The commercial and marketing aspect of Everton has for a long time been a bit of a pet hate of mine. Following a Twitter Q and A last night with our Head of Communications, Paul Tyrell, I’ve decided to try and put my thoughts into words.

For the last couple of months, Evertonains have been excited having Nike as our kit supplier, eager to get down the two Everton stores and start buying the gear. One big problem though has been the length of time it has taken for the new home kit to be released.

A full 42 days after Liverpool’s home kit went on sale, Everton’s can now be pre-ordered.

I asked Paul Tyrell about this, also asking why a club that is skint always messes up simple marketing. His reply was thus: "It’s not messed up. With the world’s biggest sportswear manufacturer you have to take your place in the queue. With a lower level brand, you can dictate."

Why then have other teams (lower league than us) who have Nike as their supplier, have had their kits out to purchase?

Now I’m sorry, but for me, his response was a very poor excuse and sums up the poor attitude Everton’s senior staff has regarding trying to drive the club forward.

Kids are the prime wearers of football kits and they love nothing more than showing off the new kit on their summer holidays. Why then do we not release kits in plenty of time for parents to purchase prior to these holidays?

Also, if you want a woman’s kit, a small kid’s kit, or need, ahem, a very large kit, then you’re screwed.

Back to when Keith Wyness took over as CEO, one of the first things he did was outsource our merchandising to JJB. On the face of it, it looked a bizarre thing to do... but, when you considered that the club was somehow losing money on this side of the business, I thought it became the sensible thing for him to do — turning a loss into an instant profit after only being in the job a few months.

We had a Liverpool city centre store, which was followed up with stores in Birkenhead and Ellesmere Port. However, these stores soon closed with the club citing our partnership with JJB as the reason due to them needing control of stores selling Everton merchandise. Which sounded strange considering Rangers had a similar agreement with JJB at the time but still had a club shop in Glasgow city centre.

Where Wyness went wrong, in my opinion, was in sitting back on the JJB deal. Instead, he should have brought people in to work in the commercial and marketing team with the job description of planning and setting out a strategy which could be implemented once the JJB deal ended, and then have the confidence of running the club’s merchandise ourselves.

Despite numerous complaints from supporters about how obtaining Everton shirts at JJB stores was, shall we say, problematic, and visually the Everton section in the JJB store in Williamson Square was near non-existent, the club renewed the their deal two years later for £10m over five years.

Still, the same problems persisted. Impossible for those outside Liverpool to go to a shop and buy a shirt, the non-kit wear range was poor, kits being released late into the summer, and on one occasion after the season had started!

The misspelling of Nil Satis Nisi Optimum on the kits, the stripes on the One 2 One kit being upside down, the change in the badge (the unnecessary inclusion of 1878 and Everton), also drew complaints.

Following Keith Wyness leaving of the club, Robert Elstone took over. When the second JJB deal ended in 2009 he signed a similar agreement with Kitbag worth a whopping £30million…. over ten years though. Again, Everton not having the confidence or nous to run our own merchandising. Although, one good thing did come of it instantly: Kitbag demanding a city centre store, which also produced the idea for Everton 2 (in) Liverpool 1. I have to say, that is a quality gimmick!

Now, why can’t Everton employ the people necessary to run our own merchandising? Why do we have to tie ourselves into deals which limit what we can do?

The only way you can buy merchandise from Everton is from either of the two club shops in Liverpool, or online. Now that to me is dreadful. We should be selling our gear in as many shops as possible, in as many areas as possible. Be imaginative in creating a ‘brand’ which people want to buy into.

Now I don’t have all the answers in this regard as I’ve only an hour to write this up before work starts again, but there are simple things that we could do.

Having a store in Australia with a cardboard cut-out of Tim Cahill in the window. It doesn’t have to be flashy, or big, just a simple shop where Aussies can easily buy stuff to do with their biggest football star with Everton reaping the benefit. Plus, with the connection formed with Tim Howard and especially Landon Donovan, the USA market is also there to be exploited.

I’m sat having my lunch in an office where there is currently a massive cruise liner holding 3,080 people sitting outside. Now it sounds pretty basic, but why aren’t there any girls from the Everton 2 store standing there with vouchers for the shop? I know it doesn’t sound much, but if just 2.5% of passengers decided to take a look, that’s 75 extra people in the shop. Money in our till instead of their pockets, it all adds up.

When we got into Europe, why did the club not sell any suitable merchandise for this? Instead, fans had to buy t-shirts and hats from other fans who had designed and got these manufactured themselves.

Why when people land into John Lennon Airport is there not a proper Everton presence there? It’s like this city only has one club and we are not it...

We’re off to play two games in Indonesia this summer; it will be interesting to see if the club have put some plans in place to make some money while there.

All-in-all, it is my belief – and I’ve thought this for a number of years – that Everton Football Club’s commercial and marketing strategy is an absolute disgrace for a club of our size and stature, and that so much more could be done to increase this income stream if we had people employed on that side of the business with a bit of creativity and imagination.

For a club that’s skint, we need to increase every revenue stream we can – and this side of things ought to be a priority.

Share this article


Reader Comments (29)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ben Howard
1 Posted 12/07/2012 at 14:46:07
"The misspelling of Nil Satis Nisi Optimum on the kits".
Wow Adam, I'd never heard of this monumental cock up! As an editor myself I'm astounded that could have been allowed to happen. The mind boggles!
Thomas Lennon
2 Posted 12/07/2012 at 14:40:34
I agree to some extent, though it is easy to sit back and come up with a few attractive sounding ideas and a lot harder to design a cohesive, consistent marketing strategy. I read one a few years back when it was stated that people outside the city could not buy goods so the club concentrated on improving the online offering - which has been very successful.

Living well outside the city I have seen the occasional attempt to sell in other outlets in the past and all have flopped - no-one buys the stuff whereas the usual top 5 + 1 or 2 do.

That was back in the days when the range was awful - perhaps now is the time to expand and indeed it is now possible to get Everton merchandising in huge outlets such as Argos, K&Co, Littlewoods when I have rarely seen that before - albeit limited in scope.

We are gradually improving and that probably reflects the range provided by Kitbag - which vindicates the outsourcing strategy to some extent.

Michael Byrne
3 Posted 12/07/2012 at 14:55:24
I have to say that I agree with you regarding the clubs presence in the airport, and even in the city, outside of the club shops. I travel over to matches as often as possible and if you didn't know better you would think that there was only one club in the city, and it's not the one in blue!!

In the City Centre, outside of the Everton 2 store, there is very little presence. I'd even got further than your cruise line suggestion and say why don't the club on home game weekends (not necessarily all of them) run promotions by placing club shop vouchers in hotels that are popular with travelling supporters. I for one never fail to visit the club shop when over and would easily spend more in if this kind of scheme existed.

If the regular "Joe" on the street can come up with a myriad of ideas, why can't anyone in the club do the same???
James Thomas
4 Posted 12/07/2012 at 14:48:47
Good article. The depressing thing is that we get this same article every year. Even when we catch up with the rest of the league and finally get someone like Nike making our kits, we still can’t take advantage. The excuse from the club that “you have to wait” is also bullshit, as you point out. Nike do not have one man who sits in an office designing kits saying “well it’s Man U first, and then Barca, and then….”. They assign people to each client. And this is not a Nike-specific problem. Our kit ALWAYS comes out way into the summer. What happened to wearing next years kit on the final game of the season? Why do the club almost actively seek to fail to make money?!

Another example of the inherent stupidity of those running the clubs commercial operations is the Evertonia membership. I live in London and so do not have a season ticket, but still like to get to as many home and away games as time and money dictate I can. Thanks to the good people at ESCLA I can get to most away games I want to (except when the club fuck up again and fail to get enough tickets - like QPR away this year) but for home games if I want to choose where I sit I have to go directly through the club. Therefore, I buy Evertonia membership for myself and my father each year so we can get better seats by buying our tickets earlier. My membership expired on 31 May and so I presumed I could just go online and renew it, and give the club £40 of money. But no, the Evertonia membership section on the website is still imploring me to buy my 2011-12 membership. WHY? Why can’t you just update the fucking scheme and let me give you money?! The slogan “Timing is everything. Get in there first” seems more and more mocking every time I read it.

Michael Byrne
5 Posted 12/07/2012 at 14:59:23
I also think the kit just being available online is madness! I live in Ireland and know of literally dozens of supporters clubs here, and it's easier to get a West Ham United shirt than an Everton one in my local city sport's shop!!
Nick Parker
6 Posted 12/07/2012 at 15:11:43
Great article.

The same applies to the marketing of Peanuts, Yobo & Yakubu. The African market is massive and every time I go to South Africa all I see is the usual suspects such as Man U, Arsenal, Shite

Steve Smith
7 Posted 12/07/2012 at 15:43:18
The new kit should be on sale as soon as the season finishes, this same mistake is repeated year after year along with any number of marketing gaffs that the club makes on a regular basis, having said that, having stuff available in sports shops throughout the globe means nothing I'm afraid, you might possibly sell a few more kits, but nowhere near enough to make it viable, success creates demand, get things right on the pitch and the other stuff will follow.
Rob Keys
8 Posted 12/07/2012 at 15:30:50
I agree with the article really. However, I don't think that the inclusion of 1878 and Everton is that bad a move. It's not as if the logo hasn't changed at all. Even in the 80s, there were not so subtle changes.

As what we have realised, people don't necessarily know Everton anymore. So to have that emblem of the tower isn't really gonna make too much sense to others. Having the year of our formation, and the name of the club spelt out so that others know about us isn't that bad, is it?

Jimmy Kelly
9 Posted 12/07/2012 at 16:27:20
I understand the points people are making but I think we need to be careful with the idea of 'if I can think of good ideas why can't they?'.

As pointed out above, you can offer as much merchandise as you want, but if nobody buys it it's not a good idea.

When I was on my graduate placement I worked in a marketing department for a large Building Society. They had loads of seemingly really good ideas but when they did market research people just didn't go for them. Similarly, they did some things off the cuff to try to generate business which ended up losing money. The head of that department is now a multi millionaire with his own advertising agency so he certainly wasn't incompetent - people just didn't want the products.

Don't get me wrong we've had our fair share of issues with this sort of thing but it's not quite as easy to turn around as you might think.

Tony J Williams
10 Posted 12/07/2012 at 16:26:43
Steve, they used to play in the new kit on the last day of the season. You used to be able to pre order it and wear it for the final game.

They are shite at customer service but if Nike don't produce it until a certain date, we are screwed. I see where he is coming from: we could dictate our orders to LCS but not the global giant Nike.

Andy Crooks
11 Posted 12/07/2012 at 18:01:23
Adam, I hope you have sent a copy of this article to Bill Kenwright and that you will update us on his response or lack of.
Jordan Maloney
12 Posted 12/07/2012 at 20:46:47
I agree... Everton lack behind the rest of the league when it comes to commercial deals, up to £4 million per season from the joint Kitbag/Nike deal which is to supply the kits and sell the merchandise... that's shite!! Then we only get upto £4 million per season from Chang Beer!! £8 million per season from our 3 main partners... that's crap if you ask me!!

No wonder we're skint when you compare us to other sides in the Premier League. Sunderland have just signed a new shirt sponsorship deal with 'Invest in Africa' reportedly worth around £20 million per season!! What's going on at Everton?? Why do we lack so badly in commercial deals??.......

And another thing: Why does Rupert the Bear always wear yellow chequered kecks??..... cos he's a twat!!
Barry Rathbone
13 Posted 12/07/2012 at 21:25:22
Once you recognise Kenwright's vested interest you don't worry about this stuff anymore, his "REAL" business is doing very well doubtless aided by being a high profile chairman - and for a hobby you can't knock it - wish I could find something similar.

The TV money is guaranteed, the fans (give or take a few thousand) turn up like sheep and a player sold every season covers the 5 million loss without murmur.

Why put time, effort and money into stuff like marketing when you don't have to?

Noel Early
14 Posted 12/07/2012 at 22:06:43
Good piece, Adam. I live in Ireland and it sickens me that I never see an Everton jersey anywhere... for instance, last Xmas a mother of a young lad I had converted into a Toffee rang me up in a panic asking me where she could get a jersey as no shop had them stocked. She couldn't believe it when I told her that online ordering was the only possible chance. As it happens, I knew my buddy was going over for the match just before Xmas so I arranged him to get etc etc etc.........

This is a disgrace; 20 years back, Everton were one of the best supported clubs over here but it has lost a great fanbase over shear neglect and poor marketing. Every kid wants a new jersey over the summer to show off to his mates, we must be losing out on millions. Whoever runs the marketing side of the club would want to be placed on the transfer list and free up some funds for Moyes.

Totally agree with you Barry, TV money is guaranteed so no need to put the effort in.

Richard Dodd
15 Posted 13/07/2012 at 09:38:45
Why wait for the season to start when you can get on with hammering the Club a month in advance?

So much negativity pre-season may be par for the course but is hardly justified.
Matt Traynor
16 Posted 13/07/2012 at 09:54:52
Ben #450, yes, years ago the club signed off on a kit design that mis-spelled our motto with an "n" instead of "m" - i.e. "Optinum". I was at an away match in Blackburn in the early 90s (we won 3-2), and I noticed it on the famous "salmon pink" away shirt a poor lad next to us was wearing. Having grilled him as to whether it was a knock off, we sought out some other fans (at least with an away ground there was a good mix of club gear) and sure enough, it was a production mistake.

On the whole Nike thing - who is the deal actually with - is it with Everton or Kitbag? Whilst the £32m, ten year deal with Kitbag seems good, it's horrendous for that length of time, and I wonder what "rights of control" we still retain? I think because it was guaranteed revenue (and could therefore be borrowed against) Everton were only to happy to sign.

david howells
17 Posted 13/07/2012 at 18:01:52
Just another example of how poorly the club has been run. It also adds fuel to the debate we have in work of where the money goes??? But after reading that, we clearly don't try hard enough to get cash in.
Peter Warren
18 Posted 14/07/2012 at 08:07:05
Bought 6 season tickets one season and transpired that one of the seats was a guy who had sat in same seat for 20 years and EFC just cocked up. Felt sorry for guy but not much I could do. What did EFC do ?

They gave guy his season ticket for his seat BUT didn't tell us. only when I went to next game my season ticket didn't work. Thought nothing of it and guy at turns tall just let me in. Then the guy told me what happened. Meaning 5 of us in same seats
and I was put in a total random seat miles away.

I won't bore you with rest of story but have loads showing their catering , food, tickets sales, merchandise is appalling and sure everybody does. They have a magnificent feel and people about the club but its run like a school tuck shop

GJ Butler
19 Posted 14/07/2012 at 08:47:51
Noel, I feel your pain. The fact you cannot buy an Everton top in Ireland in 2012 is mind boggling when you think about it. I managed to brainwash a 6 year old nephew into supporting the blues by way of dressing him in anything Everton since birth, but now he is at an age where in school he sees all his mates with lunchboxes, schoolbags, pencil cases tracksuits and jerseys of all the other top clubs - and if he walks into a sports shop over here that's all he sees - try explaining to a kid in a shop that he's not getting a Man Utd lunchbox, but you'll take him home instead, open up the laptop and let him see all the wonderfull stuff Everton have in a warehouse across the water. I fear Irish Evertonians are a dying breed, no new blood coming through, and who can blame them?
Steve Cotton
20 Posted 14/07/2012 at 13:24:59
Can we not ask someone at the club to look into this marketing farce and come back to us with:

1. Reasons why it has got so bad;
2. What they can do to improve it;
3. Who is actually running this ship... cos from where I am sitting, it seems that we are clueless from the neck up; and
4. Please give us a Liaison Officer who will listen to the gripes and then promise to sort out. LFC have at least two that I know of and they are leagues ahead in this department.
Chris Butler
21 Posted 14/07/2012 at 16:23:13
Everton FC are useless at marketing and making money that's why we're skint. The ridiculous pink away shirt in 2010-11 I mean come on, how many lads are going to walk round wearing a pink shirt?

I've given up going to matches because I'm sick of the way the club treats fans. The fact they've chosen AEK Athens as pre-season friendly opponents, how many people are going to want to attend that? If we could of got somebody like Ajax, Celtic or Napoli more fans would attend.

Also ticket prices: the club's ridiculous decision to put up ticket prices has caused many fans to not attend anymore. We rely on loyal supporters so putting up prices in times of reccession is a bad idea, that's why attendances have dropped.
Steve Cotton
22 Posted 14/07/2012 at 18:39:54
Is this why the average age of an Evertonian these days just gets older? Not enough young lads being enticed by the blue and white...
Dick Fearon
23 Posted 14/07/2012 at 21:58:29
A League Cup win would increase world wide sales and crowd numbers by a few thousand, an FA cup win would top that, Euro qualification would add thousands more.
Premier League champions and sales would go through the roof, Euro Champions and they would go ballistic.
There you have it, a poor mans guide to marketing.
Compared to on field success presentation and availability are insignificant.
Eric Myles
24 Posted 15/07/2012 at 10:43:21
Steve #933, you could try emailing info@kenwright.com

There doesn't seem to be a 'Contact Us' option on the OS?

Paul Washington
25 Posted 15/07/2012 at 20:37:59
For as long as I can remember, the club's marketing policy has been crap with cock-up after cock-up... any one remember Cliff Finch?

I live in Widnes, a town full of exiled scousers 10 miles from GP with a massive Evertonian following, and I can't buy any merchandise whatsoever locally.
Eddie Fazal
26 Posted 16/07/2012 at 03:27:34
A very good article....it has long been a sore point.

I live in Australia, and it is not easy to get anything related to Everton, but I am currently holidaying in Thailand – the home of our shirt sponsors Chang Beer, and there is not an Everton shirt in sight, other than the three t-shirts I have with me!

I am surrounded by Manchester United shirts – and even a Manchester United store, Liverpool shirts and billboards, Chelsea players on billboards and sides of trains, and to top it all, at Bangkok Airport, a Leicester City store – LEICESTER CITY, for Christ's sake!!

Chang Beer obviously sponsor many things here, and many football teams – I know that because I am daily passing advertising for some Thai football team or other, and watching TV commercials for Chang Water featuring Messi, Ronaldo et al and not an Everton link in view.

Somebody needs to get their act together, but I doubt we have anyone capable. Time to start all over again I suggest – new shirt sponsors when the contract is up for renewal, or an agreement to promote Everton in Thailand as they seem to do everyone else!

I'm thinking of switching to Tiger Beer while I'm here in protest!!
Eric Myles
27 Posted 16/07/2012 at 03:48:32
Eddie, it's because Leicester are owned by a Thai Company (King Power) who also run the duty free franchise at the airport. But don't worry, Thais can't even pronunce the name right, never mind support them!

But I am now seeing cans of Chang with pics of Barcelona and Real Madrid on them (apparently Chang are sponsors of some degree) but none with Everton on them!!

Probably not our marketing teams fault though.

Eddie Fazal
28 Posted 16/07/2012 at 04:39:01
I do actually wonder if any of our marketing team have even been to Thailand... or perhaps the truth is, we don't have a marketing team??
Adam Henderson
29 Posted 12/08/2012 at 20:33:29
I'm a Celtic fan and found this quite and interesting read. I think Nike have been delayed with a lot of clubs this season though, and most shops I've been to have been struggling to get enough Celtic kits in stock. So with Everton being a new club to Nike and other clubs who sell more kits struggling to get enough stock I think it can't be blamed on the club that kits haven't come through quickly.

And I agree with what some others have said. You can have all the bright ideas in the world but if there's no demand then you're not going to make money. You're probably going to lose it. Considering that Everton struggled to fill they're stadium over 50% last season I'd say that should be the main concern. Selling the club to the people of Liverpool is more important than America or Asia.

I'm still really not wiser as to why Everton have "no" (In EPL terms) money though. They might not have great marketing but surely it can't cost them more than £5m on the likes of Sunderland, Aston Villa, West Brom, Stoke and other such teams. Not much when you consider they must be getting about £60m a season in TV rights. And looking at last season they made about £15m in profit from transfers. Obviously there was some big wages like Drenthe and Jelavic but still where does all that money go?


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb