What does Alisher Usmanov's failure to take over Arsenal mean for Everton?

by   |   20/05/2017  88 Comments  [Jump to last]

It has been reported in the Guardian and other news outlets that Stan Kroenke has knocked back Usmanov's $1.3 billion attempt to take over Arsenal. Given the ties between Usmanov and Moshiri, could it mean that Everton is in line to be the next club purchased as a toy for a billionaire foreign owner?

Does it even matter if he spends millions and millions and Everton becomes a perennial top four and title contender as well as a CL participant? Would Evertonians trade a traditional love for local lads for squad after squad of "mercenaries" since that is what has happened at the Manchester, Chelsea, and Liverpool clubs?

I know I have asked everything in question form. I had to since I do not have the answers. I suspect if this scenario becomes a reality that it will deeply divide the fan base. Well, at least until the winning and trophy and title counts start increasing, I bet.

I wonder where Usmanov and Moshiri will each sit at the game?

back Return to Talking Points index  :  Add your Comments »


Reader Comments (88)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Chris Williams
1 Posted 19/05/2017 at 18:24:56
Usmanov failed in a ٟB bid to buy out Kroenke at Arsenal?

He's not interested in selling seemingly.

Who knows what can happen next?

Patrick Murphy
2 Posted 19/05/2017 at 18:52:25
It seems strange that Mr Usmanov would make an offer which as you say has been rebuffed by Kroenke on this occasion, and then continue to uphold the status quo at the Emirates for much longer.

According to the Echo Two people following the process closely said that other bidders were circling. Mr Usmanov is not planning on disposing of his stake and the offer to buy out Mr Kroenke came from a desire to work co-operatively and strengthen the team, one of these people said.

My concern from an Everton perspective is that if Mr Usmanov was to gain overall control at Arsenal would his companies sponsorship of Everton's Finch Farm become a conflict of interest and would Mr Moshiri want to rejoin his mate at the Emirates?

Arsenal power battle

Chris Williams
3 Posted 19/05/2017 at 19:05:04
Patrick,

I think Usmanov really wants to control and build a club, currently Arsenal, and has made a big punt here, which according to The Guardian would have given Kroenke a handsome profit.

Kroenke isn't interested at all and I guess sometimes it comes down to how many billions do I really need when I've got my own trainset to play with. I suspect neither of these two individuals is a team player unless they're the captain!

It seems that it has always been only Arsenal for him, at least so far, so I would guess that any existing arrangements would be sufficiently arms length.

But going forward, it might get interesting. Currently he's outside the tent there pissing in. Whether that will continue to be attractive to him, with no prospect of change, remains to be seen.

I've got mixed feelings about it I suppose.

Ian Hollingworth
4 Posted 19/05/2017 at 19:22:51
Sky Sports reporting Usmanov made a billion-pound bid for Arsenal. There ends another dream.
Craig McFarlane
5 Posted 19/05/2017 at 19:27:22
Ian @52

I wouldn't be so sure... reports from Kroene suggest he's not selling. Could be a final throw of the dice for Usmanov (take it or leave it) leading to him selling up and joining his bezzie Farhad in paradise.

James Flynn
6 Posted 19/05/2017 at 19:57:14
I'd be surprised if Kroenke sells. His history is of a guy who buys, and buys, and buys some more.
Mike Benjamin
7 Posted 19/05/2017 at 22:21:37
Or, as the BBC speculate, if he fails to get control at Arsenal will he turn to another Premier League club? Well let us hope so.
Colin Glassar
8 Posted 20/05/2017 at 07:37:47
Fingers crossed that the Usmanov's Arsenal bid fails and he invests in Everton instead. If that happens, I doubt players will be wanting to leave for "bigger and better clubs".
John Fieldstead
9 Posted 20/05/2017 at 07:54:02
If Usmanov is knocked back with his Arsenal takeover bid, which looks highly likely, the chances are looking favourable to Everton that he will seek out another Premier League Club to invest his billions. He hasn't got a place on the Arsenal board so therefore has no say in the running of the club even though he owns 30%.

Arsenal's majority shareholder, Stan Kroenke, seems to be on a bigger power trip then our very own Mr Kenwright however, with Mr Moshiri having more and more of an influence with Everton, what is not to say Mr Usmanov being tempted to sell his 30% stake at Arsenal and increase his investment in us?

He has obviously been given some kind of information on us, has liked what he has seen, and has started his potential love affair with the Blues by having his name put to Finch Farm. Mr Moshiri may have shown him our 'project' and whilst it is in its infancy, Usmanov may see us as an attractive proposition and something he would be able to have a bigger influence on.

The other Russian billionaire owner in the Premier League hasn't done too bad with his investment, wouldn't it be great if we could be at that level a bit sooner then we hoped?

I feel really positive about Everton at the moment. Mr Moshiri, Mr Koeman, new ground, Under-23s PL2 Champions, etc, etc. If we are to get another major investor in the shape of Mr Usmanov, it can only be a good thing. COYB.

Thomas Lennon
10 Posted 20/05/2017 at 08:19:41
I would wait to see what fan pressure is apparent at Arsenal's last match before concluding he has lost just yet, but his second choice is clear. He may even go in with a higher bid but the guy clearly wants to have some fun winning with a football club in the UK.

I too have wondered on how the ability to buy better players from anywhere in the world will impact on our culture. I suspect we will feel less direct bond with the team, players have become businesses in their own right anyway and that age of innocence is long gone. We simply replace one asset with another rather than go into any great grievance.

Why do players leave us and go on to oblivion (with the obvious exceptions)? Why can't we beat LFC home or away? Why do we fail to deliver when the pressure is on? Because they have better players and squads. The next 12 months are a vital time for Everton to progress.

Everton is different though, that is where EITC comes in and is special. Everton remain very much part of the local community, a caring inspiring part, we just need to start winning again.

Chris Gould
11 Posted 20/05/2017 at 08:21:30
Colin, Usmanov's bid will almost certainly be rejected. I think he will then sell up and leave as he's got zero influence there.
Colin Glassar
12 Posted 20/05/2017 at 08:22:52
I posted earlier that Kroenke's rejection of this bid might finally force Usmanov to throw in the towel at The Emirates. The dislike between the two is deep and personal.

I also believe former board members and influential Gooners also dislike, and distrust, Usmanov for being a "outsider". I think Henry Winter wrote about this a few years ago.

As for the original question(s), Jim, well we've got one billionaire now, I suppose another can't do too much harm, can he?

Mark Murphy
13 Posted 20/05/2017 at 08:27:40
Were our supporters in the 60s any less proud of the team because we had John Moores's millions to outbid any team in the land??
Joe O'Brien
14 Posted 20/05/2017 at 08:28:02
I think it has already been rejected, Colin... I hope it has anyway. His last throw of the dice to take over before he jumps ship, maybe?
Jeff Armstrong
15 Posted 20/05/2017 at 08:39:53
To me, this bid shows the guy is clearly not interested in Everton, he could have our club for millions less and use the change for the players, stadium and everything else that ٟ.3 Billion can buy... but no, he is determined to buy out the ageing American and he will eventually get what he wants.
Ernie Baywood
16 Posted 20/05/2017 at 08:40:00
Are we any more reliant on youth products than the teams above us? They all bring a few through.

We still have a team full of mercenaries, it's just that ours aren't as good as other teams' mercenaries.

Personally, I think it's a shame the way football has gone but we're already part of that. Might as well be a successful part of it.

As mentioned above, there are plenty of reasons to have local pride in our club and I assume those things won't change. Dare I say it but Bill might be a big part of that side of things?

Ian Bennett
17 Posted 20/05/2017 at 08:47:48
The big sticking point here is what is Usmanov going to do with Arsenal stake now? Who would buy it? These are as big questions as to whether he'd pitch in with Moshiri. Perhaps Kenwright would do a swap...
Brian Williams
18 Posted 20/05/2017 at 09:02:07
"What does Alisher Usmanov's failure to take over Arsenal mean for Everton?"

Jim, it could mean absolutely nothing. On the other hand...

I know what I personally hope it means. I hope Usmanov divests his shares in Arsenal and buys the 51% of remaining shares in Everton to become the majority shareholder/owner whatever he'd be called.

Colin, above, mentioned having one billionaire already. Usmanov's billions make Moshiri's wealth look like chicken feed (no disrespect intended).

Usmanov could (not saying he would) fund the new stadium himself and not bat an eye. He could turn us into a genuine super power of the premier league without a doubt. Would I personally want him onboard? You bet I would!!!!!!!!!!!

Tony Hill
19 Posted 20/05/2017 at 09:23:57
Colinn and Chris, this looks very interesting indeed. I know we shouldn't speculate but hard not to.
Stan Schofield
20 Posted 20/05/2017 at 09:27:17
It's an interesting question that you pose for Evertonians. My answer is that the younger supporters want only success, like I saw when I was young. I focused more on Young and Ball than on Moores.

But now I'm older and more 'cynical', I'm not wholly enthusiastic about us being even more embroiled in the big money circus that is top football. But then, I think my views on it aren't as important as those of the youngsters.

It would be nice if they experienced glory. And I suspect that when glory comes (and I think it's more a when than an if), I'll feel no different from when I was young. So long as the hairs rise on the back of your neck, that's what's really important for a supporter.

Alan McGuffog
21 Posted 20/05/2017 at 09:36:29
Stan we should get him onto the team bus after the game tomorrow. Get him up here. Show him the love. Show him the Uzbekistan graffiti that has adorned the public spaces of Norris Green for decades. Take him for a Wagon Wheel in the cafe in Broadway.
Tony Abrahams
22 Posted 20/05/2017 at 09:39:06
I hope and I pray that things like this go in cycles. We were "The Mersey Millionaires" in the sixties and, but for a brief flutter in the eighties, we have not had that much to shout about Jim.

Evertonians are a very proud bunch, and some of us realise more than others that, since the greatest Evertonian alive took over "our cub", we have won absolutely nothing.

Everton, in the community is a great thing and I think because it's pretty much established now, that a successful football team would only do it more good than harm?

I remember the eighties very fondly Jim (except of course for that fucking horrible week, in may 1986 when we threw away the double even though we was the best team in the league, IMO) and would love nothing more than my sons, being able to relive it for themselves, just to witness the joy that winning brings!

I for one would love to see Usmanov help to take Everton, back to the eighties, especially now there is no longer a European ban!!

James Morgan
23 Posted 20/05/2017 at 09:46:06
Have to agree with you there, Thomas. Usmanov wants his plaything akin to Abramovich, I'm sure he would prefer one in London but if his mate Moshiri shows him the "project" and the vision for the future, he could well be swayed to come up north.

The northwest is the "Hollywood" of football, after all. Plenty of room on the royal blue Mersey for his yachts.

Alexander Murphy
24 Posted 20/05/2017 at 10:02:11
As soon as I spotted the article on BBC Sport, my reaction was "I knew this would happen!" I just didn't think it would be until the true closed season.

Since Farhad Moshiri arrived we have been supplied with advances on an almost regular basis. Just as the rush of one report has subsided and things appear "a bit on the quiet side", then there is another announcement. Another piece put into place, not some wiffly-waffly rumour.

Usmanov isn't happy to play second fiddle (no matter how much he actually does love his Gunners) and so he is left with a stark choice. To overthrow Kroenke and take power, or tolerate Kroenke. If unsuccessful, he then clearly has the situation where he sells his Arsenal shares and does for another club what he would dearly love to do at Arsenal.

If he is unsuccessful, then I would most definitely want him to become a part of the Everton ownership. We are progressing on all fronts for the very first time in almost three decades. Usmanov's involvement would only be for the good. By turns, it could also weaken Arsenal, and that provides an avenue of opportunity for the next best placed club, Everton.

I'm anticipating this to be played out and resolved before the new season. In fact, I actually believe that it has been deliberately engineered and that the outcome is already known.

For those who haven't seen it, or don't recall it, here is the open letter from Usmanov and Moshiri to the Arsenal board in 2012:

Alisher Usmanov's 2012 letter to the Arsenal board

Just imagine that these two were talking about Everton.

James Morgan
25 Posted 20/05/2017 at 10:09:16
Breaking news: Kroenke intends stay long term.

Welcome to Everton, Mr Usmanov. 💰

Joe O'Brien
27 Posted 20/05/2017 at 10:23:24
On Sky now that Kronke is planning to stay at Arsenal long term. Usmanov will sell up his stake there shortly, I would reckon, hopefully to join up with his buddy Moshiri... it's looking more and more likely with this latest news.
Barry McNally
28 Posted 20/05/2017 at 10:26:39
Arsenal make money, Everton don't.
Gary Edwards
29 Posted 20/05/2017 at 10:30:52
I vaguely recall some of the sages on TW predicting this would happen when Moshiri acquired his share of EFC. I believe it was suggested at the time that Moshiri was merely the fluffer for Usmanov.

I think this is good news for Everton. I'm loving the timing too, only wish to see some grand gesture (in Everton's favour) after tomorrow's match, eg, a convoy of Loomis trucks, brimming over with cash, departing The Emirates, bound for Goodison.

Tony Hill
30 Posted 20/05/2017 at 10:35:30
I do wonder, Gary, if this was always planned and if the bid is just a necessary step to provide the excuse. It never seemed likely that Moshiri would go off on his own without the man for whom he has, frankly, acted as a facilitator (albeit a very rich facilitator).

Rob Halligan
31 Posted 20/05/2017 at 10:53:07
This all seems perfect timing to me. 2 days before Arsenal play Everton, Usmanov bids to buy Kroenke's shares, knowing full well the bid would be turned down. 2 days later, Usmanov and Moshiri are seen sitting next to each other in the Arsenal Directors Box. At the end of the game, Usmanov and Moshiri are seen shaking hands, Moshiri saying "See you next week down at Bramley-Moor Dock". (Obviously a good lip reader of Russian is required here).

Wishful thinking, maybe, but let's hope it becomes a reality.

Eugene Ruane
32 Posted 20/05/2017 at 10:57:24
After a few years of the Premier League, we (supporters) had the chance to walk away and say 'this is rotten'.

We could still all walk away anytime we like.

And (in theory) why wouldn't we?

We see teams 'competing' against teams who have 50 times more money (and usually more money means more wins).

There are and have been rancid owners with links to organised crime and human rights abuses.

A putrid gargoyle like Murdoch in effect ultimately controls the game.

And until recently, one of our shareholders was one of the world's most hated 'businessmen' – an eternally grasping, morally bankrupt, disgusting shit-house.

Yet..we're all still here.

Those who have walked away (on principle) have my respect, but I'm weak and so still helping prop up the whole thing.

And given this, I find it difficult to be involved (by choice) but then moralise from within.

I can't because it feels daft to me, (like "Yeah I only murdered two people, but they've murdered about 20")

So instead I've come to the conclusion if you're in, you're in and if that means Usmanov or similar, fine.

We're never going to go back to how it was so (weirdly) now the closest chance we have of getting (back to) something resembling fair is all 20 Premier League clubs are owned by billionaires with egos looking for a plaything.

Or..something.

Re "Would Evertonians trade a traditional love for local lads for squad after squad of "mercenaries"

Ask Barkley.

Chris Gould
33 Posted 20/05/2017 at 10:57:45
Tony, I was thinking the exact same thing. Usmanov knew the bid would be rejected. Everyone knew the bid would be rejected.

He can now join Mosh and show Arsenal what they could have had.

Paul Smith
34 Posted 20/05/2017 at 11:08:49
Great thread TW at it's best.

Come on over, USM – I want trophy's & glory.

Looking forward to being at The Emirates tomorrow, feeling smug but fuck knows why.

Andrew Ellams
35 Posted 20/05/2017 at 11:18:47
Personally, I think he'll get what he wants at Arsenal and there will be big changes there over the summer.

If he did switch his interest to Everton, bring it on. As stated above, if you're in this league and grasping the obscene amounts of TV money every year, you've already sold your soul so why not take the next step and and win some trophies too?

On the subject of stifling young local lads coming through, remember only two members of Howard Kendall's team in the 80's came through the ranks and neither of them were Scourers.

Ray Said
36 Posted 20/05/2017 at 11:23:57
Usmanov is in the difficult position of having a significant shareholding in Arsenal but not enough to have any influence on decision making. If he wanted to get involved at Everton, he needs to sell his shares in Arsenal... but who would buy them if they are to experience the same frustrations he has faced? It does not look an attractive buy.
Simon Smith
37 Posted 20/05/2017 at 11:27:46
If things do go in cycles (Tony No 11), maybe we could become "The Mersey Billionaires"!!!
Tony Hill
38 Posted 20/05/2017 at 11:32:17
Eugene (#20), yes I feel exactly the same. Not clean, but in too deep and too late now.
Joe Bibb
39 Posted 20/05/2017 at 11:32:50
You can't compete in Formula One driving a Mini; the same for the Premier League. If we want to be European Giants and win the Premier League, then we need top investment.
Dave Abrahams
41 Posted 20/05/2017 at 11:48:44
Good question, Jim Hardin.

Basically, would I want Everton to buy their trophies like Chelsea and Man City? I had to to stop and think hard about that... not sure...

I would definitely love to see young supporters, who have supported Everton since they were born and seen them win nothing, get a taste of roaring The Blues to titles and cup wins. Oh the pure magic and ecstasy of those great days. Yes, I would love it for them.

On reflection, it would not be the same for me as in 1963 and all the other trophy winning days, I would still get a thrill out of the success mixed with some regret at the way those honours were won, but wouldn't stop me getting wet-eyed watching our young fans going berserk with happiness at any success.

Brian Harrison
42 Posted 20/05/2017 at 11:50:50
Well I think there could me many scenarios as to why Usmanov has made his bid just before Arsenal's last home game. Maybe he hopes the fans will demonstrate at the game against Kronke owning Arsenal, hoping he might step down. But maybe he his trying to show that he really wants control of Arsenal to move them back to the top, or this could be his last throw of the dice before calling it a day at Arsenal.

Only Usmanov knows what will happen if his bid as seems likely is rejected. He certainly can't keep his shares at Arsenal if he wants to join Moshiri at Everton, so he would have to dispose of them before joining us if that's his intention.

I would imagine some hedge funding company would buy them. I cant see another individual spending that sort of money without getting control of the club and that wont happen while Kronke is still there.

Brian Williams
43 Posted 20/05/2017 at 12:02:35
Who would buy his shares? They'd be snapped up like stuff going out of date in Tesco's last thing on a Saturday. Or he could simply transfer them to a family member, his Mrs for instance.

For those who want us to compete with the top 4/6 and keep things as they've always been? The reason we're NOT competing with the top 4/6 is that (until very recently) things ARE as they've always been.

We have to adapt to thrive. If we don't, we merely survive and plod along.


Laurie Hartley
44 Posted 20/05/2017 at 12:14:55
Jim,

I think "given the ties between Usmanov and Moshiri", my view is that this has been a possibility since day one. That is why I was a bit disappointed when I heard that Usmanov had just tried to buy Kroenke out. However, now that I have had time to think about it, here is my slant on the situation.

Usmanov has been planning this move buy out Kroenke since before he bought Moshiri's Arsenal shares. In doing so he achieved two things:

1. He increased his personal share holding to 30% – thus denying Kroenke the opportunity to significantly increase his shareholding.

2. He fired a warning shot across Kroenke's bow that he was prepared to put money into an opposition club (Everton) via his long time business partner Moshiri.

There is no doubt that Usmanov has enough money and nous to transform Everton into a club that can compete with any in Britain and in time, any in Europe. Not something Kroenke or the Arsenal board would like to see happen – they have enough competition for the Champions League places as it already stands.

He then fired a second shot across Kroenke's bows by doing the USM Finch Farm deal with Moshiri. He got away with that – something that would have given Kroenke something to think about regarding ownership rules etc.

That set the stage for his bid to buy out Kroenke who has now put under a lot of pressure. Kroenke can swallow his pride and take a substantial profit or knock the offer back and retain his 67% shareholding in a club that is not going to qualify for the Champions League for the first time in 20 years.

If Kroenke sticks to his guns hopefully Usmanov's plan B will be to come in with us. Either way I am also convinced that there is no way that Alisher Usmanov will sell his 30% stake in Arsenal to any one other than a family member – maybe his developer stepson. He is on the record as saying it is a "long term investment for his family".

The thought of that may be enough for Kroenke to decide to sell out. I hope not. Don't worry about the prospect of Usmanov taking us over dividing the fan base Jim – it won't happen.

As Tony @ 11 pointed out, the last time we had a very wealthy benefactor John Moores, we were great and it was great to be an Evertonian. As a 13 year old I used to look forward to the headlines in the Echo regarding the Merseyside Millionaires – "Everton break transfer record for a goalkeeper" Gordon West. "Tony Kay joins Everton for 㿼,000". "England World Cup hero Alan Ball signs for "Everton". It was great and it didn't seem to bother my dad or any of the other older Evertonian's I knew.

As an aside, there is also the matter of the new stadium and the growing relationship between Moshiri and Peel. The Liverpool and Wirral Waters developments represent huge opportunities for people with enough money to buy into them. How about the Megafon Stadium?

Could be an interesting few months coming up. My hunch is there is a lot of money heading towards Merseyside in the next couple of years.

Up the Blues!!

Gary Edwards
45 Posted 20/05/2017 at 12:44:37
Who would buy Usamov's shares?

Usamov invested £200m in Arsenal which gave him a 30% stake. Now he's supposedly offered Kroenke £1.3bn for his 70% stake, this valuing his 30% stake at (approx) £560m. granted this is a very simplistic view of things but, even if half correct, it still seems like bloody good business and one that many fund managers would be very interested in.

Chris Williams
46 Posted 20/05/2017 at 12:57:25
Can anyone recall how much Moshiri got for his Arsenal shares whe he sold them to Usmanov?
Patrick Murphy
47 Posted 20/05/2017 at 13:47:18
Jeremy Wilson reports that Stan Kroenke has reassured Arsenal directors that there is no possibility of him selling his majority share to Alisher Usmanov and that he remains determined to win the Premier League and turn the club into one of the powerhouses of European football.

A bid of ٟ billion has been made by Usmanov for Kroenke's 67 per cent stake but, having been well aware for the last six years that his fellow billionaire wants to buy Arsenal, his long-term commitment has never wavered.

Usmanov wanted to test that resolve at the end of what has been the club's most challenging season since Kroenke won the takeover battle in 2011, especially as the club are poised to lose their usual Champions League income.

However, there was no real expectation on the side of Usmanov that Kroenke would waver and the answer has been emphatic. Indeed, Arsenal insiders believe that there is no chance of the ownership structure changing for a generation, with Kroenke's son, Josh, on the club board and keenly involved. He played college football – as well as a high standard of basketball – and always followed the Premier League when he was younger.

No Deal

Bill Gall
48 Posted 20/05/2017 at 13:49:28
We supporters are a fickle group but I believe we all want the same thing and that is a team of "Winners".

Too long we have had to watch our teams put up a valiant effort against the top teams to get a result and except for the odd game " fail " because the other team has better players and a squad that we can not afford. And then we have the other occasions were we have a defeatist attitude from the team selections that try to get a draw instead of a win.

I live in Canada now but still feel the pain when we loose against the other lot, and I don't care how much money, or who supplies it.

If Usamov comes in and gives us a winning team through the purchase of better players, then I would welcome him with open arms, especially if we beat the other lot frequently that will save me some pain and our supporters will be able to go out to work with a spring in their step.

All the top teams have this type of backing or can raise extra revenue with a ground capacity of over 70,000 so why can't we?

We need someone with money to burn, and why not Usamov ,as with him and Moshiri combined they still don't have the financial clout that City,s owners have. Times have changed and you get nowhere if you don't keep up with them – just think what would a lot of us do without a cell phone? Or all the other electronic devices that make up this modern world?

Sadly, to keep up with the crowd costs money... and the more you have, the easier it is to do.

Colin Metcalfe
49 Posted 20/05/2017 at 13:58:39
According to The Telegraph, Kroenke has issued a statement that in no way will he sell his stake to Usmanov, not even for £1 Billion; that's a petty emphatic No if you ask me... so where does this leave Usmanov? A business man who I would imagine is not accustomed to playing second fiddle to anyone.

I think it's a difficult situation Usmanov finds himself in: on one hand, he is clearly an Arsenal fan who wants the best for the club and, given the opportunity, he would jump at the chance to take over Arsenal; however, without even a seat in the board and no chance of increasing his 30% stake, he may start to look elsewhere and Everton is the obvious choice.

If he does decide to sell, I would imagine his shares would be passed on to a family member; he is, after all, a fan of the club and will want to still have ties to Arsenal.

Interesting times at The Emirates... I hope the clear unrest going on at the moment will be Everton's gain, with Moshiri's and Usmanov's combined wealth at £13 Billion, we would second only to Man City on the Premier League Rich List!!!

Jeff Armstrong
50 Posted 20/05/2017 at 14:04:05
Jeff (#5), good point, but not what we want to hear.
Steavey Buckley
51 Posted 20/05/2017 at 14:23:19
Alisher Usmanov's should recognise that he will get more bangs for his bucks while making a name for himself in Liverpool, where he will be a very big fish in a small pond compared to the many billionaires in London.
Patrick Murphy
52 Posted 20/05/2017 at 15:08:18
Geoff (#5),

You could also look at the situation in reverse: Usmanov realises that he is stuck in his current position for the foreseeable future, he makes a last gasp bid, knowing the chances of it being accepted are slim. He can now sell his own shares in Arsenal to some other interested party and leave with his head held high if he so chooses.

The Arsenal supporters cannot accuse him of running out on their club and, if he does buy another club, their fans will not worry that he will do the same to their club.

I suppose it all depends on what Mr Usmanov wants for his money, a part share in a club where he has little or no influence on proceedings or a large share in a similar club where he can dictate events.


James Flynn
53 Posted 20/05/2017 at 16:25:54
So, if Usmanov sold up and then bought into Everton, how exactly would that work for Moshiri? Usmanov would take a back seat to his protege? Moshiri sliding to the right; back to being a trusted side-kick?

Usminov made his way in business. He's no trust fund dumb-ass inherited dad's wealth. He knew, and knows perfectly well, that Kroenke doesn't sell things. He buys them.

If he was looking to get into another club, why did he buy Moshiri's 15%? He could have just come along from the get-go.

Tony Hill
54 Posted 20/05/2017 at 16:46:41
James, I imagine that might have been to allow Moshiri to go ahead of him and prepare the ground. It would allow a much smoother and more PR-friendly exit from Arsenal. They have worked together for a very long time.

As you say, he must always have known Kroenke would not sell, or not to him.

Of course, all the above might be total bollocks.

Patrick Murphy
55 Posted 20/05/2017 at 16:48:22
James (#51) Moshiri is the main man at Everton but only because he has the money to be so, I would think that if, and it's a huge IF, Usmanov wanted to invest in our club then Moshiri wouldn't be that bothered about his own role within the club.

The bigger Everton becomes, the better Moshiri's return on his own investment. If Moshiri is as good a businessman as he appears to be, and he doesn't appear to be a person that craves the limelight, it could all work out to everybody's benefit.

However, the Financial Fair Play rules will continue to hamper any potential investors at Everton and therefore the club might not be as attractive as many would like to think.

Peter Gorman
56 Posted 20/05/2017 at 16:50:48
Not total bollocks, Tony, but maybe wishful thinking.

I just get the impression Moshiri is his own man now. After hearing him speak ample times about his plans from the club, I just can't believe he is a puppet.

Colin Glassar
57 Posted 20/05/2017 at 17:11:47
Patrick, screw FFP!! It's a farce anyway, designed to protect the football elite/cartel. If Usmanov (and it's still an 'if') comes on board ,we spend whatever he's prepared to spend and we take a hit from Uefa.

We need to catch up with the leading pack so, if that means a fine, even a points deduction, fuck the lot of them as we will have a squad to compete in the very near future.

Usmanov has absolutely no chance of buying Arsenal. Kroenke hates him, Gazidis hates him, Wenger hates him, even the tea lady hates him!

Then there are all the dinosaurs in the background, the ones that held their noses while they sold their shares to Stan The Man, they all hate him as well!! They've got no shares left but they've still got influence and they have blocked Usmanov every step of the way.

Phil Bellis
58 Posted 20/05/2017 at 18:00:40
Arsenal fan's reading of the situation on Le-Grove.co.uk - interesting... Sorry can't do linky thing
Eric Myles
59 Posted 20/05/2017 at 18:46:02
Does anyone have the wording to Premier League Rule D2.2 on share ownership in more than one club??

I'm not sure whether it states for multiple share ownership it's 10% of each club, or 10% of only one club with unlimited ownership in the other.

So Usmanov would not have to sell ALL his Arsenal shared to buy us, and could retain just enough to continue to be a thorn in Kroenke's side.

Mike Benjamin
60 Posted 20/05/2017 at 19:22:40
Several of you ask the question of who would buy Usmanov's shares without having power. The Chinese might! In fact would probably snatch his hand off. Bring it on.
Patrick Murphy
61 Posted 20/05/2017 at 19:35:29
Phil # 56 Thanks for the heads-up on the Usmanov write up.

Pedro of le grove speculates on the meaning of the Usmanov bid for Arsenal and he asks:

So what do we think is going on here? Is he shaking out investors to show their hand? Is he trying to get the ball rolling on someone buying out Stan so he can rid himself of his shares at a premium and take Everton stratospheric? Absolutely.

Why would you tell your PR team to mention the other investors? You wouldn't. This is an invite

The rest of the article would seem to indicate that the Arsenal supporters aren't too happy with the situation and feel they would be better off if Kroenke accepted the offer for the good of their club.

Le Grove

Don Alexander
62 Posted 20/05/2017 at 19:37:02
If it was "total bollocks", Tony (#54), you can bet your life you'd have already been made very well aware of it by now by the usual TW suspects!
John Pierce
63 Posted 20/05/2017 at 21:06:42
It is the proverbial dream, that Moshiri and Usmanov got together and said this is how we acquire Everton FC and shaft Arsenal at the same time.

Should he leave Arsenal, currently at a Mexican stand-off regarding ownership, it might destablise the club, arguably at its lowest ebb for sometime. Fanciful perhaps but it could see both Sanchez and Ozil go and without them they would be pretty average, in the same way Zlatan has propped Man Utd up this year.

Even so if he did join, not sure FFP would bend enough to accommodate his wealth. We could inherit his list of contacts but I dare we have that already because of his relationship with Moshiri.

It's weird that Moshiri only acquired half the shares, leaving the door ajar for for someone else to step through or are we seeing want we want too?

I guess if Usmanov really did want to buy Everton, as he seems to want to be in control of the whole thing at Arsenal then he would have do so already? That's what makes me think its wishful thinking.

As for the question of a fit and proper person to buy the club, always something that's had me hesitating. No doubt our would-be suitor didn't make his money completely through fair means. Is it "can't beat 'em, then join 'em"?

Well there was a point 3/4 years ago when I thought it would all explode, the footy financial bubble like, and we'd be okay and that other clubs would evaporate with it.

But then who would we play against? It would seem inevitable the tide of the foreign owner.... and just why are there no British-based owners interested in this type of investment?

Brian Williams
64 Posted 20/05/2017 at 21:12:11
The FFP wouldn't have to bend to accommodate his wealth.

The FFP is only concerned with the spending of a club's money compared to it's turnover.

John Pierce
65 Posted 20/05/2017 at 22:00:42
Brian, I do understand that; my rather facetious point is that bringing in someone that wealthy only helps us to a point, we are limited by our brand and geography.

There are only so many ways to artificially 'bend' the rules to invest, create, manufacture turnover to 'accommodate' someones wealth within the rules of FFP.

A man, 'mansplaining' to another man? What's that called? Some TW wag find me a handle for that, its beyond me unless Brian you could help me out... chortle

Brian Williams
66 Posted 20/05/2017 at 22:16:58
John, eh?

You lost me there mate, sorry.

I do believe though if Usmanov came on board he could increase our turnover beyond anything that would make us worry about FFP.

Whether he did that completely above board would be another question.

Patrick Murphy
67 Posted 20/05/2017 at 22:24:52
John (#63),
Many industries and properties in Britain, apart from football clubs are owned by overseas concerns or individuals, whether that is due to a lack of cash being available to British individuals or they have become risk averse I'm not certain, but I'm sure that, if they could invest in a cash-cow, they would.

Surely not all foreign owners have made their money any less legitimately than the British? I'm also sure that not every foreign investor, if any, is using football as a vehicle to launder their 'ill-gotten' gains.

Globalisation is exactly what it says on the tin, money flows from all directions of the planet to wherever the best returns can be attained. Commercialism and football are long time partners, the only difference in the 21st century is that the numbers have far more zeroes on the end than they did when the game was 'pure'.

The only reason that Usmanov may come on board at Everton is that he would have more power than he currently has at Arsenal, but of course he could likely choose any football club that happens to come on the market if he so wished.

Phil Martin
68 Posted 20/05/2017 at 22:27:01
21 years without a trophy is an embarrassment. Ex-pundits like Shitbag Savage and Dwarfy Murphy looking down on us is a disgrace.

If another Billionaire wants to join us, buy us several titles and eventual Champions League glory, I'd be over the fucking moon. I don't care if that's not the "Everton" way. Hopefully I'm not alone.

Chris Leyland
69 Posted 20/05/2017 at 22:33:59
Phil (#68), it is 22 years...
James Flynn
71 Posted 20/05/2017 at 22:55:58
"So what do we think is going on here? Is he shaking out investors to show their hand? Is he trying to get the ball rolling on someone buying out Stan so he can rid himself of his shares at a premium and take Everton stratospheric? Absolutely."

This is "Bleacher Report" level "analysis" by this typist Pedro.

Usmanov is rolling in more dough than he knows what to do with. Why would he look for a premium price on his 30%? Unlike Chelsea and Man City owners, who bought-in for convenience, Usmanov is an Arsenal supporter. He wants to own Arsenal Football Club; his club.

Yet, according to this keyboard-fingerer Pedro, he wants to push the price up, so someone will offer more than he did? Then dump his shares to get into a club he cares nothing about? Yeah, please Everton, this is the guy we need.

There's no getting around Moshiri's relationship with the guy; 20+ years on. The speculation was inevitable.

This is what I think we have. Every move Moshiri has made indicates he is moving things along as HE wants. Not as an advance-man for some rival club's minority shareholder.

Laurie Hartley
72 Posted 20/05/2017 at 23:02:52
I can't see Alisher Usmanov selling his Arsenal shares for at least two reasons.

1) He has stated publicly that they are a long term investment for his family.

2) He is not exactly strapped for cash.

So it seems Usmanov now has a spare ٟB to invest – 𧹈M on a new ground for us and a 40-year-lease would be a good starting point.

Tony Hill
73 Posted 20/05/2017 at 23:29:11
Moshiri doesn't have enough money to make a difference for us. He's Randy Lerner, very rich but not rich enough. Hence my Villa paranoia.

He has always worked with Usmanov. Such dynamics do not change normally between people of huge wealth and influence.

I remember an interesting remark by Elizabeth France in her last comments on here to the effect that we hadn't yet seen the second foot land after Moshiri's arrival. Whether or not she's in the know, I shall be very surprised and very disappointed if she isn't correct.

Dermot Byrne
74 Posted 20/05/2017 at 23:58:53
Could you develop as a business to get us in a winning position with Moshiri's money, I wonder?
Bill Watson
75 Posted 21/05/2017 at 00:59:21
Dave (#41),

Until John Moores became involved, we were a club who flirted with relegation season after season.

JM didn't actually give Everton money, he made them interest free loans but that enabled us to sign players of international class and within a couple of seasons we'd won, or bought, the League title after 18 years of dross. Bit like present day Chelsea and Man City but in those days you didn't stockpile players.

Would we like to do it "The Everton Way?" If that means more years of 'taking knives to gunfights' I'm sure the answer would be a resounding No!

Bring it on!

Gordon Crawford
76 Posted 21/05/2017 at 01:04:12
Anything is possible I guess. But I'm not holding my breath for his arrival.
James Flynn
77 Posted 21/05/2017 at 01:28:11
Tony (#73) – If Lerner's the reason, put your paranoia to rest.

Lerner made his way in the world of big finance by popping out of his mom's belly. His daddy made all the money. Lerner wasted it on his NFL club, the Cleveland Browns. Kept wasting it on Villa. Form held.

Moshiri made his way attached to one of Putin's financial inner-circle; Usmanov.

Jury still out on how Everton will do under Moshiri's control? Fair enough. None of us know. We'll see. Be "paranoid" about that.

Not how we'll do compared to Villa under Lerner's ownership.

Derek Thomas
78 Posted 21/05/2017 at 04:19:37
Usmanov or Moores? Given 50 years have passed and the world has changed, there seems to me to be no substantive difference.

Moores didn't buy the players, all he did was 'back-up' the loans with his clout.

Chelsea and Man City 'bought titles' and we have to remember that between them they still don't have as many as we do. But the rules have changed so it could be 'back to future' with a big hitter providing behind the scenes financial clout.

Both Moshiri and Usmanov have cunning plans aplenty – USM Finch Farm, for instance... so there is nothing to prevent Usmanov 'selling' his Arsenal shares to the postman or whoever, then diving in at EFC.

I don't worry about player loyalty, that boat has well sailed... somewhere around the 1870-80s. If you want loyalty buy a dog not a football player. Players get paid and get tapped up. Clubs sell players. Contracts are a very moveable feast.

It'll happen or it won't – but I hope it does.

*Usmanov speaks to Dan Meis: "What's the capacity of the Emirates?"

Meis: "60,432."

Usmanov: "Make ours 60,433."

Meis;: "Why the extra 1?"

Usmanov: "That's where I'm going to sit."

Peter Roberts
79 Posted 21/05/2017 at 08:47:04
Moshiri isn't rich enough to effectively buy us a league but he has noticeably improved our revenue streams (sponsorships for training grounds, new kit sponsor valued at biggest in club's history) and sorting the stadium issue which now seems to finally be moving forward after 20 years of stalling. It may take a few years but Moshiri is building us up from the bottom to circumvent the whole FFP saga.

Usmanov might be wealthy but the FFP rules would limit the amount of investment he could put in even if he bought the remaining shares off the old guard.

Jay Griffiths
80 Posted 21/05/2017 at 09:10:54
May be best if we let the sleeping dog lie. Why would Moshiri want to hand over his control? I know this seems a little cynical but he could just as easily throw that bid at any other team in the Premier League. God forbid it went to that lot over there.

One temporary benefit is that our lack of funds over the last five years has forced us to use our academy to advance to the first team as opposed to using it as a supermarket for lower league clubs. Long may that continue.

Tony Abrahams
81 Posted 21/05/2017 at 10:12:30
Tony@73, my good mate who is very friendly with an ex Everton player, told me that he'd heard that Moshiri, was sent to get the ball rolling. We were talking about Peel being cheeky fuckers because they wanted millions for land that was given to them by Liverpool City Council for nothing, and he said that his mate had said that our new owner wasn't that concerned because he still thought the land was cheap considering the location, apparently uttering the words that you could just about acquire a car park, in London for that price!

Patrick, that le-grove article was very interesting, especially the bit were the author says that he thinks that the next Premier League television television deal could possibly be fought over by Apple, Google, or some other major company of this ilk, and every Premier League game would be available to watch for the customers.

Only one man's opinion, but it doesn't look like the Premier League bubble is going to burst anytime soon?

Julian Wait
82 Posted 21/05/2017 at 17:00:15
My gut reaction to Usmanov's latest bid for Arsenal control was that he was bidding to achieve one of two goals, ie, get control if he could, or push the price up of his own shares if he couldn't get control. However, it is possible he will be happy to just keep waiting and waiting for Kroenke to die and/or sell up.

My biggest concern, however, is Everton, and it does worry me that we're potentially tying our own success to these ownership shenanigans at Arsenal. We need to move forward on our own schedule.

Today's result is evidence of that, only being able to score a penalty against a 10-man Arsenal team which is the worst in recent memory.

Nicholas Ryan
83 Posted 22/05/2017 at 03:32:54
'Show me the Money!!'
Colin Glassar
84 Posted 22/05/2017 at 12:49:05
Julian, we are and will continue on our own path regardless what Usmanov decides to do.

Some media outlets report that Stan Kroenke will NEVER sell his shares to Usmanov. The hatred between these two runs deep. So it's up to Usmanov if he stays and twiddles his thumbs in frustration or he decides to move on.

Jim Potter
85 Posted 22/05/2017 at 13:23:11
With my rose-tinted glasses on Usmanov has had his last roll of the dice and failed at Arsenal.

The scout he sent a year ago has done the groundwork and the Fatman is about to sing.

Thomas Lennon
86 Posted 22/05/2017 at 13:45:54
Ways round Premier League restrictions? Send your partner in to start the job of transforming Everton, keep your Arsenal shares, have your cake & eat it.

We will know if Usmanov is already here by the size of the funds we spend this summer and size of sponsorship we get as the latter will limit the former.

USM is owned by both Usmanov & Moshiri so how will anyone ever follow who's money is doing what? This could be the case for a year or two yet.

David Young
87 Posted 22/05/2017 at 15:41:46
Usmanov ٟ Billion to buy Arsenal and a No-Go with this Kronke fella. Now BBC Sports saying Usmanov will look to another Premier League club?

USM FINCH Farm, is this just the start of it?!

Damian Wilde
88 Posted 22/05/2017 at 17:38:21
Usmanov and Everton? Pie in the sky.
Charles Brewer
89 Posted 22/05/2017 at 19:37:15
Just fantasising, but this could be very interesting.

Moshri has, as we know, already bought one of the most recognisable buildings in the UK, if not the world, in the Liver Building. He is in the process of buying land on the waterfront to develop what will almost certainly be a world-class sports venue - to what is likely to be a distinctive design worthy of a location unmatched outside a few locations. And as he said of the dock purchase, it's very, very cheap for land a couple of hours from London.

Last week I was at a dinner with a London-based Israeli banker and we were discussing the UK market. He pointed out that there is probably nowhere on Earth where property investment are as safe from war, insurrection and – more to the point – corrupt court systems as in England. Certainly not anywhere else in Europe, virtually all of Asia or Africa. And the USA, as can be seen from technology cases involving foreign companies, has a legal system which can be unfavourably compared with that of Italy.

The point is that England is a very sound place to invest, and if you have any concerns regarding the location of the source of your wealth, English property is a great place to stash it. London, at current prices is not great value, but Liverpool undoubtedly could be.

Looked at entirely dispassionately, it would be a very sensible thing for Usmanov to invest heavily in the north-west of England, which may well also be a major beneficiary of our distancing ourselves from continental Europe. As punts go, buying up and investing in a world-class riverside in Brexiting England is not a bad one. And having a very successful football team would do the investment no end of good.

Tony Draper
90 Posted 22/05/2017 at 21:35:27
It will be interesting if Usmanov returns with an increased offer. However, as I've posted earlier, I always suspected that, if Usmanov were to decide to call it a day with Arsenal in favour of creating something powerful with Everton, there would need to be some "endgame" played out first.

As many commented at the time, Moshiri's percentage of Everton shares does seem to hint at some "further business". This arrangement seems even more intriguing in the light of recent events.

Simply because, since his "buy up", Moshiri's history is one of marked, repeated and laudable progress, I'm finding it increasingly difficult to not let my (positive) imagination get ahead of itself.

What I certainly do expect between now and next season (playing staff ins & outs aside) will be more announcements.

Quite what? Well, how about:

Further sponsorship deal or deals for let's say a section, or a stand, or two, or even the whole ground? "Partners", as in "official XXXX of Everton FC".

Clearly with a scant two (similar) examples, I'm not the man to creatively drive this forward. But my point really is that there IS money out there and we will be tapping into it increasingly so from now on.

And not just 㿞 for some oik to walk around the pitch adorned with a sandwich board bearing the timeless legend "Eat At Joes Cafe". But also, new projects, stuff we currently just don't have any comparison for. Yet stuff that makes you sit back and think "That's bloody great... so why didn't we have one of these 20 years ago?"

I'm trying, in my own way, to say that I now expect and anticipate stuff to happen, rather than look out of the window like a bored kid during the school holidays as the rain pelts the glass for the umpteenth day on the trot.

C'mon, Alisher, you know you want to!

But,

Tony Waring
91 Posted 24/05/2017 at 12:37:07
Damian (#88) – no chance now we've got a vegan on board!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads



© ToffeeWeb