The Mail Bag

Peanuts

Comments (44)

So according to the dailies Stephen Pienaar is looking for a potential move to a top 4 club so he can play Champions League football. I can't knock any player wanting to move to improve their game or the chance to win trophies. If he went and we managed to get £13 million, who would be the ideal replacement?
Ken Williams, Merseyside     Posted 31/03/2010 at 09:12:23

back Return to the Mail Bag

Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Jamie Rowland
1   Posted 31/03/2010 at 12:44:05

Report abuse

Joao Muitiniho (or whatever his name is) or Steven Defour
Jimmy Changa
2   Posted 31/03/2010 at 13:04:34

Report abuse

He said for £13m, Jamie.
Ciarán McGlone
3   Posted 31/03/2010 at 13:06:41

Report abuse

He wouldn't get a game at any of the big clubs... He's at a club that is about his level.

I could certainly blame him.
Tony McNulty
4   Posted 31/03/2010 at 13:07:29

Report abuse

I have attended several of the London-based supporters’ meetings in the recent past.

When David Moyes came a year or so ago he made it clear that he had originally seen Pienaar as a back-up, but had been delighted how he had come on.

When Bill Kenwright came, in a throw away remark he noted how Arteta had never played as well for other managers as he had for David Moyes.

Thinking about it, with the possible exception of Always-a-Blue Voldemort, has any player improved having left David Moyes’s Everton? Our manager seems to have a knack of spotting people’s strengths and giving them the confidence to play to these strengths. A significant number of players who, although good to average, might have underperformed elsewhere, have improved at Everton. Examples would be: Heitinga; Lescott; Arteta; Pienaar; Jagielka; and even Marcus Bent, and there are many others).

If Pienaar has any sense, he’ll stay where he is.
Mike Elbey
5   Posted 31/03/2010 at 13:08:44

Report abuse

With one year left on his contract there is no way we would get anywhere near £13m for him - we would be lucky to get £5m.

In my opinion, we should keep him for next season whether he signs a contract or not as I believe with him we have a chance of top 4 next season. What we would get for him now wouldn't even pay a year's wages of a decent player.
Tony J Williams
6   Posted 31/03/2010 at 13:22:33

Report abuse

I am with Ciaran on this one. he would possibly get a few cup games with the Arsenal kids. Not good enough for the Champions League sides.

If he wants to do a Shaun Wright Philips, then ta ra lad. Good player that is at his level where he is.
Sean Condon
7   Posted 31/03/2010 at 13:09:24

Report abuse

Ciaran is right, imo. Pienaar will barely play if he goes to Chelsea or City. Heavens Stevie, aren't there enough examples of skilled players going to these clubs and rotting on the bench collecting cobwebs and paycheques? Scott Parker, Wright-Phillips, and even Joe Cole to an extent are but three cases of really fine players (whom you could argue are all in Peanuts' class if not slightly higher) whose form suffered as a result of buying season tickets on Chelsea's bench.

I'm still waiting for the one special player who rejects a big-money move and remains where he's happy. I'm not asking for Steve Bull-level loyalty here, just a demonstration of common sense over blind greed. Somehow, the contradictory Mr Peanuts (woman trouble, too much booze for that petite frame, INSANE love of God) doesn't strike me as such a trailblazer. If only Steven would just stop and ask himself "What would Jesus do?" I'm sure he'd be told by the dude with the white beard that he should stay at Goodison because the trophies are just around the corner.

Awwww, what am I talking about? I wouldn't be surprised if he's already bought a City shirt. I just hope that Moyesie really fucks Gary Cook sideways with a chainsaw on this one. £20 million? Why not? And get it sorted before August for crying out loud.
Shaun Brennan
8   Posted 31/03/2010 at 13:29:03

Report abuse

Could you see him chipping in with the required amount of goals for a midfielder at a top 4 club? I'm with Ciaran too.
Graham Holliday
9   Posted 31/03/2010 at 13:41:27

Report abuse

In my eyes, the only one of Parker, Cole and Wright-Phillips that's in the class of Pienaar is Joe Cole.

I'd hate for Pienaar to go because he and Arteta really are the creative heartbeat of our side. If either one is missing, we don't look the same team.

I've never met the guy so I have no idea if he would want to earn a place in the CL with Everton or jump ship for a side that has already qualified.

But, he seems to play with a smile on his face at Everton, so here's hoping...
Geoff Edwards
10   Posted 31/03/2010 at 13:41:43

Report abuse

He may not be good enough for the top 4 in the epl but there's a chance he could go abroad and play cl football that way.
Geoff Edwards
11   Posted 31/03/2010 at 13:46:43

Report abuse

BTW, if I was to speculate on a replacement, I would take Marko Marin from Werder Bremen.
Michael Kenrick
12   Posted 31/03/2010 at 13:54:55

Report abuse

What concerns me most with this story is the potential effect on Moyes and the rest of the team. A Pienaar bid in the summer has all the makings of the Lescott saga all over again. And we know full well what role that played in dragging down our expectations at the start of this season.

While I don't think Pienaar is as influential for us as he himself perhaps believes, the disruptive effect in removing yet another building block in the Everton team that needs to be firing on all cylinders come August and for the entire season just fills me with dread.
John Nelson
13   Posted 31/03/2010 at 14:03:56

Report abuse

I'm sorry but Pienaar has been by far our best and most consistent player this year, and would easily walk into the team of any of the "top 3" and the redshite. Just think of who they (and other teams) have got in Pienaar's position now:

Man Utd: Valencia/Nani and JS Park - Valencia and Nani can be brilliant when they feel like however are too inconsistent, and Park's work ethic is top notch however ability wise is lacking - therefor Pienaar would definately get a place in their team.

Arsenal: Malouda and Anelka - a bit weird this one as obviously Anelka is a striker and Malouda is not far off being a striker, so for winger/midfield attributes Pienaar would easily fit in.

Arsenal: Arshavin, Nasri, Rosicky - a tough one this as these are all spot on, however for winger attributes Pienaar is more accomplished - therefor would get a place.

Redshite: Pienaar would walk into their team as the "might" of Kuyt / Riera / Babel collectively aren't as good as Pienaar.

He would get into Man City's and Spur's team... however Villa have Young and Milner, in which I think the latter is very similar to Pienaar.

Not withstanding the above however, I hope he thinks he wouldn't get a place if he moves and ends up staying!

COYB
Mark Murphy
14   Posted 31/03/2010 at 14:11:36

Report abuse

You fickle buggers!

Pienaar would get into Utds, Arsenals or Citys midfield, possibly not Chelsea on a regular basis!

You really mean to say, after the latter part of this season, that you'd swap him for Park, for example?

He's been one of our main stars and IF Arteta had been in from the start he wouldnt need to leave to achieve CL football!

Murf
Jay Harris
15   Posted 31/03/2010 at 14:14:01

Report abuse

Totally with you Michael.

We are finally not building on sand and to lose Pienaar from this squad would set us back far more than some posters think.

If we are to have any chance of success we need to build on to what we've got not break it up.
Tony McNulty
16   Posted 31/03/2010 at 14:16:48

Report abuse

Michael,

Whilst clearly something went on at the start of this season, should we continue to fall for smokescreen that it was all Lescott’s fault? What team doesn’t face constant disruption as regards transfer speculation with agents holding out for more money, especially in the lead up to the transfer deadline? The Manure had it for in excess of a year with Ronaldo and it’s hardly cramped their style. In the year we lost Voldemort (and think back to all the pre season disruption then) it was followed by our best season for a long time. The Lescott saga is a convenient excuse, but I don’t think it’s the full reason for what went on.
Ste Lewis
17   Posted 31/03/2010 at 14:13:38

Report abuse

This happened when the daily rags said Saha wanted an extortionate amount or wanted to join Arsenal. It's bollocks, why rise to this shit and slag off one of our better players. I'm sure he'll sign a new contract as soon as the season finishes. For what it's worth, I reckon he'd be a first XI starter for any team on this season's form.
Graham Holliday
18   Posted 31/03/2010 at 14:21:38

Report abuse

Michael,

If Moyes hasn't learned from the Lescott debacle then we really are doomed!

Am surprised you don't see Pienaar as central to the side though? As a devotee to on-the-deck football, what player (bar possibly Arteta... and arguably actually Heitinga) contributes more?

As I'm sure you'll agree, we're far more effective when we don't resort to hoofball, and Pienaar is one of the players most adept linking play with the ball at his feet, surely?!
Gerry Western
19   Posted 31/03/2010 at 14:35:04

Report abuse

I'd hate for us to lose Piennar but the delay in him extending his contract doesn't bode well. Let's hope he does so soon. Regarding his value, I think this will undoubtedly be decided by his performances in the forthcoming World Cup. If he performs well, there is every prospect that a number of clubs could be vying for his signature. That's bound to influence his valuation.
Graham Holliday
20   Posted 31/03/2010 at 15:31:25

Report abuse

Should he leave, it's not gonna be Gosling replacing him... out for 9 MONTHS with ruptured cruciate ligaments.



The number of players that we've had of late with knee ligament damage can't be a coincidence, can it?
Jason Heng
21   Posted 31/03/2010 at 15:33:05

Report abuse

Graham, how is Lescott a debacle?

We got Distin, Heitinga and Billy for 1 guy.
Colin Potter
22   Posted 31/03/2010 at 15:36:22

Report abuse

Geoff Edwards is spot on with Marko Marin, Fabulous player, bit of a cloned Alan Ball.
Tom Fearon
23   Posted 31/03/2010 at 16:06:32

Report abuse

What is the lesson that Moyes should learn from the "Lescott debacle"? Would it have been sensible to have sold Lescott for £15m when MC first began to attract the player?
Michael Kenrick
24   Posted 31/03/2010 at 16:55:09

Report abuse

I must admit to being a little ambivalent about Pienaar. I quite like him as a player, but he's not really as effective for us as he should be. I would say nowhere near as effective as Arteta, for example.

Yes, he does a few nice tricks down the left wing, and that certainly makes us look better than we do without him... but it''s the end result that is too often lacking, be it the killer pass or the power shot on goal.

Of course he's done a few... or he wouldn't be in the team at all, but it sounds like he might be believing his own press and this idea that he is South Africa's star player is bound to magnify the size of his head somewhat.

It would be nice to just ignore the crap as newspaper speculation, sure in the knowledge that he will sign a new contract... but a similar scenario did nothing to stop the Lescott saga from developing the way it did — it just made sure we could ask a massive price for him. Can't see that daylight robbery going down again though, somehow!

I just think it is hugely important for David Moyes to keep his team together — I felt at the time that was his biggest beef about Lescott. Yes, in hindsight, the end result £24M and three players, including Bily and Heitinga is way more than fair exchange... but there are simply no guarantees next time around. And the further delay while we bed in and train up these new players just knocks the clock back another 3... 6... 9 months.

Next season is our season, our opportunity. It must be firmly grasped with both hands.
Matthew Mackey
25   Posted 31/03/2010 at 17:05:36

Report abuse

Tony McNulty — I couldn't agree more.

The reason Peanuts is having the time of his life is because the club and the manager allow him to.

If he went to Harry the second-hand car dealer in North London or, God forbid, the fat fucker next door when he plays his 'Get out of Jail' card and pisses off to Italy, or the Trash with Cash at Eastlands, Peanuts will just disappear down the plug hole of mediocrity. Lescott is a classic example — as was Tommy Gravesen when he went to Madrid.
Peter Griffin
26   Posted 31/03/2010 at 17:10:23

Report abuse

Would some of these comments about Pienaars ability/contribution be the same if he had just signed a new contract extension?

If a player is looking at contract negotiations, the agent leeks a story to the press that X is interested and willing to pay Y per week. Par for the course.

I can't see SA setting the World Cup alight, and in a struggling side, Pienaar either.

His end product isn't always good but that's most wide players for you. His workrate and link-up play with Baines is often our best source for attack. He's improved year on year, and hopefully next year he can add a few more goals to his game. We're better with him than without him, and we're trying to build on what we've got, not replace them year on year.
Dan Brierley
27   Posted 31/03/2010 at 18:07:39

Report abuse

4 goals and 4 assists in his best season to date. Is it really that good?

I do enjoy watching Pienaar, but he doesnt seem to be as creative as what his footballing style suggests. But I think Moyes is already aware of his situation, and will have 2 or 3 targets lined up to replace him should he leave. I don't feel concerned either way actually. We could do a whole lot worse than Pienaar, but we could also do better. If Moyes has a target lined up, it could mean why the club are not exactly rushing to sign him on to a new deal.

That said though, I would be happy for him to stay if he can improve his final pass and shooting. But his work ethic is something that is excellent, and an inspiration to the rest of the team.
Dave Wilson
28   Posted 31/03/2010 at 19:07:59

Report abuse

Pienaar wouldn't get in a top four team? I`ve heard it all now

Some people wouldn`t recognise a player if he ran through their living room with his muddy boots on.
David Hallwood
29   Posted 31/03/2010 at 19:11:47

Report abuse

I'm with Ste Lewis. It's amazing how everyone (rightly) slags the tabloids, and personally I'd look twice at the date on the top before I believed it, but then repeat as gospel, what is probably a piece dreamed up to fill a hole in the copy. Stop falling for their shite, and/or stop reading them, yes they can get it right... but if you throw enough darts at the dartboard, you'll hit the bullseye sometimes.

A few years ago the Observer used to publish teams based on tabloid transfer rumours, the Sky 4 invariably had a team with anything up to 24 players. If Pienaar goes he goes, but I'll believe it when I see it.
Nathan Ward
30   Posted 31/03/2010 at 19:26:01

Report abuse

Dan - Pienaar has scored 7 goals this season........

Next to Arteta, he is the most influence attacking player in the club and I would be gutted if he left.

However, the lesson from last season is, that if the player wants out, then get the best deal quickly and move on quickly.
Ray Robinson
31   Posted 31/03/2010 at 19:29:24

Report abuse

I'm sure Pienaar would walk into any of the top 4 sides... bar maybe Chelsea. In fact, he'd be a revelation at Arsenal where players seems to think in like-minded fashion — i.e., pass and move. However, unless he is giving all his surplus cash to charity, I'd like to think that this God-fearing individual will be happy with his handsome earnings at Everton and will continue to help out the team out that made him such high-profile.

Then reality kicks in!
Brendan O'Doherty
32   Posted 31/03/2010 at 19:25:49

Report abuse

Agreed David. Utter tabloid trash - I can't believe some people are falling for it and coming out with 'well he's not that good anyway'! He is the only player that gives us any real width in the team, with the result that most of our best moves come down the left. His link-up play with Baines and Arteta is a joy to watch. Definitely a leading contender for Player of the Season this year. Great work rate as well, as others have said. He is a vital member of this side, and should not be going anywhere.
Graham Holliday
33   Posted 31/03/2010 at 21:47:41

Report abuse

Re: the "Lescott debacle"... sure, we got excellent money and some very good players as a result, but it did also heavily disrupt our start to the season — and, though injuries also played a massive part — contributed to our low league position.

Dragging it out for so long was far from ideal, especially considering we were forced into using players like Baxter and Neville/Hibbert as a CB.

In that sense only, I'd qualify it as a "debacle". Not in terms of how we profited, obviously.

Regarding Pienaar's merit... Michael, I can honestly say I'm surprised — not saying you're wrong necessarily - but I thought you would appreciate his contribution to the pass-and-move style of football you always seem to so strongly advocate.

In my eyes:

Though Pienaar may sometime lack end product, his ability to help us retain possession when a more panicked player would squander it, his ability to take opposition players out of the game with a little shift of the feet, and the ways he links with Baines to create havoc down the left flank — all suggest he's a very, very important player.

Sometimes, a player's gifts are subtle ones — but important nonetheless.

Indeed, I'm also very impressed with his high-tempo pressing of opponents — a very useful trick to help regain possession.

That's my two pennies, anyway, I think the side would miss him massively were he to leave. But thankfully, as it stands, this is nothing more than speculation.
Colin Wainwright
34   Posted 31/03/2010 at 21:56:25

Report abuse

Fuckin right, Ste Lewis!

We might as well discuss what happened in the fucking Beano this week.

Stop reading shite papers!
Colin Wainwright
35   Posted 31/03/2010 at 22:04:01

Report abuse

Oh and BTW, Peanuts would fuckin' walk into any of the Sky 3 teams on current form.

The Shite can't afford him!
Sean Patton
36   Posted 31/03/2010 at 22:21:09

Report abuse

As much as Pienaar is a good player for us, if we had a natural winger as his replacement (if he was to go), it would improve the balance of the team. I hope we manage to keep him but if not then we should buy Alexis Sanchez.

This lad is brilliant, quick, dynamite shooting, tricky and although small he is stocky and hard to shake off the ball. He currently plays for Udinese so he could be bought before he gets a bigger club. He is one to watch at the World Cup, I think he and Chile will be excellent to watch this summer.
Andy Crooks
37   Posted 31/03/2010 at 23:20:45

Report abuse

Tom McNulty, you are absolutely right: Joleon Lescott would be nailed on for the World Cup had he stayed with Everton.
Kieran Kinsella
38   Posted 01/04/2010 at 00:04:36

Report abuse

When we bought Bily, I felt that we were spending the Pienaar sale money in advance and I haven't changed my mind about that since.
Iain Love
39   Posted 01/04/2010 at 00:28:25

Report abuse

"According to the dailies," — they're worse than this forum for speculation. 'Oh that Pienaar's good lets say he wants to go to one of the CL clubs...' Bag of shite,
Martin Mason
40   Posted 01/04/2010 at 03:39:01

Report abuse

Stevie Pienaar is a lovely footballer and made for our club. He has played well against the top clubs and that probably defines how well he could play if he went to one. He would be a top buy for any club but not so good that he'd be guaranteed a game.

If he wants success then I implore him to stay at Everton because with the right buys this time we are on the verge of good times.

If he's going to go though nothing can stop it and I'd only hope it's done quickly and with good grace. Soccer is a very dirty business now from clubs who are trading while technically insolvent, greedy overpaid players, greedier agents, fans with ridiculous expectations and no place for loyalty or continuity.

I love the little guy and the part he plays for us but if he goes, he goes and we have to get on with it. The Gosling injury is very disappointing though.
James Flynn
41   Posted 01/04/2010 at 03:37:43

Report abuse

Pretty funny to this American. Who exactly says Pienaar wants to go? I'm surprised to see "according to the dailies" without lot of questions about the origins of the stories.

Pienaar has one year left. Mr Moyes, do not sell him. If he wants to go, next season MUST be the best season of his career. Keep him and let his (assumed) desperation to attract Top 4 attention benefit EFC. The so-called Sky 4 is watching and, presumably, wanting him? He needs to play his ass off, doesn't he?

Myself, I think DM throws a few extra bucks at a few players in trying to keep a building side intact and have a go at EPL Silverware in 2011. It's there to be had and we have the talent to grab it.

And bring back Donovan.
Andy Callan
42   Posted 01/04/2010 at 12:40:55

Report abuse

If he wants to leave then let him go. What loyalty does he have for Everton ffs - none is the answer to that.

If Shrek can leave a club he supported and played for as a boy, then we've NO CHANCE at all of keep players that want to leave.

Unless we get investment we've gone as far as we can go imo. Get used to it as it won't get any better than finishing 5th and getting to a Cup Final (like last season).

Take up golf - that way you have only yourself to blame if you fuck it up.....
Tony J Williams
43   Posted 01/04/2010 at 13:48:34

Report abuse

I don't think it is a case of people saying "He is not that good", he is.....in our side but moving up the level to the other "top" clubs I don't see him commanding an automatic starting place, the way he does with us; hence why I personally think it would be a bad career move for him. he stands out for us but will just be Joe Ordinary in the Chelsea, Man Utd and Arsenal sides.
Terry Riley
44   Posted 12/05/2010 at 22:33:28

Report abuse

http://www.rtl.nl/components/programma/vandervorstzietsterren/miMedia/
210166/210175.alleen_nl.29726163.Van_Der_Vorst_Ziet_Sterren_s2_a9.xml

Here is Johnny Heitinga interviewed on Dutch tv A bonus is that a dutch pornostar is also in the same program!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.



© ToffeeWeb