The Mail Bag

Let's see how loyal the players are...

Comments (16)

Some of our players are young, and will have many seasons left in them. Some are at their peak (Arteta, Jags, Yak), and some have peaked and won't have too many more goes (Saha, Neville - stop cheering at the back).

So, in a variation of YADM, would you call the players together and say, right lads, we're not going to qualify for Europe next season. The Europa league is too much effort for too little gain. Therefore, are you all willing to forgo one season of European football, travelling to far flung places like BATE, Kharkiv etc. to really push for top 4 in 2010/2011?

With a fit squad, full pre-season / preparation, we go all out on the assault.

(This is where my plan goes fanciful). The Board will provide a reasonable transfer fund, and commensurate increase in wage budget, on the understanding that the nucleus of the squad remains in place. We'll also go all out for the domestic cups.

Would people go for that? It's hypothetical I know, but following on from Keiran's email - would give game time to some of the other fringe players, and a chance for some experience.

I know many have enjoyed the European Goodison nights, and trips abroad, but until there's a re-evaluation of the worth of the CL and Europa, we've got to focus on that surely?
Matt Traynor, Singapore     Posted 01/03/2010 at 04:17:08

back Return to the Mail Bag

Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Andy Fletcher
1   Posted 01/03/2010 at 11:16:17

Report abuse

We will qualify via the Intertoto cup ;-)
Kieran Fitzgerald
2   Posted 01/03/2010 at 11:08:29

Report abuse

The Europa League was always just about prestige and us fans getting to enjoy some european nights after years of a drought. We always knew Matt that the prize money wasn’t the issue. The prestige always comes at the latter stages of the tournament when the big clubs are involved and there is more attention focused on the competition.

The last two seasons we have been very poor in the competition and there has been very little prestige to be had. Some of the games this season have been horrendous on the fans. Well known clubs like Benfica and Sporting this season, and Standard last season have made us look to be very poor.I for one would not be too saddened if we didn’t qualify for next year’s tournament.

I think you’re right about getting the players on board. As fans, myself included, we could accept not playing in what is a much lesser competition if it meant being able to focus on bigger prizes and more chance of success, but would the players go for this?

I think the funding will play a part as getting quality players in during the August window would signal a certain intent on the club’s part to the existing squad.

For me, the biggest part of this theory would be which players would Moyes be prepared to sell in order to raise the cash. But, as mentioned in comments to my post, of the expendable players that fans would list, who would Moyes have the nerve to sell?

I think we do have the squad to make a concerted push for the bigger prizes, with one or two additions and more focus. Time will tell though.
Tommy Coleman
3   Posted 01/03/2010 at 11:52:28

Report abuse

"Preparation" ?

I don’t think so, not if the last two summers are anything to go on.

Moyes likes the Europa, he thinks his players do also so the team will be going for it.
Kunal Desai
4   Posted 01/03/2010 at 12:05:41

Report abuse

Teams that finish 3rd in the Champions league group stage go into the Europa league. Why?? Surely if you go out of any competition then that means you go out!
This is why ehe Europa league is made a complete mockery and that the governing body FIFA haven’t got a clue when it comes to devising any club/country competition.
Dan Brierley
5   Posted 01/03/2010 at 12:01:43

Report abuse

Finishing Place Prize Money awarded 2008/2009:

1. Manchester United £15,220,000
2. Liverpool £14,459,000
3. Chelsea £13,698,000
4. Arsenal £12,937,000
5. Everton £12,176,000
6. Aston Villa £11,415,000
7. Fulham £10,654,000
8. Tottenham £9,893,000
9. West Ham £9,132,000
10. Manchester City £8,371,000
11. Stoke City £7,610,000

I think its a no-brainer to be honest. You’ve got to finish as high as you possibly can. Our turnover is going to be nearly 4 million down if we end up in 10th. Thats not taking into account the extra revenue we got through the FA cup last season. Europe provides income, experience, co-efficient improvement, incentive for new players to join, extra chance of silverware. This is why all clubs want to be playing European Football.
Mike McLean
6   Posted 01/03/2010 at 13:27:57

Report abuse

As Dan kinda says, the Europa might have benefits but the bottom line for the club has to be to finish as high as possible for the prize money.
Andy Crooks
7   Posted 01/03/2010 at 14:03:44

Report abuse

Dan,what you say is spot on.The difference between one place could be the same as Neils transfer fee.We are cash strapped and every place counts.Until yesterday I still considered 4th place an outside possibility.Well,how wrong can a man be.
The difference between us and the top teams is about consistency.Everton can never be a banker on your fixed odds coupon.We are capable of losing to any one
James I'Anson
8   Posted 01/03/2010 at 14:07:26

Report abuse

So, if we finish 5th we will get about 4.5m more than if we finish 11th.

Who gets that?
Moyes?

A couple of good runs in the cup must be worth something.

Wo got that?
Moyes?

Basically, finishing 17th or 5th obviously makes a massive difference to the club financially but i’m afraid it wont make any difference to the transfer kitty. It never does.

Selling our best players is the only thing that makes any difference to the tranfer funds given to Moyes.
Mike Oates
9   Posted 01/03/2010 at 15:05:21

Report abuse

Pre-season preparation - you must be joking . With up to possible 10 players in World Cup , Jun 11th - Jul 16th , we’ll be lucky to have 10 1st teamers for the first 2-3 weeks of pre-season.

No decent players will want to talk about transfers until late July, possibly early August and I can see the normal poor start again.
Joe McMahon
10   Posted 01/03/2010 at 15:45:11

Report abuse

Mike, The Fro won’t be fit for the start of the new season either. To be honest I just can’t see the past of 4-5-1 at home, never any money to spend, and never winning a trophy until both Moyes & Kenwright piss off, yes thaht’s MOYES. he’s still learning yu know, after 8 years???
Mark Reid
11   Posted 01/03/2010 at 16:55:13

Report abuse

Joe McMahon.

I don’t know where you got that information. The recovery period for the opearation Fellaini had is 12 weeks.

He will be able to run and train on his ankle then.

He just won’t be able to play competitive matches until late June 2010 (the end of the second 12 weeks are to prevent re-injury and so contact will be minimised but he should be able to kick a ball by early June and be in full training end of June).
Ian Smitham
12   Posted 01/03/2010 at 18:05:27

Report abuse

Joe, 4-5-1 at home, bring it on. A central attacker and an attacking midfield going at a flat back four who do not know who to defend against. Last year 4-6-0 was our best formation.

"Never any money to spend" Just wondered where it comes from?

"Never winning a trophy" Er, when did we last do that? One year in 1995, and a brief spell in mid eighties.

As for still learning-when does one stop learning?

Finally, assuming the language gets past the moderators (and God knows why this abusive diatribe is allowed on here), sort the spelling-as you say, "still learning"

Lee Kidd
13   Posted 01/03/2010 at 18:23:26

Report abuse

Everton are still a club that could go the way of Portsmouth if we gambled on Champions League qualification. We simply don’t have the means to set a transfer budget to back it.

We’re going to fall further behind the likes of Aston Villa and Tottenham in the next few years because we don’t have the means to compete. I hope - really, really hope - that the ridiculous economy in football bottoms out so that clubs go back to being run properly and competing on similar means - because are we fuck going to get rid of Kenshite and we’re not going to have a sugar daddy Abrahmovic come in.
Pat Finegan
14   Posted 01/03/2010 at 22:47:09

Report abuse

So you’re saying we should throw the season? We have a chance to get to Europa and thus make a tonne of money so why wouldn’t we? With a squad that is nearly fit (I say nearly because, realistically, we will never be fully fit) we have the ability to play in the Europa league and challenge for a top 4 spot. We need money so we need to qualify.

Now let’s say we don’t play in Europe next year and we make it to the Champions League. The Champions League is much harder than Europa. What if we have an early exit? It’s way too much of a gamble.
Mark Stone
15   Posted 02/03/2010 at 05:52:38

Report abuse

We won’t finish top four next season.

The only ay we could have a pop a top four is through major investment.

No manager, even Ferguson, Mourinho, Ancelotti, Capello or Wenger wouldn’t get us in the top four. And under most managers we’d be in a relegation battle each year.

This opinion is based purely on the money we have to spend.
Conor Ryan
16   Posted 02/03/2010 at 08:55:08

Report abuse

Just a thought but we didn’t actually spend any money last year, we just used the money we got for the sale of forehead.

I’m expecting another big money sale again this year, most likely Fellaini will be sold in a simulary "reluctent" fashion.

So if you take the pre-sale of Lescott transfer kitty that we didn’t need to touch and add it to this years kitty plus the £25mill for Fellaini/Rodders shouldn’t that in theory give us serious buying power in the summer.

Perhaps the long awaited ’superstar’.

ps: I am aware this may be over simplified...

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.



© ToffeeWeb