Season 2015-16 Opinion Talking Points
The gullible fans of Goodison Park
A group of fans like no other, an indescribable love for our team
Up to Sunderland or down to Bournemouth, in our thousands we're happy to stream.
Putting up with performances so often wide of the mark,
We are the gullible fans of Goodison Park.
Blue Bill with his empty promises, his media soundbites are strong,
Yet Blue Bill is nowhere to be seen, when inevitably things go wrong.
And what about Bobby Elstone, a man so out of his depth,
A lie or an excuse is murmured, with each and every breath.
In came the saviour we had longer for, a billionaire to roll back the years,
Could this be the man to put us back on top, eradicating all of our fears?
Like City before us we expected, a Robinho-esque statement of player,
But this is Everton of course, and to dream we better not dare.
For a moment we were linked to the best, a club once against rich with cash,
But the months went by, our transfer funds dry, and the dream over in but a flash.
Sell-to-buy is the policy we must get used to, despite the claims of Blue Bill.
As we watch those around us strengthen and spend, not even the gossip columns give us a thrill.
The train has left, the ship has sailed, so don't be fooled into thinking it ain't so.
We might make one or two signings, but only when Ross and Rom go.
So next time you walk home, we've lost and you're miserable and frozen,
Console yourself with one of Blue Bills favourites...
You didn't choose, you were chosen.
But still we'll go back, that's just what we do,
We'll still give our everything for those boys in blue.
That one-off moment, that occasional spark,
Because we are the gullible fans of Goodison Park.
Return to Talking Points index : Add your Comments »
Reader Comments (108)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 01/06/2017 at 17:29:42
He can't win whatever he does!
3 Posted 01/06/2017 at 18:05:21
4 Posted 01/06/2017 at 18:11:49
Am I gullible?
5 Posted 01/06/2017 at 18:43:04
6 Posted 01/06/2017 at 18:46:35
7 Posted 01/06/2017 at 18:48:27
So next time you walk home, we've lost and you're miserable and frozen,
Console yourself with one of Blue Bills favourites...
You didn't choose, you were chosen.
William Topaz McGonagall lives ("..and when shaking icing sugar or straining liquid from solids, he sieves").
Sorry, never understood this kind of..'thing' - the kind of thing that would regularly appear on the letters page of the Football Echo.
'Ode To King Kenny' - by Ron Ballbag, Ormskirk etc.
Shudders.
8 Posted 01/06/2017 at 18:57:22
9 Posted 01/06/2017 at 19:02:56
Brian (#2) – agree. Damned if you don't, damned if you do.
Mine is not a defence of Kenwright just – see above
10 Posted 01/06/2017 at 19:03:33
11 Posted 01/06/2017 at 19:13:13
12 Posted 01/06/2017 at 19:18:42
How many posts before one about the striker whose name shall not be spoken? I'll give it 25. I can hear the straining of leashes now.
13 Posted 01/06/2017 at 19:38:13
There has been no-one at the club associated at the top who drives this forward. We as fans, have just accepted it and taken the shit thrown at us. I mean would Kenwright really be chairman of those lot across the park 20 years later??? He would have been forced out of the club the minute he lied to its fan base.
You look up and aspire to those above you, that's what we've been doing for decades; we sit down, shut up and don't say a word. The mentality of our supporters has never changed.
I'd love a Robino-esque signing to make that statement but it won't happen and that's because we don't have the tough guys at the top to make it happen – they are just merrymen happy to plod along, in their eyes running an 'ordinary' business.
14 Posted 01/06/2017 at 20:01:52
Actions speak louder than words and Everton spout lots of words but not a lot of action when it comes to transfers.
We all know this summer will be like all the others with a last minute scurry of activity and not a lot of improvement.
15 Posted 01/06/2017 at 20:03:08
16 Posted 01/06/2017 at 20:07:44
Gooners are bored of winning the FA Cup only... Christ – 1995 last time we won it or anything. What would Gooners do if their stadium was Goodison Park?
17 Posted 01/06/2017 at 20:28:49
Everton is finished as we knew it. Progress, rampant capilatism, and greed sorted that years ago. To compete with the big boys, you need balls and,unless things change, we re just going to be the ones nobody minds or doesn't particularly dislike.... 7th-placed Everton.
Do I like it? No. Do I want a Russian billionaire to join his mate and boost us into the stratosphere? Probably again, no. What do we want apart from a cup or two and a few European trips?
18 Posted 01/06/2017 at 20:38:38
Ffs, the transfer window doesn't even open until Friday 9th June and the 'doom mongers' have us written off already, it's as if they want us to fail.
19 Posted 01/06/2017 at 21:26:12
20 Posted 01/06/2017 at 22:01:52
21 Posted 01/06/2017 at 22:05:42
I haven't travelled away this season, but I'm still waiting for these players who appreciate us so much, to have a walk down the train on the way home from London or even just invite a few kids into there carriage, and witness the joy that such an act could bring?
22 Posted 01/06/2017 at 22:09:52
23 Posted 01/06/2017 at 22:24:04
24 Posted 01/06/2017 at 22:29:21
26 Posted 01/06/2017 at 22:41:19
David,
Given your constant mantra of "You're all just happy to sit on your arses and accept mediocrity: – I'd be very interested to know by what means you – personally – signal your defiant rejection of the shitty status quo to the decision-makers currently in situ at the club.
If the full range of your furious rejection is firing off a few vexed posts to ToffeeWeb railing against poor results/a lack of transfers/that large female steward who looks like Leatherface when he ladies himself up for lunch, and trotting out your best Popeye impression in the pub ("That's all I can stands coz I can't stands no more!!! Pint of Stella please, Pamela."), then I think it's fair to suggest you're hardly a voice for change or the fucking 'V for Vendetta' of football supporters yourself.
27 Posted 01/06/2017 at 22:55:16
28 Posted 01/06/2017 at 23:23:51
What business of yours is it what any of us do?
Why do you think we should be answerable to you?
29 Posted 01/06/2017 at 23:33:55
Or should we all go to B&Q every weekend and do the DIY instead?
30 Posted 02/06/2017 at 00:03:55
Do you really not see John's poin...oh shit, sorry..I didn't realise you..um..
Editorial Team
31 Posted 02/06/2017 at 00:05:59
32 Posted 01/06/2017 at 00:24:02
"Why do you think we should be answerable to you?"
Delicate Don,
Just because you can't see the point doesn't mean there wasn't one. I would normally question how you could possibly fail to fathom what that point was when it wasn't exactly shrouded in subtlety, but given you seemingly can't distinguish between an expression of interest (even with a big, bright, self-explanatory label saying "I'd be very interested to know" slapped on it) and a demand to know 'what people do', then I would obviously be wasting my time and only giving you further opportunity to bleat like Dustin Hoffman after he'd been strapped into Laurence Olivier's dentist's chair.
"...what the site's designed for, namely cast an opinion?"
Don't stop halfway, Don. Yes, it's a public forum where people can voice an opinion but, following on from that, once said opinion is aired then anyone who is moved to do so is subsequently free to respond.
You honestly believe any and every "opinion" should be deemed sacred and shielded from question, comment or scorn, no matter it's content, inference, or validity, simply because it's been let loose on the world? ('What gives you the right to criticise a rallying cry from the Ku Klux Klan? They're perfectly entitled to "cast an opinion". It's probably because of people like you waiting to hammer them for it that they started wearing hoods to begin with.")
I prefer to judge an "opinion" on its merits, rather than just the simple fact someone saw fit to fucking voice it in the first place.
33 Posted 02/06/2017 at 00:46:43
34 Posted 02/06/2017 at 00:52:52
Anyway, why is it that they can't have a pint only station at half time. Were the pints are already poured and waiting so we all get to have one ffs.
Grrrr... it makes me mad! 😡
35 Posted 02/06/2017 at 02:19:46
We implemented a whole new structure and that takes time. We've spent £76.6mil since Moshiri took over it's hardly dreadful. This is not the Bill era anymore - our new sponsorship deal illustrates that. The window isn't even open yet - take a breath and relax. If at the start of August we've spent a measly £20mil on a couple of punts, then raise hell. But I'll predict that we will smash our spending records this season, and that these complaints will look premature and overdone.
I'd be more worried about the Lukaku and Barkley transfer sagas. The success or failure of our season might well rest on their futures being sorted sooner rather than later. I trust Koeman, I trust Walsh, and I trust Moshiri, and I hope that Bill is sidelined, but I fear Lukaku and Barkley fucking us.
36 Posted 02/06/2017 at 02:34:21
You forget we've only spent a little bit over what we've received in transfers.
So far, Moshiri has spent bugger all on transfers. Whether that's down to him, FFP, Bungling Bill or targets not wanting to come we can't be sure.
But if he doesn't spend a shed load by the end of the upcoming window – on top of Lukaku and Barkley sales – then we'll know for sure we are still a sell to buy club. That would be 3 windows without major investment in terms of transfers.
37 Posted 02/06/2017 at 03:37:36
I think the purchases of Schneiderlin and Lookman in the January window, which is traditionally quiet, was a statement of intent.
I also feel claiming that we are a sell to buy club if we do not spend a shed load on top of Barkley and Lukaku fees might be going a bit far too.
It needs contextualisation imo. We need to spend big irrespective of whether those two go, but them going is necessarily going to bring in a large amount of money which we may not be able to spend effectively, especially as clubs will be all too aware of our spending capacity.
I think it's fair to assume that we would bring in around 𧴜 mil from the sales of Barkley and Lukaku in that context, 𧴺 mil spent on 5/6 players would be a far bigger financial statement than 㿊 mil spent and Lukaku and Barkley staying, in view of the increased wages etc.
We need to spend big on a goalkeeper, a creative midfielder, a CB, and another striker. We need a new left back too, and possibly a back up right back depending on the belief Koeman has in Kenny and Holgate. If Lukaku and Barkley go, we will need to replace them. That is the task ahead of us, and our ability to bring the right players in will define our ambition.
Whatever happens, we cannot know it now. None of us has a crystal ball. But I don't see the point in deriding this set-up based on years of pathetic spending under Bill. A lot has changed, and I think there is enough reason to believe that the Everton of Moshiri, Koeman and Walsh will be very different to that of Kenwright and Martinez, Moyes, or a string of earlier managers.
38 Posted 02/06/2017 at 04:34:18
I'd quite happily sell Lukaku and Barkley for £100 to 130mill and bring in 5 top class players. I then wouldn't be too bothered about our net spend as we'd be a hell of a lot stronger post window than pre.
Trouble I see though is if they go and we spend their fees and not much else, we'll still have the sell-to-buy label.
It's going to take some decent money from Mosh during this window on top of any incoming for us to lose that label and get us all on the same page.
As for the playing staff, I'm hoping Kenny and Galloway show enough to be considered good enough for full back cover / pushing incumbent hence saving us some money in fees and wages. The other areas of the pitch? Absolutely agree.
39 Posted 02/06/2017 at 04:38:02
Still chuckling.
40 Posted 02/06/2017 at 05:01:20
I think what has caused the gloom amongst many of us is that with 5 games to go we looked to be in with a chance to finish in 5th or 6th spot. We failed miserably and as a result I think it has left many of us deflated.
Having said that, I have a sneaky feeling that there are going to be some big moves coming off in the next three months both on and off the field.
The situation at Arsenal has settled down. Wenger getting a new contract suggests to me that nothing is going to change there any time soon. Will Usmanov be willing to sit on the outer for another season? Watching the Cup Final on the TV he was nowhere to be seen when Kroenke was shaking Wenger's hand.
Anyway we chose to be Evertonians and I wouldn't have it any other way. (As long as I can have the occasional moan on TW.)
41 Posted 02/06/2017 at 05:32:20
The training ground has a sponsored name now, he bought a building in Liverpool for himself, the club signed a new shirt sponsor after the Chang deal expired, which would have happened no matter the owner, and we've hardly invested in he playing squad.
What am I missing? Barkley won't sign. Lukaku won't sign. We're apparently bringing in Southampton's reserve right-back after he was judged to not even be good enough at that role for them. There has been zero sign that the club intends to actually go after any big name quality players. Instead we look like losing our two best players.
We finished 7th, that was not a great accomplishment. We were knocked out of both Cups at the first stage. Moshiri has been here a year and a half but all that has happened is the status quo of the Moyes decade.
42 Posted 02/06/2017 at 05:41:41
I do agree with you though that the transfer dealing last summer were, to put it politely, not executed with the desired level finesse. Thinking of Sissoko mainly.
