Home side edge first pre-season game

, 14 July, 66comments  |  Jump to most recent
Austria Vienna 2 - 1 Everton
The first public game of the new era under Roberto Martinez, and plenty who did not play tonight: new signings Antolin Alcaraz, Arouna Kone & Gerard Deulofeu are definitely absent. As are Tim Howard, John Heitinga, Seamus Coleman, Nikica Jelavic, Ross Barkley, Luke Garbutt and John Stones, who have all been given extra time off following summer international commitments.

Everton's line-up included only Joel Robles of the new signings as they lined-up in an old-school formation, 4-5-1, with Vellios ploughing the lone furrow up front. Most players appeared to be wearing their regular numbers from last season, with the new squad numbers set to be announced at 10 am tomorrow. They made a bright start, pushing the home side back for a free-kick whipped in by Baines that came off Magaye Gueye's shoulder, then a corner.

The passing was crisp and Everton looked to move the ball around well in the warm evening sunshine. But some sloppy play at the back saw Osman slip and give up an easy goal to Stankovoic who rounded Joel and slotted home. Poor goal to give away...

Another poor pass let Okotie run in one-on-one with Joel but the new keeper stood strong an stopped what would have been an embarrassing second goal. Spiridonovic then fired fractionally wide as the Austrian side started to play a little. Some nervy moments from Tyias Browning, who was wearing Number 18 and playing right back.

Pienaar won a free kick that should threatened and his resulting set-piece shot static shot got over the wall but was well off target. A free-kick for Vienna at the other end came to nothing but Shane Duffy had his hands full dealing with Okotie.

A nice move saw Magaye Gueye feed Baines, the ball coming back to Pienaar who clipped it to the far post where Naismith controlled it superbly and lashed in a great shot that was well saved by Lidner in the Vienna goal.

Duffy needlessly handballed as he lost his man, and Stankovic slotted home from the penalty spot, Robles going the wrong way.

Everton responded well, Baines calmly pickling out Vellios after good work by Gibson, who glanced it home at the near post. A very nicely worked goal.

Naismith should have had a penalty when caught on the ankle but the ref played a bit of a homer and ignored the Everton forward, who needed some treatment.

Browning, Jagielka, Baines, Naismith, Osman, Pienaar, Gueye and Vellios were all replaced at the break, Grant (#16) coming on at half-time along with Fellaini, Mirallas, Oviedo, Kennedy (#26), Anichebe, Distin & Hibbert.

A deflection caught Joel cold but fortunately bounced back off the bar. Joel was called upon again as the last man as Distin slipped, allowing Okotie to run free and fire at the big man in the Everton goal. The home side then rang the changes on the hour, with seven of their side being replaced.

The game went a bit flat after that, and two more changes were made by Everton: McAleny (#23) and Junior (#30) coming on for Grant and Gibson.

Mirallas did well to get into the area off a nice give and go with Anichebe but then seemed to freeze rather than shooting at first sight, and in the end allowed the keeper to take it off his feet. Very poor.

Junior was show a yellow card for a rather unnecessary late foul. Austria were looking for a third but Distin was well placed to clear off the line as the home side pushed the Blues back. Indeed all 11 were back for a corner which came to McAleny, who could only hoof it forward to nobody.

Blues' final passing was just far too casual when they did have possession, which halted their forward progress again and again in the second half.

The game came to an end with most of the players getting a good run out, but still looking a little rusty and lacking in sharpness — just as you would expect for the first game of the pre-season.

Austria Vienna: Lindner (46' Kardum), Okotie (60' Vrsic), Ortlechner (46' Roguli), Ramsebner (60' Dilaver), Murg (60' Rotpuller), Stankovic (60' Gorgon), Leovac (60' Mader), Spiridonovic (60' Jun), Holland (41' Wimmer), Royer (60' Hosiner), Koch.
Subs not Used: P Grunwald, A Grunwald, Suttner

Everton: Joel Robles: Browning (46' Hibbert), Jagielka (46' Distin), Duffy, Baines (46' Oviedo); Naismith (46' Mirallas), Pienaar (46' Kennedy), Osman (46' Grant (67' McAleny)), Gibson (67' Junior), Gueye (46' Fellaini) ; Vellios (46' Anichebe).
Subs not Used: Springthorpe.

Attendance: 7,125

» Read more



Reader Comments (66)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Andrew Bone
2 Posted 14/07/2013 at 17:49:33
Junior looked capable of pushing on into the team this year, Vellios scored a cracking header and Kennedy looked useful. Thought overall the youngsters did ok and should have had a pen with Mirallas making a mess of a good chance.
Ross Edwards
3 Posted 14/07/2013 at 17:53:41
Well, lets not get too upset, Martinez has only had 2 weeks with them and a new playing style is difficult to adapt to at first, plus Austria have had a longer pre season, so they were more competitive then we were, and it was a reserve side.
Drew Shortis
4 Posted 14/07/2013 at 17:53:43
The point of this game was to begin getting the lads match fit again. Vienna were sharper as their season begins sooner and they are well into their pre-season preparations. It was also a chance to give some of the youngsters a run out and assess how they do. We will improve over the next few matches as the players get sharper and the passes start connecting more consistently!
Drew Shortis
6 Posted 14/07/2013 at 17:56:08
This game goes to show how important Baines is for us. Not just a left back! I hope a new contract is forthcoming soon. Fellaini is almost as important for us, but if an offer comes in from a CL team I expect he will jump ship. At least RM will have some funds if that happens!
Timothy Blanshard
7 Posted 14/07/2013 at 17:53:19
Just finished watching it online with no commentary, was kind of an odd match, several sub changes, we didn't play bad and Joel, well I reckon he's a good keeper who can only get better and better, Oviedo impressed me too.
Derek Knox
8 Posted 14/07/2013 at 17:52:56
There was a few encouraging signs there,especially with some of the younger ones, I won't name them, but some of the more senior players were well below par! I know you can never put too much analysis on the first pre-season game,but it showed indicators of where we have strengths and weaknesses,unfortunately there seemed to be more of the latter than the former! Giving the ball away too cheaply and casually at times stuck out,especially in the first half!
Jackie Barry
9 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:02:16
Vienna much sharper their season starts in 10 days time.
Tony Draper
10 Posted 14/07/2013 at 17:55:30
This was a friendly warm up game against the Austrian Champions who begin their season next week, I believe.

So Roberto gives 'em all a run-out, good.

It was a practice match, wasn't it?

David Hallwood
11 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:03:39
It wasn't an odd match Timothy (#583), it was what it was: a pre-season friendly, designed to get rid of the summer hol beer belly, sharpen up the squad's fitness, and as long as we're not getting beat 10-0, the scores are irrelevant.
Drew Shortis
12 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:01:00
Joel not at fault for either goal, and made a couple of good saves. Looked confident claiming crosses and I expect him to really challenge Howard for the number 1 jersey.

Baines cross for Vellios highlights his importance to the team. I was happy to see Tolos back in the side.

Gueye looks ineffective and none of the youngsters really stood out. We looked stronger when Fellaini and Anichebe got on the pitch and played a bit more football in their half, but there was no final ball.

Naismith had a good shot saved and could have won a penalty. If we have to play him it is much better to have him as a striker than as a poor right winger.

Does anyone know why Jelavic wasn't playing?

Jamie Barlow
13 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:09:19
It showed nothing except Howard has a battle for the No1 jersey. Nothing else mattered, just fitness. It was just a load of overweight lads having a kick about. An end to the training in Austria. Accrington will be shitting themselves for the backlash.
Phil Walling
14 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:04:49
For all the screaming about his omission last season, I thought Duffy struggled throughout both when partnered by Jags and then Distin.

Clearly the new manager looks to playing it out of defence and the Irishman can`t do it. Just hope Alcatraz is more up to it.

Up front we were woeful and hardly had a shot. Mirallas was appalling and Victor and Naismith were as useless as ever.

Just a pre-season, I know, but if Fancy Dan passing is all we look for, we`ll be in BIG trouble come August.

Suresh Gill
15 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:09:46
Jelavic has been given extra time off after his internationals.
John Gee
16 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:14:18
I'm not sure I can watch another season of Anichebe playing the whining little bitch. His team mates need to tell him to fucking man up. It must give defenders such a lift to watch his moaning and his woe is me bollocks all the time.

With so many different options available for the position just off the striker it was disappointing to see Phil Lynott playing there again when he's so good at breaking up play further back.

Rusty, too many hoofs, sloppy passing, poor decisions, one paced, no tactical plans. So a typical first pre-season game to give them a run out. Welcome back to work boys, onwards and upwards.

Timothy Blanshard
17 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:08:23
David @588

I know what a pre-season friendly is and what it involves, and I doubt very much if one single EFC player had a beer belly to get rid of.

My opinion it was an odd match, but hey thanks for trying to correct my own humble with yours. If you read my post again I never mentioned the score, so I'll stick to what I think and you're obviously entitled to share your thoughts on here as am. Whether you agree with me or not is irrelevant.

Chris James
18 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:28:09
As everyone says it's first pre-season match so nothing to panic about yet (although Liverpool smashed 4 in theirs), lets see how next couple of game go.

That said it was a chance for youth to stake a claim though and not sure how many did - Duffy definitely did look off the pace, so when Heitinga goes I think another central defender cover will be as important as another mid.

James Morgan
19 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:23:11
Robles was the stand out man, I thought Junior looked reasonably tidy when he came on. All in all just a knock about to shake off the rust.
Phil Walling
21 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:30:06
John, what worried me was to see Jelavic struggling to pass his way out of defence. He's the ideal Moyes centre-half but this 'pass along the backline' tactic which Martinez obviously favours frightens me to death and explains why Wigan were so woeful at the back.
Phil Walling
22 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:36:19
James,

Robles sat on his arse to stop two one-on-ones – that's all. He never went for one cross and Distin saved his bacon twice. No better that Mucha was my verdict.

Patrick Murphy
23 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:33:56
WTF has the number of goals scored by the Dark Side against PNE got to do with anything. We are neigbours of theirs and that's it, what we do or don't do has nothing to do with them. Obviously the Dark Side are going to be certain challengers for the PL Title (Again) and we will struggle to achieve mid table respectability it's all about cash isn't it?

It was a meaningless friendly - albiet against the Austrian Champions? - with most of our star players omitted, If we still look like a shambles come a fortnight before the real stuff starts then fine we can start to be unsettled. Whatever happens it has nothing to do with our rivals, it's all about what we do and how we do it. The Media has convinced everybody that Everton FC are tied to what LFC do and it's a pile of manure.


Derek Knox
24 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:39:39
Phil (607) Jelavic wasn't on the pitch! I think you mean Jagielka! Yes passing back, or square in defence is not to be encouraged! There are a few who still resort to that,rather than look up and pass meaningfully forward!
Sam Hoare
26 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:42:33
Meaningless game though would have been nice to see a bit more coherence and fluidity from the lads.

Robles and Oviedo looked the most promising. Jags is going to need to spend most of pre-season working on his distribution!

Stewart Lowe
27 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:34:20
I'm sorry but "Home side edge first pre-season game"? I watched the full game and that's not how I saw it. It's obvious to us all that this game has little meaning on the season ahead and is considered a run out for all the players, but I was surprised by the inability to make simple passes to players 4-5 meters apart. This is bread and butter and I know things will improve, but it was just not nice to watch.

The fact that we have a new manager, a new system in place and everybody starting with a clean slate would have you believe that certain fringe players would be chomping at the bit to get closer to the first team but in the case of Duffy, I am not sure he is good enough at this level, and what I saw of him today would justify Moyes's decisions last season to keep him on the fringes. He looked very flat-footed and his slow pace would see any half decent attacker beat him for pace which is a concern. He hasn't had a busy summer like others have and he is only 21 so his speed shouldn't be a problem at this stage of pre-season.

Finally, there was very little in the game to suggest Martinez had drilled them into playing something like the way he had Wigan playing last season and for much of this first game a lot of the play was hoofing it up field in the hope of Fellaini or Anichibe getting on the end of it, which they didn't.

Phil Walling
28 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:45:46
Thanks, Derek, of course I meant Jagielka. I thought that defensively we were a shambles and the change of tactics could well prove disastrous using Moyes's players.
Gary Reeves
29 Posted 14/07/2013 at 18:51:27
I like Jags, he's been a warrior for us for a few seasons now. A few people make the point here though,that he's not the greatest footballer. His distribution can range between erratic and poor. It would be a concern if RM was expecting cleverer play out from the back – 'cos Jags (and Distin,for that matter) ain't no Beckenbaeurs!
Derek Knox
30 Posted 14/07/2013 at 19:00:52
Putting a positive spin on things,maybe it is a wake-up call! I think RM is astute enough to see that further improvements are needed both in preparation and back-up to the squad! If we had won comfortably,it would have been a false impression! (I know some first squad members were absent.) It's all about depth of resources, as well as tactics!
Paul Gladwell
31 Posted 14/07/2013 at 19:04:14
Pretty unfair on our keeper there Phil, his one on ones were very good saves using his body making himself as big as possible, they were not fluke saves.
Jay Harris
32 Posted 14/07/2013 at 19:07:44
Thought it was a frustrating game with so much possession and so little end result (sound familiar).

However individually I was impressed with Matty Kennedy, Conor McAleny, Velios, Oviedo and Junior to an extent.

Special mentions for Gibbo, Felli and Baines who all showed their class and who IMO we should make every effort to keep.

I was unimpressed with Jags, Duffy and Mirallas.

Joel was good news and bad news for me showing his inexperience in commanding the box but making some excellent one on one saves.

All in all showing potential but a long way to go even taking into account it was pre season against a half decent side and nothing to reassure me that Martinez "Barcelona Style" passing from the back will not cause us to start leaking silly goals.

Dave Lynch
33 Posted 14/07/2013 at 19:26:29
Why the mention of the red shite ?

The gulf between Preston and the Austrian champions is massive.

Get a fucking grip and wait for a few week and see how we progress, Martinez is clearly trying to get a look at the whole squad and that team was not a tenth of our first eleven.

Paul Gladwell
34 Posted 14/07/2013 at 20:09:11
Well said Dave, they may not be top draw but they are starting their season soon, one that includes Champions league games, whereas Preston!
Tom Bowers
35 Posted 14/07/2013 at 20:04:40
As expected, all the usual over-reactions. The first warm-up game. RM taking a look at what individuals he has. I am sure it will take another few games and in particular the US tour before he has a squad he wants and knows what his starting eleven will be.

Forget results just for now.

Paul Ferry
36 Posted 14/07/2013 at 20:06:28
(630) 'Special mentions for Gibbo, Felli and Baines who all showed their class and who IMO we should make every effort to keep'

I thought that Gibson was way below par: did he actually complete a pass that was more than 10 yards long?

Felli? Dear Lord, he looked like he didn't give a shit today. Casual. Lost the ball too often for comfort.

Baines was okay, nothing more, nothing less.

But then this was, after all, a feather-weight friendly, although it's reasonable to
think that even the established players would grab an opportunity to impress the
new gaffer, whether it's in Vienna or LA.

Maetinez provides us with a chance to change things on and off the pitch. I know
that there were notable absentees, but today's team had a somewhat depressing
Moyes feel about it. I, for one, am hoping in this new era that the days of Osman,
Anichebe (yet one more embarrassing display to add to the long list), and Gibson)
are numbered.

On one level, this game was not really a sign of things to come - hopefully - as it
was by and large Moyes boys out there struggling it seemed at times to get to
grips with a different approach to the game.

The need for more new players is glaring, but at least it looks like we have at long
last found a decent goalie (penalty aside), and Oveido looked the part to me, along
with good marks for Velios, Kennedy, and Junior who I thought looked quite bright
in his half-hour or so.

Someone remind jags, Felli, Nuts, Gibson, Osman, Mirallas that they ought to be doing
their level best to impress the new gaffer, the old one has gone.

New boss, new players, new tactics, new formations ...........

But didn't feel like it today for me at any rate.

Phil Sammon
37 Posted 14/07/2013 at 19:57:59
A decent run out but much work is ahead.

Robles looked decent and made a couple of good stops. He really doesn't like leaving his line though. There was a couple of occasions when Distin screamed at him for not collecting simple balls that were rolling towards the box.

Gibson was the stand out man. His long range passing was superb and he made himself available at every opportunity. Baines and Pienaar were back on form together in the first half too.

Youngster-wise, Duffy was woeful in the first half. He makes Heitinga look like Usain Bolt...pumped full of steroids. If Martinez insists on his defenders playing out from the back then he has his work cut out with Duffy, Jags and Distin. Differing abilities but they all scare me shitless when they try pass it between themselves.

Kennedy looked quick and tidy in possession. Oviedo looked lively too.

To be honest the youngster who impressed me most was Conor Grant. Very confident and really calm in possession in the middle of the park. Reminded me of Jack Rodwell when he first came on the scene. Lets hope he kicks on more than Jack ever did.

Phil Sammon
38 Posted 14/07/2013 at 20:18:06
Paul Ferry

'I thought that Gibson was way below par: did he actually complete a pass that was more than 10 yards long?'

WHAT?!?!?!?

Were you watching the game you cretin?

Tony Gee
39 Posted 14/07/2013 at 20:20:34
I didn't see it... Was it a 3-5-2 system we played?
Paul Ferry
40 Posted 14/07/2013 at 20:18:06
Whoops, looks like Phil (641) and me saw a very different Gibbo today.

I agree with nearly all Phil says here, except that I felt that Grant looked
way out of his depth in even this featherweight friendly, and a sign of
this was subbing this sub, not exactly a confidence builder.

But let's celebrate differences!

Phil Sammon
41 Posted 14/07/2013 at 20:22:14
Paul

He wasn't subbed because he played poorly. It was his first taste of first team football so him and Junior shared a half to give them both minutes.

Honestly, I can accept differing opinions at times... but to slag off Gibson today... you're off your rocker.

John Audsley
42 Posted 14/07/2013 at 20:21:34
I didn't see the game and it doesn't look like I missed anything.

At least pre-season has a tougher look to it this year than last.

I reckon it will take Martinez a very long time to instill new ways and practices into players who were so used to Moyes's thinking. A tough season awaits but I"m glad of the change.

Paul Ferry
43 Posted 14/07/2013 at 20:48:55
Thanks for the 'cretin' tag Phil (642).

Yes, I watched every minute of it, while also tracking the forum,where,
if you like, you will be able to follow similar opinions of Gibson today
to the one of mine that you are at odds with.

He's actually come in for a lot of debate and discussion these last few
days or so and one thing that is clear is that Gibbo has supporters and
detractors with a greater number somewhere in the middle.

I for one feel that we will bring in a much more talented and creative
defensive mid if, as I hope happens, Felli goes.

As for Grant, that's a fair point and I hadn't thought of it in that way.
But even so he did very little in his run out and one of the things that
really cried out to me today and yesterday and the day before is the
need to move on and change things, not necessarily wholesale by any
means at all, but we need change .......

David Cooper
45 Posted 14/07/2013 at 20:18:03
Strangely, our summer holiday around Europe found us in Vienna this evening with nothing planned! Living in Canada for the past 23 years, the last time I saw the Blues live was in the 80s at Loftus Road, so it was impossible to turn down to see the Blues live and even my wife tagged along!

We met up with some real Blues on the tram going to the ground as well a few Vienna police. There must have been about 1000 Blues in the ground by kick off. With no programme, it was tough to identify everyone and I made a right fool of myself asking the guy behind me who number 6 was! My excuse was that he was well tanned and I am used to seeing him from the front on TV!

All the new coaching staff were on show and did a really good job of laying out the the cones and bibs. RM was the centre of attention but Boy Billy walked on to the pitch and was greeted by a chorus of boos so he turned around and went back into the main stand far away from the rest of us.

The game started at a gentle pace with the Blues already showing RM's influence as we made pretty patterns outside our area. The pairing of Duffy and Jags were not comfortable doing this and it was only a matter of time before a misplaced pass became the first goal. If RM wants to play out from the back, I'm not sure Jags is the person to do that.

Anyway Austria Wien were much sharper, as expected, but after almost 10 days pre-seaso,n the Blues did not look that interested except for youngsters who were out to impress. Naismith hit a tidy volley which brought about a good save but then an aimless cross hit Duffy on his hand and it was 2-0... not that anyone seemed to mind except the 1,000 faithful supporters.

Then 12 more Blues arrived on the side pitch to warm up: Fellaini, Mirallas, Distin, Anichebe and more youngsters... big cheers by the faithful. I turned to take a close look at Fellaini's hair and missed the Everton goal! Given that it was about 30 years since I saw them score a live goal and I was not happy; however, my wife thought it was hilarious!

Half-time came and went and there were 8 new Blues on show. Not much really happened as we continued to misplace passes and chase fleet-footed Viennese waltzers. Mirallas was played through by Big Vic who is still moaning about not getting the ball where and when he wants. Time up on the big lad I hope. Back to Mirallas, who beat the last defender, pivoted but dribbled the ball into the hands of the goalkeeper. More changes and then the Ref blew bang on 90 minutes. Exit 1,000 Blues who have seen it all before.

My impressions....

1. Everton are not built to play the ball out from the back unless we get some players who are very comfortable with ball at their feet.

2. It was the first per-season practice match so nothing should be made of it.

3. None of the senior players except Bainsey 1st half and Silvan 2nd half seemed much bothered.

4. If we are going to play it around in midfield Gibbo is a better bet than Ozzie.

5. Joel Robles looks a very good acquisition.

6. Of the youngsters, Junior and Kennedy looked as if they might bring something different to the team. But Junior is tiny.

7. I think Fellaini is waiting to move and, if he does, I don't think we will see much from Mirallas.

8. We can't lose Baines but Oviedo in 45 minutes looked good.

9. I hope Kone knows where the goal is.

10. When I missed the goal there was no instant replay.

11. I may have been mistaken but RM seemed more interested in coaching the young players than saying anything to the senior players.

12. It was great to meet real Evertonians but there was an air of despondency among them.

13. Not sure if I will get to see Everton live again so I'm glad we went.

COYBs.... here's wishing for a different season!

Wayne Smyth
46 Posted 14/07/2013 at 21:03:44
Don't know why people are making much of this performance or result at all.

It's worth remembering this is the last match for the Austrian champions before their league starts, and we're still 4 or 5 weeks away from our first competitive game.

RM played a mixture of experienced and young players in both halves, so we never saw our strongest possible line up out there. Also worth mentioning we have half a squad unavailable, too, so it's really not fair to whinge too much about the result.

I got the impression he wanted to have a look at the entire squad including the youngsters to see what we have, which is entirely reasonable.

I thought a number of things stood out:

1) Robles will be No 1 this season in goal. I thought he played very well in terms of his distribution, calmness and shot-stopping.

2) Gibson played better than I sometimes give him credit for. He was mostly very good in terms of his all round play.

3) We gifted both goals to the Austrians, and generally looked shit at the back. Some of the blame is for Duffy, but also Jags was poor and at fault for the first goal which set the tone. I don't think Duffy will be a RM type centre back, and he doesn't have pace or appear to have a decent reading of the game... and you usually need at least one to be a top class centre half.

4) Oviedo looked very decent. wasn't really tested defensively, but looked good going forwards.

5) Out of our youngsters, only junior looked capable of immediately stepping up. None of the others really shone or showed enough.

6) We lacked creativity. I'm keen to see one of Deufoleu/Barkley come into the side to provide a spark that can unlock a defence. Too much passing sideways and backwards, but again you have to bear in mind the fact that half the team on show was our reserves.

I suspect that RM will pick one or two of the fringe players again for future friendlies, but I think he'll also discard most of them back to the ressies for another season.

When we have a critical mass of first team players in there, and the addition of Kone, Jelavic, Coleman, I think we'll be fine.

Paul Ferry
47 Posted 14/07/2013 at 21:34:16
Completely agree about making definitive judgments based on a featherweight friendly. And I suspect that we will look and be a quite different outfit on the 1st day of the season, given all the missing today: Deufoleu, Barkley, Kone, Jelavic, Coleman, Alcaraz, and I suspect two or more new faces still to come, defensive creative mid, someone wide, another striker.

My feeling is that we will have a very tasty starting 11 on that 1st day and that it will not include our costly risky liability, Felli.

Sam Hoare
48 Posted 14/07/2013 at 22:03:42
If you're right Paul then we will do well to replace him. He's an experienced premiership star able to dominate teams on his day as evident on the first day of last season. He can be a liability but he's still one of best players. Wonder who would come in instead and be expected to hit the ground running? Would have liked Wanyama but that train has sailed...
Kevin Rowlands
49 Posted 14/07/2013 at 21:59:30
Paul, are you serious when you say Fellaini is a liability or is it a wind up? From what I seen of the game he stood out from the rest, a fit and up for it Fellaini could get into any club side in the world, he is going to be a huge loss if and when he leaves, on another note I'd like to see that Macaleny kid given more playing time, he looks a very good prospect to me.
Alan Humphreys
50 Posted 14/07/2013 at 21:53:51
David (657) I think we've all done something similar at one time or another and missed a goal. Least my moments of lapse were helped out by MOTD.

Sorry you missed the goal but hope you (& the Missus) enjoyed the game if not the result. Least you got to see Fellainis bonnet though....

Mark Frere
56 Posted 14/07/2013 at 23:39:27
James,

I can understand why my wording could be a bit misleading. What I meant is - we are better off with Fellaini than without him, but I think Martinez would benefit considerably more with £24 million to spend and no Fellaini.

Ernie Baywood
57 Posted 14/07/2013 at 23:43:52
Good to have football back - I disagree with half the posts on this thread and I've missed it!

Personally thought it was a fairly standard first up warm up. Frustrating watching them get their touch and fitness back but that's always the case.

Bright spot was probably Oviedo for me. If the worst happens then hopefully he's ready.

Low point was the defence. The formation wasn't too different but the setup was. Centre halves the width of the penalty area apart and trying to play a lot in defence. That looked tactical to me.

Fellaini taking the armband in the second half and looking like a man on a mission was interesting...

James Flynn
66 Posted 15/07/2013 at 00:14:48
Mark (689) - Is that at me? Of course agree we're better with Fella than not. Here's what bothers me about Fella and/or Baines going. It means we're re-building. They're our 2 best players.

We had a fine team last season that didn't make the CL due to lack of finishing. So we'll improve in the standings next season by selling off our 2 best players? How?

There's no particular time Fella said he wanted to leave. Not once. If Baines gets the substantial pay raise he has coming, why would he go?

Martinez is our manager for at least 3-4 years. If he put up with, smilingly, suffering his last club's owner, he won't break a sweat suffering Kenright etal.

That's what worries me. Among other things Martinez.

Paul Ferry
67 Posted 15/07/2013 at 00:55:09
'So we'll improve in the standings next season by selling off our 2 best players? How?' (702)

It's mind-numbingly obvious and it is what clubs have done for eons.

In order to rebuild a team, even more so when a new gaffer takes over the hot seat and even more so when you are relatively cash poor, a decision needs to be made: how do we raise the sponds?

One extremely credible option is to consider whether the team would be better, deeper, and stronger if a top quality player was sold in order to bring in three or four quality players.

That is why selling a big asset can in fact turn a team into a better team.

It's not rocket science.

Si Cooper
68 Posted 15/07/2013 at 01:07:55
"It's mind numbingly obvious" - isn't that a little bit like calling someone a simpleton?

Sorry Paul but this 'extremely credible option' is actually a debatable one. Just because we can all provide examples were it has worked in the past doesn't actually guarantee it will work the next time.

It is a gamble, any which way you put it, and people wondering whether we may be better off retaining these players and building a team around them from youngsters, loanees, free agents and whoever can be afforded from whatever funds can be squeezed from the increased TV money, is as valid as your own stance.

Let's face it, you want Fellaini gone and so any scenario that includes that eventuality will get your unstinting support.

Jim Knightley
72 Posted 15/07/2013 at 01:39:29
I can't believe that people are trying to extrapolate conclusions from this match...it's the first pre-season match ffs! If we had won 10-0, it will have made no difference come the 17th. This game is, and was, only about fitness...don't get concerned about what we are seeing on the pitch until the start of August.
Phil Sammon
74 Posted 15/07/2013 at 01:32:59
Here's the correct answer to stop your squabbling.

Fellaini is a patchy player. World class at times, distinctly average at others. He has won us far more games than he's lost us though, and I think that's worth considering when labelling him a 'liability'.

One conundrum is where to play him. His best games have come when he's played high up the pitch - but he doesn't want to play there. It also leads to a predictable and one-dimensional style of play.

He wants to sit deeper - but he's ineffective there. He breaks up play well and links play beautifully with 5-10 yard passes. However, his passing range is limited. To play that position you need to be able to grab the ball and force counter attacks. I don't think he's good enough at that.

So would we be better off without him and with £24 million in the bank?

Firstly, you can forget Martinez seeing all the money.

But I still think Martinez could build a better or equally good squad by selling the big man.

There's also the matter of his contract. It's getting to the point where selling him is actually looking like the sensible option as it may be our last chance to recoup big money for him.

So, all in all, I'd be sorry to see him leave, I'm a big fan, but I think it might be for the best.

What is of significantly more importance to me is hanging onto Baines - our real star player.

Si Cooper
77 Posted 15/07/2013 at 01:38:19
Yes Paul, one of the many options open to the manager as to how he can improve the squad he has inherited is to sell a high value player and bring in multiple cheaper players.

It is not something that comes with a guarantee, however, and it also lets the board get away with with their continued miserliness (which some may call 'prudence', but I think they should have expected to right off some of their own personal fortune each year when they took the club over).

I do see Fellaini's faults and though I may wince at his flying elbows and quick temper I think that overall he is an asset and an important player for us. If he goes, we do not have a ready-made replacement already at the club, which either means a speculative foray into the transfer market or a radical change of playing style that would render that type of physically imposing, destructive and goal-scoring midfielder redundant.

Not exactly a foregone conclusion imho.

Phil Sammon
78 Posted 15/07/2013 at 01:55:23
And Gibson is a very good player - key to our team.
Ernie Baywood
86 Posted 15/07/2013 at 03:17:08
There is a possibility that Martinez sees all the money if he's sold. It's a different climate this year - that's why you're seeing lesser clubs splashing cash around.

For us to do that we have to sell first as we can't use the TV money to increase the wage bill or pay for fees.

In terms of cashflow for wages and fees - it's nailed on we sell someone.

Christopher Timmins
89 Posted 15/07/2013 at 06:34:14
First pre season fixture and as such is only used as a means of building up fitness. No points on offer today.
Phil Sammon
90 Posted 15/07/2013 at 07:50:56
What's happened to Paul Andrews then?
Matt Traynor
91 Posted 15/07/2013 at 09:26:46
Ernie #725, you may be on to something. Given we reputedly lost around £9m (before player trading) in recent accounts - most of which is due to debt servicing and finance charges, then the new windfall would suggest (if wages stay around the same level) that we would have a float of around £10-15m.

Of course that money comes in throughout the season, so we'll still need to duck and dive in the transfer market. For the other clubs less burdened by debt payments, they are like a kid in a candy store. There are 3 divisions within the premier league, and for the last few seasons we've finished around the top of the middle tier. Now the question could be who's going to challenge us, rather than are we going to challenge the top tier?

Dan McKie
92 Posted 15/07/2013 at 09:38:09
People speaking about Martinez wanting to play it out of defence is all very well and good, but you have to hope the players make the right decision when they get out on the pitch. If there is a pass available to make, which wont put us in trouble, then make it. If you have attackers breathing down your neck, and other players are marked, then hoof it. There is no one way to play, and expecting players who are 29 and 36 years old to suddenly become technically gifted would be naive. I just hope Martinez knows that.
Phil Walling
93 Posted 15/07/2013 at 10:24:15
Martinez `bigging up`Joel in the post match interview indicates that at last Howard has some serious competition.Much being made of `playing it the Martinez way`and Jags and Duffy don't seem too comfortable with the concept of playing it out of defence,particularly if zonal marking requires them to be half the pitch apart!
Distin is a natural of course and it will be interesting to see who best sits alongside Alcaraz who I suspect will be an automatic pick.
Of even greater concern yesterday was the failure to carve out real goalscoring opportunities and,upfront, I don`t see any of Vellios,Anichebe and Naysmith being any improvement on what we`ve already seen of them.Mirallas never got out of first gear,missed a sitter although,no doubt,was still nursing his perennial injury!
In short,our new manager has a mountain to climb both in personnel and tactical education.Let`s hope that Felli and Baines stay with us and `the missing six`improve on what was on show in Austria.
Harold Matthews
94 Posted 15/07/2013 at 15:04:32
Agreed Phil W. A mountain to climb.
Paul Ferry
95 Posted 15/07/2013 at 15:57:35
Vellios, Anichebe and Naysmith (746) does not really look like a formidable and imposing front team, do they?
Paul Andrews
97 Posted 15/07/2013 at 17:41:31
730 Phil,

"What's happened to Paul Andrews then"

He is still trying how to figure out how the player who most impressed you was a young sub who came on and was subbed.After 22 minutes.

Wayne Smyth
98 Posted 15/07/2013 at 17:39:47
One thing to consider about keeping your "best players", is that often they are a massive financial drain on the club. Fellaini has the wages of two players as well as being worth a fair few quid.

The upshot of this is that something has to give in terms of the quality of the rest of the squad if we want to keep our most valuable assets.

For example. Would we have been better off last season selling fellaini for £24M and bringing in a very good striker for the £10M - £15M bracket, and a decent midfielder to replace fellaini for about £5-£10M.

I suspect we may have finished higher in the league and we would have been a better overall side.

In short, its a case of a side being only as good as its weakest link. We can have a Rolls Royce midfielder, but it makes no sense if we have the Fiat Punto of the striking world.

Moyes was always very much against selling his better players, even if it meant he had no cash to strengthen other areas that were really short of quality. If it were me, I'd be a proactive seller looking to move the most saleable players on to the highest bidder until the side became solid in all areas.

Barry Lambert
99 Posted 15/07/2013 at 19:23:19
However much I admire RM encouraging the big boys to be a bit more creative, passing the ball around as opposed to hoofing it up the park, it frightens the life out of me. It's all well and good to adopt the mindset of a Barcelona player (and yes I believe all players should aspire to achieve the optimum level of their ability) but when was the last time you saw a Shirehorse win the Derby? Jags has to be one of the best tacklers and shot blockers we've seen at Goodison for many moons. Distin was cast in a similar mould. I just don't like to see them fannying around with the ball in dangerous situations.

I have always liked RM and admired his positive ideas and I also think he will do well for us. You can rest assured that his commitment and passion will never be questioned; however, I believe there will come a time (sooner rather than later) when he may have to accept a compromise. I fear that our current centre backs will all too frequently be caught with their trousers down.

Just cast your minds back to when Brenda took the helm across the park. He was hell bent on getting the likes of Carragher and Skirtel to play the ball out of defence, RM-style, and what a laugh that was. I remember one game on MOTD when the RS made 26 passes without reaching the half- way line ,the end product being a long pass-back from Carragher that was intercepted and ended up in the back of the Kop end net!

Brenda saw the errors of his ways and effected a compromise somewhere between caution and flair and it chokes me to admit that it worked. If we can get somewhere between Moyesy and Martinez then that will do me.

James Flynn
100 Posted 15/07/2013 at 23:07:18
Paul Ferry - Certainly you're not a simpleton.

Can't unsay what I said, but can apologize for saying it and do so here.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb