Before today, David Moyes’s reunions with the club where he spent 11 reputation-building years had been exercises in routine and, often, comprehensive defeat. Beaten home and away as manager of Manchester United four seasons ago, the Scot had the same treatment meted out to him as manager of Sunderland last season and he was handed his heaviest defeat against Everton last November when the Blues romped to a 4-0 win under David Unsworth.
Add to that the fact that in the Premier League era, West Ham are Everton’s favourite opponents, throw in an essentially meaningless end-of-season game and you had the ingredients for an occasion where even Sam Allardyce could throw caution to the wind and go for it a bit. Stop laughing at the back.
The much-maligned manager did finally experiment with two strikers, although their lack of experience playing together, West Ham’s first-half dominance and Everton’s crippling lack of creativity meant that they weren’t able to link up like a genuine strike partnership at any stage. In any case, Allardcye largely nullified any nod towards attacking adventure by deploying three centre-halves and two holding midfielders and if the intent was to release Leighton Baines and Seamus Coleman to conduct raids down the flanks, it didn’t work.
The result was a performance that mostly made the Hammers, who began the day in 15th place, look a significantly better team than their record and recently averted crisis suggests they are and, eventually, resulted in a defeat that may have seemed harsh when comparing chances created but which was wholly deserved on the balance of play.
Indeed, in the first period in particular, all the “joined up” football was coming from the home team, with the visitors largely reliant on direct balls forward and attempted penetrating passes from deep. West Ham were next to bottom when Allardyce came on board at Goodison and while has spent the last few months moaning that his team can’t play with style because of the players at his disposal, Moyes has seemingly got on with the job of getting his side playing some pretty decent football.
With the Hammers moving the ball around crisply in midfield and Mario Lanzini and Marco Arnautovic buzzing around purposefully in forward areas, Everton’s three central defenders betrayed their unfamiliarity with the formation and were opened up after 10 minutes by a neat interchange.
Arnautovic had seconds earlier seen his first shot in anger blocked well by Michael Keane but after the Hammers retrieved the ball, he played Mark Noble in close to goal with a one-two pass. The midfielder’s side-foot shot searching for the corner was stopped brilliantly and one-handed, however, by Jordan Pickford.
After Joao Mario had flashed a shot an inch wide of the post in the 26th minute, Moyes’s side almost shot themselves in the foot just past the half-hour mark. Angelo Ogbonna mis-controlled badly an up-and-under clearance by Phil Jagielka allowing Oumar Niasse to rob him of the ball and drive into the penalty area towards Adrian. The Senegalese striker elected to go shoot towards his near post and the goalkeeper made the save with his out-stretched leg.
It was a miss that the Blues would rue seven minutes later when Lanzini capitalised on embarrassing defending to give West Ham the lead. An innocuous-looking pass from Cheikhou Kouyaté deceived Keane as it eluded the toe of Arnautovic and Lanzini, who had started the move near the halfway line continued his run between two blue shirts to pick up the loose ball and slot home.
Allardyce responded at half time by withdrawing Ramiro Funes Mori, who had done nothing to suggest he has been hard done-by by being excluded from the starting XI since he regained his fitness, and introducing Davy Klaassen into a midfield that now boasted four central midfielders and no width.
It resulted in more possession for Everton but precious little service to the strikers or threats to the Hammers’ goal apart from a tame effort from Klaassen from around 20 yards out that Adrian claimed easily. Instead of taking one of the midfielders off and going for a more attacking formation, however, Allardyce stuck to type hooked Cenk Tosun when it came time to throw Theo Walcott on, much to the Turk’s visible disgust.
His fury was probably matched by most Blues fans; as a decision it made no sense under the circumstances. As the goals that were raining in on the other side of London at Wembley in one of those wild final-day goal-fests that happen every now and then ably demonstrated, what on earth was there to lose in just going all out for goals?
Two minutes later, it was 2-0 from a goal largely out of nothing. Picking up a pass in a benign area outside the Everton box, Arnautovic simply rolled Keane who was too tight and too slow to recover and smashed a shot practically through Pickford’s gloves from 25 yards. The replays aren’t kind to the young goalkeeper who appeared to crouch expecting the ball to dip towards the ground before it lifted slightly at the end and flew past him.
Niasse gave Everton hope 11 minutes later, however. Having seen a strong shot of his own beaten onto the post and out by Adrian after he’d collected an excellent flighted ball down the channel by Klaassen, the striker was on hand with some deft control and an emphatic finish to make it 2-1 from the ensuing corner.
Morgan Schneiderlin looped a header back into the six-yard box where a Aaron Cresswell got a head to it but Niasse quickly flicked it back towards goal, swivelled and rapped it in almost on the goal line with 16 minutes to.
The hosts restored their two-goal advantage and effectively sealed the game eight minutes later, however, shortly after Jagielka had done enough to put Pablo Zabaleta off in front of goal so that he swiped the ball wide rather than make it 3-1.
Lanzini was the marksman again, profiting from the yard or two’s space afforded him by Coleman at the corner of the area and curling a shot towards the top right corner. Pickford went for it with his opposite hand and got fingers to it but could only guide it onto the post and in.
Everton had a late flurry where they threatened to make a game of it again when Walcott found himself in but was denied by Adrian and the ‘keeper was quick to react to Niasse’s follow-up and bat it away to safety as well.
So an awful season, forgettable in almost every way except for the stain it will have left on the Blues’ Premier League era, one already blemished by two scrapes with relegation, is finally out the way.
The threat of the drop, to the extent that it existed with 24 matches left in the campaign, was largely extinguished fairly soon after Allardyce arrived. (It’s hard to believe there were 12 teams worse than Everton, the paucity of quality in the top flight rendering a finish as high as eighth flattering in the extreme.) The interim has been a frustrating succession of dull performances, moribund football, lifeless defeats to the teams that finished above, and a near constant yearning for 2017-18 to be over.
Now that it is, the club’s hieraerchy can hopefully start making the key decisions – starting with the removal of the manager – that will ensure that next season is nothing like what has just transpired. As a fanbase, patience is being replaced by apathy but it’s by no means irretrievable. Another big summer awaits if those in the corridors of power are ready to take the bull by the horns and steer it in the right direction.
Reader Comments (30)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
1 Posted 14/05/2018 at 08:32:48
It's two years since the man took over and all in all its been an absolute disaster. Yes, I know the stadium is in place (we hope) and the Club's finances are on an even keel but the macro view of Everton Football Club is shambolic, and I fear it may get worse.
This is where we get to see his metal and his ability to steer a juggernaut with more burst tyres than we all dare count. One by one he needs to sort each issue out and turn the thing around.
I guess we will all know if he's the right man for Everton by the end of August.
2 Posted 14/05/2018 at 08:42:12
Bit of an eye opener to be honest and everyone should have a read of it. Gives as true a view as possible of what supporters of other premiership teams think of our club.
3 Posted 14/05/2018 at 08:43:06
4 Posted 14/05/2018 at 09:32:22
Let's not forget the high quality football we were playing during the first part of the season with our 3 number 10's. We have been playing dreadful football for a long time!
Sam Allardyce, was hired because of our horrific start to the season, when he arrived we were out of contention for a top six place, out of the League Cup and humiliated in Europe.
Given, the above, I can't see how the removal of the current manager guarantees us anything for the season ahead. Hopefully, we will be lucky in our choice of a new manager and that the new man can improve the current squad and have better luck with his acquisitions, however, its a bloated and mediocre squad and there is a lot of work to be done.
I wish the new man well and promise not to get on his back during his first year in the job.
5 Posted 14/05/2018 at 09:48:55
(1) most seemed to think we'd done good transfer business with Pickford (understandable) and Keane (what went wrong?) singled out for special mention,
(2) Tom Davies (followed by Seamus) was our most admired player,
(3) Ross Barkley was our most disliked player with many feeling he was/is over-rated, and,
(4) virtually everyone was spectacularly wrong over their relegation tips with no-one at all picking Stoke or WBA! Only one person had Swansea as a definite with two suggesting them as possible. Perhaps illustrates that outside the Sky Six, mediocrity plays on a level field!
Maybe I should have added a fifth - most seem to like us!
6 Posted 14/05/2018 at 09:57:41
7 Posted 14/05/2018 at 10:29:01
Better than nothing - but clearly we haven't been as fortunate as Chelsea or City . We seem to be more in the West Ham and Leicester tier financially - maybe Tottenham at a push.
8 Posted 14/05/2018 at 10:31:32
Martin, the things that stood out for me were; next to nobody expected us to finish above seventh.
This makes me wonder "Are we as deluded as some claim we are expecting to be challenging the top four? Nobody else expects it. Do we need a reality check?
(Devil's advocate there).
The other one that stood out was the fact that all of the other supporters had Burnley for the drop.
9 Posted 14/05/2018 at 10:43:26
First to admit that the players attitude and application has been at times shameful. But that is what happens when they dont respect the manager and his approach. Both Koeman and Allardyce lost the dressing room and proved to be two of the worst managers in our long history.
10 Posted 14/05/2018 at 10:51:54
The performances all season have been poor and the responsibility for same rests principally with Koeman. He spent the money. He did not replace Rom with a like for like.
11 Posted 14/05/2018 at 11:11:11
You're probably right about us as fans being 'deluded' but I suppose that's what's kept the turnstiles clicking over the last five years. Of course the gap between the top clubs and ourselves is large and has grown larger in the last five years, a combination of their having better players and our ineptness on and off the pitch.
Moshiri was probably misguided in his thinking or at least badly advised, that the signing of a shed-load of players would be an easy fix, that would bridge the gap between 7th and the higher places, particularly as at the same time, he oversaw the loss of the better players, Lukaku, Stones et al.
What the last five years has shown, is that Everton FC lacked a proper foundation for the football side of the club, for good or ill, the whole thing was predicated upon the ability of the manager, a decent, dedicated manager such as David Moyes, was able to cope with any financial restrictions, and he was able to coax regular good performances from mostly average players.
Since then each manager has arrived and failed to get consistent performances from the players as individuals and there is no semblence of a team out on the pitch and there hasn't been for a good while.
We are all waiting for the club to be run better than it has been in the last couple of decades, perhaps, it was inevitable that we would have to witness it going backwards, before it moves forwards. If things on and off the pitch don't improve soon though, we could be on a devastating downward spiral.
The team on the pitch, for me at least, mirrors the way the boardroom has been and is operating, there is no sense that each individual is pulling in the same direction, each it seems is persuing their own selfish agenda, there is no obvious leader, there are too many confused signals leading to much muddled thinking and rank poor decisions.
Until that fault-line is addressed and until somebody actually takes ownership of the football side of the club, we face more of the same in the foreseeable future and any dreams we have for the team, will be seen from the outside at least, as delusional.
12 Posted 14/05/2018 at 11:16:45
Couldn't have put it better myself mate, spot on.
13 Posted 14/05/2018 at 12:17:57
14 Posted 14/05/2018 at 12:42:34
When you are losing games to Soton 1-4 and West Ham 1-3 you know you have a poor side.
Allardyce should face up to the truth that he is not a good manager and do the right thing-quit !!!
Next season will just be more of the same if he stays even with new signings. He just has no idea about inspiring a squad to better things.
15 Posted 14/05/2018 at 13:29:00
Well said Lyndon - now we pray for a Silva lining.
16 Posted 14/05/2018 at 13:31:09
17 Posted 14/05/2018 at 13:35:34
Actually I find it quite comforting.
18 Posted 14/05/2018 at 13:36:35
19 Posted 14/05/2018 at 13:50:39
20 Posted 14/05/2018 at 15:53:59
That to me says the players are mirroring the manager not the board.
21 Posted 14/05/2018 at 18:11:15
A top 4 place is there for the taking next season if we have a positive and sensible manager in place who will do the right things.
The signing of a couple of influential players. continuity, a settled team with a back 4 and we will be fine.
22 Posted 14/05/2018 at 18:26:31
23 Posted 14/05/2018 at 18:29:48
We're Everton, we have won more titles than Chelsea, in fact we have won more titles than City, Spurs and Leicester put together. Some of these clubs have spent a century trying to get above us and think they are there for keeps . .We'll see about that
We have to get our house in order for sure, but we wont do that by listening to where others feel we belong, especially those ex players in the media who didn't win a carrot when they were playing themselves
24 Posted 14/05/2018 at 18:37:49
A 2017/18 summary using a myriad of adjectives used in TW headlines throughout the season.
‘ A season in adjectives ‘
Depressing, Woeful, Awful, Abject, Dreadful,confused, lacklustre,disappointing,crumbling,terrible, succumb,wasteful,inconsistent,unimaginative, slaughter, shocked,struggle, poor,shambolic,humiliated, capitulation, ugly, beleaguered, damaging, dismal slump
Just about sums it up Id say.
25 Posted 14/05/2018 at 18:44:11
26 Posted 14/05/2018 at 21:27:35
27 Posted 14/05/2018 at 22:32:29
28 Posted 14/05/2018 at 00:25:51
Er, no, no it is not. Have you seen his record since leaving us?
29 Posted 15/05/2018 at 14:02:16
Very difficult to blame players attempting to make sense out of a 1st half back 3 system which does not suit us. Yes, Allardyce must tke the blame especially after S'ton the week before. Funes comes in having had little time on the pitch in a back 3 and gets unfairly criticised.
If Sam goes, let us give him credit for what he has done, we were in a very bad situation when he came, despite us being in 13th (thanks to the 4 0 win). I didn't hear many dissenting voices and realy the only other choice was probably Unsy who I like but it was obviously too early for him.
Alistair is correct, let's not panic, we have a good squad of players but fair enough we have high expectations. we do not have the Premier league history of Man City, United, Arsenal and Chelsea ad nauseum but we can bulid on our squad. No problem with Moyes but Wenger good, Please not the divi from watford.
30 Posted 15/05/2018 at 14:13:30
Did anyone see Moyes' "the grass isn't greener comments"? He was talking about players wanting moves. Talk about the kettle calling the pot black.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.