Can Everton challenge for a Champions League place?

, 13 July, 49comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton do have the talent to compete for a Champions League spot under Roberto Martinez as long as they keep their best players.

» Read the full article at Give Me Sport



Reader Comments (49)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kevin Day
1 Posted 13/07/2013 at 08:55:50
Had we "gone for it" last season in a few games we would be in the champions league this season, on the down side to that, would David Moyes still of gone to Man U had that been the case, but, if he had of still jumped ship, as he probably would, who would be our manager right now, would it of still been Martinez? My guess would be we would of got either Vitor or Bielsa.
Colin Glassar
2 Posted 13/07/2013 at 09:22:40
Rumours abound that Bainsey has agreed a new long term deal with us and will finish his career at GP. Great news, if true, now we need to sort Fellaini out.
Kev Johnson
3 Posted 13/07/2013 at 09:41:51
Great news indeed, Colin, IF TRUE! ("Rumours abound"? Where?)

Personally, I'm not that bothered about Fellaini - as long as we reinvest most of the money on a quality replacement - but Leighton Baines is The Man.

Colin Glassar
4 Posted 13/07/2013 at 10:12:37
I saw it very early this morning Kev while I was have breakfast with some friends from Pluto and Sandra Bullock. I definitely saw it and I will get back to you with the sauce.
Patrick Murphy
5 Posted 13/07/2013 at 10:31:52
Pluto and Sandra Bullock an item? And with offspring to boot. Who would have thunk it, Colin.
Noel Early
6 Posted 13/07/2013 at 10:38:05
Twitter awash with the Baines rumour, hopefully this is true as we won't make a better signing all summer.

As for us getting Champions l
League football, it all depends on how well the players grasp the new system Martinez will likely employ. If we make a similar start to last season, then I think it is possible. Norwich away and West Brom at home — first two matches will tell a lot.

James Martin
7 Posted 13/07/2013 at 10:45:15
Kevin maybe if we'd 'gone for it' in every game we would have won the whole league then? You can't just take a handful of our worst performances and say if only we'd gone for it we wouldn't have lost/drawn them. Every team could do that. Anyone blaming stupid factors such as Mirallas being subbed in the 89th minute for Naismith or Moyes 'playing one up front against relegation teams' as the reason we didn' get fourth is deluded.

Our squad wasn't/isn't good enough. We had 2 senior strikers in the whole squad, neither of whom were scoring much. Contrast that to Arsenal who have Giroud, Podolski, Gervinho, Walcott, Oxlade Chamberlain. In loads of games we dominated got one up but then couldn't kill it off, you're then asking to be sucker punched. In fcat if we'd been savvy and sat back more in some of those one nil games we may have won them. Instead like at Fulham away we went to try and kill them off pouring everyone forward only to get done. Our 2 CBs aren't a good enough partnership to make up for the profligacy of our strikers. A change up top and at the back would improve our first 11 to a champions league level first 11 (indeed the fact we finished ahead of Liverpool with Suarez scoring all those goals shows how good the rest of our team is) but the squad is nowhere near that.

An injury free season, some luck, and the converse for Arsenal and Spurs and we may sneak in. I suspect we'll fall just short though like we did under Moyes and people will look to blame a few short term factors thus ignoring the long term squad issues. If people think Martinez is going to be Moyes without the pitfalls then you will probably be disappointed. He will have his annoying traits as well like every manager does. If we had a champions league level squad, criticism of the manager would be valid but does anyone really think we do? In my eyes we were up there most of last season because of Moyes who wrung everything out of a limited squad. I hope for the sake of the expectations on here that Martinez can do the same or better.

Colin Glassar
8 Posted 13/07/2013 at 11:05:29
Patrick, I thunked Sandra then woke up.
Paul Andrews
9 Posted 13/07/2013 at 11:29:10
James Martin,

One of Roberto's annoying traits is that he will go out and try to win every game.
Regardless of opposition.

Kevin Day
10 Posted 13/07/2013 at 11:48:46
James Martin,

There was 4-5 games at least last year where we took an early lead then sat back, only to end the game 1-1 or lose 2-1, like we did at Norwich after being in total control of the game, which is a prime example. So therefore I 100% stand by my earlier post.
And Paul Andrews, thank you.

Kieran Fitzgerald
11 Posted 13/07/2013 at 11:42:43
This squad had a crazy amount of draws last season. While it is fair to say that a Moyes squad rarely went into double figures in the loss column, it always had way too many in the draw column. This squad has the ability and skill set to win fair more games than it did previously. It also has the ability and skill set to make more out of Martinez' style than the Wigan squad had.

This squad isn't going to suddenly forget all of the defensive strengths that Moyes developed in it. Martinez would need to be a complete fool to discard these strengths, which I don't think he is. I think that Martinez has the chance to combine his attacking style with what is a very settled back four and a very well organised and drilled squad. We have enough pre-season games against decent opposition for him to try new things.

While this may not be a CL level squad, I do think we have more than enough to give it a go.

Jim Knightley
12 Posted 13/07/2013 at 11:58:28
Personally, I don't think we can, especially if Arsenal manage to bring in the pedigree of central striker suggested.

In terms of Alcaraz and Robles... I don't think they will add anything to the squad this season, and personally, I think Alcaraz is a lesser defender than Heitinga, even in view of the Dutchman's poor form last season. I'm very hopeful for Robles long term... but not for this season.

Then Kone and Deulofeu... I believe they will improve the squad, and the first 11 to a degree... but I don't think it will be enough to bridge the gap to fourth (we finished 9 points behind Spurs last season).

Spurs have added Paulinho already, and will not be finished yet... and will also have Kaboul and Ekotto back next season, and will be a stronger proposition, if they sort out their striking issue.

Arsenal's form was incredible post January, and with their midfield, and the possible addition of Suarez, or Higauin (Still more likely imo) I think they will be better. Then Chelsea, Man City, and Man Utd will all be beyond us.

I'm more concerned about the likes of Swansea and Southampton, and their addition of some super players, than realistic about the Champions League. That said... it depends where our business goes. Whilst I'm not hugely expectant of either... if we started the season with Honda and Moses (loan) in our squad, kept everyone bar Naismith and Heitinga (I'm assuming sales are needed before any potential bid for Honda, or another AMC, is made), and remained relatively injury free, I think we could have a great shot at it.

We will have a sense of excitement and good feeling around the club, we've got a decent start, and we've got a first 11, which on their day, can challenge pretty much anyone in this league. But, the squad is still an issue for me, and the possibilities of injuries quickly reduce our first 11 from top 4-6, to a mid-table side. We need a couple more additions, imo, before we can realistically expect to push those above us.

Jamie Barlow
13 Posted 13/07/2013 at 12:17:35
Paul@281, probably the reason they went down.
Paul Andrews
14 Posted 13/07/2013 at 12:21:12
Jamie,
How do you think a more positive attacking Everton will do this season?
I would wager any amount of money we don't get 15 draws.
An added bonus is we will be entertained,instead of watching the dull attritional style of football of the last 11 years.( first 6 months of last season excepted)
Jim Knightley
16 Posted 13/07/2013 at 12:20:57
I think trying to win is an overly simplistic representation Paul...Martinez put far too much emphasis on attack, and not enough on defence. As a result, Wigan finished the season with around a mid-table goals scored amount...but the joint worse defence in the division. Injuries played a part...but there was the kind of nativity on show which will never equate in this league to long term success. But, managers can learn from mistakes...and as has been remarked in this thread, we have a superb defensive foundation...a foundation good enough for fourth place for sure, and, if Martinez does not amend it, and continues to bring good defenders into this club over the next few seasons, then hopefully he can bring a little more diversity to the attacking game, and the kind of passing football which sometimes disappeared during the Moyes era. That is where the potential for progress lies.
Paul Andrews
17 Posted 13/07/2013 at 12:41:48
Jim,

At the risk of repeating myself.

Wigan .....Caldwell, Bramble, Boyce etc.

Everton....Coleman, Jagielka, Distin, Baines.
It's hardly rocket science.

Jon Ferguson
18 Posted 13/07/2013 at 12:37:06
I think we could get Champions League, but I wouldn't say we were favorites.

Chelsea, Man Utd and Man City are too far off in the distance. Arsenal and Tottenham are almost put of sight (with additional signings). That makes it difficult to start with. But a good run of form on our part, a bout of confidence and a few poor results by them and there is a chance.

It may not be a popular view, but I rate Rodgers and think us and Liverpool will be neck and neck all season. Then one of Swansea, Southampton, Newcastle or (outside bet) Norwich will have an amazing start and possibly chug themselves over the finishing line to a Europa League space.

It's going to be an exciting season. They're is so much change generally and a few of the clubs behind us have brought in good players. Also, most teams in the Premier League are playing a more expansive game, maybe even Stoke (actually probably not them).

I can't wait for it to get started!

Jamie Barlow
19 Posted 13/07/2013 at 12:55:00
If its hardly rocket science, why didn't Martinez realise that he couldn't carry on doing what he was doing? You have to play to your means. It wasn't working but he carried on doing it.

I think we'll do well and I'm really looking forward to it. We obviously have better players than Martinez had at Wigan but that doesn't mean I want him to go out and attack like a lunatic if it doesn't work, just so I can watch good football. He has to get the balance right.

Jim Knightley
21 Posted 13/07/2013 at 12:57:22
Paul, did you watch Wigan last season? it did not just come down to defenders...and why relate Wigan to Everton? why not other teams in the league, who they also let in far more goals in? They let more goals in than Villa, who had a mostly Championship/youth back line, and consistently failed to provide proper midfield protection to their defence. There was an unforgivably naivety to the way they played....it was entertaining (at points), not just because of the goals they scored (47) but the goals they let in (73)
Mark Frere
33 Posted 13/07/2013 at 13:52:58
I think we've got an outside chance of making the CL. With Kone and this new Spanish hotshot, our forward line looks considerably better than last season. I'm not very convinced Jelavic will rediscover his scoring touch, I really hope he proves me wrong though.

I'm just hoping we can sign another CM before the transfer window closes. Diame with a £3.5 million buyout clause seems quite realistic and I do really rate him.

I've got a feeling though, that Fellaini could be sold in the next 2-3 weeks. If RM could invest money from a Fellaini sale wisely – on 3 top-draw players, we should have one hell of a squad for the coming season.

My dream for next season would be top 4 and a cup, unlikely I know but we must have dreams and aspirations, or what's the point?

Mike Hughes
36 Posted 13/07/2013 at 13:56:17
Can Everton challenge for a Champions League place?

YES! I think we are serious contenders.
None of this consolidation, season-to-settle-in crap.

Logic?
Man-for-man we are better than last season at the moment.
Last season we did not fulfil potential due to too many draws.

Opposition can invest heavily but the opportunity is there for us.

We've got the team spirit to better most other clubs.
We just need RM to inject the winning mentality.

With the US tournament a great opportunity to build team spirit and understanding even further, we should be raising the bar for 13/14.

That can only mean 5th or higher.



Ross Edwards
38 Posted 13/07/2013 at 14:28:51
I can see Southampton and Swansea doing well, and Liverpool sinking even further. Signing players totally unproven at PL level, and without Sewer Rat for 6 games, they won't even make the top 8. If we start well like last season and finished strongly, I think we will be in with a shout.
Kieran Fitzgerald
40 Posted 13/07/2013 at 14:32:45
I think that we would need a near perfect season for the CL. No long term injuries, no serious dip in form, hanging on to Baines, if not Felliani as well, a winning start to the season for confidence as well.

We would need Spurs to have a wobble. With the teams who usually finish seventh to tenth, be it Southampton, Swansea or Newcastle next season, we usually tend to pull away from them come February or March. They have strengthened though, and might look to push on to the next level, so the head to head results could play a major part.

With the RS, much will depend on Suarez. If he stays, and can get his head right, they will be a danger. If he goes, and they spend the cash well, then they will be a danger. If things stay as they are, their dressing room may well end up getting messier and more poisonous. Losing a senior player like Carragher from the dressing room will be a big loss for them.

Mike Hughes
41 Posted 13/07/2013 at 14:36:16
Ross I agree with you. It sounds very obvious but starting well will be key - not just for the points - but for confidence all round. Last season's good start was atypical for us and mainly due to players getting a bit more of a break than expected due to a pre-season tour screw-up. We've been perennially bad starters but I'm looking for 10 points minimum from first 6 games. Something like that would allow us to build confidence and momentum.
Ross Edwards
42 Posted 13/07/2013 at 14:47:44
I can see us getting an away win at a Sky 4 team. Robbie will make us go for it especially at Anfield.
Ross Edwards
43 Posted 13/07/2013 at 14:51:13
We need to take at least 3 points off our rivals above us if we want top 4.
Kieran Fitzgerald
44 Posted 13/07/2013 at 14:51:29
Ross, the head to head results with the top four could play an important part for us this year. If we are a couple of points closer com the end of March, it could give us the boost to keeping pushing and put pressure on them.
James Stewart
45 Posted 13/07/2013 at 19:50:17
Top 4 is a tough ask. Especially given that we have a chairman who can't back his manager to compete with the likes of Norwich and Southampton.

I think we will surprise a few people next season though and no one will be pining for Moyes I'll bet on that!

Paul Andrews
46 Posted 13/07/2013 at 20:19:53
I would have a fair size wager Roberto gets 3 away points against one of the sky 4 pretty quickly.
David Greenwood
47 Posted 13/07/2013 at 20:20:30
Personally, I cant wait for the new season.

A manager with a positive approach, new signings in place already, and so far, Baines still with us.

I think a top three place was in reach last season, no doubt about, but for a myriad of reasons it didn't happen.

Anyway this season, Chelsea will be stronger, Utd weaker, City much the same, Spurs and Arsenal much the same as well. RS weaker without Hannibal. Their new signings don't worry me at all, who are ya?

Come on Bobby, silverware and top three please.

John Ford
48 Posted 13/07/2013 at 21:00:48
If Martinez league record matches Moyes he will have done well. It would be nice to think there is a more attractive style awaiting us and it will still take somethng special to break the glass ceiling. Having said that we were very easy on the eye for the first half of last season even if it didn't always end in victory. I'd also like a cup win....obviously.
Dan Doran
49 Posted 13/07/2013 at 22:00:41
Spurs finished 5th with 72 points. 72 POINTS! I hate to say it but even if we brought in a few good players back in January, I still don't se us getting more than 72 points. There's always this year...and the year after that...
Mark Frere
50 Posted 13/07/2013 at 22:12:35
Dan Doran - I think Spurs were very unlucky, most seasons 72 points have usually guaranteed a top 4 finish.
Steven Telford
52 Posted 13/07/2013 at 22:39:45
Looking at the stats, (age too) I think if we had piped Swansea in signing Boney, instead of buying Kone it would have been a better investment. investment.

I know things are tight, but seeing us be out bided by the likes of Norwich, and Swansea..... and (in bids) Cardiff........ etc We'll there is a reality check if ever there was one.

Big Club? or "Big history" perpetuating a mirage?

Kevin Day
53 Posted 14/07/2013 at 09:02:59
More importantly Paul Andrews, Roberto gets us 3 away points over the park.
Phil Walling
54 Posted 14/07/2013 at 09:58:37
No,we shall finish SEVENTH-behind the Sky Five and Spurs!
Put your money on that but pin your hopes on a Martinez Miracle!
Alan Smith
55 Posted 14/07/2013 at 10:12:52
If the window shut today we would do it. Arsenal have not improved and are just threatening to spend money. Spurs will go all out for that uefa cup again, and struggle in some of their Sunday games.

If Fellaini goes forget it. We might like Bains more for personal reasons, or Fellaini's dad reasons. But when he playes CM he runs the show.

Easily the the best Holding midfielder in the leaque and truly irreplaceable. If you don't agree try and think of a player who covers that much ground as big and strong who technically as good on the ball. Oh the small matter of about 8-10 goals per season.

You might say toure, who cost twice as much and never done anything against us. So keep thinking......


Barry Rathbone
56 Posted 14/07/2013 at 10:13:53
Depends if we can cope with playing out from the back and whether or not this season the possession is effective.

The side to side fanny of Brenda's mob and last years DM looks good on the stats but is actually a nothing game.

Live in hope tho.

Richard Dodd
57 Posted 14/07/2013 at 10:27:37
Wally-Moyes was the miracle worker ! With Martinez,I think we shall have lots of ups and downs in the League and maybe-just maybe- some excitement in the cups.
I`d be very wary about backing us for seventh but I`ll put some money on Moyes Boys topping the Prem at Christmas-even with one up front!
Champions League? Forget it,it will NEVER happen!
Colin Glassar
58 Posted 14/07/2013 at 10:30:20
If we can keep Fellaini and Bainsey, which is looking increasingly likely IMO, then we have about an equal chance of getting 4th place with the likes of arsenal and spurs. I read today that RM might still bring in a few more Spanish players to bolster the squad. If they are quality then the more the merrier.
Sam Hoare
59 Posted 14/07/2013 at 11:02:37
Colin, why do you think we will have an equal chance as Arsenal when they were reasonably far ahead of us and have 70m to spend possibly on the likes of Higuain and rat face?

I think we are outsiders for CL and RM will do very well to have us challenging for them and in the top 6.

Wayne Smyth
60 Posted 14/07/2013 at 10:54:47
Richard, I've a feeling that Chelsea will be the outstanding team this season. They have a very strong squad, a manager who the players and fans respect, and a manager who knows what it takes to win things in this league. There are question marks over nearly every other team chasing the top spots....including us.

I can see Moyes seriously struggling at Utd. He's already working the leagues best players like cart-horses in pre-season and lost his first game. He's got rid of decades worth of championship winning coaching know-how and Rooney looks like he may be off. For the first time in 11 years he's gone from no pressure, to one of the highest pressure jobs in football. I can see him losing the dressing room if things don't go well; he never has shown an ability to deal with big ego's.

Arsenal have shown themselves to be inconsistent too often to really push for the league. They could well finish outside the top 4 if they don't replace Van Persie's goals.

City have a very strong squad, but they also have a manager with no premier league experience. It remains to be seen if he'll transfer his abilities from La Liga successfully.

The RS have serious defensive deficiencies. Carragher is gone. Gerrard is about ready for the knackers yard and Hannibal is likely to be playing abroad soon. They've brought in lots of attacking players with no premier league experience to their team, but no defenders as yet. They conceded too many goals last season, and they haven't looked to put that right.

Spurs could well lose bale, but either way they're not streets ahead of us in terms of ability or strength.

When we last finished 4th, we did so on the back of a very consistent run, combined with a number of teams doing worse than they would have expected. We still require 2 or 3 teams to have an off-season AND RM needs to get the team playing with consistency and confidence and get results in almost every game. But the above scenario is far more likely than it has ever been in my opinion.

Paul Andrews
61 Posted 14/07/2013 at 11:17:16
Kevin Day,

Ditto mate.
One thing you can guarantee is Martinez wont go across the park and lay down like the last manager.

Jim Knightley
62 Posted 14/07/2013 at 11:30:02
Given that we beat United, Spurs and City at home last season, along with some important draws, I'd be surprised if our results against the top 5 were any better tbh.
Paul Andrews
63 Posted 14/07/2013 at 12:07:25
What still no away win at Arsenal,Chelsea,Utd and Liverpool Jim?
It's been 11 years you know
Brian Wilkinson
64 Posted 15/07/2013 at 10:50:49
James, what Kevin was saying is spot on about going for it instead of sitting back, in regards to a handful of games, Everton dropped 21 points from winning positions last season, to me that is slightly more than a handful of games, yes you are spot on as well had we gone for it every game we could have been pushing for the top, You can say what you like in regards to not being negative but over a course of ten years law of averages say you will win at least one if not more games away to the likes of the four Moyes could not get a win at, that's ten years of the usual sitting back and trying to get a draw, Man U away 3-1 down then 4-2 we are forced to attack and bingo we get a 4-4 draw, goodison sitting back losing 3-1 a few seasons ago changes and goes all out attack again we get a 3 all draw, twice Everton have shown they can do it so why sit back going for a draw instead of going for it at the start then when we get one finish it off get that second goal instead of sitting back, Even Martinez managed a win at the emirates with his wigan side, playing the likes of Reading, qpr, Southampton and Wigan at home and playing 4-5-1 is negative to me.
Paul Andrews
65 Posted 15/07/2013 at 11:48:43
Brian,

Very good post with some accurate points re sitting in and going for the draw.
That was a point I was discussing recently,like it or not David Moyes approached quite a lot of games with the mentality of not getting beat as opposed to setting out to win the game.

Mike Green
66 Posted 15/07/2013 at 11:56:06
I think we'll be very inconsistent next season so Im expecting anywhere between 6th and 12th next season. I'll take top half, a good cup run and a derby double to be honest, it's going to take time for Roberto to settle in.
Steve Pugh
67 Posted 16/07/2013 at 07:17:08
Brian 748, maybe because they sat back and relaxed thinking job done. Sometimes people forget that the other team influences what we do.

I fear that some of the contributors on here are setting themselves up for a big fall with their expectations.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb