Boss states club's position on Baines

, 3 July, 133comments  |  Jump to most recent
Baines is the best left-back in the country
Roberto Martinez has made it clear he sees Everton icon Leighton Baines as the best left back in the country, and a hugely important part of Everton's future, despite rumours that Manchester United are preparing to submit an improved offer to tempt him to make the switch to Old Trafford.

Martinez said: "I think Leighton is more than a player, he is an icon. He represents a lot about our football club and I am really, really excited about Leighton.

“A lot of people sometimes get upset when other clubs show an interest in your players — I always feel that that is a real compliment because that means Leighton is working and progressing really well.

“But obviously he is someone who is vital for our future and for what we are going to achieve. This is a big season for him and for us as a club.

"When you are the left-back of this football club, and the level that he has been reaching over the last few years consistently, it shows me that he is the best left-back in the country.

"As a player, it's a very important year for him in terms of setting standards and trying to reach important things at the Club. And, in a World Cup year, we are really looking forward to seeing that real consistency of performances and making sure he can be himself, as he has been in the last few seasons.

"I can't wait to start working with him.”

Quotes or other material sourced from EvertonFC.com



Reader Comments (133)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Paul Mackie
1 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:01:59
No mention of Ashley Cole anywhere in his statement. Well played Roberto, well played.
Steve Edwards
2 Posted 03/07/2013 at 13:57:14
So he's gone then? I'll take that with a pinch of salt. Money talks louder than a manager trying to hang onto his star player.
Steve King
3 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:11:18
I've got to say, his management of the media has been very impressive up to now. Always well thought out and very positive
Ajay Gopal
4 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:05:20
A huge statement of intent. I really do believe that the club is at an important crossroads here. If they finally do sell LB, then it means that we really have become a 'small club' – keep him, and it does 3 things:

(1) It tells everybody else that we are here to win things and not just to make up the numbers;
(2) LB knows that the club is ambitious and he is a key player for our ambitions;
(3) It is a strong message out to potential signings – Everton are building a strong team, and you will be part of that.

Even if we keep what we have and do not make big signings – just a new CF (Kone), a new CB (Alcaraz), a creative MF (Honda?) and new GK would do for me.

Tony Marsh
5 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:09:49
Roberto — you're wrong, son: Baines is the second-best left-back in the country... that's why Despicable Dave is offering a pittance for him.

If Leighton was the best LB in the country and being English he would fetch at least £20M and not the poxy £12M on the table.

I suppose Moyes will come back with £8M and Paul Scholes etc and we usually go for it.

I have heard that Leighton isn't all that fussed about DM and maybe he will turn Man Utd down because of that. I mean Utd's best player couldn't wait to leave as soon as he knew who the next Man Utd boss would be....

I think there is still a chance Baines will stay unless super sill money and salary are offered – which isn't the case at the moment.

Mike Green
6 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:10:30
Agreed, Paul – also no direct mention of Man Utd, their supposed bids, Baines value, Moyes, selling him etc just that he's quality, you know it, we know it, he's our player – and more than just any old player - so if you really want him start bidding seriously, otherwise sling your hook.

They'll come back with £18M tomorrow!

Gerry Quinn
7 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:04:10
At least RM has already gone way way more than one step beyond the normal Moyes and BK reaction of total silence when the media start selling our players off!

Quite a clever move by RM. He has placed Baines up onto a pedestal which is richly deserved.

The ball has now been flung directly into the Boardroom's lap. Would they dare contemplate selling him now after those statements?

Even if they did, although you may be right about selling him, I would imagine we could now get a price way above what we have normally accepted.

Al Philby
8 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:15:47
This strange piece of journalism (by a Manure fan?) about Baines might be of interest. One is left wondering just what it is that makes this guy tick:

http://bet.unibet.com/football/2013/07/01/why-signing-leighton-baines-will-be-Moyess-first-mistake-man-united/286

The author:

http://www.lifesapitch.co.uk/alex-netherton.png

James Stewart
9 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:22:56
Great handling of the issue by Martinez. Stark contrast to the Ashley Cole rubbish Moyes was spouting last year.
Robert Collins
10 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:19:40
Unless I've missing something? I didn't see a positive statement along the the lines:

"Leighton is our player he's contracted to us, he's happy at our club and we're are happy to have him here. Therefore we do not welcome any interest in Leighton from any other clubs, he is not for sale."

I can only draw the conclusion that Leighton is for sale and expect him to go for around £18M+.

It's what wasn't said that is important here!

Eric Myles
11 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:34:53
Quite possibly true Robert.

Billy has said that the transfer budget will depend on who is sold.

No offers have been recieved for Fellaini.

An offer has allegedly been made for Baines.

Time to start talking the price up.

Steve King
12 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:34:38
Al - What a weirdo! Also completely wrong!

Robert - The statement you just made is what every club come out with before they end up selling their player. I think RM's refusal to go into specifics and be defensive about a potential transfer shows exactly the opposite of your conclusion.

Ciarán McGlone
13 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:36:12
Nowhere in this article does Martinez 'state the club's position on Baines'..

Things he doesn't say
- He's going nowhere
- Not for sale at any price
- Under contract for a further 2 years and we'll hold him to it
- He doesn't want to go

To be honest the quotes from Martinez sound like marketing!

Drew O'Neall
14 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:34:31
Any other conspiracy theorists thinking that the bid from Man Utd was just a parting favour to Bill Kenwright from David Moyes with no real intention of follow through?

Ajay 019 sees it as 'a huge statement of intent' if we were to keep the player.. RM and BK get a 'Win' without doing anything, just rejecting an imaginary bid and keeping a player who never wanted to leave in the first place.. Further it softens the blow as other star players are flogged..

Robert Collins
15 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:37:46
Steve King @ 031

I have to disagree with you there Steve.

The statement I have just posted above usually forces the player to ask for a transfer because he knows he's going nowhere without one (Rooney?). In this case RM may well be saying to the board "I want to keep him!", but RM has just talked the price up and the door has been left wide open for another attempt on Baines.

Fellaini may not go anywhere this summer and so Roberto's war chest has to come from somewhere?

The club is edging its bets on this one, if we can offload Fellaini they'll slam the door on Manure concerning Baines.

The club will try to make this Baines interest go on for as long as possible in the hope we can sell Fellaini first and then have no need to sell Leighton.

Paul Andrews
16 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:44:36
"He is an icon, he is vital to our future".......


.......As opposed to the ginger minge bag " Errrr he is the 2nd best left back in the Prem"

The "vital to our future" may give a clue to anyone thinking it is a sales pitch.

Paul Andrews
17 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:50:16
Robert,

Leighton made a statement last week,saying he had too much respect for the club to ask for a transfer.

Over to you Mr Chairman.

Patrick Murphy
18 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:40:06
Nothing to do with RM, but do Wigan Athletic and Dealin' Whelin' get anything if Baines leaves Everton?
Robert Collins
19 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:53:18
Paul Andrews @ 038

I didn't know that Paul.

Then as far as I can see, he really is for sale, BK should have have made the statement: "He's not for sale!"

If Leighton will not ask for a transfer then Logic demands BK to make the above statement and end this speculation.

I expect him to go for the right amount (22m?).

Steve King
20 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:50:36
Robert Collins,

Fair enough reasoning. I guess we'll have to agree to disagree.

I think the whole "he's our player/not for sale/length of contract" statements make us sound desperate and ultimately like a small club doing what they can to force up the price.
Whereas RM has spoken with confidence about his future at Everton and made the player feel wanted and important. He has refused to fuel the media fire by barely mentioning a transfer, except with a positive statement about interest in the player being a compliment.

Harold Matthews
21 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:39:19
United have a long history of specialist wingers and defensive fullbacks.
Granted, Baines would be ideal for RVP but the move would be very revolutionary.

On the other hand, Roberto's speech appears to have been carefully constructed by a PR team.

Steve King
22 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:00:51
Having said all that, if they bid over £20 million I reckon Everton would accept and he'd go. To be honest I'd be ok with that, as long as every penny was re-invested.
Eric Myles
23 Posted 03/07/2013 at 14:56:36
Paul #036 "The "vital to our future" may give a clue to anyone thinking it is a sales pitch."

Vital to our future could mean 'we must sell him to get money to strenghten the squad or we'll be in deep sh!t.'

Let's hope he doesn't have his mind changed about asking for a transfer at 11pm on 31st August like Arteta.

Robert Collins
24 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:02:39
Steve King @ 044

If he went, I wouldn't be devastated, but it would be bad for moral in a general sense?

22m+ would be good business, if Roberto puts it to good use.

I think the Ideal scenario is Fellaini off and 24m+ in, Baines stays and Roberto brings in a few shrewd buys.

Paul Andrews
25 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:02:45
Robert,

he is definitely for sale mate,they all are.My point was Leighton will not put a transfer rtequest in.You are right of course Mr Chairman should make a statement "That is the end of the matter,Leighton wont put a request in,he is not for sale"
Don't hold your breath waiting for that.

Eric,
One of them will go,i would prefer it to be Fellaini.

Patrick Murphy
26 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:03:16
It really doesn't matter what RM says does it? Whatever he says will be torn to shreds or seen as the opposite to what he actually says. RM says '"I can't wait to start working with him.” that doesn't sound like a sales pitch to me. I imagine some people would have been happier to have Big Dunc or Phil Neville as manager.
Paul Andrews
27 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:08:51
Robert,

Another interesting one for you re £24 mil for Fellaini: I heard the clause that allows him to go for a stipulated fee, supposedly £24 million, runs out on the 15th August. A full two weeks before the window closes.

Chris Keightley
28 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:10:59
Loyal or not, if I was Baines, I'd consider going to the current English Champions not only enhancing your chances of being England's left back for the next 3-4 years but also winning medals which surely is why a player plays — loyalty lasts for as long as the opportunity of not winning medals continues.

He's been a great servant to our club; if he decides he would like to leave the game with a few medals in his cabinet, then who are we — however much it will grind — to have a right to stop him???

Robert Collins
29 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:12:27
Paul Andrews @ 049

If that is true? It's both positive and negative in that, some clubs may decided to wait and see if they can start the bidding at a lower price (than 24m), but if there's considerable interest may end up paying more than 24m.

On the the other hand, what have we got spend on players in the meantime? Hence why the door is being left open on Leighton?

Brian Harrison
30 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:13:02
As I have said before on this matter Leighton Baines will ultimately make the final decision. The press reported that Baines had told friends that he had too much respect for Everton to ask for a transfer. So if that's true and he is sold and doesn't ask for a transfer then we will know that the decision was taken at manager and board level.
Brendan McLaughlin
31 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:04:30
Might as well have just done up a brochure and sent it to all the interested parties...and a manager who doesn't get "upset" when teams come looking to take your best players...refreshing I suppose but surely it raises questions as to the managers determination to keep them in the first place?
John Beesley
32 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:28:59
I give up, if nobody at the club says anything they get stick.

If anybody does make a comment every syllable and nuance is analysed to death by conspiracy theorists.

Geoff Freeman
34 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:40:51
For goodness sake lads stop looking for hidden meaning in Roberto's statement. He is only being honest when he says he would expect other teams to want the best left back in the country.
Ernie Baywood
35 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:50:29
Sometimes you hear a player isn't for sale and they are sold. Other times you don't hear it and they stay.

At the end of the day, fluff pieces like this don't mean anything. It's just a reporter asking a question and a manager having to respond with something vaguely on topic.

I'll wait for some proper news.

Paul Thompson
36 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:55:29
Some Toffee Webbers:

'Our managers never say anything'
'Our managers never say anything positive'

New manager says something positive about Baines.

Some Toffee Webbers respond:
'He meant the opposite of what he said'
'It's what he didn't say'

FFS. What have we got now, a bunch of linguistic experts? No wonder they say silence is golden.

Drew Shortis
37 Posted 03/07/2013 at 15:49:10
Nice one Roberto, spot on. Ultimately this may be down to how much United are willing to offer and if Kenwright feels the offer is too good to turn down. But Martinez's words make it less likely he will go on the cheap. £12m is a laughable offer for a key player belonging to a top six side! If United want him they will have to make a silly offer for our Iconic left-back.

I'm still feeling bullish about him signing a new contract, which might also encourage Fellaini to give it one more year and make Everton a more attractive proposition for potential new recruits. Getting Honda in would also be a massive signal of our intent to challenge for trophies and a CL spot next season.

Geoff Freeman
38 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:05:50
Paul, Spot on
Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
39 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:11:27
I have to agree... this is getting really tiresome.

None of us have any idea what is going to transpire this summer or next season. We may think we do... but we don't.

Please wind your necks in with these ridiculous projections.

RM has been in the job hardly two days... please, let's give him a chance, FFS!!!

Drew Shortis
40 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:07:03
Just read that Manure fans 'analysis' of Baines. His article is laughable! "Baines has next to no pace", "cannot contribute to counter attacks", "cannot surge into midfield", "only good at crossing", "nothing obviously amazing" what a clown! He clearly hasn't seen much / anything of Baines if he comes out with this drivel. The guy is just embarrassing himself posting such crap. In the last few years I have yet to speak to a non Everton fan who has not been full of praise for Baines so it is not a case of being biased. Really comical stuff!
Mike Green
41 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:07:37
Steve King #031 - totally agree.

If Martinez goes into specifics 'he's not for sale', 'he's worth £30m' etc all he does is tighten his own negotiating position. Why put conditions on himself or the player at this stage, let Man Utd do all the leg work.

All those things are variable and can change - the only things that are fixed at the moment are he's Evertons left back and he's brilliant. The variables are not up for discussion unless Baines wants them to be or we want them to be, so its up to Man Utd to make us want them be and at £12m they're quite simply not.

Until then he's done exactly the right thing and fanned the flames of desire with indifference to their interest, while putting his arm round our player and winking in their general direction.

Drew Shortis
42 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:27:56
Mike Green
Putting a price tag on Baines would only send out the signal that we are ready to negotiate. If he says Baines is worth £30m United can go into barter mode. I think we have done the right thing by rejecting their farcical bid and coming out with a statement of our ambition without sounding like we are desperate or playing hard to get. We don't want to sell, so we shouldn't begin such a dialogue!
Mike Green
43 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:32:55
Drew - that's what I said?
Kev Johnson
44 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:34:58
No one can hear you, Mike. Your voice is so high that the human ear can't pick it up. Fortunately, I'm not human.
Mike Green
45 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:39:17
.
Mike Green
46 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:40:18
Jesus, you're right Kev!
Barry Rathbone
47 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:28:23
There is being positive a la Ian Holloway then there is intelligent, considered positive comment - fortunately RM uses the latter.

Surely the Rooney/ Lescott transfers are fresh enough to discredit absolute statements like "not for sale at any price" - unnecessaryhostage to fortune stuff.

I understood the reticence to comment by the previous regime because they appeared as dull as dishwater and sometimes downright devious.

Not so Roberto - well said that man.

Peter Warren
48 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:43:32
Roberto is spot on with what he said. If Baines doesn't sign a contract he will likely be sold - indeed probably mismanagent if this occurred - so it would be foolish to say he's not for sale.
Kev Johnson
49 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:49:06
Some new Martinez 'transfer talk' quotes on the OS. Sounds like Kone and Alcaraz are defo going to happen, with one or two more likely to come in. In fact, it sounds from what he's saying that we're not losing anyone, just adding to the existing squad! Hmm, unlikely.

Mike - try talking in a very low voice. Just be sure to stop before you get to the Andre Villas-Boas level. That man's voice is so deep that I struggle to understand what he's saying!

Gerry Quinn
50 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:52:28
"Please wind your necks in with these ridiculous projections"

Love it - well said, Editor!

Roberto should take a note from you when dealing with the media..."Prego, viento su cuello en, no para la venta"

Mike Green
51 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:56:30
Noted Kev - (rumour has it he actually does have a frog in his throat....)
Chris Keightley
52 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:59:26
Based on the rumours and other speculation, Alcaraz will definitely have his medical tomorrow, with the Kone bid defo accepted tomorrow. If this dosen't happen, maybe a few on here will understand that, unless they have the scarf above there heads on the OS, then it's guff!!!
Andy Whittingham
53 Posted 03/07/2013 at 16:57:24
Kev 087 - Yes, I'd always thought AVB sounded like a didgeridoo!
Alan McGuffog
54 Posted 03/07/2013 at 17:02:11
This is not sarcasm. Honest.
There are lots of people posting here who seem to have some knowledge and understanding of football finance. Now then.
It is said that our debt is around £47 million....is that correct ? If so there are a lot of clubs in a worse state I would go bail..
Should we ship out Felli, Leighton and Heitinga we would surely pull in most of that amount......now I am NOT advocating this, I'm merely trying to understand our position. We would be down two superb players and a bam-pot but we would have no debts. Tabula rasa as it were.
We would be in the shite on the pitch but would it be of any advantage to have a clear balance sheet ?
Just wondering like
Kev Johnson
55 Posted 03/07/2013 at 17:11:02
Alan - you're way off topic. This thread is about didgeridoos.

Gerry Quinn
56 Posted 03/07/2013 at 17:14:40
Didgeridoos? Does that mean we can all start drooling overJudith Durham again then?
Alan McGuffog
57 Posted 03/07/2013 at 17:19:24
Fair go cobber !
Kev Johnson
58 Posted 03/07/2013 at 17:25:15
Do you know, "didgeridoo" is not an Aboriginal word? Westerners gave it that name because they thought that it was like the sound it made. Fascinating stuff. Er, COYB!
Mike Green
59 Posted 03/07/2013 at 17:27:32
Is that why the call AVB "Ribbitt..."?
Gerry Quinn
60 Posted 03/07/2013 at 17:30:12
did-geri-doo?
Did Gerry do - WHAT?
Alan Baillie
61 Posted 03/07/2013 at 17:16:47
Alan 092: If we did pay off the debt, kenshite would only start mounting it up again. We would have a far worse team and therefore generate a lot less money. Hence, further in Debt. Sad isn't it!!!
James Flynn
62 Posted 03/07/2013 at 17:20:14
Al Philby - Thanks for the link. Had a good laugh.

What a nut.

Wayne Smyth
63 Posted 03/07/2013 at 17:45:01
I don't see why people are getting worked up about the potential of Baines being sold. He's just a left back and one player at the club, albeit one of the best we have. But we've sold lots of "best" players before and come out stronger due to the reinvestment of the cash.

The fact that we rely on Baines for so much of our creativity speaks volumes about the last managers attacking tactical nous. I think Baines will be important going forward this season, but less so, as our overall attacking game improves under Martinez.

I'd love him to stay, but I'd only have a problem if he was sold at the wrong price. I think around the £20M mark is reasonable for an english international of his proven ability. If I'm honest I doubt that Moyes will spend that much and I can't see baines demanding to leave.

We have a potential replacement in the form of Oviedo, but again thanks to Moyes unwillingness to play his fringe players, none of us are any the wiser as to his ability, at left back or elsewhere!

Guy Hastings
64 Posted 03/07/2013 at 18:06:36
There's an ominous silence on the matter from Dave Whelan.
Tony Draper
65 Posted 03/07/2013 at 17:57:17
#048 Patrick Murphy

Yep Mate I'm with you on this.
Roberto has said what he has said, and I like the way he's said it.

For me the signs are that Bainsey is NOT in a big rush to pull on a united shirt and that Roberto is genuinely delighted to have such an ace in the squad.

A new contract on greatly improved terms has been promised, so why should Bainsey throw a tranfer request in right now ?

Beyond that is the realm of cheap journalism.......and the delusional "body linguistics" of the paranoid and bewildered.

"When he says 'Left Back'........he really means left back in the dressing room !"
.........oh please.....go and play the double white album backwards !

Barry Rathbone
66 Posted 03/07/2013 at 18:23:12
I have a little ditty about Tim Cahill which refers to a didgeridoo - to the tune of "the runaway train com over the hill and she blew" - marvelous.
James McPherson
67 Posted 03/07/2013 at 17:47:47
Michael (Kenrick) - I understand what you say and why you say it! However, what's happening here is the natural culmination of all the deceitful and consistently devious behaviour and antics of the board.

Deny it, as we all will, the cynicism that pervades this forum is testament to how the Snake Salesman's Propaganda machine is in full throttle.

No better way to manage 'the rabble' (the board's view not mine) than pedal the dark arts of spin, counter spin and more spin.

It stinks and it's only our love of Everton that keeps us going...

I agree, love of Everton can be tiresome these days!

Kev Johnson
68 Posted 03/07/2013 at 18:29:53
I like to hear that ditty, Barry. Come on, I've given you plenty of time to make it up...
Dan Brierley
69 Posted 03/07/2013 at 18:37:30
James, 112. It has absolutely nothing to do with the board! But nice try.

It just sounds like Martinez is saying exactly what he expects people want to hear. He doesn't seem to have his own personality, and have the balls to say the truth. You don't hear Fergie, Wenger, Mourinho etc coming out with this over the top level of adoration over a player they have been manager of for 2 days!

I love Bainesy, but is he an 'icon thats vital for our future?' Top notch left back, but he will never be an icon in the same way as Dunc, Cahill etc. Nor is he 'vital' for our future, we will survive if he is sold tomorrow. Actually, what would he say if Baines is sold tomorrow?

'Well Baines was an icon, but Oviedo has the potential to be a phenomenal super turbo icon, and represents everything that human beings stand for'

Quite frankly, I am not too bothered what he says. I will measure him on Everton's performance, not press conferences. If he delivers on what he says, then happy days.

James McPherson
70 Posted 03/07/2013 at 18:49:27
Dan 121,

I was referring to Michael Kenrick's desire to stop all the analytical supposition - little wonder with the lies and deceit presented to them on a daily basis. No-one has a clue what is going on at Everton. Just as the board would wish I imagine.

With regard to Martinez. I will be supporting him as he is manager of EFC. However I am distinctly unimpressed, uninspired by the appointment of him, his soon to be backroom staff, our soon to be striker - all given very easy escape routes from the Championship - having all made a healthy contribution to journey downward.

Dan Brierley
71 Posted 03/07/2013 at 18:57:41
James, thanks for the explanation. But analysis of what Martinez said would happen anyway, regardless of whether the board were top notch or as sly as a snake oil salesman.

But thinking about it now, Martinez sounds as disgustingly over the top as our chairman sometimes....

Kevin Tully
72 Posted 03/07/2013 at 19:04:06
Here's a good link to see who's signed who in the P.L. ;

http://www.soccernews.com/soccer-transfers/english-premier-league-transfers/

James McPherson
73 Posted 03/07/2013 at 19:05:36
Dan, I agree with you. This 'mutual compatability' - (route out of chamiponship for you Roberto, easy supine compliant manager that echoes what I want to say for me) may just have been the clincher in the ineterview process.

Well I say process....it was that three week soujourn where I pretended that I was engaged in a rigourous search for the absolutely best candidate available...

It stinks Dan and it will do until the Maharaja of Mendacity, The Sultan of Subtefuge, The Prince of Propaganda. The Baron of Bullshit, The Chieftain of Chicanery...whatever his monika...departs!

Alan Baillie
74 Posted 03/07/2013 at 19:15:04
The link below is to a good analysis of what Baines means to us all. It also has a couple of clips of pure magic. A blast from the past Sheedy and why Baines is so special. 12 million my arse!

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2354914/Everton-wont-make-Leighton-Baines-goes-Manchester-United-sell-Marouane-Fellaini.html

Paul Andrews
75 Posted 03/07/2013 at 19:19:44
I think we can describe Mr Chairman as an I con.
Patrick Murphy
76 Posted 03/07/2013 at 19:18:12
Are you saying that Mr Martinez is not telling the truth, have you watched the video of this interview on the OS website? He seems pretty genuine to me, a lot less defensive than some other managers, which leads me to think he means what he says. I didn't see any strings attached to him and he wasn't sat on BK's knee , the more that I see him, the more I like who he is - if he can get an old cynic like me in his favour then he must have a bettter than even chance of impressing the players.
Barry Rathbone
77 Posted 03/07/2013 at 19:28:29
Kev Johnson, be it on your own head!!

(to the tune of :- "the runaway train come over the hill and he blew)

verse 1:
The wizard of oz is Tim Cahill and he's blue
A spring heeled jack he'll score a goal for you
In green and gold or royal blue
he's everton's boxing kangaroo
and he's blue blue blue he's a true blue.

verse 2:
The wizard of oz is Tim Cahill and he's blue
he comes from a land where they play a didgeridoo
but we don't care, it's legal there
so why do they hide it under the stair?
and he's blue blue blue he's a true blue.

Officer it's nothing to do with me Kev Johnson forced me.

Ross Edwards
78 Posted 03/07/2013 at 19:37:11
At least he is more positive than Dreary, also Sky are reporting that Martinez said that we will be signing 3-4 players, one in each position.

At least he is outlining what he is looking to improve rather than Dithering Dave who didn't have a Scooby who he was signing until 2 weeks before the first game.

Kev Johnson
79 Posted 03/07/2013 at 20:11:42
I like it, Barry. I like it very much. My favourite bit is "it's legal there / so why do they hide it under the stair?" Didgeridootastic! Take a bow that man!

I suggest you adapt that ditty for Arouna Kone if, as seems likely, we buy him. Or you could look at it the other way and start with an unusual instrument then build the song around that, namedropping an Evertonian in passing. It's up to you, mate, you're the songwriter around here.

Barry Rathbone
80 Posted 03/07/2013 at 20:22:25
Thanks Kev doubtless when I'm piddling about on the guitar something will come - it's like a disease.

Hibbo, Neville, Howard, Arteta, Distan, Baines, Felli, Landon all had the treatment.

Really need medical attention tbh.

Mike Green
81 Posted 03/07/2013 at 20:21:20
Patrick #135 - I've just watched it through and he certainly talks well, seems like a really level headed bloke without boring the tits off you.

I thought it was interesting that he threw the World Cup in there as a good thing and a reason for Baines to get his head down with us and perform to secure his place there. I wonder if Fergie ever did that with Rooney....?

Either way, he seems very decent, thoughtful and ambitious which'll do for me.

IMWT!

Jamie Barlow
82 Posted 03/07/2013 at 20:32:30
Brilliant Barry. My daughters favourite was Tim and is walking about the house singing it non stop.
Barry Rathbone
83 Posted 03/07/2013 at 20:46:31
Jamie, you've made me a happy man good luck to you and your little girl.
Liam Young
84 Posted 03/07/2013 at 21:07:21
I am sick of people saying it is an offer he can't turn down, the only way everton will ever get to where they should be, is to keep hold of our top players. RM has said all the right things here.

Above all else I am sick of us thinking negative living in uniteds shadow. We need to start being more ambitious minded, Big Nev Southall said this, and I agree with him. Everton under Moyes became a club doing better, but we start seasons aiming for top 6, that's a shite attitude, always aim for the top!!!, this club needs to start thinking bigger. RM can take this mentality forward. COYB,

Get lost Manchester, all that place does is throw money to get success, they do fuck all for English football. Crap youth systems,

Wayne Smyth
85 Posted 03/07/2013 at 21:56:39
Liam, I disagree about selling our players.

Given we're not going to get any investment, the best way we're getting near the top is to sell our best players for very large fees and buy and develop upcoming talent with the proceeds.

All clubs sell their top talent. Man U do it, RS do it, Arsenal, Spurs, why should we think we're any different in that regard? If the price is right, everyone is for sale.

People moan about the RS buying 4 players and us buying no-one, but they just reinvested the money they received from Carroll. I suspect they'll lose Suarez too for a large fee and reinvest that.

We've spent before when clubs have poached our players, like Arteta, Rooney, Lescott. Personally I'll take Mirallas over Arteta. The Arteta, Rodwell, Lescott and Rooney money have helped us to establish ourselves as a top 6 side. Without that cash to improve the side as a whole, we may have been relegated.

We can have the worlds best left back, but if our striker or midfielders are shit, then we're going to keep losing games. The strength of the entire squad determines where you finish, not how good an individual players is. Weakest link and all that....

Harold Matthews
86 Posted 03/07/2013 at 22:15:50
Great stuff Barry...I'm singing it too. Cheered me up no end.
Andy Walker
87 Posted 03/07/2013 at 22:40:08
Leighton's off then. Just hope we get £20m for him. RM talking the talk again, not walking it.
Ross Edwards
88 Posted 03/07/2013 at 22:46:50
What do you want him to do Andy, get in his car and punch Moyes into submission?

Hmm, not a bad idea...

Adam Smith
89 Posted 03/07/2013 at 22:42:45
Hi, I have been reading the site for years but this is the first time I have ever posted anything and wish it was more positive!

Many comments on here have commented on how Baines 'isn't that kind of person' etc - comments that I would also have agreed with. However, I have heard that Baines would actually be keen to move on should the 'right offer come along'. Also that Baines would not request a transfer as he is happy enough, but that he is keen on a move to . . . yep, Man United. The supposed source - Jim Martin.

Now, I know that this is silly season, with all kinds of rumours and 'my friend knows someone' style bullshit, however I have no reason to doubt this - although I hope to God it isn't true!

The big thing here is that he is unlikely to ask for a transfer and with anyone else that should keep him within our clutches, however with our board they may well accept an offer for a player that represents a substantial profit. If United feel we are asking too much would appear to be the only thing that may prevent this transfer.

It is not my intention to be a doom and gloom merchant - I for one am looking forward to the new season and truly believe that Martinez represents OUR (not a bigger or more affluent club's) best chance of improving. Like many people I believe that, although it pains me that our club has to be run this way, we should be looking to move on Fellaini and reinvest it whilst keeping Baines as he is clearly our best player. In order for us to get a player 75% as good as Baines is currently, in his position it is my belief that we would have to spend about £13-16 million - thus not leaving much to reinvest in the redevelopment of the squad.

I also believe that Martinez whilst not playing his exact system he used at Wigan, will look to utilise a hybrid of that and our existing system - those who think he will just do exactly what he did at Wigan are doing the man a disservice The problem with this is that BOTH require attacking full backs and whilst Coleman has come on leaps and bounds and I'm sure Oviedo WILL be good enough, he isn't Baines' standard yet.

Let's hope we get the outcome we all desire! COYB!!

Brian Wilkinson
90 Posted 03/07/2013 at 22:52:19
What worries me is some points about a pr stunt,looking at Martinez saying we have players here at the club and will only sign players right for the club etc sounds like a time loop we had with Moyes, we will only look at players improving the squad.

January comes; January is not easy getting the right players in,forward to end of season still dithering on signing players, end of August arrives, bids put in for players we have no chance of signing, feeble excuses we tried our best, back to home base and awaiting the January transfer window.

I'm hoping against hope Martinez gets the backing to sign players and keep players he wants.

Matthew Williams
91 Posted 03/07/2013 at 22:59:44
The club should just tell the footballing world it's £30 mill for Bainsey, up front, or he stays here, end of,the only exception is those lovable Mancs, where it should be NO SALE whatever the price! They can't wait to get rid of Rooney, after years of being bailed out by his goals in key games,but now he's being treated like a fucking leper! The shite being written by that sad manc only confirms one thing, it don't matter how good you are, if your a Scouser, you will never be accepted at man Utd. Baines is quality, we all know it, our Iron man player, true Blue & humble to boot, fuck em all off & keep him, Skreech too, let's start building a great team again,add what we can, bring the young lads through & lets see what the new season brings! NO MORE SELLING!
Vijay Nair
92 Posted 04/07/2013 at 01:05:32
Andy Walker (178) - RM talking the talk again, not walking it.

Are you serious Andy? RM been in the job a whole 3 days. What exactly would you expect him to do?

Eric Myles
93 Posted 04/07/2013 at 06:05:35
Paul #049, so you're saying that a club that has a history of selling it's best players on deadline day and not bringing in replacements will turn down an offer of 24 million if it's within 2 weeks before the window closes?

I think we'll accept any offer at any time.

Eric Myles
94 Posted 04/07/2013 at 06:14:17
Alan #092, the 45 million figure often misquoted as the debt is actually the nett debt which means that after we've sold all our assest (mainly players) the Club still owe 45 million.
Paul Andrews
95 Posted 04/07/2013 at 07:40:21
Eric,
I'm not saying that at all.
I am saying that Fellaini will go for less than £24 million.
What would you do if you we're a prospective buyer?
Pay £24 million now? or wait until the 15th of August and play hard ball with a financially strapped club who have a history of selling their best players?
Tom Dodds
96 Posted 04/07/2013 at 08:08:35
Mathew (#191) — Exactly what every Evertonian should be mailing in to every fan site consistently. We should be like all ships sailing in the same direction with one added mandate: Get shut of this chairman of ours.
Andrew Laird
97 Posted 04/07/2013 at 08:32:47
I like Roberto's soundbites. Over to you Manure, why don't they try to sign Ashley Cole? Mr 'greater things' regards him as the best left back in the league I wonder if Chelsea would accept £12m? I doubt it.
Dan Brierley
98 Posted 04/07/2013 at 13:56:36
CEO Myles (#209), so you are saying our squad value is £24 million as per the intangible assets in the accounts? Please allow 'Thick, delusional Dan' to clarify something you seem to not understand. Your statement is completely wrong.

Purchased players' values are not reflected in the assets once they are amortised (buying price divided over contract length). So players like Baines, Fellaini, Jagielka will have negligible value in accounting terms. Likewise homegrown players, like Duffy & Barkley will also have values of zero.

Why is it reported like this? Because it's a false economy to say your players are worth 'x' amount in your books, as a player's true value is only how much a buyer is willing to pay. Imagine if you say a player is worth £20M in your accounts, but you sell him for £10M... that's an immediate £10M loss on your accounts. Conversely, you would never make a profit unless a player is sold above the account valuation.

So it is correct to say, if Felli is sold for £24M and Baines for £20M, we could pay off our debts. I just wanted to point this out, as I remember you saying once 'you have to challenge these things, otherwise some people might actually believe it'. We wouldn't want anybody believing your 'mistake' (ahem) now would we?

Paul Andrews, I noticed you asked me a question on another thread a few days ago, sorry I haven't been online much these days, so I missed it. I was going to answer, but then thought, it would be weird to answer three or four days later when the context is completely lost!

Patrick Murphy
99 Posted 04/07/2013 at 14:36:20
So, Dan, if you buy 10 players at £1M each meaning a total outlay of £10M and then put them in the accounts as let's say 20% of that outlay: £2M. The following season you sell all the players for £15M, what is the profit in the accounts?

Is it a) actual difference in outlay and money recouped, ie, £5M? Or is it book value of £13M profit?

I am a simple person and don't understand creative accounting.

Dan Brierley
100 Posted 04/07/2013 at 14:43:47
Pat, my understanding is that it works like this. If you bought a £10 million player on a 5-year contract, at the end of Year 1 he is worth £8 million, Year 2: £6 million, Year 3: £4 million and so on. Obviously a lot more complex than that, but that's the general overview of how it works.

So if you sold that player for £20 million in year two, your intangible assets would be down £6 million, but you would list £20 million in your 'disposal of player registrations'. So, at the end, your accounts would show +£14 million. I am sure someone else can explain in much better detail than me...

Harold Matthews
101 Posted 04/07/2013 at 15:05:21
Bit over my head Dan. Wouldn't the players age come into it?
Paul Andrews
102 Posted 04/07/2013 at 15:49:58
Dan 351,

No problem at all.
You seem to have a lot running through your mind re the assets,tangible or otherwise.
Too much on your plate to worry about answering my post.
I can't remember what the point was either if that helps.
Anyway,apology fully accepted with gratitude.

Brian Denton
103 Posted 04/07/2013 at 16:11:06
Dan (357) Yes, that's a fairly good summary. The £14 million in your example would be recognised in the income and expenditure account as a profit on disposal. The difficulty for non-accountants arises because the practice of putting a capital value on players (or more precisely the unexpired portion of their registrations) and depreciating them is relatively new. Or at least relatively new to old gits like me. In the 'olden days' player purchases and sales were treated as consumables and reflected in full in the year they happened. Much like 'Other Operating Expenses'...........

What is key is to recognise that the Book Value bears no relation to the concept of value in most people's minds - which would be 'resale value', or even 'value to the team'.

Dan Brierley
104 Posted 04/07/2013 at 16:10:45
Harold, the theoretical 'worth' of the player (age, ability, stamina etc.) is not something that is accounted, as how do you measure it? Each player is completely different, you cannot apply an equation to work out the value of a player. Each 'investment' in a player is a stab in the dark. Torres for 50 million, Michu for 3 million. It generally doesn't stack up. It is not like commodities such as metals, minerals and currencies that have calculated market values.

If you buy a player for 10 million on a 5 year deal, your accounts show that 10 million declining over the 5 years. If he then signs a new contract, there is no revaluation performed. So he is amortised, and no longer considered an asset from an accounting perspective. So in reality, we have tens of millions in assets that are not declared through the accounts. This is why the creditors are comfortable with PL debt levels, as the assets are there to cover if everything went tits up tomorrow.

Andy Walker
105 Posted 04/07/2013 at 16:40:33
RM is great at the management speak, talking the talk, you'd think he was a management consultant from KPMG or something not a football manager. Walking the walk is ditching this style of pretentious vacuous statement and saying something that has meaningful content. He can do that from day 1 in the job.
Ross Edwards
106 Posted 04/07/2013 at 16:57:55
Goodness me, so he can't even speak without being criticised now?

Come on Andy, if he said that we weren't signing anyone, let Baines go, we're going down etc, then you can criticise him but he's only been in the job 4 days!

Dan Brierley
107 Posted 04/07/2013 at 16:43:57
Brian 402, same here. Which is why I don't get excited anymore when I see a headline such as 'Everton made a loss of 10 million'. Did we lose 10 million, or did the contracts amortise?

Nor do I get upset when I look at the asset decrease over the last decade, because the 'non-declared' squad value pisses on what we have apparently 'lost' in tangible assets over that same period. Having assets off the field is lovely, but is it a football clubs core business to own assets that don't actually kick footballs? Now if we were a PLC with active shareholders on the other hand.....

Brian Denton
108 Posted 04/07/2013 at 17:05:14
Andy (427) I would say that anyone who uses the expressions 'talk the talk' and 'walk the walk' without inverted commas is in no position to accuse our new manager of 'management speak' !!!!!
Luke George
109 Posted 05/07/2013 at 05:09:31
Just read on BBC Sport that Man City are interested in someone called Negredo for £24M... that name does sound familiar, mmmmm.
Paul Andrews
110 Posted 05/07/2013 at 09:04:49
Luke,

All bollocks I am afraid.
Everyone gets excited when this shithouse of a chairman leaks it to his cronies in the press that we have made enquiries for this player and that player.
Nothing happens,nor will it until we sell a player.
At the first press conference when Martinez was introduced Kenshite said "I have got a few quid for him"
Looking at the imminent collapse of the Kone signing the "few quid" didn't stretch to £5 million.

Patrick Murphy
111 Posted 05/07/2013 at 09:23:32
Dan Brierley thanks for your input regarding the way the values of players work on the balance sheet, it is a mysterious world this dark art of accounting.

Iain Johnston
112 Posted 05/07/2013 at 14:05:56
Dan, does the players wages come into it?, For instance £10m for the player plus say £10k a week wages over five years equals £15m overall, or is it assumed the wages are there regardless of the players cost?. The player may cost £1m but would still be paid £5m over the term of the contract?
Dan Brierley
113 Posted 05/07/2013 at 14:25:44
Iain, it might very well do, the answer is I don't know the exact calculation used. But it's clear the full salary won't be factored, as it is recorded as an expenditure and not on the assets column.
Andy Walker
114 Posted 05/07/2013 at 16:03:09
Just don't like this style of talk Ross, it reminds me of the bloke in charge of the RS.
Tony Hanlon
115 Posted 05/07/2013 at 16:09:26
Man Utd statement : Rooney not for sale — end of discussion.

So Moyes... listen: Baines not for sale — end of discussion.

Alan Humphreys
116 Posted 05/07/2013 at 16:43:45
Tony (741) so if Moyes comes back after being told no then he's just as bad as Hughes et al, Managers he slated whilst he was with us. Two-faced the lot of them.
Matt Traynor
117 Posted 05/07/2013 at 16:48:09
Tony/Alan, if Moyes comes back it's because Billy has told him what price we'll accept. We need a transfer kitty after all, and no-one is biting for Fellaini.
Harold Matthews
118 Posted 05/07/2013 at 17:15:44
Dan. Thanks. I never realised accounting had so many wierd twists and turns.. How did they manage to nab Al Capone? !!
Alan Humphreys
119 Posted 05/07/2013 at 19:46:44
Matt, quite possibly. Kind of insider trading IMHO. The FA could have a rule that no Manager is allowed to raid their old club for a season. Moyes is fully aware of the players contracts and acceptable values which puts him at an unfair advantage point.
Andy Walker
120 Posted 05/07/2013 at 22:18:18
Moyes a top PL manager gone. Everton's back room staff decimated and replaced by Wigan staff, yes Wigan. Baines and Felli on the way. Relegated Wigan players as replacements. RM an apparent graduate from the McKinsey school of football management, now in charge of our 'project' spouting management speak. FFS this is a disaster in the making. The ramifications of DM leaving should now be clear to all.
Eric Myles
121 Posted 06/07/2013 at 00:45:06
Dan #432 the losses are related to income and expenditure, think Mr. Macawber, nothing to do with contract amortisation which is related to assets.

As for the 'non-declared squad value' I guess you mean players like Anichebe, Osman, Hibbert, hardly pissing over the loss of assets value of £60 million is it?

Eric Myles
122 Posted 06/07/2013 at 00:57:29
Andy #832, the ramifications of Moyes leaving are not clear at all.

What was clear was that we needed a change, Moyes had done all he could for this Club and was in a rut as were the players and the fans.

The change of manager may put us in a worse position, or an even better one, we'll have to wait and see. But at least give the new manager a chance, the players haven't even kicked a ball yet FFS.

Eric Myles
123 Posted 06/07/2013 at 01:00:40
Dan #351 "Imagine if you say a player is worth £20M in your accounts, but you sell him for £10M... that's an immediate £10M loss on your accounts."

Sorry Dan, that's not how it works. Remember Robhino who City bought for £32 mill and sold for £15 mill, well their accounts showed a profit on his sale!!

"So it is correct to say, if Felli is sold for £24M and Baines for £20M, we could pay off our debts." But Dan, our debts are nearly £90 mill, £84.5 mill according to a post you made yourself. Stop making the mistake that nett debt is what we 'owe' and if we sell all assets to pay off debt then who will take to the field on a Saturday? What field will they even take to as Goodison will have been sold also!

Andy Walker
124 Posted 06/07/2013 at 07:12:25
Open your eyes Eric its there for all to see. We have lost a top management team and replaced it with one that failed last year. That is fact. It looks like the same is going to happen with the players now too.
Andy Walker
125 Posted 06/07/2013 at 07:12:25
Dup
Mike Green
126 Posted 06/07/2013 at 07:20:12
Andy - that's not fact, it's opinion.
Mike Green
127 Posted 06/07/2013 at 07:21:57
No matter how many times you say it :)
Paul Andrews
128 Posted 06/07/2013 at 07:24:47
Andy Walker 832,

But apart from that everything's custy

Eric Myles
129 Posted 06/07/2013 at 14:29:27
Well Andy if we're doomed already you won't even bother watching any games next season or looking for the results even?

May as well support Hartlepool!

Dan Brierley
130 Posted 08/07/2013 at 17:20:10
Eric, my example came from this video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyiCfCSbQFE&feature=player_embedded#at=49

Feel free to explain to us how it does work if you think that this guy is wrong. This is the guys credentials who created the video:

"www.financialfairplay.co.uk site is run on a not-for-profit basis by Ed Thompson.

I am a Financial Projects manager working for one of the world's largest banks.

I have been described by the Independent on Sunday as '“One of the country's leading analysts of Uefa's Financial Fair Play regulations”, and through this site aim to clarify key aspects of the Financial Fair Play rules. I enjoy producing financial projections and illustrations on how the rules will impact clubs. I have been commissioned to write articles, present seminars and have given BBC interviews on the subject of financing within football."

Vijay Nair
131 Posted 09/07/2013 at 10:41:38
The club needs to tell Moyes to fuck right off in no uncertain terms.
Derek Dolan
132 Posted 09/07/2013 at 13:40:23
News today of a new impending new bid of £12 million. Such a miserly increase is unlikely to make a difference to the clubs stance. It's looking like Baines will have to hand in a transfer request. Everyone seems to think it's as easy as telling DM he's just not for sale but ultimately it will come down to the player himself. This is what worries me. The lure of playing champions league could be too great for Baines. Will he get the chance with Everton? That must be going round his head but he knows it's unlikely and the Man Utd opportunity may not come around again. The Guardian reported that last year he was prepared to entertain the idea of leaving (see link below). Despite loving the club, I honestly think he will want to give it a crack with Utd. We know he loves Everton but at the end of the day it will be about his own personal ambitions. The only stumbling block will be the fee. What is he worth? The figure being mentioned seems to be anything higher than £15 mill with add ons. Will Moysie fork that out? We've seen how stingy he is with player valuations so we can live in hope.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2013/jun/28/everton-leighton-baines-manchester-united
Mark Tanton
133 Posted 09/07/2013 at 14:01:46
I think he will ask to go in the end. It's a real test of Leighton's ambition and desire to win medals before retirement - you're a long time out the game and memories and medals are precious.

If he asks to go he deserves our utmost repsect and best wishes.

Eric Myles
134 Posted 09/07/2013 at 14:10:11
Well Dan, he'll never get a job as City's accountant, here's the explanation I read of how the accounts would show a healthy profit on the sale:

"If we take Robinho as an example: he was bought for £32.5 million in September 2008 on a four-year contract, so annual amortisation was £8.1 million. He was sold after two years, so cumulative amortisation was £16.2 million, leaving a value of £16.3m in the books. Sale price to Milan is reported as £18 million, so City will report a profit on sale of £1.7 million in the 2010/11 accounts. Therefore, City will show an annual profit improvement of £18.1 million after this deal: £8.3 million lower wages + £8.1 million lower amortisation + £1.7 million profit on sale."

Simple really.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb