Neville goes back to Man Utd as coach

, 4 July, 125comments  |  Jump to most recent
Phil Neville has returned to Manchester United as David Moyes's new first team coach. Neville was photographed arriving at Carrington early this morning, where he is expected to be announced as Moyes's latest backroom appointment alongside four former Everton colleagues in Chris Woods, Steve Round, Robbie Cooke and Jimmy Lumsden.

Quotes or other material sourced from The Daily Mail



Reader Comments (125)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Jon Withey
1 Posted 04/07/2013 at 08:57:30
So Phil Neville has gone to Man Utd. Well, the MOB haven't got much left over now!

Bit disappointed actually, but hey.

David McKitt
2 Posted 04/07/2013 at 09:38:54
Gutted to see him go to Man Utd and not us to be honest.. I know wasn't the greatest player in the world, but he was a great role model and I think he'll make a really really good coach.
Patrick Murphy
3 Posted 04/07/2013 at 10:04:11
I'm glad that PN has gone to the club he supports – he might be good, he might be bad, but it completely severs all ties with the chosen one. Now RM can impose his own style and he can be judged purely on what he and his team does rather than have people associated with the previous regime being blamed or praised for the fortunes of EFC in the coming months and seasons.

Phil Sammon
4 Posted 04/07/2013 at 10:46:45
Sort of agree with you there, Patrick, though I do think he'll be a good coach.
Ian Corky
5 Posted 04/07/2013 at 10:47:16
I am very disappointed, Phil Neville has the ear and the trust of Baines and Fellaini, it is believed, Neville could be the lever for the Ginger Twat to steal Baines from us...
Tommy Coleman
6 Posted 04/07/2013 at 10:48:32
I love the fact Man Utd have become Everton rejects. Any chance Moyes can bring Kenwright with him ?


http://www.thedailymash.co.uk/sport/david-Moyess-first-day-in-charge-2013070274512

Tom R Owen
7 Posted 04/07/2013 at 10:50:08
How many assistants does DM need? I see Giggs is also to be a player -coach!
Tom R Owen
8 Posted 04/07/2013 at 10:51:58
Tommy
If Kenwright went OT it would have to be renamed theatre of fantasy not dreams!
Ernie Baywood
9 Posted 04/07/2013 at 10:56:22
Debatable whether this Everton news... but good luck to him anyway I guess.
Tommy Coleman
10 Posted 04/07/2013 at 10:58:31
Tom - Or just Theatre of Day Dreams.
Kev Johnson
11 Posted 04/07/2013 at 10:57:54
I'm glad he's gone - and I'll tell you why... Pip is no name for a grown man. It always made me think of the protagonist of Great Expectations. Acceptable name for a Dickensian character, terrible name for an Everton captain. I rest my case.
Lenny Kingman
12 Posted 04/07/2013 at 11:02:27
No more super spies in the camp. Excellent news.
Barry Rathbone
13 Posted 04/07/2013 at 11:05:01
Another "yes man" to tell Moyes what a good job he's doing when it goes tits up - gets better day by day.
David Pearl
14 Posted 04/07/2013 at 11:07:51
As long as Sheeds, Dunc and Stubbs remain I don't give a shit about PN. So all along the background staff worked for Moyes and not Everton.
Scott Hamilton
15 Posted 04/07/2013 at 11:06:25
Sour grapes is a terrible thing but I really want to see Moyes fail at United, obviously coupled with a resurgent Everton.

It would be great for the Prem. League to see their stranglehold finally relinquished but it would also be great for Us; proof that no man is bigger than our club and that all of those pundits that talked of "little Everton" punching above its weight thanks to Moyes were wrong.

Stewart Lowe
16 Posted 04/07/2013 at 10:43:14
I wish Phil Neville very well but I have a feeling that he will be just another average manager if he gets the opportunity.

For me, there are literally maybe 15-20 very impressive managers in world football that have a model of how they believe football should be played. Ferguson, Guardiola and Mourinho are perfect examples of this.

Ferguson had the vision to evolve his style of playing from his first Managerial game at Aberdeen right up to his last at Manchester United. When Managing Aberdeen, the general style of football was hard, aggressive and with very little technical play but has since become extremely technical and scientific, yet he has learned and re-learned many times along his career to stay in front.

Guardiola and Mourinho are examples of how looking at football scientifically can reap the rewards because the difference between winning and losing these days could be ¼ of 1% different to how your opponent plays, it's that tight sometimes. Mourinho has managed Chelsea, Porto, Inter Milan, Real Madrid etc and has been showered with success because he plays his football model that wins games and only tweaks the games that require the ¼ of 1% to win. Guardiola is very much in the same mould as Mourinho and it was unfortunate for Mourinho to not win more trophies when up against Guardiola that had inherited the greatest domestic team for maybe 30 years.

The point I am making here is that you could place Mourinho, Guardiola or Ferguson as the Manager of Yeovil Town and with the right resources (and I don't just mean money), they would eventually become world beaters because the model of football they would be playing would eventually be the same as Chelsea, Barcelona or Manchester United. People might think, well anybody can do it by throwing £500M at the club but that's just not true. Newcastle and Liverpool must have squandered £500M each trying to chase the title over the last decade and not succeeded as a result of bad management and laughable transfer activity.

That is why I believe that 15-20 managers world wide will have a good working football model as a basis to how they want their team to play, whilst the likes of Allardyce, Pardew, Hughes, Bruce and Di Canio fill our football league clubs with poor and outdated football models and considered blaggers of the game.

Andrew Laird
17 Posted 04/07/2013 at 11:30:56
My day has just improved.
Al Philby
18 Posted 04/07/2013 at 11:27:36
Good news. Awful player and no leadership skills. An upstart all the way. Adiós payaso.
Derek Knox
19 Posted 04/07/2013 at 11:39:44
Tom R Owen (249) Rumour has it Tom he wants a coachful of coaches to help him out! Too many cooks!
Derek Knox
20 Posted 04/07/2013 at 11:42:36
Slight change of thread here, but can someone explain to me, why it's generally been mooted that we need 3-4 players added to the squad! We have lost 3 with Neville, Mucha and Hitzlsperger for starters! I would have thought 7-8 to replace them and refresh would be more appropriate! Wish he would go for Nathan Redmond! Class act, pacy, tricky and an eye for goal!
Jon Withey
21 Posted 04/07/2013 at 11:53:03
To put the boot in, now that he has left:

Why did he walk away from the U21s World Cup with no criticism?

Everyone else in the England set-up got slaughtered.

Jake Lucas
22 Posted 04/07/2013 at 11:54:22
It is sad to see him go, think he would had helped RM gain the trust of the changing room.

Not the only bad news today, I see we still haven't actually made any concrete inroads into signing any players, anyone else getting a bit fed up that this is the case?

It's the same old s*** every year, the longer we leave it the high the price goes up on each and every player we'll be looking to sign. I know RM has been at the club less than a week, but surely he would have pitched a summer time game plan to BK while being interviewed for the job?! So surely knows who he wants to sign, so what's the hold up? Mean while all the clubs around us have now signed 3,4,5 or even 6 players.

Tony Marsh
23 Posted 04/07/2013 at 11:56:27
The way PIp playe d the game would not give me confidence in his coaching abilities. I mean all coaches are taught the ropes to get the badges but surely some of thier own input would go into the training side of things? What could PIp possibly teach players that he didn't learn from the FA coaching manual?

I am glad he has gone. I've got plenty of respect for the lad but the thought of him getting hold of talented players would frighten me to death. I reckon he would be a David Moyes, Howard Wilkinson, Graham Taylor type clone.

Good Luck anyway.

Patrick Murphy
24 Posted 04/07/2013 at 12:09:02
Just as an aside I think the Journo's are completely confused at the moment, visited the Mail Online, clicked on the Everton icon and 75-85% of the stories are about MUFC. No mention of EFC transfer news, RM's first dqy only a link to the new kit.
Mike Green
25 Posted 04/07/2013 at 12:10:21
Left wanting in his final few seasons but always a complete pro representing us on and off the pitch.

Good luck to him, a good bloke.

Peter Cummings
26 Posted 04/07/2013 at 11:56:54
Man Utd fans are already shaking in their boots... most of them don't rate Moyes and their view is if — he couldn't win anything in 11 years at EFC with his 'assistants' — what is he doing at OT??

If he manages to prise Baines away, his once great relationship with us will be shot to pieces.

Danny O'Neill
27 Posted 04/07/2013 at 12:20:22
Meanwhile tumbleweeds at Goodison. Is anybody there????
Jamie Barlow
29 Posted 04/07/2013 at 12:28:17
Jake, I know its a bit "out there" but maybe he'd like to see what he has to work with first, before spending what little cash we have. He's already realised we need another centre half and a forward and ٣ million for the pair seems like a good start. Give the bloke a chance. Up until yesterday, he hadn't even spoke to all the players, let alone see what they can do, or even if they want to stay.
Alan Ross
30 Posted 04/07/2013 at 12:55:54
Moyes finally realises he can't coach for toffee. Pardon the pun.
Paul English
31 Posted 04/07/2013 at 13:09:48
Over the 11years Moyes was our manager, I still didn't know whether he was a good or bad manager; the jury was always out on him. Now that he's got his dream job, just look at that cheesy grin, it looks as though his false gnashers are going to fall out.
Derek Wadeson
32 Posted 04/07/2013 at 13:12:05
I supported David Moyes fully while he was with us, I still would support him in any argument about his track record and ability while with us. Phil Neville was part of his set up and I wish him well, I hope he becomes a successful coach.

But they have both now departed and we now have to back RM and hopefully if he coaches a good a game as he talks we will improve on the last eleven years.

For anybody who disliked the Moyes regime, today must be a great day. For anybody who puts Everton first we can only hope that Roberto improves the squad and nobody who matters leaves especially to MUFC.

Raymond Fox
33 Posted 04/07/2013 at 13:08:26
Agree with Peter, about Moyes.
I don't see him as a utd manager.
Yes, hes in the same mould as Fergerson, an angry scot, but his philosophy of how to play aint!

As far as Neville is concerned, I doubt wether he will command a lot respect with mancs players, because lets face it he was a pretty average player.
Seems a decent bloke though, so I wish him well, but I don't think we'll miss his coaching skills.

Stewart Lowe
34 Posted 04/07/2013 at 13:04:28
I very much agree with one of the other comments on here. Everton have released Neville, Mucha and Hitzlsperger. Before we released these three, we were already the smallest squad in the Premier League.

I think Martinez is probably struggling to juggle whatever his budget might be. But if we can emphasise the need for 20+ goal a season striker, a keeper, a defender and one midfielder, we could back this up by slowly introducing Barkley, Kennedy, Stones and Duffy this season. I also believe that the more technical and quick-passing style of offensive play that Martinez likes to play, we will be seeing more of Oviedo and Gueye this coming season.

Also, I have no idea why we don't employ Baines in a more advanced winger role, as his slight and short stature would suit this better than a left back. Left back has always been his position, but aren't full backs supposed to come in with the clean and effective tackles that Distin and Jagielka are so renowned for doing time after time? I think That is why Ashley Cole has always been ahead of Baines because Cole does actually put those tackles in. I don't think Baines would be rated so high if he didn't have such a good goal scoring and assists record, but then, isn't that a winger???

Ryan Sloan
35 Posted 04/07/2013 at 13:32:38
Great news! Now he can teach the Man Utd youngster's how to lump the ball, and bypass the midfield.

I'm not bothered, and I agree that RM can stamp his name on the club... No more hoofball; Yes!

Andy Boyer
36 Posted 04/07/2013 at 13:29:35
If I was a Man Utd fan, and I know some unfortunately, I wouldn't be happy, ar e you seriously telling me that one of the biggest, most famous, most decorated clubs in Europe couldn't attract a bigger name.....?


I have the feeling that Moyes is there to do all the heavy lifting that SAF didn't want or couldn't do anymore but SAF is still there and I view Moyes as a puppet, there is no way he was first choice for the job and he knows it, SAF will still have a final say in things no matter what.

I am actually pleased that Moyes has taken his entire staff more or less as we needed a clean sweep, minimal lingering feelings if you know what I mean.

I am looking forward to seeing how Utd do next season as I have a bet on that they will either finish completely trophy-less (Charity Shield or whatever it's called aside) with Moyes intact as "manager" or with SAF back in charge and a Cup win.

Moyes couldn't even fluke a cup in 11 years, he and his players choked embarrassingly in the big games consistently and I can't see it changing at Utd.

I'll be shocked if Rooney stays as I honest think he knows what's coming and doesn't want to be a part of it.

As for Neville, well I wish him well, he served us well as a player and am ambassador for the club and also he represented people with disabilities tirelessly which I always respected and appreciated as my Son is autistic and he helped to highlight the issues and troubles that we as parents have to deal with and help our children overcome.

Andy Boyer
37 Posted 04/07/2013 at 13:40:18
Sorry for my piss poor spelling and paragraphs, the window to type in is tiny and I couldn't get an idea of the layout, which looks pants.
Gavin Ramejkis
38 Posted 04/07/2013 at 13:43:49
Pissing myself in work today with a Man U fan saying they are going to have to buy a few more of those big red chairs and stretch the dugout for Gollum's lackies to sit next to him on match day, how long until each Man U player has their own coach?
Dick Fearon
39 Posted 04/07/2013 at 13:50:40
From what I have read in the papers, and judging by the huge amount of transfer activity, a lot of managers have not let the grass grow under their feet. I hope that our boy has not been wasting time in Brazil and would not be surprised to see some Confederations Cup players land at Goodison Park.

The Barcodes are reportedly interested in Kone and offering cash so I guess that's that as far as he is concerned.

Jon Ferguson
40 Posted 04/07/2013 at 14:08:33
I hope not, but fear that Neville will develop into a Hughes, Bruce, Hodgson style manager. They are symptomatic of how cronyism is hindering football development. Certainly if Neville learnt anything from Taylor on his U21 jaunt, it will be detrimental to his development.

It has bemused me for years why people are confused at how poorly we develop as a footballing nation. I like Pearse as a person, but putting him in charge of our youngsters was a terrible idea, allowing him to continue for 8 years is criminal. He can't develop players technically and his tactical philosophy is pub chat standars.

I don't know if Martinez is going to win us trophies or be a flop, but he has a footballing philosophy. He's studied great coaches and developed innovative ideas. Hopefully his time at Wigan gave him enough time to tinker and he's got his ideas straight. I'm glad he's our manager and won't be asking for his head even if we come 10th this season, as long as I can see a development of our style. We have to look long term.

This is not meant to be a Moyes bash. The man gave Everton pride and safety at a time when we could have done a Leeds or Wednesday. He does have a philosophy, but it's Mourinho esq without (at Everton) the finances to buy a Robben or Ronaldo, making it less pleasing on the eye.

It will be interesting to see now Nevilke develops. His generation need to pull their finger out or we'll have another couple of generations of tired football to watch, internationally and outside the top 6 (with a couple of exceptions) in the Premier League.

Keith Glazzard
41 Posted 04/07/2013 at 14:56:31
Phil Neville and Moyes have many qualities, but unfortunately these overlap far too much. I can't imagine any heart missing a beat at GP when the team was announced and Pip was back in midfield. Very good right back and on-field leader, but really Mr Moyes, that showed the lack of imagination and ambition as clearly as anything.

You served us well Pip, but now you're going home. Safe journey, but I think you might find it quite a bit different now when you get there.

Ross Edwards
42 Posted 04/07/2013 at 16:09:59
Thanks David, just Kenwright, Bobby Elstone, Osman and Naismith left please.

It will be just like old times. Man U fans will be forming their own MOB after 3 games when they have zero points.

Sam Bull
43 Posted 04/07/2013 at 16:12:32
Well, I will be up all night worrying now; no Phil Neville to teach/train the team!

Phil cannot pass a ball, cannot shoot, cannot tackle.

The best ball he ever played was a through-ball to the opposition, who went on to score.

Great loss.

Simon George
44 Posted 04/07/2013 at 16:33:09
Hopefully this marks the end of our association as Man Utd's feeder club.

Can we now look to only develop players and staff for the good of Everton?

Derek Turner
45 Posted 04/07/2013 at 16:52:03
DM: Where is Wayne?
PN: Er, getting a beasting on the hill boss.

DM: Where is everyone else?
PN: Er, practicing backward passing boss.

DM: Tactical genius.
PN: Er, thanks boss.

DM: Not you, moron.

Ross Edwards
46 Posted 04/07/2013 at 17:01:28
Practicing hoofball as well Derek.
Kevin Jones
47 Posted 04/07/2013 at 17:07:49
As Yoda would say " Good news I hear "
Derek Turner
48 Posted 04/07/2013 at 17:19:41
Yoda is in Newcastle having a medical.
Alec Laurie
49 Posted 04/07/2013 at 17:32:36
In hindsight, all part of the plan?
Surely an off the record agreement months ago when Pip resigned (or hence Pip resigned).
Further evidence Moyes new about Utd ages ago!
Colin Glassar
50 Posted 04/07/2013 at 17:36:22
Glad to see the back of all of them. The new manager needs his own people not someone who would be spying for our ex. Neville is a manc who didn't even know what our motto was or even what year we were founded so he is going home as we were just an employer for him.
Steve Burgess
51 Posted 04/07/2013 at 18:08:32
Given the amount of revenue pumped into the premiership, and the massive underperformance of the national team over the past 5 decades it is difficult to get upset about the loss of a professional yet average English squad player with virtually no proven ability as a coach.
Tony McNulty
52 Posted 04/07/2013 at 18:45:58
I'm beginning to feel that we've actually sent "Agent Moyes" to the Manure.

The full significance of this fact will only become apparent in the weeks and months ahead.

Steven Telford
53 Posted 04/07/2013 at 20:01:45
Big Vic to partner Van Persie!!!
Tony Draper
54 Posted 04/07/2013 at 20:22:29
They have left. Gone.

They will only be of concern to me twice a year in the PL and possibly in the cups. From now on, DM and his cronies are opposition – NOT old pals. Farewells were made at the last home game. I care little as to how they progress or develop, for.... They have left. Gone.

Roberto interests me. I like the guy and I genuinely believe that he has much more to offer us than we have seen so far at both Swansea and Wigan. I dearly want Roberto to get our squad to add some flair to the solidity that we KNOW that we already possess. Will he simply "Throw the baby out with the bathwater" just to enable us to attack more?

Judging by his comments I believe that EVERTON may have appointed Roberto at just the right time, a time when he is both successful AND wounded. A time when the lessons are fresh. A time when he has stepped away from the limitations to accept the challenge of returning The School of Science to its illustrious heritage.

I rate Roberto's chances higher than our ex managers... and THAT will do for a start.

Ste Traverse
55 Posted 04/07/2013 at 20:35:31
Absolutely hilarious to see the self-styled 'world's biggest club' fast turning into Everton B.

Moyes seems to be coming back for all his mates, so can he please do us a favour come and take his biggest 'mate' at Everton....Bungling Bill.

That would be SOOOO appreciated.

Timothy Blanshard
56 Posted 04/07/2013 at 20:36:11
His time was up at our club, a lot of people have never forgotten how he went to the man u end when we knocked them out of the cup, then came to our end after clapping them. I haven't forgotten either.

I do wish him luck but not at our expense, not even a shock to me he's gone.

Can't wait for this season to start it's going to be one of the most interesting seasons in years.

Thomas Windsor
57 Posted 04/07/2013 at 20:59:47
Phil wasnt a bad full back but never ever a midfield player, but I never blamed him — I always blamed Moyes for playing him there.

So I wish him all the best but I hope Man Utd struggle and we win the League!

COYB

Alan Baillie
58 Posted 04/07/2013 at 21:31:30
Timothy, Cant really argue with your feeling on Pip. He has always been one of them an acted like he cared about us. How ironic that they have a fat bastard who is the opposite. Pip did ok for us but its good that he has gone. Out with the old and start fresh. Sink or swim it will be an interesting season.
Colin Glassar
59 Posted 04/07/2013 at 21:47:50
I feel a tad sorry for giggsy as Moyes will probably play him till he's 50. I wouldn't surprised if pippin plays a few games for the mancs next season as well and see Cahill going there on loan.
I think the mancs are fucked with this fella.
Alan Baillie
60 Posted 04/07/2013 at 22:18:03
Collin: I hope you are correct. Unfortunately money talks and for that reason I think Moyes will not be found out for what he really is.
Craig Robb
61 Posted 04/07/2013 at 22:28:28
Glad he has gone, never wanted him, never liked him, never rated him, seems to me that some people would give him kudos every time he made a statement acknowledging that he was shit. Good professional, no discernable talent.
John Shepherd
62 Posted 04/07/2013 at 22:35:43
At least he had the balls to say he was retiring when he found out what was happening, didn't try and mug us off like Moyes did.
James Stewart
63 Posted 04/07/2013 at 23:52:02
@599

Have to agree. Was never a fan and never wanted him here. He's always been red through and through so good riddance. He was always going to go back there.

Andrew Presly
64 Posted 05/07/2013 at 01:08:36
The man is a legend, a colossus, a modern day Corinthian. Maybe the last. It's going to be hard to keep on living, really. Where do we go from here? Bereft.
Tony Farrell
65 Posted 05/07/2013 at 02:26:23
Why is everyone concerned with what Moyes, Neville, the backroom knobheads are going to achieve? They're Manure's worries, not ours; they've gone so let's get on with job in hand. I for one won't be disappointed not to see that (whatever job he does) Round sitting there with those earphones stuck to his head listening to the Magic Roundabout and nodding to whatever Moyes was telling him.

I am so glad Sharpy, Sheeds, Stubbs and the Big Mon are still with us... a bit concerned with Roberto Martinez's back room staff coming en bloc – nothing there to inspire. (Has anyone honestly heared of any of them especially the goalie coach?) Anyway, they're here; Moyes's brigade have gone. So let's put our energies into not wondering how the Mancs do with our cast-offs but let's get behind Roberto and give him our support.

Eric Myles
66 Posted 05/07/2013 at 06:18:09
If Neville is the first team coach what's Round's job going to be?
Colin Glassar
67 Posted 05/07/2013 at 07:34:14
Eric, Roundy's job will be organising clip boards, pens, pencils, sharpies, headphones, microphones etc....for his immediate boss, Neville. He will also be making the tea and sandwiches when ginger sits down with his staff. Basically he will be a runner, doing little favours for everyone and gossiping like an old woman.
God, I'm so happy this lot have gone.
Timothy Blanshard
68 Posted 05/07/2013 at 07:46:13
This article says it all about Pip.

http://metro.co.uk/2013/07/05/return-of-phil-neville-is-david-Moyes-first-great-decision-at-manchester-united-3869733/

Ciarán McGlone
69 Posted 05/07/2013 at 09:01:49
One less 'yes man' - frankly this is a good thing..

Those who suggest he will be a good manager have yet to provide any cogent reasoning for this conclusion - other than the somewhat questionable assertion that he is a good leader..

Phil Sammon
70 Posted 05/07/2013 at 09:09:10
Ciaran

Perhaps you could provide reasoning as to why he wouldn't be a good coach.

He is a leader, as you say, and yet he balences that with being well liked by his team mates. He's doing well down the coaching route and seems highly committed to the next chapter of his career. I think most signs point to him being good at the job - so until he gets into it you can't really blame people for suggesting so.

Fair enough if you don't like the guy - but that last post was bollocks.

Mike Rourke
71 Posted 05/07/2013 at 08:56:00
No-one places apples on desks with more care and precision than Pip.

No-ones nose is browner.

DM just couldn't do without him.

First our cone-setter extraordinaire, now our grade A teachers pet. Moyes is really picking the bones out of us

Paul Andrews
72 Posted 05/07/2013 at 09:27:47
I don't think being a leader and being well liked defines a good coach.
A lot of coaching is instinctive,a feel for the game and comes from within the person.
If it was down to being able to pass an exam we could all be coaches.
Phil Sammon
73 Posted 05/07/2013 at 10:45:37
Of course it doesn't, Paul, but it is a good start isn't it. If he couldn't lead, was hated by everyone and couldn't pass an exam then he would be in an altogether worse position...surely!
Paul Andrews
74 Posted 05/07/2013 at 10:52:05
With that reasoning Phil,why don't you take the coaching badge?
Their is a vacancy at Goodison
Phil Sammon
75 Posted 05/07/2013 at 10:57:24
I'm not sure I follow your logic.
Dan Brierley
76 Posted 05/07/2013 at 10:50:19
Fully agree, being a leader and a likeable character is one thing. But this then has to be underpinned by being able to pass on the knowledge of what it takes to be the best both on AND off the field. Being a great footballer means nothing if you have the wrong mindset (Drenthe, Van Der Meyde anyone?). So what would make Phil Neville a great coach? 6 PL medals, 3 FA Cups, a CL, Intercontinental Cup and 59 Caps would certainly make me believe that this guy knows what he is talking about. And thats why it is a loss that he is moved on, as I believe he was the only employee (staff and player) of our club with domestic UK honours.
Paul Andrews
77 Posted 05/07/2013 at 11:07:04
You will never make a coach with the lack of imagination shown there Phil :-)
Paul Andrews
78 Posted 05/07/2013 at 11:08:19
Dan,
Mark Hughes.
Paul Ince etc etc
Phil Sammon
79 Posted 05/07/2013 at 11:16:54
Paul

You're really not getting this are you.

Geoff Edwards
80 Posted 05/07/2013 at 11:38:32
Ciaran, he's been highly rated in the coaching fraternity ever since he started doing his badges. That's why he has been fast tracked into the England youth setup, though judging by some of the other coaches there that is not a ringing endorsement!
Graham Tansey
81 Posted 05/07/2013 at 11:42:35
Phil Neville will be our next manager.
Brian Denton
82 Posted 05/07/2013 at 11:42:47
Dan (651) Good quiz question. I would hazard that Duncan Ferguson has an FA Cup Winners medal; Sharp and Sheedy have League and FA Cup medals. Sorry, no cigar.
Geoff Edwards
83 Posted 05/07/2013 at 11:48:13
Funny how people dismiss P. Neville as a coach purely based on his ability as a player - he could be the next Alex Ferguson for all we know.
Ciarán McGlone
84 Posted 05/07/2013 at 11:52:02
"Perhaps you could provide reasoning as to why he wouldn't be a good coach. "

-------------------------------------------------

You want to prove a negative?

Really?

Phil Sammon
85 Posted 05/07/2013 at 11:53:28
Ciaran

Yes, really.

I wouldn't ask - but you seemed so miffed at others not justifying their own opinions that I thought it best to make a similar request of you.

Kev Johnson
86 Posted 05/07/2013 at 11:50:41
I think the opposite, Geoff. Maybe not on TW, but at large people are building him up as having all the right credentials to be a top coach - precisely because he is considered to have been a good player/skipper. I don't see it really. It's the exception rather than the rule that international players make the best coaches.
Derek Thomas
87 Posted 05/07/2013 at 11:52:45
Brian#661; on the whole the better the player the poorer he is as a coach, historically, the top ' winners' as coaches were not the Hoddle's Maradona's, Charlton's Ball's... They were the Fullbacks, Cenrehalves, the hard but fair winghalfs and the odd rip shit or bust centreforwards ( SAF, Harry Catterick, Clough )

So based on that Neville may turn out to be a world beater

Lenny Kingman
88 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:03:15
#662
He could be the next Alex Ferguson for all we know.

Surely not. That mantle rests firmly with David Moyes. Well until the end of September anyway.

Patrick Murphy
89 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:09:29
For what's it's worth another highly decorated,England international, well behaved model professional with the initials PN didn't turn out to be a great manager Phil Neal anyone? No I didn't think so.
Geoff Edwards
90 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:12:50
Haha Lenny, I also think Moyes won't last 5 minutes there, though I think it;s a shrewd move getting the likes of Giggs in to act as a conduit between Moyes and the players when they start complaining about his methods.
Lenny Kingman
91 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:20:20
Indeed Geoff.
Furthermore I would say that United are boxing clever in this instance. Giving themselves plenty of option for when the inevitable happens. The Moyes experiment goes tits up.
Ciarán McGlone
92 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:23:39
I wouldn't ask - but you seemed so miffed at others not justifying their own opinions that I thought it best to make a similar request of you.
-------------------------

You do no the difference between qualifying an opinion and proving a negative?

And by the way, I wasn't 'miffed' at 'other's not justifying their own opinions'...What I actually posted (as opposed to your own version of it) - was that their reasoning was not cogent...

Remind me how the under 21's did by the way...??

Ciarán McGlone
93 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:27:57
Here's the 'k' and the 'w' by the way...they arrived late..
Kevin Tully
94 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:25:22
Lenny - my thoughts exactly. Giggs & Neville are there as a contingency if things don't work out.

He will be the Man Utd's equivalent of L'pool's Hodgson experiment. The fans will give him a chance, but are expecting him to fail, and didn't really want him in the first place.

Geoff Edwards
95 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:39:42
He's actually pretty much a Scottish Roy Hodgson, I've been saying this for ages.
Tony Draper
96 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:30:15
Brian Clough wasn't a decent player? Really, "young man" ?

As a player, Clough was a prolific goalscorer with Middlesbrough and Sunderland, scoring 251 league goals from 274 starts. He also won two England caps, both in 1959. Clough retired from playing at the age of 29, after sustaining anterior cruciate ligament damage. He remains one of the Football League's highest goalscorers.

Perhaps he just didn't keep enough clean sheets for the "Contrary Marys"?

Lenny Kingman
97 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:34:18
Sounds about right Kevin

I really can not understand United giving Moyes such a long contract. An absolute Kings ransom which Davey boy has now in his pocket effectively.

Fergies face is going to go beetroot coloured when his prime selection Moyes, and his ship of fools, sink without trace in the not too distant future.

Peter Warren
98 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:50:46
wish Phil well but not concerned he is not with us. I felt losing David Weir a bigger loss than Neville
Kevin Tully
99 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:55:19
Even big Vic is happy, I thought there was a little dig in there, probably about playing two strikers ;

"When I heard that [Martinez] became my manager I was happy," Anichebe told Everton TV. "I was sad to see David Moyes go because I have been with him for so long and he is the one that brought me through, but we have brought in a great young manager who plays great football.

"It's going to be a really exciting time for us and we are going to be playing completely differently. It's going to bring a new breath of fresh air to everyone.

"Everyone has got a great chance and has to compete. There are no guaranteed starters because it is a completely different manager. It's going to be an interesting season."

Phil Sammon
100 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:56:27
Ciaran

'You do no the difference between qualifying an opinion and proving a negative?'

No, I don't have a clue. Please enlighten me.

The U21's did very poorly - consistent with the entire England setup. Do you lay the blame at Neville's door? I'm sure he has to shoulder a portion, but I think it's relatively minimal.

What isn't cogent about the argument? He's a good leader, well respected, has a good work ethic, 'model pro' etc.

Your problem seems to be that he's shit at football and you think he's probably a bit of a cock. I wouldn't disagree with that - but I think there's a lot of people encouraged by his development as a coach.

Paul Mackie
101 Posted 05/07/2013 at 13:02:18
I think Neville will actually make a pretty good coach. Not every great manager has set the world alight as a player.

Of course I don't have to say why I think Neville will be a good manager as apparently we don't need reasons for opinions here on ToffeeWeb now. Right Ciarán?

Derek Turner
102 Posted 05/07/2013 at 12:52:41
I am sooooo bored,

I have barely done a days work this week waiting for something to happen...........
I thought Monday was the big day, instead, as last week and the week before, all I get to read about are the mancs.

Still, I cheer myself up with this mugshot of the ginger one practicing smiling.

http://thisisnotfootball.co.uk/2013/05/10/west-ham-and-david-Moyes-and-that/

Kevin Tully
103 Posted 05/07/2013 at 13:24:13
Phil #692,

Anyone who still has 1980's highlights in their hair aged 36 is shit.

Paul Andrews
104 Posted 05/07/2013 at 13:22:32
Phil, 657

Neither are you if you don't take the badge

Ste Traverse
105 Posted 05/07/2013 at 13:21:46
Yet another pile of shite posted by Delusional Dan Brierley #651 taken to the cleaners on here.

Forgetting the 100% gold carat blues legend Kevin Sheedy is on our staff?

Ferguson won the FA Cup with us. Stubbs won stuff in Scotland. (you did say UK)

Tim Howard won medals with United. Distin won one with with Portsmouth.

What a gold carat fool you are. Please check your stats before embarrassing yourself yet again by posting absolute rubbish.

Kev Johnson
106 Posted 05/07/2013 at 13:46:54
Kevin Tully has made a philosophically irrefutable point there (697).
Dan Brierley
107 Posted 05/07/2013 at 13:49:40
699:

Sheedy and Ferguson is where in our coaching staff Ste:

http://www.evertonfc.com/match/everton-squad.html?team=99998

If you are going to comment, get it right. Stubbs won stuff in Scotland (how inspiring to young players knowing he won stuff in a league akin to our championship). Tim Howard is a keeper, and Distin I will give to you. So for my one incorrect statement, you manage three. Not a bad ratio considering your track history....

Robbie Shields
108 Posted 05/07/2013 at 13:59:08
Dan, I can only assume you are very young and naive. I have more footballing skills and technical knowledge in my left testicle than Pip has in his entire body and experience of being a liability whilst a great MUFC side won everything in site. The guy is as tactically inept and clueless as Moyes, something you and the rest of the world are about to see very publicly exposed in the coming season.

COYB and Good riddance Moyes, Round and Pip.

Dan Brierley
109 Posted 05/07/2013 at 14:12:15
Robbie, is this the same Moyes that you, Ste Traverse et al famously said 'will never get a top job, and will never win anything?' I will file your comment along with your annual relegation and administration predictions.
Tony J Williams
110 Posted 05/07/2013 at 14:14:30
Thread should have been closed after post 697, there is simply no way to dispute that fact.
Ciarán McGlone
111 Posted 05/07/2013 at 14:10:16
"Your problem seems to be that he's shit at football and you think he's probably a bit of a cock. "
-------------------------------

Phil,

I would dearly suggest you read the posts you choose to criticise before actually formatting said criticism.

Nowhere have I suggested that Neville would be a shit manager based on the above reasoning.. because that appear to be what you are proposing as my position above...

I'll tell you what...seeing as your posts so far appear to be a mix of philosophical chicanery and simple manufacturing of my position..why don't we agree that our opinions differ....

You appear to think he'd make a good coach..

I've seen little to indicate that conclusion..


Does that help?

Brian Denton
112 Posted 05/07/2013 at 14:19:59
Dan, in 651 you said 'employee(staff or player)'. You did not limit it to 'coaching staff or player', though this might have been your intention. Which of these people do you NOT consider to be employed by Everton:
Duncan Ferguson; Graeme Sharp; Kevin Sheedy ?
Sean Patton
113 Posted 05/07/2013 at 14:29:10
Not just the highlights but he is not even a proper Manc as he is from Bury.
Dan Brierley
114 Posted 05/07/2013 at 14:37:07
Brian, you are indeed correct. I did not articulate myself as the subject was Phil Neville, and his ability as coach. I am glad you managed to get the undertone, as it was quite obvious. Others are not so capable of noticing this apparently. I wasn't running a quiz question as you quite rightly pointed out! If I am totally honest, I have not got a clue regarding the employment status of the three ex-players you have mentioned. The only details I found on coaching staff were from the web page I shared. The context of the discussion was whether or not Phil Neville's experience is useful to the club. I personally believed he had something to add, based on his impressive haul of trophies. This is the point I was trying to make. It makes no odds anyway, as the guy is gone now and thats the end of that. And I agree with above, post 697 trumps all!
Phil Sammon
115 Posted 05/07/2013 at 14:45:22
Ciaran

Your original post:

'Those who suggest he will be a good manager have yet to provide any cogent reasoning for this conclusion - other than the somewhat questionable assertion that he is a good leader.'

You see, this is what I'm trying to address. Prior to, and since, your post people have pointed out various traits that Neville has that they believe will make him a good manager. He may well fall flat on his face, I'm certainly not disputing that, but his has some skills that I believe give him a good platform to go on and make a good coach.

My jovial comment at the end of my last paragraph (692) was a laboured attempt to illustrate how you yourself have failed to argue a case against Neville. You seemed to assert that a negative comment required less qualifying than a positive one. Though I could be wrong - if so please clarify exactly what you meant by:

'
You do no the difference between qualifying an opinion and proving a negative?'

Paul Andrews
116 Posted 05/07/2013 at 15:20:42
Tim Howard is a goalkeeper.
He doesn't count then :-)
Phil Sammon
117 Posted 05/07/2013 at 15:41:34
Darron Gibson?
Steavey Buckley
118 Posted 05/07/2013 at 16:35:51
Tactics in many instances are largely determined by players at the disposal of the manager.
Teams like Man u can afford an open style play because they have the most skilled players at their disposal. More so, for teams like Barcelona. But teams like the previous Wimbledon that beat Liverpool in the FA cup had moderate set of players so played a more physical game and put more pressure on the opposition. And when Wimbledon had the ball they played it up front as soon as possible to attack and defend in the opposition's half. And in the way got results beyond their abilities. Not nice to watch, but effective. The same goes for the teams that Tony Pullis had at Stoke.
Brian Denton
119 Posted 05/07/2013 at 18:43:49
Fair enough Dan (717). Taken like a gentleman !
Ste Traverse
120 Posted 05/07/2013 at 23:29:44
Delusional Dan.

Can you please send me the links were I said Moyes will never get a top job? I was never part of the MOB brigade on here.

Don't put words into my mouth you absolute moron.

Derek Thomas
121 Posted 06/07/2013 at 01:21:02
'Those who can, Do!...those who can't, Teach. I give you Phil Neville player and coach, in 8 words, add on the highlights thing

Now you can close the thread

Mike Jones
122 Posted 06/07/2013 at 01:37:29
Just watching Moyes on 'telly' for the first time since he left. What's all that about going to Alex Ferguson's house and him telling Moyes you are my replacement and Moyes gulping and being overwhelmed. You should only gulp when Everton offer you a job and if you can't then fuck off. So Moyes, fuck off. Along with all of his apologists. This is Everton; I hear the word and I gulp.
Mike Jones
123 Posted 06/07/2013 at 01:37:29
Just watching Moyes on 'telly' for the first time since he left. What's all that about going to Alex Ferguson's house and him telling Moyes you are my replacement and Moyes gulping and being overwhelmed? You should only gulp when Everton offer you a job and if you can't then fuck off. This is Everton; I hear the word and I gulp.
Steve Cotes
124 Posted 06/07/2013 at 02:26:50
Those who slated PN are being harsh. One bad back pass or less than talented player doesn't make you a bad coach. Like it or not, he comes across as articulate and understood the club. I loved the story where he told the kids off for not collecting the bibs up after training. The man has standards born by his time spent under two good managers and two great clubs. We need those standards to remain at Everton.

My friend was fortunate enough to have lunch with Tim Cahill, apparently he said PN was the real under boss at Everton and all the players respected him. I'd rather have him behind the scenes than the relegated lot from Wigan.

Thanks for your loyalty, Phil, you will always have my respect, you always knew what Everton was all about.

Eric Myles
125 Posted 06/07/2013 at 03:51:56
Duncan Ferguson - Coach
http://www.evertonfc.com/academy/duncan-ferguson-coach

Kevin Sheedy - Coach
http://www.evertonfc.com/academy/kevin-sheedy-academy-coach-17-19-years.html

Kevin Rowlands
127 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:40:25
Good riddance, at least we won't have to put up with his silly ass tweets telling us how great BK is, and we all need to roll up our sleeves etc etc, bog average player, how he was involved in that 'send off' after that final game still annoys me, absolutely not worthy of that, my abiding memory of him will always be that sublime pass to Mcmanaman for Wigans second then having the absolute cheek to start waving his fist at everyone screaming c'mon, Everton legend?, no friggin chance!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb