Blues land Alcaraz and Robles

, 9 July, 249comments  |  Jump to most recent
Free agent defender and Spanish keeper arrive

Goalkeeper Joel Robles becomes the third signing of the week after the capture of Alcaraz and Kone
Everton have confirmed the capture of their second and third signings of the week with the news that Antolin Alcaraz sealed his free transer from Wigan Athletic, while Joel Robles arrives from Atletico Madrid for an undisclosed fee, reported in Spain to be €4m.

Alcaraz was out of contract this summer and his move to Everton has been mooted ever since Roberto Martinez was installed as David Moyes successor as manager.

The 30 year-old agreed a two-year deal, the club confirmed and signed the paperwork after a successful medical and international clearance was secured. That cleared the way for him to reunite with Martinez, who brought him to the Premier League two years ago.

Robles, meanwhile, also links back up with Martinez after a fee was agreed today with Atletico. The 23 year-old spent last season on loan at Wigan and kept a clean sheet at Wembley in the Latics' FA Cup triumph over Manchester City in May.

He signs a five-year contract and comes in to provide competition for places to Tim Howard following the release this month of Jan Mucha.

Everton fly out to Austria for Sunday's opening pre-season friendly against Austria Vienna and were keen to press ahead with the deals before they jetted off.

Alcaraz and Robles will join his new team-mates at the training camp but Arouna Kone, the Blues' first signing of the summer, will remain on leave until later this month.

Speculation persists, meanwhile, that Everton are in a good position to sign hot Spanish U20 winger Gerard Deulofeu on loan from Barcelona for next season. Journalist Guillem Balague tweeted today that the Blues are favourites to land the 19 year old who is also reportedly wanted by Tottenham Hotspur.

 

Reader Comments (249)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Tom R Owen
1 Posted 09/07/2013 at 13:54:08
Alcaraz in on two year deal.
James Marshall
2 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:10:01
Sky Sports are reporting the Alcaraz deal being imminent, Andrew.

http://www1.skysports.com/football/news/11671/8814820/Transfer-News-Antolin-Alcaraz-to-sign-for-Everton

Kev, I'm all for icons to jazz the place up a bit and make me feel special. A blue fez?

Mark Tanton
3 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:28:04
Not marquee perhaps, but a very useful and welcome addition in my book. Some might say he's too old, but he wasn't when transfer negotiations started!
Kevin Rowlands
5 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:31:49
This one is a no brainer, upgrade on Heitinga, free, and will be able to fill in for Distin, who at his age needs some rest/bench time next year also with Duffy hopefully stepping up I think we're in very good shape in the CB position.
Brin Williams
6 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:35:38
Yip, and this goalie Robles really impressed me in the Cup final - go man go.
Mike Rourke
7 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:31:30
Well it's taken long enough.

Now after this guy, Kone and all the other coaches, tea ladies and programme sellers have made their way from The DW to Goodison I hope we finally get around to cherry picking the only exciting asset they have - McManaman.

Phil Davies
8 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:34:02
Really not convinced about Alcaraz at all, you could make the case that he is a poor, injury prone defender and with Martinez possibly using three central defenders he could very well be starting for us next year.
James Stewart
9 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:40:25
Robles is a great move. Hopefully with displace Howard.


Alcaraz I'm not so sure about his stats were on a par with Heitinga which says it all. Would rather Duffy was given a shot but hey ho.

Andrew Ellams
10 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:42:58
James, Duffy may well still get his chance. I think we will see a bit more rotation this season that previously.
Kev Johnson
11 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:38:18
Yeah, Robles, that young Spanish keeper seemed pretty good when I've seen him. One thing, though. If he signs for us he's not allowed to have "Joel" on is shirt, as he did at Wigan. I had enough of that with bloody "Jo" a few years back. If we're not careful we'll end up like Brazil, with players sporting names like "Big Frank" and "Spiderfishman". Anyway, I fully expect this transfer to be done and dusted in the next 48 hours. In other words, next week sometime.
Al Philby
12 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:45:26
Robles cannot be a loan deal. He has got only a year left on his contract.
Thomas James
13 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:47:23
We are beginning to turn into Wigan.

1. Kone
2. Joel Robles
3. Alcaraz

Which is great, but I really think we need another central midfielder to compliment Gibson.

Dan Brierley
14 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:49:06
Can't argue for a free signing, especially with Distin having only a year left. Have not seen enough of him to comment on his performances, has any body actually had a decent look at him?
Andrew Ellams
15 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:54:22
Dan, he is a solid central defender Dan with good positional sense but not blessed with great pace. A decent fill in when required for the guys who will be first choice and a good experienced head that I think would make a good foil for Duffy should Roberto fancy playing the two of them together in cup games.

Also captained his country to the quarter finals of the last World Cup

Phil Davies
16 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:54:48
Al, so did Drenthe when we took him on loan from Real Madrid.
James Morgan
17 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:44:37
Should mean we get a couple of million for Heitinga. Jagielka, Distin, Alcaraz and Duffy seems a decent quartet.
We still need a good few more signings yet though.
Dan McKie
18 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:55:37
Happy to see players coming in, and I think both Kone and Alcaraz will do well for us. The interesting thing is that Wigan fans really believe that they would have stayed up had Alcaraz been available, which although hardly the most glowing of recommendations, it does suggest that Wigan fans saw him as being worth at least a few points alone.
Kev Johnson
20 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:55:38
A serious point about Robles... Before RM was appointed, we were discussing Bielsa as a possible manager. There was someone (who wrote cogently but whose name escapes me, sadly) who said that Bielsa would replace Howard with a keeper with superior distribution skills (even if his shot-stopping skills were inferior), as he liked his teams to play out from the back. I wonder if RM is the same, and how good Roble's distribution is? I think Howard is a decent keeper, generally, but he does tend to welly it down the park too many times.
Stewart Lowe
21 Posted 09/07/2013 at 15:57:29
A very good signing I think. Not a typical British centre half like Jagielka and so can offer us better options at the back. He is great with the ball at his feet and likes to carry it forward, which is why I say un-British like.

With £5m for Kone, Alcaraz on a free and Robles on a season long loan, I am very keen to see how he spends the remainder of his budget.
Stewart Lowe
22 Posted 09/07/2013 at 16:05:17
My only concern with Robles is that all the clips I have seen of him in goal, he rarely makes an effort to catch the ball and instead opts for the more flamboyant punching or deflecting shots away from goal.

This could be down to him being just 22 years old and trying to make saves look more dramatic than they actually are but it is a concern as Howard attempts to catch at almost every opportunity.
Eric Myles
23 Posted 09/07/2013 at 16:10:27
Come on Mike #880, you just want an excuse to break out the kazoos out and sing the theme tune to Benny Hill.
Andrew Laird
24 Posted 09/07/2013 at 16:03:46
No problem with this signing as long as there are more.
Jim Knightley
25 Posted 09/07/2013 at 16:08:49
This was expected...he won't add anything but we needed another number in. Allows us to sell Heitinga too and hopefully re-invest the money. Robles would be great...he looks a keeper with potential, who will offer good cover to Howard, and perhaps the potential to replace him if he suffers from the type of form dip he had earlier on last season. I also think we could realistically look to make Robles permanent if he works out, and bring in the kind of youth we hoped the Martinez era would herald.

I really think we need another winger, and another central midfield now. Moses on loan would be perfect, with an option to buy. And someone like Fer obviously would be great, although I doubt that we have the money to fund a move (could possibly we were able to sell both Heitinga and Naismith)

Kev Johnson
26 Posted 09/07/2013 at 16:23:41
So, Kone yesterday. Alcaraz today. Possibly Robles tomorrow...

We're getting a new player a day, right?

You are spoiling us, Ambassador Martinez!

Shane Corcoran
27 Posted 09/07/2013 at 16:27:03
Eh, he hasn't signed. This is just a rumour. Why is it being elevated to the top left of TW?
Andrew Bennett
28 Posted 09/07/2013 at 16:32:23
I think this is brilliant — Martinez has only been here a little over a week and the squad is progressing. Anyone focusing on the fact that we are signing Wigan players is missing the point; we are signing much needed squad players.

It felt a bit odd with the Kone press release yesterday that he was standing on his own and not with Martinez but this speaks volumes for me – Roberto clearly has a plan and is getting down to it.

A very proactive start in my opinion.

Paul Kelly
29 Posted 09/07/2013 at 16:39:01
He's signed according to SSN. Done deal.

More numbers to the squad, can only be a good thing, surely?

James Morgan
30 Posted 09/07/2013 at 16:33:29
Now it's confirmed.
Steve Cotton
31 Posted 09/07/2013 at 16:54:42
He's like a good looking Jamie Carragher
Chad Schofield
32 Posted 09/07/2013 at 16:55:18
Brilliant! Great work to have got two players in within eight days of starting the new job RM!

Can't believe people are bemoaning "took long enough" and "not exactly a marque signing."

Paul Andrews
33 Posted 09/07/2013 at 16:59:17
2 year contract?
Very clever move.
We have had managers in the recent past who have given average players 5 year contracts
Colin Glassar
34 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:12:10
Alcaraz has an 84% successful passing rate which is better than many midfielders. Adios hoofball, welcome back football.
Shane Corcoran
35 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:18:01
Man, is my face red.
James Marshall
36 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:38:08
Alcaraz is a really good, cultured defender so this is great news - his age doesn't really matter either on a 2 yr deal and free = good business to my mind.

As for Robles, I'm made up he's signing permanently. Quality young keeper and should be our number one by Christmas. Really good signing, and we signed him from Atletico Madrid not Wigan......which makes a change! ;-)

Timothy Blanshard
37 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:35:09
I am just watching the interview on the official site and even after all these weeks, that badge is NOT growing on me in any way shape or form I can't take it seriously it's such a let down, I really wish they could have changed it before the start of the new season. What a mess! imo
So Glad it's going to be changed.
Back on topic I think he will do well for us, if he gets anywhere near the form of Buzz I will be happy, welcome to the best club in the world.
Denis Richardson
38 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:33:07
As alreasdy mentioned, seems a decent enough signing on a free and his wages will not be that high so we'll 'save' by getting rid of Heitinga. Certainly don't need 5 CBs.

Not sure how much longer Distins legs will hold out and have to admit I'm not a great fan of playing three CBs. Have heard many CBs say they prefer playing in a pair so as to avoid confusion on who marks who etc...anyway what do I know.

Welcome aboard Alcatraz - his parents may as well have just called him that.

Hopefully the loan for the GK has an option to buy, in case he turns out better than Howard.

That's almost 3 players in now - replacing Hitz, Neville and Mucha, numbers wise.

Paul Kelly
39 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:38:09
Stay out the sun Shane.

Any news on getting Robles?

Andy Walker
40 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:23:10
We loose our manager, then most of our back room staff and our captain. Appoint a manager and then a group of coaches from a relegated team. Now we start buying their old (in both senses of the word) players. Baines on the way, probably followed by Felli as well.

This is a complete joke, and there seems to be general ambivalence to it apart from the odd exception. Where's the passion shown by so many supporters when BK even sneezes, when our team and its management is being terminally weakened? I'm not that bothered about our owner at the moment compared to what's actually happening to the most important part of our team, ie, the players and management. Why haven't the media been picking up on the 'Wiganisation' of EFC and the almost inevitable consequences?

We have the look of a poor team next season having lost Moyes and his backroom staff and the likely loss of Baines and Felli. The management consultant in charge of our team is wearing the emperor's new clothes.

Derek Knox
41 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:38:54
When does the shuttle service start from Wigan DW to Goodison Park? Oops it's been running for a couple of days now! Might as well go the whole hog and get Macarthy and Mc Manaman while we are at it! That young goalkeeper looks like good competition for Tim Howard!
Peter Laverty
42 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:29:22
Kone
Alcaraz
Robles

Diame?
Moses?

I'd have no problem with that at all.

Stewart Lowe
44 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:46:03
Andy Walker: I don't know how one person can be so negative. It was obvious Moyes was going to Man Utd at some point in his career and so a new dawn of football and how its played was inevitable at Everton. How can you be anything but excited at what's around the corner. Some people would not be happy if the next 3 people through the Goodison door were Messi, Ronaldo and Iniesta. Let's have less of the doom and gloom please.
James Marshall
45 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:49:35
Considering our financial position, and I've been one to complain heartily about the Wigan thing, I'd say that we've done pretty well so far in signing these 2, possibly 3 players.

The Robles deal is a really good one, particularly.

Just a midfielder required and that'll be all our summer business buttoned up early so the squad can get ready for the new season in earnest. That alone makes a pleasant change.

Denis Richardson
46 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:43:39
Andy 944 - being a bit melodramatic aren't you?

First of all its standard that a manager brings in his own backroom staff - happens almost every time a manager changes, he simply wants to have the sme people he trusts working for him. (Which is why about 3-4 of our old staff have joined Moyes at Manu even thouhg the staff Moyes let go are arguably much much better given they've won about 20 odd trophies between them!). So no issues there really.

Re the players, we've only signed 2 ffs and one of them came on a free. Hardly as if we've turned into Wigan. We were crying out for another strker and now have one.

Lets keep the moaning on the side until we've played a few games first - give the guy a chance!

Will you still be moaning if we win the first 3-4 games?

Colin Glassar
47 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:50:08
Andy Walker, if you write to BK he might give you a cuddle. Moyes has gone, get over it.
James Marshall
48 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:57:35
Technically speaking, Alcaraz wasn't signed from Wigan either - his contract has expired and he's a free agent, so in truth we've only signed Kone from Wigan.
Jim Lloyd
49 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:46:02
Andy (#944),

It's our owner who has employed Martinez after listening to his plans for Everton. Presumably he has also sanctioned the moves Roberto has already made. I guess the Man Utd fans, or some of them, will be saying the same about our previous manager and the team he has taken with him and the "Evertonisation" of their club.

I think he's bought two decent players in and hopefully it'll mean he can get a few bob for the sale of Heitinga. And I think he'll need all the pennies he can grab hold of....

I believe we're still in the financial straight jacket we were in during the January window. If Baines and/or Fellaini go, then we might have a few bob. We will otherwise have to wait till we get some leftovers from the Telly Money.

Ajay Gopal
50 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:50:56
Ahh.. 3 additions who have actually won something....;-)
Dan Parker
51 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:57:57
We all thought Distin was old when he joined us and he's been a revelation since joining, easily had our moneys worth there. Hopefully the same with the new guy and offload Heitinga who's on about 75k a week?
Phil Sammon
52 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:01:04
Deulofeu looks like it's happening too.
James Marshall
53 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:02:17
References please, Phil? Don't tease me with sentences like that one!
Michael Brooks
54 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:03:35
Please can some explain to me why I should be happy about getting ex-Wigan players and coaches?

I have come to terms with appointing a manger that got his team relegated but with all these Wigan players and coaches coming in it just seem like a huge step backwards.

Everton seem to be linked to only Wigan current and past player! Can someone, anyone explain to me why Everton shouldn’t be aiming higher?

Ciarán McGlone
55 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:04:06
Ballague has just tweeted that we're favourites to get the Barcelona kid as well..
James Marshall
56 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:05:04
Because we don't have enough money to aim higher, Michael and we're not a top club any more, and we're not in Europe.

That's about the size of it.

Paul Kelly
57 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:05:51
Robles-done deal according to two different sites!
Jeremy Benson
58 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:05:50
3 players from a first team 11 that were relegated. Enough said, I think.
James Marshall
60 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:08:49
Robles is the goalkeeper, you can hardly blame him for the other 10 players, and he only played 8 games all season for Wigan last year.. Alcaraz was injured for the last third of the season, so you can't blame him either.

Kone did his bit by scoring 11 goals in the Premier league, so you can't blame him either.

Have a bit of perspective, Jeremy. No offence mate.

Barry Rathbone
62 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:56:32
Adam, being relegated doesn't mean the whole team is crap.

I'd have Taarabt and Remy from QPR, Le Fondre from Reading as well as the known suspects from Wigan.

You're deliberately being obtuse the Wigan outfit has a mass of extenuating circumstances that makes us look like footballing aristos by comparison.

Even so against massive odds they bettered us when it mattered (ie en route to winning something) - why ignore that?

Jeremy Benson
63 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:11:30
So James, none of the wigan first 11 can take any responsibility then?

So by that very logic, we could just take them all, and somehow not get relegated?

Jeez.

Dick Brady
64 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:13:05
And the Everton squad keeps on getting older.
Ajay Gopal
65 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:07:30
Sky Sports reporting that Alcaraz is a left-back. I thought he was a centre-back? Can someone please enlighten me on that?
Paul Kelly
66 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:11:47
Bit of perspective.

We've got a striker whose better than what we've got.

A defender who'll probably be a squad player(guess).

And a decent keeper who will give Howard (at the least) a much needed kick up the arse, or possibly replace him, I don't know.

We've paid only 5 million, for all three plus wages.

It's the level were at i'm afraid. But I'm still optimistic.

Michael Brooks
67 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:11:25
Ok James Marshall so Everton will be aiming to buy players from relegated sides, the last side that did that was Wolves, work out well for them!!
James Marshall
68 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:13:09
Jeremy, we're not signing the entire team, it's hardly the same thing.

The keeper only played 8 times all season and some of those games were in the cup so how is that relevant?

Alcaraz was injured for the last 13 league games too, so how can you hold him personally responsible for them getting relegated?

Kone scored 11 goals, which seems to me to be more than any of our strikers last year.

I don't mean to get into a row with you, but having a little bit more perspective and not being quite so reactionary would be worth thinking about.

Admittedly we're not buying the best players out there, but we don't have the money or the pulling power for the best players out there.

Joel Robles is a really good young keeper, and will be a great signing.

James Marshall
69 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:19:11
See above, Michael.
James Stewart
70 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:17:25
Ajay, he's a left sided centre back so sky have it about half right as usual
Paul Kelly
71 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:21:49
Correction. Apparently we're buying Robles. Thought it was just a loan.
Michael Brooks
72 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:20:52
I believe Everton have more pulling power than you think, top six side with a good team just needing one or two good players to push on, not average players.
Stephen Coles
74 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:24:05
Isn't that the keeper that doesn't know the back pass rule? yea great! lol
Mike Allison
75 Posted 09/07/2013 at 17:57:51
"We have had managers in the recent past..." Pedant's corner maybe, but we haven't had 'managers' (plural) in the recent past. Do you mean Moyes? And which player are you unhappy about getting a five year contract?

"Certainly don't need 5 CBs." We may if Martinez wants to play the three at the back formation he employed at times at Wigan. Because of this I wouldn't be quite so certain that he's looking to sell Heitinga. Obviously I see the logic of the assumption, but its not a foregone conclusion.

"This is a complete joke, and there seems to be general ambivalence to it apart from the odd exception. Where's the passion shown by so many supporters when BK even sneezes, when our team and its management is being terminally weakened?" Andy I see your point, and I think deep down we've all got a nagging feeling you could be right, but again, its far from a foregone conclusion. I don't think anyone lacks passion, but its impossible to be as sure as you seem to be about the way things are going. Wigan looked brilliant at times last year, and won a trophy. We've had this whole argument a few times during the manager switch, and people are just inclined to take the positive interpretation at the moment. Those people (the three players plus coaches), in an Everton environment rather than a Wigan one, could possibly achieve big things, and its certainly not the case that they are destined to do exactly what they did at Wigan, when so much else is different.

James Marshall
77 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:23:41
Can you elaborate on that, Michael? What pulling power do you believe we have?

My opinion is that we're not a top European club in the vain of Utd, Madrid, Barca, Bayern, Chelsea, even Arsenal and dare I say it, the RS.

We have zero European pedigree and most players outside the UK under about 25 have barely heard of us. I just don't think we're a big draw any more, although having a Spanish manager who knows the Spanish league and probably has better contacts than the last manager, certainly helps.

Oh, and money talks. We don't have much.

Patrick Murphy
78 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:20:16
I think we'll find that buying players is going to be like this for the next few seasons. That is buying experienced and proven players for around £3-£5m on relatively short-term contracts and hoping that our youngsters develop into first team players or develop enough to have a reasonable sell on value. I think that it has more to do with the Fair play rules and our buying policy will adapt as required, of course it could be just a case of RM getting in players who he has worked with and integrating them into the squad, which would give those players already here a fair crack of the whip and they won't have the opportunity to complain.

I don't think we'll see anymore Felliani's or Yakubu type transfers for a good few years, not ideal but probably the only way to start addressing the balance sheet situation.


Jim Lloyd
79 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:13:21
Michael, 958.
No-one can explain it to you, if you don't want to see. Moyes took our coaches after he left for Man Utd. Martinez comes in and evidently has faith in his coaching team to get the best out of the players he's got/brings in.

Could I just remind you that, unless he wanted to do all the coaching himself, he had to get some in. Do you suggest he leaves it a few months and goes on a scouting tour, as we wouldn't have a scout either to do any scouting, and let the team look after itself|?

Gordon Bennett, the players he's brought in look useful. The club isn't awash with funds, so it's no use drawing up a wish list of top-of-the-range players. Even if we sell players, Martinez might well only get enough to buy a couple more.

It is't the Wiganisation of Everton. What he's done so far gives me hope that we can start playing some attractive and winning football... at last!

Drew Shortis
80 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:19:47
I'm very pleased with all three new signings. It makes sense for Martinez to cherry pick the best of Wigan's players as he knows their capabilities. I think £5m for Kone will be great business if he plays the role expected of him and can get 15+ next year. Alcaraz on a free is a handy addition and will allow Heitinga to be moved on, giving us some funds for a midfielder (Diame?) and saving £50k off of the wage bill. Joel will provide excellent competition and cover for Howard, and it doesn't sound like he is going to cost us an arm and a leg.

Our next priority is to sort out Baines and Fellaini's immediate future. I hope they both stay, but if they are going then get it done quickly. We can then go after the likes of Honda, Diame, McManaman, Moses, McCarthy, Capoue, Fer and the Brazilian LB from Granada. If they both decide to give Martinez a season to show what he can do I think we can only expect to get in one relatively cheap midfielder and some loans, but we will still have two world class players in the team. With the prospect of Barkley breaking into the first team and some talented youngsters like Junior and Duffy getting more of an opportunity I think we are looking in really good shape!

Paul Ferry
81 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:13:19

Jeremy (967) So James, none of the wigan first 11 can take any responsibility then?

I put all the blame fairly and squarely on the shoulders of
the Wigan gaffer, er, hang on, .....

Stewart (901) but it is a concern as Howard attempts to catch at almost every opportunity.

That's it! Nailed on! Howard 'ATTEMPTS' (emphasis clearly on attempts) to catch a ball at nearly every opportunity.

Then we need to incorporate the flopping, fluffing, and flapping-opometer

So attempts = tgx45 to the power of 23 - divided by flops, fluffs and flaps that would be th@X-6723 - moderated by average Prem flops, fluffs and flaps that is 78-34NNX

In a nutshell: tgx45 to the power of 23 divided by th@X-6723 moderated by 78-34NNX

That gives us a grand score of: YU-34@BB87L+4

And that, quite frankly, Mr. Howard is nowhere near
good enough for an Everton goalkeeper.

I'm sorry, but the fact's don't lie on this one.

Thank Allah we seem to be getting a goalie who can
step into Mr. Howard's shoes straight away

IHHFB

Phil Sammon
82 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:25:22
Surely we should judge the players individually rather than the performance of the team they've left.

After all, would Man Utd be finishing 6th if they bought Baines and Fellaini?

Patrick Murphy
83 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:27:12
Oh and I meant to add that Wigan Athletic although a lot smaller than Everton in fan-base also have a reputation for being a family club both inside the dressing room and out in the community, there are more positive similarities between the two clubs than some would like to acknowledge.
Michael Brooks
84 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:27:21
I never said Everton have the same pulling power as a top European side such as Madrid, Barcelona, Bayern, Chelsea, Arsenal, Utd and City or even at a push Liverpool, that hurt to say/write.

However, Everton do have more pulling power that half the sides in the premier league! More that West Ham, Stoke and in fact anyone except Liverpool who finish below them! Don’t you agree?

I know money is very short and Everton have an owner who is refusing to sell the club! However a top six side, good side with good players with a chance a slim chance of getting into Europe probably the Euro League but I would take that, wouldn't you?

James Marshall
85 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:36:23
http://www.evertonfc.com/news/archive/2013/07/09/blues-sign-joel-robles
Mick Gallagher
86 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:07:47
Andy 944
We have lost Neville, Mucha, Heitzs can't spell the rest and brought in 2 players maybe 3 so far. Explain how we have been weaked as the manager he's gone fuck him and ones who have gone with him. You haven't got a problem with the chairman he controls the money and what we can afford.
Peter Thistle
87 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:28:49
Robles has signed on a 5 year contract.....
James Marshall
88 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:37:46
Agreed, MIchael and I wasn't accusing you of saying anything about those quoted clubs - I meant more that we can't compete for the top top players like they can.

I also agree we have more pulling power than West Ham, Stoke etc but we're a halfway house in that regard, and as a result our signings reflect that.

As things stand I don't like the situation we're in, but you have to make the best of it otherwise you give up. And none of us are doing that are we!

Kev Johnson
89 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:40:57
Robles arrives for an "undisclosed fee". Goddamnit, I wish we knew how much he cost!
James Marshall
90 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:42:40
I prefer it when the fee is undisclosed so that other teams don't know we paid with shirt buttons and magic beans.
Paul Andrews
91 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:37:22
Michael Allison,

"Not being a pedant blah blah " hahahaha
Lighten up man,sit in the currant with a beer. Or beers (plural)

Victor Anichebe was the player by the way. Absolutely baffled by that one.

Alan Humphreys
92 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:18:42
James (940 & 952), very good point. 3 players in, one a free agent, another from Wigan and the 'keeper from Ath Madrid. Pedantic maybe but who isn't a pedant !

More than likely Martinez was already going to sign Robles after his loan, so makes perfect sense to bring a player he's worked with to us permanently.

Not a bad couple of days business. Yes, they're not marquee signings but who knows, still the best part of 2 months to go. Fuck me, my glass is fast becoming half full.

Andrew Ellams
93 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:47:42
Kev@993 not too much I hope or it will just affect the resale value
Colin Glassar
94 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:46:11
Guillem Balaguer has just tweeted that we are now firm favourites to get the Delafelau (?) kid from Barca on a season long loan. He even said he will be visiting GP quite often next season. Happy days if this is true and when it comes to Spanish players he's usually right.
Lyndon Lloyd
95 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:53:59
It won't be much, Kev. He was in the final year of his contract at Atletico.
Kevin Tully
96 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:47:34
If we can bring in the boy from Barca and keep what we have, quite a happy blue here ( beer now chilled sufficiently may have added to said happiness)

If Baines goes however, I will be fookin' fumin'

Can someone close this window please? Or slam it shut to use Sky parlance.

Lenny Kingman
97 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:52:30
The newcomers can add spice to this great club. There's something brewing in the pot. And it smells good.
Ross Edwards
98 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:00:07
3 signings in 2 days! Wow, and maybe the Barca kid Balague is excited about. The Roberto era well and truely underway now. Really can't wait for August!
Tim Locke
99 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:53:30
Interesting http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1695972-barcelona-why-winger-gerard-deulofeu-will-not-succeed-in-the-premier-league
Kev Johnson
100 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:05:30
Gerard Deulofeu seems like an odd one to me. He looks great on YouTube - but then so does my Auntie Ag, playing 'Louie Louie' on the banjo while balancing a sea lion on her nose. They should call it YouLie. But I digress... I heard he wants to go out on loan to get regular playing time but I can't see him getting more than a handful of appearances for us.
Jon Withey
101 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:02:15
Good squad boost that, and done early enough for pre-season.

If we can keep everyone else (bar Heitinga, Naismith), get in a decent midfielder and a young wildcard (Barca kid sounds fine), it wouldn't be bad.

Brian Cleveland
102 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:49:32
Robles signed for an"undisclosed fee".

That seems to happen a lot... what is the real reason for not disclosing the fee? Never quite understood it.... is it because there are so many conditions and addons it's impossible to calculate? Or are we trying to fool the tax man and bank manager?

Charlie Percival
103 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:06:11
People moaning about ’undisclosed’....

Sometimes it’s because another club offered a similar deal but the player had a preference for a certain club.

The likelihood with us is that it’s because the transfer fee will be paid in installments.

Steven Telford
104 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:04:31
Spurs and Arsenal will be shitting bricks. Sorry, I should can the sarcasm, the price is right, and good to have a young keeper, hopefully he comes through.

Lets hope we see some more good names added, but if we could PLEASE see an a contract extension for Baines, I would breath a sign of relief. A long term replacement for Pienaar would not be bad to see emerge.

I keep swinging between optimism and pessimism in regards to Everton at the moment...

Colin Glassar
105 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:03:22
A few days ago I was moaning about our lack of transfer activity and now all this!! And we are still in July. Well done Roberto, get them in nice and early something your predecessor normally failed to do.
Stuart Mitchell
106 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:14:43
Gerard Deulofeu next in on loan

Good source
Guillem Balague þ@GuillemBalague 1h
Everton clear favourites to get Deulofeu. Loan deal but no more: he will go back at Barcelona. I'll be going to Goodison often this year!

Kristian Boyce
107 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:13:24
Welcome to Wigerton. Hopefully next up is Emmerson Boyce, just for the fact I can buy a shirt and get my name on the back, and not look like a complete idiot, on second thoughts....
Stewart Lowe
108 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:10:45
Undisclosed is only a label given to a transfer when either a buying or selling club wishes the fee to remain anonymous on the grounds of not wanting other clubs to realise how much money they have at their disposal.

For example, If Everton have paid a lot of money for this young prospect, then you can bet that any club selling to Everton from now on would increase their prices based on Everton having money to spend.
Kev Johnson
109 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:12:08
Thanks for the link, Tim (005). Interesting, as you say, although the conclusion was a bit weak. He basically seemed to be saying that Gerard Depardieu (as Barry Rathbone called him) would have to up his game in the Premiership, which is a bit obvious, and that he needs to learn to deliver an end result instead of just bewildering the opposition with mazy dribbles. Exactly the same was said of a young Ronaldo, but he turned out all right! Right now, he sounds like a useful impact sub.

I'm reasonably happy with the incoming players, especially Robles, but getting a superstar-in-waiting from Barca would be a tad more glamorous than three ex-Wigan men. Ha! Listen to me, I'm like a kid at Crimbo. I've got three presents already but I'm now more excited about opening the next one!

Al Reddish
110 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:29:18
SSN say we have put an £18m price tag on Baines. Looks like he is off then.
Quite pleased with 3 early signings and if you consider these are replacing Neville Hitzlesperger and Mucha then you gotta think it's an improvement in what we had.
Matt Garen
111 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:08:23
Personally I can't see anyone stumping up what will amount to a total fee and wages contract of £50m for Fellaini so think he will stay - ( 24m + 5yrs @ 100k a week). Wishful thinking here getting a couple of mil for Heitinga plus his wages is used on Honda and Delefou comes in on loan then that's definitely an improvement on last seasons squad.
Brian Cleveland
112 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:32:34
While none of the signings (manager, staff or players) coming from Wigan are necessarily bad individually, they don't seem to have given the "wow" factor that a lot of people are looking for.... it just seems everything is "OK" rather than something special. We want to be wowed and feel excited, and it's not quite getting there.... but neither is it terribly negative.... not sure what I feel, but would like to see something without a Wigan connection happen!!

Where do I sign on for www.pieweb.com?

Ross Edwards
113 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:40:38
Well, I think the nickname we can give Martinez now: Rapid Robbie. Thoughts?
Kevin Day
114 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:42:57
All this activity is giving me a nose bleed, going for a lie down.
Colin Glassar
115 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:40:45
Well it looks like the Diame rumours are true according to BK (that's blue kipper btw). Martinez said he wanted 4 players (goalie, defender, MF, and forward), 3 positions are now filled only a MF player is missing and at £3.5m Diame would be a bargain. Anyone on top of these lads will just be the icing on the cake.
Kunal Desai
116 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:38:36
So what are the ambitions of EFC this coming season with the signings we have made. I'm don't think challenging top 4 is again possible. If Baines leaves are we going to get a number of poor replacements in and revert to the days of WS? I hope the like of Alcaraz and Roubles are squad players and nothing more and that we are actually going to get two or three quality players for the first team when either Baines or Felli leave or maybe both.
Ray Said
117 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:51:27
It looks like sensible but not exciting news. If we can stiffen the squad this way then maybe there will be some cash for a top quality signing.? I wont hold my breath. Looks like Fer is in Norwich for contract talks which is disappointing.
Kevin Rowlands
118 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:40:24
No personel offence but some fans live in lala land, we've just added a striker, upgraded the reserve goalie, Alcaraz is definitely an upgrade on Heitinga who was shite last season, and all this for approx. 2/3 mill if you count the money we'll get for JH, that's great wheeling and dealing for a club with no real money, and I doubt we'll see any big money signings till either LB or/and MF are sold if that is what is going to happen, that's the reality of our situation.
Colin Glassar
119 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:56:17
Absolutely crucial now that we keep Baines and Fellaini. If we can get rid of Heitinga and Naismith and buy Honda and Diame then we are sorted. In Roberto I Trust.
Clive McBride
120 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:59:20
Now I know why there's big white stripes on the new tops......it's the new Wigan strip!
Declan Burke
121 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:54:52
Well done, Roberto. 3 signings in 2 days. It would have taken dithering Moyes 6 months pissing about, before he signed 3 players. I like your style!
Ben Dyke
123 Posted 09/07/2013 at 19:50:31
Whether we get a real top draw signing totally depends on losing Baines and/or Fellaini. To get these three in from Wigan is sensible to me. The manager knows their strengths and weaknesses and knows how to blend them in to a team. From where I am I can see that they definitely add something, particularly Kone. We will have more pace up front and with him now playing with better players we should see 15 goals hopefully. I like the look of Robles even if hes a bit raw and hes a great punt for at worst a 2nd keeper. Alacaraz was part of Paraguay reaching Copa America Final in 2011 and at worst adds depth to our squad.

Its hard to pick fault with this unless we still think we are competing with Spurs, Arsenal, and Liverpool - because sadly we arent. They routinely spend 7 or 8 figures on players. We don't.

Paul English
124 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:03:32
Gang, the new goalie cost €4million according to Marca, the Spanish newspaper.
Paul Andrews
125 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:14:34
Ray Said,

For £8 million I would be more disappointed if Fer was at Spurs or Arsenal for talks

Mike Gaynes
126 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:07:33
I think most of you guys are missing the big news. Not that Alcaraz and Robles aren't excellent pickups, but if it's true that we're about to sign Gerard Deulofeu on loan, we are in for some serious excitement. I've watched the kid every minute in the U-20 World Cup, and he is absolutely electrifying. He and Mirallas would give us the most potent flank attack we've had in decades. And maybe signal a move of Pienaar into the middle.. or to the bench.
Anthony Flack
127 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:18:52
Speedy Martinez - Ross, not sure if you are old enough to remember his cousin Speedy Gonzalez
Mark Frere
129 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:09:05
Colin Glassar - Its very wishful thinking to hope to sign Honda and Diame, but I admire your optimism.

I personally would be happy with just one of the 2 and Diame seems the more likely.

Things are certainly going in the right direction for us with latest 3 additions to our squad. If we can get this young Spanish lad - Deulofeu this will add even more flair to our already pretty top notch team.

Personally, I would rather us sell Fellaini so RM can do some significant work in the transfer market

Ross Edwards
130 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:23:07
Very good Anthony. Hits Rapid Robbie for 6 that's for sure.
Sam Hoare
131 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:21:12
Very sensible if not necessarily glamorous signings. An improvement seemingly on what we have for relatively little expense. Deulofeu would be a bit m
Mike Allison
133 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:30:50
"...although the conclusion was a bit weak."

Kev I think your analysis of that article is spot on. There was nothing to say there and the guy took a while to say it. It seemed to be 'young player has talent but needs to develop his end product' and 'the Premier League is more difficult than the Spanish 2nd division'. I didn't exactly feel enlightened, nor put off signing the player.

Kevin Rowlands
134 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:36:55
To the naysayers ask yourself three simple questions, is Robles an upgrade on Mucha, is Alcaraz an upgrade on Heitinga, and is Kone an upgrade on probably Naismith? I think the answer is yes on all three so whats the problem?
Stewart Lowe
136 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:37:54
Now that I have seen the goals that Gerard Deulofeu has scored and also the well connected rumours stating that we are clear favourites to sign him on a year long loan, the only emotion I feel is gutted. This guy is obviously phenomenal and it's clear to see why Barcelona are so adamant on him going on loan and insisting he will return to them to them when the loan ends.

How can we build a team with such a talent as him in it when we are all going to be devastated when we have to then send him back? I would rather not have him in the first place rather than have to try and fill his boots when he goes back to Barcelona. How do West Brom fill the boots of Lukaku after such a great season? It's not easy.

Patrick Murphy
137 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:33:04
Walking through Wigan town centre the other day, I'd lost track of the time and was concerned as I didn't want to miss my train, when I happened to notice the church tower, but it was different to what I had expected on the top was a sculpture in the shape of a pie, perplexed by this I turned to a local lad and asked him "how the hell do you know what time it is - if you have something silly like that on the church and no clock-face'?
He looked at me as if I was stupid and exclaimed "course I knows what time it is - It's summat to ate"
Oldies but goodies!
Paul Gladwell
138 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:47:07
Made up we got a keeper and one who has played for Spain at all levels and a player we never bought from Wigan like some seem to think.
John Hall
139 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:55:30
No dithering there, Robbie! :)
Paul Gladwell
140 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:54:33
Kev, read a few Barca fans online raving about the lad so fingers crossed we can grab him for a year.
Chris Sillett
141 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:47:51
Is it transfer deadline day already haha? I cant remember the last time we signed three players in two days this early in the summer! I think there is mixed reactions to the players because they have come from a relegated team but if we signed say Remy from QPR would you consider him to be a championship player? I always thought Kone looked decent last season and 13 goals isn't a bad return from his first season in the Premier League, he'll be a better option than Jelavic (on last seasons evidence) and £5 million is peanuts in todays market. Alcaraz is coming on a free and if Martinez decides to go with a 3-5-2 formation then Alcaraz is ready made for that, hes a 'footballing centre back' who likes to bring the ball out and pass it rather than just hoof it so he'll be a good compliment for Jagielka. Joel Robles is another who I thought looked good in the games I seen him hes only a baby in goalkeeping years and he will no doubt improve so we are potentially getting a future Spanish international keeper for next to nothing! I would still like to see a big name midfielder like Honda join but we are only in early July so theres plenty of time yet. If Moyes was still here we would all be getting stressed about having signed nobody!
Tom Dodds
142 Posted 09/07/2013 at 21:05:07
Any news on Baines`s new contract anyone ?
(that was the clubs plan wasnt it?)
John Audsley
143 Posted 09/07/2013 at 21:08:04
A really good week!

I've a feeling Mr Robles is going to be a fucking good player... a really fucking good player!!!

Peter Fearon
144 Posted 09/07/2013 at 21:15:19
OK, enough players responsible for their last club's relegation, please. Please.
Jay Harris
145 Posted 09/07/2013 at 20:54:22
Good analogy that Kevin #047.

I particularly like the purchase of Robles the understudy to De Gea for Spain.

IMO we need a good defensive mid now and Diame or Fer would fit the bill for me.

It may even be enough to persuade Felli and Baines that we're looking up.

Dan Brierley
147 Posted 09/07/2013 at 21:04:20
The keeper is a great signing, glad that we have some youth and potential being brought in. Although according to Wiki he has played only a couple of international games in the last seven years so there still seems to be a long way to go in his development. But much happier with this type of signing than the last two.

Is Alcaraz a better CB than Heitinga? I bloody hope so, but have not see anywhere near enough evidence to suggest it yet. Lets face it, if he is behind 35 year old Distin in the pecking order then he is not worth getting too excited about.

Steavey Buckley
148 Posted 09/07/2013 at 21:43:43
Martinez's record of buying and selling players is probably the best in the premier league. He was always in a worse position than Moyes when it came to having to allow his best players to leave.
David Chait
149 Posted 09/07/2013 at 21:32:09
Happier with Robles than the others... If Alcaraz turns out better than Distin cool, if not at least he was free, only 2 years and we still have Distin. Kone cost proper money... I liked him when I saw him... But time will tell..
Noel Early
150 Posted 09/07/2013 at 21:38:46
I will hold my hands up to usually being the most depressing supporter on here at times,but I am delighted with the business we have done so far, Kone will get more goals that Victor so in my opinion that is an upgrade.Everytime I seen Alcarez he has impressed,he is a tad slow but is a great reader of the game and Wigan supporters his prolonged absence was the a major reason why they went down.Oh and he came as a free agent.

The best signing of the lot will be Robles, huge potential for a young keeper.Has a good presence and excellent distribution which in my opinion is very important.We really needed an upgrade at this positon as Howard had been a weak link for a few years.It wont take long for this boy to take his place.

Mike Hughes
151 Posted 09/07/2013 at 21:47:17
Bloody Nora! I haven't been on here for about 24 hours......and 3 new players. I'll be keeping tabs on the hour from now on. Typical Everton...spend, spend, spend......
Tom Bowers
152 Posted 09/07/2013 at 18:55:31
RM is moulding the team for what he wants and if he gets some bargains and they work out as a plus for Everton then we cannot complain. Moyes made some excellent buys from lower clubs which served well but he also made some clangers which did not compliment the talent he had already.
He has not wasted any time especially with pre-season games about to start although Kone will be away a little longer.
There are bound to be departures also and so he should have an idea on a settled starting eleven come the Norwich game all being well.
We needed cover for the back four especially given Jags.injuries and Distin's age although Duffy could stake a real claim this season given the chance.
Like most people I feel another really good midfielder is necessary
Kevin Thompson
153 Posted 09/07/2013 at 21:52:17
Positives
a)3 signings in 2 days, rather than 3 signings in 2 years.
b) Signings arrive early, hopefully settle in quickly
c) signings have premier league experience
d) Kone scored 11 goals and had 5 assists in 33 games for struggling team
e) Young goalkeeper signed
f) Defender that can play in a number of positions bought on a free
g) no one sold (Yet)

not bad for Martinez first 10 days in charge

Kevin Rowlands
154 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:03:36
Peter 059, I think its a little unfair to say these players were responsible for Wigans relegation, Robles I think played seven games, Alcaraz was missing for 2/3rds of the season with injury and RM has publically said they would probably still be in the prem if he had been fit, and Kone scored thirteen goals whilst playing on his own up front, more btw than our strikers combined, I would say these three are probably amongst the least to blame for their relegation.
Barry Rathbone
155 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:08:52
Just chuffed at the decisiveness and positivity from Roberto, no-one knows how it's gonna work but at last something is happening.

One doesn't want to overstate the case.... I just think we'll win both cups and the league beating the RS by double figures home and away.

Brendan Rogers being netted while swimming of Anglesea for looking like a porpoise will just be the icing on the cake.

Can't wait for the season.

Kev Johnson
156 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:11:57
Sorry to be the skeleton at the wedding, or whatever it is, the pig in the poke, the fly in the ointment, the dog in the manger - no, that's still not it, the, er... ghost in the machine, no that means something completely different. What's that phrase? You know, the one? It'll come to me... Anyway, sorry to be the [...] in the [...] but I've got to say I'm deeply disappointed. Dismayed. Gutted.

We haven't bought anyone in hours!

I think it might be Mike Hughes' fault (@067). SInce he came back on TW we haven't made a single signing.

Andrew Bone
157 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:30:42
Love the fact that sky announced the signing of Robles with the footage of him smashing the ball against Bale in the six yard box. Surely there is some other footage.

They did precede this with Luis Suarez telling "Brian" Rogers he wants to leave.

Harold Matthews
158 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:16:49
Exciting day and great humour.

Kevin Day and his nose bleed.... Hilarious.

Paul Ferry.985. and his brilliant description of Howard. ha,ha,ha...had me rollin'.

Pete Gorman
159 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:37:42
Given that these two buckaroos come on a free I won't huff an moan about the transfers as much as Kone but like several others above have noted, shouldn't we be a little concerned about the calibre of player Martinez is going for?

The whole 'go with what you know' guff that people have been spouting is wearing thin now; surely Martinez has more ambition than ex-Wigan dross?

I would have thought Martinez appreciated that he has quite fortunately stepped up in class at Everton and would shop accordingly.

How many players did Moyes sign from Preston?

Andy Walker
161 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:34:08
Would Moyes have signed either of these Wigan players? I don't think so.
Would Wigan have been relegated if Moyes had been manager? I don't think so.
Does anyone GENUINELY believe we will finish P5 or better?
Is the gauge of a good manager one who can sign lots of players in a short time? Not in my book. Maybe just maybe finding players like Mirallas, Pienaar, Jags, Distin, Felli etc takes some TIME. It doesn't take a genius to quickly buy 3 players in 3 days. I could do that but then they'd probably be shit.
Mid table is the best I hope for, but then we'll gets lots of highly impressive management speak from our exec manager.
Martin Handley
162 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:23:28
Like most people on here I was under the impression that transfers took up to three years to negotiate and half an hour to fail the medical coz you have some snot in your nose!

Come on Roberto lad whats all this 3 in 2 days crap with possible 2 or even 3 more in August it's just not the Everton way mate!

But I like your style!

Clive Lewis
163 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:46:32
Worried about signings don't really show any imagination, its really a case of, "he will do, he was alright for us at Wigan".
Worried for the new season if we are going to sign Phil Nevills everywhere. Kone is an OK signing but not really a future purchase, 1 or 2 season wonder I am hoping.


"Wigan is home to the annual World Pie Eating Championship"

Peter Warren
164 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:52:41
V happy so far only disappointing news was to here us slap a price of £18m on Baines. Hopefully that's a load of shite and he signs a new contract.
Patrick Murphy
165 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:55:10
What those Wigan lads will be able to do Clive is say to our 'stars' this is what a Cup Winners medal looks like and they will be able to relate how it feels to win a Cup at Wembley - and they will also know how horrible it is to be relegated and if they have anything about them they will not want that feeling again.
Andy Walker
166 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:58:25
Peter 084 he's going. But we have Alcopops or whatever is feckin name is to replace him. Looking good eh?
Tony Marsh
167 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:43:20
Ah the days of Dithering Dave seem such a long long time ago. Isn't it nice to have a pro-active manager with his finger on the pulse?

Martinez is out of the traps like lightning and he is making all the right moves and noises. Don't you just love it? Massive improvement already on what we had last season and no doubt there's more to come.

I can't beleive how some of you were putting the boot in to Roberto before he had even signed up. Well lets hope you cut him some slack for a while and give him a chance to get to work properly.

I cant wait for the season to start were as under Moyes I dreaded it. Weepy Bill has got one right for a change. Well done that man.
Stewart Lowe
168 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:57:24
Never mind Man Utd baulking at an £18m price tag for Baines, shouldn't we be talking more £25m for a player that appears to be Europe's best in that position according to passing, assist, tackling accuracy and completion? I just don't know where the valuation of a mere £12-14m price tag for Baines comes from who is still only a young 28 years old?
James Flynn
169 Posted 09/07/2013 at 21:17:22
Like what's happening.

Get the Barca kid in. Keep Baines and Fella (Please), Top 4 here we come.

Kevin Rowlands
170 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:02:36
I believe he will be going aswell Andy 087, but I think we have a very capable replacement in Bryan Oviedo, plus the young lad Garbutt just signed on for another 2 years and Alcaraz can also play that position, I realize Baines will be a huge loss but its not all gloom and doom at left back for us.
Andy Walker
171 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:09:23
Kone's ok but what's the smart deal, Mirallas for £6m or Kone for £5m? What will they be worth in 3 years time? I'll start the ball rolling, Mirallas at least £15m but could be £25m, Kone nil. If it was your £5-6m that was being spent who would you want to spend it?
Andy Walker
172 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:14:32
Kevin I agree, but think there's lots of rose tinted spectacles being worn at the mo. I really hope I am wildly wrong but after 40 years of watching the blues I have never felt as unsure about a new season as the next.

My instinct on Martinez is he's style and PR over substance.

Brin Williams
173 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:15:15
Does all this activity mean that we may hear less from the BU or are there other outstanding matters like a new ground, Bill out, new owners, better pies - that still need addressing?

Oh! by the way all this activity, goings and comings and somebody putting dosh on the table meets with my approval – the rest will happen in due course!!

Bob Parrington
174 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:29:04
On the lighter side, I hear Alcaraz takes no prisoners! Oops, is that a typo?
Kevin Rowlands
175 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:26:02
Andy, I very much doubt if resale value was ever a thought when Kone was signed, he's here to hopefully do a good job for the next three years and get us some goals, do you think Utd were thinking about resale value when they bought a 30 plus year old RVP? I doubt it, I for one am not concerned with these buys, all three are upgrades on the players they are replacing for in reality peanuts in this day and age.
James Flynn
176 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:15:16
Marsh - No one cares about ManU's manager. Why do you?

Martinez will land where he lands managing Everton. We're all of us looking to see.

Mick MacManus
177 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:38:06
The momentum is building fast for the new season. IMWT!
Andy Walker
178 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:35:12
Kevin, not for a minute, but then Man Utd objectives are completely different to ours ie find the final piece to the puzzle to win the league for them, but players with future resale value for us as we need to generate profit from our sales as its the only way we can survive, it's that critical for us.

Buying Kone pisses £5m away, when if it had been spent more wisely it could have given us £15m to spend in 3 years time, that's the basic principle that has enabled us to do what we have for the past 10 years. Martinez needs to learn quick, all significant player purchases need to be long term investments for us, not so other wealthier teams.

John Daley
179 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:41:59
"Would Moyes have signed either of these Wigan players? I don't think so.
Would Wigan have been relegated if Moyes had been manager? I don't think so."

What has that got to do with anything? Who cares what Moyes would or would not have (possibly...maybe) done? What he won't be doing is ever managing Everton again, so what relevance or allure does he or his alternate universe actions retain?

The 'what would David Moyes do?' mantra just makes you sound like you should be singing in a squawky voice whilst prancing about South Park:

http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=sNJmfuEWR8w&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DsNJmfuEWR8w

Brendan McLaughlin
180 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:37:46
Martin #081
In case no-one has ever told you...speed isn't everything.(And that's a tip you can apply to a world of situations)
Andy Walker
181 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:43:58
John I take it you agree albeit don't like to admit it. Martinez WILL be compared to Moyes just like Moyes will be compared to Ferguson. That's the real world. Perhaps you will compare RM to Mike Walker as it's an easier level to match?
Kristian Boyce
182 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:45:19
Neville, Mucha & Hitzlesperger: Out
Kone, Robles & Alcarez: In

I think most people would say the replacements are an improvement on the 3 that have left. But the reality is that they are replacing the numbers that have left. We still need 3-4 more players to strengthen the smallest squad in the league.

Mike Corcoran
183 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:44:23
John Daley I am laughing. I was working through a dilemma the other day when the phrase "what would Noel Edmonds do?" ran through my head. I fell about laughing.

I imagine RM has had a similar experience with "what would David Moyes do?"

And for both I am thankful

Harold Matthews
184 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:32:55
Andy,

Take it easy mate. You're bustin' a gut over something you can do nothing about. We're all a bit nervous. Of course we are. These latest signings are not spectacular but are a reliable backup in specific areas.

The big stuff will come later when we find out what's happening with Fellaini and Baines.

Paul Ferry
185 Posted 10/07/2013 at 00:07:16
Harold mate (110) another thread, I know, but you're here.

Losing Dave Hickson must be a particularly poignant moment for people of your generation.

Having just read the 'Official Autobiography' and gushed over the early Moores years, what a time to be a blue and a scouser walking down Matthew St, whistling, heading for the Grapes, spring in the step.

Ah....

Denis Richardson
186 Posted 09/07/2013 at 22:47:45
Jeez - there really are some people on this site who always see the glass half empty. Admittedly we're all entitled to our opinion but can we please ease up on the negativity until a couple of things have happened:

1) The season has started and we see what our full squad is come mid August.

2) The transfer window has closed and we see what our full squad is until Xmas.

3) We've actually played a few games and see how the team plays under the new regime.

We're only at the start of July! There's still a full month to go till kick off and there is 100% guaranteed to be more players coming and going in the next month, so lets just have some perspective and be a bit patient.

The players we've signed will not the last and there will be more stuff happening on the Fellaini and Baines front as well....

Keep the faith...

Chris Sillett
187 Posted 10/07/2013 at 00:09:40
Andy Walker #95, thats a ludicrous statement to say you're the most unsure of a season in 40 years! So you weren't worried about the season after we stayed up by the skin of our teeth in 1994 or 97/98? And I can remember being very worried in the early 2000's under Walter Smith! If you're worried about a squad that finished 6th last season with the players we have then I don't know how you got through the 90's!
Kevin Rowlands
188 Posted 10/07/2013 at 00:17:13
Andy, can we actually let the lad kick a ball for us before we crucify him and Martinez, your talking about someone who was 1/3 the price of Jordan Henderson, 1/7 or 1/3 the price of Andy Carrol, 1/2 the price of Charlie Adam, 1/4 the price of Stuart Downing, get some perspective for goodness sake and btw we are probably going to retrieve a large chunk of that money on a useless Johnny Heitinga.
Albert Perkins
189 Posted 10/07/2013 at 00:10:30
I think Roberto wants to stabilize his new team and prepare it for Martinization. He's brought in 2 players who know his style and can help the rest make the adjustment.

I don't mind if any players are sold and immediate replacements not made. Let Roberto develop his own team at his pace and bring in top class players when they come available and ones he feels will really fit in and enhance the team.

Asking him to immediately put together a top 4 team is too much. Give him a little time to really work with what he has got. He may turn some of our youngsters with promise into the real thing, and surprise us with imaginative additions. I hope so.

Here's to a more attacking and entertaining season.

John Daley
190 Posted 09/07/2013 at 23:55:54
"Martinez WILL be compared to Moyes "

I don't have any problem with comparisons being made between their respective performances, but theoretical 'what if?'s and 'what would?'s are a wearisome waste of time.

To criticisize Martinez for making a decision that the mini-Moyes-who exists in your mind wouldn't have made (because, y'know, you don't actually know for a fact what the 'real ginge Davey' would've done) is just madness and far removed from anything resembling "the real world". In fact it's confusing fiction with reality and makes about as much sense as saying Sully Muntari was shit at Portsmouth but fucking superb in Monsters Inc.

Harold Matthews
192 Posted 10/07/2013 at 00:10:32
Paul. Yes mate. Spent many hours in the Grapes. Great memories. I met another Blue in there once, before going on to Yates Wine Lodge and Reece's dance. I ended up legless in the Gents and was carried downstairs and chucked into the street. Too many Aussie whites. Still don't know how I got home.

As for my great hero, Dave. The last time I saw him play, I was in the Shed at Tranmere and he banged in at least three. I was right behind the goal and to this day I can still see the ball ripping into the net.

Of all the players I have seen, he was the most memorable and many Blues of my generation would say the same. It's hard to know why. Maybe it was his thick mop of fair hair and non-stop swashbuckling style of play.

Funny thing is, my most abiding Goodison memory of Dave has nothing to do with scoring goals or being a general nuisance in the box, but it does sum up the attitude we all loved. The opposition were on the attack. Practically everyone was in our half. Suddenly, one of our lads hoofed the ball out and it rolled aimlessly toward their right corner flag. No-one was near it. No-one moved. No-one except Dave that is...

At breakneck speed, he raced 40 yards and chased it down just before it crossed the line. Can you imagine the roar of 60,000 fans. What happened after is long forgotten but that brilliant moment is forever stamped in my mind. As you say Paul... Ah.

Paul Ferry
194 Posted 10/07/2013 at 03:38:34
Reeces Cafe - my mum used to take me there when we went shopping.

Wasn't it just before you got to Church ST, walking from St Johns on the right hand side and there was a lane wasn't there, with a bookies - Ladbrokes? - on the ground floor on the corner, and there was a lift to the cafe .......

Ha, always nice to wallow in mersey nostalgia

Harold Matthews
195 Posted 10/07/2013 at 03:56:39
You've got it Paul, though not sure about Ladbrokes in those days.
The dance was upstairs. Couldn't go wrong. If you were sober that is.
Paul Ferry
196 Posted 10/07/2013 at 04:13:14
Lovely story, by the way, Harold (#126) – makes you think that you were there – me not you!!!!

Just reading the 'Official Autobiog', amazing that on average 50 people were treated by St Johns Amb each game for the crush on the terraces, I didn't know that was the reason for the semi-circles behind the goals - Spurs had 'em too.

Wow, 50 .....

And, coming back from Australia Johnny Morrisey was told he was up for sale ... madness ...

Catterick was never that popular, am I right? The Young/Royle thing at Blackpool and so on .....

Sorry to be a nerd.

First match 1976 and I love the 60s era.

Harold Matthews
197 Posted 10/07/2013 at 05:21:44
Paul. I always thought Catterick was well respected. He won trophies and put together great teams. Who can forget Harvey, Kendall and Ball.
The Blackpool business was a sad affair. Always made me feel sick. A few nutters disgraced everyone.
Shankly sorting the other mob out didn't help.( There was big money in those days and I bought a semi with gardens back and front for £1,200.)

Factories like Fords and Vauxhalls got going around '62 / 63. For once the other mob had a decent team and a more fierce rivalry developed.

Catterick was a useful player and very good manager. Never a man of the people like the great Joe Mercer, he was twice as private and twice as serious as Moyes. This,sadly, caused many fans to misunderstand him.
Pre 60's nobody thought about managers. They hardly got a mention.
Suddenly, the good old days vanished'. TV, pop music, coffee bars, night clubs the lot. The world went mad.
You know the rest.

Sounds a good book. Off to bed. Thanks for the chat Hope all's well in Chicago.

Andy Walker
200 Posted 10/07/2013 at 07:51:29
Chris 116. It's how I feel if that's ok with you mate. And no I wasn't as worried with those other post near miss seasons, why, because I felt we would learn and improve for the next season after having had a major shock.
Next season is full of uncertainty. You use past performance last season as a reason not to worry about next, well I wouldn't be worried if the management personnel responsible for getting the team to 6th were still there and 2 of our top players weren't likely to have gone, past season performance is then very relevant. Add to that new management with a relegation track record and now we're bringing in some of the actual players that got their team relegated. They can bring all their experience of what it takes and feels like to get relegated and pass it onto our players who haven't had the privilege.
Ray Roche
201 Posted 10/07/2013 at 08:16:28
Harold Matthews @ 138

Morning, Harold, some interesting and nostalgic comments in your posts, mentioning Reece's brought back a few memories I can tell you! Catterick was a bit of an enigma, wasn't he, a man who sent out a team to play wonderful expansive football but remained very private in all aspects of his life. The complete opposite of Shankly at the other place. It's such a shame that he banned the press and TV from our matches in one of the best periods in our history denying us a chance to look back at our heroes on the like of youTube and stopping younger lads like Paul from appreciating just how good we were. As regards the Blackpool affair, I was within a couple of feet of Catterick when the so called assault took place. As I remember it there was a lot of jostling and Catterick stumbled on a kerb as he went to board the team bus.This was manna from Heaven for a Press who didn't like the man and I couldn't believe the articles in the papers the next day which stated he'd been "kicked to the ground" . That was bollocks. Sure, the fans were upset by the dropping of Alex Young in favour of teenage Joe Royle, but apart from the chanting and jostling it wasn't what I'D call an attack and I was as close as I am to this computer. I have long since learnt to take much of what appears in the press and on TV, including the BBC, with a pinch of salt and that occasion as well as others when I've seen first hand how slanted the BBC can be, have only underlined my thoughts on our "free press".

Andy Walker
202 Posted 10/07/2013 at 08:12:34
John 120, 'theoretical what ifs'. Here's how I will rate Martinez, I will compare him with the bar set by Moyes in the following categories:
Our final position in the league
Do we get in Europe
How we do in the cups
How we perform against the top sides
Where we finish relative to the RS
How he sets teams up and use of subs
What's our style of play
Transfer dealings. Do we make money over the longer term i.e. what type and quality of players do we buy
What's the quality of the back room staff
How successful is he in retaining key players

Everything Martinez and his team do will be compared against Moyes' record, at least initially for 1 or 2 seasons. Some of these categories are subjective others objective, but none are 'theoretical'. These current player purchases by Martinez fall into the transfer dealings category.

What I WILL NOT be using to compare his performance are:

How many players are signed per day
The quality of his interviews to media
The colour of his hair
Does he fall into any stereotypical personality categories dictated by his race
What he says about BK

Ged Simpson
203 Posted 10/07/2013 at 08:22:12
Andy - you seem to be the new Tony Marsh when it comes to our new manager. Meanwhile Tony has a sense of optimism that is a joy to read.
Al Philby
204 Posted 10/07/2013 at 09:09:51
According to a fresh report in the Spanish press, Deulofleu's future will be decided today.

Mirallas-Kone-Deulofleu

People should fear us.

James Marshall
205 Posted 10/07/2013 at 09:45:31
Just to add to what most people are already saying:

Us buying Joel Robles is a good statement, especially when you consider good quality goalkeepers are like rockinghorse shit. Case in point, Chelsea trying hard to buy John Ruddy and have this morning signed the 40yr old Mark Schwarzer. A good old pro but goes some way to showing how difficult it is to sign a good keeper. Makes the Robles signing look even more telling if you ask me.

I was totally underwhelmed when Martinez took over, and although some of us are not overly impressed with our signings this week, I personally am pretty pleased with them all.

Alcaraz is 30 (experienced) and a very cultured centre-half, a ball player with a bit of pace about him and will play very well with Jagielka or Distin.

Robles is an up & coming keeper with a bright future ahead of him - he's quick, athletic, powerful, commanding and he can catch - handy.

Kone is 29 but some are saying he's a young 29 as he pretty much missed 4 years of football due to injury when he was in Spain. He's big, powerful, quick, holds the ball up really well and can finish. He might not be a 23 year old superstar who's going to score 30 goals, but there aren't many of those around. If he can back say 15 or so it'll be a good return.

Now all we need is to secure a midfield player, someone to compliment what we already have - whether we lose Fellaini remains to be seen, but if we do I can see us buying two midfield players to replace him anyway.

Plenty of names being banded about, and I really like the look of Deulofeu even if he is only 19 and considered a fancy-dan by some this kid can really play and he'll frighten the living daylights out of centre-halves in the Premier League. YouTube is infamous for making a player look good and all his footage is for the Barca B team, which is effectively like playing in our Championship (Div 1 for those who prefer the old ways - I do!) but even so, he has talent to burn. For one season on loan, what do we really have to lose?

Honda would be great too, but I can only really see him going to Milan now.

There is also the French kid from PSG, who's name escapes me, but he has a decent reputation and is the right ago around 25 I think so would be a good addition.

Victor Moses? Never fancied him myself, though Martinez obviously does having signed him so we'll see.

For those worried about us signing Wigan players, to be pedantic as I am prone to be - we've only actually signed Kone directly from Wigan. Robles was never their player, he came from Atletico Madrid and Alcaraz was a free agent.

When was the last time you can remember us signing 3 players in the space of 2 days?!

What a difference a day makes.

Jarrod O'Neill
207 Posted 10/07/2013 at 10:09:24
We also have been linked with scott sinclair on a loan deal too but that seems to have gone quiet
Andrew Ellams
208 Posted 10/07/2013 at 10:08:15
Every year their there is a thread about who we should and shouldn't sign over the summer and every year somebody raises the subect of cherry picking players from the relegated sides. Well we have done that, and from the cup winners too. Would people have moaned as much if it wasn't their ex manager who signed them?
Dan Brierley
209 Posted 10/07/2013 at 10:50:40
Andrew 170, of course you are right. But when we mention cherry picking doesn't that mean taking the best, such as looking at players like Taarabt, Mcmanaman, Le Fondre, Hoilett etc.?
Andrew Ellams
210 Posted 10/07/2013 at 11:26:20
Dan, Taarabt is a legend in his own lunchtine who has been inconsistent at best in two years in the top flight, McManaman I would be happy with but not at the price Wigan are likely to ask, Le Fondre hasn't quite got it to play in a top side, Hoilett made a bad move to QPR and needs to prove himself again before he becomes a good option.

I think for the players we need he has chosen well and of course he knows them all pretty well.

Harold Matthews
211 Posted 10/07/2013 at 10:45:58
Ray. Good morning. Absolutely delighted with your "on the spot" version of the Blackpool incident. It never did make sense but, as you say, the press and organisations like the BBC are not too interested in the truth. In fact, their agenda can often be quite mysterious. Remember the BBC female reporter announcing the collapse of building three on the morning of 9-11 when we could all see it was still standing. It did,of course, come down several minutes later, the girl has never been seen again and no explanation was given. Strange stuff indeed.

Yes, Catterick was a very complex character and the media ban did us no favours.

Also, after signing off last night I remembered that the big changes for me and my mates came around about 1955/56 when Rock n Roll exploded into our lives, I was aged 20 and on the Atomic tests at Monte Bello and Maralinga with my ears glued to an old wireless set. When I eventually arrived back home my mum thought I'd gone crackers." Rock me Daddyo" and all that stuff.

Anyway Ray, let's hope BK and Martinez keep strengthening the squad. With so much at stake, next season might be special.

Filip Lillevars
212 Posted 10/07/2013 at 12:19:37
I don't understand why people don't like the Alcaraz signing, he was Wigan's best defender by far last season I would say. Heitinga, for all of his experience, has lost it, maybe he will find it again but I don't think we have the time to wait for him to get back on track.

Alcaraz will do fine covering for him and I'm sure his age is no problem either. Look at Distin, he is a gem still at his age! No I'm excited for the coming season now, just hope Martinez can make them all fit together!

Paul Andrews
213 Posted 10/07/2013 at 12:44:25
Andy Walker,158

The bar set by Moyes has been set quite low when taking points 2,3 & 4 into account.

Tom Bowers
214 Posted 10/07/2013 at 12:40:53
Of course Martinez will be compared to Moyes if only for the naysayers to proclaim that it was a mistake to make the change.
However it isn't as if Moyes is a hard act to follow on the contrary Moyes has the task of following Fergie knowing he has never won a trophy compared to what Fergie has achieved.
Personally it's a no brainer. Martinez will do his own thing and already has started to strengthen the squad in my book.
Will be interesting to see what transpires as to who is moved out of the team or out of the club to accommodate the new lads.
A lot rests on the Fellaini situation as I am sure wheels are in motion elsewhere to sound out the situation.
Whilst he is not indispensable he is an asset given his form over the last year or so but if he goes at least RM will have the money to get an adequate top class replacement.
James Marshall
215 Posted 10/07/2013 at 13:14:18
Adel Taraabt? Only really rated by himself. He's crap and has a bad attitude.

I wouldn't touch him with a bargepole.

Dan Brierley
216 Posted 10/07/2013 at 12:54:19
Andrew 184, you are totally right about Taarabt being inconsistent up to now. But surely you will also remember Arteta and Pienaar both underperforming before coming to Everton and fulfilling their potential? I hope our new manager is able to develop players like this.

Agreed, McManaman will not be cheap as he has 2½ years to go on his contract, you are probably talking £5-8 million. Le Fondre who you suggest is not quite good enough, ended the season voted Reading's best player, managed 12 goals from substitute appearances, had the second best conversion ration in the PL, and is 26 years old. What exactly is not good enough compared to Kone?

And regarding Hoilett, if he goes to another club and proves himself, then we will need to pay perhaps two/three times the price for him if we want him in future. I think the lad is a cracking player, and just what we need. Sign him up while his stock is low.

Anyway, I think you can get my point that there appears to be better players out there that might help us break the top four barrier. But its still early days in the window, so hopefully we will start to see some better acquisitions as the summer progresses.

Dan Brierley
217 Posted 10/07/2013 at 13:19:49
According to this analysis, Kone and Big Vic are equal in terms of effectiveness last season:

http://www.eplindex.com/epl-news/34657/arouna-kone-comparison-everton-forwards-stats.html

John Daley
218 Posted 10/07/2013 at 13:28:01
"Some of these categories are subjective others objective, but none are 'theoretical."

Really? This is what it sounds like to me:

'If Moyes was still manager would he have bought any of these players? No, definitely not. Not a chance. Don't say he would because he wouldn't. I know for a fact because we have a psychic connection like Michael Myers and his niece....or...erm...Rod Hull and Emu. Thus, Moyes wins'.

Theoretical.

'Would Moyes have kept Wigan up if he was their manager? Yes, absolutely. There's no doubt about it because before tapping my red trainees together three times, and bidding farewell to tin plated Pip, scarecrow Steve Round and Chris the cowardly lion, I bore witness to his alt-world Wigan wizardry. Thus, Moyes wins'.

Theoretical.

'How much is Mirallas going to be worth in three years? I'll tell you: £15m guaranteed, but I watched a lot of Lovejoy when I was younger so we'll call it £25m if Kev is kept in his original packaging. Future Kone on the other hand has a set selling price of half a smoked silk cut and a fistful of slummy.

If Ian Mcshane wanted to make a profit on player trading he'd hand his money to Moyes rather than Martinez, because his signings are always made with an eye on resale value and are virtually guaranteed to mushroom in value....erm....except for Richard Wright, Per Krøldrup, James Beattie, Simon Davies, Nuno Valente, Andy van der Meyde, Phil Neville, Yakubu, Bily, Distin etc. They don't count. It all comes down to these two signings: Kev v Kone... for no apparent reason. Thus Moyes wins.'

Just... nonsensical.

Martinez has barely been in the job for more than a week and hasn't even sat his arse in the dugout for the first time. His signings haven't set foot on the pitch yet and you have no idea of how they're going to perform, so how can you criticise and claim he is performing worse than Moyes already?

Kevin Tully
219 Posted 10/07/2013 at 13:29:05
Dan, did you even look at that second table? Apart from nearly twice the goal return, your comment is completely factual.

Hate these tables anyway, 32 games vs 19 is not a comparative sample (see the contradiction?)

I love those Sky stat's, when they come out with a load old tripe like "Everton have won 43.5% more games when Neville, rather than Coleman has started at right back."

When you look more closely, they don't take into consideration who the opposition were, what competition, and the sample is usually IRO 120 vs 19 games played.

If Kone scores the winner at Anfield, he's worth every penny.

Jackie Barry
220 Posted 10/07/2013 at 13:48:50
Underperforming compared to Moyes in the transfer market, LOL!!!! OH my goodness my sides are going to burst, that's the funniest thing I have heard in a while! He has already outperformed Moyes in the transfer market, we would have had to wait until August for any signings and then they would be deadline day beaters. Seriously give Martinez a chance you bunch of lunatics, the window has only just opened and I am sure he is going to add more.
Andrew Ellams
221 Posted 10/07/2013 at 14:08:06
Dan, what these stats don't take into account are the quality of the team those players were part of and of the team mates too.

I suggest if you revisit those stats in 12 months time when they have had a year at the same club you will see a difference between the two.

Gary Carter
222 Posted 10/07/2013 at 14:09:15
Laughable signings and laughable manager who I pray don't turn us into a laughable club. All the anti Moyes mob were chastising him for the average of the squad, now they are Martinez fans it's on that he is bringing in 30 year olds, actually that was being kind, sub standard 30 year olds that were involved in getting a team relegated !!! I truly despair, and I'm a very positive person normally !!!
Brian Conrad
223 Posted 10/07/2013 at 13:49:07
A ball hasn't been kicked in earnest, yet the negativity from some people on here is unbelievable, all the doom and gloom merchants should go away to Negoweb,
James Marshall
224 Posted 10/07/2013 at 14:30:15
Gary - how do you feel about the Robles signing?
Kevin Rowlands
227 Posted 10/07/2013 at 14:28:15
Andrew, you have told us that we must buy players that have sell on value because we have to, but then you also tell us that we must keep Baines and Fellaini. If you believe the first part so vehemently then surely we have to cash in on Baines at £15/18 mill now and Fellaini at £23/25 mill as if they sign new contracts now there sell on value in 3/4 years will be a fraction of what we get if we sold them now.

Can you see how this argument your making about Kone is ridiculous, you can't have it both ways mate.

Andrew Ellams
228 Posted 10/07/2013 at 14:53:29
Kevin, which Andrew is that for?
Kevin Rowlands
229 Posted 10/07/2013 at 14:51:17
Gary 234, Robles, Kone, Alcaraz are replacing Mucha, Heitinga and possibly Naismith, can you explain to us how upgrading these three squad positions is 'laughable' please? also we have yet to kick a single ball under Martinez but he's deemed as 'laughable' to you as well; why? Are you on a wind up here.
Kevin Rowlands
230 Posted 10/07/2013 at 14:57:05
Walker 158 mate, he's in the Martinez glass half empty crowd, personally I'd prefer to see us actually play a few games before we jump all over him, you know kinda like at least give the bloke a chance, making comparisons between him and Moyes now is ridiculous imho.
Andrew Ellams
231 Posted 10/07/2013 at 15:03:17
Sorry me being dim, didn't see an Andy and couldn't remember saying any of that stuff.
Harold Matthews
232 Posted 10/07/2013 at 14:57:09
I'm pleased with the signings even though they're not spectacular.
Robles was a must and Alcaraz has the smell of a Baines exit.

Where this leaves Oviedo is anyones guess but I've a feeling Martinez will like him. The lad needs to establish himself with the Costa Rican national team who were quite brilliant the other night against Cuba. My God. Those lads can pass and move.

To be honest, I'm feeling pretty low after learning Victor Wanyama is about to join Southampton. The lad is my favourite British league player and Saints fans are in for a real treat.
If we bring in Moses for £8m and big wages I'll feel even worse.

Interesting point brought up by Barry Hearn the Orient chairman.
He claimed a serious deteriation in the market for talented lads with prospects. With so much at stake, clubs are not interested in "might-be's". They want "Actual".

Geoff Freeman
233 Posted 10/07/2013 at 15:50:46
I'm 67 years old and been watching our beloved team since 1955 and seen the good and bad times,in fact if I had come home from work and found Alex Young in bed with the wife I'd have made him a cuppa and asked for his autograph .
The point I'm making is I'm getting on in life and I would love us to win a trophy so resale value for Kone is no concern to me if he scores 13 goals this season. 6 against the Red shite 6 against the mancs, oh and the winner in the
F A Cup Final .
James Marshall
234 Posted 10/07/2013 at 16:38:27
Hi Geoff, my real name is actually Alex Young.

Just the one sugar please, old chap ;-)

Harold Matthews
235 Posted 10/07/2013 at 16:53:33
James. Still lingering on the tea-cup I see. Hmm.
James Marshall
236 Posted 10/07/2013 at 17:39:33
Lingering on the teacup - is that a euphemism?
Dan Brierley
237 Posted 10/07/2013 at 17:27:37
Kev Tully and Andrew Ellams, couldn't we sya the same thing about Kone's stats from last season? Perhaps he only scored against poor opposition, such as Everton in the Cup!

Personally, I believe there were better players out there that could have filled these roles. Instead of taking the risk and believing he could develop some under performing players into top players, he has took the safe option and took 'solid' players from his old club. Of course its not a bad thing, but it's not exactly inspiring either. I don't see these players taking us on to the next level beyond where we are, but would love to be proved wrong.

James Marshall
238 Posted 10/07/2013 at 17:57:29
We can't afford players to take us to the next level, and that's really the crux of the problem.
Stewart Lowe
239 Posted 10/07/2013 at 21:48:13
Dare we dream of anyone else coming in? lol
Ross Edwards
240 Posted 10/07/2013 at 21:51:49
Gary Carter. I am going to put this very bluntly. What you have written in that post is absurd, stupid, insulting and arrogant in every way.

"Laughable players, Laughable manager"

I am totally shocked that you even have the bare faced temerity to describe a manager that has only been here for 1 week and has won an FA Cup, one of the most famous trophies in world football as laughable. Give me one reason mate, why he is laughable. Go on, because that is frankly a disgraceful comment.

Also, to describe our players that we have signed as laughable as well is so dismissive and arrogant. Surely as a Moyes supporter, you were willing to support him for 11 years, yet you are so horribly dismissing our new manager within a week of arriving. Well, as you seem to think you can do better than our "laughable manager" you go ahead.

Gary, tell me why Martinez will fail, in your eyes. And do not mention the "oh, he got relegated and he's nicked 3 players from Wigan" cliche because it is so wrong.

You say he has signed players over 30. Deulefeu from Barca is 17, Robles is 23. And this is ironic I think coming from you, who supported a manager who played a 31 year old Steven Pienaar, 31 year old Leon Osman and 36 year old Phil Neville in his final season. Pot, kettle and black springs to mind.

As for "turning us into a laughable club" Well, hasn't Bill already done this?

What has Martinez done to make us laughable? Answers on a postcard please.

This post is such hurtful, and frankly horrible bile written about a man and players who are representing the club we all love so dearly. You have a vendetta against Martinez, without a ball even being kicked.

No Gary, our new signings and our new manager aren't laughable. Your comment and your doom and gloom mentality is laughable.

Jim Lloyd
241 Posted 10/07/2013 at 22:17:35
Ross.

Well said lad!

That sad man is a weird kind of Blue.

Paul Ferry
242 Posted 11/07/2013 at 00:29:14
Patrick Murphy (051) 'Walking through Wigan town centre the other day'

Fuck, images of litter and straw being blown across a windy bare street.

Discarded pies with a false tooth locked into the gristle: the visual reminder of one more Wiganer's epic oral struggle with a pie that lies (eh packed with yer mams meat and potatoes)

A clog someone lost lies smelly next to a litter bin filled to the brim with Wigan things.

'The Night Chicago Died' by Paper Lace echoes from the one remaining alehouse, a hearty sing along is taking place in

A ferret crawls out of a cap rimmed with stinky sweat and the now lost hairs of
a balding black pudding seller.

A youth skips along in Pod and a fading pink Lacoste shirt pushing to one
side with a casual shrug the 34 years that have eclipsed since this dress
was put on by a savvy scouser.

Loose cats and dogs, so many loose dogs and cats.

Ah Wigan.

I wouldn't even wish it on Ronald Reagan, Neil McGregor, miner murderer Thatcher, or the skipper of the HMS
Conqueror ......

Well, second thoughts, why not ....

Up the workers

IHHFB

Harold Matthews
243 Posted 11/07/2013 at 02:37:35
Ross. Well done mate. Top class post.....and an important one in my opinion.

Paul. Great stuff.
I'm off to bed now and hope I don't dream about Wgan

Gary Carter
244 Posted 11/07/2013 at 02:37:58
Ah Ross, how the devil are you old chap ? :-)

I describe the appointment of our new manager and the players he is bringing as laughable because that is my opinion, this is an Internet forum open to people who want to voice their opinions and in my case frustrations.

In my opinion our signings are exactly as I described. Many people on here were at great pains to constantly voice out motto "nothing but the best" under the Moyes regime. Unfortunately we/he simply couldn't afford "the best" and so I often thought that under Moyes our motto should have been "nothing but the best we could possibly afford".

Now I feel BK took an easy option in appointing a media darling with an accent that, for some reason, everyone seems to love because of this myth that Wigan played great football. They didn't; they played losing football under a man that either arrogantly refused to (or was too stupid to) adapt his tactics and this ultimately got his team relegated. This man in turn is now equally unimaginatively as Kenwright going back to his old club to bring in players I find uninspiring, ordinary and would not even class as "nothing but the best we can afford" but more "nothing that takes any effort or imagination". I don't like this and want better for our club.

For me, we are rapidly sliding into below even mediocrity. My opinion, an opinion I'm entitled to and an opinion I'm allowed to voice whether you like or agree with it or not. :-)

Ross Edwards
245 Posted 11/07/2013 at 12:58:38
I'm not denying your right to your views Gary, I just disagree with it entirely. I wouldn't mind if it was 15 games into the season and being plumb last but to say Martinez is laughable a week into his tenure is just wrong in my view.

By the way, I'm fine thank you.

Andrew Ellams
246 Posted 11/07/2013 at 13:03:04
Gary we could be entering new ToffeeWeb ground here, but I think the majority could well be with Ross on this one
Patrick Murphy
247 Posted 11/07/2013 at 13:13:19
Paul 568 that's an uncanny description did you have me followed?
Carl Taylor
248 Posted 11/07/2013 at 13:05:29
Is Gary-wary, sad that Davey-wavey won't be around anymore? Poor Baby. I don't understand how you see no fault in Moyes, (Kroldrup, Billy, negative tactics, late goals conceded), after 11 years of evidence and you condemn Bobby Martin before a ball has been kicked? Someone has a crush on our former manager, me thinks?!!!
Paul Andrews
249 Posted 11/07/2013 at 13:22:03
Gary Carter,

For someone who describes himself as a "very positive person" you sound very miserable to me.

Paul Ferry
250 Posted 11/07/2013 at 16:50:00
(671) I was the one with the dark glasses and newspaper - we were just relieved to ge you on the train
Patrick Murphy
251 Posted 11/07/2013 at 16:57:05
Paul I wondered what all that cheering and clapping was about, I did spot a few people in dark glasses and it was foggy so I should have sussed you out.
Ross Edwards
252 Posted 11/07/2013 at 20:01:13
"I describe the appointment of our new manager and the players he is bringing as laughable because that is my opinion"

So, no reason then? No footballing reason or evidence why he is laughable, just your opinion?

Gary Carter
253 Posted 11/07/2013 at 14:09:22
Carl, I must say that for a five year old I'm very impressed that you are using a computer. I think maybe mummy or daddy should read what I wrote to you again as I don't believe I put anywhere that David Moyes had no faults, and to reverse your argument back on to you I can't believe that after 3 years of overwhelming evidence that you can see no fault in Roberto martinez's appointment at a club supposedly challenging for Europe, or as your sweet little pet name for her is, bobby Martinez awww how cute you both are :-)
Steve Brown
254 Posted 12/07/2013 at 08:48:39
Gary Carter, I agree with every word you say so crack on lad. The more histrionic the comments become from the former Moyes haters/now Martinez lovers, the closer your are to hitting the nail on the head. Appointing him was a laughable BK decision actually, but he is there now so let's give him a chance. It will take a lot more than 3 ex Wigan players and a loan signing kid (even from Barcelona) before I start wetting myself with excitement like some on here.

Ross, go in the bathroom, look in the mirror and ask yourself if you have ever posted "hurtful and frankly horrible bile" on TW in relation to the chairman, board or previous manager. If the answer is "no" then you are a liar as I've read plenty of them. Otherwise stop the squealing you hypocrite.

Carl Taylor
255 Posted 12/07/2013 at 10:19:19
As for yours, and Steves, opinions, you are entitled to them as I am to mine. If I'm wrong, a rarity admittedly, I will say so and be bitterly disappointed. The sad thing is, the Moyes lovers will be delighted if I'm wrong and happy to see my club struggling. Who is the supporter here? Right, I'm off to my next lesson, reading, I'm on Janet and John book 4 now!
Gary Reeves
256 Posted 12/07/2013 at 11:03:42
Gary, I kind of think you've brought that on yourself a little,and like a few others you're fearing a future without DM - without reason IMO. I'm feeling optimistic about Martinez, and anticipating a bit more excitement. Wigan could never be a big draw for top players (even if they had big money – which they didn't) so he was always handicapped by that... Give him a chance, I think he can do well.
Ross Edwards
257 Posted 12/07/2013 at 12:54:03
Steve, of course I admit I have said some things about people that I shouldn't, but at least I don't dismiss the abilities of a manager and his signings within a week of arriving, so don't talk to me about being a hypocrite mate.

Steve, tell me why Martinez will fail please.

Al Philby
258 Posted 12/07/2013 at 12:59:24
Ross, you seem like a reasonable chap; hence I cannot see why you are continuing to pursue this discussion. There are embittered people in this world. Let them give vent to their misgivings. Once they have run out of steam, their minds will change. You cannot coerce people into adopting your worldview.
Mark Frere
259 Posted 12/07/2013 at 13:14:27
Al Philby - Put your wooden spoon away!
Ross Edwards
260 Posted 12/07/2013 at 13:17:47
Wooden Spoon? Explain...
Tony J Williams
261 Posted 12/07/2013 at 13:31:16
Wooden Spoon = Stirrer..
Al Philby
262 Posted 12/07/2013 at 13:29:53
Ross, a wooden spoon is a medal awarded to a person devoid of merit. So, this dig was aimed at you. Mark Frere, by the way, is also a big fan of Gibbo.
Gary Reeves
263 Posted 12/07/2013 at 13:59:56
Al,what is it with you and Gibson? You said yesterday that anyone who rated him clearly hasn't played footy. And yet in the same breath you proclaim OSMAN! I'm challenging you to a game of 3-and-in. . Name the time and place!
Al Philby
265 Posted 12/07/2013 at 14:23:26
Gary Reeves, reread the thread; you are confusing me with someone else. I never said what you claim that I said. You don't want to challenge me. Until the age of sixteen I was a very able footballer. I do not have the physique to be a professional; but from a strictly technical point of view I am light years ahead of your beloved Gibbo.
Gary Reeves
266 Posted 12/07/2013 at 14:46:27
On the Deulofeu thread - Al Philby#585. . "Gibson is a non-entity in comparison with Osman"... A couple of things Al; He's not my beloved Gibbo; I think he's useful player, with a bit more to come. Not the most mobile but neat and clever.

Secondly, I could play a little footy myself and I'm sorry but I don't and haven't ever rated Osman as a Premier League player. The fact that he's now an international says more about England. Vernon Sangster car-park 3pm Sunday? I'll bring the Alpine, you bring the Yorkies.

Al Philby
267 Posted 12/07/2013 at 15:22:22
Thank you for the challenge, Gary. I am in the aviation business and I am in the city three months of the year only. Hence I cannot meet you. I wish you all the best. Kopites are gobshites. And I am looking forward to reading your ode - co-authored with Mark Frere - about the divine powers of Gibbo. I hear it's some sort of sequel to Njal's Saga. Best of luck!
Kevin Tully
268 Posted 12/07/2013 at 15:36:30
Feck me Gary - you must have come from money. Yorkies & Alpine!!!

That sounds like Christmas morning to me fella, never mind a kickabout.

How about some rotten oranges from the fruit market, and a giant plassy container all 43 of us had a swig from.

Ahh.....jumpers for goalposts, a red or orange Wembley fly- away on Newsham Park - happy days.

Gary Reeves
269 Posted 12/07/2013 at 15:47:25
How very dare you Kevin! . . Wembley Trophy's weren't flyaways. We saved for weeks for them! Repaired them with hot knives,ha.
Scott Hamilton
270 Posted 12/07/2013 at 16:29:28
WTF, no signings for 24 hours?! Martinez out!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb