Fantastic Gibson strike seals win

, 31 January, 132comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 1 - 0 Manchester City
David Moyes opted for experience over natural position this evening by naming Tony Hibbert as starting centre half alongside John Heitinga. Starting XI: Howard; Neville, Hibbert, Heitinga, Baines; Gibson, Fellaini, Drenthe, Donovan; Cahill; Stracqualursi. Subs: Mucha, Duffy, Forshaw, Gueye, Barkley, Baxter, Vellios. New signing Nikica Jelavic still not confirmed before the game.

Match Summary

Heitinga gave away a poor free-kick early on but nothing came of it as the game continued with generally scrappy play and poor passes from both sides until Everton won their first corner, Stracqualursi thought his header had scored but Lescott headed it off the line... just! At the other end, Richards got in on Howard and City won their first corner.

City were pushing Everton back from the 5th minute, with Hibbert heading away well, and Everton breaking with better shape and joined-up passing, letting Stracq make another header on target. But Everton were torn asunder by a simple move, Milner in acres of space down the right, a driven cross that Clichy drove hopelessly high and wide.

Everton were resorting to hoofball from defence but fared better when they played it on the ground, although Drenthe did himself no favours feigning a foul on an over-elaborate dummy dodge around Kompany.

Another corner in the 18th minute that Donovan played too short to the near post. Baines caused gasps when he was easily dispossessed by Nasri but the defensive shape was good and all they got was a corner that Howard caught easily.

Another incisive City attack required a header behind by Neville and Everton broke well form the corner only for Drenthe to rush his free-kick and concede possession shockingly that allowed Aguero to conjour a shot that went wide. Drenthe was becoming his own worst enemy, far too wound up to be of much use at all as he lost the ball with an unforced miskick.

Everton finally gained some possession but were hopelessy stymied and allowed themselves to be forced back to Howard. Cahill was then somehwt luckily picked up a free-kick for a 50-50 challenge by Barry. Donovan took the kick but it was too slow and low. However, on the follow-up, Stracqualursi put off Hart, and set up Donovan for a snapshot well over.

The atmosphere was hotting up nicely with some determined attacking by Everton, and a superb free-kick from Baines careened off Fellaini for a corner. A very neat piece of play followed, Baines persistence led to a cross in to Stracq, his center a set-up for Fellaini who should at least have hit the target.

At the other end, a fantastic curling drive from Nasri deserved a goal but it smashed off the underside of the bar near the angle and bounced down barely a foot in front of the line, where Aguero in the follow-up had his shot incredibly saved by a point-blank reaction from Howard but he was offside. Breathless stuff from both sides.

Then an astounding protest stopped the game on 41 minutes. While play was up the Gwladys Streeet end, an Everton fan sneaked on and secured himself to the Man City net. A group of stewards and cops remonstrated with him and took 3 minutes to break him free.

During half-time, the signing of Nikica Jelavic was confirmed with the ex-Rangers player paraded along with his new Royal Blue shirt.

City mounted some penetrating attacks after the break, but seemed to be intent on spurning chances from which you might usually expect them to score. Everton were still in the game, but not convinced they really could hold off the increasingly insistent threat from the visitors, with some simply horrible, unforgivably bad passing when the Blues had possession.

Fellaini made a vital interception on Aguerro that could so easily have been a penalty but wasn't. On an increasingly rare Everton foray, Lescott was booked for his foul on Stracqualkursi but Donovan made a poor fist of the free-kick. However, right on the hour, Drenthe battled forward again with the ball, played it out to Baines, whose deflected cross to Donovan was set up perfectly for Gibson to produce a fabulous slightly deflected strike that would shake any itinerant protesters off the Gwladys Street net. A fantastic strike to put the Blues in front.

Mancini reacted by switching out some of his expensive stars, including Lescott, to a crescendo of boos from the Goodison faithful. Gibson was set up for another strike but it appeared to blocked for a corner. Everton, though, now seemed to have more belief, and looked to play the ball forward with more spirit and determination, Stracqualursi doing particularly well and the ball dropping to Gibson for his third first-time volley.

City fans screamed for a penalty when the ball smashed into Neville's arm but Everton broke with Donovan and Stracqualursi threatening to exchange passes but just failing. An intense barrage of City pressure followed, with plenty of last-ditch defending by a Blues defence rocking visibly on the back foot. Drenthe got the yellow card his clumsy challenges deserved and he was withdrawn, to be replaced by Jose Baxter on 78 mins.

Everton's defence had been effectively solid, relying again and again on blocks and interceptions, with Hibbert and Heitinga putting in a great shift. Neville on a break crossed well to Baxter but he did very poorly, controlling the ball but drilling it into Clichy.

At the other end, Everton continued to frustrate every City attack but it was increasingly nervy stuff, with the need for cool and mature heads... so on came Vellios for Stracqualursi, who had put in an excellent shift full of spirit and determination, if severely lacking in quality.

Johnson made a tremendous run into the Everton area, but Baines blocked him superbly. it was breath-taking stuff, with four minutes of extra time coming from somewhere, Mancini looking lost and frustrated at the inability of his far superior moneybag players to lord it over their poverty-stricken hosts.

Meanwhile, the atmosphere among the Everton fans built with increasing expectation that he Blues had secured an excellent win against the City money-machine — only their third loss as they thought they were ploughing relentlessly towards the Premier League title. A fantastic result for the Blues, and the best, most entertaining game in ages and ages.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Report Page



Reader Comments (132)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


David Hallwood
1 Posted 31/01/2012 at 19:20:54
Mmmmmmmmmm... that'll give Duffy lots of confidence. BTW we're 7/2 to win with Citteh odds on @ 10/11.
Kevin Elliott
2 Posted 31/01/2012 at 19:21:46
Heard that Jelovic hasn't signed yet and that he has left goodison. Anyone know what's goin' on?
Hope this isn't another fuck up.
Colin Potter
3 Posted 31/01/2012 at 19:28:33
If I were Duffy, I'd ask for a transfer.
This prick would put Messi off his game.
Thoroughly disgusted!!!!!
Brian Waring
4 Posted 31/01/2012 at 19:33:05
Doesn't make sense, you replace a natural centre half, who has played well, with a right back.
John Daley
5 Posted 31/01/2012 at 19:31:47
Not going the game tonight and when that happens we normally seem to get a win. However this decision has demolished my slight optimism. Duffy has acquitted himself well in his run outs so far and has looked paticularly strong in the air. Can't see Hibbert or Heitinga coping very well with the aerial threat of Dzeko. Wonder what the odds are on Hibbert giving away a penalty?
Shane Corcoran
6 Posted 31/01/2012 at 19:39:26
I knew it. I called it before Duffy's first game that if Moyes has both Neville and Hibbert available he'd play one at CB ahead of Duffy.
Jon Ferguson
7 Posted 31/01/2012 at 19:43:07
Duffy's omission is stupid for a number of reasons.
1) he's on form
2) it's a chance to learn against the best
3) if he has a bad game he learns from his mistakes (I don't believe it would shatter his confidence).
4) Heitinga could talk him through the game, enhancing his own confidence.
5) we now have no pace at the back
6) we now have no height at the back.

I'm sure there's more reasons. Gutted about this decision!!!
Joe McMahon
8 Posted 31/01/2012 at 19:47:06
John- I know what you mean, Hibbert v Pace means Pace wins & Hibbo gives away a penatly.
Joe McMahon
9 Posted 31/01/2012 at 19:48:04
Guys, Pienaar is on the bench at Spurs looks like it's one in & one out. Squad needs to be bigger, Donovan's off in under 4 weeks.
Michael Kenrick
10 Posted 31/01/2012 at 19:45:49
What a shocking kick in the balls for the lad (assuming he is not injured)... talk about confidence.

Moyes is just utterly astounding... unless the lad has picked up a knock... but if that knock is sufficient to prevent him from starting, why is he on the bench? In which case, have Cahill back there (at least he can head the ball) and play the other overlooked kid, Barkley.

But no, it's always his tried and trusted favourites who get the nod.
Jeremy Benson
11 Posted 31/01/2012 at 20:11:30
Hmm. No anichebe? Even on the bench?
Liam Reilly
12 Posted 31/01/2012 at 20:33:22
Utterly fucking disgraceful decision to drop Duffy. What chance has he got to get into this team as soon as Distin & Jags are back.

He'll be lucky to get 20 minutes for the rest of the season.



Michael Kenrick
13 Posted 31/01/2012 at 20:40:50
Anichebe is injured.
Michael Kenrick
14 Posted 31/01/2012 at 20:41:29
THIS IS INCREDIBLE... Man chains himself to goalpost!!!
Liam Reilly
15 Posted 31/01/2012 at 20:42:22
WTF, some numbskull has just handcuffed himself to the goalpost
Derek Williams
16 Posted 31/01/2012 at 20:45:37
He was looking for a quiet place to have a peaceful protest!
Nigel Tufnell
17 Posted 31/01/2012 at 20:55:59
No doubt someone on here will blame Moyes for that nutter.

I remember one gig we did where Smallsey got himself locked inside one of the stage props. Took 2 roadies with a blow torch to get him out.
Steve Carter
18 Posted 31/01/2012 at 20:56:48
For all his critics I think Hibbo is having a pretty solid game. Impressed with Straq too - at least, unlike Saha, he's having a go.
Jim Knightley
19 Posted 31/01/2012 at 20:58:58
Very good first half, hopefully we can carry it on, although I expect their quality will show in the second half.



Good to see Denis up front and having a go, even if he will be replaced by Jelavic next match.
Steve Carter
20 Posted 31/01/2012 at 21:07:24
Just announced on the teev that Saha is going to Spurs. What a great bit of business from us - must've bitten 'arry's arms off to the elbows...
Andy Crooks
21 Posted 31/01/2012 at 21:07:54
Jon Ferguson,spot on with all you say. I find the decision to leave Duffy out appalling. It sums up all that is dreadful about Moyes.On a recent post I called for some more balance and was moving towards a less entrenched view. By fuck,does Moyes make that difficult.
Jim Knightley
22 Posted 31/01/2012 at 21:23:31
Yesssssssssssssssssssssssssss
Jim Knightley
23 Posted 31/01/2012 at 21:45:49
Cahill and Denis need to come off...look like they have nothing left. Whatever happens, a great performance.
Wayne McNee
24 Posted 31/01/2012 at 21:48:30
Straq! You fuckin beauty! Why the fuck have we suffered Saha!! Excellent performance... All round!!
Jim Knightley
25 Posted 31/01/2012 at 21:57:12
You can moan at Moyes however much you like about Duffy...Today we were incredible at the back, and no team has defended so well against Man City all season. Lets hope this determination continues.
Tom Laskaris
26 Posted 31/01/2012 at 21:57:52
Tears in my eyes while I'm writing this. So very very proud of this great club. Boys were great today. What we lacked in flair was made up with heart. Cahill and fellaini best for me.COYB!!!!! Made my week.
Eddy Bernard
27 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:00:17
Hibbert for England
Anthony Jones
28 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:00:00
Fantastic result.

Strikes me again though that the positive change in dropping Saha was forced in Moyes. Why hasn't Count Stracquala been playing every week? He would have scored easily as many as Saha.

Barkley needs game time.

Peace.
Kiern Moran
29 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:01:19
Did not see any of the game as was at work. Thought it was a mistake to drop Duffy when I saw the side but got to say Moyes seems to have called this one right. Fantastic result. Time to push on!
James Martin
30 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:03:11
Shame on all those slagging off Hibbert. You could see Moyes' logic. Duffy is great in the air but slow on the deck, Aguero might have ripped him a new one. Hibbert kept him shackled well. Great play by all the boysand the loanees Drenthe and Strac. they have their limitations but its so good seeing players playing with a bit of pride and aggression.
Nick Entwistle
31 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:02:18
Reminds me of the night Gosling put the shite to the sword. The second half was an epic. Brilliant. I don't know what had changed. Fulham result, a Moyes blast, the new signing, Straq up front, but just a beautiful effort. So many heros. Strac, Evans, The Big Hair, JH and Hibbo. Going to watch it all over again on MOTD... RAAAAAGHHHH!
Tom Bowers
32 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:03:04
A terrific result. Somewhat bemused at the omission of Duffy but I guess anything Moyes does shouldn't surpise anyone.
However, City were not able to exploit the lack of height in Everton's rearguard and I think that must go down to the wonderful work rate of all the players.
Still I lost count of the number of times Everton gave the ball away cheaply in the first half. That could have been suicidal against City but they dodged some bullets and got the result(the best one of the season so far)with the derby match still to come.
Chris Leyland
33 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:11:41
Not bad tactical selection for a clueless PE teacher Was it?
Kevin Sparke
34 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:02:15
Hibbert -immense
Kevin Sparke
35 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:13:20
Straq - a god in the making
James Morgan
36 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:12:16
Straq my new fave player
James Lauwervine
37 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:13:50
The Count was phenomenal tonight and the defending was awesome. We just never looked like conceding to me.
Rob Walden
38 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:13:53
Couldn't get there tonight but watched on the box. Brilliant... really brilliant. Moyes deserves full credit for his selection, H & H at the back were superb. We have a superb manager with incredibly motivated players over-achieving, don't forget it moaners.
Jim Slade
39 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:10:49
Absolutely brilliant display tonight. A lot of guys on here need to swallow their words after the performances of Hibbert and Heitinga.
Strac was immense tonite.
Thought Jose Baxter looked way out of his level. The fat lunatic who handcuffed himself to the goal looked more up for it than Baxter and fitter too.
Great nite. What a differance a few hours make in the life of us blues!

Kevin Sparke
40 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:13:49
Moyes - dropping Duffy... 'oh what a twat' was my first reaction.

But that back four held the most talented attack in the league... and Moyes did a job on them.

Which is why he's won League manager of the year three times and I teach IT

Dave Southon
41 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:14:17
A very professional performance.

The omission of Duffy got some stick here, but again proves that DM does know what he is doing and while we moan about ultra defensive tactics he simply plays to our limits.

We don't have any outstanding players but through hard work and endeavour we can get results, it won't be pretty but we must back our manager; our board is a different matter though.

DM in.
BK out.
Nick Entwistle
42 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:17:28
What I like about Strac is that he puts in the effort we would all like to believe we would if we had the chance to play for Everton. Makes Cahill look like Jo.
Alex Mullan
43 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:15:27
The other week when we signed Gibson there was a landslide surge of abuse for him from -many- so called fans on this site. He was deemed useless, a Man Utd reject, paceless, not a striker; basically not wanted (not by all, but by many). I hope your all enjoying that humble pie. Great to see a fellow Derry man score a winner against the Merc City

Come on you blues!

I can't pick out anyone tonight who was man of the match, so many heroic performances from people filling gaps. Special mention has to go to The Straq and Hibbo though, they deserve their night of credit more than most.
Matthew Lovekin
44 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:19:49
Get Straq signed up now! How much do Tigre want?
Dean Adams
45 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:20:43
Straq was awsome! We should learn from this.
Absolute magic.
Jim Slade
46 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:10:49
Absolutely brilliant display tonight. A lot of guys on here need to swallow their words after the performances of Hibbert and Heitinga.

Strac was immense tonite.

Thought Jose Baxter looked way out of his level. The fat lunatic who handcuffed himself to the goal looked more up for it than Baxter and fitter too.

Great nite. What a difference a few hours make in the life of us blues!
Dick Fearon
47 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:19:26
A big well done to Moyes for calling it right.
Keeping a low profile for a while will be more than a few who slagged him off for playing Hibbert.
C'mon you blokes, 10 hail Mary's and ten our fathers.
Colin Potter
48 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:18:24
Strac played like he really wants to stay at Everton and the way we are cash strapped, he will do for me. An excellent performance from him. Although I thought it was stupid to drop Duffy, Hibbert had a really good game.
Tom Bowers
49 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:20:35
It still begs the question: why on earth did Moyes persist with Saha when he had hungrier players on the sidelines?
Stracqs is showing his worth and if this guy Jelavic teams up with him, we may have an offence to savour. However, it means Cahill's days may be numbered along with Anichebe although back-up is still needed and there is also Vellios.

But let's not underrate Wigan on Saturday after this result. They are fighting for survival.
Howard Meakin
50 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:18:12
Moyes got it spot on tonight, Hibbert and Straq justified their starts. How thoroughly satisfying to see Lescott and Mancini's rich boys giving a good spanking.
Ciaran Armstrong
51 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:26:58
Thought dropping Duffy was no good for his confidence, but result will show him how to perform for the rest of the season.
Hibbo and Heitinga were great but the work put in by Donovan, Straq Attaq and Creme de Drenthe was superb!
Vellios should have come on 5 mins earlier as Straq and Cahill were dead on their feet - otherwise fine.

[thanks to E John and B Taupin...]
"Hey Nikica was it cold,
In that little corner of Glasgow,
You could stroll around the globe,
And never find a warmer club to join.
[Chorus]
Coz Nikica, you may not yet know,
Anything about our home,
But you'll hear us when we sing to you,
Nikica... We need your goals!"
Roman Sidey
52 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:25:55
Fantastic result. Suddenly the fixture list doesn't look so daunting, with Wigan, Chelsea, Shite, and QPR to come, what was looking like four points at best can now look more like 7-10 points, maybe more. Amazing what a little bit of belief can do.

Fair play, I thought Moyes had had a fucking stroke to put Hibbo in at centre half against the top of the league City, but he did the job. Wouldn't accept him being there long term, but tonight, credit where it is due.

Loved/was confused when Moyes subbed Straq for Vellios when we were already up 1-0. Could this be a sign of things to come from the Ginger one? Hope so, but very quiet hope.

Still, Moyes out.
Graham Mockford
53 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:23:43
The Moyes haters seem very quiet tonight. No doubt this season has had some low points and nice to see Moyes has recognised it by freshening the squad up but as ever this is only ever going to be on a one-in, one-out basis.

My problem with the mindless anti-Moyes stuff is the short sighted simplistic view that a run of poor form means he doesn't know what he's doing despite eight years of evidence to the contrary.

Form is temporary, class is permanent.
Jon Ferguson
54 Posted 31/01/2012 at 22:27:19
Great result and equally as important a great performance.

Still bemused at Duffy's omission, not convinced we wouldn't have won with him but Hibbert had a good game. I'm not a Hibbert hater, but he's not a natural centre back.

Gibson put in a good shift. Again, I wasn't excited about his signing, nothing against him, I just wanted some width or a striker. His performances so far look like we could have got a bargin.

On that performance Straq can't be dropped, Jelavic may have to earn a place.

Drenthe can be shit for ¾ of a game, but he's the only player we have who can produce world class moments. We can't afford to neglect that. We can sign him on a pre-contract agreement now. Give him what he wants. He could be a great player for years to come.
COYB!
Ian Smitham
56 Posted 01/02/2012 at 00:33:05
Got back from the game a few mins ago. Read the report and note one omission that needs retifying. Just how did Drenthe get the ball for the goal, and who says that Fella cant tackle. Watch it for those that did not go, and wince when you see how hard fella went in.

Re Hibbert I believe that Moyes will always pick players who will do what he says and be relied upon to do that, I doubt Duffy was dropped more moyes wanted to go with experience against the best team in the division, and like TH or not, anyone who denies how well he played tonight needs to have a long hard look at how objective they are. While I am ranting can I also say how well Johnny is playing. He really has improved and from being an accident waiting to happen, he is now coaching the likes of Duffy on the pitch. On job training.

Strach. Wow, he may not be that good but a standing ovation from all parts of the ground tonight reflected his effort and how it clearly lifted the players and that crowd.

Lastly, if I may, for a club so close to administration, how do they find the money to pay a substsantial part of the fee up front and how come the share price has not collapsed?
Shaun Brennan
57 Posted 01/02/2012 at 01:23:53
The goal took a bit of a sweet deflection. Probably going in the other corner though :-)
Phil Rodgers
58 Posted 01/02/2012 at 01:30:16
Straq has earned his stripes tonight. Can't remember being as happy as this to be an Evertonian. Made up that pienaar is back. Heitenga mom
Jamie Sweet
59 Posted 01/02/2012 at 01:20:12
I'm not a "Moyes hater", but I have been highly critical of him recently. My main gripe being team selection, especially regarding Saha.

He drops Saha - sticks a lad up front who has the heart and desire to lead the line and what do you know, it pays off immediately.

Credit to Moyes for making the change, but it should have been done ten games ago in my opinion.

Now Saha has gone, so no longer an option for Moyes to go back to the Cahill Saha combo which clearly wasn't working. I'm suddenly much more optimistic.

Moyes also looked far more happy in the post-match interview. A bit of a glint back in his eyes. Perhaps cos he was allowed to spend a little bit of money!

And finally credit to our manager for going with Hibbert. I'd rather see Aguero try and get past Hibbo than young Duffy - although I'd still like to see the young lad at the back for the Wigan game.

It's amazing what a difference a day makes! Great result and a pretty pleasing transfer window considering. COYB!
Peter Bourke
60 Posted 01/02/2012 at 01:38:15
Have to say watching here in Australia the atmosphere seemed out of this world. The crowd were absolutely sensational last night. Not a bad player on the pitch, but a special mentionto La Strac and Tim Cahill who both ran themselves to a standstill giving every drop of blood for the club. Hibbo was outstanding and Jonny was masterful at the back. Another assist for landon and felli's best game for ages.....I could go on and on. Lets hope we kick on from here and Goodison becomes the fortress again.
James Flynn
61 Posted 01/02/2012 at 01:47:00
Christ Almighty! I'm on the US East Coast and it took me 2 hours to get back in here. You lot ever sleep?

Great win, Saha out (peculiar a manager fighting for the League Trophy would see Saha as a positive signing), Peanuts back (expecting a whirling dervish thru the end of the season).

Up the Table we go. Just like that, Everton's back.

Who's next?

COYB

Kenright/Green etal OUT!
James Flynn
62 Posted 01/02/2012 at 02:00:34
Jamie (413) - Dead on. Out with the old, in with the new.

We still have an ownership problem, no question.

But this infusion of new blood combined with earlier infusions (Straq first) will see us staying up this season (As much as it bothers me to have to put it that way).

Up the Table we go!

COYB

Kenright/Green and them OUT.
Shaun Brennan
63 Posted 01/02/2012 at 02:12:08
I'm gutted I missed the game. I've moved to Calgary recently and was out on site whilst the match was playing.
Michael Kenrick
64 Posted 01/02/2012 at 02:26:26
Hi Shaun, I just flew through Calgary the other day, on my way to Regina, Saskatchewan.

What are you doing in Calgary?

ps: Jimmy Flynn ? when the fuck are you gonna figure out how to spell K e n W r i g h t??? See that big W in the middle? It's silent. Just like the pee in "Shower". But that doesn't mean it's not there.

Geddit, you dumb Yank???

Ooops... that's the Merlot talking... I'm drinking to excess in celebration of our great win over the Moneybag Mancs.

But that's no excuse... I shouldn't have called you a dumb yank. Absolutely unforgivable. I take it back unreservedly...

Or is too late?
James Flynn
65 Posted 01/02/2012 at 02:11:06
Wigan up next. They any good? We are.
Jamie Crowley
66 Posted 01/02/2012 at 02:32:07
That was the Everton I've missed the last year or so.

Heart, determination, blood and guts effort.

Straq was fantastic. Felli was superb. As someone pointed out it was his fair and crunching tackle that led to the goal initially.

Does anyone else love the way Gibson rips it? God we've needed someone who can shoot from distance.

That's the most fun I've had watching Everton since the 5-3 Blackpool game.

Still befuddled at Duffy not starting... but we won and Hibbo was good.
Jamie Crowley
67 Posted 01/02/2012 at 02:40:00
Mchael -

I think I can speak for James as the only other Yank I'm aware of who contributes now and again:

Yes, you can call us dumb Yanks.

Yanks aren't very thin skinned....

And considering I've been on TW for a mere 4 or so years and James I believe is coming up on 2 years... most ppl on this site seemingly have been here for a decade.

Gotta earn your stripes and whatnot
Shaun Brennan
68 Posted 01/02/2012 at 02:52:16
Hi Micheal. I'm working for Hatch Mott Macdonald. Currently working on the LRT extension project, which if you don't know is a new rail line in the west of Calgary.

The weather is completely up and down here at the moment.

Nearly been here for one month.
Jamie Sweet
69 Posted 01/02/2012 at 02:49:58
I believe Michael, that being overseas, and therefore unable to attend any Blue Union march, James has decided to lead his own protest against our chairman by constantly spelling his name incorrectly.

It is a subtle form of protest... far more so than, say, hand-cuffing yourself to a goal post - but it shows initiative and a desire to at least do something to help the cause. I therefore support him fully him in this grammatical onslaught against Bill.

Kenright out!
Paul Ferry
70 Posted 01/02/2012 at 03:05:56
Day-after-day I have knocked Moyes for, I believe, real and deep reasons, that have not been at all resolved by that wonderful disaplay. But we should not this night (In watched the game at 7pm Chicago time), be tapping Moyes out. His face after the final whistle reminded me of how decent and dignified this man is and how much he loves my club. I stopped backing him 3 years ago but tonight I was reminded of why I supported him for 7 years, Please prove me wrong DM. And (1) a new free scoring young striker (2) nuts coming back to where he belongs, in front of our LB LB, for the 1st time in ages I'm feeling great. So, Moyesey, great job tonight, great job in the transfer window,

Please prove me wrong.

CV=OYB
Paul Ferry
71 Posted 01/02/2012 at 03:16:03
Sorry... COYB - not Mike's merlot - what are you doing in Regina? - but a great, really great Malbec - COYB
Michael Kenrick
72 Posted 01/02/2012 at 03:24:48
Hi Paul,

Working on a solution mining project for potash extraction. Saskatchewan is one of the leading producers for potash, which is mined from evaporite beds 1,000 meters below ground. There are 8 or 9 existing mines in the so-called Potash Belt; we're working to get a new one permitted...
Paul Ferry
73 Posted 01/02/2012 at 03:34:27
Mike, I always thought that Evertonians were the smartest people in the world and you've just confirmed that. I was in Regina last year. Enjoy your night. Nice thing for us on this side of the Atlantic is that we get more drinking time to celebrate. Hope you get the permit.

Nuts coming back is filling me with anticipation and exhilaration, and it's lovely thinking what team we might put out this weekend, especially after, what I thought, was a great display by our Denis.
Michael Kenrick
74 Posted 01/02/2012 at 03:35:14
Nice one, Jamie (#425)... including the subtle omission of a letter from my name too. Setting a new precedent... protest noted ? and ignored.

There's a couple more... I think Tom Bowers is in the US, but may not be a true Yank. And Jay Harris is in Florida... lucky bastard has probably retired there. Well, good luck with the local drivers, Jay!

I think you're right: we're all shockingly old and decrepit. But if you can avoid starting every post with "I've supported the Blues since 1948" and similar such bollocks (Yes, Trevor!!!), then I think you're doing okay.

What a goal by Gibbo!!! First time I've roared in weeks. Pity it was deflected... but they all count!
James Flynn
75 Posted 01/02/2012 at 03:32:08
Michael (422) - Look out Kenwrick. Current ownerwship must go, whatever the spellwing.

You possess a permanent pass for me after that fantastic rant a couple seasons ago when we put ManU to the sword.

On the other hand, I assumed you were a wine drinker when you got after me as a "touchy-feely" American in some discussion about LD staying with EFC. Merlot at that! To use an American expression, you fucking pussy.

All that aside, no apology needed Kenwrick. I say with all the spirit of ToffeeWeb, Go fuck yourself!

Michael Kenrick
76 Posted 01/02/2012 at 03:48:41
Paul (#436) ? Had a really good steak at The Keg in Regina, which was hopping. Fillet Mignon, medium rare, Chicago style.

Now call me dumb, been here far too long, but I'd never heard of Chicago style. It was scrummy. As was one gorgeous waitress in a little black dress.... [Down boy!]

It will be great to see Pienaar back and flying down the wing. As for Stracq... willing, yes. But he's a lumbering carthorse. I can remember (for my numerous sins) when we used to slag off Tony Hateley... (Holy Shit ? that dates me!)

Makes you wanna weep!
Zack Yusof
77 Posted 01/02/2012 at 03:52:49
What a match, what a transfer window... one thing's for sure, it's never dull being an Evertonian.

After the pain comes the pleasure and now, I'm passing the time at work trying out some new team line-ups for Wigan this weekend.

How about:

Howard
Hibbert Duffy Heitinga Baines
Donovan Big Hair Gibson Pienaar
Strac Jelavic

Subs: Mucha, Drenthe, Barkley, Vic, Baxter.
Zack Yusof
78 Posted 01/02/2012 at 04:03:04
Speaking of last night's wine, mine was a lovely Zinfadel all the way from LA. Superb stuff..

Here's to more celebratory wine drinking this weekend!!!
Michael Kenrick
79 Posted 01/02/2012 at 03:59:06
Haha, Jimmy, you give as good as you get. Fair play.

Funny you should mention that rant...

Tonight's efforts in L4 by the Boyz in Blue prompted similar thoughts, along the lines of: "If this is what the team can really do, when down to the bare bones, what the fuck has Moyes been playing at for the last six months?!?!?!"

But I'm wearied by such puzzlements, and long since gave up on hoping for a change from Dull & Dour Misery guts. For me, this was simply another episode of Lottery Football: throw out a team and see where they land. Win some; lose some. We all know the House is stacked against us, but we can pitch one against the odds just when least expected... only to return to our losing ways next time.

Ho hum.
Michael Kenrick
80 Posted 01/02/2012 at 04:11:14
Come on, Zack... five subs??? You know the rules.

Add Neville & Vellios. Anichebe may still be injured.

Oh, and we still have McFadden on our books. Apparently.

Talk about coming back down to earth with a bump!
Paul Ferry
81 Posted 01/02/2012 at 04:12:19
Mike - medium rare - perfect - never heard of Chicago style, suspect that might be a Saskatchewan thing. You're not unfair about our Stracg, but for the 1st time since Beckford (Velios apart) I saw an Everton striker earning his pay cheque, chasing, threatening, looking keen, playing for a place. Lovely.

I'm with you on the one great night mode. But at least it feels good in a long while at any rate.

And, with nuts and our new striker who actually scores (and, ha ha Harry, you normally poach from us but we got u this time), that lazy fucker Saha leaving (if he had the decency and dignity that Moyes has, he woukd give nine-tenths of his last six-months salary to charity), I'm opening another malbec. Good luck with the bargaining and wheeling and dealing in Regina
Zack Yusof
82 Posted 01/02/2012 at 04:30:43
Whoops! Sorry Michael.. still buzzing on last night's Zinfadel.. Yes, add Cahill, Vellios and Neville for Vic if injured. We'll leave McFadden aside for another week...

Anyway, it's so great to have options for a change. The sun is shining this morning, the boss is away and plans are being made to bunk off work early. Life is good!!!

Keep up the great work Toffeeweb!!

James Flynn
83 Posted 01/02/2012 at 03:55:58
Jamie (425) - Kenwrick has nailed his purse to the mast with a bottle of Merlot as a hammer.

Nuf said.

By the bye - Since every team in the AL East has strengthed its pitching, what's up with your Sox? Henry's paying too much attention to the Shite?

Gotta be kind of fucked-up for you, no?
Peter Bourke
84 Posted 01/02/2012 at 04:31:26
Zack...did we lose Cahill during the transfer window??
Zack Yusof
85 Posted 01/02/2012 at 04:38:47
Peter, I think with the new options that we now have, we now have the choice of not having to play Cahill every week, regardless of form, I think.

Having said that, Tim did have a good run out last night though so, as Michael posted earlier, it has to be a place on the subs bench for him in my team for this weekend.
John Daley
86 Posted 01/02/2012 at 04:11:30
Fair to say I was a bit fucking bemused at the decision to drop Duffy and play our short arse veteran right back at centre half. I thought Hibbert and his diminutive Dutch mate would really struggle against the height of Dzeko but I'll hold my hands up and admit that I called it wrong. The pair of them were pretty much faultless all game. Still think it represents a bit of a kick in the cock for Duffy though...

I'll also admit to a slight attitude change towards Heitinga. He's alway struck me as, well, a bit of a twat really with his tendency to jump out of a challenge flying firmly in the face of his fist pumping, fake hardman histrionics. However, in the absence of Distin and Jagielka, he's really stepped up to the plate and seems to be relishing the responsibility of being the defensive leader.

"As for Stracq... willing, yes. But he's a lumbering carthorse."

Well, he put in a superb shift last night and ran himself to a standstill but he also showed some neat touches, brought others into play and held the ball up well. I'd certainly rather have him on the pitch than Anichebe, who's got less fight, less awareness, less aerial ability, and looks less like Leatherface from the Texas Chainsaw Massacre, than Stracqualarsi. If he's a 'lumbering carthorse than big Vic must be a lumbering 'My Little Pony'.
Jamie Crowley
87 Posted 01/02/2012 at 05:09:34
I think the My Little Pony jingle may be the most contagiously annoying jingle ever created.

Every time I ever heard that stupid song pimping up the little girls dream toy it stuck in my head for hours, no matter how much I wanted it gone.

A pony with a pink mane you can comb. Seriously.

Describes Vic perfectly
Michael Kenrick
88 Posted 01/02/2012 at 05:32:37
Sorry, Jimmy lad (#453) I don't follow rounders. It's a bit girlie, isn't it.

And why are they always wearing pyjamas?
Devin Massopust
89 Posted 01/02/2012 at 06:37:06
Saw some other Yanks posting so I thought I'd give it a go seeing I'm from the heartland of the States. The first time I knew it was Everton for me was two years ago when I watched them play City at Goodison. They gave it all they had and the atmosphere was tangible from here in the States sitting in my living room. Reminded me alot of tonight.
COYB
Anto Byrne
90 Posted 01/02/2012 at 05:47:51
Moyes to Duffy 'Don't be a fucking smartarse and try to play football. Hoof the fucking thing down to Denis for a bit of Argy Bargy... no wait, you ain't playing."

Astounding decision and typical no-brainer to bench a young kid and tell him you don't have any confidence in him on the big stage. FFS it's no wonder I'm not the £65k-a-week manager of EFC ? I wouldn't never in a million years have dreamt of playing a right back at centre half who for the last 600+ games has only ever played right back.

Maybe he can play up forward as well.
David Ellis
91 Posted 01/02/2012 at 06:52:36
Michael K at 460
I think that comment knocking baseball is a bit uncalled for (and not very original). Whilst on the topic of baseball, and in a vague attempt at bringing this back onto EFC matters, you ought to watch the film Moneyball (or better still read the book). Its about a club struggling to compete in a league against much richer clubs...sound familiar. And finding a way of doing it, by being smart about how they placed a market value on players.

Accountants have done analysis of transfer fees and their effect on results on the pitch. This shows no correlation between success and the amount of transfer fees. There is a very close correlation between the wage bill and success.

They also show that players start to decline in value after the age of 28 - so that is ususally a good time to sell them because their performances tend to decline before their value does (perception takes a while to catch up with reality).

So to succeed
- pay good wages to keep your best players
- accept any offers for players aged 28-29
- don't pay transfer fees

This may be counter intuitive - but that's why clubs do not do these things, and as a result mis-price players. The data shows this quite clearly.
Steve Yoder
92 Posted 01/02/2012 at 07:32:17
Think earlier comments re Straq a bit unkind--he made some excellent passes tonight to set up play, so it is clear he has some vision and creativity, attributes missing this last half season at Everton. He was dead on his feet for the last 15 minutes he was in, but he never stopped running.
Hibbo was a surprisingly great substitution.
Cahill was quiet, but you kind of expect that by strikers against Man City. He ran a good deal, so that's a positive.
I'm loathe to say it as a Yank, but Donovan had a poor game overall. A few nice plays, but a poor first touch and he often isn't on the same page for passing with his teammates. Still a good addition overall.
The great thing was the hustle, and the way all of the team moved to the ball. So many poor goals have been conceded, or not scored, due to lack of effort. Tonight was different; no matter where the free ball lie, every man moved toward it. Inspired.
Martin Mason
93 Posted 01/02/2012 at 07:42:18
Isn't it amazing that when things couldn't really have got much worse that we produce a staggering performance like last night, we get two good players at the end of the transfer window, Moyes makes a brilliant choice of Hibbert at CB and all of a sudden Straqualursi comes of age. The man least likely to in my opinion too. They say that the darkest hour is before dawn and maybe, just maybe we have reached the bottom and turned around.

Steve, Donovan was very good he laid the goal on and had a very good all round game. Nothing spectacular but good hard yards.

Fellaini wis magnificent.
Sam Hoare
94 Posted 01/02/2012 at 07:51:54
Great result and great to see some of the 'haters' giving moyes credit where due. Combined with a new striker and the return of a favourite son things are suddenly looking alot better and I think the freshness that we have been needing is upon us.

Will be interesting to see who gets the starting strikers spot with the arrival of jelavic and Denis playing so well last night. Can't see him going 2 up front but maybe I'm wrong.
Martin Mason
95 Posted 01/02/2012 at 08:17:39
I'm sorry, Heitinga was magnificent last night. How can he be dropped? He will be.
Andy Crooks
96 Posted 01/02/2012 at 08:17:51
Indeed Sam,freshness is upon us. A magnificent effort. I was upset about Duffy but Hibbert played a blinder.It's been a good week for Everton and credit to Moyes for getting that performance.
Joe McMahon
97 Posted 01/02/2012 at 08:25:01
This is exactly where JH should play, not in midfield. Thats his pisition, I much prefer him to Jaqs. We restricted City, just wish we didn't have everyone back for corners. Good to see SP back, pity only a loan. Wht did Monaco Arry buy him?
Joe McMahon
98 Posted 01/02/2012 at 08:29:38
Sorry should say - Why did Monaco Arry buy him?
Paul Ward
99 Posted 01/02/2012 at 07:58:06
How refreshingly different todays comments are. We still have the same problems off the field but for once I think the team deserve all the credit they get for such a brave performance. Let us not kid ouselves most of the skill and possession was with City but Everton battled all the way. I have seen every game this season and this was the first time I have been entertained by them. The main question is will we be back to our normal shit against Wigan.
James McPherson
100 Posted 01/02/2012 at 08:48:47
In this past year I have been critical of Moyes. My criticism has centred upon his desire and passion that in my eyes was dwindling and being replaced with an all too public acceptance that we can never compete.

Well last night reminded me of the Moyes of old. It was wonderful to see. Fire, passion and unbridled delight that his team did so well. That attitude clearly transferred itself to the pitch. I cannot recall an Everton team working so hard. STraq, yes slightly limited in ability, but an absolute trojan in his work ethic. No better example for Jelavic to see what is required in the PL.

Well done David Moyes. Well done Everton. Lets hope it's a corner turned and we can channel that energy and desire game in game out.

If I were Moyes I would show a VT of Mancini before every game. "THought it would be easier". Damning of Everton, even more damning of himself.
Kevin Tully
101 Posted 01/02/2012 at 09:20:22
I have slagged off Straq before last night and cringed when the team is announced, but fair play, he puts a shift in.

I still think he is a below average player, but he somehow raises the crowd. Instead of trying to beat two or three men as Saha always did, he keeps it simple. Bring the ball down, lay it off and run, not too fucking difficult eh Louis?

With a good run in the cup, we can all start to hopefully get back to talking about the football for the rest of the season. We all deserve something to shout about.
Tommy Coleman
102 Posted 01/02/2012 at 09:36:26
Lyndon - How could you give Drenthe 5 ?
He was a contstant thorn in City's side. I'd give him 8. He was the main player posing questions of their defense. Not that everything came off for him of course but he was the main man going forward.

Nice to wake up this morning being a Toffee, some good signings and a great result.

COYB
Scott Hamilton
103 Posted 01/02/2012 at 09:44:40
Hibbert 7. Drenthe 5. FFS!!!

Paul Foster
104 Posted 01/02/2012 at 09:44:50
About 9 or 10 of the first dozen posters (above) must have their tails between their legs this morning.

Some absolutely ridiculous abuse of Moyes for picking a defender with 10 years of top-flight experience (during which he has faced some of the world's best strikers week after week) ahead of a young had with about 180 minutes of top-flight experience (and only about 800 minutes at any professional level). Duffy may become a great talent. He may not. But at this stage, I know who I'd rather have facing and tackling Aguero - one of the most technically gifted players in the league.

Great performance, great win. Oh, and great team selection.
Lawrence Stolworthy
105 Posted 01/02/2012 at 09:41:53
Finally a decent performance against a good side. Ok, so Citeh were a bit below par and still had a few chances but we defended like Spartans and even attacked a bit. Egg on the faces of Mancini and Lescott & Co again! And Mancini thought we were there for the taking....damn cheek.

Straq was immense again....he may well be a little limited in his all round ability but I don't think he has reached his limit yet. He is getting fitter, faster and sharper and should now get a run of a few games to harrass defenders. If we have a striker that runs and runs and drags defenders out of position we end up with a bit of space for midfielders like Cahill to move into to score.
We should sign up Straq for his heart alone and hopefully BK can pull a few strings and find a bit of cash to allow Moyes to sign Drenthe on a permanent deal. We need to keep him as he is the only player we have with genuine attacking flair and a turn of pace and we'll need him more than ever when Donovan and Peanut leave again.
Ray Robinson
106 Posted 01/02/2012 at 10:03:47
Fantastic performance last night but is anyone else slighly concerned at the attendance last night? Less than 30,000 with City taking their full allocation. Doesn't bode well for the future does it?

Sorry to put a damper on things on a night when the commitment and effort were back in abundance. Those who did turn up provided brilliant support as a result.
Anthony Flack
107 Posted 01/02/2012 at 10:08:38
I could not get to the game, watched it on Sky - summary from my old man who did go, hits the mark for me

A magnificent performance by a team well drilled by Moyes to frustrate and put City out of their stride. Hibbert was a masterstroke by Moyes, against two small skilful forwards who might have embarrassed Duffy on the ground, but who knows? For me Hibbert shaded it for man of the match over Heitinger who was excellent also. Gibson was poor again, but I am convinced he is not yet tuned up and not match fit after all he had not played much at all for 2 years. Once he gets into the scheme of things and his role and properly fit he should be OK. Drenthe a few flashes of excellence but mostly a waste of space. There is something wrong in his head and I do not believe that can be changed even by Moyes. Kenwright deserves great credit for missing the game to stay in London to persuade Levy to let Piennaar come back on loan. Harry had said no very late on cos he failed to get a foreign player in time. Piennaar is a brilliant addition for 6 months. He was on the bench for Spurs last night! Stracqu was superb last night. Moyes was right when he said last week that suddenly it has clicked for him and all the fitness, training hard work and willingness to learn has borne fruit. On another day he would have been man of the match for me. He led the line brilliantly. Sign him on. Add in the Croat and onwards and upwards we go. I would not have said that two days ago.
Jamie Barlow
108 Posted 01/02/2012 at 10:38:56
Brilliant display from the boys last night and long may it continue.

I haven't felt this good for quite a while even though nursing a very sore head and a swollen face.

Its not often very hard to pick a Man of the Match but i'm struggling today. Hibbert was fantastic. Felli was everywhere and was as cool as ice. Johnny came very close and should be player of the month for his recent displays with Duffy but my choice goes to Denis. He's an animal. Lescott and Kompany didn't know what had hit them. There was a point in about the 70th minute where he chased someone for about 40 yards and then just collapsed but jumped straight back up to close down again. I've not seen a forward put in that much effort for years. He got Goodison rocking and thats half the battle. Its a great place to be when its rocking under the lights. Great to see him get a standing ovation from every part of the ground.

I can't stop smiling today.

David Bridge
109 Posted 01/02/2012 at 11:10:53
Best ive seen us player this season and most of last season. Atmposphere electric every player put massive effort into the game Strac was amazing good touch, strong, held the ball well. COYB
Andy Crooks
110 Posted 01/02/2012 at 14:45:53
Paul Foster, as one of the posters you refer to I can assure you that I am elated this morning and extremely happy to have been wrong. I was gutted for Duffy and felt that it was an appalling decision.

Of course Hibbert plays a blinder and Moyes is vindicated, credit to him. Just one of the reasons he earns £3million a year and I don't. Still I'd have Duffy ahead of Hibbert against Wigan.
Nelly Verdonghan
111 Posted 01/02/2012 at 15:20:46
Well Guys I have to hold my hands up....I slaughtered Moyes before kick off for his centre back selection but I have to say both Heitinga & Hibbert were tremendous last night....so time to eat some humble pie....I'm not to proud to say I was wrong.

Must say I didn't agree with Davie Proven's choice for MOM tho'...I thought it was Denis by a country mile. Straq ran & chased after everything and covered more ground in one game than that lazy waster Saha has in 2 seasons ....absolutely made up that conman has gone to Spurs to be a burden on their wage bill instead of ours.

Just hope this is the first of many similar performances by both Straq and the team in general. He is by no means the finished article but his raw energy and commitment was a joy to see and the absolute minimum that should be given by EVERY player in EVERY game. I certainly hope Anichebe took note of Denis's work rate and willingness to put opposing defenders under pressure.

I have been very critical of our style of play this season but if we can produce performances like last night on a regular basis then all may not be lost after all...just hope the manager continues in the same vein at the weekend and does not revert to type on Saturday.
Brian Waring
112 Posted 01/02/2012 at 16:14:36
We haven't had anything to shout about this season, last night, there was plenty. Superb performance, and when the fans are in full roar, there is no louder, or better.
Credit all round.


Tony J Williams
113 Posted 01/02/2012 at 17:18:55
Stracq couldn't keep that up for more than a handfull of games, the poor lad will be knackered
Terry McLavey
114 Posted 01/02/2012 at 20:08:43
Spurs fan at work said "Harry" was good at getting the best out of players,well good luck with saha ! so it just tax returns he not too good with ?!!!
Mick Davies
115 Posted 02/02/2012 at 00:43:02
A full blooded performance against a side very out of sorts. Apart from Heitinga and Howard, all our players made some blunders but we got through with passion, something we haven't seen for a long time until glimpses against Fulham.

I think Straq deserves a run in the team, possibly alongside Jellyfish. As for Hibbert, that was the most stupid of all the stupid decisions Moyes has made this season. He was found out almost every time there was a one to one and he should have given 2 pens away. One when he felled Nasri and the other when he allowed Lescott to get around him so he had to push him into Howard and lucky for us, we got a free kick.

If it wasn't for Jonny on the spot, we would have been beaten tonite and he's been working well with Duffy so let's hope this partnership is reunited against Wigan. With the new signings, especially Peanuts coming back, our squad is now at its strongest for a long time and if we don't have a decent cup run, at least the semis, then Moyes has no excuse about investment, he has to go.
Paul McGinty
116 Posted 02/02/2012 at 03:38:57
Mick, come back to us. Fact is we didnt concede.
Hibbo had a really good game. He and Heitinga played Citys two expensive
strikers off the park. Moyes was vindicated in his selection this time. I do agree with you on the Duffy , Heitinga partnership. On the plus side , its good to have options. Others will have better memories; Hasnt Hibbo played centre back away in Europe (Bate?) in another win, so the manager had seen him before playing in an unnatural position.
Peter Bourke
117 Posted 02/02/2012 at 04:14:25
Mick Davies.
You cannot be serious. Hibbert was one of the best on the park and Man City had only one decent shot on goal. It was a masterclass in defending and a brilliant piece of management by Moyes.
Your bending of the truth regarding two apparent penalties he should have given away made me laugh.
Andrew Sherry
118 Posted 02/02/2012 at 05:40:37
Joe McMahon #482/3 - I don't think we should exclude the possibility that they bought Pienaar just to deprive us of his services - there was an opportunity to weaken their main rivals for a European place, for a mere 2.5 million and wages that, to a club as rich as Spurs, amount to small change. Plus they have a fairly decent back-up for left mid. Blinding piece of business, and it worked.

Now that they have moved up a level and no longer see us as rivals, we can have him back, no problem.

They did something similar with the two Kyles from Leeds a few years ago.
Eric Myles
119 Posted 02/02/2012 at 06:18:52
^Andrew, I think those 2 Kyles were from Sheffield United?
Mick Davies
120 Posted 02/02/2012 at 16:28:49
"Mick Davies.
You cannot be serious. Hibbert was one of the best on the park"
Sorry Peter but it's you who isn't being serious. He never did anything what we could call a saving tackle, Heitinga did about 4. Baines, Neville, Fellaini and Gibson all protected him and when he did have contact with their players he almost gave away (but we got lucky) two pens. Got roasted on the half way line and even when he chased back he ended up on the floor as usual, looking like the Herbert he is. He is absolute garbage and Duffy's confidence, which must have been sky high lately, has probably been dented by this pathetic change of a tall capable young CH for a short, incapable RB who was just returning from injury. Good man-management by Moyes that
Dave Wilson
121 Posted 02/02/2012 at 16:57:04
Mick

where did you watch the game from ? behind the couch ?

What makes you think you can tell us Hibbert was poor and was lucky not to give away penalties ? do you think we didnt watch it ?

Hibbert has his critics, but he was terrific against City and has rightly been praised on by Evertonians all over the world.

Brian Waring
122 Posted 02/02/2012 at 17:32:05
Mick, whilst Aguero done Hibbert a few times, overall he had a great game.
Ian Smitham
123 Posted 02/02/2012 at 08:38:15
Mick, Talking of "the most stupid of all the stupid", there are some pretty stupid posts on here at times. At Right back he would have had his work cut out, to be asked to play centre back against possibly the Worlds' most expensive strikers, which he did without moaning for our cause is a credit to him and a discredit to those who can not see it. Worse, for those who choose not to see it.
Mick Davies
124 Posted 03/02/2012 at 02:46:43
It's a good job Nevin isn't still playing, he'd probably be in instead of Heitinga.. So we won because of Hibbert? or did we win in spite of Hibbert? We can all draw our own conclusions but City were poor and they have been since Yaya left for Africa. To play a shortarse right back in place of a young and promising centre half was shameful. What that will do to him is show where he lies in the pecking order i.e. behind a 31 year old unfit useless twat
Peter Bourke
125 Posted 03/02/2012 at 03:01:42
It was a stroke of genius by Moyes Mick.
And what it will do to Duffy is make him work even harder to get his spot back and make him a better player.
I didn't realise Hibbo is unfit. He was part of a backline that schooled City's much heralded attack and played the full 94 odd minutes, yeh he is super unfit.
Tony J Williams
126 Posted 03/02/2012 at 09:17:49
"To play a shortarse right back in place of a young and promising centre half was shameful"

Or to put it in terms of rational human beings, to play the most European capped Everton defender, who is strong in the tackle in place of a young lad who has played 3 games for us against a team who has scored the same amount of goal in 20 games that they had all of last season.

Hibbert haters hate!
Ian Smitham
127 Posted 03/02/2012 at 18:43:46
Tony, quite right. I was taught that when in a hole one should stop digging. I would add that maybe when in a minority of one, one ought to stop embarrassing oneself.

Credibility-Nil
Andy Crooks
128 Posted 03/02/2012 at 19:13:08
I said before the game that dropping Duffy was an appalling decision and I bow to no one in my championing of him. However, Hibbert was excellent and I believe Moyes's decision was fully vindicated. I think Duffy should start against Wigan,though.
Peter Warren
129 Posted 03/02/2012 at 19:50:21
Agree with any I thought decision was bad but hold my hands up hibbert wAs excellent. But different game against Wigan and duffy who has been great every game I see him should start. Duffy and heisting a can both play footy too
Alex Mullan
130 Posted 03/02/2012 at 20:04:39
Mick 979,

What shite are you on about, claiming we may have won 'in spite of Hibbert'. Hibbert could easily have been MotM. Id say it was a toss up between him, Heitinga and Strac.

Did you even see the game? Shoulda' gone to spec savers if you did fella.
Ian Smitham
131 Posted 03/02/2012 at 21:51:07
Andy, I think he picked a horse for a course, I think he was protecting a young player from what could have got really ugly. As I went to the game I was thinking we could be on for a real beating, which in this case might destroy Duffy.

That said, the previous home game I saw him at I thought he was excellent and wrote same on here.

On that basis I say restore to CB, play him along side JH who I also believe has been excellent and a mentor.

As for Tony, make him RB as to "drop" him would really be an insult.

That then leaves the issue of the RB displaced, which is a conundrum for Mr Moyes, but not for me. on the evidence of what I have seen this season, benchwarmer, though bearing in mind the weather, that may well be a challenge in itself.
John Sreet
132 Posted 03/02/2012 at 22:00:40
Hibbert was awesome, those who are blind cannot see, but those who can see but choose not to are simply prejudiced or dumb!
Ian Smitham
133 Posted 03/02/2012 at 22:22:21
John, The exact point I made at #009, Glad I am not the only one who has that view.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads