Skip to Main Content
Members:   Log In Sign Up
Text:  A  A  A
Season 2011-12

Why is it always 2-2 with Villa?

By Paul Traill   ::  11/09/2011
 11 Comments (Last)
With evening plans in place I drove the match today parking up where I normally do. I?m sure its going to come back to bite me at some point but I?ve developed a new tactic to avoid the ?watch yer car? posse hanging around near where you park your car ? pretend to be on your phone. I put my phone to my ear as I walk away from the car and then again as I walk back towards the car and it seems to work hassle free?so far so good anyway.

I was in the pub slightly before Gary and Sue though when they turned up was able to get a seat, sat next to some Norwegian Evertonians. A lot of the pre-match talk of course centered on The Blue Union protest and Bill Kenwright and its fair to say we all have differing views on how things are going with the board etc. Regardless, we were all quite excited by the prospect of seeing the two new faces today. As I got the team news via Twitter it was apparent that neither were starting the match with Cahill up front on his own. I liked the look of the midfield, with Fellaini holding, Rodwell the main central midfield, Coleman back and on the right wing with Bilyaletdinov on the left and Osman playing just off Cahill in attack. Tony Hibbert came in at right back. Jageilka skippered with Neville dropping to the bench. Maybe a sign of the times with Neville being dropped?though we were at least able to win the toss for once! The substitutes bench looked decent with Mucha, Neville, Gueye, Vellios, Barkley, Drenthe and Stracqualursi.

Aston Vila featured Everton old-boy Richard Dunne, apparent summer transfer target Charles N?Zogbia, ex-Red Emile Heskey and their record signing Darren Bent. The referee was Michael Oliver, the crowd was buzzing. Strangely for Aston Villa, their supporters only filled half the allocated away tear.

We began at an excellent tempo, Seamus Coleman skipping away down the wing and his ball in falling to Osman whom appeared to be taken out by Dunne in what should have been an early penalty though the referee deemed otherwise?I?ve never quite understood why referees are so reluctant to give penalties early in games.

Undeterred Everton pressed on and continued to create chances with Dunne, Collins and Warnock all making good interceptions and clearances to keep Everton at bay after good wing play. Inside the box, Jagielka and Osman both came close to getting the early goal though both were denied by Given, and I think Jagielka also headed narrowly wide. At the other end Bannan, an early substitute for Heskey, drilled a decent effort from a long way out which Howard got behind. Off the ball an image of Bill Kenwright on the big screens was met by some boos though then drowned out by loud applause from the majority of the Everton support. Fair to say opinions are still split though it was also nice to see many supporters behind the club.

Everton took the lead after quite a few passes resulted in a ball forward to Cahill. He did well, shielding the ball and laying off a pass to Osman who side-footed first time past Given to the delight of the Goodison crowd. 1-0 and Everton playing excellent. Everton weren?t finished for the half either and were agonizingly close to going two ahead when Rodwell let fly from distance and with the ball going well wide it deflected off Fabian Delph, wrong-footing Given though just curling wide of the opposite post?would have been particularly fortunate to be fair. Otherwise, Fellaini blazed over as Everton dominated at the break.

At half-time I went to see Ste, accompanied by another friend Steve who used to be a season ticket holder at Everton before emigrating to Canada?good to catch up with him.

Everton were a little tentative after the break and it seemed Villa had gotten a rocket from the boss and came out a much more positive team?albeit without creating anything. It was therefore all the more frustrating when Petrov let fly from about 30 yards with the ball somehow nestling into the corner?after all our chances Villa hit one from miles out and it goes straight in. Furthermore, prior to that we were denied what seemed a clear penalty when Bannan tripped Baines inside the box though the referee said no when right on the spot. It makes me wonder if it would have been very different had we have gone 2-0 ahead.

Everton, assisted by the crowd, roused themselves following Petrov?s long range equalizer and were soon back in front. Fellaini?s shot fro the edge of the box was deflected for a corner. Baines delivered, Cahill?s header was well saved and as Jagielka was under it trying to judge his header, Delph clattered into him and the referee pointed to the penalty spot this time. Baines stepped up, sent Given the wrong way and Everton 2-1 ahead. Was good to see Neville come down the pitchside to bark out a few instructions to his team as we got back to business.

Bilyaltedinov was soon subbed for Drenthe to make his debut, and he didn?t disappoint, surging forward whenever possible and getting into good attacking positions. He looks a useful player once he gets fully fit. Seamus Coleman was also visibly shattered and needed to come off. He was replaced by Barkley.

I think everyone was happy enough with the substitution, though gobsmacked with what happened next. A ball across to our right side from Villa was chased by Albrighton with Hibbert as Barkley gave up on it, though it was kept in and in control of Barkley. He cold have done a number of things but for some reason played a crazy crossfield ball toward Baines at left back. Villa took back possession and although there was then a little period of time between then and the eventual Agbonlahor header, you could see it coming really and were left frustrated once again. How on earth do we always seem to draw 2-2 with Aston Villa? We?ve managed four 2-2 draws with Villa in the last five seasons.

Everton weren?t finished yet however and still had the chances to win the game in the dying minutes. Substitute Vellios got on the end of a forward ball and nicked the ball past Given outside the box though his side-footed volley went inches wide. I thought he?d scored. Desperate to make amends, Barkley was rampaging forward where possible and set up another chance for Vellios who?s snap-shot was tipped over by Given.

In the end, honours even and though frustrated I left the ground upbeat with the performance from our team today. If, and we know it?s a big if, we can keep hold of our young players the future does look bright. Coleman, Rodwell, Fellaini, Barkley, Vellios and Drethe are all good talents and there could still be big things to come from this team.

I was straight back to the car and straight home?the mobile phone trick worked a treat once again.

Player Ratings:

Howard: Might be disappointed to have been beaten by Petrov?s long range drive and his distribution was disappointing at times. Not a great deal to do though really. 5

Baines: Excellent getting forward. My Man of the Match. 8

Distin: Very solid. Can see him having a very good season. 8

Jagileka: Rash decision-making at times. Certainly not one of his better performance and is still to really get going this season. 6

Hibbert: Did well getting forward I thought. Helped Coleman out when he was visibly tiring. 7

Fellaini: Held things together well. I think once he gets another half a dozen games or so under his belt he?ll be flying. 7

Rodwell: Did quite well. His heading not the best and hit some frustrating shots well over the bar but worked quite well. Has to take on more responsibility on the ball now though I feel. 6

Osman: Worked well first half and got a good goal though tired as the game wore on. 7

Bilyaletdinov: Showed flashes in the first half though never really got going in the game in truth. Rightly subbed. 5

Coleman: Gave everything before tiring. Good to have him back. His enthusiasm is fantastic. 6

Cahill: Put in a great shift. A real warrior performance. 7

Drenthe (for Bilyaletdinov): Looks an exciting player. A few sort of headless-chicken moments but generally good. Very quick and skillful and should be great once he gets up to speed. 7

Barkley (for Coleman): His bizarre pass really cost us but he?ll learn from that, and boy, did he try to make amends. Unleash him next week and he?ll get his rewards I think. 6

Vellios (for Cahill): Did very well. Unlucky not to score and a nice opener for Denis as he may realize he?s going to have to work to get into the team. 7

Reader Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Mark Browne
1   Posted 11/09/2011 at 15:38:31

Report abuse

Paul, hard not to disagree, but once again errors we make seem to result in goals conceded. The first goal, I thought Rodwell was lying too deep (on the edge of the area) so when Petrov received the ball, he had acres of room and plenty of time to unleash a fabulous shot that gave Howard no chance. Compare that chance to the one at the end of the first half from Rodwell, from a similar position, he was closed down quickly, resulting in the shot being blocked, albeit narrowly wide. The second, as you point out was loss of possession, but we still had enough men to defend our area, and Distin should never have been beaten in the air by Agbonlahor. Once we cut out the errors, we will gain confidence and I hope that we can go on one of our long unbeaten runs that characterize Moyes' teams in the second half of the season.
Mike Gaynes
2   Posted 11/09/2011 at 15:46:08

Report abuse

Good report, Paul. You agreed with several other folks in giving Distin an 8, but the fact is that he rates the largest share of blame for their second goal. Getting outjumped at the back post by a smaller man behind him is not Distin's usual standard.

Bily bewilders me. He orchestrates so well for Russia, but for us he rushes everything. Even his teammates were telling him to have more patience and not be in such a hurry, but he treated the ball like it was on fire and he couldn't wait to get it off his foot. Missed some excellent opportunities as a result.

I'm excited about Drenthe and Vellios. Some terrific talent there, and Drenthe's speed is breathtaking. He's the quickest player we've had in a long time.
Ray Robinson
3   Posted 11/09/2011 at 16:05:23

Report abuse

Not sure where you get your 2-2 stat from Paul?
Dominic Bobadilla
4   Posted 11/09/2011 at 17:37:59

Report abuse

Aston Villa-Everton 6-2; you should have been there Paul. I had nightmares aboout Tony Daley for 4 weeks running.
James Stewart
5   Posted 11/09/2011 at 18:13:02

Report abuse

Quite accurate ratings there. I thought Jags was woeful and Distin does the work of two cbs at the moment. 10m for him is laughable. Not worth 1 at present.

Rodwell again poor. Can't see why Barkley doesn't start ahead of him.

Fellaini was imperious I thought my motm.
Peter Anthony
6   Posted 11/09/2011 at 17:51:58

Report abuse

Post no.4: GTF for bringing that up... that was a pissin nightmare.

I was a kid at the time and living in the midlands surrounded by villa fans... (I've never met a nice one!) Not a good memory...

Dominic Bobadilla
7   Posted 11/09/2011 at 21:01:55

Report abuse

6: That was the beginning of the end for Harvey. The look on his face was priceless. Poor guy was never the same again.
Dick Fearon
8   Posted 12/09/2011 at 00:03:41

Report abuse

To be fair, I did meet a decent Villa fan... but that was a long time ago.
Gavin Ramejkis
9   Posted 12/09/2011 at 12:43:53

Report abuse

I was hacked off the way we sat back twice after scoring, Villa were genuinely there for the taking but after we scored twice we bloody sat back, never the right thing to do against those spawny gets
Dan McKie
10   Posted 12/09/2011 at 13:44:47

Report abuse

Although Distin did have a good game, I thought he was at fault for Villa's 2nd. Didnt get off the ground and was outjumped by Agbonlahor! Jags is looking very short on confidence and if Johnny was fit, id say let Jags sit on the bench for a game or 2.
Adam Cunliffe
11   Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:34:16

Report abuse

Went the match with my Villa supporting girlfriend, needless to say we didnt speak coming much on the train home! Guess she and her family break the mould of Villa fans thought 'coz they're really nice!

Still on a personal level, I hate thier fecking club and the fact we never seem to do well against them. Either way Wigan next SHOULD mean 3 points.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to Column articles, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.

© ToffeeWeb

We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.