Last night spiralled out into a drunken stupor, as many a Saturday night does, and it became easy to forget that the Mighty Blues had failed to beat a struggling team two divisions below them. But, as morning comes with the inevitable juddering of reality, so too does the fact that we did not progress yesterday. So too that we sit 6th in the table when we should be at least a couple of places higher. And all of this hurts worse than the boozy headache.

As I woke confused, my mind flipped back to the year we finished 4th, the last time the "top 4" (whatever that means) monopoly was broken. Yes, I’m prone to gazing longingly out of my bedroom window recalling Kilbane’s mane. But I also got to thinking about mentality. It is one of those buzz-words that we hear bandied around by the media and champions of Moyes. It was the kind of word that we may have often shunned, feeling as though there were no appreciative comments about the way we played football, that grit and diligence were our only tools. And yet mentality seems to be exactly what we have lacked this season.

Have there been injuries? Yes, and to players like Mirallas and Gibson who seem to have an influence on our style of play. Have we been unlucky? Yes, I cannot remember a season where so many poor, poor performances from officials went against us. Have we lacked investment? Without a doubt! January would have been the perfect time for sofas, coat pockets and collections of West End programmes to be raided, and yet we bought an unknown, though promising, full-back who is unlikely to play this season.

These things and more have transpired against us. And yet mentality is lacking. Heightened expectations, years of a bare trophy cabinet, the dour predictions of our manager have all led us to believe that we should be better off. And yet the team that DID challenge the hierarchy last was comprised of players who we would smirk at now. Would we swap Bent for Jelavic? Of course not! But how many results were ground out through determination and desire? I always think back to Tim Cahill bulleting a header in the dying embers of a game away at Sunderland. We had rode our luck and never looked like winning the game... but we did. I cannot imagine us doing that this season.

Even the times where we have showed this "character" — that the media often places upon us — seem to have felt flat. I punched the air when we made it 3 - 3 with Villa the other week but there was no overall satisfaction. A team we should have beaten comfortably had pushed us to the brink and drawing level was a small victory. We all would have taken a scrappy, battled 1 - 0 win, maybe Distin bundling one in off his arse. But instead, we are left feeling lucky to be leaving with a point against a team who the week prior to playing us had been beaten by Bradford and Millwall.

Beyond this frustration also stems a disbelief at problems that are easily spotted but wholly ignored. None of us are football managers, and it is easy to spout mutterings about no money and "we just need 3 or 4 players" when even free trasnsfers cost serious money... (Was "the new Scottish Rooney" Steven Naismith really free?) And yet, this season, failings that have been discussed for years seem to have gone unchecked.

With reference to last night’s game, how on earth is a new contract being contemplated for Philip ’Pip’ Neville? His lack of composure is embarrassing in the top flight but against Oldham it stank to high heaven. Our first goal came about because Jagielka had seen him gift possession too many times. That lonely punt up field would have been a success even if Jelavic hadn’t got on the end of it, for the simple fact that it would not have been another aimless drifting of the ball for a throw-in, from a player whose experience is sold to us almost daily, like a mate who tells us his girlfriend is lovely and a proper laugh but is as funny as stubbing your toe.

Other issues have lingered. I met a mate of mine last night from Stoke (good Saturday night entertainment obviously). We’d spoken about Jack Butland a few weeks back when Begovic was linked with a move to Man Utd, and I had said he was just the kind of player we needed. Tim Howard actually made a few good saves the other day but, whether it be age, lack of competition, or even that mentality already mentioned, he has had a poor season. How many points have we gifted through nervous goalkeeping? I even thought he should have done better on Oldham’s equaliser. With Mucha obviously not up to scratch surely investing in a goalkeeper with potential like Butland’s would have made sense. It wouldn’t have cost the earth if Stoke managed to land him. Maybe it boils down to "loyalty," another magic word that has begun to turn sour. These words ring hollow, in a similar fashion to a government who uses terms like "big society" to lull us into a false sense of belief that "we’re all in this together."

I do worry about the summer, because the grass isn’t always greener. I can see Roberto Martinez coming in, making Emerson Boyce his marquee signing and then calling our 4 - 0 trouncing against Norwich as "like a victory," blaming the linesman and then making a cryptic remark. And yet stagnancy seems to have set in. Some kind of vibrancy is needed. Character can be built but it can also ebb away. That lovely wife you’re married to for 25 years is bound to piss you off royally after a while — however nice she was at first.

As my hangover really starts to kick in, I look over not just last night but a league table that should appear more comfortable. I think of hearing things like "Thomas Hitzlsperger is like a new signing." I think of Jealvic’s lost confidence — a beauty queen newly scarred. Even without worrying about finances, stadiums, a board continually looking for investment and finding nothing, I feel concern. Maybe it’s the hangover. Maybe it’s picturing Phil Neville talking about his disappointments with the team when the blame lies so often at his own feet. Or maybe we’ve reached our glass ceiling. Maybe 6th is our limit.

Share this article


Reader Comments (11)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


James Stewart
1 Posted 17/02/2013 at 15:27:52
You make an interesting point when comparing the current lot to the team that finished 4th. I don't think we can hold that team in that high a regard though. We came 4th by the skin of our teeth and a lot of it was more to do with other teams' failings. After Gravesen left, we were really poor. It was hardly a great team to watch.

Too many players are misfiring at the moment. Jelavic just can't finish anything and the likes of Howard, Heitinga, Neville have had seasons to forgot. Yes, we have some top players but they are carrying too many passengers. We needed a shot in the arm and new blood in January and I can only see 4th slipping further away. Opportunity missed.

John Gant
2 Posted 17/02/2013 at 16:43:20
And you wrote that with a hangover! I have to be spoon fed...
Adam McCulloch
3 Posted 17/02/2013 at 16:50:27
Absolutely and I think that the current crop and our stuttering performances are made all the more frustrating when you look back. We now have a better squad, one assembled entirely by Moyes, that plays better football than back then – and yet we do not look capable or deserving of 4th place.
Barry Rathbone
4 Posted 17/02/2013 at 17:13:41
For my sins in the mid 70s when Liverpool were winning everything me and my mate went alternate weekends to Goodison and Anfield for 12 weeks to see if we could see what their secret was.

On face value it made no sense they would buy non-descript puddin's from the lower leagues - Brian hall, Steve Heighway, Phil Neal etc while we spent big on latchford, Dobson and others.

They were always "busy" no matter what the opposition or what the score was they legged it round as though on drugs keeping it simple nothing "fancy" or any hollywood passes from first minute to last and won every game. They had 80% standard players week in week out playing at 100%

No time to worry about attitude or mentality Shanks and Paisley drilled into them what was expected before getting the kit on. These limited players most of whom did nothing when they moved on knew their jobs had basic athleticism and pace and just did it.

Clough did exactly the same at Derby and Forest - modern coaches are of the "too much analysis produces paralysis".

Tony Marsh
5 Posted 17/02/2013 at 17:42:36
Good post, Adam. I agree with most of it. I agree Neville is finished but he doesn't pick himself, does he? Same with Osman, he stinks to high heaven and should've been turfed out after the 2009 FA Cup Final horror show but again he still gets a shirt every week. In my opinion, the biggest flaw that Moyes has is not being able to spot players who are either finished or so out of form its scarey.

As I am typing this, Wigan have just dismantled Huddersfield 4 - 1 away — something we would never do to a Championship side. I would take Martinez in a heartbeat, the man is class and it was him who set the footprint we now have at Swansea. Martinez is on a hiding to nothing at Wigan as the town is Rugby League mad and football is seen as a puff's game.

Martinez would put the pride back in to our club with his football philosophy. Everton are the worst footballing team I have seen in the top flight consistently over the past 10 years. Apart from the odd month here or there, we have been shocking to watch under Moyes.

Time for a change as it's all too predictable and boring. Trying to encourage the next generation to come and watch us gets harder the longer Dour Dave stays. I can't see him leaving though because no so-called bigger club's fans would put up with the gormless way he goes about his business. He will keep them up but destroy any spirit and morale they have at the club. Please leave us, Davey, FFS.

Jay Harris
6 Posted 17/02/2013 at 18:30:09
Very good post Adam and I do agree about mentality.

The only problem is that mentality is the difference between average premiership players and expensive "win everything" players that the likes of City, Chelsea and United have.

IMO that is why Arsenal havent been doing as well recently because they've bought players lacking that winning metality.

It is hard to pick that sort of player up on the cheap or free and you have to give Moyes credit for building a team spirit that is second to none while only shopping in the bargain basement.

Only Fellaini and Baines would get into a top 4 squad and it took Bainesy a long time to get to that level.

Andy Meighan
7 Posted 17/02/2013 at 22:06:17
Barry (#161) I liked that last bit: "too much analysis produces paralysis" — so true.

And Tony (#162), I couldn't agree more with that line that, under Moyes, Everton have been fucking dreadful to watch. Yes we've had our moments but generally for me they've been too few and far between.

I think the majority of us on here definitely think this is his last season; in some respects, I'll be sorry because be honest he's galvanised the club. But, fuck me, for the majority of the time it's been like pulling your own teeth... it's been downright miserable.

Derek Thomas
8 Posted 18/02/2013 at 08:40:01
I thought with the Rooney money Moyes could be the Blue Shankly and kickstart a Revolution. But over and over he fails the main requirement (according to Napoleon) of Generals in the field (or in our case on it), never mind all the skill, experience, knowledge... is he lucky... Moyes isn't.

Not withstanding his own foibles, when push comes to shove something always conspires to do him and us down.

Last calendar year we were poised, we had a goodish start but were victims of our own success and the bad luck of Ref's decisions.

We then add in Jelly's form slump and Howard and Heitinga and Neville.

Injuries Mirallas and Gibson plus Hibbo and Coleman.

Then came January (say no more)

We have drawn 11 or 12 ...It has been so up and down we could've won 6 of them and in some cases we could've lost 6 of them.

The Moyes years are (I hope) ending not with a bang but a whimper.

But at the moment Adele hasn't even took her coat off yet, nevermind sung.

There are many opportunities yet to snatch defeat from the jaws victory

If Moyes goes... in whatever form to wherever, we will be facing an unknown (declines the chance to go all Rumsfeld Re unknowns).

But if Moyes stays, again in whatever circumstances, we will have a nearly man for the next 4 yrs who, in the end, decided that discretion WAS the better part of valour... as if we didn't know.

He steadied the ship, yes.

He could've been better backed by the board, yes

His good points got us where we are, his failings stop us from going on.

This goes double for Bill; This is where Moyes lack of luck comes in...Oh and doubtful subs, Too much loyalty and sq pegs in round holes.

He and I have, to coin a downunder phrase, done our (collective) dash

Bring on next season.

Episode IV... A New Hope

Just where and who our Obiwan is I haven't a clue and worse still I don't think Bill has.

Ged Simpson
9 Posted 20/02/2013 at 09:12:47
A great post Adam. Considered, not full of the usual childish slander and, above all, really nicely written.

Unless you are a genius you took some time on that and gave it some thought.

You will probably end up be slagged off soon for not calling someone a cunt or coming up with a unbelievable conspiracy theory.

Breath of fresh air and hope the hangover has gone.

Adam McCulloch
10 Posted 20/02/2013 at 16:53:57
Only just seen this Ged, fancy being my P.R man? Haha ta mate. Also fair play Derek for the Star Wars reference. I think Steven Naismith could be our Jar Jar Binks!
Ged Simpson
11 Posted 20/02/2013 at 17:12:40
No

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb