Brazil World Cup – Economic Effects

Now the Confederations Cup has been and gone, including the high-profile economic protests, John Wilkinson has notified us of this article he has published at Go Articles. He was hoping to open up discussions regarding the economics, more specifically the supply of money, for the World Cup, to be hosted by Brazil in 2014 .

» Read the full article at Go Articles



Reader Comments (10)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
1 Posted 13/07/2013 at 05:43:28
Thanks for submitting that, John... although, to be honest, I'm not quite sure what kind of discussions you expect from us. We're just a bunch of Everton fans!

Yes, some of our number will be students of economics... and may even be able to comment on the supply of reals for the World Cup. I won't be one of them, though... In fact, I can't quite believe I'm taking this seriously. It's not something I can say I have any interest or concern in, to be honest.

But don't worry-wart articles like this get posted before every Olympics, every World Cup – despite each country's massive fight for the 'honour' of holding these bonanzas? And every time we hear that (a) preparations are delayed, (b) the investment is out of all proportion and (c) the lasting financial benefit is dubious at best?

Now, it seems, we can add [look out!] — problems with the Money Supply!!!
I just think John Cleese would have had far more fun with this arcane subject than I have managed here...

ps (for John): I started reading the full copy of the article you submitted to us, thinking you had written it for ToffeeWeb, and was puzzled by the citation of Antunes within one of his own quotes. That sent me searching for where this really came from and Google popped it up at GoArticles.com. A word of editorial advice: You really should proof-read to remove errors like this and other typos.

Colin Glassar
2 Posted 18/07/2013 at 13:47:52
Breaking news!!! Sepp Blatter has just realised it gets hot in the summer in Qatar.
Matt Traynor
3 Posted 18/07/2013 at 14:04:34
Colin I seriously hope some of the European federations tell Blatter to do one, and threaten to boycott the tournament.

It will really mess up most of the European leagues.

At least UEFA and FIFA have failed to overturn a court ruling today that means that World Cups and Euro Championships have to be shown on free-to-air TV in UK (and Belgium!)

Colin Glassar
4 Posted 18/07/2013 at 14:40:43
Matt, both the 2014 and 2018 world cups could blow up in the face of Fifa. The first for being politically unstable, the second due to the real threat of heat stroke killing someone.

I think England and Germany could host these competitions at the drop of a hat as we both have everything ready to go.

Matt Traynor
5 Posted 18/07/2013 at 15:08:21
I think you mean the 2022 WC being the hot one Colin, 2018 being in Russia, which may also bring it's own problems. I think it was pretty evident with the voting that there was corruption around, the follow up shenanigans with the CONCACAF and AFC with both federations mired in bribery allegations only serving to further suspicion.

I'm cynical about the whole thing now. The WC in 2006 was supposed to go to South Africa, until a Scottish-born Oceania representative had a fit of guilt, and refused to vote the way his confederation wanted, In the end they got it in 2010, and for a while there was concern it wouldn't be run well, with infrastructure running late etc. There was a non-quorate FIFA meeting in Singapore in 2007 where I believe they even considered stripping SA of the WC and doing as you said, getting a European country to stage it instead. In the end they feared the legal implications and instead put some of their own money into SA to get things moving.

I don't believe for one minute they'll remove it from Qatar because the legal case arising would go on for years. Corruption runs through it if you believe the stories - even down to the sponsors (Mexico getting two tournaments in five? Thanks to Coca Cola. The way VISA paid their way to replace Mastercard as official clearing house. Etc.)

Usually the football tournaments are slighter more beneficial than the Olympics, as usually there are clubs that benefit from new/upgraded stadia. The facilities put in place for Olympics are usually under-utilised after. I remember looking around the Barcelona site one spring and it was literally covered in moss!

Colin Glassar
6 Posted 18/07/2013 at 18:31:37
You make some excellent, and pertinent, points Matt but the FA/PL have already said they will not condone a change to a winter World Cup for obvious reasons. It will only take another major FA to follow suit and the whole thing will come crumbling down as there will be a stampede of nations (western European most likely) who will claim to be unable to attend.

Despite loving the tournament I think it's about time someone put a nuke under Blatter and his gang of evil gnomes. Fifa, and Uefa, need ripping apart and starting anew.

Phil Sammon
7 Posted 18/07/2013 at 18:42:21
Colin

The FA have said that, but do you think they will stick to it?

FIFA are corrupt. Everybody knows they are corrupt. People in FIFA have been charged and found guilty of corruption. I don't know what more has to happen before somebody says 'enough'.

It's going to take a major nation to boycott a World Cup to finally bring down this all-powerful organisation that answers to no-one. And I don't mean boycotting a tournament because of the time of the year. I mean someone pulling out purely because they are unwilling to work with these criminals.

Colin Glassar
8 Posted 18/07/2013 at 18:52:10
Phil, I think the financial pull of the EPL is such that if it comes down to it they will pull the plug and refuse permission for any of it's players to participate. This would be a cataclysmic event of gargantuan proportions equal to the reformation (I wrote that for my history A level paper and have been dying to use it for eons now).

We need to coordinate this with some key allies like the Spanish, Dutch, Italians, Portuguese etc... (I don't trust the Germans or the French). Basically with anyone who owes us money. If the majority of the big European nations pull out and refuse permission for our African, Latin players etc..to participate then FIFA will either have to go to war or back down and we all know what the Swiss (Blatter) and French (Platini) do in these situations.

Phil Sammon
9 Posted 18/07/2013 at 19:07:43
Haha, I cant argue with such logic.

Gerry Morrison
10 Posted 18/07/2013 at 19:26:27
Matt,
If I remember correctly, the 1986 World Cup was supposed to be in Colombia, and was changed to Mexico at the last minute because of the political situation in Colombia. Something that could conceivably happen with Brazil.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads