Manchester City sack Roberto Mancini and, although it takes a week or so to announce it, its clear Pellegrini was lined up before Mancini was sacked.
David Moyes tells Everton around Christmas time that he will not consider signing a new contract until the end of the season. The season ends and Moyes becomes manager of Manchester United. Bill Kenwright, having had almost 5 months notice, announces that Everton “will not be taking a quick decision, we will be taking time.” So much for a Plan B!
Why do I have a real sense of unease about this business of “taking time”? Is it because, other that BKs decision to appoint Moyes, he has delivered on little else at Everton! That may have something to do with it. But my real concern is his desire to go through a process that doesnt seem to feature in the procedures followed by most other clubs — in particular, the top 5. It seems they operate with a focus, determination and speed which, when it comes to picking managers, is distinctly lacking at Everton.
My concern (and please let me be wrong) is that, when the Manager is eventually announced, most of us will, to say the least, be very unhappy. I say this because I fear that this carefully considered process will enable BK to say something like “we listened to what every candidate had to say and the ideas and vision for Everton Football Club put forward by Mr Whoever, impressed so much that he virtually chose himself.”
In fact, most of us know that the Number One criterion for selecting a Premier League manager is his track record. Okay... there are the other usual considerations: for example, that hes not a wife-beater or hasnt got the personality Heinrich Himmler. But, subject to obvious personality disorders, the track record is paramount!
For my money, that rules out an internal candidate. While I would happily have any of the internal candidates in supporting roles, I cannot possibly see how a club which finishes 6th in what is supposedly the best league in the world could even consider someone who has never managed before. I also feel it is pretty disingenuous of Moyes and other key figures around Everton to be suggesting people who have no management experience. Let them go out and prove themselves at other clubs; then, at some future date – if youve proved you can hack it – we will welcome you back!
That leads me nicely to Phil Neville. Phil has been a great captain and leader both on and off the pitch but it really would be inanity in the extreme for a club like Everton to appoint what would virtually be a trainee manager. Two months ago, Phil was looking to extend his playing career. Now... apparently the last 5 years have been leading up to this role.
To dispel any myths about the precedent of successful in-house people, both Howard Kendal and Joe Royle had considerable managerial experience with other clubs before they landed their jobs at Everton. Likewise, there are a number of precedents for great team captains not being able to cut the mustard as managers: Brian Robson and Roy Keane immediately spring to mind. The above points against appointment apply equally to David Weir and Alan Stubbs, both of whom we all (as Evertonians) admire.
We will probably never get 100% supporter agreement on who we want as the next Everton manager. Personally I favour Pereira but would also be happy with Laudrup. I suppose what I really want now at Everton is a foreign coach who has chalked up some degree of success. However, as it says in the title of this article, I have a growing unease that what most of us want isnt going to happen.
Please, Bill – make me eat my words!
Reader Comments (56)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
3 Posted 25/05/2013 at 01:40:40
Very disappointing behaviour by someone I admired. But who is it that's letting him get away with it? Our one-man Board.
4 Posted 25/05/2013 at 05:12:14
And let's be fair, there's a reason why we don't have a manager yet and it's that, unlike Utd, we were hoping ours would stay. And, unlike City, we can't offer a massive budget and CL football. I'm sure someone has been eyeing up prospective candidates but its a big decision which may have payments in the millions attached to it - take all the time you need.
5 Posted 25/05/2013 at 05:28:51
Mind you Bill not having the final say may or may not be blessing in disguise.
Lumsden and Wood potential lose worry me not one jot
Sid, wife beater, bishop beater, I don't really care so long as he's a RS beater and a Manc beater, infact beats the shite out of all and sundry in the Prem.
As you say Moyes and we presume here, BPB knew at Christmas. We can infer that Neville didn't but was one of the first to know, hence his change from keeping on playing.
As is usual from Everton ( who brought you KD, Fortress, DK, Pipe lagging-gate, Park End Wall-gate etc etc ) this whole thing has fiasco / slow motion train wreck written all over it.
6 Posted 25/05/2013 at 07:31:19
7 Posted 25/05/2013 at 08:04:09
8 Posted 25/05/2013 at 08:18:08
Moyes is certainly not blameless and must have known about Fergie, but he would have been stupid and unambitious if the biggest job in football had come up and he'd have turned it down.
Maybe a big factor in his decision was Kenwright and the board for not stumping up the money in January, when everyone could see we needed only 2-3 players for us to get into the top four.
9 Posted 25/05/2013 at 08:33:31
Kenwright is devoid of ambition and inspiration and I fear he will cling on at Goodison Park no matter that he is slowly destroying the club. This is a pivotal time for the club. He must get it right.
10 Posted 25/05/2013 at 08:02:07
Without going into all the routine Kenwright bashing, let's just examine some of the facts and 'ahem' fictions.
1. At the end of the season, Sir Alex Ferguson resigns... and, within a matter of days, David Moyes is announced as their new Manager.
> Yes this is true, clearly they'd been lining this up for a couple of weeks/months.
2. Manchester City sack Roberto Mancini and, although it takes a week or so to announce it, its clear Pellegrini was lined up before Mancini was sacked.
> This is pure speculation with absolutely no way of knowing the truth. As things currently stand Man City are actually managerless – Pelligrino has NOT been appointed.
3. David Moyes tells Everton around Christmas time that he will not consider signing a new contract until the end of the season.
> This is also true, but there was a belief (shared amongst most on this site) that Moyes could still stay, potentially even without the CL.
4. The season ends and Moyes becomes manager of Manchester United.
> True.
5. Bill Kenwright, having had almost 5 months notice, announces that Everton “will not be taking a quick decision, we will be taking time.”
> This really isn't true at all, BK hasn't had 5 months of Moyes leaving, he's had 5 months of the possibility he'd need to find a new manager and a possibility he would not. We know absolutely nothing about what was said between Moyes and BK privately, what was known about Man Utd and what BK or anyone else has done behind the scenes in terms of preparation or Plan B.
One point which I think you're neatly ignoring in your rant is that the situation about manager availability changes dramatically at the end of the season (a point we've not yet reached in some European leagues) as chairman and managers around the world reassess their positions. Bearing that in mind, making a decision 5 months before the end of the season when we didn't know who was available and whether Moyes would actually leave would be rather more difficult than you're portraying it.
Basically Moyes announced his decision to leave just over 2 weeks ago and since then we've drawn up a shortlist, spoken to a number of candidates and support staff internally and externally and by all accounts it would appear we're closing in on a new appointment within the next week – with Martinez and Perreira both in the running.
Ultimately I'm really no Kenwright apologist, I think we need new ownership (although they are by no means guaranteed to be any better or lead to better results – see Blackburn, Villa, Sunderland, Liverpool, etc, etc) and there are countless mistakes that have been made. However, what I don't see ANY point in is the relentless, blinkered, glass entirely broken negativity towards the board and the club that seems to be filling these pages now.
Getting rid of Moyes seems to have provided very little relief (which is odd because it was exactly what much of this site had been clamouring for for much of the last 5 or so years). If I didn't know better, I'd almost say that some of you would be happier to see the club struggling so you can have something to whinge about. Maybe if you're really lucky we'll get a relegation battle to look forward to next year!
11 Posted 25/05/2013 at 08:51:51
Bill really is confusing everyone who gives a shit.
My next guess is Neil Lennon to be backed after the cup final tomorrow.
12 Posted 25/05/2013 at 09:00:49
Its all about mitigation of risk, whether you transfer the risk (not really applicable in this instance as the risk of not having a manager), avoidance (offer an incentive to stay - unlikely given BK's jackanory leadership style), reduction (line up alternatives) or acceptance (another of BK's head in the sand moments) - again a failure of BK's chairmanship - lack of planning and foresight.
13 Posted 25/05/2013 at 08:46:00
I disagree, I think that is EXACTLY what you are and the clue/giveaway for me is your choice of the word 'mistakes' suggesting 'human error but something that could happen to anyone'.
Disingenuous in the extreme in my opinion.
You add..
"..what I don't see ANY point in is the relentless, blinkered, glass entirely broken negativity towards the board and the club that seems to be filling these pages now"
Tough.
I don't see any point in 'well researched' 'full marks for effort!' badly disguised tributes to David Moyes but that's TW and we can't have everything
The reality is the actual football has finished, we can't discuss games so people concentrate on other aspects of Everton.
As for your last paragraph, insulting in the extreme.
Evertonians, who don't happen to think like you, don't want the club to succeed - desperate.
14 Posted 25/05/2013 at 09:21:46
If he now does what he says and "listens" to the fans, he will sign up Perreira, or Bielsa, or Laudrup. If he pretends to listen to the fans (more likely given his track record) it will be Stubbs or Martinez (maybe Neville).
Nothing is certain in choosing a manager but playing the odds by recruiting ones with a track record of success in winning leagues has got to help.
15 Posted 25/05/2013 at 09:41:48
Everton stand sixth in the richest football league on this planet, they will rake in over 50 million from Sky for the oncoming season and they will entertain around 35 thousand die hards for most games at Goodison. That is BIG fucking business.
How anyone can think that the likes of Neville, Stubbs or even big Dunc will be given the managerial reins to run this truely great club needs to stop reading all the bollocks that the media feels free to publish. Yes, we do have a total tart for a CEO and a mindless fuckwit for a chairman - however, even these two twats are aware of what Sky throws to Everton every season, so they will want to ensure that Everton remains in the EPL.
The manager position will be filled soon enough. I mean, every fucker must know that BK likes to milk all the media attention he can get, so we will just have to wait and then wait some more - then Martinez, Laudrop or a top European coach will be presented with all the gusto that BK can deliver. Personally, I don't give a fuck who it is, but rest assured the new manager is going to be one busy boy.
17 Posted 25/05/2013 at 10:17:53
Mike #694, it's actually closer to £70m from next season. And only about 40% of it is from Sky. But it's the same for all the other clubs, who all seem to be able to earn more none-TV revenue than us, so we'll still struggle to sign anyone of note unless Man U's new manager no longer wants them.
The only thing guaranteed with the increased broadcast revenue is a commensurate rise in "Other Operating Costs".
19 Posted 25/05/2013 at 11:08:04
Add in to this that we actually have a manager until June 30, a ridiculous situation that should be rectified immediately. Can you actually have two managers at the same time? Is Ferguson still technically United's manager? Who sacked Mike Phelan?
20 Posted 25/05/2013 at 11:22:27
The 'couldn't do anything for 5 months' is not accurate by the way either:
http://www.goal.com/en-gh/news/4371/exclusives/2013/04/10/3892055/everton-eye-porto-boss-pereira-as-potential-Moyes-successor
...the above is from near 2 months back and notes Pereira visiting the club several months before that. Now it may have been an amateurish, bumbling, half-arsed measure by a board that is all of those things...but it clearly cant be said that nothing was happening.
Now that I've come dangerously close to uttering the heresy that the board may, I repeat 'may', have shown the slightest glimmer of forethought I shall go away before the villagers have to start lighting their pitchforks.
22 Posted 25/05/2013 at 13:26:09
The right manager doesn't have to have the best track record, or have won a trophy. They simply need to have the knowledge, drive, ambition and skills to drive the club forward. Maybe such a person does exist within the walls of Goodison Park, maybe Martinez is that person, or Bielsa, or even Lennon. The big thing is most of us, as fans don't really know.
Unfortunately what we do know is that every single one of us is a footballing genius compared to our Chairman, so if we don't know what hope does he have?
23 Posted 25/05/2013 at 14:10:47
I'd just wouldnt judge Kenwright yet on this one until we find out who he appoints. Or if he takes ages in making a decision.
But you raise a very good point, which hasnt really talked about yet. No Plan B. There was never a guarantee Moyes was not going to sign the contract, it didnt seem like Kenwright had anybody lined up as a replacement just incase. Thats pretty shocking business sense for a chairman of a top 6 football club.
Im just hoping Kenwright makes the right decision in his appointment. And we need it in the next week or so!!
24 Posted 25/05/2013 at 14:15:50
Im sorry, but an article from goal is not proof that Kenwright was having contingency plans to replace Moyes.
I don't think he's done anything, because he genuinely thought Moyes was going to stay, and thats heart over your head.
Again, hopefully he delivers, but its not looking too good at the moment.
25 Posted 25/05/2013 at 15:12:36
26 Posted 25/05/2013 at 14:49:29
Many of you keep saying he is an idiot, no sense, no direction, total liar yet you lap up everything he says without question. In many cases its quite clear he is saying the 'right' things in front of the cameras. Yet some of you seem to be completely unable to detect it. The irony of peoples perception of Kenwright is actually quite funny. I think the guys is a lot more clever than people give him credit for. Do I want him to continue as Chairman? Yet again, no I do not, as he simply doesn't have the finances needed. Do I believe he will sell our great club to any Venky/Magnusson/Glazier/Hicks/Gillette/Fernandes/Mandaric/Lerner style takeover? Not a fucking chance. And for this I will applaud the guy.
27 Posted 25/05/2013 at 15:03:53
People are so quick to jump in and criticise; it was happening within days of Moyes's announcement.
The fact is, some people adopt their stance and then stick to it regardless of the circumstances. FFS, we had people on here who managed to find fault with everything Moyes did, which was strange considering he led us to a 6th place finish. Maybe not everything wrong then?
And Bill. According to this thread he's clueless, never made a good decision. Except he is the Chairman of a club in the top 6 of the league and a multi millionaire to boot. If he's clueless, what does that make the rest of us?
History has shown plenty of bad decisions in Bill's tenure, but do people really think our new manager will be chosen solely by Bill aided by Google? Really think that a Premier League chairman hasn't heard of Bielsa? Do you not think a man who can manage multiple businesses isn't smart enough to ask some qualified people for advice on this?
28 Posted 25/05/2013 at 15:51:34
As qualifications in finance or indeed any other discipline are not required to become the Chairman of a PL football club, we have no idea whatsoever as to his abilities we can only judge on what we see. My perception of the man is that he is a well-meaning, friendly man who is cautious in the main but who gambles on pie in the sky schemes which occasionally come off, not my idea of someone to trust with Everton FC.
29 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:01:10
30 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:05:08
31 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:08:00
32 Posted 25/05/2013 at 15:55:11
Ernie, is Bill a multi millionaire?So he didn't mortgage his house then? If he is a multi millionaire why is he chairman of a skint club? Have you ever considered the possibility that he is living the dream on the cheap? How much of his multi millions has he invested in Everton?
"If he is clueless, what does that make the rest of us?."
I would suggest it makes us Evertonians with a clueless self serving charlatan luvvy as the chairman of our club.
33 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:09:48
34 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:06:53
Just about the only thing I see any agreement on is that none of us likes the uncertainty. We'd all rather have a manager in place than not. But it's still only May and I just don't get the concern of some contributors on here that it's already taking too long. It will take as long as it takes. Very probably if the club had employed a new manager by now, the same people would be complaining about a rushed/hasty/knee-jerk appointment and that we should have waited and got so-and-so from such-and-such. Kenwright is damned if he does and damned if he doesn't, as so often appears the case.
35 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:13:00
36 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:16:06
37 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:16:28
Seems he's actually not far of being a genius.
The following three points are undoubtedly true.
1) Most dupes don't know they're dupes (nb: that's WHY they're dupes).
2) Grumpy narky con men don't do well, much better to present yourself as honest, friendly and interested in the same things as those you wish to con.
3) A good con merchant doesn't need to con EVERYONE - just people enough to stay in business.
Is Bill a good con man?
Anyone who can lie to you (again and again) and get CAUGHT lying (again and again) and STILL have people saying "Yeah but..." is VERY good imo.
38 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:18:10
Well we can't say we weren't consult......D'OH!!!
39 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:21:21
40 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:19:18
BIALYSTOCK talking to Bloom his accountant
It's not cheating ... It's charity.
Bloom, look at me ... look at me!
I'm drowning. Other men sail
through life. Bialystock has
struck a reef. Bloom, I'm going
under. I am being sunk by a
society that demands success, when
all I can offer is failure. Bloom,
I'm reaching out to you. Don't
send me to jail. Help! Help!
41 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:28:51
The previous version of the Crest - created 13 years ago - was often misrepresented, suffering regularly from the omission of key elements like our name and our year of formation. As technology marches on, those challenges have increased. On television, on websites, on mobile devices, the Crest was far too often badly reproduced.
From OS
42 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:32:04
I really can't be arsed listing the various skill sets required, but does anyone here know what being a producer actually entails?
Once you do some research, things will become a whole lot clearer.
43 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:44:35
If any of them offered his asking price you wouldn't see him for dust.
44 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:41:05
So we were wrong - all sorts of fans WERE consulted, the badge was shaped by 'the fan-base' etc blah waffle.
Not only that but Everton listened to 'the various groups' etc.
And there was 'feedback' (impressed: "Ooooohh...feedback!")
Only one problem.
Do you - ANY ONE OF YOU - remember hearing one (just one!) Evertonian, ever ever ever saying "I don't like our badge, it needs changing/redesigning/refreshing"
Me neither, in fact it might have been the only Everton-related subject that nobody appeared had a problem with.
So did 'the fan-base' approach the club and say "The badge needs changing"?
Did. They. Fuck.
Still on the plus side, 2% REALLY like it and 7% like it so in true Everton style, fuck the other 91%
Oh and I know this is subjective, but our crest now looks like a tatty, cheap and nasty bit of 70s design with our name in lettraset.
45 Posted 25/05/2013 at 16:53:58
"Kenshite", as Gavin so often charmlessly calls our Chairman is in a no win situation and as Sid suggested in his opening piece:
"when the Manager is eventually announced, most of us will, to say the least, be very unhappy."
That observation Sid is a very safe bet as unhappiness is available in bucketloads on this site, albeit travelling under the guise of banter and debate.
I also, like an earlier writer remember being very excited at the appointment of Mike Walker all those years ago. It seemed an inspirational choice at the time but we all know how that turned out.
A bit of luck is needed here as there is no obvious outstanding candidate and although frustrating, at this critical period for Everton, taking time to consider is almost certainly the wise option.
46 Posted 25/05/2013 at 17:51:52
No fuckin' wonder we are in the state we're in. Sleepwalking into oblivion. If I sound a tad dramatic, you need to give yourself a shake. We are only going one way, under Kenwright, the badge, the shafting from Utd, the January transfer debacle are just the latest series in this boards disgraces.
And still, people make excuses.
47 Posted 25/05/2013 at 18:08:04
"Badges? we don need no steenkin badges!!"
48 Posted 25/05/2013 at 18:41:24
49 Posted 25/05/2013 at 18:50:35
As the ranters are clearly fixed in their doom and gloom view and likely won't be happy until their nightmare scenario has been fulfilled and they can smugly say 'I told you so' from the depths of the Championship post-bankruptcy-fuelled relegation, I will merely ask one question.
What exactly actually do you hope to achieve in your bitter, poison-tongued, one-sided ranting? Many of you have been engaging in the same old nay-saying shit in all the years I've been visiting this site about one thing or another (style of play, weakness of individual players, the DK debacle, Moyes tactical naiviety, etc) and yet I fail to see one single positive or meaningful outcome from all this 'expert' criticism.
I know misery loves company, so I suppose bitterness craves acknowledgement?
To be fair, I can understand the noses of the glass-half full boys have been put out of joint at the fact that their anti-Moyes rants ended with Dithering Dave being handed the top job in the country and thus making them look a little bit less like football genii than they might have believed. But still, what's the point of all this, are you nihilists?
50 Posted 25/05/2013 at 19:07:37
51 Posted 25/05/2013 at 20:37:58
52 Posted 25/05/2013 at 21:08:09
53 Posted 25/05/2013 at 22:31:25
r />
Profits at Bill Kenwright Productions, one of the UK's biggest commercial theatre producers, shrunk by two-thirds last year and the company has given warning of a further slump after a "difficult" summer in which its longest-running show, Blood Brothers, closed after 24 years.
According to the Liverpool Daily Post, the group's pre-tax profits fell from £2m in 2010 to £668,000 the following year, on turnover down 13% to £30.9m.
The drop is despite the Society of London Theatre trade association having announced record box-office receipts of more than £528m across its members in 2011.
This is a man under severe pressure and he'll take every man jack of us down with him.
54 Posted 25/05/2013 at 22:38:29
Question - do you see no irony in someone constantly moaning and fucking whining about people moaning and fucking whining?
To be honest, if a website made me as miserable, bitter and angry as TW appears to make you, I'd gip it.
55 Posted 26/05/2013 at 00:48:10
"To be honest, if a website made me as miserable, bitter and angry as TW appears to make you, I'd gip it."
To be equally honest I have to ask you, if a football club made me as miserable, bitter and angry as Everton appear to make you?
56 Posted 26/05/2013 at 07:24:46
- Cue Family Fortunes wrong answer sound effect -
Sorry but there's a BIG flaw there according to your 'logic' .
Remember - I AM 'miserable bitter and angry' (and ranting and bile-filled and a nay-sayer and GRRRR etc blah yawn) so surely Everton (and TW) makes perfect sense for me.
It's YOU who want's to portray yourself as Mr Positive.
It's YOU who (apparently) spends each day singing 'Zippedee Doo Dah' (while no doubt polishing your collection of full-sized Moyes statues).
It's YOU constantly informing the world that your glass is brimming over and that you're very similar to Larry (of 'Happy as Larry' fame).
Still not to worry,, whenever someone 'answers' a question WITH a question, it's fairly obvious they're floundering and looking to deflect.
57 Posted 26/05/2013 at 11:02:32
So we quite possibly are looking for a management team. Whoever is appointed, he and his coaching team will have to win the dressing room over very quickly unless we don't want our best players to make the trip up the East Lancs Rd.
Redknapp, Jordan and Adams. I think this crew would be well received by Alan Stubbs and David Weir who I think are part of the glue that has holds our club together.
There you go it's easy isn't it.
59 Posted 26/05/2013 at 12:45:02
Again.. Too much Manc influence!? This started with DM so the conspiracists are well within their rights to be suspicious!
People complaining about negativity? Well us fans are investing in the club for entertainment or success & the custodians AREN'T investing for profit margin. See the conflict of interests there?
60 Posted 26/05/2013 at 13:06:40
The one and only reply expected from you Dave. Well done.
61 Posted 26/05/2013 at 13:37:17
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.

1 Posted 25/05/2013 at 01:02:20
BK sickens me at the best of times with his antics and failures, this is another new low but listen carefully and you'll hear the tell tale warble of the lesser spotted excuse merchant in the distance getting closer and closer to share their wisdom, wit and most importantly excuses galore.