that easy getting him out of bed for school!

It's sad that the fans, are going to start getting more aggressive with their protests, especially if it's coming at a time when Bill Kenwright is not a well man. What else can they do though, vote with their feet?

There is plenty of clubs in this country, that enjoy great support, but there is none so loyal, as the travelling blue army, they deserve better, hopefully starting today!

He's done a wonderful job in that respect.

Perhaps, and this is only a wild-arsed theory, but perhaps we have to go down a bit to come back up? If you see what I mean - like Man Utd in the sense (barring his fluke first season) that they had SAF and stability/success and we had OFM and stability/no success. Since SAF left (barring OFM's failure with them) they've been on a downward curve, which is slowly becoming an upward one - so, perhaps we have to be patient and expect there to be a downward curve before an upward one?

Or am I pissin in the wind? Maybe, just maybe, we the supporters need to be a little more patient and expect results to fluctuate for a couple of seasons before things get back up to the level we've been used to?

Or maybe Martinez is a snake-oil salesman sailing a rudderless ship towards the Bermunda triangle of mediocrity?

I hope it's the former.

I also think we'll get turned over today. I'll be watching in a bar in Thailand so either way it'll be a good night out for me!

There's bound to be a downturn, I'm just surprised it didn't happen in his first season.

Of course he could just be a shit manager which is equally as likely!

No encouragement needed, but I hope your smiling like the locals, later on tonight!

Here it is:
Link

It looks like the bookies are tipping Saints to turn us over at a canter. This should be the inspiration to buck the form book, and show them what we are made of.

I am confident that we have the players to win this one, it's just whether Robbie selects the correct formulation and tactics.

2-2 draw today. I predicted a W1 D3 L0 last week (first four games till new players come in) and I'm sticking to that.

Got my first season ticket in 62-63 season and this is the most boring football I’ve seen in all the years of ups and downs since then. Zero intensity on the pitch translates to zero atmosphere in the ground -- soul destroying.

Can you spot the one word that shoots this statement down in flames?