To address the OP, Robinho style desire. He was pretty much a failure. Signed for 㿌 million, sold for 㾻 million after 2 playing seasons, 53 appearances and 16 goals. Basically, Super Kev has similar stats during Bobby's first two seasons. Yes it drew attention, but ultimately ended in farce. Against us he was brought on as a sub... then taken back off!
If you want better examples of the kind of signings we should be looking at as examples:
Yaya Toure, 㿄 million
N'golo Kante, 㿌 million
Saido Mane, 㿏 million
Victor Wanayama, 㾸.5 million!!
The biggest names and highest transfer fees don't always equate to the best transfers
Whatever anyone thinks, FFP does affect us. At the time city and Chelsea had their big sprees it hadnt come into effect. City did overstep and ended up with a penalty.
We cant throw money around with careless abandon.
Chelsea had a plan. When Abramovich took over he invested heavily for a few seasons, but Peter Kenyon was tasked with making the club self sufficient within 6 years of the takeover, meaning they would no longer need the interest free loans and to cover wages and transfers.
Do we still need to sell to buy? I would say to a certain extent yes. But that is the case at most clubs bar the real financial elite. The difference now is that it is not sell to survive! Moshiri can't pour money in directly for transfers. The increased TV money will help, but every team is getting their share, everyone has more buying power, players are getting more expensive.
Referring back to Chelsea, they also had a net spend of around 㿀 million last season. Okay, they spent more overall and the Oscar transfer boosted the income, but no longer do the rely on the big man to pump cash in. They sell to help balance the books and bring in new players
Finally, as stated by many so far, the transfer window isn't actually open yet. Only Man City have done any real business, buying players that are really outside of our price range. Give it until the beginning of next season to judge whether its same old Everton or not.
43 Posted 02/06/2017 at 06:01:59
The training ground name, USM Finch Farm, indicates to me that people with a LOT of money see Everton as a good investment. Given Usmanov's stake in Arsenal, that was a significant statement on his part. I don't think that would have happened without Moshiri's involvement.
Last but not least, unless Dan Meis has deliberately mislead us, Moshiri has done the groundwork to get us a new stadium on the waterfront.
I think Moshiri wants to "do something" with Everton and is ambitious. The big question for me is can Koeman and Walsh deliver on his on-field expectations.
No, David, in my opinion, we have moved on from the Kenwright/Moyes modus operandi.
44 Posted 02/06/2017 at 06:13:39
Or doesn't this count? I realise it's not for players but it was money spent by the club. Well spent or otherwise depends on your point of view.
45 Posted 02/06/2017 at 06:24:31
46 Posted 02/06/2017 at 08:21:11
47 Posted 02/06/2017 at 09:44:54
I was talking about the contents of the message in the card and it was mostly a load of sickening nonsense from the master of sickening nonsense.I wasn't concerned about any transfer dealings, they will come, but the fact that Kenwright is still a part of Everton.
Mark, if you go to the away games you are a better Evertonian than me, and certainly not gullible but you surely cannot have been impressed by the efforts of the team away from home, hence my reference to Kenwright talking about how much the players appreciated the supporters; the effort they put in didn't reflect that appreciation.
48 Posted 02/06/2017 at 09:54:21
The 60s was great, and after winning the league in 69-70 I thought we'd take the 70s by storm, but we didn't, we were relatively mediocre.
But then, after 14 years of doing little by Everton standards, we were on the rise again, with the result that the 80s was also great. In that decade, we could have taken Europe by storm, but for the usual the knee-jerk daft decisions of politicians, beyond our control.
It's been 22 years since we won a trophy, and we've been mediocre for a couple of decades. But, like the 14 years that elapsed after the 69-70 league title, we could rise again. There are now signs of an increased likelihood of this happening, the regime is changing.
Money is important, and we've got more of it now. But money isn't everything, as Leicester showed, and as is shown by the fact that the lot across the park have never won the Premier League despite their massive spend on players.
So anything can happen in the next few years. But nothing will happen without belief.
49 Posted 02/06/2017 at 10:40:54
When Leicester won the title, I bet the greatest pleasure and feeling of glory was felt by the supporters who'd kept on going, year after year, through thick and thin. The other supporters, who jump on the band wagon when things are on the up, won't get the same feeling.
50 Posted 02/06/2017 at 12:05:31
I loved a moan in the Kenwright days, because there were so many reasons to do so, but it's a bit early now, no? I'll answer your question though, even if they have some obvious answers.
As Laurie says we brought in Koeman. This is not something to just be ignored – Koeman clearly wasn't Moyes or Martinez. Koeman was the guy being touted for the Arsenal job, and for other big positions.
He had performed brilliantly at Southampton despite significant player departures, and most importantly of all, he had finished above us in two successive seasons. When is the last time we had brought in a manager from a team above us?
Next – we also brought in Walsh. From the Premier League Champions. He is the guy credited with masterminding the extremely successful Leicester scouting strategy. Again, we have brought in a successful and respected individual from a team who didn't just finish above us, but won the Premier League.
This is the team I have confidence in, and who we must give time to. Moshiri clearly understands the importance of hiring the right people – I'm confident that Koeman was the best manager available to us.
A return to the top 7, despite squad problems and a lack of time, is something I will take hope from after 2 years of bottom half finishes, even if the top 6 look frustratingly out of reach in terms of general wage and spending capacity and quality.
Next – We didn't 'hardly invest in the playing squad" – we spent 㿸.6million. It's hardly nothing is it? our net spend was the 10th highest in the division last season – higher than Chelsea, Liverpool and Southampton. Our gross spend was the seventh highest in the division, behind Leicester, Arsenal, Man City, Man Utd, Chelsea and Palace.
So we are better than the majority of Premier League clubs in spending... Are you really going to claim that was typical of the Premier League era? Because as I remember it, we consistently spent less than practically everyone in the Premier League.
We've also not just got a new sponsorship deal. We've finally got a COMPETITIVE sponsorship deal. Again– I don't know if you were following us in the previous seasons, but we were not competitive in this respect. It was an embarrassment in fact.
The stadium appears to be moving forward and it's the 2nd of June. Would us being linked in bullshit stories to whatever constitutes 'big name' players make you happy? I'll withhold my judgement and hope that we are doing business in the right way this summer – behind close doors, with minimal press leaks.
Personally though I'd be happy with both Sandro and Sigurdsson – one would give us a back up striker/starting second striker necessary to fill a gap, and another would provide creativity and goals, and more importantly consistency from a position marked by inconsistency from the likes of Mirallas, Deulofeu and Barkley, irrespective of their merits.
We won't be taking players from top Champions League teams, but with the right strategy we can buy cleverly abroad and target talents in this league. Lanzini, King, Keane, Heaton and Iheanacho stand out. This is the first summer window which has begun with Koeman, Walsh and Moshiri on board – I'm backing them to be a success, despite the futures of Lukaku and Barkley casting a cloud. We are not Man City or Man Utd – we need patience, and we need our management and scouting team to be clever. I'm backing them.
Also, James, I like the look of Kenny. I wouldn't be adverse to him starting with Holgate and Kenny as right back options to be honest, but then I think Holgate is a better centre-back than right-back. I think at times Koeman's substitutions have suggested a displeasure about Holgate's attacking contributions, despite him putting in an admirable shift. I'm not so sure about Galloway – I think he is also a better centre-back than right back.
Hopefully the Europa will enable some minor rotation, and the ability to give these youngsters the shot they deserve. Holgate and Davies have shown that trusting in youth can work out well. And if we are to improve we have to target and develop young players.
52 Posted 02/06/2017 at 13:11:32
53 Posted 02/06/2017 at 13:40:22
Stat: "Our net spend was higher than Liverpool's and Chelsea's
Fact: Chelsea and Liverpool have spent... na, no point in explaining that one. Everyone in possession of the facts will see through your latest silly little stat.
"Koeman is clearly no Moyes or Martinez." Well, yes he is. The football we play would put a glass eye to sleep. Get back to me when he finishes 4th or 5th as those two did – that`ll be some wait.
I laughed out loud when you tried to claim Steve Walsh was responsible for masterminding the signings of the Leicester players – not because I don't believe it, but because on a recent debate about the stupidity of using stats in isolation as an argument, you claimed that Leicester had signed the likes of Vardy and Marhrez on their stats alone! No mention of Walsh. If your first half-baked claim had any truth in it at all, why are you telling David Barks that he is myopic in not recognising Walsh as a brilliant acquisition? Why didn't we just bring in a statto?
It doesn't surprise me that you don't understand the extent of David's pessimism /criticism. You don't seem to have his grasp of the facts. We have spent years of having to be self sufficient, only using TV funds and whatever we have brought in through sales without any contribution to transfer funds from board members. Did that change when I wasn't looking?
Instead of trying to tell David that he is myopic, pessimistic and critical, why not show him where he is wrong? I for one, will wait for that post with particular interest.
54 Posted 02/06/2017 at 13:51:12
55 Posted 02/06/2017 at 14:09:49
Note that Everton's wage bill is the seventh highest of the Premier League teams and that's where we ended up. Obviously it's not the only factor as Spurs exceeded their position in the league compared to their spending on wages – so good management and a team ethic can lead to real achievements on the pitch.
The clubs that pay the most in wages do have a far better chance of success. From that perspective, it would seem that most fans of most clubs are 'gullible' each and every season.
As for owners/directors dipping into their own pockets to fund transfers or wages, well that's just pie-in-the-sky thinking, Moshiri indicated that he wanted Everton to grow in a sustainable way and that would not lead me to think that Everton FC will be throwing their money about wily-nily in the next few years.
Put it this way: Everton could double the players wages, this coming season, but it would still not guarantee anything more than a battle with our nearest and dearest for fourth place and could put too much of a strain on our – in comparison to the super clubs – limited resources.
Wage bill, Season16-17
1 Barcelona 𧷏m
2 Man Utdd 𧷁m
3 Chelsea 𧷁m
4 Real Madrid 𧶲m
5 Man City 𧶰m
6 PSG 𧶧m
7 Arsenal 𧶢m
8 Bayern Munich 𧶙m
9 Liverpool 𧶀m
10 Juventus 𧵭m
11 Tottenham 𧴰m
14 Everton 𧴢m
17 West Ham Utd 䀋m
18 Southampton 䀈m
19 Stoke City 䀈m
20 Swansea 䀈m
21 Leicester City 䀆m
22 Sunderland 䀆m
24 West Brom 䀀m
25 Crystal Palace 㿼m
56 Posted 02/06/2017 at 14:22:56
We'll bring Rooney back with no pot to piss in
We're hoping that Walsh is a bit of a geezer
We've got rid of Chang but now it's Sportpesa
[I never did get poetry!]
57 Posted 02/06/2017 at 14:33:21
Where did I ignore Walsh? (You claim I made no mention of him and state that Leicester signed Mahrez and Vardy purely on stats alone?) I've just check the thread and I made one reference to Leicester's scouting model and mentioned Walsh:
'The most obvious example, in terms of true centralisation of stats, was in the Leicester's model and Walsh's influence.'
Now tell me one thing do you see Walsh's name there? Because I do, just before influence (ie, effect, impact).
It's difficult debating with you - On the one hand there is the exaggerated bile to counter, and then just pure fiction. The stat issue, in terms of scouting, is not relevant to this debate, but it is needless to say that Leicester's scouting, like the other Premier League teams, uses statistical measures and software alongside the eyes of scouts. (David Mills watched Kante for Leicester for example, and compiled clips and statistics for consideration.)
I await an apology for a groundless accusation. If you want to attack me out of some evident dislike, then don't use lies to do it.
As I said to David, if you read my post in full, I believe that this set-up will be far more efficient than the previous. I've already explained why I think that, as, again, you will see if you read my post.
To sum up: We got Koeman who was not from the lower leagues (Like Moyes) or from a relegated team (Like Martinez) but from a team above us. We got Walsh (from the Premier League Champions and someone I've praised several times on here, if you go with the traditional act of reading what I write).
We spent more money than we ever have before - Our gross spend was double our previous record. Our new sponsorship deal is far far higher than previous ones, finally bringing us to a level where should have been at years ago.
I also believe that the stadium plans are moving forward. If you can't understand how all of these represent change, then there is no helping you.
The question, as I see it, will be over the extent of the change and if it will continue Some will claim No, and I am claiming Yes. I will predict that we will again beat our highest gross spend (set last season) this year.
I also love the fact you bring up TV funds, as if no-one else is spending TV funds! It's hilarious TV funds is now the most significant part of so many clubs' revenue streams. Surely you can understand something as fundamental as this?
I'll reiterate one more time, for fear of it being lost in your translation Kenwright has not supported us properly, especially in terms of revenue creation. I believe that Moshiri is changing that, as per the reasons described.
58 Posted 02/06/2017 at 14:38:57
I didn't get said card (I usually get my tickets from other sources than the club) so don't know what it says. Just think it's not such a bad thing to cause so much ire. I'm long in the tooth and have followed Everton through the really depressing years of Bingham, Walker, Smith etc. (I quite liked the Gordon Lee away days – memory may be playing tricks on me but we always seemed to be tonking Leicester or QPR in the sunshine.)
Nowadays, it's all mainly about the match day than the match. The beers before and after and the away fans atmosphere but I've seen some decent stuff all the same. It's not all bad!
59 Posted 02/06/2017 at 14:50:36
Well, in return, here's the problem I have with people like you, Don. People who constantly seek to wrap themselves (and others) in the protective cloak of "Everyone is entitled to an opinion. Who are you to challenge it?".
You can't demand the right to publicly air your opinion, whilst running for the hills at the first sign of public disagreement or dissent. What you're actually doing then is exposing an entirely different belief: the belief that you, for some indefinable reason, should be permitted to impose your views upon other people without possible reproach. It's the mentality of a foot-stomping child.
You keep banging on about what ToffeeWeb "is for". Despite what you seem to think, it is not a platform to make absolutely any point you wish before pissing off because you don't want to hear anything that may contradict you.
This is a forum for discussion and debate, both of which are silenced by the suggestion disagreement and dispute are somehow unacceptable and 'ignorant'. Hiding behind cries of rudeness/impoliteness is just piss weak and petulant.
If sufficient thought has gone into the formation of someones 'opinion' then they should surely be able to justify their attitude when questioned, rather than immediately resorting to throwing their arms up in the air and calling it quits. Otherwise, it suggests their 'opinion' was always a flimsy one of little to no substance from the start and, in such a case, they have no one else to blame but themselves when people start pointing the finger at their folly.
What if a chef accidentally wandered into a convention of world renowned cock doctors, just as the discussion turned to what they thought would have been the best course of action when faced with John Wayne Bobbits detached dick?
If he raised his hand and piped up with "Well, the best course would clearly have been a nice Cassaulet. Slice it up and slow cook it in a pot with some tomatoes and beans. But obviously the simplest, smartest solution all round would have been to just shove it in a hot dog bun. Add a bit of brown sauce and... voila... Bob's your baloney pony."
Would the correct response there be to say "Well, naturally, we automatically respect your opinion simply because you've taken the time to state it and we wouldn't dare dream of doubting your professional expertise. For reasons of politeness alone we couldn't possibly disagree. Please stay the rest of the week. We'd love to hear your thoughts on erectile dysfunction and that old Etonian who ejaculates egg yolk."
To you, maybe.
To me? No. Would it fuck.
I'd have him down the banks and tell him he was talking complete bollocks (when we're talking cock surgery).
"I'm sure your venom towards Evertonians would be welcome on Liverpool forums though"
Don the doyen of decency committing the number one faux pas on this forum? Say it ain't so. It's like Bob Geldof getting caught telling some malnourished kid to sod off and go root through McDonalds rubbish bin if his stomachs rumbling so much. Seen as though you post under the mistaken impression that you should automatically get a free-pass, then I'm quite prepared to let it go. Don't know about Michael and Lyndon like.
60 Posted 02/06/2017 at 15:00:41
I don't want to embarrass you, check the correct thread and you will see who is "lying".
62 Posted 02/06/2017 at 15:08:43
My comment is taken from #232 which I will repeat for your benefit: 'The most obvious example, in terms of true centralisation of stats, was in the Leicester's model and Walsh's influence.'
It does not correspond with your lie, namely: 'You claimed that Leicester had signed the likes of Vardy and Marhrez on their stats alone! No mention of Walsh.'
I don't understand why someone caught in lie then seeks to compound it with a subsequent lie. What to hear something amazing, Darren you can admit when you are wrong or have made a mistake.
I don't think anyone is under any conception that errors can't be made and apologies can't be given. What I can't understand is why you continue with the lie when I've shown that it is false. It's really poor behaviour, especially when it takes the place of actual debate and discussion. I'm not inventing your position don't invent mine.
64 Posted 02/06/2017 at 15:13:49
Leicester and Southampton finished above us for the first time in many supporters' lifetimes. You portraying them as somehow bigger because we poached a couple of their staff is riseable. We dwarf both of those clubs and took their staff because we could. Make no mistake, if any of the teams above us wanted them, we would not be in the reckoning.
I didn't bring TV funds into the equation, it may have escaped your blinkered view, but they have been there for years.
Now once again, I will issue the challenge: You berated David Barks saying his opinion was myopic and pessimistic. Can you tell him where he was wrong facts, not half-baked opinion and a few carefully selected stats.
You've had one try and failed.
65 Posted 02/06/2017 at 15:33:03
Also, given that Southampton finished above us the season before, the lifetime of that supporter would have to be a year. But you are right, for infants of less than 1 year old, Southampton finishing above Everton in 15-16 would have been the first in their lifetime.
Honestly can you just go away? I enjoy having debates with people who can construct an argument it is like smashing my head against a wall with you. If you don't even know that Southampton finished above us two years in a row, then what is the point?
And unbelievably, football moves on. Taking Walsh from a title winning Leicester side, after much acclaim for the scouting set-up he masterminded, is a great achievement. It would take only the most pig-headed ignorance to deny otherwise.
But then...
66 Posted 02/06/2017 at 15:39:54
You really don't help yourself do you?
As I have suggested before, you appear intent on claiming the title of TW's Dunning-Kruger Effect poster boy.
Like many an ill-informed alehouse lawyer, you loudly shout your (more-often-than-not dumb) opinions looking for any takers, then when you are challenged or get a response you don't like, you suddenly become Violet Elizabeth Bott.
And to anyone (who gives a shit) I'll prove it using this very thread.
In # 28, it is you who accuse John Daley of having 'no point' (nb: he had made no comment to or about you before this post).
He responded as he was entitled to, as his point (as I indicated # 30) was obvious (from Jupiter) to Lennie Peters.
Even though everyone (but you) could see it, he explained exactly where/what the point is.
So did you respond with "Actually I've just re-read it and yes there was clearly a point, my apologies"?
No, instead (no doubt arms wide, hurt look) you whine and whinge "What did I say? God you can't even express your opinion without..." blah blah.
I think Edward Lear put it best when he said..
A young ToffeeWebber named Don,
Posted nonsense lacking style or aplomb.
He could give but not take,
Like a fragile snowflake,
Certainly not like our manager Ron
67 Posted 02/06/2017 at 16:08:08
It is only liars who feel they don't have to tell the whole truth.
Recognise this sentence? "Kante and Mahrez stand out as primary examples of how stats can influence playing recruitment. Their story is a real Moneyball"
Just thought I would show you that anybody can select a few stats and snippets of conversation to put forward an argument. Very few would select them in order to brand another person a liar... I wouldn't have thought many would be daft enough. This was on a thread where you repeatedly returned to champion the wisdom of using stats.
I would be interested to see where you learned that Leicester used stats in order to sign these players.
Oh and BTW – I said Leicester AND Southampton... see that? Notice the word in caps? ... Did they both finish above us besides last season? No? if you'd have read it the first time, you would have avoided looking silly with your "one-year-old fan" nonsense.
Southampton did not finish above us because they have suddenly become giants. The finished above us because we had a dressing room in disarray led by a manager who had lost the plot. So stop this idiotic "we tempted them from bigger clubs".
It not only appears you carefully select the half-story stats you put up, but you also select the words you read... thus getting half a story
I think the comments David Barks put up there still stand unchallenged.
68 Posted 02/06/2017 at 16:23:08
An ambitious transfer window is required with some top quality additions otherwise it is just more of the same. Lots of perceived promise but very little action.
Perhaps that is one of the reasons why Lukaku and Barkley are allegedly seeking pastures new.
69 Posted 02/06/2017 at 16:25:49
I remember tonking QPR in the rain as well Sure it was October and we were in that stupid open end. Think it was the day Latch got 4 and we all agree got one
Could be wrong cos it was 41 years ago But I'm sure you get my drift. I'll look it up on YouTube when I get out the bath...
70 Posted 02/06/2017 at 16:32:03
When I followed the Blues away, from 1953 to the 1980s, it wasn't all about the match, there was always plenty going on and I never got all that upset about results, although they always counted.
Maybe it's just Kenwright and the phoney world he lives in that makes me write a post about him; when he comes out with his rubbish,I should just ignore him, but he is hard to ignore and so was his piece about the players and how they appreciated the fans.
Mark, I hope we both have happier days in the future even if mine will mostly be at Goodison Park and The Bramley-Moore Dock, or whatever it will be called.
71 Posted 02/06/2017 at 16:39:24
What you call gullibility, the rest of us would probably see as a balanced, rational assessment of our possibilities (and yes, a bit of perpetual hope). The club is making progress, in smaller steps than we would like, but it will never be enough for the band of dignitas divas on this site. What have the Romans ever done for us, eh?
72 Posted 02/06/2017 at 16:43:50
'The most obvious example, in terms of true centralisation of stats, was in the Leicester's model and Walsh's influence. Kante and Mahrez stand out as primary examples of how stats can influence player recruitment. There story was a real Moneyball story.'
You stated, clearly, that: 'YOU claimed that Leicester had signed the likes of Vardy and Marhrez on their stats alone! No mention of Walsh.'
Why don't you just admit it? You can't say I didn't mention someone, when I clearly did, as I have on numerous occasions.
As for stats, as I've mentioned before, I have experience in scouting of their use and EVERY Premier League club uses them to aid player development. I don't know why this keeps having to be said. Leicester have a head of technical scouting ffs (Ollie Waldron) his job is to provide analytical insights he is one of several staff who work in that area. You only need to do a minimal amount of research to find this out. It's not as if this is something hidden from the media various reports illustrate it. This is from a Guardian article from 2014:
'All 20 clubs in the Premier League – and many in the lower divisions – now employ data analysts to make sense of this information. Manchester City has 11 of them. In 2012, Liverpool caused a stir by creating a new position, director of research, for Ian Graham, who has a PhD in theoretical physics. The analysts are involved in pre-match preparation and post-game debriefs; they help to identify transfer targets and devise strategies for nurturing young players through the ranks.'
Link: https://www.theguardian.com/football/2014/mar/09/premier-league-football-clubs-computer-analysts-managers-data-winning
This is from a rather simplistic article in the Daily Mail, that does not go into the ideas much, but provides a basis:
'Leicester's statistical scouts analysed key metrics of midfielders in Europe's top five leagues — interceptions, tackles and forward passes per 90 minutes — and some big names featured. Xabi Alonso, Toni Kroos and Lassana Diarra.
Leicester focused on realistic targets. A Brazilian called Allan, who moved from Udinese to Napoli last summer, was considered, but Kante stood out because when background checks were made, his name appeared on a club report already filed.
A Leicester scout had been to see Caen in the months prior to this search and Kante was picked out.
Combined with positive video analysis using clips from Wyscout, the company that films huge numbers of games across Europe, and the discovery that Kante had never suffered a significant injury, the evidence was aligning.
Next was to send Walsh, who likes to see all incoming players in the flesh, and David Mills, Leicester's chief scout, to watch Kante in Ligue 1. Safe to say, they were impressed.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-3572087/Leicester-s-secrets-Premier-League-title-success-Appoint-right-manager-scout-good-players-ahead-technology.html#ixzz4irL6T2d1
Wyscout, the company mentioned, does far more than providing video clips. This is from a Skysports article:
as they look to unearth the next Riyad Mahrez or assess whether a South American starlet could cut it in the Premier League, their task has been made easier by Wyscout, a cutting-edge video and networking platform which has changed the landscape of player recruitment and scouting over the last decade.
Wyscout offers comprehensive video coverage and detailed statistical analysis of thousands of players in 80 countries worldwide, with a team of 200 analysts who accumulate data from 1300 matches per week for a rapidly expanding database which is used by some of the most prestigious clubs in the world.
http://www.skysports.com/football/news/11096/10120950/wyscout-the-scouting-tool-used-by-arsenal-manchester-united-and-others
Could you please just read these, so we don't have this argument anymore. You can attack stats if you wish, but you cannot ignore that every Premier League club uses them to aid in player acquisition, training, and development. There is even technology now being used which records players' actions on the pitch and in training, and tracks various signifiers.
73 Posted 02/06/2017 at 16:45:29
75 Posted 02/06/2017 at 17:09:46
As good a record as Walsh has for recruiting some very good players, I always think the manager should be the person highlighting targets for Walsh and his team to check out, rather than the other way round, so it seems that Walsh is identifying players and hoping to convince Koeman that they are right for Everton.
The fact that there is no mutual agreement between the two of them is very worrying. Let's face it if the team perform badly then it will be Koeman who will carry the can. So for me he should be the person selecting what player to buy not the director of football. I have never understood what is the point of a director of football and this highlights the problem.
76 Posted 02/06/2017 at 17:14:31
77 Posted 02/06/2017 at 17:21:19
The article about Walsh talks about how they have been doing analysis and due diligence on players on an ongoing basis and have been working actively since January on this window. He also says the department is 'large'. So we are no different to other clubs, although I don't know how much this happened before Walsh.
We recently headhunted an analyst from Forest Green.
Discussions with Koeman have also been ongoing apparently and targets are always agreed on. Hopefully the list was compiled on an ongoing basis and passed on to the appropriate people to start work on recruitment.
Time will tell.
The article was on the OS yesterday and I'm not sure if the Echo published it in totality
79 Posted 02/06/2017 at 17:22:01
Perhaps, Ronald feels a little bit like Homer Simpson at times?
80 Posted 02/06/2017 at 17:23:20
Although now, with such a wide and complex scouting system, it's common for staff to recommend players to the manager. Walsh's comments seem relatively reconcilable, in that respect, even if he has a certain force of opinion:
'We've got a large team of people working with me and I collate a lot of information from them.
“My department is very well run, very organised and we make sure we get as much information about the player that we possibly can. If we like the player, I've got to try to convince Ronald that he's the player for us.
“It could well be that Ronald has seen the player as well, so it's a collective decision at the end of the day.â€
Let's hope that they agree, and that we can welcome a few exciting players in before August. Earlier than latter is always better - a full pre-season surely helps new acquisitions bed in.
83 Posted 02/06/2017 at 17:32:39
I thought it was rather strange that we have headhunted an analyst from Forest Green Rovers, they were a non-league outfit till 2 weeks ago. Is this the best we can do?
Seems these days there are people analyzing everything. Whatever happened to the manager running the club? I can well imagine the response that Clough or Stein or Shankly or Paisley or Ferguson would have said about a Director of Football. Something maybe along the lines of "Well, if they are that good, give them the manager's job."
I can't think of too many of these Directors of fFootball who had much successful influence. I know Daniel Commoli was sacked from Spurs and Liverpool, don't know how much he was paid but doesn't seem like it was money well spent.
85 Posted 02/06/2017 at 17:43:08
86 Posted 02/06/2017 at 17:43:20
For instance, the oft quoted statistic of pass-completion rate. This will tell me that players like Tom Cleverley are good at retaining possession. However, my eyes tell me that this type of player gets the ball and gives it to the nearest man. Who can't play football like that? You receive the ball, pass it back whence it came and get a 100% pass-completion rate.
You never beat a man, go round a player, split the defence, you just "keep it simple". Put three players like this in your midfield and you have no creativity, no goal threat and will ultimately win nothing.
I don't judge players by their stats; I don't judge them by how well they can turn it on against teams like Bournemouth at Goodison either. I judge them by how they compete at places like Anfield, Stamford Bridge, Old Trafford, White Hart Lane or the Emirates. If they continually resemble rabbits-in-headlights, go missing, and show no character or ability, then they are not good enough for Everton FC.
Until we stop being sentimental and retaining players who wouldn't make the bench at the teams that regularly finish above us (eg, Mirallas) then we'll always be also-rans. We need to start recruiting players who have the spirit and ability that this club once prided itself on. I'm not having it that only mega-bucks can recruit such players. Unless we raise the bar of what is acceptable for our club (players, fans, management) we will always be "plucky old Everton", "best of the rest", etc.
87 Posted 02/06/2017 at 17:47:23
They got promoted so maybe he has some sort of reputation. How well you can analyse stats doesn't necessarily depend on how big the employer is I guess.
I think the football world has changed since those days when recruitment was often local, English or Scottish / Irish.
These days it's worldwide and some sort of sifting seems necessary, or to find hidden gems as in Moneyball I guess. Although the quality of analysis seems variable, for example, when Liverpool bought that grock from Newcastle for 㿏m. Was that on Commoli's watch?
There is a potential for conflict, depending on the personalities involved, such as Benitez and Carr at Newcastle seemingly, but Koeman has recently said he's comfortable working in that structure. Wenger, on the other hand, isn't.
88 Posted 02/06/2017 at 17:49:57
That's why a person wouldn't just look at one statistic in a vacuum. They would analyze that pass completion percentage in combination with total passes per game, distance, beating a man, key passes and assists, and on and on. Analyitics are important in every single walk of life and only getting more important.
90 Posted 02/06/2017 at 18:03:28
Stats are there to aid decisions but not make the decisions, and they have to be contextualised. There is not enough manpower to watch every division and every player multiple times – certain stats might allow a team to identify certain targets, and then follow them up in person, and subject them to more vigorous analysis. They can't determine how a player will gel in a different league, or cope with a different style of football with a different manager, but they can give certain ideas that will help.
For example, Kante's and Gueye's tackling and interceptions stats (along with others) were superb in France and that contributed to the purchase of players that could have been missed otherwise. They both continued to perform in the Premier League, and Kante notably finished his maiden season with the most tackles and interceptions per games (as well as a good level of high-intensity sprints), which enforced what most football fans and pundits could see – Kante was a wonderful tackler, who was crucial to winning possession and starting counter-attacks.
It's far to say that most clubs in the world would be interested in Kante now, but they were not when Leicester signed him for less than ٤ million.
94 Posted 02/06/2017 at 18:16:31
Seeing as the team did okay and not much more, with the possibility of losing two key players and not a new signing on the immediate horizon, it would seem that many outsiders would believe that Evertonians are particularly gullible.
Or, as I see it, extremely loyal and hopeful.
95 Posted 02/06/2017 at 18:18:23
I love evidence. The problem I have with stats is that we don't always see the context and we usually get the stats that suit the statistician's argument. Or we get what's easy to measure more often than what's important.
So for me, stats are useful, but the tail shouldn't wag the dog. I'm with Paul Kealy. Wish I could write like him, punt like him and drink like him!
96 Posted 02/06/2017 at 18:18:26
GULLIBLE BASTARDS!! um...like me.
97 Posted 02/06/2017 at 18:23:11
I live near Old Brighton nowadays but I'm waiting for my lovely missus to grow old and wrinkly so I have an excuse to come home and reclaim my season ticket in my dotage!
98 Posted 02/06/2017 at 18:27:49
Nevertheless, I have to say from a personal perspective of someone who has followed the Blues since 1960 and seen the greats (players, managers, and the great Sir John Moore), the not so greats (players, managers and Kenwright) I am fully behind the Moshiri - Koeman - Walsh ticket and can already see progress.
As Jim said, we have to be patient and supportive of the time it takes to turn a sinking ship into a world class cruiseliner – especially when at least 6 other clubs have more wealth, media popularity and recent success.
It took Spurs at least 10 years of constant investment and reinvestment just to get 2nd so far from accepting mediocrity we have to be realistic as well as ambitious.
We will return to the top but it will take time and a hell of a lot of support from the terraces.
99 Posted 02/06/2017 at 18:30:43
100 Posted 02/06/2017 at 18:31:14
Also glad that our season tickets have been sold. I feel that a lot of us are hopeful under the new regime, even if we've been let down a lot in recent years.
I'm looking forward to European football again at Goodison, especially when it gets interesting in the latter stages! (Assuming we get there, of course.)
102 Posted 02/06/2017 at 18:53:44
I understand that threads can take directions - and should do - but this is just plain ridiculous and I note on here and I am sure I speak for the majority when I see that this is not just tiresomely dull but maligns the excellent reputation of ToffeeWeb and its editors
I suspect that one reason a thread is 'hi-jacked' like this is that people bored to feck do not see the point in posting not least with the hideous image of a 1,000 word epic post aimed back at them. by, well you all know the identity of the sultan of length on here.
Can we please put a stop to this. This is not denying free speech. Its denying a moribund level of repetitive one-man-upmanship that harms the otherwise top quality of ToffeeWeb and I suspect makes more than a few roll their eyes when a particular name appears on the right hand side in the same thread 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15 times.
Editorial Team
104 Posted 02/06/2017 at 19:01:45
105 Posted 02/06/2017 at 19:12:05
106 Posted 02/06/2017 at 19:47:13
My Mrs recently asked me why I bother, why I get so worked up, why I let a bad result upset me so much. She couldn't understand why it meant so much. So I made the stupid mistake of trying to explain it in terms she could fathom very easily. I said:
"You know how I was previously married before we met?"
"Yes," she said, "though I fail to see what that's got to do with it."
Instead of feigning a stroke or something, I carried on: "Well I got divorced, met you, fell in love with you and we married, yeh?"
" Yeeeees...." she said.
"Well, if we were to split up for whatever reason, it wouldn't be beyond the realms of possibility for either one of us to fall in love with someone else and be happy, would it?"
"No, I suppose not, " she said, "but what's your point?"
"My point is that, while I could love, fall out of love, and marry more than one woman in my lifetime, I could never love another club other than Everton."
That's what it means! She took it well; I know this because she even started to make me her "special soup" soon after. The healthy one that makes me lose weight. I'm down to four stone in no time at all!
107 Posted 02/06/2017 at 19:51:13
"My Mrs recently asked me why I bother, why I get so worked up, why I let a bad result upset me so much. She couldn't understand why it meant so much."
For a moment, I thought you were about to take us into bedroom matters...
108 Posted 02/06/2017 at 20:08:47
109 Posted 02/06/2017 at 20:13:33
110 Posted 02/06/2017 at 20:19:18
111 Posted 03/06/2017 at 01:34:53
Three men smash up house and car
113 Posted 03/06/2017 at 06:55:15
I have reluctant faith in the new owner and manager, but Kenwright the bad apple is still there controlling transfers. The key to Everton's success is about how little Moshiri listens to Bill or better still buys all his shares.
114 Posted 03/06/2017 at 07:57:41
115 Posted 03/06/2017 at 08:07:02
Excellent post. I agree with all of your comments. It is not preventing free speech nor a form of censorship, but it had become tiresome and tedious.
116 Posted 03/06/2017 at 08:37:07
117 Posted 03/06/2017 at 09:10:04
Good luck to you in the future, hope you enjoy watching Everton where ever we play.
118 Posted 03/06/2017 at 12:31:28
As much as I bitch and moan about our players/team over the years and as much as I may threaten to not renew my season ticket, it's just never an option to not go to the game.
I approach every new season with the same optimism and hope that finally this may be our year. That we may at last win something again and to miss that, well it doesn't bear thinking about.
Gullible? No, just typical football fans who are full of hope.
119 Posted 03/06/2017 at 15:50:18
120 Posted 03/06/2017 at 16:16:18
121 Posted 03/06/2017 at 17:04:09
122 Posted 08/06/2017 at 08:36:35
If my eight year old neice had written this then I'd be thinking "I hope she's gifted at maths, 'cos her English Lang/Lit is terrible".
Please don't pen any more, or if you do, then please don't submit them. This is embarrassment enough.
Scott, you are the Glen Keeley of Everton Poetry.
123 Posted 08/06/2017 at 08:47:52
(I'll get me coat and go to vote.)
124 Posted 09/06/2017 at 05:08:14
Read this thread a little late but have been right through it. I don't take the Bill thing personally, it's standard corporate fare, structured thanks. It's not meant to touch hearts so much as prevent criticism of its absence.
The claws-out arguments in the thread: doesn't bother me, I'd just skip if it did but I see the point that it can maybe frustrate some/new readers. Why not move them to a fight zone "Posts placed in Snarl Room by editor". Best of both worlds.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 01/06/2017 at 17:09:54
It is Kenwright at his vomit-inducing best, he lists all the staff from himself, Koeman, Moshiri have been blown away by the away support and finishes that paragraph by saying "And believe me, every single player who has pulled on that famous Royal Blue jersey this season understands and appreciates the efforts you go to for our Club."
Well why didn't they fuckin' show it on the pitch?