The past couple of days have seen much discussion regarding the whole Fellaini situation. I’m interested in hearing a few opinions on a broader scale. For the purposes of this article, let’s assume that the alleged statements are true and he is indeed considering his future.

Firstly, I want you to put yourself in Fellaini’s shoes. No really... have a good think about his situation:

  1. You are young man in his mid-20s, currently being lauded from all sides about how great you and your current form are.
  2. You are paid £75k per week to play for Everton, a club who took a gamble on you and have developed you into a quality player.
  3. You have played for 4-5 years with the same club, the same manager, largely the same group of players and have experienced both highs and lows.
  4. Your father, agent and God knows how many others are telling you that you are a Champions League player who deserves double his current salary.
Then, I want you to put yourself in Joe Bloggs’s shoes...
  1. Joe is a young man in his mid-20s, currently being told by his boss at work how good a job he is doing, he is considered a massively valued asset to ABC Ltd.
  2. He is paid £20k a year to work for ABC Ltd, a company who took a chance and employed him when many others didn’t; he has developed his skills in many areas.
  3. He has worked at ABC for 4-5 years with the same manager, largely the same group of people and had good times and bad times.
  4. Numerous head-hunters are telling Joe that he could command a £40k salary and should look to further his career.
Now then, from what I’ve read on TW in the past few days I am going to suggest that a fairly high majority of people are going to say that if Fellaini leaves, he proves himself to be a disloyal, ungrateful and greedy individual. Now the crux of the argument, would the same apply to Joe?

The older I get (now 29), I take players leaving Everton less and less personally. I understand why they do it, whether that is to get more money, play at the highest level, the basic desire for a change in life/culture or disagreements with management/players etc.

Being a rich footballer does not make you immune to the same feelings as you and I. They live in their own world, consumed by their own thoughts and interests. Guess what? So do we! The financial disparity is there but the same principles of self preservation apply.

Some people are more ambitious, value money more than others or feel stagnant in their current career (maybe Van Persie recently?). Others are genuinely happy to stay where they are, they love the environment they are in, the people that surround them, are happy enough with their salary and don’t like change (Le Tissier).

The bad guy isn’t always the one who leaves a club and the good guy isn’t always a hero for staying. At work, when it comes to the crunch (although some wouldn’t like to admit it), I find that people largely do what suits them best. I know I do. Why shouldn’t footballers do the same?

Share this article


Reader Comments (34)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Jim Harrison
1 Posted 11/09/2012 at 07:36:12
It's more to do with the way they go about it. RVP stating that the clubs vision doesnt meet his in a "I am better than this" kinda way. Same (if its true he has said it) with Fellaini. I have done this, I am now bigger than this. Fair play, maybe he is? But Why rub it in the face of the people who pay your wages? Being a footballer, he must understand the partizan nature of fans. It maybe just his job, but its our passion. Actions and words like this wind us up because the club means something to us. It demonstrates a lack of appreciation/understanding of his customer base.

Most people have probably experienced something like this at work. A colleague becomes dissatisfied where they are and believes they are worth more/have more to offer than they currently do. One person continues to work well, finds the job that matches their ambition, hands in appropriate notice, then leaves wishing everyone well. Another tells everyone how good he/she is, how underpaid/under appreciated/underused they are and how they are going to find a job at a better place as soon as one comes up, Goes to the pub and tells all in earshot about how it too. Which person annoys you more?

I agree that he is more than within his rights to aspire to higher things, but bearing in mind his agent is capable of advertising him privately to suitors, I resent him, or any player doing so vocally.

Kev Prytherch
2 Posted 11/09/2012 at 08:40:19
Brilliant response. Although I agree with the original article too.

I always kind of had respect for Franny Jeffers when he left. He said he wanted a shot of winning medals and turned down a lucrative contract (I think from Newcastle) to wait for Arsenal. No bullshit misquoted, he said what he wanted and did it.

Phil Walling
3 Posted 11/09/2012 at 08:43:03
The original article indicated that he wanted to fuck off in January, ie, couldn`t get out fast enough. If he leaves next summer and whoever is manager then gets a good wedge to spend, so be it.
Sam Morrison
4 Posted 11/09/2012 at 09:27:14
It's a fair comment Jonathan but as Jim says above it's about how you go about something. I'm not one to boo ex-players (kind of pointless from the armchair) but I was deflated reading this as the special season I still believe we can had felt undermined... here's someone who doesn't share that sense of anticipation, or magic.

Maybe that's naive of me, I dunno, but I think the right thing for Marouane to do would have kept that to himself. He has a high enough profile not to do his advertising in press conferences.

Barry Rathbone
5 Posted 11/09/2012 at 09:10:38
People recognise ambition is part and parcel of life the difficulty for some (me included) is acknowledging a top footballer can't realise that here.

Rooney, Lescott, Arteta and inevitably Fellaini represent the milestones of this journey into the abyss.

Yet people defend or, in the case of one poster, gleefully revels in the antics of those reponsible.

Kevin Hudson
6 Posted 11/09/2012 at 09:37:56
Honestly, I think this is a phony controversy, and I have to agree with your premise Jonathon. I also think that people are basing their hostility towards Marouane on emotion rather than logic.

Granted, supporting a club IS primarily based on emotion. However, if Phil Neville indicated that this would be his last season before retirement, there wouldn't be this "well fuck you!" attitude doing the rounds.

I have never expected Fellaini to spend the remainder of his career with us. If he's honest enough to suggest he wants to move somewhere else at some point, no problem: Thanks for the service - good luck.

What I find more patronising is that he (and presumably 'his people,') have felt the need to 'manage,' and indeed walk-back his comments to pacify the 'outrage.' I'd always take honesty over spin.

Bottom line: If he is angling for a move, then as a positive, one can hope that he puts in the performances to earn one to the type of club he may ultimately crave.

Paul Gladwell
7 Posted 11/09/2012 at 09:53:25
Cannot blame him for being ambitious, but after a good feelgood factor start to the season, we now have this debate – even The Echo having a right old go – and it was all really not needed; get your head down keep shut, then do one if you want.

I have always been a fan of Fellaini's and cannot believe some of the rubbish that has been wrote claiming he is not very good as he is. Enough people throughout the game with better qualifications than certain lads on here are all in agreement he is up there with the best in this country at the moment, but so what!?!

If you think there are better places, piss off; no player is bigger than this club. They come and go, it`s no big deal as long as we get a good wad for him.
Kevin Hudson
8 Posted 11/09/2012 at 10:00:52
Final point:

Steven Naismith joined US because he didn't want to stay and help Rangers in the Scottish 3rd division. Loyalty simply wasn't enough of a motive for him to override personal ambition.

I have not seen him criticized ONCE on ToffeeWeb.

Shane Corcoran
9 Posted 11/09/2012 at 09:47:15
I think Jim Harrison covers what I think. I don't think the RVP case applies as it was clear from both he and Arsenal that his and the club's future needed to be discussed. They obviously didn't see eye to eye on the club's future, he stated this and said he wouldn't renew his contract because of this. And that's all he said as far as I know. Fellaini just talked when he shouldn't have. I don't blame him one bit for feeling how he feels as illustrated in the original article. But he's in the game long enough to know how football differs from other businesses, i.e. the fans care.
Mike Allison
10 Posted 11/09/2012 at 10:28:45
Football clubs aren't the same as other business. Playing football for a club is not the same as any other job. The comparison does not hold. In particular there is the clear sense of a football club as entity with history, emotional connections, and the emotional support offered by its fans to its employees. This is not the case at ABC ltd. They have no fans paying £30-50 a week on tickets, meeting up to discuss their fortunes either in person or in the pub.

The next reason is that footballers earn way above the threshold where money makes a difference to happiness. Joe Bloggs's income will directly affect what he can and can't do on a daily, weekly and yearly basis in terms of where he can afford to live, what holidays he can go on and so forth. A footballer's salary won't. The threshold by the way, and I wish I knew how to find a reference to this, is $60,000 a year. Beyond that, money doesn't increase happiness, things like quality family time and feelings of fulfilment and so on make all the difference.

Having said all that, trophies and achievements will make a difference, and unless we can offer Fellaini that, then for that reason, we can't take personally his desire to leave.

Mike Allison
11 Posted 11/09/2012 at 10:38:17
Please excuse the couple of small errors in the previous post, I'm sure you can figure out what I meant.

I didn't realise how easy it would be to find reference to the $60,000 threshold. Here's one link:

http://www.mymoneyblog.com/happiness-is-earning-60000-a-year.html

Tony J Williams
12 Posted 11/09/2012 at 10:20:12
Ambition ....shambition, As the lesbian (allegedly) Miss J sung, "it's all about the money, money".... and the ego thing of having medals in the drawer.
Lee Courtliff
13 Posted 11/09/2012 at 10:36:47
If he wants to go then fine. Just make sure we get a massive fee. I don't see the point in getting angry about players leaving. Its their right. I don't expect any loyalty off any player. It makes things easier to deal with when they eventually ask for a transfer. Which almost all do in the end.
Kev Johnson
14 Posted 11/09/2012 at 10:48:45
Tony (999) - actually, Jessie J - whose sexual orientation is neither here nor there, FFS! - sang "It's NOT about the money, money, money". Bit of a difference, I'd say.

Tomorrow here on TW: the lyrics to Lana del Rey's 'Video Games' cast an interesting light on the 'Can Coleman play at right back?' question...

Sam Morrison
15 Posted 11/09/2012 at 10:58:16
Kev (004) You've obviously not heard the B-side to Video Games where she casts aspersions on the idea that 4-4-2 is the bedrock of the modern game and suggests three at the back, with Yobo playing on the left of Heitinga and Distin (to be fair to her, this was before the transfer went through)
Steve Fletcher
16 Posted 11/09/2012 at 10:52:40
IVO the OP title, can I just add "..kicking, screaming Gucci little piggy" ?
And for those that don't get the reference, it's Radiohead, not a dig at Felli.
If he goes in Jan or next summer, it'll be for a CL qualified team. And I don't blame him. Hopefully, he'll play in the CL for us. If not, so be it.
Kevin Tully
17 Posted 11/09/2012 at 10:50:28
If you are good enough to become a professional footballer, you have to be highly ambitious just to reach that stage. I wouldn't knock anyone who wants to have medals to show for their efforts at the end of their career.

Take Arteta for example he took a pay cut to go to Arsenal - a true case of someone moving for the right reasons.

It must be frustrating as hell for managers these days, all you hear is about the Champions League, and players who want a taste.

You also have to remember loyalty is a two way steet, if we got an offer for Baines from Arsenal for £25m, who is to say we would refuse - even if he was happy & he did not want the move ?

I suppose we just have to accept that with the obscene amounts of money on offer, combined with all the other factors, we may lose any player at any time.

My advice is to support the club - players will always come & go.

Drew O'Neall
18 Posted 11/09/2012 at 10:59:40
The whole thing would sit better with me if they were just honest instead of using code for what they really mean to placate a small and diminishing minority of gullible fans.

If you are leaving for more money, say you are leaving for more money, not ‘lack of ambition’ or for ‘Champions League Football’ or any of the other bollocks.

And another thing, stop kissing the badge unless you sat in the Bullens as a boy and don’t intend to leave until you are sold.

Tony J Williams
19 Posted 11/09/2012 at 11:50:13
Kevin, Arteta did take a pay cut, but guess what? as soon as the season was over, him and his agent were in there renegotiating his wages. Article on BBC, 5th June 2012.

Bob Skelton
20 Posted 11/09/2012 at 11:56:16
Have to agree with you Jon. There is real life....and the fictional one we expect our football players to follow. Keep reading TW for the fictional one....highly moral with no ambition to better onesself!
Andy Crooks
21 Posted 11/09/2012 at 12:36:19
The two examples in the original post are incompatible and irrelevant.
Phil Martin
22 Posted 11/09/2012 at 12:34:24
Jonathon,

Your comparison is invalid.

You're comparing an average guy who will probably be working till he's 70 just to be able to retire with a roof over his head. To a guy (the footballer) who already has enough money to live a life of luxury for as long as he lives.

Yes the footballer can pursure as much money as he wants. but let's not pretend the footballer needs another £2M a year on top of his 3.5M a year salary -because he's trying to feed his kids.

Let's also remember that if average joe bloggs broadcasts a statement publically courting rival companies while employed by someone else. He'd be in massive trouble.

Footballers are paid to represent their club - on and off the field. Touting yourself about in interviews (if ti's true) is seriously bad form. So let's not pretend he's just being ambitious.

Kieran Fitzgerald
23 Posted 11/09/2012 at 13:10:20
I worked it out recently that your average footballer, on 50k a week, will earn more during the six weeks of the close season than I will earn in the next twelve or thirteen years. Made me think.

On the other hand, I am not the type of employee that would be happy to spend thirty years with the one company. I managed six and a half years in my last job. I left for a change, taking a drop of money in the process. Having the change and a fresh burst of motivation was worth the trade off. I'm four and a half years in my current job. I'm generally happy to stay. I like the job, the people in the office and my manager is alright.

However, my personal circumstances have changed since my last job. I am more likely to stay in this job because I have to for personal reasons, than my last one. I now have to think about school runs, child minding in the evening, having a family life. At times I would like to change jobs. It would be nice to be offered a job with twice the money. But because of where I'm at personally, I might not be able to take it.

For footballers, the same things must apply to some degree. In some ways, it must come down to what means more to you, your career or your family. It can sometimes be a balancing act. Why has Baines never pushed for a move, why has Hetinga, for all his whinging, never put in a transfer request. I appreciate that it is a short career. You will only get to play at the top level, at the top teams, when you are in your prime. But you have to remember that the majority of footballers, have more in common with your average joe than you think. Not every football player is on 40k a week. For every premier league footballer, there are ten lower league players who are all on a professional wage.

James Martin
24 Posted 11/09/2012 at 15:41:37
The difference between footballers and your average Joe is that a pay rise for average Joe drastically alters his standard of living. If he goes from £20k a year to £40k he can go form perhaps just making ends meet to living relatively comfortably, maybe he can think about getting a house, a new car or starting a family. He oculd make the move purely for economic purposes and vindicate it.

These footballers earn more than thye know what to do with. In terms of living standars there's probably not that much mroe you can buy on £100k a week that you can't afford on £70k a week. Different factors therefore come in to play such as professional ambition that may never affect Joe Bloggs above economic reasons.
Dennis Stevens
25 Posted 11/09/2012 at 21:32:38
Oh to be a young man in my mid-20s! ... or mid-30s ... or even mid-40s!
Gerry Morrison
26 Posted 11/09/2012 at 22:24:36
Jonathan, I hate to state the obvious, but football teams are not the same as ordinary businesses.
Jamie Sweet
27 Posted 11/09/2012 at 22:42:51
The one key difference between Fellaini and Joe Bloggs, is that within the next 12 months, Mo will earn more money than Joe will in his entire life-time. So it could be argued that looking to increase your wage from its fully undeserved – astronomical level it's already at (for doing a "job" that most of us would actually pay to do) could be considered as being greedy.

Having said this, I can't blame any player for wanting to play at a higher / Champions League level. And let's face it, most of our high profile players to leave recently have most certainly gone on to better things.

Rooney = Medals galore, including Champions League winner
Lescott = Premier league winners medal / Champions League games.
Pienaar = Started in both legs of Champions League victory over AC Milan (before he fell down the pecking order).
Arteta = Regular starter in Champions League team.
Rodwell = Already starting games for current PL Champs & in the Champions League squad.

Who can blame anyone for wanting to test themselves at the highest possible level (and actually stand a chance of winning things!)?
Sean McKenna
28 Posted 12/09/2012 at 04:40:49
Hold on a wee minute, there's a massive difference between football and any normal firm.

Example: if Joe Bloggs turns up at his new job and was fucking useless for the first 6 months, he would be sacked!!


Example: if Joe Bloggs goes on the sick for 6 months, every year for 2 years running, he would be sacked.

Example: if Joe Bloggs tells the newspaper that his company is a bit shit but that other company across the road is the bee's knees, he would be sacked.

Example: if Joe Bloggs decided to elbow some fucker in work, resulting in missing a few weeks of work, he would be sacked.

Example: if I came into work with a haircut like that, I'd be sacked (joking about that one but stranger things have happened).

In my view, footballers should be paid £10k max... if they win the league, they get a million bonus... and cups, half a million, etc etc. If that was the pay structure I'm 100 percent sure we would see a much improved performance from all players.

Shaun Brennan
29 Posted 12/09/2012 at 05:02:48
If Fellaini is angling for a move, well I certainly hope he puts a transfer request in and forfeit any loyalty payment due to him.

That way we'll soon see his true colours.

Mike Allison
30 Posted 12/09/2012 at 09:44:20
"..kicking, screaming Gucci little piggy"

I always read that as a Spice Girls reference, its not hard to match each one to a word in that line.

Jim Harrison
31 Posted 12/09/2012 at 16:21:57
Have to say, footballers jobs are in essence just the same as anyone else's. They do a job, someone pays them. they just get paid a disproportionate amount of money compared to the majority of us. They fall into a similar category as musicians & film stars. But how upset do you get when tom cruise pulls out of a film production? most likely not at all, because you don't give a shit about tom cruises film projects.

As said before, its what the club means to us that makes it important to us. These guys don't have our connection, but should conduct themselves professionally.

Andy Crooks
32 Posted 12/09/2012 at 19:33:15
Jim, I agree. They are working class lads and I don't begrudge them a penny. However, I expect them to show some responsibility and to act with an iota of intelligence. I think there comes a point, lets place it for example at £30,000 a week when money becomes irrelevant.

To compare a Premier League footballer with a fan who doubles his pay from £20k to £40k a week is, well, showing a lack of insight.

Steve Fletcher
34 Posted 15/09/2012 at 01:49:12
I'm a bit late coming back on this but for Mike @120 thats a good call. That line was supposedly written because of a scary woman hyped on Colombian marching powder that was aggressive and paranoid in a bar Thom Yorke was in. Not sure if it was one of our cough *most talented* cough girl groups though... but I'll let you decide which one to libel just in case!
Craig Fletcher
35 Posted 15/09/2012 at 02:15:52
Can't blame Fellaini; or any other footballer, for wanting to win medals/titles. It's up to EFC to show Fellaini that he can achieve that by staying put - all we ask in return is for him to give nothing less than 100% whenever he puts on a blue shirt.
Oh, and if can also keep his mouth shut about his future with Everton when he speaks to the media, that'll also be appreciated; thanks Maro.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb